DeiRenDopa said:
Well, for starters, it lacks (at least) one essential component; in short, the "solar model on [you] website" is not quantitative.
That is simply NOT TRUE! If you don't read the links, INCLUDING BIRKELAND'S WORK, it's not my personal fault. Stop being so lazy!
Here's the MM comment which started this: "
The solar model on my website is an updated (with satellite imagery) presentation of THEIR SOLAR MODEL, not mine."
Now, as usual, we have to do a fair amount of creative interpretation to understand what MM means. In particular, what is "
THEIR SOLAR MODEL"?
Well, the context is this: "
Kristian Birkeland and his team were the very first members of the EU community in terms of LAB TESTED EMPIRICAL PHYSICS with electric suns, in this case "cathode" suns. The solar model on my website is an updated (with satellite imagery) presentation of THEIR SOLAR MODEL, not mine. Another noteworthy member of the EU community would be Hannes Alfven. His model is a HYDROGEN PLASMA FUSION model."
An updated presentation (not version, or interpretation), of Kristian Birkeland and his team's model of "
electric suns, in this case "cathode" suns". Not, of course, of Hannes Alfven's "
HYDROGEN PLASMA FUSION model".
Does MM channel Kristian Birkeland and his team? If he doesn't - and he doesn't, this being the Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology part of JREF - what is the basis of MM's (astonishing) claim?
Why it's images!
Does MM's website present quantitative analyses of the "
satellite imagery"?
No.
Does that website present quantitative re-analysis of Kristian Birkeland and his team's published work, to show their relevance to parts of the electromagnetic spectrum that team did not do imaging (photography, at the time) in?
No.
Does MM's website present simulations, or theoretical analyses of the physical regimes now known to exist in the relevant parts of the Sun, with the purpose of showing correspondence between Kristian Birkeland and his team's published conclusions and results and the satellite imagery?
No.
Does ... (you get the idea).
So, while it is a possibility that "THEIR [Kristian Birkeland and his team's] SOLAR MODEL" is quantitative, that (quantitative) model is not, in fact actually on MM's website (links to publications by Birkeland are).
But, more importantly, the "
updated (with satellite imagery) presentation of THEIR SOLAR MODEL" that is actually on MM's website is most assuredly not quantitative.
You're back on Ignore next time MM.