Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Who besides me is correcting RC and GM and setting them straight PUBLICLY about the fact that electrical discharges occur in CONDUCTORS?
You are the only one here with the delusion that electrical discharges occur in CONDUCTORS so you are the only one whining about this.

Who besides me is doing ANYTHING to point out the fact that BOTH the E (circuit) and B (field) orientations of plasma physics are EQUALLY VALID?
You are the only one here with the delusion that BOTH the E (circuit) and B (field) orientations of plasma physics are EQUALLY VALID so you are the only one whining about this.


And where is your "correction" of Tim Thompson who has cited the evidence that the E and B ) orientations of plasma physics are NOT EQUALLY VALID?
Other than you whining about people who know about plasma physics "whining" (stating the fact ) that the B, v paradigm is better than the E, j paradigm.

What you have demonstarted is that you are ignoring plasma physics. Maxwell's equations are EQUALLY VALID in their E and B description. But plasma physics includes more than Maxwell's equations - read Alfvén sometime :jaw-dropp. As soon as you add Newtonian mechanics, the B, v paradigm becomes the better paradigm to work in.
 
Remember, nothing other than a fusion model ever got anywhere close to working, and fusion models worked just fine.

No, actually they DIDN'T work "fine". That was the whole point of further experiments with neutrinos.

You don't have to have a crystal ball. This is science, and you're allowed to make hypotheses---even conditional ones. You could try this:

"Unless there is a serious misunderstanding of neutrinos, the Sun does not undergo much fission. However, if we hypothesize that <insert a particle-physics hypothesis you have no evidence for>, there may be room for <fission-based sun model>"

I think I've posted something similar in one of my recent posts to DRD.

Waaaaaait a second. The last time particle physicists put forward a particle-physics hypothesis they had no laboratory evidence for, YOU WENT BALLISTIC. It was called "dark matter", they had lots of non-laboratory evidence for it, and in your mind it was a travesty against science to even consider such a thing. But now, all of a sudden, some "dark", invented-out-of-thin-air, no-laboratory-evidence-available hypothetical laws of particle physics are fair game.

I'm NOT proposing anything that cannot be LAB TESTED. FYI, IMO DM is the LEAST of your worries as it relates to empirical physics. I've stated that on a number of occasions.

Unsurprising, really. You never really held a "I only believe laboratory experiments" position. It's just a rhetorical tic you adopted for use in your anti-dark-energy crusade.

Which idea have I put forth that COULD NOT be "tested" here on Earth in CONTROLLED conditions?
 
With respect to electric sun theories in general, that is *EXACTLY* what the collective is doing. Who besides me is correcting RC and GM and setting them straight PUBLICLY about the fact that electrical discharges occur in CONDUCTORS? Who besides me is doing ANYTHING to point out the fact that BOTH the E (circuit) and B (field) orientations of plasma physics are EQUALLY VALID?

If they're really equally valid, shut up about it. Nobody is out there railing against Phys Rev Letters for publishing lots of papers with base-10 numbers. "Who besides me is doing ANYTHING to point out that base-8 is EQUALLY VALID?"

Clearly you don't think they're equally valid. You think there's some important difference between them, and that if people switched to E-orientation, suddenly everything Alfven said would be right and magnetic reconnection would be wrong.

With respect to electric sun theories "in general"---there is no such thing as "electric Sun theories in general". The only things you have are the unrelated collection of papers that show up in a Google Scholar search for "+electric +solar". A real stellar model would have to show (in one paper, in mathematical form) solutions to the power-generation, heat-transfer, and hydrostatic-equilibrium equations. For mainstream models, this is something I did in a one-semester "numerical methods in astrophysics" class---and, I might point out, that was a classroom full of people who had never programmed a computer before. Why is it that fifteen undergrad astronomers can, in sixteen weeks, both learn Fortran and solve the Lane-Emden equation, whereas electric-sun advocates have produced no solution whatsoever over a half century?
 
Bingo! Hmm. You do seem to understand it? Now I don't really understand your complaints.
Bingo :eek:! You do not seem to understand the stupidity of putting a neutron star in the middle of a normal star!


This is quite basic physics:
  1. A neutron star has an enormous gravitation field.
  2. This will compress hydrogen on its surface to high temperatures and pressures.
  3. Manuel adds even more energyt o the mix (4e26W of power flowing through this hydrogen).
  4. That causes enormous amounts of fusion.
  5. The energy from that fusion will blow the star up :eye-poppi.
 
With respect to electric sun theories in general, that is *EXACTLY* what the collective is doing. Who besides me is correcting RC and GM and setting them straight PUBLICLY about the fact that electrical discharges occur in CONDUCTORS?

First, I was talking specifically about the solar neutrino question, and taking issue with your assessment of it, so your response here is simply changing the subject. But since you brought it up:

A number of us tried (without success) to point out that you were using different versions of the word "discharge." Nobody disagreed that currents can flow in a plasma, the disagreement was (usually) about whether dialectric breakdown was necessary for a current flow to be considered a "discharge" which, obviously, depended on the definition of "discharge." And all such semantic debate was abso#*(&$*lutely irrelevant to the underlying reality of the nature of solar flares.

And, no, I really, really don't care what Dungey really, really meant in some paper written in 1958.

Who besides me is doing ANYTHING to point out the fact that BOTH the E (circuit) and B (field) orientations of plasma physics are EQUALLY VALID?

Frankly, I haven't really followed that part of the discussion, but it's appeared to me that you've used the whole E/B thing to distract attention from more fundamental problems.

I know, I know, you're going to say that E/B is the most fundamental issue. I'm not buying it.

You all sit back and do NOTHING to seek TRUTH IMO. Even people that I respect and admire like you and ben are GUILTY of not setting the record straight IMO.

You feel that we aren't being intellectually honest, yet hearken back to several months ago when you gave us that long list of papers that you felt supported you. I read some of them, and even quoted the conclusions from two of them saying that measured solar data did not support the electric arc theory, and you said, "So what?"

Think about that! The sources that you cited as observational evidence for your model actually refuted you, and you said "So what?" You didn't go back to re-evaluate it, you didn't reconsider your conclusions, you simply rejected your own evidence when it didn't seem to support your conclusions.

But you say that we aren't seeking the truth.

I actually did some analysis of the physical properties of your 'iron sun.' I also made that computer model of photons passing near the limb to see if they'd look the way you thought they'd look. I did some thermal radiation calculations, and that photons-propagating-through-the-photosphere thing. These were all analyses I did on your model. You did none of those things. You didn't even analyze your own model, nor did you ever accept or refute my analyses.

But you say that we sit back and do nothing; that we aren't seeking the truth.

I and others (mostly others) made running-difference images to show that transient phenomena appear to be solid in such an image. You ignored all of that and your web page still cites the RD video as proof that the sun has a solid surface.

But you say that we sit back and do nothing; that we aren't seeking the truth.

Remember all those pages of discussion about that image of the sun that you thought showed a green layer (I don't remember what you thought it was)? I actually made my own version of that image, others contacted the people who released it. You neither attempted to duplicate the image nor contacted NASA about it.

But you say that we sit back and do nothing.

We finally proved that the green disk was put there in Photoshop. You never (AFAIK) admitted you were wrong about that.

But you say that we aren't seeking the truth.

I'll stop there before I get myself in trouble.
 
Yet, as I (and perhaps other readers) now know, your own electric Sun idea is radically different from any of those produced by the EU community.

No. Kristian Birkeland and his team were the very first members of the EU community in terms of LAB TESTED EMPIRICAL PHYSICS with electric suns, in this case "cathode" suns. The solar model on my website is an updated (with satellite imagery) presentation of THEIR SOLAR MODEL, not mine. Another noteworthy member of the EU community would be Hannes Alfven. His model is a HYDROGEN PLASMA FUSION model.

These two individuals represent the "Grandfather and Fathers" of EU theory. Later folks like Jergens may have produced ALTERNATIVE solar models, but these aren't even necessarily representative of "mainstream (if there is such a thing) electric sun" ideas. Birkeland's model and Alfven's model are the kinds of things that scientists like Peratt promote. IMO you're intentionally not recognizing the fact that there are MULTIPLE options to choose from, not one single model that represents the sum total of all "electric sun" theories! Jergen's model isn't even interesting to me for the reasons Zig explained very clearly. IMO there isn't any particular need for an external energy source in the first place. The suns all could be "wired together" in some ways, but they don't have to draw the bulk of their power from an external source. Birkeland's model had an internal energy source, namely the transmutation of elements. Alfven's model uses fusion. These IMO are the two most "mainstream" "electric sun" theories. Jergens model is simply a "johnny come lately" idea that IMO isn't even all that interesting.

So much so that, over at Thunderblots, they are careful to explain to newbies that your ideas are not consistent with EU, and that discussion of your ideas is not welcome there (you know this, right?) Put bluntly, you are not a member of the EU community.

Coming from you, that claim is absolutely HYSTERICAL. You do realize I've posted there years ago and nobody ever asked me to leave, right? :) I assume that you can point me to a thread that explains that the discussion of Birkeland's solar ideas isn't welcome?

You know.....

Given all this, why do you keep on trying to conflate your electric Sun idea with EU?

When did I take credit for Birkeland's solar model?

It's really fascinating how hard you work at trying to create division in the EU community. Why? What are you hoping to achieve?
 
Last edited:
DeiRenDopa said:
Yet, as I (and perhaps other readers) now know, your own electric Sun idea is radically different from any of those produced by the EU community.
No. Kristian Birkeland and his team were the very first members of the EU community in terms of LAB TESTED EMPIRICAL PHYSICS with electric suns, in this case "cathode" suns.
I read somewhere recently about a group (religious, of some kind, I would guess) who conducted some ritual or other concerning dead people, the result of which was that these (dead) people became part of their community (or something like that).

It's difficult to belong to a community if you're dead. I've no doubt Kristian Birkeland belonged, while alive, to several communities; some community or other in Norway at the time, for example. However, I doubt that the name "EU" (or whatever that is in Norse) was even invented then.

In a broader sense, one might say something about an intellectual tradition, or something similar, and give it the shorthand "community". In that sense, Kristian Birkeland certainly belonged to such a community, the community of (physical) scientists.

A core aspect of such people, a tradition one might say, stretching back to the time of Galileo and Newton, is their insistence that the science they do be quantitative (and objective, and independently verifiable, etc).

Viewed in this way, and taking the self-defined, contemporary EU community as the template, Kristian Birkeland cannot possibly have ever belonged to any EU community.

Oh, and I guess we should celebrate; you did not write COMMUNITY, nor *COMMUNITY*, nor "community", nor ...

The solar model on my website is an updated (with satellite imagery) presentation of THEIR SOLAR MODEL, not mine.

Yes, you've said that before.

Many times.

However, we all know - thanks to your hundreds (thousands?) of posts here, that this cannot possibly be true.

Why?

Well, for starters, it lacks (at least) one essential component; in short, the "solar model on [you] website" is not quantitative.

When you address that fundamental problem, please let us know, in this thread, so we can go take a look at it.

Another noteworthy member of the EU community would be Hannes Alfven. His model is a HYDROGEN PLASMA FUSION model.
Sigh. Another dead guy.

As with Kristian Birkeland, he cannot possibly belong to any EU community, for the same reason.

These two individuals represent the "Grandfather and Fathers" of EU theory.
By associating the collective writings of 'electric(al) theorists' (i.e. Thornhill, Scott, et al.) so closely with "EU theory", we can conclude, with impeccable logic, that whatever it (EU theory) is, it is not science (or at least not part of the physical sciences, of the kind Kristian Birkeland and Alfvén studied and wrote about).

Later folks like Jergens may have produced ALTERNATIVE solar models, but these aren't even necessarily representative of "mainstream (if there is such a thing) electric sun" ideas. Birkeland's model and Alfven's model are the kinds of things that scientists like Peratt promote. IMO you're intentionally not recognizing the fact that there are MULTIPLE options to choose from, not one single model that represents the sum total of all "electric sun" theories! Jergen's model isn't even interesting to me for the reasons Zig explained very clearly. IMO there isn't any particular need for an external energy source in the first place. The suns all could be "wired together" in some ways, but they don't have to draw the bulk of their power from an external source. Birkeland's model had an internal energy source, namely the transmutation of elements. Alfven's model uses fusion. These IMO are the two most "mainstream" "electric sun" theories. Jergens model is simply a "johnny come lately" idea that IMO isn't even all that interesting.
By now, I hope, you'll see that the distinction I'm drawing is much more fundamental than that.

DeiRendopa said:
So much so that, over at Thunderblots, they are careful to explain to newbies that your ideas are not consistent with EU, and that discussion of your ideas is not welcome there (you know this, right?) Put bluntly, you are not a member of the EU community.
Coming from you, that claim is absolutely HYSTERICAL. You do realize I've posted there years ago and nobody ever asked me to leave, right? :) I assume that you can point me to a thread that explains that the discussion of Birkeland's solar ideas isn't welcome?
Who said anything about any such discussion?

If you're not familiar with the material on that website - on "Iron Sun", and on Manual's ideas (these are quite central to your own electric Sun ideas, aren't they?) - well, go do some surfing (you may be in for some rather rude shocks).

When did I take credit for Birkeland's solar model?

It's really fascinating how hard you work at trying to create division in the EU community. Why? What are you hoping to achieve?

Um, right, vintage MM.

This is the sort of thing that helped me make up my mind to put you on Ignore.

Now, are you going to answer any of my questions on your electric Sun idea, as published by you?
 
Last edited:
First, I was talking specifically about the solar neutrino question, and taking issue with your assessment of it, so your response here is simply changing the subject. But since you brought it up:

A number of us tried (without success) to point out that you were using different versions of the word "discharge." Nobody disagreed that currents can flow in a plasma, the disagreement was (usually) about whether dialectric breakdown was necessary for a current flow to be considered a "discharge" which, obviously, depended on the definition of "discharge." And all such semantic debate was abso#*(&$*lutely irrelevant to the underlying reality of the nature of solar flares.

I disagree about it's relevance and importance. It's CONCEPTUALLY CRITICAL to UNDERSTAND that flares are in fact "electrical discharges in plasma". The moment one conceptually "gets it", they get it. If they REFUSE TO ACCEPT IT, like RC and GM, they will NEVER understand a solar flare. Dungey knew it was an "electrical discharge' process as well as a "reconnection" process. Today's astronomers are CLUELESS to the fact that they occur in flares as RC demonstrates.

And, no, I really, really don't care what Dungey really, really meant in some paper written in 1958.

You should IMO. You should care what he "really really, really, really meant", not only at the level of mathematics, but physics, and CONCEPTUALLY, otherwise you just don't "get it". Why would you "care" one iota about the word "reconnection" and not care about the word "discharge"? Why favor a B orientation over an E orientation?

Frankly, I haven't really followed that part of the discussion, but it's appeared to me that you've used the whole E/B thing to distract attention from more fundamental problems.

No. There is a fundamental refusal to embrace an "electric sun" or an E orientation to solar physics. It's "magnetic yada yada yada", never "ELECTROmagnetic yada yada yada" when you read papers from the mainstream. There is a fundamental BIGOTRY involved in that process. Even at the level of mathematics, nobody seems willing to accept Alfven's work on flares as "valid". Even that paper by Mann and Onel was pretty much ignored in terms of ACCEPTING an E orientation to solar flares.

I know, I know, you're going to say that E/B is the most fundamental issue. I'm not buying it.

Not really. I'm willing to accept a MIDDLE position. Sometimes the B orientation might be more relevant. Sometimes the E orientation might be more relevant. I'm willing to be FAIR about it. Aflven was the flip side of this crew, and the flipside of the mainstream today. Aflven ignored B so intensely that I think he alienated folks.

You feel that we aren't being intellectually honest, yet hearken back to several months ago when you gave us that long list of papers that you felt supported you. I read some of them, and even quoted the conclusions from two of them saying that measured solar data did not support the electric arc theory, and you said, "So what?"

Think about that! The sources that you cited as observational evidence for your model actually refuted you, and you said "So what?" You didn't go back to re-evaluate it, you didn't reconsider your conclusions, you simply rejected your own evidence when it didn't seem to support your conclusions.

When I put together that list, I simply went through and picked out all the various references I had cited. You happened to pick ONE that didn't support a high energy arc among the THIRTY papers I cited. I'm not even sure what the original context of the paper was when I first posted the link to the paper you cited.

Did you however just read ONE or did you read all thirty? Why didn't you comment on that paper by Mann and Onel? IMO it's *THE* best paper from an E/Circuit orientation that I have seen applied to solar physics in recent years. Why not read it and comment for us?


But you say that we aren't seeking the truth.

I actually did some analysis of the physical properties of your 'iron sun.' I also made that computer model of photons passing near the limb to see if they'd look the way you thought they'd look. I did some thermal radiation calculations, and that photons-propagating-through-the-photosphere thing. These were all analyses I did on your model. You did none of those things. You didn't even analyze your own model, nor did you ever accept or refute my analyses.

When did you present that analysis for me to review?

But you say that we sit back and do nothing; that we aren't seeking the truth.

I and others (mostly others) made running-difference images to show that transient phenomena appear to be solid in such an image. You ignored all of that and your web page still cites the RD video as proof that the sun has a solid surface.

The fact you created a couple of hand made RD images is not INSTANT EVIDENCE that you're right DAS. Which exact conversation are you talking about?

But you say that we sit back and do nothing; that we aren't seeking the truth.

Remember all those pages of discussion about that image of the sun that you thought showed a green layer (I don't remember what you thought it was)? I actually made my own version of that image, others contacted the people who released it. You neither attempted to duplicate the image nor contacted NASA about it.

Woah. I've created MANY RD images. I've contacted MANY people at NASA over the years. Please refresh my memory as to WHICH SPECIFIC IMAGE you're referring to.

But you say that we sit back and do nothing.

We finally proved that the green disk was put there in Photoshop. You never (AFAIK) admitted you were wrong about that.

But you say that we aren't seeking the truth.

I'll stop there before I get myself in trouble.

Huh? Honestly Das, I don't even recall the conversation, but obviously you do (sort of). Care to site me a link? You never know, I could have a change of heart if I reread the thread in question? :)

My point is that it's impossible to have a serious conversation about an E oriented view of the universe when fundamental processes and fundamental concepts are DENIED. Trying to explain an electrical discharge process in a solar flare to an EU HATER is literally IMPOSSIBLE because they literally believe that "electrical discharges cannot occur in a conductor"! WTF? It's like trying to discuss radiometric dating methods with a creationist who's insisting that the method is utterly invalid.
 
Last edited:
If they're really equally valid, shut up about it. Nobody is out there railing against Phys Rev Letters for publishing lots of papers with base-10 numbers. "Who besides me is doing ANYTHING to point out that base-8 is EQUALLY VALID?"

Clearly you don't think they're equally valid. You think there's some important difference between them, and that if people switched to E-orientation, suddenly everything Alfven said would be right and magnetic reconnection would be wrong.

No, actually what I said is Alfven would be right about everything EXCEPT reconnection. I'm willing to simply call it "circuit reconnection" or 'current reconnection" and embrace the B. :) It's the Tim's, the RC and and GM's that refuse to embrace the E. :)

With respect to electric sun theories "in general"---there is no such thing as "electric Sun theories in general". The only things you have are the unrelated collection of papers that show up in a Google Scholar search for "+electric +solar". A real stellar model would have to show (in one paper, in mathematical form) solutions to the power-generation, heat-transfer, and hydrostatic-equilibrium equations.

Alfven's model uses standard fusion ben.

For mainstream models, this is something I did in a one-semester "numerical methods in astrophysics" class---and, I might point out, that was a classroom full of people who had never programmed a computer before. Why is it that fifteen undergrad astronomers can, in sixteen weeks, both learn Fortran and solve the Lane-Emden equation, whereas electric-sun advocates have produced no solution whatsoever over a half century?

As I have tried to explain to you, I personally favor fusion at this moment in time, but I do entertain the idea of fission as well. I don't really see the point of reinventing the wheel. What's the point?
 
Last edited:
Neutrons have internal STRUCTURE that does not lead to neutron repulsion

http://www.livescience.com/4601-discovery-understanding-neutrons.html

This is the link I was looking for ben. The outside shell of the neutron acts to "repulse" other neutrons. Gravity is no match from EM forces at small enough distances, and the neutron soup simply grows in size, it no longer compresses.
Oh dear - you need to learn to read :eye-poppi!
Discovery Changes Understanding of Neutrons
Since 1947, physicists have thought the neutron, an electrically neutral elementary particle and a primary component of an atom, actually carries a positive charge at its center and an offsetting negative charge at its outer edge.
But new research shows the setup is more complex.
The neutron has been found to have a negative charge both in its inner core and its outer edge, with a positive charge sandwiched in between to make the particle electrically neutral.
"Nobody realized this was the case," said Gerald A. Miller, a University of Washington physicist. "It is significant because it is a clear fact of nature that we didn't know before. Now we know it."
(emphasis added)
The discovery is about the distribution of charge (quarks?) within neutrons.
Neutrons are still electrically neutral. There are no EM forces between them due to charge because outside of them there is no charge.

The charge distribution will not be significant until the neutrons are overlapping and the uneven distribution of charge can produce a force. But that means that the Pauli repulsion has been overcome and there is nothing to stop the neutron star from becoming a black hole.

If we ignore your ignorance about positive charges and negative charges canceling then that will not make the "neutron soup" grow. It would delay the compression until the gravitational forces overcome the repulsion.
 
Well, for starters, it lacks (at least) one essential component; in short, the "solar model on [you] website" is not quantitative.

That is simply NOT TRUE! If you don't read the links, INCLUDING BIRKELAND'S WORK, it's not my personal fault. Stop being so lazy!
 
If they're really equally valid, shut up about it.

That's like telling Martin Luther King, "If you're equal, shut up about it!" Huh?

It's the blind bigotry toward E/circuit side of plasma that's the problem ben.

When RC, GM, Tim and the rest of those who won't embrace the E embrace the E, I'll shut up about it, and not a moment sooner. ;)
 
It's CONCEPTUALLY CRITICAL to UNDERSTAND that flares are in fact "electrical discharges in plasma".
It's CONCEPTUALLY CRITICAL to UNDERSTAND that the definition of electrical discharges means that they are physically impossible in plasma and so are not the cause of solar flares.
Dungey though used of the term "electrical discharge" in his work on magnetic reconnection being the cause of solar flares.
 
Last edited:
As the neutrons flying away from the core DECAY into protons and electrons, they release energy.

Nope. If neutrons are energetically allowed to fly away from the core at all, that means they're energetically forbidden from falling into the core in the first place.

Like I said, Manuel uses a "neutrons are extra-repulsive" picture when he wants neutrons to get OUT of the core, but he forgot to use this picture when he compressed the neutrons INTO the core to begin with.

I think you didn't take the time to fully understand his theory ben. That isn't what he's proposing.

He doesn't think that's what he's proposing, but it is. That's the really idiotic thing about it.

Bingo! Hmm. You do seem to understand it? Now I don't really understand your complaints.

Why would he? Again, I'm horribly confused now. You seem to realize that the core would necessarily experience fusion and release energy. What's the problem? His model doesn't FORBID fusion!

This is a quantitative science, Michael. Manuel's model predicts fusion. Specifically, it predicts a supernova-like runaway fusion in which the Sun burns its entire core in a minute or so, blowing off its outer shell in the process. Manuel's model does not have a stable 4x10^26-watts-for-billions-of-years solution.

Until that happens, there will be a fusion process in and around the core taking place in Manuals model, at least the one I was introduced to. I have no idea WHEN you originally talked with him.

I read a bunch of papers with your name on them on Manuel's web page.
 
Somewhere I've posted a paper about recent experiments that show that a neutron actually looks more like an Oreo cookie with out outside negative shell, a positively charged middle and another negatively charged core.
Sounds yummy.

As the neutrons flying away from the core DECAY into protons and electrons, they release energy. As they decay they form the components for hydrogen which are REPULSED from the "outside crust" of the neutron core which is highly positively charged. Keep in mind that the core is spinning rapidly with respect to the outside "surface of the sun". The core and crust of the neutron star rotate once every 5 minutes, whereas the outside surface of the sun rotates once every 27.3 days. The neutron core also rotates in the z axis over time producing the 22 year magnetic solar cycle.

...snip...

At some point the core simply evaporates to the point that the remnant of the neutron star simply "explodes". Until that happens, there will be a fusion process in and around the core taking place in Manuals model, at least the one I was introduced to. I have no idea WHEN you originally talked with him.

I'm NOT proposing anything that cannot be LAB TESTED....

Which idea have I put forth that COULD NOT be "tested" here on Earth in CONTROLLED conditions?
:eye-poppi

In Houston, perhaps. Elsewhere, local zoning ordinances may prohibit construction of housing for neutron stars.
 
This is a quantitative science, Michael. Manuel's model predicts fusion. Specifically, it predicts a supernova-like runaway fusion in which the Sun burns its entire core in a minute or so, blowing off its outer shell in the process. Manuel's model does not have a stable 4x10^26-watts-for-billions-of-years solution.

It does NOT! How did you account for the charge repulsion between the positively charged crust of the neutron core and positively charge protons once the neutrons decay?

I read a bunch of papers with your name on them on Manuel's web page.

None of them included a word about runaway fusion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom