Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 VII
What "mathematical ignorance"? I went to all the trouble of speaking your language, citing the exact equations where Priest turns electric current into magnetic wine, thereby sinking Clinger's ship and all you ignored it!
I had not noticed this particular comment until
The Man posted it.
This is, of course, very false. We did not ignore it. We proved conclusively that you were and are dead wrong,
dead wrong, in your assumptions about the equations; see, e.g., my previous post
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 V and posts referenced therein. We thereby also show that your math skills are somewhat deficient by comparisons with your claims.
Um, the only "ridiculous" attempt you made to SWEEP THE ISSUE UNDER THE CARPET that is even worth responding to, you did in this post Tim:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7808363#post7808363
Well, actually that is the post that quotes the post where I said ...
No it is not. Look at the sentence immediately prior to equation 16. It read as follows, with my added emphasis:
"Equation (15) gives a singular field only on the negative part of the z-axis. Here both currents and magnetic charges are present:"
What the HECK is a magnetic charge that you claim is "present".
Nobody claims that a magnetic charge is present; that claim is not made by the paper and it is not made by me.
Furthermore, how is it there in the ABSENCE of that current Priest describes?
I have no idea what you are talking about. I doubt that you have any idea either. As the paper explicitly states, both monopoles and current are used mathematically (neither is claimed to be physically present).
The only reason it's there at all is because a BIRKELAND CURRENT runs and through that Z axis.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birkeland_current
[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/79/Magnetic_rope.png/300px-Magnetic_rope.png[/qimg]
That's a BENNETT PINCH Tim!
No, the diagram is not that of a Bennett Pinch.
In equation 17, they're literally converting CHARGED PARTICLE KINETIC ENERGY into "magnetic charges", AKA MONOPOLES!
No, they are not doing any such thing. That's why people say that your mathematical skills are, despite your contentions to the contrary, pathetic. I agree; you have no idea what an equation is, you have no skill to read mathematical equations, and you always avoid math because you know as well as we do that you have no idea what it is. I know that for a fact, and I dare you to demonstrate that I am wrong.
FYI, here's a link the the relevant page where the two equations are listed:
http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1992A&A...258..535D/0000539.000.html
You forgot this, from
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992, 22 November 2011 ...
Furthermore, these equations, and this paper, are vastly overblown and exaggerated by Mozina. This trick of using magnetic charges appears in only a few papers, and they are all early in the process of describing the physics of magnetic reconnection. Its sole purpose is to play a role in multipole expansions of the magnetic field. But superior methods soon arrived and this methodology of using magnetic charges, which was even then esoteric & obscure, disappeared altogether, never to be seen again. It does not appear in any text book on plasma physics, field modeling, or magnetic reconnection that I have seen. That's why I said I didn't want to talk about this, because it is irrelevant. irrelevant. The current state of the physics of magnetic field modeling and magnetic reconnection does not involve any of this at all.
Here is what is really going on in the paper, the truth that sails so far beyond Mozina, he doesn't even feel the intellectual breeze. Out in the plasma where they want to study the physics, including magnetic reconnection, there is a magnetic field. The field obviously comes from somewhere, but it certainly is not generated by the plasma co-located with the magnetic field, it is generated elsewhere. We know that magnetic fields are
physically generated by the motion of electrically charged particles, which can be expressed as charge neutral plasma flow or by the usual electrically charged current flow. If the magnetic field has a complicated geometry or topology (those two words
are not synonymous) the physical current patterns required to generate them can be too mathematically complicated to allow a numerical computation of the desired field. So, one good computational trick is to just use monopoles, which always make the job of computing the field a lot easier. So, what Dèmoulin & Priest are doing is creating a small array of monopoles and simple currents and placing them under the model photosphere where they will then computationally create the magnetic field where they want it, with geometry & topology to match those observed, and then that field/plasma interaction physics can be studied. The monopoles and currents that appear in equations 16 & 17 are never used anywhere in the paper in any direct way and have absolutely nothing at all to do with the physics under study, other than to
computationally generate the desired remote magnetic field.
Furthermore, pay attention to the my self-quoted paragraph above. This trick appears only in early papers, and in very few of them, and is quite literally never seen again. Once more powerful computers allow more powerful computational capability, the need for this kind of computational trick is gone. The ability to model magnetic fields with more realistic current and plasma flow is obviously an improvement. So Mozina "tilts at windmills"; he has no idea what those two equations are really doing, and ignores the fact that nothing like it appears in any text book and nothing like it is used in any of the current studies, and ignores the fact that his entire argument, aside from being 100% wrong, is also 100% irrelevant.