Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oliver Manuel is a crackpot who has postulated a wholly impossible version of the way the Sun is constructed. His numbers are nonsense. His papers on the issue are constructed, at least in part, on complete lies. He's a fraud.

I demand this post be removed. It's pure personal attack. You folks have no real scientific arguments. Therefore you all attack PEOPLE! What PATHETIC behavior.
 
Last edited:
To a degree, yes, they are mutually exclusive. There's nothing preventing/precluding the sun from picking up external energy in this model, but it does rely upon an predominantly INTERNALLY produced energy source. I've never quizzed them individually however.

If we stick with what's published (and available to all to read), the degree to which your ideas and the electric Sun ones of Thornhill, Scott, and Talbott are mutually incompatible (not exclusive) is absolute.

Why? Because, in their ideas, the Sun has no significant internal source of energy.

Yes and no. Although I prefer a Birkeland solar model, I'd consider Alven's model the first "runner up" for a variety of "practical" reasons.

Here's an example of why your ideas don't even come close to being accurately called astrophysics (or similar).

Whatever Alfvén's model of the Sun is, it is mutually incompatible with the idea that there's a solid (or rigid) surface - composed of iron, or some iron alloy/compound/mixture - beneath the photosphere. Whatever shortcomings there are in Alfvén's published work, they do not include contemplating gross violations of the laws of thermodynamics.

(there are, in this thread, already many lengthy discussions - if they can be called that - of Birkeland's ideas; no point in me repeating them here).

No. You missed the last one. I consider the solar model on my website to be a "pure" Birkeland solar model, including the fact that I STILL consider fission to be a viable energy source, even if it's a minority energy source.

So, in "the solar model on my website", what is it that - predominantly - powers the Sun?

My personal belief is that Birkeland got it right. The sun isn't simply a homopolar generator as Alfven believed, it does in fact act as a "cathode in space" as Birkeland predicted.
What's its voltage (with respect to what)?

What is the estimated current?

That IMO is the MOST IMPORTANT difference between Alfven's model and Birkeland's model. The mass flows in the solar wind patterns tend to suggest the flow is continuously away from the sun except for rare circumstances. That's true at the poles as well, perhaps PARTICULARLY true since the solar wind move FASTER in the polar regions than near the equator.
DeiRenDopa said:
What are the key points of commonality between your 'electric sun' idea and Peratt's 'electric sun' idea? What are the key points of disagreement?
I've never asked him that question actually. I would "assume" that he favors Alfven's basic model. I'm not sure how he would justify the lack of plasma inflow at the poles, which would in fact be my first question to him. :)
May I infer from this that you've not actually read what Peratt has published, in terms of ideas on an electric Sun?

Sure. In Birkeland's "cathode sun" model, current carrying "loops" are in face an "experimental prediction" of his working simulation. They are in fact a primary means to FALSIFY his cathode sun theories were they to be absent in the solar atmosphere. That would pretty much shoot his theory dead on the spot. The other key "prediction" from his experiments relates to the flow of particles (predominantly away from the sun), and the interactions with the heliosphere which he simply referred to as "space".

The flow of matter in the solar atmosphere was "predicted" by Birkeland's model to work in VERY specific ways. There's no way to continue to accept his model for instance were those high energy coronal loops ABSENT from solar satellite images. A cathode sun operating at 600 million volts damn well BETTER produce "electrical discharges" in the solar atmosphere as he predicted, or his predictions were worthless. Fortunately he hit the nail on the head. :)
Let me see if I have understood you correctly.

Surrounding the metal sphere, in Birkeland's lab, was a gas. That gas had, throughout, essentially the same temperature and pressure (except within any discharges), and contained no plasma (again, except within any discharges).

The real Sun is surrounded by a plasma, whose temperature, pressure, and degree of ionization varies by many orders of magnitude, over distances of a few solar radii.

You have done no experiments, no simulations, and no theoretical calculations to show - in quantitative terms - that the former is a reasonable approximation to the latter, in any respect whatsoever.

Is that about right?
 
If we stick with what's published (and available to all to read), the degree to which your ideas and the electric Sun ones of Thornhill, Scott, and Talbott are mutually incompatible (not exclusive) is absolute.

Why? Because, in their ideas, the Sun has no significant internal source of energy.

Well, that may have been true in the past. It *MAY* still be true today, but the EU community as a whole has been "maturing" over time and I've personally learned a LOT over the past 7 or 8 years. My beliefs are not static over time, so I don't presume that to be true of others.

Here's an example of why your ideas don't even come close to being accurately called astrophysics (or similar).

Whatever Alfvén's model of the Sun is, it is mutually incompatible with the idea that there's a solid (or rigid) surface - composed of iron, or some iron alloy/compound/mixture - beneath the photosphere.

That's true. It's pretty much a "standard" solar model with electrical interactions between the surface of the photosphere and the heliosphere. If Birkeland's model turns out not to be true, I would prefer that over 'standard' solar theory. As I said, it's a 1st runner up model IMO. :)

Whatever shortcomings there are in Alfvén's published work, they do not include contemplating gross violations of the laws of thermodynamics.

A cooler, more dense layer under a neon layer of plasma, no more violates the laws of thermodynamics than the fact that the chromosophere is hotter than the photosphere and the corona is hotter than both.

So, in "the solar model on my website", what is it that - predominantly - powers the Sun?

Well, at the moment, I'd have to say that the evidence favors fusion, certainly as the "primary" energy source. If things in the neutrino world keep "changing over time" I think fission could make a comeback. :)

What's its voltage (with respect to what)?

600 Million Volts with respect to the heliosphere.

What is the estimated current?

That depends on the cycle.

May I infer from this that you've not actually read what Peratt has published, in terms of ideas on an electric Sun?

No. I simply haven't talked to him RECENTLY. I have no idea what he believes RIGHT NOW. I'd have to assume he favors a plasma sun based on his writings.

Let me see if I have understood you correctly.

Surrounding the metal sphere, in Birkeland's lab, was a gas. That gas had, throughout, essentially the same temperature and pressure (except within any discharges), and contained no plasma (again, except within any discharges).

The sphere is discharging to the walls of the experiment creating "dusty plasma" throughout the chamber. Crank up the voltages and current to corresponding numbers suggested by Birkeland and I guarantee you that plasma will surround the sphere.

The real Sun is surrounded by a plasma, whose temperature, pressure, and degree of ionization varies by many orders of magnitude, over distances of a few solar radii.

True. The "best" results that Birkeland actually achieved in terms of creating plasma LAYERS took place when filled the chamber with pressurized gasses rather than in pure vacuum chambers. Layers formed around the sun, just as we see them in satellite images today. "Jets" formed too, as did "electrical discharges" in large looped shapes, just as we observe in satellite images today.

You have done no experiments, no simulations, and no theoretical calculations to show - in quantitative terms - that the former is a reasonable approximation to the latter, in any respect whatsoever.

Is that about right?

Nope. Then again, you don't care about anything I've published, do you?
http://arxiv.org/find/all/1/all:+mozina/0/1/0/all/0/1
 
Last edited:
I demand this post be removed. It's pure personal attack. You folks have no real scientific arguments. Therefore you all attack PEOPLE! You suck.


Oliver Manuel is welcome to join this forum if he would like to contribute to the discussion or defend his notions about the Sun. I'm not alone in my opinion about his work. It is well supported in several discussions on the BAUT forum from several years ago. I am also not aware that he has updated his papers to rectify the failures of his claims to match physical reality or to eliminate the falsehoods which, as I recall, were pointed out in those discussions.

But, being that his paper on the CNO Cycles uses the idea of electrical discharge loops as a foregone conclusion, and the paper does not describe the physics of those alleged discharges or even quantitatively support their existence, that paper does not lend support to the electric Sun conjecture. And neither his Cosmic Nuclear Cycle paper or his Sun's Origin paper discuss an electrical Sun at all.
 
Oliver Manuel is welcome to join this forum if he would like to contribute to the discussion or defend his notions about the Sun.

You have no right to attack INDIVIDUALS! If this board is moderated FAIRLY, your claims about his work should be removed and you too should get some time off for piss poor behavior. I doubt you personally have ANY background in particle physics theory. Your claims about his work are meaningless. They are pure personal attacks because you personally are incapable of NOT using sleazy debate tactics.
 
MM, I've read a handful of Oliver Manuel's papers. I've even heard him speak at an APS meeting. Based on my scientific assessment of Manuel's 'work', when GeeMack says

Oliver Manuel is a crackpot who has postulated a wholly impossible version of the way the Sun is constructed. His numbers are nonsense. His papers on the issue are constructed, at least in part, on complete lies. He's a fraud.

I agree wholeheartedly. You have no way of confirming this, but my physics research overlaps to an uncannily large degree with Manuel's. I mostly do experimental nuclear, particle, and neutrino physics but I've also forayed into stellar interiors (and unusual nuclear physics therein), the solar wind, and geochemistry (including meteorites). If you can find a point in Manuel's "model" that you think is worth defending, let's see it.
 
Last edited:
So "anything goes" in terms on this board in terms of personal attacks WITHOUT SO MUCH AS CITING A SINGLE FLAW IN HIS WORK, as long as it's a MAINSTREAMER doing the attacks? OMG. This place is a haters cult. If I said stuff like that, I'd be banned or at least given time off for that behavior. Where's the consistency in the applications of the rules around here?
 
Last edited:
It is ABUNDANTLY clear that the term "crackpot" is your hater's cult's version of calling an atheist "evil" for poking holes in someone's mainstream theistic belief systems. The application of the rules is either consistent, or it's not. Which is it going to be around here? Are you going to debate FAIRLY or not? What does GM know about nuclear physics?
 
You have no right to attack INDIVIDUALS! If this board is moderated FAIRLY, your claims about his work should be removed and you too should get some time off for piss poor behavior. I doubt you personally have ANY background in particle physics theory. Your claims about his work are meaningless. They are pure personal attacks because you personally are incapable of NOT using sleazy debate tactics.

As long as the person being "attacked" is not a member of this board, then the "Patrick rule" applies.


In other words, as long as Patrick can attack astronauts and not be banned for it, then anything DOES "go".
 
You really don't understand burden of proof...

Sure I do. I showed you something like SEVEN key high energy emission processes, including x-rays, gamma rays, and even NEUTRON CAPTURE SIGNATURES that were directly associated (IN THE LAB) with "electrical discharges". I think the hater side showed me exactly *ONE* of the seven things on my list that was done with "magnetic reconnection". The burned of proof has nothing to do with EU hater beliefs.
 
What does GM know about nuclear physics?

More than MM knows about electromagnetism. Seriously, MM, you are the last person on Earth declaring that someone is unqualified to discuss physics. You, for example, have repeatedly failed to understand the mere definition of a field line, or the slightest whiff of the vector-calculus-based equations that govern them, yet you expect people to read your opinions about magnetic reconnection.

Whether or not GM is a credentialed expert on this point, the fact is that he's right. Whether or not you are a credentialed expert on this point, you are wrong.
 
Your whole argument is one giant personal attack. Did you even personally acknowledge that work by Alfven in his double layer paper, or Mann and Onel in their paper that linked Alfven's ideas to solar satellite images? No. Did you find any mathematical error in any of those two papers? NO! You don't care about the math ben. You use that to ATTACK PEOPLE, in this case me. What's the point of presenting you with math that supports these ideas if you never read and acknowledge that math and that support?
 
Last edited:
In the above post I'm talking about Manuel's crackpot model of the Sun's interior. I am no longer paying attention to anything you are saying about the corona.
 
Well, that may have been true in the past. It *MAY* still be true today, but the EU community as a whole has been "maturing" over time and I've personally learned a LOT over the past 7 or 8 years. My beliefs are not static over time, so I don't presume that to be true of others.
MM, this point has been made, before, in this thread and others, many times, so I'm surprised to find myself making it again.

What you, or Thornhill, Scott, Talbott, or anyone else believes is irrelevant.

The only thing which is relevant, to a science-based discussion, is what is published, in a form that is accessible and verifiable (as in one could - in principle - verify that the authors listed are, in fact, the authors).

If you know of any such publication, by Thornhill, Scott, and/or Talbott, which presents their electric Sun ideas and shows that the Sun has a significant internal source of energy, please do so.

If you can't, then my statement is accurate.

A cooler, less dense layer under a neon layer of plasma, no more violates the laws of thermodynamics than the fact that the chromosophere is hotter than the photosphere and the corona is hotter than both.
None of which is, of course, relevant to anything Alfvén wrote (with respect to your electric Sun ideas being mutually inconsistent with whatever ideas he had, concerning the Sun).

If you can point to anything in Alfvén's published works which shows he made a case that the optical depth of the photosphere, at a physical depth of several thousand km, was ~<1, please do so.

Well, at the moment, I'd have to say that the evidence favors fusion, certainly as the "primary" energy source. If things in the neutrino world keep "changing over time" I think fission could make a comeback. :)
That's good to read.

600 Million Volts with respect to the heliosphere.
And your evidence for this conclusion is ...?

Recall, this is what you wrote: "The sun isn't simply a homopolar generator as Alfven believed, it does in fact act as a "cathode in space"". In other words, it's your claim (and part of your electric Sun idea).

That depends on the cycle.
What is its average, over several cycles (ballpark estimate will do)?

What is a typical range (again, ballpark estimates will do)?

Recall, this is an answer to my question "What is the estimated current?"

No. I simply haven't talked to him RECENTLY. I have no idea what he believes RIGHT NOW. I'd have to assume he favors a plasma sun based on his writings.
So we can leave Peratt out of this discussion entirely, can't we?

The sphere is discharging to the walls of the experiment creating "dusty plasma" throughout the chamber.
What is this ""dusty plasma""? As you've used double quotes, I presume you intend to give the term a special meaning, quite different from the usual (textbook) meaning.

Crank up the voltages and current to corresponding numbers suggested by Birkeland and I guarantee you that plasma will surround the sphere.
Words are cheap MM.

Have you done an experiment to confirm this? As far as I know, no.

Have you done a simulation to confirm this? As far as I know, no.

Have you done some theoretical work, modelling perhaps, to confirm this? As far as I know, no.

In short, nothing objective, nothing independently verifiable.

As these are foundational components of science (at least astrophysics), whatever this part of your idea is, it isn't science.

True. The "best" results that Birkeland actually achieved in terms of creating plasma LAYERS took place when filled the chamber with pressurized gasses rather than in pure vacuum chambers. Layers formed around the sun, just as we see them in satellite images today. "Jets" formed too, as did "electrical discharges" in large looped shapes, just as we observe in satellite images today.
However, the physical conditions - gas composition, pressure gradients, temperature gradients, radiation field, etc - of his ""best"" results are all many, many orders of magnitude different from those of the real Sun, aren't they.

Nope. Then again, you don't care about anything I've published, do you?
http://arxiv.org/find/all/1/all:+mozina/0/1/0/all/0/1
Um, I know what's been published with your name on it, MM.

My statement - "you have done no experiments, no simulations, and no theoretical calculations to show - in quantitative terms - that the former is a reasonable approximation to the latter, in any respect whatsoever" - refers explicitly, and only, to the degree to which the conditions in Birkeland's lab experiment replicate those of the real Sun's atmosphere (i.e. above the photosphere).

In none of your publications do you present results of any experiments you have conducted (relevant to my statement), nor any simulations you have run, nor ...

So I guess we may conclude that, by omission, you confirmed the veracity of my statement.

Nice one.
 
I demand this post be removed. It's pure personal attack. You folks have no real scientific arguments. Therefore you all attack PEOPLE! What PATHETIC behavior.
You cannot demand anything:
Oliver Manuel
  1. Is a crackpot.
  2. His solar model is wholly impossible (a neutron star in the middle of the Sun :jaw-dropp!). It ignores the actual physics.
  3. His papers are constructed, at least in part, on complete lies - one of which is your delusion that the Sun has a surface with mountains on it.
 
It's also utterly irrelevant since Birkeland's solar model is *INTERNALLY* powered.
It's also utterly irrelevant since Birkeland's solar model *DOES NOT EXIST* and his ideas *ARE NOT AN ELECTRIC SUN FANTASY*.
Birkeland speculated that the Sun could be powered by radioactive decay of uranium, radium, etc., i.e. fission. He was wrong.

Here is the post by DeiRenDopa again. No mention of Birkeland. Just the list of Electric Sun cranks.
Originally Posted by DeiRenDopa
This is, to me, one of the most astonishing things about this (Electric Sun) idea.

Proponents of it (the Electric Sun idea) have been all over internet fora, for many years, screaming, yelling, whining, spamming, posting links to youtube videos, posting long and wordy comments, etc, etc, etc (i.e. not just MM, not just in this forum).

And yet, among those tens of thousands (hundreds of thousands?) of posts, and millions of words, not even once has anyone posted anything remotely resembling mathematical (and that includes just plain quantitative) support for the core concept (i.e. that the Sun is - predominantly - powered by giant, interstellar (or intergalactic) Birkeland currents)! :jaw-dropp :eek:

Of course, this hasn't stopped the principals - Thornhill, Scott, Talbott, Tresman, and maybe one or two others - from making promises (of varying degrees of specificity) that exactly such support is being (furiously) worked on, and its publication is just around the corner (as in, a month or so).

In one sense this is quite remarkable: how have the principals been able to so successfully keep the con going for so long?
 
How many DECADES did the mainstream cling to FUSION as the only energy source of the sun even AFTER it utterly *FAILED* to predict the correct type of neutrinos, and BEFORE it found *ANY* evidence of flavor changing?
About THREE DECADES between the deficit dicovery and the detection of the missing neutrinos.

How much time should they have waited before throwing away the known and tested laws of physics?
 
Although I prefer a Birkeland solar model, I'd consider Alven's model the first "runner up" for a variety of "practical" reasons.
There is no Birkeland solar model so you are stuck with Alfvén's model.
That is a problem for you because his model is ... the standard solar model :jaw-dropp!

Alfvén never published a solar model.
You may have the delusion that his work on solar flares is a solar model. It is not.
 
I consider the solar model on my website to be a "pure" Birkeland solar model, including the fact that I STILL consider fission to be a viable energy source, even if it's a minority energy source.
Once again you deluded about the existence of a Birkeland solar model.
You are also fooling yourself about fission being a viable energy source. If you knew anything about fission then you would know that it cannot happen in the Sun. There are no nuclear reactors floating around in it!

You may be thinking about natural fission, i.e. radioactive decay. IN that case provide us with the calculations that you made in determine that it is a "minority" contributor.
By "minority" do you mean:
  • 0.00000000000000000000000000001% of the energy output or
  • 0.0000000000000000000000000001% of the energy output or
  • 0.000000000000000000000000001% of the energy output or
  • 0.00000000000000000000000001% of the energy output or
  • some other number?
Start with the observation that about 0.0000000001% of the Sun is uranium.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom