DeiRenDopa said:
I think I'm missing something really important here, so, MM, help me out please.
What do "Alfven's double layer paper" and "the paper by Mann and Onel" have to do with your (published, on your website) electric Sun idea?
I asked you about the latter before, and here's how you answered:
Now this answer does not - to me anyway - connect the dots.
For example, there is no link - in your post - between "Birkeland's "cathode sun" model" and "the paper by Mann and Onel". Specifically, there is nothing that shows - in terms of theory or simulation [1] - how the regions of physical parameter space in the former relate to the latter. Take a highly simplified case: what are the boundaries of the pressure-temperature parameter space in "Birkeland's "cathode sun" model"? What are they in "the paper by Mann and Onel"?
[1] you have already admitted that the conditions in Birkeland's experiments are many orders of magnitude different - in the key physical parameters, such as temperature and pressure gradients - from those of the real Sun
[qimg]http://www.thesurfaceofthesun.com/images/birkelandyohkohmini.jpg[/qimg]
There was a time in my life where I had some "respect" for folks like you and those I perceived at the time as EU "critics". Your last series of questions however, and this thread specifically have very clearly demonstrated the problem with EU hater mentality. I cannot believe that it's "news" to you that I've been promoting an *INTERNALLY* powered solar model for the past *SEVEN* years!
And this is relevant to the post of mine that you quoted, how exactly?
How could you POSSIBLY have taken the time to LISTEN to me and attempt to understand me and still not know that? How can you possibly still NOT understand that coronal loops formed by *electrical discharges* are a *KEY* PREDICTION of Birkeland's work which must be "scaled" to size as he himself suggested?
Again, this is relevant to the actual content of my post, how?
I mean, you posted an image (yet again), and wrote some words.
The words do not contain anything quantitative. Nor is there anything that looks like a system of equations.
But perhaps I did not make myself sufficiently clear.
I am NOT INTERESTED, *not interested*, *NOT INTERESTED* (you get the idea) in yet more nudge-nudge wink-wink/handwaving explanations incorporating ill-defined (or not defined, or worse) key terms!
I would like to read an explanation, from you (as you're the only one proposing this particular electric Sun idea), of the work you've done to show that the quantitative Birkeland PREDICTIONs (whatever they may be) are consistent, quantitatively, with the contents of "the paper by Mann and Onel" (ditto "Alfven's double layer paper"). As a start, I suggested that you show what overlaps there are, in terms of the ranges of temperature and pressure of the physical regimes in each.
This whole conversation is surreal from my perspective, and it demonstrates the problem with trying to communicate with "haters". Haters aren't interested in UNDERSTANDING. They are only interested in continuing to spread hate and confusions and engage themselves in PERSONAL ATTACKS.
I can only speak for myself.
If you read what I wrote as a PERSONAL ATTACK (whatever that is), I apologize. I did not intend to ATTACK you PERSONALLY, nor do I think that my post contains language that could be interpreted - by a native speaker of English - as constituting such an ATTACK.
<irrelevant text skipped>
When the MATHS are presented to support the earliest PREDICTIONS of the electrical aspects of electric sun theory, EU haters utterly and completely ignore it! EU Haters don't care about TRUTH at all. All they care about is spreading disinformation and obtaining some sort of twisted ego gratification by attacking INDIVIDUALS!
Do you honestly not see a problem with what you wrote?
I mean, you talk about "
electric sun theory", without making it clear that you are (or should be) referring to only your own electric Sun ideas.
Then there's this: "
When the MATHS are presented to support the earliest PREDICTIONS of the electrical aspects". That might be so, in your own head, but my question to you - in a post which you chose to quote (and to which I'm now responding) - is about the (apparent) lack of a quantitative basis for this statement (of yours). And I even narrowed my question down to something both incredibly simple and fundamental: can you show - quantitatively - that the temperature and pressure conditions of "
the earliest PREDICTIONS" are consistent with "
the MATHS [...] presented"?
If you can, well and good, please do so (and if any reader know of any posts, by MM, in this thread, where he has already done so, would you mind providing a link?). If you can't, then please just say so.
EU haters are *EXACTLY* like creationists that HATE evolutionary theory. No amount of evidence matters. No amount of dialog matters. None of these haters cares about the scientific search for "truth". All they care about is promoting HATE.
To repeat: I do not recall ever seeing any quantitative evidence posted by you. Quantitative evidence meaning a demonstration that the physical regimes (of the "
*KEY* PREDICTION of Birkeland's work", "
the paper by Mann and Onel", and "
Alfven's double layer paper") at least overlap.