DeiRenDopa
Master Poster
- Joined
- Feb 25, 2008
- Messages
- 2,582
Amazing.You insisted on defining "electrical discharge" to include "sudden releases of electric or magnetic energy". Under that definition, all of mainstream solar physics has indeed embraced the reality that electricalMoz dischargesMoz occur in flares. There are no haters who deny electricalMoz dischargesMoz. The particular form of electricalMoz dischargeMoz which is thought to occur is one called "magnetic reconnection".Michael Mozina said:Likewise haters cannot embrace the REALITY that "electrical discharges" occur in flares
Out with it, Michael. Everyone knows what you want to argue: you want to say "the Sun has high voltages on it, like Birkeland's sphere did, and solar flares are DC currents that flow due to that voltage". But you can't find any support for that statement in the literature.
You therefore mine for statements that you can twist into agreeing with you. You get one paper saying "this flare was a release of magnetic energy", another paper saying "a discharge is a release of electric or magnetic energy", and yet another paper saying "the terella underwent electric discharges", and you pretend that this adds up to vindication. It doesn't.
There's no actual, meaningful dialog taking place here.
I wonder if MM can provide for us all objective, independently verifiable evidence that "flares" exist on the Sun?
As far as I know, every piece of evidence MM has offered, so far in this thread, comes from the work of others, e.g. Dungey.
As far as I know, all such other-than-MM evidence is built upon a vast amount of other experimental and observational evidence, distilled into nice shorthands by use of math. For example, Maxwell's equations will appear somewhere in the looooong chain that ties what's in Dungey's paper to things that we humans can see, hear, touch (etc) for ourselves.
And essential to establishing a firm chain of logic and evidence is math, and quantitative analysis of data ... but MM rejects this (or, at the very least, simply does not understand it).
But, I could be wrong; perhaps MM can show that flares exist on the Sun, by presenting objective, independently verifiable evidence that does not require, at any key point, math and/or quantitative analysis?
(If he can't, then it's clear no meaningful discussion is taking place ...)