Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
None of them included a word about runaway fusion.

That's the problem, see? Manuel didn't bother applying the laws of physics to the hydrogen around his hypothesized neutron star. These laws of physics actually predict runaway fusion of a star with a neutron-star core, and they continue to predict this whether or not Oliver Manuel bothered to (or is competent to) calculate it and include it in his crackpot writeups.

You think Manuel's star doesn't undergo runaway fusion? Show my why not. Show me a reasonable pressure and temperature profile ( P(r) and T(r) ) for this star, work out the gravitational forces and show that it's in hydrostatic equilibrium, show that the fusion rates are reasonable, and show that the temperature gradients and convection can transport 4e26 watts from the core to the surface. That's what it means to have a stellar model.
 
Last edited:
That's the problem, see?

IMO the "problem" is that you're making an allegation based on a handwave as best as I can tell and then trying to pass it off as "truth".

Manuel didn't bother applying the laws of physics to the hydrogen around his hypothesized neutron star. These laws of physics actually predict runaway fusion of a star with a neutron-star core, and they continue to predict this whether or not Oliver Manuel bothered to (or is competent to) calculate it and include it in his crackpot writeups.

When and where did you make these "runaway fusion' calculations for me to look at ben?
 
Remember all those pages of discussion about that image of the sun that you thought showed a green layer (I don't remember what you thought it was)? I actually made my own version of that image, others contacted the people who released it. You neither attempted to duplicate the image nor contacted NASA about it.
Woah. I've created MANY RD images. I've contacted MANY people at NASA over the years. Please refresh my memory as to WHICH SPECIFIC IMAGE you're referring to.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5913370&postcount=3013
 
It does NOT! How did you account for the charge repulsion between the positively charged crust of the neutron core and positively charge protons once the neutrons decay?

If a positively charged core repels a bunch of positively-charged protons, it's left with an excess of electrons and is therefore not a positively charged core any more.

Of course, "pretending that charged objects remain magically charged forever" is sort of Ground Zero of electric-universe idiocy.
 
When and where did you make these "runaway fusion' calculations for me to look at ben?
Actually it is not ben that needs to make these calculations.
It is Oliver Manuel who is proposing that a neutron star exists in the middle of every star. The physics means that there will be fusion at the surface of this neutron star. We know this because we observe radiation from that fusion at the surface of neutron stars when matter falls onto them( x-ray burster and dwarf nova ) :jaw-dropp !

Thus it is up to Oliver Manuel to show that this fusion does not happen to the extent that stars blow up.

ETA
We observe that this matter falling onto neutron stars is either ejected or forms part of its surface.
What magic do you (or Manuel) evoke to stop large amounts of matter undergoing even more fusion also being ejected or incorporated into the surface?
 
Last edited:
Woah. I've created MANY RD images. I've contacted MANY people at NASA over the years. Please refresh my memory as to WHICH SPECIFIC IMAGE you're referring to.
It is not an RD image.
You did not create it.
You did not contact NASA about it.

It was a PR image.

From Micheal Mozina's iron crust has been totally debunked!:(item 53)
Did you cherry pick the SDO image to support your fantasy? - the answer is yes. MM saw a "green line" in one PR image and ignored its absence in another.
The SDO image"green line" is a processing artifact as confirmed by the NASA team.
But anyway
What went wrong with your counting of pixels in the SDO image?
Where are your calculations that the SDO artifact has a width of *EXACTLY* 4800 km
 
It often seems that having a discussion with an EU groupie is not unlike having a discussion with a defective Turing machine.
 
DeiRenDopa said:
Well, for starters, it lacks (at least) one essential component; in short, the "solar model on [you] website" is not quantitative.
That is simply NOT TRUE! If you don't read the links, INCLUDING BIRKELAND'S WORK, it's not my personal fault. Stop being so lazy!

Here's the MM comment which started this: "The solar model on my website is an updated (with satellite imagery) presentation of THEIR SOLAR MODEL, not mine."

Now, as usual, we have to do a fair amount of creative interpretation to understand what MM means. In particular, what is "THEIR SOLAR MODEL"?

Well, the context is this: "Kristian Birkeland and his team were the very first members of the EU community in terms of LAB TESTED EMPIRICAL PHYSICS with electric suns, in this case "cathode" suns. The solar model on my website is an updated (with satellite imagery) presentation of THEIR SOLAR MODEL, not mine. Another noteworthy member of the EU community would be Hannes Alfven. His model is a HYDROGEN PLASMA FUSION model."

An updated presentation (not version, or interpretation), of Kristian Birkeland and his team's model of "electric suns, in this case "cathode" suns". Not, of course, of Hannes Alfven's "HYDROGEN PLASMA FUSION model".

Does MM channel Kristian Birkeland and his team? If he doesn't - and he doesn't, this being the Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology part of JREF - what is the basis of MM's (astonishing) claim?

Why it's images! :D

Does MM's website present quantitative analyses of the "satellite imagery"?

No.

Does that website present quantitative re-analysis of Kristian Birkeland and his team's published work, to show their relevance to parts of the electromagnetic spectrum that team did not do imaging (photography, at the time) in?

No.

Does MM's website present simulations, or theoretical analyses of the physical regimes now known to exist in the relevant parts of the Sun, with the purpose of showing correspondence between Kristian Birkeland and his team's published conclusions and results and the satellite imagery?

No.

Does ... (you get the idea).

So, while it is a possibility that "THEIR [Kristian Birkeland and his team's] SOLAR MODEL" is quantitative, that (quantitative) model is not, in fact actually on MM's website (links to publications by Birkeland are).

But, more importantly, the "updated (with satellite imagery) presentation of THEIR SOLAR MODEL" that is actually on MM's website is most assuredly not quantitative.

You're back on Ignore next time MM.
 
The fact you created a couple of hand made RD images is not INSTANT EVIDENCE that you're right DAS. Which exact conversation are you talking about?


Actually I am somewhat of an expert in graphics of this type. I understand exactly what a running difference image is, how the data is obtained, how it is assembled, and what it means. I know the use of running difference images to support the solid surface of the Sun conjecture is absolutely wrong. I know that this has been explained so many times that the continued use of them for that purpose can be nothing but an intentional falsehood. I also know that the use of them in the Oliver Manuel papers, including the way they are described and attributed, is an out and out lie. Those papers of his which use running difference images to support Manuel's claims are fraudulent misrepresentations of actual science.

Woah. I've created MANY RD images.


Many? Thirty five frames in a short video? Without even understanding how the images were made? The evidence does not seem to support much relevant experience or qualification.

I've contacted MANY people at NASA over the years. Please refresh my memory as to WHICH SPECIFIC IMAGE you're referring to.


And it is certain that none of them ever said any running difference images show an iron rich surface on the Sun. Never. I have discussed solar satellite imagery with some of the experts at NASA, the people who are hands-on involved in the particular projects which obtain, process, and analyze those images. Any claims that they show solid surfaces, glowing neon layers, lightning-like electrical discharges, or iron rich rigid structures are untrue.

Huh? Honestly Das, I don't even recall the conversation, but obviously you do (sort of).


It was a discussion about the first public relations color composite image from the SDO. The mis-alignment of the originals made a greenish stripe around the Sun in the image. The colors were simply mis-aligned, and several of us through objective analysis were able to determine that. Our conclusion was confirmed by contacting the head of the science team of the SDO. It does not show different layers, but it is still being falsely used to try to support that notion on the solid surface of the Sun web site. And that, among many other blatant falsehoods on that web site, is why the site and the information it pretends to provide can be definitively considered fraudulent. As an expert in the particular graphics under discussion, I would attest to that for the purpose of scientific documentation and as an objective, scientific critique of the information offered at the web site where they are posted.

Care to site me a link? You never know, I could have a change of heart if I reread the thread in question?


Since those images are still being used to support a work of fiction on a web site that pretends to be scientific, it's reasonably obvious there's been no change of heart yet.

My point is that it's impossible to have a serious conversation about an E oriented view of the universe when fundamental processes and fundamental concepts are DENIED. Trying to explain an electrical discharge process in a solar flare to an EU HATER is literally IMPOSSIBLE because they literally believe that "electrical discharges cannot occur in a conductor"! WTF? It's like trying to discuss radiometric dating methods with a creationist who's insisting that the method is utterly invalid.


This is the valid criticism of the above complaint...

A claim was made that solar flares and CMEs are, or are caused by, electrical discharges akin to lightning here on Earth. That claim is false, demonstrably false, false according to the laws of physics. Electrical discharges like lightning bolts or the sparks in a toy plasma ball cannot occur in the conductive plasma of the solar atmosphere. There is no belief involved. It's a simple scientific fact. And the only objection to that fact seems to be based on some cherry picked words and phrases from some scientific papers.

Apparently it is still being claimed that solar flares are or are caused by lightning-like electrical discharges. If that claim has been rescinded, I must have missed it. Everyone who understands the physics, even remotely, will agree that those electrical discharges cannot occur in the conductive medium of the solar plasma atmosphere. According to simple physics, it isn't going to happen.
 
When and where did you make these "runaway fusion' calculations for me to look at ben?

First, I looked up the amount of hydrogen that's required to support detonation on an ordinary (M=1.4) neutron star. It's about 10^17kg, and it compresses into a layer about 10cm thick. That, all by itself, cannot burn stably but rather experiences runaway thermonuclear detonation; a whole neutron-star surface layer ought to (according to the known reaction rates) burn in a few seconds at this density. And it does.

That's for a massive neutron star, the only question is whether Manuel avoids this fate by putting in a less-massive neutron star. I worked up some 1D hydrostatic equilibria in Mathematica to see whether this helped. A less massive star has a lower pressure *gradient* at the surface, but a low-pressure-gradient doesn't help; because Manuel's hypothesized neutron stars have such a thick layer of H, the total surface pressure is x-ray-flash-like or worse. This 1D picture seems to be reliable for neutron stars as small as 0.003 solar masses. (That's around where I'd care about getting the spherical symmetry right.) So that's my answer: Put a solar mass of hydrogen on a small neutron star, and it compresses to white-dwarf-like densities (10^6 times higher than the mainstream Sun model) and that density supports runaway nuclear fusion. End of story.

With those ten lines of Mathematica, I have now written ten lines more stellar-structure code than the theory's author did himself. And that's all I intend to do. Michael, if you think this theory isn't idiotic crap, do some work that says so. What, am I supposed to assume that the math will work out in your favor before you've even done it? I should assume that on the strength of what---your reputation?
 
Last edited:
It was a discussion about the first public relations color composite image from the SDO. The mis-alignment of the originals made a greenish stripe around the Sun in the image. The colors were simply mis-aligned, and several of us through objective analysis were able to determine that. Our conclusion was confirmed by contacting the head of the science team of the SDO. It does not show different layers, but it is still being falsely used to try to support that notion on the solid surface of the Sun web site.
For those interested , this is the page that lies about the PR image.

The rest of the site is just Michael Mozina listing his delusion about seeing a solid surface for the Sun in various images. He of course ignores what the images contain, e.g. light from the corona!
 
First, I looked up the amount of hydrogen that's required to support detonation on an ordinary (M=1.4) neutron star. It's about 10^17kg, and it compresses into a layer about 10cm thick. That, all by itself, cannot burn stably but rather experiences runaway thermonuclear detonation; a whole neutron-star surface layer ought to (according to the known reaction rates) burn in a few seconds at this density. And it does.

That's for a massive neutron star, the only question is whether Manuel avoids this fate by putting in a less-massive neutron star. I worked up some 1D hydrostatic equilibria in Mathematica to see whether this helped. A less massive star has a lower pressure *gradient* at the surface, but a low-pressure-gradient doesn't help; because Manuel's hypothesized neutron stars have such a thick layer of H, the total surface pressure is x-ray-flash-like or worse. This 1D picture seems to be reliable for neutron stars as small as 0.003 solar masses. (That's around where I'd care about getting the spherical symmetry right.) So that's my answer: Put a solar mass of hydrogen on a small neutron star, and it compresses to white-dwarf-like densities (10^6 times higher than the mainstream Sun model) and that density supports runaway nuclear fusion. End of story.

With those ten lines of Mathematica, I have now written ten lines more stellar-structure code than the theory's author did himself. And that's all I intend to do. Michael, if you think this theory isn't idiotic crap, do some work that says so. What, am I supposed to assume that the math will work out in your favor before you've even done it? I should assume that on the strength of what---your reputation?

No EU groupie has even come close to providing a thoughtful analysis of this type among the over 6,200 posts on this thread. All the EU phonies ever do is make vague references to some obsolete or crackpot papers while pretending to be have something scientific to say. It's quite pathetic!
 
For those interested , this is the page that lies about the PR image.


Yep, that's the one. I double checked it. It's a three color composite made from the AIA 304Å channel and two others, probably the 211Å and 193Å channels. The colors are way over saturated. There is a black circle overlaid on the image then turned down to about a 20% transparency, probably to calm those blown out colors. The black circle is a few pixels larger than the disks in the satellite images underneath. That size discrepancy and the semi-transparency of that added circle is what causes the greenish rim. The entire thing was produced as a PR image, made to look pretty, with no intent of anything more. Using it as if it has some scientific merit is simply laughable.

The rest of the site is just Michael Mozina listing his delusion about seeing a solid surface for the Sun in various images. He of course ignores what the images contain, e.g. light from the corona!


That issue of the data coming from far above the photosphere has been explained so many times the tread has almost worn off. The only rebuttal to it has been an unsupported assertion something to the effect that the light doesn't necessarily have to come from above the photosphere. Absolutely no objective or quantitative explanation of that assertion has ever been provided. We're supposed to accept the legitimacy of the conjecture "because it is based entirely on observation". Which is, of course, nonsense.
 
More time showing proper results from the model, less time arguing pointlessly with masses of words on an internet forum.

This is how to convince people. You come here with some solid computational model showing your proposed model of the sun works, we'll all have egg on our faces. A LOT of egg. 158 pages' worth. Doesn't that prosepct excite you more than another 158 pages of being unable to convince anyone?
 
Last edited:
More time showing proper results from the model, less time arguing pointlessly with masses of words on an internet forum.

This is how to convince people. You come here with some solid computational model showing your proposed model of the sun works, we'll all have egg on our faces. A LOT of egg. 158 pages' worth. Doesn't that prosepct excite you more than another 158 pages of being unable to convince anyone?

158 papers written by me personally wouldn't convince an EU hater of anything. Alfven wrote HUNDREDS of papers on circuit theory as applied to events in space, including coronal loops. This crew doesn't care one iota about the maths in the final analysis. Did the paper by Mann and Onel convince anyone here of the scientific/mathematical legitimacy of circuit theory as applied to coronal loop activity? How many of you accept that "electrical discharges happen" in plasmas/conductors yet? Dungey linked flares to electrical discharges DECADES ago and yet this crew REMAINS in hard core denial to this very day. Lee EMPIRICALLY connected iron ion emissions to ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES in plasma in the *1970*'s. . This crew doesn't care.

Ben provided me with no calculations WHATSOEVER to even look at and review, let alone a PUBLISHED AND PEER REWIEWED WORK, and yet PS is convinced that ben has ALREADY presented the most important piece of evidence in the thread! WTF?

One thing that this thread has taught me is that no amount of maths really matter to a hater. They can't embrace the E because they have to give up their hate to embrace the E. They can't call solar processes ELECTROMAGNETIC processes, they are emotionally and sometimes professionally invested in "dumbing it down" to one orientation or the other.

I do honestly believe that fusion is the primary source of energy from the sun. I assume it has the "standard' solar mass, the standard solar output in terms of energy production, and undergoes STANDARD atmospheric behaviors from about 4800K under the photosphere outward, including convection, coronal loops, etc. If and when I see any real opportunity to DEVIATE in some way from STANDARD theory in a way that produces TESTABLE differences between them, I'll sit down and write a paper about it. At the moment I can't even think of anything to write about that might convince a hater of anything.

SDO does in fact present a new frontier in terms of coronal loop activity, and I do have some projects I'm working on that I believe are worth the effort. It's done in my "spare time". To do it "properly" will require the accumulation of information over YEARS, not weeks, or even months. If and when I feel it's PUBLISHABLE and I see how the data works out, you'll be the first to know.

Despite the OVERWHELMING evidence to demonstrate the scientific legitimacy of evolutionary theory, there are steadfast creationists. Likewise, despite the OVERWHELMING scientific evidence to demonstrate that electrical discharges occur in solar flares, and circuit theory in general, there will always be 'EU haters'. IMO this crew is *SO* emotionally invested in their position, nothing I personally publish will EVER be 'enough' anymore than anything BIRKELAND published was ever enough to convince the mainstream in his lifetime, or Alfven convinced this crew. It's all about BASHING PEOPLE with creationists and EU haters. It's all about protecting their current belief systems. Truth is irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
If a positively charged core repels a bunch of positively-charged protons, it's left with an excess of electrons and is therefore not a positively charged core any more.

Of course, "pretending that charged objects remain magically charged forever" is sort of Ground Zero of electric-universe idiocy.

*YOU* were the one that pointed out that once it's ejected it's NOT coming back, regardless of which particle we talk about. The core simply releases the raw material, neutrons, which decay into ELECTRICAL CURRENT (AKA moving charged particles) that are necessarily moving OUTBOUND. Nothing "comes back" to the spinning core. The EM field around the core spits out particles at close to the speed of light.

Start by explaining to me WHY you think a RAW NEUTRON STAR is somehow going to experience "runaway fusion" just because it spits out protons and electrons around itself?
 
Actually I am somewhat of an expert in graphics of this type.

Your audio/visual expertise in no way makes you an "expert" on solar physics anymore than it makes you an "expert" on masonry when we happen to be discussing pictures of a brick wall.

understand exactly what a running difference image is, how the data is obtained, how it is assembled, and what it means.

No, you do not. You do not even have the VERY FIRST CLUE how the light itself is created because you personally remain in hard core denial that electrical discharges occur in solar flares. You could NOT begin to explain an iron ion solar image or a running difference image because you cannot even link iron ion emissions to solar activity in the lab using "magnetic reconnection"! MR scored a wimpy 1 of 7 and only because *I FELT SORRY FOR IT*! Lee however did provide us all with a link between "electrical discharges' through plasma and iron ion emissions in the 70's. Dungey linked electrical discharges to solar flares in the 50's!

You're no expert on nuclear chemistry so your opinions about Manuel's work are IRRELEVANT. You haven't the ability to attack the science in any meaningful way so you attack the man. Such pathetic behavior!
 
Last edited:
Alfven wrote HUNDREDS of papers on circuit theory as applied to events in space, including coronal loops.

Alfvén has 148 papers in ADS, many of these are not on circuit theory.

This crew doesn't care one iota about the maths in the final analysis. Did the paper by Mann and Onel convince anyone here of the scientific/mathematical legitimacy of circuit theory as applied to coronal loop activity?

I have discussed this paper by Önel and Mann, but as soon as we start a real scientific discussion, you back out. The most blatant example is your non-participation in the scientific discussion thread of Birkeland's work.

Unfortunately, I cannot find my discussion, but it is somewhere around page 60 of this thread.
 
Last edited:
*YOU* were the one that pointed out that once it's ejected it's NOT coming back, regardless of which particle we talk about. The core simply releases the raw material, neutrons, which decay into ELECTRICAL CURRENT (AKA moving charged particles) that are necessarily moving OUTBOUND. Nothing "comes back" to the spinning core. The EM field around the core spits out particles at close to the speed of light.

Start by explaining to me WHY you think a RAW NEUTRON STAR is somehow going to experience "runaway fusion" just because it spits out protons and electrons around itself?

Why would they be ejected in the first place?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom