Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
How many DECADES did the mainstream cling to FUSION as the only energy source of the sun even AFTER it utterly *FAILED* to predict the correct type of neutrinos, and BEFORE it found *ANY* evidence of flavor changing?

You're obviously unaware of this history.

When Ray Davis solar neutrino data "came up short" in the 1960s and 1970s, people did try alternative solar models. They tried adjusting the Sun's core temperature, composition, opacity. They tried adjusting nuclear reaction rates. They tried adjusting the laws of GR. They tried hypothesizing new particles, like axions, that transported energy in different ways. They tried magnetic fields. They tried hypothesizing that neutrinos had mass and changed flavor.

You know what they did with these hypotheses? They tested them. They tested them in every last numerical detail that was available. There's no point having a vague idea along the lines of "maybe there's more carbon in the solar core"---you have to apply the laws of physics, all of them, and find out what would the sun look like IF there was more carbon in the core. The laws of physics told us, over and over and over again, that a carbon-core star would not explain the Sun's structure. Nor would axions. Nor would magnetic fields. Nor would a remeasurement of the proton radius. Nor would a reevaluation of the laws of plasma opacity. And so on.

You know what came out of those tests, Michael? Alternative-solar-fusion hypotheses never agreed with the data in all detail. The-normal-sun-plus-neutrino-oscillations hypothesis did agree with the data in full detail. You know which model was confirmed when SuperK/SNO/KamLAND/etc. came online? The model that agreed with all of the modern data.

(Where do you, Ratcliffe, and Manuel fit in this process? Nowhere I can see. You're stuck in the sort of free-brainstorming, "huh, I wonder if it works if X" phase and you somehow thought that was enough. I haven't seen any evidence that you've actually turned that brainstorm into a solar model. And a good thing too, because the resulting model does not agree with the data---sorry.)
 
Dungey himself made that connection. More HATER DENIAL.
...
More pure denial since Dungey himself made that connection while coining the term "reconnection'! Holy cow!
Holy cow - more ignorance!
Starting with the minor point - Dungey did not coin the term magnetic reconnection. Parker coined it. Dungey's book was instrumental in making it the standard term used for the phenomena.

The major point is more CRANK IGNORANCE: Dungey never stated that flares and CMEs are caused by electrical discharges. Dungey never connected solar flares with actual electrical discharges.
From Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma.
Dungey's obsolete usage
  1. Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different.
    13th January 2011 (13 months and counting :eye-poppi)
  2. Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection
    18th October 2011 (120 days and counting!)
  3. MM: Citing Dungey means that cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection!
    8th November 2011 (99 days and counting)
 
The Membership Agreement does not protect people who are not members of the forum from personal attack. Which is why we're really glad Ms. Palin does not have an account here. :)
 
Complaints

The Membership Agreement does not protect people who are not members of the forum from personal attack. Which is why we're really glad Ms. Palin does not have an account here. :)


Aside from that, demanding the removal of a post in-thread is the wrong thing to do. The right thing to do is to click on the exclam (!) in the triangle at the lower left corner of the offending post and report it to the moderators with your complaint. They will deal with it appropriately.
 
You're obviously unaware of this history. <really interesting stuff deleted for brevity>

That was interesting. I knew the Solar Neutrino Problem existed, and that they observe neutrios in old mines full of chlorine, but I didn't know about the many hypotheses they tried. Thanks for that.
 
Incredible....well, incredibly sad.

You whine that a solar model should have a defined composition. I give you that composition based on nuclear chemistry analysis. You call the guy that has devoted a life's work to the idea a crackpot and a fraud and never cite a single legitimate flaw in his work, even though he's published MANY papers on the topic. What's the point of giving you folks what you ask for anyway? You ignored Alfvens' maths. You've handwaved a little at the Mann and Onel paper and pretty much IGNORED the implications of that paper as it relates to the legitimacy of circuit theory as applies to plasmas and solar satellite imagery. The whole denial process is based upon personal attack and outright pathological denial of the evidence presented! Wow. Creationists have ABSOLUTELY NOTHING on EU haters.
 
Last edited:
Oliver Manuel looked at some meteorites and saw a certain mix of elements. That's science.

He hypothesized that this corresponded to the mix of elements on the Sun. That's hypothesizing.

According to all of the other not-currently-in-dispute laws of pressure, temperature, density, gravity, etc., Manuel's proposed mix of elements would stick together in a very non-Sun-like object, with an extremely non-Sun-like radius and luminosity. That's science that Manuel has avoided doing. That's a test of Manuel's model. He has not performed this test himself, but I have, and his model is wrong.

It's not "hating" to say so. That's what science is supposed to do. It's supposed to sort through the infinite collection of hypotheses, find the one that agrees with the data, and reject the others. Manuel's model got yet another bog-standard rejection, because, just like many others, it doesn't agree with observed reality.

The axion-mediated-cooling and the neutrino-decay and the Saha-equation people took their hypotheses, studied them rigorously and in as much, and learned whether the data contradicted them. Manuel did not, and that's the beginning of the road to ridicule.
 
Speaking of pure unadulterated denial of scientific and historical fact:

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1958IAUS....6..135D/0000135.000.html

When are you going to get off that denial-go-round?
Speaking of pure unadulterated ignorance of scientific and historical fact:
From Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma.

Dungey's obsolete usage
  1. Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different.
    13th January 2011 (13 months and counting :eye-poppi)
  2. Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection
    18th October 2011 (120 days and counting!)
  3. MM: Citing Dungey means that cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection!
    8th November 2011 (99 days and counting)
When are you going to get off that delusion-go-round?

When are you going to learn to read your citations?
The defining feature of a discharge in this context is the existence of a large current density.
and from Dungey's 'electric discharge' = large current density in magnetic reconnection
Originally Posted by D'rok
Originally Posted by Dungey (1953 paper)
A 'discharge' will be a region [of a large mass of ionized gas in a more or less complicated state of motion] in which the electrons are accelerated to high energies by the electric field, so that all the electrons are moving in the same direction with large velocities.

ETA
It would take an idiot not understand that
  1. Dungey's context is magnetic reconnection as a cause of solar flares.
  2. 'Electrical discharges' in Dungey's context have nothing to do with actual electrical discharges (which are impossible in plasma).
Thus citing him is stupid since he invalidates the thread assertion that solar flaresare caused by electrical discharges.
 
Last edited:
In the ancient world (perhaps culminating with Aristotle) science was observational in nature and only verbal descriptions were possible. To a limited extent, Archimedes and a few others were precursors of the modern world's physicists with the discovery that the universe behaves wholly mathematically. Galileo, Newton and all subsequent physicists have been able to describe their theories only through mathematics.
Regarding electromagnetic phenomena (the subject of this thread), Maxwell demonstrated this mathematical reality of electromagnetism exquisitely through his famous equations. Consequently, all modern physicists know that here can be no analysis of electromagnetic phenomena without using mathematics. Crackpots and charlatans can only use ordinary language to push their agenda and it has been amply manifested that electric sun and EU cranks do not possess the mathematical skills to understand the false physics they endlessly promulgate.
I believe we can easily *IDENTIFY* those Internet dwellers who advocate *CRACKPOT* physics and *DISMISS* them as frauds and *PRETENDERS* who have a pathological need for attention.
 
Last edited:
You're obviously unaware of this history.

When Ray Davis solar neutrino data "came up short" in the 1960s and 1970s, people did try alternative solar models. They tried adjusting the Sun's core temperature, composition, opacity. They tried adjusting nuclear reaction rates. They tried adjusting the laws of GR. They tried hypothesizing new particles, like axions, that transported energy in different ways. They tried magnetic fields. They tried hypothesizing that neutrinos had mass and changed flavor.

You know what they did with these hypotheses? They tested them. They tested them in every last numerical detail that was available. There's no point having a vague idea along the lines of "maybe there's more carbon in the solar core"---you have to apply the laws of physics, all of them, and find out what would the sun look like IF there was more carbon in the core. The laws of physics told us, over and over and over again, that a carbon-core star would not explain the Sun's structure. Nor would axions. Nor would magnetic fields. Nor would a remeasurement of the proton radius. Nor would a reevaluation of the laws of plasma opacity. And so on.

You know what came out of those tests, Michael? Alternative-solar-fusion hypotheses never agreed with the data in all detail. The-normal-sun-plus-neutrino-oscillations hypothesis did agree with the data in full detail. You know which model was confirmed when SuperK/SNO/KamLAND/etc. came online? The model that agreed with all of the modern data.

(Where do you, Ratcliffe, and Manuel fit in this process? Nowhere I can see. You're stuck in the sort of free-brainstorming, "huh, I wonder if it works if X" phase and you somehow thought that was enough. I haven't seen any evidence that you've actually turned that brainstorm into a solar model. And a good thing too, because the resulting model does not agree with the data---sorry.)
I know you did not intend to come even close to listing the types of alternatives proposed, tested, and found wanting.

However, one of my personal faves is missing: the idea that everything is exactly as the physics of the day pointed to, just that the Sun has these, you know, oscillations, in the fusion rates in its core. Oscillations that last tens/hundreds/thousands/... of years. And that we happen to be 'observing' the Sun's core at a low point in its fusion rate cycle (that's why Davis saw such low numbers of neutrinos), and that these cycles aren't reflected - in any obvious way - in the Sun's (eventual) photospheric emission because {insert clever ideas here}.

Oh, and let's not forget the dozens (or more?) of papers on 'here's why Davis' reported rates are wrong (subtext: his experimental methods are not up to scratch/his analyses ignore huge systematic effects/etc)'.

Now back to your regular, scheduled program ...
 
In the ancient world (perhaps culminating with Aristotle) science was observational in nature and only verbal descriptions were possible. To a limited extent, Archimedes and a few others were precursors of the modern world's physicists with the discovery that the universe behaves wholly mathematically. Galileo, Newton and all subsequent physicists have been able to describe their theories only through mathematics. Regarding electromagnetic phenomena (the subject of this thread), Maxwell demonstrated this mathematical reality of electromagnetism exquisitely through his famous equations. Consequently, all modern physicists know that here can be no analysis of electromagnetic phenomena without using mathematics.

That's true. That's why I have provided you folks with Alfven's double layer paper, and that paper by Mann and Onel. They mathematically express solar flare events from the circuit/E orientation of plasma physics.

Crackpots and charlatans can only use ordinary language to push their agenda

You mean kinda of like you and that magnet cartoon?

and it has been amply manifested that electric sun and EU cranks do not possess the mathematical skills to understand the false physics they endlessly promulgate.

More personal attacks from an EU hater. Yawn. EU haters aren't interested in mathematics or physics or they would read and respond to, and *ACKNOWLEDGE* those papers by Lee, by Mann, and by Alfven. They only use mathematics as a PRETENSE FOR PERSONAL ATTACKS. No theory rises and falls on the maths skills of a single individual. Get over it already.

I believe we can easily *IDENTIFY* those Internet dwellers who advocate *CRACKPOT* physics and *DISMISS* them as frauds and *PRETENDERS* who have a pathological need for attention.

Kinda like you and your NEED to interject PERSONAL ATTACKS into what SHOULD BE an honest scientific conversation? When did you intend to acknowledge the mathematical validity of the circuit/E orientation to plasma physics and spend some time convincing your side of the aisle that yes indeed, ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES can and do occur in solar flares?

Are you personally ever going to respond to and acknowledge those papers by Alfven and by Mann and Onel? Did you find any mathematical flaws in their presentation? Do you have any mathematical or scientific arguments, or are personal attacks all you're good for?
 
What *IS* the point of trying to have a scientific conversation on this topic on this website anyway? None of the HATERS care one IOTA about mathematics or physics. If they did they would simply accept the validity of Alfven's double layer paper and that paper by Mann and Onel, and embrace the E side of plasma physics. Since HATERS can't do that, they are forced to resort to the only thing they can do, denial and personal attacks. How utterly sad.
 
Of those seven high energy emission patterns that have been associated with solar flares, all seven are explained *IN THE LAB* with "electrical discharges" through plasma. Only *ONE* of the items on that list has been EMPIRICALLY associated with "magnetic reconnection". No SPECIFIC orientation, E or B is "better than" another in terms of mathematics. Maxwell's equations can be expressed either way.

The EU haters can't even accept basic physics, namely that "discharges happen" in plasma. The rest of the argument therefore goes around and around in circles of pure denial with nothing more than personal attacks against anyone promoting an E orientation to plasma physics. It's just WEIRD behavior that is typically limited to CULTS.

The haters aren't interested in mathematics. They aren't interested in laboratory physics either. They're only interested in ego gratification based on personal attacks. Honestly, creationists have ABSOLUTELY NOTHING on EU haters. It's pure denial, denial and more denial.
 
I wouldn't ask an illiterate Nahuatl speaker whether or to use the Oxford comma or not. I'd ask someone who actually reads and write English and accomplishes things with such writing.

For the same reasons, I wouldn't ask Michael Mozina, who doesn't actually solve plasma equations himself, whether to use the E or the B orientations.
 
What *IS* the point of trying to have a scientific conversation on this topic on this website anyway? None of the HATERS care one IOTA about mathematics or physics.


Apparently everything available to support an electric Sun conjecture has been provided. It has all been rejected for various reasons, not the least of which being it doesn't even mean what the electric Sun proponents seem to believe it means. Much of it is cherry picked words and phrases with a "discharge" here and an "electrical" there. That and a bunch of looks-like-a-bunny nonsense that nobody seems to be able to assemble into a contiguous whole. It's not even a theory. Barely even a conjecture since the case hasn't been presented in a way that can be understood... scientifically... by real scientists. If there's nothing else, maybe the conversation is over.

If they did they would simply accept the validity of Alfven's double layer paper and that paper by Mann and Onel, and embrace the E side of plasma physics.


Yes, if real scientists simply believed these things with the same faith as the advocates do, simply accept the validity of it without objective quantitative support, this wouldn't be so difficult. :D

Since HATERS can't do that, they are forced to resort to the only thing they can do, denial and personal attacks. How utterly sad.


So the failure isn't the fault of the electric Sun proponents? Maybe the mean old critics are to blame for the failure. Persecution, I say! There's surely a conspiracy among the tens of thousands of solar and plasma physicists on Earth to silence the truth. :rolleyes:
 
Apparently everything available to support an electric Sun conjecture has been provided. It has all been rejected for various reasons,

There's only one real "reason". The evidence blows away EU hater belief systems, starting with your belief that electrical discharges do not occur in plasmas. The moment a hater embraces the circuit/E orientation to plasma physics, the jig is up. The moment they let got of the hate, the hater party is over, and science prevails over hatred. EU haters can't and won't give up their hatred for EU oriented ideas, just as creationists cannot and will not give up their hatred for evolutionary theory. The moment that hatred is gone, all that remains is science that blows that hatred away.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't ask an illiterate Nahuatl speaker whether or to use the Oxford comma or not. I'd ask someone who actually reads and write English and accomplishes things with such writing.

For the same reasons, I wouldn't ask Michael Mozina, who doesn't actually solve plasma equations himself, whether to use the E or the B orientations.

Even if it's all true, so what? No theory rises or falls on the math skills of a single individual. Did you find any flaw in Alfven's double layer paper? Did you find any flaws in the paper by Mann and Onel?

I guess the EU hater mentality is based upon the false belief that if they bash individuals, the actual math that crushes their beliefs doesn't really exist.
 
Even if it's all true, so what? No theory rises or falls on the math skills of a single individual. Did you find any flaw in Alfven's double layer paper? Did you find any flaws in the paper by Mann and Onel?

I said, I'm not following the corona-physics part of the thread.

Mann and Onel? It's a short, unremarkable paper (cited once, by another Mann and Onel paper) and it shows what electrons do in the presence of a Sun-like magnetic field with a small (few kV) electric field. It claims that this electric field arises from thermodynamics. I have no problem with any of that, and it doesn't sound the slightest bit like it supports your assertions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom