How many DECADES did the mainstream cling to FUSION as the only energy source of the sun even AFTER it utterly *FAILED* to predict the correct type of neutrinos, and BEFORE it found *ANY* evidence of flavor changing?
You're obviously unaware of this history.
When Ray Davis solar neutrino data "came up short" in the 1960s and 1970s, people did try alternative solar models. They tried adjusting the Sun's core temperature, composition, opacity. They tried adjusting nuclear reaction rates. They tried adjusting the laws of GR. They tried hypothesizing new particles, like axions, that transported energy in different ways. They tried magnetic fields. They tried hypothesizing that neutrinos had mass and changed flavor.
You know what they did with these hypotheses? They tested them. They tested them in every last numerical detail that was available. There's no point having a vague idea along the lines of "maybe there's more carbon in the solar core"---you have to apply the laws of physics, all of them, and find out what would the sun look like IF there was more carbon in the core. The laws of physics told us, over and over and over again, that a carbon-core star would not explain the Sun's structure. Nor would axions. Nor would magnetic fields. Nor would a remeasurement of the proton radius. Nor would a reevaluation of the laws of plasma opacity. And so on.
You know what came out of those tests, Michael? Alternative-solar-fusion hypotheses never agreed with the data in all detail. The-normal-sun-plus-neutrino-oscillations hypothesis did agree with the data in full detail. You know which model was confirmed when SuperK/SNO/KamLAND/etc. came online? The model that agreed with all of the modern data.
(Where do you, Ratcliffe, and Manuel fit in this process? Nowhere I can see. You're stuck in the sort of free-brainstorming, "huh, I wonder if it works if X" phase and you somehow thought that was enough. I haven't seen any evidence that you've actually turned that brainstorm into a solar model. And a good thing too, because the resulting model does not agree with the data---sorry.)
)