DeiRenDopa said:
Yet, as I (and perhaps other readers) now know, your own electric Sun idea is radically different from any of those produced by the EU community.
No. Kristian Birkeland and his team were the very first members of the EU community in terms of LAB TESTED EMPIRICAL PHYSICS with electric suns, in this case "cathode" suns.
I read somewhere recently about a group (religious, of some kind, I would guess) who conducted some ritual or other concerning dead people, the result of which was that these (dead) people became part of their community (or something like that).
It's difficult to belong to a community if you're dead. I've no doubt Kristian Birkeland belonged, while alive, to several communities; some community or other in Norway at the time, for example. However, I doubt that the name "EU" (or whatever that is in Norse) was even invented then.
In a broader sense, one might say something about an intellectual tradition, or something similar, and give it the shorthand "community". In that sense, Kristian Birkeland certainly belonged to such a community, the community of (physical) scientists.
A core aspect of such people, a tradition one might say, stretching back to the time of Galileo and Newton, is their insistence that the science they do be quantitative (and objective, and independently verifiable, etc).
Viewed in this way, and taking the self-defined, contemporary EU community as the template, Kristian Birkeland cannot possibly have ever belonged to any EU community.
Oh, and I guess we should celebrate; you did not write COMMUNITY, nor *COMMUNITY*, nor "community", nor ...
The solar model on my website is an updated (with satellite imagery) presentation of THEIR SOLAR MODEL, not mine.
Yes, you've said that before.
Many times.
However, we all know - thanks to your hundreds (thousands?) of posts here, that this cannot possibly be true.
Why?
Well, for starters, it lacks (at least) one essential component; in short, the "solar model on [you] website" is not quantitative.
When you address that fundamental problem, please let us know, in this thread, so we can go take a look at it.
Another noteworthy member of the EU community would be Hannes Alfven. His model is a HYDROGEN PLASMA FUSION model.
Sigh. Another dead guy.
As with Kristian Birkeland, he cannot possibly belong to any EU community, for the same reason.
These two individuals represent the "Grandfather and Fathers" of EU theory.
By associating the collective writings of 'electric(al) theorists' (i.e. Thornhill, Scott, et al.) so closely with "EU theory", we can conclude, with impeccable logic, that whatever it (EU theory) is, it is not science (or at least not part of the physical sciences, of the kind Kristian Birkeland and Alfvén studied and wrote about).
Later folks like Jergens may have produced ALTERNATIVE solar models, but these aren't even necessarily representative of "mainstream (if there is such a thing) electric sun" ideas. Birkeland's model and Alfven's model are the kinds of things that scientists like Peratt promote. IMO you're intentionally not recognizing the fact that there are MULTIPLE options to choose from, not one single model that represents the sum total of all "electric sun" theories! Jergen's model isn't even interesting to me for the reasons Zig explained very clearly. IMO there isn't any particular need for an external energy source in the first place. The suns all could be "wired together" in some ways, but they don't have to draw the bulk of their power from an external source. Birkeland's model had an internal energy source, namely the transmutation of elements. Alfven's model uses fusion. These IMO are the two most "mainstream" "electric sun" theories. Jergens model is simply a "johnny come lately" idea that IMO isn't even all that interesting.
By now, I hope, you'll see that the distinction I'm drawing is much more fundamental than that.
DeiRendopa said:
So much so that, over at Thunderblots, they are careful to explain to newbies that your ideas are not consistent with EU, and that discussion of your ideas is not welcome there (you know this, right?) Put bluntly, you are not a member of the EU community.
Coming from you, that claim is absolutely HYSTERICAL. You do realize I've posted there years ago and nobody ever asked me to leave, right?

I assume that you can point me to a thread that explains that the discussion of Birkeland's solar ideas isn't welcome?
Who said anything about any such discussion?
If you're not familiar with the material on that website - on "Iron Sun", and on Manual's ideas (these are quite central to your own electric Sun ideas, aren't they?) - well, go do some surfing (you may be in for some rather rude shocks).
When did I take credit for Birkeland's solar model?
It's really fascinating how hard you work at trying to create division in the EU community. Why? What are you hoping to achieve?
Um, right, vintage MM.
This is the sort of thing that helped me make up my mind to put you on Ignore.
Now, are you going to answer any of my questions on your electric Sun idea, as published by you?