Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Michael Mozina said:
Likewise haters cannot embrace the REALITY that "electrical discharges" occur in flares
You insisted on defining "electrical discharge" to include "sudden releases of electric or magnetic energy". Under that definition, all of mainstream solar physics has indeed embraced the reality that electricalMoz dischargesMoz occur in flares. There are no haters who deny electricalMoz dischargesMoz. The particular form of electricalMoz dischargeMoz which is thought to occur is one called "magnetic reconnection".

Out with it, Michael. Everyone knows what you want to argue: you want to say "the Sun has high voltages on it, like Birkeland's sphere did, and solar flares are DC currents that flow due to that voltage". But you can't find any support for that statement in the literature.

You therefore mine for statements that you can twist into agreeing with you. You get one paper saying "this flare was a release of magnetic energy", another paper saying "a discharge is a release of electric or magnetic energy", and yet another paper saying "the terella underwent electric discharges", and you pretend that this adds up to vindication. It doesn't.
Amazing.

There's no actual, meaningful dialog taking place here.

I wonder if MM can provide for us all objective, independently verifiable evidence that "flares" exist on the Sun?

As far as I know, every piece of evidence MM has offered, so far in this thread, comes from the work of others, e.g. Dungey.

As far as I know, all such other-than-MM evidence is built upon a vast amount of other experimental and observational evidence, distilled into nice shorthands by use of math. For example, Maxwell's equations will appear somewhere in the looooong chain that ties what's in Dungey's paper to things that we humans can see, hear, touch (etc) for ourselves.

And essential to establishing a firm chain of logic and evidence is math, and quantitative analysis of data ... but MM rejects this (or, at the very least, simply does not understand it).

But, I could be wrong; perhaps MM can show that flares exist on the Sun, by presenting objective, independently verifiable evidence that does not require, at any key point, math and/or quantitative analysis?

(If he can't, then it's clear no meaningful discussion is taking place ...)
 
It is abundantly clear there is no dialog in this thread. It's just

"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"
"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"
"But arguing isn't just contradicting everything I say!"
"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"
"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"

The thread is hundreds of pages, and the only good thing to come out of it is that a few people (myself included) have learned some interesting physics. But at this point, I think the evidence is good enough for lurkers and passers-by. It's time to abandon the thread entirely, in my opinion.
 
A review of these recent posts about the definition of "discharge" reveal that these arguments from Mozina are not rational to the point of indicating a hopeless misunderstanding of the basis of the scientific issue being discussed. He seems to understand that there is no breakdown of a dielectric in solar plasmas, affirms that lightning on earth involves the ionization of air (the breakdown of an insulator), but then continues to berate those who do not want to call these currents in solar plasmas "discharges." He seems to think the definition of "discharge" is somehow critical to the science of solar physics. When one tries to avoid the question of the definition of "discharge" and approach the actual physics happening, he does not seem to be able to separate the two. He seems to think the definition is the physics.
We have witnessed this same behavior regarding terms like pressure, dark energy, magnetic reconnection. The real physics, which is inseparable from the defining mathematics, is not the issue -- it's the words and his highly idiosyncratic meanings that drive his faulty understanding and his illusions about physics.
He is better served on this other mentioned crackpot forum where others will likely also see physics as a word play science. In that environment, endless discussions about the number of fairies that can dance on an electron can delight all and reveal the secrets of the universe.
 
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 VIII

This is the Mozina version ...

Well, actually that is the post that quotes the post where I said ...

Nobody claims that a magnetic charge is present; that claim is not made by the paper and it is not made by me.

I have no idea what you are talking about. I doubt that you have any idea either. As the paper explicitly states, both monopoles and current are used mathematically (neither is claimed to be physically present).
Emphasis mine. IMO this statement says VOLUMES. I must have posted two dozen or more links that demonstrate that magnetic fields have no source and no sink. You provided the source/sink paper that is DIRECTLY RELATED to this issue. When confronted with the two lines of math that demonstrate that CURRENT (water) is being turned into MAGNETIC CHARGES (magnetic wine), you don't even acknowledge it! Math is *IRRELEVANT* to this crew. You use it ONLY WHEN IT SUITS YOU, and you IGNORE the maths you don't like.


Now let's see the real version ...

Well, actually that is the post that quotes the post where I said ...

Nobody claims that a magnetic charge is present; that claim is not made by the paper and it is not made by me.
Furthermore, how is it there in the ABSENCE of that current Priest describes?
I have no idea what you are talking about. I doubt that you have any idea either. As the paper explicitly states, both monopoles and current are used mathematically (neither is claimed to be physically present).
Emphasis mine. IMO this statement says VOLUMES. I must have posted two dozen or more links that demonstrate that magnetic fields have no source and no sink. You provided the source/sink paper that is DIRECTLY RELATED to this issue. When confronted with the two lines of math that demonstrate that CURRENT (water) is being turned into MAGNETIC CHARGES (magnetic wine), you don't even acknowledge it! Math is *IRRELEVANT* to this crew. You use it ONLY WHEN IT SUITS YOU, and you IGNORE the maths you don't like.


As all can see, when I said "I have no idea what you are talking about." I was specifically referring to Mozina's specific comment "Furthermore, how is it there in the ABSENCE of that current Priest describes?". I had then, and have now, no idea what absent current Mozina was talking about. But he chose to leave that out, and then falsely misrepresent what I said.

He also forgot to mention this part of my post ...

Here is what is really going on in the paper, the truth that sails so far beyond Mozina, he doesn't even feel the intellectual breeze. Out in the plasma where they want to study the physics, including magnetic reconnection, there is a magnetic field. The field obviously comes from somewhere, but it certainly is not generated by the plasma co-located with the magnetic field, it is generated elsewhere. We know that magnetic fields are physically generated by the motion of electrically charged particles, which can be expressed as charge neutral plasma flow or by the usual electrically charged current flow. If the magnetic field has a complicated geometry or topology (those two words are not synonymous) the physical current patterns required to generate them can be too mathematically complicated to allow a numerical computation of the desired field. So, one good computational trick is to just use monopoles, which always make the job of computing the field a lot easier. So, what Dèmoulin & Priest are doing is creating a small array of monopoles and simple currents and placing them under the model photosphere where they will then computationally create the magnetic field where they want it, with geometry & topology to match those observed, and then that field/plasma interaction physics can be studied. The monopoles and currents that appear in equations 16 & 17 are never used anywhere in the paper in any direct way and have absolutely nothing at all to do with the physics under study, other than to computationally generate the desired remote magnetic field.

Furthermore, pay attention to the my self-quoted paragraph above. This trick appears only in early papers, and in very few of them, and is quite literally never seen again. Once more powerful computers allow more powerful computational capability, the need for this kind of computational trick is gone. The ability to model magnetic fields with more realistic current and plasma flow is obviously an improvement. So Mozina "tilts at windmills"; he has no idea what those two equations are really doing, and ignores the fact that nothing like it appears in any text book and nothing like it is used in any of the current studies, and ignores the fact that his entire argument, aside from being 100% wrong, is also 100% irrelevant.


Mozina says above, "When confronted with the two lines of math that demonstrate that CURRENT (water) is being turned into MAGNETIC CHARGES (magnetic wine), you don't even acknowledge it!". But of course this is not at all true. I do indeed acknowledge those equations. In fact, I have explained in the two paragraphs quoted above, which Mozina certainly saw, exactly how & why current is turned into magnetic charges. Mozina's language is so poor that I did not understand until now what he meant by current "being turned into" magnetic charges. Indeed, instead of generating the magnetic field with currents, they generate the magnetic field with a mix of currents & magnetic charges, in the manner and for the reasons explained above. But Mozina completely overlooks the fact that nobody suggests that such things as magnetic charges are physically real (this paper makes no such suggestion, it is merely a computational device); it has no direct involvement in the magnetic reconnection process, was never used again by anybody and never appears in any text book.

Why is it that Mozina is only too happy to call anybody who disagrees with him a "hater", while at the same time deliberately ignoring the non hate-based reasons for disagreeing with him? I don't think Mozina will stop posting here because he loves to be insulted, to feel insulted, and to insult back. In fact, rather than leave, I think he will deliberately get himself banned as a badge of honor. Anything to avoid any real discussion of real science.
 
Indeed, instead of generating the magnetic field with currents, they generate the magnetic field with a mix of currents & magnetic charges, in the manner and for the reasons explained above. But Mozina completely overlooks the fact that nobody suggests that such things as magnetic charges are physically real (this paper makes no such suggestion, it is merely a computational device)

Of all the postdoc-research-projects, in all the towns, in all the world, that Michael Mozina's ignorance could have walked into, it walked into mine.

I've done exactly this computational trick myself. I helped supervise a grad student once on a numerical-magnetostatics project, and believe me, the simulation of our (actual, physical, laboratory) system was chock-full of fictional "magnetic charges". If you have a curlless, divergenceless vector field, you can represent it either as the curl of a (fictional) vector potential, or as the gradient of a (fictional) scalar potential. It so happens that any scalar-potential calculation looks, mathematically, exactly as though you were calculating a "potential" due to your 1/r distance from a "charge". I remember this grad student and I poring over the geometry of our magnets to figure out whether the inner solution was valid only out to the closest position of a physical electrode, or out to the (larger) closest position of a fictional charge. I remember going over the graphs that confirmed that the monopoles-calculation corresponded to exactly the same fields as the (slow) Ampere's Law calculation.

You really thought that Priest did something wrong, used actual magnetic monopoles, etc., and that you, the non-math-using amateur had correctly unmasked their mistake? Well, you thought wrong. Now you know. Thanks for the laugh.
 
It is abundantly clear there is no dialog in this thread. It's just

"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"
"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"
"But arguing isn't just contradicting everything I say!"
"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"
"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"

The thread is hundreds of pages, and the only good thing to come out of it is that a few people (myself included) have learned some interesting physics. But at this point, I think the evidence is good enough for lurkers and passers-by. It's time to abandon the thread entirely, in my opinion.

True.

What's important to note, I think, is *why* it's a non-discussion.

Take a somewhat hypothetical, concerning "flares" on the Sun.

Observationally, a solar flare is pretty easy to describe, and every now and then there are 'white light flares' (i.e. flares so bright they are visible, to the (suitably shielded) eye, across the visible spectrum.

But what a solar flare is, beyond what you can (in principle) see with your eyes, requires physics. For example, flares are obvious, and often quite spectacular, when the Sun is observed by an x-ray observatory. But such an x-ray observation can be understood *only* if you accept that x-rays are a form of electromagnetic radiation, that the instruments aboard the spacecraft function in a certain way, that the spacecraft is observing the Sun, ... all of which require an acceptance of much of textbook physics1.

Note that one of MM's claims is that at least some of Birkeland's experiments are relevant to understanding solar flares because a photograph or two from those experiments resembles ('looks like') some soft x-ray images of the Sun, from an orbiting x-ray observatory.

To go one step further, and consider possible explanations of the observations of solar flares - whether built on/incorporating Electric Sun, Sun-has-a-rigid-iron-surface, the Sun is powered by an inner neutron star, or anything else - requires an understanding of those ideas. And any such explanation *must* get quantitative! :D

For example, a white light flare is one in which the total energy in the visible (a part of the electromagnetic spectrum) is some considerable fraction of the total energy output of (that part of) the 'quiet' Sun; so unless the proposed explanation can be shown - objectively and in an independently verifiable way - to give an energy output in that ballpark, it is a non-starter. Ditto for the observed x-ray output, etc ... all the way up to the full SED (spectral energy distribution). Oh, and how the SED changes with time too ...

Now AFAIK, not once has MM ever even hinted that his proposed explanation(s) could do any of this, much less outlined how! :jaw-dropp :eek:

What's particularly sad (if that's the right word), is that MM doesn't seem to even understand *why* this is necessary, in order to have a meaningful discussion2.

1 try to accurately describe such an x-ray observation without - implicitly or explicitly - relying upon textbook physics! No, really, see if you can do it
2 BTW, this is also (one of the things) which makes the discussions on Thunderdolts so hypocritical; they claim 'scientific', but do not actually do any science (physics), because they do not do any math (or anything quantitative).
 
!U

True.

What's important to note, I think, is *why* it's a non-discussion.

Take a somewhat hypothetical, concerning "flares" on the Sun.

Observationally, a solar flare is pretty easy to describe, and every now and then there are 'white light flares' (i.e. flares so bright they are visible, to the (suitably shielded) eye, across the visible spectrum.

But what a solar flare is, beyond what you can (in principle) see with your eyes, requires physics. For example, flares are obvious, and often quite spectacular, when the Sun is observed by an x-ray observatory. But such an x-ray observation can be understood *only* if you accept that x-rays are a form of electromagnetic radiation, that the instruments aboard the spacecraft function in a certain way, that the spacecraft is observing the Sun, ... all of which require an acceptance of much of textbook physics1.

Note that one of MM's claims is that at least some of Birkeland's experiments are relevant to understanding solar flares because a photograph or two from those experiments resembles ('looks like') some soft x-ray images of the Sun, from an orbiting x-ray observatory.

To go one step further, and consider possible explanations of the observations of solar flares - whether built on/incorporating Electric Sun, Sun-has-a-rigid-iron-surface, the Sun is powered by an inner neutron star, or anything else - requires an understanding of those ideas. And any such explanation *must* get quantitative! :D

For example, a white light flare is one in which the total energy in the visible (a part of the electromagnetic spectrum) is some considerable fraction of the total energy output of (that part of) the 'quiet' Sun; so unless the proposed explanation can be shown - objectively and in an independently verifiable way - to give an energy output in that ballpark, it is a non-starter. Ditto for the observed x-ray output, etc ... all the way up to the full SED (spectral energy distribution). Oh, and how the SED changes with time too ...

Now AFAIK, not once has MM ever even hinted that his proposed explanation(s) could do any of this, much less outlined how! :jaw-dropp :eek:

What's particularly sad (if that's the right word), is that MM doesn't seem to even understand *why* this is necessary, in order to have a meaningful discussion2.

1 try to accurately describe such an x-ray observation without - implicitly or explicitly - relying upon textbook physics! No, really, see if you can do it
2 BTW, this is also (one of the things) which makes the discussions on Thunderdolts so hypocritical; they claim 'scientific', but do not actually do any science (physics), because they do not do any math (or anything quantitative).

This is an *EXCELLENT* example of pure denial in action IMO, and typical of EU hater behavior. I handed you folks not only *QUANTIFIED* numbers in that Mann and Onel paper as it relates to solar flares, I handed you DIRECT EMPIRICAL LABORATORY MATH AND PHYSICS that demonstrates a direct link between electrical discharges through plasmas and high states of ionization of iron. This gives us (those of us not in pure denial) *DIRECT EMPIRICAL* and *QUANTIFIED* evidence to support the fact that electrical discharges occur in the solar atmosphere and in flares. I also handed you folks Dungey's *QUANTIFIED* work, and showed you *EXACTLY* how Priest turns electric water in the magnetic wine in his QUANTIFICATIONS. EU haters are utterly SUBJECTIVE about QUANTIFICATION and QUALIFICATION. None of you can provide any QUALIFIED (empirical) connection between all of the seven high energy observations associated with solar flares and "magnetic reconnection". Discharges score a 7 of 7! MR theory scored a wimpy 1 of 7 on that list of LAB QUALIFICATION and only because I felt sorry for it. When shown that the E orientation has EQUAL MATHEMATICAL VALIDITY in terms of explaining solar flare outputs, EU haters go into PURE UNADULTERATED DENIAL and QUANTIFIED evidence *AND* qualified evidence. Creationist have absolutely *NOTHING* on EU haters in terms of the use of pure denial in debate. WOW!

After 7 years of discussions on this topic it was evidently news to you that the solar models I support are INTERNALLY powered. Why should I then be surprised that you're in hardcore denial of the QUANTIFIED evidence I presented in that paper by Mann and Onel, the double layer paper by Alfven, and Dungey's work? Denial is just ridiculous. There's no way to actually deal with it scientifically. You folks just aren't interested in the "Science" aspect at all. It's just about bashing the individual with haters. You can't call me evil, so you attack me in other ways. Yawn. Denial won't save EU haters from the fact that we live inside an electric universe. That fact is as plane as the electrical discharges occurring in the solar atmosphere on a daily (actually constant) basis.
 
Last edited:
A review of these recent posts about the definition of "discharge" reveal that these arguments from Mozina are not rational to the point of indicating a hopeless misunderstanding of the basis of the scientific issue being discussed.

Earlier in the week you agreed that a discharge is a release of stored energy. Today you're back to attacking individuals rather than dealing with scientific fact.

He seems to understand that there is no breakdown of a dielectric in solar plasmas, affirms that lightning on earth involves the ionization of air (the breakdown of an insulator), but then continues to berate those who do not want to call these currents in solar plasmas "discharges."

Dungey used the term "electrical discharge" before I was born PS. Surely he understood that there was no dielectric breakdown going on, right?

He seems to think the definition of "discharge" is somehow critical to the science of solar physics.

It is. It's important to know that an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE as defined by Dungey is a RELEASE OF STORED ENERGY.

When one tries to avoid the question of the definition of "discharge" and approach the actual physics happening, he does not seem to be able to separate the two. He seems to think the definition is the physics.

The "physics" is found in the lab PS. I've shown you *SEVEN* physical processes that are PHYSICALLY related to the release of stored EM energy, otherwise known as ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES and solar flare events.

He is better served on this other mentioned crackpot forum

I love how EVERYONE there must now be a "crackpot" because they show interest in something you yourself claim you aren't able to discuss and won't discuss in equations 16 and 17 of Priests paper. You WON'T address the quantified evidence by Mann and Onel. You WON'T address that paper by Lee. You won't and don't do anything other than attack individuals. HATER Cult behaviors, pure and simple.

where others will likely also see physics as a word play science. In that environment, endless discussions about the number of fairies that can dance on an electron can delight all and reveal the secrets of the universe.

No, they'll actually DISCUSS the maths in the Mann and Onel paper. They'll actually DISCUSS Dungey's use of electrical discharges in "reconnection' events. They'll actually ALLOW for alternative concepts to be heard like a real SCIENCE forum rather than attacking individuals, running from the data, and acting like a hater cult.
 
You really thought that Priest did something wrong, used actual magnetic monopoles, etc., and that you, the non-math-using amateur had correctly unmasked their mistake?

No, I showed you where the process of "reconnection" absolutely REQUIRES current and plasma. Deny it all you like, but plasma isn't OPTIONAL in terms of sources and sinks. The SOURCE of kinetic energy is an E field. Current and magnetic field energy associated with that current simply comes up the z axis and "reconnects" to the X,Y axis.
 
As you’re the only one here who has claimed such sources or sinks (monopoles) are required for magnetic reconnection.

No. I claimed that PLASMA and CURRENT are required for "reconnection" and I showed you the exact two equations in Priests 'Source/Sink' paper to prove it. Deal with it, or don't deal with it, but it's right there in a black and white in the two equations I cited.
 
Interesting that given every opportunity to quantitatively and objectively support an electric/iron Sun conjecture, we get 500+ words complaining about failing rather than any attempt to succeed. Okay, whatever the reason, failure it is.

Interesting that given every opportunity to embrace Mann's work, Dungey's work and Alfven's work in terms of quantification you FAIL to do so. Interesting that given the opportunity to embrace QUALIFIED evidence including all seven key high energy observations associated with solar flares and electrical discharges, you STILL FAIL to accept reality. Denial is about failure alright, but not MY failures, HATER FAILURES. I can't personally get creationist to accept quantified and quantified evidence anymore than I can EU haters to embrace the fact that electrical discharges occur in flares. It's not my fault however. Denial begins within. It has nothing to do with me personally. I've provide you with SEVEN key QUALIFIED pieces of evidence to support the fact that flare involve electrical discharges (in conductors), and MANY quantified pieces of evidence like Mann's work, and Alfven's work. The failure isn't mine.
 
Last edited:
You insisted on defining "electrical discharge" to include "sudden releases of electric or magnetic energy". Under that definition, all of mainstream solar physics has indeed embraced the reality that electricalMoz dischargesMoz occur in flares. There are no haters who deny electricalMoz dischargesMoz. The particular form of electricalMoz dischargeMoz which is thought to occur is one called "magnetic reconnection".

Out with it, Michael. Everyone knows what you want to argue: you want to say "the Sun has high voltages on it, like Birkeland's sphere did, and solar flares are DC currents that flow due to that voltage". But you can't find any support for that statement in the literature.

Baloney. I handed you that very literature on a silver Platter Did you ever even ACTUALLY READ that paper by Mann and Onel? Did you ever take the time to read Alfven's theories on solar flares ben? I seriously doubt you did.
 
It is abundantly clear there is no dialog in this thread. It's just

"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"
"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"
"But arguing isn't just contradicting everything I say!"
"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"
"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"

The thread is hundreds of pages, and the only good thing to come out of it is that a few people (myself included) have learned some interesting physics. But at this point, I think the evidence is good enough for lurkers and passers-by. It's time to abandon the thread entirely, in my opinion.

Oddly enough I actually tend to agree with you. I gave up debating creationists about evolutionary theory because it was clear that no amount of quantified or qualified physics mattered to a creationist. Likewise it's very clear that all the quantified evidence like Alfven's work and Mann's work and Dungey's work, and all the QUALIFIED evidence like Lee's work don't matter to an EU hater. All that matters to a hater is attacking the individual. Mainstreamers can't call me "evil" in their little hater cult, so it's "crackpot*, *crank*, yada, yada yada. Same dance, different tune. Yawn. This place is boring. Nobody discusses the actual physics, they discuss PEOPLE. Yawn.
 
This is an *EXCELLENT* example of pure denial in action IMO, and typical of EU hater behavior.


That is an uncivil personal attack and an insult, not an argument.

I handed you folks not only *QUANTIFIED* numbers in that Mann and Onel paper as it relates to solar flares, I handed you DIRECT EMPIRICAL LABORATORY MATH AND PHYSICS that demonstrates a direct link between electrical discharges through plasmas and high states of ionization of iron.


That is not an argument. It's a complaint about failing. And it's untrue.

This gives us (those of us not in pure denial) *DIRECT EMPIRICAL* and *QUANTIFIED* evidence to support the fact that electrical discharges occur in the solar atmosphere and in flares.


That is also a complaint about failing, and also not true.

I also handed you folks Dungey's *QUANTIFIED* work, and showed you *EXACTLY* how Priest turns electric water in the magnetic wine in his QUANTIFICATIONS.


That is not an argument. It's just a silly way to dishonestly re-frame legitimate science to justify a complaint about failing.

EU haters are utterly SUBJECTIVE about QUANTIFICATION and QUALIFICATION.


That is another uncivil personal attack and insult, not an argument. And not true.

None of you can provide any QUALIFIED (empirical) connection between all of the seven high energy observations associated with solar flares and "magnetic reconnection". Discharges score a 7 of 7! MR theory scored a wimpy 1 of 7 on that list of LAB QUALIFICATION and only because I felt sorry for it.


As arguments go, making up a list of criteria then selectively shoehorning some fictionalized criteria of an against-the-mainstream conjecture into that list is simply dishonest. And that, "I felt sorry for it," nonsense is just plain silly.

When shown that the E orientation has EQUAL MATHEMATICAL VALIDITY in terms of explaining solar flare outputs, EU haters go into PURE UNADULTERATED DENIAL and QUANTIFIED evidence *AND* qualified evidence. Creationist have absolutely *NOTHING* on EU haters in terms of the use of pure denial in debate. WOW!


Wow, indeed. All that shouting, insulting, and incivility, but not a drop of objective quantitative support for any electric/iron Sun conjectures. Complaints about failing will not result in success.

After 7 years of discussions on this topic it was evidently news to you that the solar models I support are INTERNALLY powered. Why should I then be surprised that you're in hardcore denial of the QUANTIFIED evidence I presented in that paper by Mann and Onel, the double layer paper by Alfven, and Dungey's work?


All that alleged evidence is, in some cases, wholly irrelevant. In others it is actually support favoring the standard solar model and magnetic reconnection rather than lightning bolts on an iron Sun, the dishonest cherry picking and willful ignorance of the real science notwithstanding. And as always, the insults and complaints about failing are not likely to advance the discussion.

Denial is just ridiculous.


Now that is true.

There's no way to actually deal with it scientifically.


When it comes to the claim that solar flares and CMEs are like lightning on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball, clearly there is no way to actually deal with it scientifically.

You folks just aren't interested in the "Science" aspect at all. It's just about bashing the individual with haters. You can't call me evil, so you attack me in other ways. Yawn. Denial won't save EU haters from the fact that we live inside an electric universe. That fact is as plane as the electrical discharges occurring in the solar atmosphere on a daily (actually constant) basis.


As expected, that is not an argument to support any electric/iron Sun conjecture. It is an uncivil complaint about failing and what seems to be a dishonest inference that scientists hate unsupported/unsupportable conjectures. In reality, where legitimate science is a quantitative objective process, that couldn't be further from the truth. In reality, real scientists don't hate nonsense claims. They objectively analyze the presentation of evidence, if there is any, and when there is none, as in the electric/iron Sun conjectures, they reject them.

And as mentioned before, a complaint about failing is not an argument and is not likely to result in success.
 
No. I claimed that PLASMA and CURRENT are required for "reconnection" and I showed you the exact two equations in Priests 'Source/Sink' paper to prove it. Deal with it, or don't deal with it, but it's right there in a black and white in the two equations I cited.

OK, I would like to review these equations. Would you please write them out or provide a link since I'm not sure which of the dozens of links you have included would have the equations you have in mind.

Addendum: I suspect I will regret this.
 
Last edited:
It is. It's important to know that an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE as defined by Dungey is a RELEASE OF STORED ENERGY.

Really, so a spring releasing “STORED ENERGY” is an “ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE”? Perhaps there were some other important things to know? Oh and don’t blame Dungey for your own simple inclination to label any “RELEASE OF STORED ENERGY” an “ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE”.


No, I showed you where the process of "reconnection" absolutely REQUIRES current and plasma. Deny it all you like, but plasma isn't OPTIONAL in terms of sources and sinks. The SOURCE of kinetic energy is an E field. Current and magnetic field energy associated with that current simply comes up the z axis and "reconnects" to the X,Y axis.

What “process of "reconnection"”? The one with just some “RELEASE OF STORED ENERGY” that you simply want to call an “ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE”? As already explained to you, and you could demonstrate yourself with some simple magnets, magnetic reconnection does not require plasma.
 
Me:
He seems to think the definition of "discharge" is somehow critical to the science of solar physics.
Mozina:
It is. It's important to know that an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE as defined by Dungey is a RELEASE OF STORED ENERGY.

Therein lies a significant part (but by no means all) of the problem.
 
No. I claimed that PLASMA and CURRENT are required for "reconnection" and I showed you the exact two equations in Priests 'Source/Sink' paper to prove it. Deal with it, or don't deal with it, but it's right there in a black and white in the two equations I cited.

Don’t lie Michael Mozina or have you just forgotten why you fixated on these two equations in the first place?

LOL! I'll have to stop laughing before I can respond to the ABSOLUTE NONSENSE in your last post, but that particular line made me laugh. Thanks.

I just LOVE how you DON'T CARE that Priests MONOPOLE DEVICE is a CURRENT. :) Wow!

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7809010&postcount=5801

Clinger:

You're ignoring the physical differences between E fields and B fields, specifically that E fields DO have monopole charges, whereas B field lines do not have monopoles and magnetic charges like E fields. This means that your equations related to Origin the Null B lines were never appropriate to start with. B fields do not start. They do not end. They do not have a source. They do not have a sink. A NULL CANNOT be the "beginning" of any B line Clinger. You do NOT have a monopole so you CANNOT treat the B line like an E line. You can't "begin" a B line at a POINT. It simply doesn't work that way! The B LINES (actually WHOLE FIELDS) are CREATED BY current. They don't "begin" at some arbitrary NULL point.
You're a liar and a fraud Clinger. Not only do I understand math *AND* physics, I pointed out YOUR error for you. You and your vacuum god Origin are both frauds. The fact you don't want to deal with it, and the fact that you're too afraid to actually put your "work" through a peer review process, tells the whole story. You just *IGNORE* the fact you don't have a monopole up your sleeve and you're intent on treating B fields like E fields anyway. You're grossly violating the laws of physics in the process. You may "bark math" by you don't even SPEAK PHYSICS.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7809010&postcount=5801

I provided you with at least a dozen references that all prove that you're full of it and full of yourself, and you've provided NONE that demonstrate your claim. You argue *EXACTLY* like a nasty creationist intent on attacking the individual rather than deal with the topic.
I've now posted MORE THAN A DOZEN published references to demonstrate that Clinger is *IMPROPERLY* trying to turn a B field (without beginnings and sources) into a E field (with them).

You have produced *ZERO* published references to support his claim that B lines have a beginning in the absence of a monopole. Your side argues *EXACTLY* like any ordinary group of haters. You don't argue with PUBLISHED materials, you HANDWAVE. In spite of the fact that Clinger is *OVERTLY* trying to ignore the laws of physics, the hardcore haters are still all convinced he's right! Oy Vey.

Not a single one of the HATERS has made any attempt to "educate" me. Quite the opposite. You've done your best to BELITTLE the individual, hold *IGNORANCE* supreme, and ignore the laws of physics entirely. Not one of the four of you has ever even read a book on plasma physics, so how the HELL could you ever educate ME to that field of science? You're like the blind leading the blind, and you're intent on poking any and every sighted individuals eye out! The only 'education' you four might have given me is an education on hate. I've seen that plenty already.

Clingers MATHS amount to NOTHING. Literally! They literally amount to 0+0=0 in the absence of all plasma There's NOTHING that could BEGIN there. There's NOTHING that could end there. It's nothing more than an *ORDINARY NULL* and a NULL is absolutely, positively *NOT* the beginning of anything.




You require magnetic monopoles for your "reconnection", your 'Source/Sink' insistence, and fixated on that paper and those two equations because it seemed to give you what you wanted, you’re 'Source/Sink'. Apparently without understanding it was just computational tool. No one here but you has claimed the necessity of such monopoles ('Source/Sink') for magnetic reconnection.


Again you’ve got your two equations, so show mathematical exactly where W.D.Clinger went wrong. By all means please give it your best shot.
 
OK, I would like to review these equations. Would you please write them out or provide a link since I'm not sure which of the dozens of links you have included would have the equations you have in mind.

Addendum: I suspect I will regret this.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8057820&postcount=6474

On the off chance you do actually want to discuss the maths and/or the physics of the process Priest describes in terms of sources and sinks, it's found here:

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1992A&A...258..535D/0000539.000.html
 
Don’t lie Michael Mozina or have you just forgotten why you fixated on these two equations in the first place?

I 'fixated' on them because we were discussing sources and sinks and you all CLAIM to honor mathematics and QUANTIFIED evidence. Don't LIE about my motives.

You require magnetic monopoles for your "reconnection",

No. *CLINGER* would require magnetic monopoles to get *HIS* contraption to work. Priest's "source" simply requires CURRENT!

Again you’ve got your two equations, so show mathematical exactly where W.D.Clinger went wrong. By all means please give it your best shot.

Clinger "went wrong" when he claimed "reconnection" was "plasma optional". Equations 16 and 17 demonstrate that fact.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom