Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.

The operative word in your sentence is the word "SOME". You figured out SOME (and damn little) of the relevant math related to 'reconnection' theory. You left out the plasma physics part of the math so your argument fails at equation 16 and 17 of Priests paper. You can never deliver the current in equation 16, so you can never deliver the "magnetic charge" (AKA MONOPOLES) in equation 17.
 
Last edited:
The operative word in your sentence is the word "SOME". You figured out SOME (and damn little) of the relevant math related to 'reconnection' theory. You left out the plasma physics part of the math so your argument fails at equation 16 and 17 of Priests paper. You can never deliver the current in equation 16, so you can never deliver the "magnetic charge" (AKA MONOPOLES) in equation 17.
No kidding.

That must mean Priest's equation 17 is entirely irrelevant to my calculations, which is what all of us have been saying all along.

In MM explains his confusion, part 12, I pointed out (for the umpteenth time) that there are no magnetic monopoles in my model. I also pointed out that I have given several different mathematical proofs of that fact:

div B = 0 is not a handwave. I have presented at least three separate proofs of div B = 0 for the magnetic fields in my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection:
It's a scientific fact that div B = 0 implies there are no monopoles, so I have proved there are no monopoles in any of the fields involved in my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.


So Michael Mozina has once again confirmed what I wrote earlier today:

Michael Mozina has run from that equation and its consequences. He has tried to disguise his flight by flaming about irrelevant equations, which he understands as little as Ampère's law. To disguise his staunch denials of scientific fact, he attacks individuals who dare to explain his errors.
 
FYI, it's not "me" that first used the term "electrical discharge" in relationship to solar flare events PS, it was DUNGEY and PERATT that used that term long before I was introduced to EU/PC theory. That is where I got the term in the first place, specifically Peratt's book, Physics Of The Plasma Universe. I quoted him for you.

I also showed you where Dungey used that same term "electrical discharge" in precisely the same way as Paratt defines the term. Dungey is describing the sudden release of stored EM energy in one giant "electrical discharge" during a reconnection event. There's nothing inconsistent about their use of the term. In both instances they describe the RELEASE OF STORED EM ENERGY, not the process of ionizing air!

If I were to say a capacitor in a circuit discharged, I certainly would not usually mean that the dielectric material between the plates broke down.
Assuming you understand and are reporting Dungey's and Peratt's use of the word discharge accurately, I find myself in agreement with you on this. If those individuals used the word discharge to mean a sudden release of energy in the form of a current in a plasma, why would anyone object? It may be more conventional to confine that term to situations where a dielectric breaks down today, but who cares? The only important aspect of this is to agree as to what we mean when we discuss it. Without precisely defined terms, it's tough to do and discuss science.

However, I do not agree with this:

Get RC and GM to wake up and smell the coffee already. They're hopelessly stuck in pure denial at this point. I guess they figure if they never acknowledge Dungey's use of the term and Peratt's definition of the term, they can live in denial forever. The moment they let go of the denial-go-round, they lose the debate.

Instead of embracing the physics, the haters attack the individual, deny the evidence exists, lather rinse, repeat.

Winning a debate about terminology has little to do with science. Why is it so important to you that they accept this atypical usage of a word? They have been making the point that this usage of discharge is obsolete. How hard is that to understand and why does anyone (including you) care?
 
Last edited:
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 VII

What "mathematical ignorance"? I went to all the trouble of speaking your language, citing the exact equations where Priest turns electric current into magnetic wine, thereby sinking Clinger's ship and all you ignored it!
I had not noticed this particular comment until The Man posted it.

This is, of course, very false. We did not ignore it. We proved conclusively that you were and are dead wrong, dead wrong, in your assumptions about the equations; see, e.g., my previous post Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 V and posts referenced therein. We thereby also show that your math skills are somewhat deficient by comparisons with your claims.
Um, the only "ridiculous" attempt you made to SWEEP THE ISSUE UNDER THE CARPET that is even worth responding to, you did in this post Tim:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7808363#post7808363


Well, actually that is the post that quotes the post where I said ...

No it is not. Look at the sentence immediately prior to equation 16. It read as follows, with my added emphasis:
"Equation (15) gives a singular field only on the negative part of the z-axis. Here both currents and magnetic charges are present:"

What the HECK is a magnetic charge that you claim is "present".


Nobody claims that a magnetic charge is present; that claim is not made by the paper and it is not made by me.

Furthermore, how is it there in the ABSENCE of that current Priest describes?


I have no idea what you are talking about. I doubt that you have any idea either. As the paper explicitly states, both monopoles and current are used mathematically (neither is claimed to be physically present).


The only reason it's there at all is because a BIRKELAND CURRENT runs and through that Z axis.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birkeland_current

[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/79/Magnetic_rope.png/300px-Magnetic_rope.png[/qimg]

That's a BENNETT PINCH Tim!


No, the diagram is not that of a Bennett Pinch.

In equation 17, they're literally converting CHARGED PARTICLE KINETIC ENERGY into "magnetic charges", AKA MONOPOLES!


No, they are not doing any such thing. That's why people say that your mathematical skills are, despite your contentions to the contrary, pathetic. I agree; you have no idea what an equation is, you have no skill to read mathematical equations, and you always avoid math because you know as well as we do that you have no idea what it is. I know that for a fact, and I dare you to demonstrate that I am wrong.

FYI, here's a link the the relevant page where the two equations are listed:

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1992A&A...258..535D/0000539.000.html


You forgot this, from Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992, 22 November 2011 ...
Furthermore, these equations, and this paper, are vastly overblown and exaggerated by Mozina. This trick of using magnetic charges appears in only a few papers, and they are all early in the process of describing the physics of magnetic reconnection. Its sole purpose is to play a role in multipole expansions of the magnetic field. But superior methods soon arrived and this methodology of using magnetic charges, which was even then esoteric & obscure, disappeared altogether, never to be seen again. It does not appear in any text book on plasma physics, field modeling, or magnetic reconnection that I have seen. That's why I said I didn't want to talk about this, because it is irrelevant. irrelevant. The current state of the physics of magnetic field modeling and magnetic reconnection does not involve any of this at all.


Here is what is really going on in the paper, the truth that sails so far beyond Mozina, he doesn't even feel the intellectual breeze. Out in the plasma where they want to study the physics, including magnetic reconnection, there is a magnetic field. The field obviously comes from somewhere, but it certainly is not generated by the plasma co-located with the magnetic field, it is generated elsewhere. We know that magnetic fields are physically generated by the motion of electrically charged particles, which can be expressed as charge neutral plasma flow or by the usual electrically charged current flow. If the magnetic field has a complicated geometry or topology (those two words are not synonymous) the physical current patterns required to generate them can be too mathematically complicated to allow a numerical computation of the desired field. So, one good computational trick is to just use monopoles, which always make the job of computing the field a lot easier. So, what Dèmoulin & Priest are doing is creating a small array of monopoles and simple currents and placing them under the model photosphere where they will then computationally create the magnetic field where they want it, with geometry & topology to match those observed, and then that field/plasma interaction physics can be studied. The monopoles and currents that appear in equations 16 & 17 are never used anywhere in the paper in any direct way and have absolutely nothing at all to do with the physics under study, other than to computationally generate the desired remote magnetic field.

Furthermore, pay attention to the my self-quoted paragraph above. This trick appears only in early papers, and in very few of them, and is quite literally never seen again. Once more powerful computers allow more powerful computational capability, the need for this kind of computational trick is gone. The ability to model magnetic fields with more realistic current and plasma flow is obviously an improvement. So Mozina "tilts at windmills"; he has no idea what those two equations are really doing, and ignores the fact that nothing like it appears in any text book and nothing like it is used in any of the current studies, and ignores the fact that his entire argument, aside from being 100% wrong, is also 100% irrelevant.
 
Oh, I agree with Priest that is a "trivial" process alright, so TRIVIAL that absolutely, positively NOTHING happens in the NULL. It couldn't. There's no energy at a ZERO point of one, or even an INFINITE number of 0 points of magnetic lines.
That is absolute gibberish, Michael Mozina.
There is a magnetic field. It is not zero everywhere as you seem to be thinking. Or to use your language:
Everyone with 2 brain cells will agree with Priest that is a "trivial" process alright, so TRIVIAL that absolutely, positively SOMETHING happens in the NULL. It can. Magnetic lines by definition cannot exist at the NULL point and so any that cross it must start and end there.
There's energy at a NONZERO point of one, or even an INFINITE number of NONZERO points of magnetic lines.
​
Magnetic reconnection in a vacuum is a trivial process so plasma scientists rarely mention it. It is trivial because they are a lot more interested in processes in plasma.

But we have
and
W.D. Clinger's derivation of magnetic reconnection in a vacuum.
 
You quite literally know ABSOLUTELY NOTHING about the images because you have no idea what the light source is.
Gee Mack knows what the light source in the solar images is as does everyone in this thread (except maybe you since you keep going on about this)- the Sun :jaw-dropp!
To be more exact the solar plasma. Which makes it a bit ignorant to talk about "the light source" in solar images since every point in the image is a light source.

You have NO RIGHT to question ANYONE about their "interpretation" of solar satellite images.
...usual "hate" rant....
He has the right to wonder about the question the competence someone who is still citing a PR image with a green line caused by misalignment of images as evidence for the really inane fantasy that the Sun has a solid surface.
Micheal Mozina's iron crust has been totally debunked!

Your interpretation of solar satellite images is obviously wrong because it is based on a faulty premise, i.e. the fantasy that the Sun has an iron surface that is visible in these images. Simple physics states that this iron surface is impossible.
Your interpretation of solar satellite images is obviously wrong because you have demonstrated your ignorance of what they contain.
The SDO image"green line" is a processing artifact as confirmed by the NASA team. and still not understood by you.

Where are Alfven's "HUNDREDS of papers on circuit theory as it applied to plasma?
First asked on 30th September 2011 and still no citations.
150 days and counting, Michael Mozina

MM: Explain your "0+0=0 and NOTHING begins there" statement
First asked 5th December 2011 (86 days ago and counting)
 
MM: Can you understand that MR in a vacuum does not involve plasma

You left out the plasma physics part of the math so your argument fails at equation 16 and 17 of Priests paper. You can never deliver the current in equation 16, so you can never deliver the "magnetic charge" (AKA MONOPOLES) in equation 17.
The stupidity of thinking that W.D. Clinger's derivation of magnetic reconnection in a vacuum is a derivation of magnetic reconnection in plasma (a topic that textbooks containing hundreds of pages do not complete cover!) is obvious.

Michael Mozina:
Can you undestand that W.D. Clinger's derivation of magnetic reconnection in a vacuum is not a derivation of MR in plasma?

MM repeats his delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper!
 
Winning a debate about terminology has little to do with science. Why is it so important to you that they accept this atypical usage of a word? They have been making the point that this usage of discharge is obsolete. How hard is that to understand and why does anyone (including you) care?
This is a primary problem with Michael Mozina's logic - these is none!

He started with an OP about Bruce's idea that there is actual lightning on the Sun. That idea is easily debunked because there cannot be any lightning in plasma. But Michael Mozina cannot understand the physics and is still over a year later citing Bruce :jaw-dropp.
See my 30th November 2010 post listing the flaws in Bruce's idea (and an interesting bit of ignorance from MM - he thinks that molecuels are dust!).

Michael Mozina continued with the vague "solar flares are caused by electrical discharges" claim which is obviously wrong since electrical discharges can never happen in plasma. He has been unable to answer the question Where is your scientific evidence for electrical discharges on the Sun? for 14 months now other than repeating

Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma!
 
This is a primary problem with Michael Mozina's logic - these is none!

He started with an OP about Bruce's idea that there is actual lightning on the Sun. That idea is easily debunked because there cannot be any lightning in plasma. But Michael Mozina cannot understand the physics and is still over a year later citing Bruce :jaw-dropp.

Apparently he has moved away from that idea. A few posts above, he does say that there is no dielectric material to break down (like lightning on earth) in solar plasmas. Consequently, he admits that a "discharge" (since he keeps insisting on using that term) occurring in the sun is a totally different process. We have seen this before. Idiosyncratic definitions are part of his tool bag and are the engine that keeps these interminable threads going.
 
If I were to say a capacitor in a circuit discharged, I certainly would not usually mean that the dielectric material between the plates broke down.
Assuming you understand and are reporting Dungey's and Peratt's use of the word discharge accurately, I find myself in agreement with you on this. If those individuals used the word discharge to mean a sudden release of energy in the form of a current in a plasma, why would anyone object? It may be more conventional to confine that term to situations where a dielectric breaks down today, but who cares? The only important aspect of this is to agree as to what we mean when we discuss it. Without precisely defined terms, it's tough to do and discuss science.

Indeed. Therein lies the rub PS. Your side is stuck in a denial holding pattern that is propped up with pure BIGOTRY! As long as they never have to agree on scientific terms and definitions, maybe they can hide themselves from the reality that "electrical discharges" occur in flares, and "electrical discharges" have been associated with "reconnection" events since the term "reconnection" was first invented. Both terms were used by Dungey.

However, I do not agree with this:

Winning a debate about terminology has little to do with science. Why is it so important to you that they accept this atypical usage of a word?

It's not "atypical" in any way, shape or form. Dungey used it. Bruce used it. Lot's of folks used it in relationship to solar flares. There's nothing 'atypical' about it. It's just an E oriented term and the blind bigotry is more important that getting on with a real discussion.

They have been making the point that this usage of discharge is obsolete.

That's is an utterly ridiculous argument! That's like claiming the term "automobile" is "obsolete", therefore no automobiles exist in the universe, only "cars".

How hard is that to understand and why does anyone (including you) care?

The only reason your side 'cares' at all is because your side is stuck on a denial-go-round of *EPIC* proportions! You folks HATE EU theory like a creationist HATES evolutionary theory. Creationist sometimes don't want to agree on terms like Micro-evolution and macro-evolution to have a real conversation. Likewise haters cannot embrace the REALITY that "electrical discharges" occur in flares and there has been documented evidence of this idea since the time of BIRKELAND, DUNGEY, BRUCE and MANY MANY OTHERS!

You guys our 100 years or more behind the times. Talk about 'obsolete'.
 
Last edited:
Well, actually that is the post that quotes the post where I said ...

Nobody claims that a magnetic charge is present; that claim is not made by the paper and it is not made by me.

I have no idea what you are talking about. I doubt that you have any idea either. As the paper explicitly states, both monopoles and current are used mathematically (neither is claimed to be physically present).

Emphasis mine. IMO this statement says VOLUMES. I must have posted two dozen or more links that demonstrate that magnetic fields have no source and no sink. You provided the source/sink paper that is DIRECTLY RELATED to this issue. When confronted with the two lines of math that demonstrate that CURRENT (water) is being turned into MAGNETIC CHARGES (magnetic wine), you don't even acknowledge it! Math is *IRRELEVANT* to this crew. You use it ONLY WHEN IT SUITS YOU, and you IGNORE the maths you don't like.
 
No kidding.

That must mean Priest's equation 17 is entirely irrelevant to my calculations, which is what all of us have been saying all along.

But that's the problem Clinger, it's DIRECTLY RELATED to the source and sink of the process in question. The process in question is a PLASMA PHYSICS process that *REQUIRES* the flow of CURRENT. Plasma and current are not OPTIONAL!
 
I can see I'll be posting a lot more on Thunderbolts in the future. They seem to be interested in real scientific dialog. The EU haters that post here aren't even INTERESTED in an HONEST SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION on this topic, or the topic of solar flares. It's just one personal attack after another after another. Anyone and everyone that posits an "electric sun theory" is called a "crackpot" a "crank", etc, up to and including Hannes Alfven himself. Yawn. This is like discussing evolutionary theory with hard core creationists.

Math's don't ACTUALLY matter to any of you. You abuse the concept of mathematics the way a creationist, or an astrologer might abuse them. The mathematics only matters to you when it's convenient, or you can use it to ridicule individuals. The physics (like Lee's empirical work) is UTTER IRRELEVANT to EU haters. There's nothing rational about EU hater behaviors. "Electrical discharges in plasma? What discharges?" Oy Vey. You folks don't give a damn about Dungey's FULL work, just half of it.
 
Last edited:
Emphasis mine. IMO this statement says VOLUMES. I must have posted two dozen or more links that demonstrate that magnetic fields have no source and no sink.
As you’re the only one here who has claimed such sources or sinks (monopoles) are required for magnetic reconnection. The lack of such monopoles remains simply your problem.

You provided the source/sink paper that is DIRECTLY RELATED to this issue. When confronted with the two lines of math that demonstrate that CURRENT (water) is being turned into MAGNETIC CHARGES (magnetic wine), you don't even acknowledge it! Math is *IRRELEVANT* to this crew. You use it ONLY WHEN IT SUITS YOU, and you IGNORE the maths you don't like.

“DIRECTLY RELATED to this issue”? What you mean the issue of your strawman monopole argument against magnetic reconnection? Look, again, you’re the only one here claiming monopoles are required for magnetic reconnection so you can whine about your “wine” all you want as you’re the only one who needs to drink it.

I can see I'll be posting a lot more on Thunderbolts in the future. They seem to be interested in real scientific dialog. The EU haters that post here aren't even INTERESTED in an HONEST SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION on this topic, or the topic of solar flares. It's just one personal attack after another after another. Anyone and everyone that posits an "electric sun theory" is called a "crackpot" a "crank", etc, up to and including Hannes Alfven himself. Yawn. This is like discussing evolutionary theory with hard core creationists.

Math's don't ACTUALLY matter to any of you. You abuse the concept of mathematics the way a creationist, or an astrologer might abuse them. The mathematics only matters to you when it's convenient, or you can use it to ridicule individuals. The physics (like Lee's empirical work) is UTTER IRRELEVANT to EU haters. There's nothing rational about EU hater behaviors. "Electrical discharges in plasma? What discharges?" Oy Vey. You folks don't give a damn about Dungey's FULL work, just half of it.

Again, if math or those two equations you continue to whine about actually matter to you and you still think W.D.Clinger's assertions and calculations are wrong. Then simply use those two equations to mathematically show exactly what and where W.D.Clinger did wrong. Whining about them won’t do that for you and if you can’t or just won’t do exactly that than the only thing that evidently actually matters to you is just your own whining. Once again your efforts to posit your own particular distain and lack of understanding of mathematics upon others is obvious and futile.
 
Likewise haters cannot embrace the REALITY that "electrical discharges" occur in flares

You insisted on defining "electrical discharge" to include "sudden releases of electric or magnetic energy". Under that definition, all of mainstream solar physics has indeed embraced the reality that electricalMoz dischargesMoz occur in flares. There are no haters who deny electricalMoz dischargesMoz. The particular form of electricalMoz dischargeMoz which is thought to occur is one called "magnetic reconnection".

Out with it, Michael. Everyone knows what you want to argue: you want to say "the Sun has high voltages on it, like Birkeland's sphere did, and solar flares are DC currents that flow due to that voltage". But you can't find any support for that statement in the literature.

You therefore mine for statements that you can twist into agreeing with you. You get one paper saying "this flare was a release of magnetic energy", another paper saying "a discharge is a release of electric or magnetic energy", and yet another paper saying "the terella underwent electric discharges", and you pretend that this adds up to vindication. It doesn't.
 
As long as they never have to agree on scientific terms and definitions, maybe they can hide themselves from the reality that "electrical discharges" occur in flares, and "electrical discharges" have been associated with "reconnection" events since the term "reconnection" was first invented. Both terms were used by Dungey.
...usual hate rant snipped...
We agree on the definition of electrical discharge. It is the sudden flow of current allowed by the breakdown of a dielectric medium, e.g. lightning. They are impossible in plasma. So it is idotic to state that electrical discharges cause solar flares.

We understand the stupidity of citing Dungey who states that you are wrong - solar flares are caused by magnetic reconnection.
 
Missed this:
FYI, it's not "me" that first used the term "electrical discharge" in relationship to solar flare events PS, it was DUNGEY and PERATT that used that term long before I was introduced to EU/PC theory. That is where I got the term in the first place, specifically Peratt's book, Physics Of The Plasma Universe. I quoted him for you.

I also showed you where Dungey used that same term "electrical discharge" in precisely the same way as Paratt defines the term. Dungey is describing the sudden release of stored EM energy in one giant "electrical discharge" during a reconnection event.
FYI, so many delusions and lies :jaw-dropp!
Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma!

DUNGEY never used this term in relationship to solar flare events. He used this term in the context of magnetic reconnection. The MR is then the cause of solar flares. The idiocy of citing someone who states that you are wrong is obvious.

Michael Mozina's fantasy about Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge!
PERATT never used this term in relationship to solar flare events.
You have been constantly lying about PERATT's definition of electrical discharge.

You have not been able to understand that DUNGEY and PERATT defintions are different!
Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different.
13th January 2011 (13 months and counting)

DUNGEY's usage does not involve any "sudden release of stored EM energy".
Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection
18th October 2011
 
Apparently he has moved away from that idea. A few posts above, he does say that there is no dielectric material to break down (like lightning on earth) in solar plasmas.
However Michael Mozina's recent citing of Bruce who requires a dielectric material to break down (like lightning on earth) suggests that MM has forgotten his own debunking of Bruce :eek:.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom