Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Even if it's all true, so what? No theory rises or falls on the math skills of a single individual. Did you find any flaw in Alfven's double layer paper? Did you find any flaws in the paper by Mann and Onel?

I guess the EU hater mentality is based upon the false belief that if they bash individuals, the actual math that crushes their beliefs doesn't really exist.

I think I'm missing something really important here, so, MM, help me out please.

What do "Alfven's double layer paper" and "the paper by Mann and Onel" have to do with your (published, on your website) electric Sun idea?

I asked you about the latter before, and here's how you answered:
Sure. In Birkeland's "cathode sun" model, current carrying "loops" are in face an "experimental prediction" of his working simulation. They are in fact a primary means to FALSIFY his cathode sun theories were they to be absent in the solar atmosphere. That would pretty much shoot his theory dead on the spot. The other key "prediction" from his experiments relates to the flow of particles (predominantly away from the sun), and the interactions with the heliosphere which he simply referred to as "space".

The flow of matter in the solar atmosphere was "predicted" by Birkeland's model to work in VERY specific ways. There's no way to continue to accept his model for instance were those high energy coronal loops ABSENT from solar satellite images. A cathode sun operating at 600 million volts damn well BETTER produce "electrical discharges" in the solar atmosphere as he predicted, or his predictions were worthless. Fortunately he hit the nail on the head.

Now this answer does not - to me anyway - connect the dots.

For example, there is no link - in your post - between "Birkeland's "cathode sun" model" and "the paper by Mann and Onel". Specifically, there is nothing that shows - in terms of theory or simulation [1] - how the regions of physical parameter space in the former relate to the latter. Take a highly simplified case: what are the boundaries of the pressure-temperature parameter space in "Birkeland's "cathode sun" model"? What are they in "the paper by Mann and Onel"?

[1] you have already admitted that the conditions in Birkeland's experiments are many orders of magnitude different - in the key physical parameters, such as temperature and pressure gradients - from those of the real Sun
 
I said, I'm not following the corona-physics part of the thread.

Then you aren't following the thread because it started out to be about CME's to begin with, and the whole thing has been focused on solar flares.

Mann and Onel? It's a short, unremarkable paper (cited once, by another Mann and Onel paper) and it shows what electrons do in the presence of a Sun-like magnetic field with a small (few kV) electric field. It claims that this electric field arises from thermodynamics. I have no problem with any of that, and it doesn't sound the slightest bit like it supports your assertions.

Then you aren't following the thread.
 
What an absolutely PATHETIC argument. I've seen hard core denial before, but your denial that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares absolutely takes the cake.
What an absolutely IGNORANT statement. I've seen hard core ignorance before, but your ignorance that electrical discharges are physically impossible in plasmas and flares absolutely takes the cake.
This is something that anyone with a basic knowledge of physics knows.

Take for example, Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge that needs the breakdown of a dielectric medium. He gives the example of lightning where the dielectric medium that breaks down is air. There is no dielectric medium in plasma. It is a highly conductive ionized gas.

As for Dungey: What an absolutely PATHETIC argument citing someone who states that you are wrong :jaw-dropp!
Dungey's obsolete usage does not support your delusion.
  1. Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different.
    13th January 2011 (13 months and counting :eye-poppi)
  2. Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection
    18th October 2011 (121 days and counting!)
  3. MM: Citing Dungey means that you are stating that the cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection :jaw-dropp!
    8th November 2011 (100 days and counting)
 
Last edited:
There's only one real "reason". The evidence blows away EU hater belief systems, [...]


Utter nonsense. There is no "EU hater belief system".

[...] starting with your belief that electrical discharges do not occur in plasmas.


I do not hold any such belief, the uncivil and dishonest protests to the contrary notwithstanding. A claim was made that solar flares and CMEs are, or are caused by, electrical discharges akin to lightning here on Earth. That claim is false, demonstrably false, false according to the laws of physics. Electrical discharges like lightning bolts or the sparks in a toy plasma ball cannot occur in the conductive plasma of the solar atmosphere. There is no belief involved. It's a simple scientific fact. And the only objection to that fact seems to be based on some cherry picked words and phrases from some scientific papers. But wishing an against-the-mainstream fantasy into reality by dishonestly redefining terms will fail. It won't work any better going forward than it has in the past.

The moment a hater embraces the circuit/E orientation to plasma physics, the jig is up. The moment they let got of the hate, the hater party is over, and science prevails over hatred. EU haters can't and won't give up their hatred for EU oriented ideas, just as creationists cannot and will not give up their hatred for evolutionary theory. The moment that hatred is gone, all that remains is science that blows that hatred away.


There are no EU haters, certainly not in this conversation. And dishonestly and uncivilly referring to critics as haters isn't advancing the discussion one bit. There is no conspiracy against non-standard theories, conjectures, or ideas. Nobody is being persecuted. If a scientific theory or conjecture has what it takes, and those advocating for it communicate it in a compelling, cogent, quantitative, objective, scientific way, it will be accepted into the fold. If it fails to be accepted, it is because it fails to be legitimately scientific or because its advocates fail to present it properly. That's all.

The failure of the electric Sun contingent to get their ideas accepted is not the responsibility of the real scientists. The failure belongs to the electric Sun advocates. It is theirs. They own it. All of it. Complaining about failing and blaming other people for the failure has no value in the world of science. The fact that we see more of that in this thread than we see of anything legitimately scientific says a lot about the validity of the electric Sun conjectures.

Productive suggestion: Determine whether the failure is in the conjecture itself or in the way it's being presented. If the failure is because of the presentation, fix the presentation. If the failure is in the conjecture itself, it's bound to be rooted in the math. Science, real science, is a quantitative process. Have someone competent in the relevant math repair the flaws then present it again. If the mathematical flaws can't be rectified, abandon the conjecture.
 
Last edited:
Did you find any flaw in Alfven's double layer paper? Did you find any flaws in the paper by Mann and Onel?
Your ignorance continues.
No one has found any flaws in Alfvén's double layer paper.
No one has found any flaws in the Mann and Önel paper.

No one has been able to understand your inability to understand the contents of these papers.

These are both rather trivial (judging by their citations), scientifically valid papers.

Alfvén's double layer paper was a nice theory that matched the total energy for a flare using an circuit model including a double layer. This approximation is however only good for large scale properties and cannot produce details. For example there is no actual physical structure for the flare. A circuit model is not "E orientation of plasma physics".
Science has progressed since the paper was written and the evidence is that MR causes the flares and accounts for much more than this simplistic model.

Citing Mann and Önel is stupid since they have MR as a cause of the acceleration of their electrons.
Generation of large scale electric fields in coronal flare circuits by Onel and Mann does an excellent job of describing the acceleration of electrons in solar flares using a circuit model.
This model requites a magnetic connection and they explicitly mention the possibility of magnetic reconnection providing this (bottom page 5).
Citing Mann and Önel is doubly stupid since the paper is about the acceleration of electrons by magnetic fields - no electrical discharges are mentioned.
 
Then you aren't following the thread because it started out to be about CME's to begin with, and the whole thing has been focused on solar flares.

Let me correct my statement: I'm not following the corona-physics part of the thread any more. I contributed for a long time. I always had the impression that you didn't read my comments---though you often replied to them, your replies were mired in exactly the same ignorance no matter what I had typed at you. So I gave up.

But I wasn't replying to your current corona-physics business, whatever it is. I was posting about (a) the fact that the Sun's neutrino emissions strongly oppose its being fission-powered, and (b) Oliver Manuel's ideas about the Sun---I can't even call them a "hypothesis" or a "model"---include (if you apply the laws of physics) the prediction that the Sun has inflated into a red giant.

I stand by those statements and I don't care what Onel and Mann have to say about a completely different topic, get it?
 
I think I'm missing something really important here, so, MM, help me out please.

What do "Alfven's double layer paper" and "the paper by Mann and Onel" have to do with your (published, on your website) electric Sun idea?

I asked you about the latter before, and here's how you answered:


Now this answer does not - to me anyway - connect the dots.

For example, there is no link - in your post - between "Birkeland's "cathode sun" model" and "the paper by Mann and Onel". Specifically, there is nothing that shows - in terms of theory or simulation [1] - how the regions of physical parameter space in the former relate to the latter. Take a highly simplified case: what are the boundaries of the pressure-temperature parameter space in "Birkeland's "cathode sun" model"? What are they in "the paper by Mann and Onel"?

[1] you have already admitted that the conditions in Birkeland's experiments are many orders of magnitude different - in the key physical parameters, such as temperature and pressure gradients - from those of the real Sun

birkelandyohkohmini.jpg


There was a time in my life where I had some "respect" for folks like you and those I perceived at the time as EU "critics". Your last series of questions however, and this thread specifically have very clearly demonstrated the problem with EU hater mentality. I cannot believe that it's "news" to you that I've been promoting an *INTERNALLY* powered solar model for the past *SEVEN* years!

How could you POSSIBLY have taken the time to LISTEN to me and attempt to understand me and still not know that? How can you possibly still NOT understand that coronal loops formed by *electrical discharges* are a *KEY* PREDICTION of Birkeland's work which must be "scaled" to size as he himself suggested? This whole conversation is surreal from my perspective, and it demonstrates the problem with trying to communicate with "haters". Haters aren't interested in UNDERSTANDING. They are only interested in continuing to spread hate and confusions and engage themselves in PERSONAL ATTACKS.

That's what the EU hater cult does FOR A LIVING! I mean really. Many of you are or were PROFESSIONAL astronomers. Rather than attempt to UNDERSTAND the model being presented, every single one of you have FAILED to even make such an attempt.

When the MATHS are presented to support the earliest PREDICTIONS of the electrical aspects of electric sun theory, EU haters utterly and completely ignore it! EU Haters don't care about TRUTH at all. All they care about is spreading disinformation and obtaining some sort of twisted ego gratification by attacking INDIVIDUALS!

EU haters are *EXACTLY* like creationists that HATE evolutionary theory. No amount of evidence matters. No amount of dialog matters. None of these haters cares about the scientific search for "truth". All they care about is promoting HATE.
 
Last edited:
Let me correct my statement: I'm not following the corona-physics part of the thread any more. I contributed for a long time. I always had the impression that you didn't read my comments---though you often replied to them, your replies were mired in exactly the same ignorance no matter what I had typed at you. So I gave up.

Boloney. You "gave up" because you KNOW FOR A FACT that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and solar flares and you don't want to talk about it, lest you be ostracized by your online buddies like RC that are in PURE DENIAL OF SCIENTIFIC FACT! I smell fear.

But I wasn't replying to your current corona-physics business, whatever it is. I was posting about (a) the fact that the Sun's neutrino emissions strongly oppose its being fission-powered, and (b) Oliver Manuel's ideas about the Sun---I can't even call them a "hypothesis" or a "model"---include (if you apply the laws of physics) the prediction that the Sun has inflated into a red giant.

I stand by those statements and I don't care what Onel and Mann have to say about a completely different topic, get it?

Ok, PLEASE SHOW ME where you falsified MANUEL's MODEL (not necessarily mine) so I have SOME idea of what you're talking about.
 
Utter nonsense. There is no "EU hater belief system".


Michael Mozina said:
There's only one real "reason". The evidence blows away EU hater belief systems, starting with your belief that electrical discharges do not occur in plasmas.

I do not hold any such belief, the uncivil and dishonest protests to the contrary notwithstanding.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6607542&postcount=64

Oh, so you NOW ADMIT that this statement of yours is false?

The solar atmosphere is plasma. Plasma is a conductor. A discharge cannot occur within a conductor.

Yes or no? Stop tap dancing.
 
Last edited:
I know you did not intend to come even close to listing the types of alternatives proposed, tested, and found wanting.

However, one of my personal faves is missing: the idea that everything is exactly as the physics of the day pointed to, just that the Sun has these, you know, oscillations, in the fusion rates in its core. Oscillations that last tens/hundreds/thousands/... of years. And that we happen to be 'observing' the Sun's core at a low point in its fusion rate cycle (that's why Davis saw such low numbers of neutrinos), and that these cycles aren't reflected - in any obvious way - in the Sun's (eventual) photospheric emission because {insert clever ideas here}.

Oh, and let's not forget the dozens (or more?) of papers on 'here's why Davis' reported rates are wrong (subtext: his experimental methods are not up to scratch/his analyses ignore huge systematic effects/etc)'.

Now back to your regular, scheduled program ...

Note that during all that time, scientists NEVER stopped promoting a fusion solar model, not EVER. I've already explained that I think Fusion has the upper hand AT THE MOMENT. I just don't profess to have a crystal ball as it relates to long term neutrino science like some folks.
 
Isn't it astonishing? A layman, who claims no expertise in physics, but asks a few probing questions about these EU conjectures can be branded "a hater," when he concludes such conjectures have no merit. I suppose if I were to examine vitamin C anti-cancer therapy and conclude it has no merit, I would become a "vitamin C hater."
So:
I am an acupuncture hater.
I am a homeopathy hater.
I am a flat earth hater.
I am an ID hater.
I am an ESP hater.
I am a voodoo hater.
etc.
With so much hate, I'm not sure I can live with myself.:(
 
Note that during all that time, scientists NEVER stopped promoting a fusion solar model, not EVER.

Various scientists promoted various models. Of course, a lot of them stuck with the fusion model (and variants thereof), but as Ben indicated, there were a lot of other possibilities put forward, and I'm confident that many of these alternatives had some very passionate supporters. As time passed and more data was gathered, the alternatives were individually rejected as they couldn't fit the observations.

You seem to be characterizing the whole process as a scientific orthodoxy covering their collective ears and going "LA LA LA LA LA!" whenever someone tried to show any conflicting data, but that's certainly not how it seemed to me. Rather, they spent a lot of resources in re-evaluating their models and in understanding the data that appeared to conflict. In this case, it was the apparently-conflicting data that was being misunderstood.
 
DeiRenDopa said:
I think I'm missing something really important here, so, MM, help me out please.

What do "Alfven's double layer paper" and "the paper by Mann and Onel" have to do with your (published, on your website) electric Sun idea?

I asked you about the latter before, and here's how you answered:


Now this answer does not - to me anyway - connect the dots.

For example, there is no link - in your post - between "Birkeland's "cathode sun" model" and "the paper by Mann and Onel". Specifically, there is nothing that shows - in terms of theory or simulation [1] - how the regions of physical parameter space in the former relate to the latter. Take a highly simplified case: what are the boundaries of the pressure-temperature parameter space in "Birkeland's "cathode sun" model"? What are they in "the paper by Mann and Onel"?

[1] you have already admitted that the conditions in Birkeland's experiments are many orders of magnitude different - in the key physical parameters, such as temperature and pressure gradients - from those of the real Sun
[qimg]http://www.thesurfaceofthesun.com/images/birkelandyohkohmini.jpg[/qimg]

There was a time in my life where I had some "respect" for folks like you and those I perceived at the time as EU "critics". Your last series of questions however, and this thread specifically have very clearly demonstrated the problem with EU hater mentality. I cannot believe that it's "news" to you that I've been promoting an *INTERNALLY* powered solar model for the past *SEVEN* years!
And this is relevant to the post of mine that you quoted, how exactly?

How could you POSSIBLY have taken the time to LISTEN to me and attempt to understand me and still not know that? How can you possibly still NOT understand that coronal loops formed by *electrical discharges* are a *KEY* PREDICTION of Birkeland's work which must be "scaled" to size as he himself suggested?
Again, this is relevant to the actual content of my post, how?

I mean, you posted an image (yet again), and wrote some words.

The words do not contain anything quantitative. Nor is there anything that looks like a system of equations.

But perhaps I did not make myself sufficiently clear.

I am NOT INTERESTED, *not interested*, *NOT INTERESTED* (you get the idea) in yet more nudge-nudge wink-wink/handwaving explanations incorporating ill-defined (or not defined, or worse) key terms!

I would like to read an explanation, from you (as you're the only one proposing this particular electric Sun idea), of the work you've done to show that the quantitative Birkeland PREDICTIONs (whatever they may be) are consistent, quantitatively, with the contents of "the paper by Mann and Onel" (ditto "Alfven's double layer paper"). As a start, I suggested that you show what overlaps there are, in terms of the ranges of temperature and pressure of the physical regimes in each.

This whole conversation is surreal from my perspective, and it demonstrates the problem with trying to communicate with "haters". Haters aren't interested in UNDERSTANDING. They are only interested in continuing to spread hate and confusions and engage themselves in PERSONAL ATTACKS.

I can only speak for myself.

If you read what I wrote as a PERSONAL ATTACK (whatever that is), I apologize. I did not intend to ATTACK you PERSONALLY, nor do I think that my post contains language that could be interpreted - by a native speaker of English - as constituting such an ATTACK.

<irrelevant text skipped>

When the MATHS are presented to support the earliest PREDICTIONS of the electrical aspects of electric sun theory, EU haters utterly and completely ignore it! EU Haters don't care about TRUTH at all. All they care about is spreading disinformation and obtaining some sort of twisted ego gratification by attacking INDIVIDUALS!

Do you honestly not see a problem with what you wrote?

I mean, you talk about "electric sun theory", without making it clear that you are (or should be) referring to only your own electric Sun ideas.

Then there's this: "When the MATHS are presented to support the earliest PREDICTIONS of the electrical aspects". That might be so, in your own head, but my question to you - in a post which you chose to quote (and to which I'm now responding) - is about the (apparent) lack of a quantitative basis for this statement (of yours). And I even narrowed my question down to something both incredibly simple and fundamental: can you show - quantitatively - that the temperature and pressure conditions of "the earliest PREDICTIONS" are consistent with "the MATHS [...] presented"?

If you can, well and good, please do so (and if any reader know of any posts, by MM, in this thread, where he has already done so, would you mind providing a link?). If you can't, then please just say so.

EU haters are *EXACTLY* like creationists that HATE evolutionary theory. No amount of evidence matters. No amount of dialog matters. None of these haters cares about the scientific search for "truth". All they care about is promoting HATE.

To repeat: I do not recall ever seeing any quantitative evidence posted by you. Quantitative evidence meaning a demonstration that the physical regimes (of the "*KEY* PREDICTION of Birkeland's work", "the paper by Mann and Onel", and "Alfven's double layer paper") at least overlap.
 
Note that during all that time, scientists NEVER stopped promoting a fusion solar model, not EVER. I've already explained that I think Fusion has the upper hand AT THE MOMENT. I just don't profess to have a crystal ball as it relates to long term neutrino science like some folks.

Remember, nothing other than a fusion model ever got anywhere close to working, and fusion models worked just fine.

You don't have to have a crystal ball. This is science, and you're allowed to make hypotheses---even conditional ones. You could try this:

"Unless there is a serious misunderstanding of neutrinos, the Sun does not undergo much fission. However, if we hypothesize that <insert a particle-physics hypothesis you have no evidence for>, there may be room for <fission-based sun model>"

Waaaaaait a second. The last time particle physicists put forward a particle-physics hypothesis they had no laboratory evidence for, YOU WENT BALLISTIC. It was called "dark matter", they had lots of non-laboratory evidence for it, and in your mind it was a travesty against science to even consider such a thing. But now, all of a sudden, some "dark", invented-out-of-thin-air, no-laboratory-evidence-available hypothetical laws of particle physics are fair game.

Unsurprising, really. You never really held a "I only believe laboratory experiments" position. It's just a rhetorical tic you adopted for use in your anti-dark-energy crusade.
 
There's an important aspect here that I did not cover in my earlier post.

I've added bold for emphasis.
There was a time in my life where I had some "respect" for folks like you and those I perceived at the time as EU "critics". Your last series of questions however, and this thread specifically have very clearly demonstrated the problem with EU hater mentality. I cannot believe that it's "news" to you that I've been promoting an *INTERNALLY* powered solar model for the past *SEVEN* years!

How could you POSSIBLY have taken the time to LISTEN to me and attempt to understand me and still not know that? How can you possibly still NOT understand that coronal loops formed by *electrical discharges* are a *KEY* PREDICTION of Birkeland's work which must be "scaled" to size as he himself suggested? This whole conversation is surreal from my perspective, and it demonstrates the problem with trying to communicate with "haters". Haters aren't interested in UNDERSTANDING. They are only interested in continuing to spread hate and confusions and engage themselves in PERSONAL ATTACKS.

That's what the EU hater cult does FOR A LIVING! I mean really. Many of you are or were PROFESSIONAL astronomers. Rather than attempt to UNDERSTAND the model being presented, every single one of you have FAILED to even make such an attempt.

When the MATHS are presented to support the earliest PREDICTIONS of the electrical aspects of electric sun theory, EU haters utterly and completely ignore it! EU Haters don't care about TRUTH at all. All they care about is spreading disinformation and obtaining some sort of twisted ego gratification by attacking INDIVIDUALS!

EU haters are *EXACTLY* like creationists that HATE evolutionary theory. No amount of evidence matters. No amount of dialog matters. None of these haters cares about the scientific search for "truth". All they care about is promoting HATE.

Now just recently you posted this here, in this very thread.

You want a discussion of your own electric Sun idea, and only one aspect in particular in this thread.

Fair enough.

Yet what does this post of yours - the one I'm quoting here - do?

Why, it conflates your own electric Sun idea with EU. It makes explicit reference to "electric sun theory". It implicitly identifies you as being a member of "the EU community". And so on.

Given this - and this post of yours is by no means unique in this regard - it is not at all surprising that readers may conclude that you want to discuss any and all electric Sun ideas, no matter who proposed them, no matter where. In fact, I think it would be surprising if a reader were to conclude otherwise!

Yet, as I (and perhaps other readers) now know, your own electric Sun idea is radically different from any of those produced by the EU community. So much so that, over at Thunderblots, they are careful to explain to newbies that your ideas are not consistent with EU, and that discussion of your ideas is not welcome there (you know this, right?) Put bluntly, you are not a member of the EU community.

Given all this, why do you keep on trying to conflate your electric Sun idea with EU?
 
And if you want the error in the Oliver Manuel model---well, there's a long list. His energy budget for a "neutron star" is nonsense. He's taken the Table of Nuclides and extrapolated to estimate the mass-per-nucleon of a pure-neutron nucleus. (Why should such an extrapolation work?)

He now has two, conflicting numbers for the mass per nucleon of a neutron star: one conventional number (0.91 amu), and his own wacky extrapolation (1.018 amu). He implicitly assumes the former when stating "neutron stars form in gravitational collapse", and then he switches back to the latter when extracting energy from the neutron-dripline decay of these same stars.

This violates conservation of energy. If neutron matter actually weighs 1.018 amu*A, then neutron matter cannot be the end state of gravitational collapse. If neutron matter is the end state of gravitational collapse, then neutrons cannot gain energy by un-collapsing out of this end state. Manuel has accidentally drawn the nuclear version of that MC Escher picture where a canal powers a waterwheel, and the waterwheel's runoff feeds the canal.

So that's idiotic mistake number one.

Idiotic mistake number two is slapping a neutron star into the core of the Sun. Manuel puts this star in there, invents his neutron-emission nonsense and pretends that it "supplies hydrogen" to the rest of the Sun. He forgets about gravity. The gravitational pull of a neutron star's surface is very, very high. If there's a sea of hydrogen above this surface, it has to be at very, very high pressure. Manuel has stipulated that there's 4e26W of power flowing through this hydrogen---never mind that that's an impossible super-Eddington heat transfer rate---so it's also very, very hot. You know what ultradense, ultrahot hydrogen does? It undergoes fusion---extremely rapid fusion. In fact, this sort of fusion---dense hydrogen compressed by a neutron star's gravity---has been studied extensively, under conditions much calmer than Manuel's crazy scenario. One example is the "x-ray burster", which looks like a mini-supernova (which, in binary-star contexts, ends only when it runs out of fuel), another is the "dwarf nova" (same thing, but on a white dwarf).

Does Manuel actually build a stellar model that shows whether hydrogen can survive in a calm, cool, low-density, non-exploding cloud near his "neutron star"? No he doesn't. I see no evidence that he is aware of the mere fact that stars have to obey temperature/pressure/gravity relationships.

So that's idiotic mistake number two.

Shall I continue?
 
Various scientists promoted various models. Of course, a lot of them stuck with the fusion model (and variants thereof), but as Ben indicated, there were a lot of other possibilities put forward, and I'm confident that many of these alternatives had some very passionate supporters. As time passed and more data was gathered, the alternatives were individually rejected as they couldn't fit the observations.

You seem to be characterizing the whole process as a scientific orthodoxy covering their collective ears and going "LA LA LA LA LA!" whenever someone tried to show any conflicting data, but that's certainly not how it seemed to me. Rather, they spent a lot of resources in re-evaluating their models and in understanding the data that appeared to conflict. In this case, it was the apparently-conflicting data that was being misunderstood.

With respect to electric sun theories in general, that is *EXACTLY* what the collective is doing. Who besides me is correcting RC and GM and setting them straight PUBLICLY about the fact that electrical discharges occur in CONDUCTORS? Who besides me is doing ANYTHING to point out the fact that BOTH the E (circuit) and B (field) orientations of plasma physics are EQUALLY VALID?

You all sit back and do NOTHING to seek TRUTH IMO. Even people that I respect and admire like you and ben are GUILTY of not setting the record straight IMO.
 
Last edited:
With respect to electric sun theories in general, that is *EXACTLY* what the collective is doing. Who besides me is correcting RC and GM and setting them straight PUBLICLY about the fact that electrical discharges occur in CONDUCTORS? Who besides me is doing ANYTHING to point out the fact that BOTH the E (circuit) and B (field) orientations of plasma physics are EQUALLY VALID?

You all sit back and do NOTHING to seek TRUTH IMO. Even people that I respect and admire like you and ben are GUILTY of not setting the record straight IMO.
(bold added)

MM, do you genuinely not see that you're doing it again?

The one thing, above all others, that is common to all "electric sun theories" is that the Sun is powered predominantly by external electric currents.

In your electric Sun idea, the (real) Sun is not powered predominantly by external electric currents.

Why don't you leave off all references to others' "electric sun theories", and focus on just your own idea? The more you clutter up this thread with stuff about ideas that are (wildly) inconsistent with your own, the less time and effort anyone can spend trying to understand your own idea (and challenging it).
 
And if you want the error in the Oliver Manuel model---well, there's a long list. His energy budget for a "neutron star" is nonsense. He's taken the Table of Nuclides and extrapolated to estimate the mass-per-nucleon of a pure-neutron nucleus. (Why should such an extrapolation work?)

At some point the outside shell of the neutron repulses other neutrons to the point that further compression due to gravity is offset by far stronger EM forces that push them apart. Somewhere I've posted a paper about recent experiments that show that a neutron actually looks more like an Oreo cookie with out outside negative shell, a positively charged middle and another negatively charged core. Manuel's work does suggest there is an upper limit to the amount of compression you can hope to get before it simply won't compress any further.

He now has two, conflicting numbers for the mass per nucleon of a neutron star: one conventional number (0.91 amu), and his own wacky extrapolation (1.018 amu). He implicitly assumes the former when stating "neutron stars form in gravitational collapse", and then he switches back to the latter when extracting energy from the neutron-dripline decay of these same stars.

As the neutrons flying away from the core DECAY into protons and electrons, they release energy. As they decay they form the components for hydrogen which are REPULSED from the "outside crust" of the neutron core which is highly positively charged. Keep in mind that the core is spinning rapidly with respect to the outside "surface of the sun". The core and crust of the neutron star rotate once every 5 minutes, whereas the outside surface of the sun rotates once every 27.3 days. The neutron core also rotates in the z axis over time producing the 22 year magnetic solar cycle.

This violates conservation of energy. If neutron matter actually weighs 1.018 amu*A, then neutron matter cannot be the end state of gravitational collapse.

Sure it can. That's just as heavily packed as it can get. Anything else added to the dense soup will simply cause that core to grow rather than "pack the core" any further.

If neutron matter is the end state of gravitational collapse, then neutrons cannot gain energy by un-collapsing out of this end state.

I'm not sure if that's really what he's suggesting. The neutrons themselves naturally repulse one another and were it not for gravity, they would drift away from one another. The DECAY process into protons and electrons releases energy, but the FUSION AROUND THE CORE releases energy.

Manuel has accidentally drawn the nuclear version of that MC Escher picture where a canal powers a waterwheel, and the waterwheel's runoff feeds the canal.

So that's idiotic mistake number one.

I think you didn't take the time to fully understand his theory ben. That isn't what he's proposing.

Idiotic mistake number two is slapping a neutron star into the core of the Sun. Manuel puts this star in there, invents his neutron-emission nonsense and pretends that it "supplies hydrogen" to the rest of the Sun. He forgets about gravity. The gravitational pull of a neutron star's surface is very, very high. If there's a sea of hydrogen above this surface, it has to be at very, very high pressure. Manuel has stipulated that there's 4e26W of power flowing through this hydrogen---never mind that that's an impossible super-Eddington heat transfer rate---so it's also very, very hot. You know what ultradense, ultrahot hydrogen does? It undergoes fusion---extremely rapid fusion.

Bingo! Hmm. You do seem to understand it? Now I don't really understand your complaints.
confused.gif


Does Manuel actually build a stellar model that shows whether hydrogen can survive in a calm, cool, low-density, non-exploding cloud near his "neutron star"? No he doesn't.

Why would he? Again, I'm horribly confused now. You seem to realize that the core would necessarily experience fusion and release energy. What's the problem? His model doesn't FORBID fusion!

I see no evidence that he is aware of the mere fact that stars have to obey temperature/pressure/gravity relationships.

So that's idiotic mistake number two.

Shall I continue?

You're going to have to really clarify your problem with his model for me because it DOES EXPERIENCE FUSION and it does release energy as a result of neutron decay.

At some point the core simply evaporates to the point that the remnant of the neutron star simply "explodes". Until that happens, there will be a fusion process in and around the core taking place in Manuals model, at least the one I was introduced to. I have no idea WHEN you originally talked with him.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom