Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is incorrect. I have looked at both sides of this argument. I agree with Clinger's analysis, because I understand the math behind it. In my opinion, if you don't agree Clinger's analysis, it's because you don't understand it, not because it is incorrect.

Actually it's because I (finally) *DO* understand it that I don't agree with it. It's not unlike the model Priest describes when he turns that particle kinetic energy into quantized magnetic units in that paper Tim cited. Clinger's problem is that he forgot the plasma. No plasma, no current to convert into quantized magnetic energy in equation 18 of Priest's paper. It's not his "math" that is screwed up, it's his PHYSICS, more specifically his LACK THEREOF.
 
Last edited:
That's because you don't know much. The neutrino flux is wrong, so it cannot have a large fraction due to fission.

http://www.physicscentral.com/buzz/blog/index.cfm?postid=5719941848717510971

I'm not so sure. I don't know exactly how neutrinos oscillate, or 'disappear' and whether that process is consistent between various flavors. I can't be as "sure" as you seem to be.

And you still haven't provided a model. Fusion doesn't just happen. It needs certain conditions. And the energy its producing doesn't get magically transported from the inside to the outside, it has to flow according to the laws of physics. The standard model accomplishes both providing the necessary conditions for fusion and transporting that energy to the surface of the sun. Your "model" makes no attempt to do either.

It would provide the basic "heat" even at the surface. The only transportation difference is the amount of energy transferred from below the solid surface into the atmosphere via electrical discharges. This model REQUIRES a lot of atmospheric energy release.

Nope, I can rule out lots more than that. Including your fission-powered sun.

Not really, not without ASSUMING a lot about neutrino behaviors and such assumptions have been KNOWN to lead us astray.

But you can't provide any other mechanism to actually produce that energy, let alone pass it through your cold iron shell.

Sure I can. Fusion and fission in the core produce the basic heat and release the electrical energy that discharges itself in the atmosphere above that cooler shell. It's still THOUSANDS (plural) of degrees in temperature at the surface!

That's far too large a voltage to be sustained for any prolonged period of time. Unlike his brass ball, plasma has no work function.

It's a conductor that conducts all current from the core away from the core.

Is "more" somehow code for "exclusively"? Birkeland didn't know about fusion. Nobody at the time did.

I'm just saying that his power source was really described as a "transmutation of elements". I'm sure if he knew about fusion he would have considered it.
 
Last edited:
[...] The model I promote on my website (and this thread) is *INTERNALLY*, not *EXTERNALLY* powered! [...]


Just as a point of correction, normally a solar model is thought of as a quantitative description of the Sun, usually explaining at least some of its characteristics often including things like composition, density, mass, thermal characteristics, and luminosity. In that sense, there is no model promoted on the "thesurfaceofthesun.com" web site, certainly no more so than claiming to present a model of the Moon by saying it's round and it looks like it has speckles on it. It's a conglomeration of wild guesses and nonsense, most of which appears to be based on gross misunderstandings of contemporary solar physics, and some of which appears to be based on outright fabrications and falsehoods.

Carry on.
 
Last edited:
Fission? Jeeeeeeeez.

MM, are you interested in seeing exactly how thoroughly the solar-neutrino energy spectrum disallows fission from contributing to the Sun's power? The rate is wrong by a factor of 1,000,000. The flavor is wrong (neutrinos vs. antineutrinos) and the spectrum is wrong. I would say with considerable confidence that the neutrino data is inconsistent with more than 1/10,000,000 of the Sun's power coming from fission.

If you want to continue entertaining the solar-fission idea, you have some explaining to do.

If you want to say "OK, now I know, the Sun isn't fission powered" that'd be appropriate a good start. One might wonder how someone whose mission-in-life is the promotion of an alternative solar model had managed to overlook this. It's like Alfred Wegener showing up at a geology conference and revealing that he'd never heard of the Indian Ocean.
 
Fission? Jeeeeeeeez.

MM, are you interested in seeing exactly how thoroughly the solar-neutrino energy spectrum disallows fission from contributing to the Sun's power? The rate is wrong by a factor of 1,000,000. The flavor is wrong (neutrinos vs. antineutrinos) and the spectrum is wrong. I would say with considerable confidence that the neutrino data is inconsistent with more than 1/10,000,000 of the Sun's power coming from fission.

If you want to continue entertaining the solar-fission idea, you have some explaining to do.

If you want to say "OK, now I know, the Sun isn't fission powered" that'd be appropriate a good start. One might wonder how someone whose mission-in-life is the promotion of an alternative solar model had managed to overlook this. It's like Alfred Wegener showing up at a geology conference and revealing that he'd never heard of the Indian Ocean.

The problem Ben is that 10 years ago I could have said the same thing about your standard model if wall we looked at were NEUTRINOS. You're right that I have explaining to do, and antineutrinos would have to behave differently than neutrinos, but there is some evidence that the latter idea could be true. We'll have to wait and see IMO.

The only point I would make here is that while fusion is more easily explained at the moment, it's not entirely clear yet that fission plays *NO* role in solar output. That's all I'm saying.
 
I would say with considerable confidence that the neutrino data is inconsistent with more than 1/10,000,000 of the Sun's power coming from fission.

It's still greater than zero, and it's only consistent with what we CURRENTLY understand about neutrinos. Considering how much we've learned over the past couple of decades, I think it's work waiting awhile before passing summary judgement. You folks lived with neutrino mysteries for DECADES. I can afford to wait awhile before I decide.
 
I can't say to "know" or have met any of the three on your personal list, but what makes them representative of "electric sun" theories? The model I promote on my website (and this thread) is *INTERNALLY*, not *EXTERNALLY* powered! You keep lumping every electric sun concept into *ONE* concept, as though that ONE concept represents ALL concepts.

Thank you for the clarification.

I hadn't appreciated just how radically different your 'electric sun' idea is from that of Thornhill, Scott, and Talbott.

Mutually inconsistent, the two, they are.

In fact I think Jergens was pissy because Alfven DIDN'T claim that the vast majority of the energy came from an EXTERNAL source. Birkeland certainly never suggested it was EXTERNALLY powered.

I'm not so sure of this, but it doesn't matter, does it? I mean, your 'electric sun' idea is radically different from that of 'Jergens'.

It's also radically different from that of Alfvén.

And that of Birkeland.

In other words, it has but one proponent (you).

Have I got that right?

All three of them published AMPLE materials to demonstrate their DIFFERENT views. Only Jergen's believed that suns were powered by external currents.

I guess that answers my last question.

How about Peratt?

Good question.

What are the key points of commonality between your 'electric sun' idea and Peratt's 'electric sun' idea? What are the key points of disagreement?

How about OTHERS? What do you mean "that leaves....."

Refer to the post I wrote, which started this mini-thread.

It's irrelevant now.

The constant stream of personal attack and any and all EU proponents is what is BLATANTLY dishonest about these discussions.

So you say.

Did you find any real error in that paper by Mann and Onel DRD?

I'm sorry MM, would you please be so kind as to remind me of the relationship between "that paper by Mann and Onel" and your 'electric sun' idea? Thanks.

I really don't want to make the mistake (again) of mis-representing your 'electric sun' idea.
 
Last edited:
It would provide the basic "heat" even at the surface.

Don't put heat in quotes. It has a very definite physics definition. And no, it wouldn't produce heat at the surface, not with an intervening cold layer. That would violate the 2nd law of thermodynamics. You would need a non-thermal energy transport mechanism. You don't actually have one that works.

The only transportation difference is the amount of energy transferred from below the solid surface into the atmosphere via electrical discharges. This model REQUIRES a lot of atmospheric energy release.

What model? You don't have a model. You have hand-waving. Electric discharges, however you want to define them, require charge separation. But you have no mechanism which can produce large charge separation. In fact, the central elements of your theory will help prevent large charge separation.

Sure I can. Fusion and fission in the core produce the basic heat and release the electrical energy that discharges itself in the atmosphere above that cooler shell. It's still THOUSANDS (plural) of degrees in temperature at the surface!

1) Fusion produces heat
2) ?????
3) Electric discharge!

It's the underwear gnome theory of the sun. It makes no sense. How the hell do you separate large amounts of charge in a conducting medium? And if you say "double layers", slap yourself, because that's not a lot of charge, and it won't transport those separated charges to the surface through your solid shell. Basically, you're claiming that there's an INCREDIBLY efficient spontaneous heat engine within the sun for producing electricity. And this heat engine operates... how? You don't have a clue. Hell, you don't even seem to realize that your theory requires this.

It's a conductor that conducts all current from the core away from the core.

Thus violating conservation of charge.

Yeah, not gonna fly. Why would the current go through the atmosphere and not simply short-circuit through the shell? Or hell, just discharge underneath your solid shell?

I'm just saying that his power source was really described as a "transmutation of elements".

Which is 1) just another term for fission, because that's the only transmutation anyone knew about, and 2) even if we expand it to include fusion, it just becomes far too vague to be useful to our discussion.

I'm sure if he knew about fusion he would have considered it.

I'm sure he would have, but it doesn't matter, because he didn't.
 
MM: The simple debunking of the core Electric Sun concept

IMO the "con" is the part highlighted in yellow, and comes from your side of the aisle, the "haters" of electric sun (electric anything in space) theories.
There is no opinion needed.
The core concept that DeiRenDopa emphasized (and you highlighted)
(i.e. that the Sun is - predominantly - powered by giant, interstellar (or intergalactic) Birkeland currents)! :jaw-dropp :eek:
​
is so easily debunked that it makes people who believe in this concept very ignorant and a persistent belief idiotic.
This has been pointed out to you before. But here is the simple science one more time:
  1. The laws of physics tell us that fusion must be happening at the center of the Sun.
  2. We observe enough neutrinos from the Sun to explain its output through this fusion.
  3. We do not observe the gamma radiation that this fusion will produce. This means that the fusion happens in the center of the Sun.
 
What model? You don't have a model. You have hand-waving. Electric discharges, however you want to define them, require charge separation. But you have no mechanism which can produce large charge separation. In fact, the central elements of your theory will help prevent large charge separation.

1) Fusion produces heat
2) ?????
3) Electric discharge!

It's the underwear gnome theory of the sun.


This may just be the entire situation in a nutshell. There is no electric Sun theory, not by the conventional scientific meaning of the word "theory". There is no electric Sun model. There are thousands, maybe millions of words of unsupported assertions, but no model, no quantitative description of how this electric Sun thing is supposed to work. There is no mathematical explanation for the mass, density, thermal characteristics, or luminosity of the Sun. It's all a work of fiction, made up with cherry picked words and phrases from real science, and all stuck together with spit and twine. The funniest part, or maybe the most pathetic, is the advocates pretend to be defending a model, but they can't even manage to describe it.
 
I can afford to wait awhile before I decide.
That is the problem - you have little idea how science works.
Scientists make their decisions based on the available evidence.

The laws of physics means that there is solar fusion. That fusion powers the Sun since there are no other viable scientific mechanisms. For example one one would be idiotic to suggest fusion on the surface of the Sun powered by interstellar electric currents (invisible with no source or other effect!) because the gamma radiation would be obvious.

So the late 1960s discovery of a deficit in the neutrino flux suggested a problem with the laws of physics rather than with the existence of the fusion. And the solution already existed - neutrino have mass! Now we have the experimental evidence for oscillation between the neutrino type.

What you are doing is crossing your fingers and hoping that this scientific model of the Sun will fail.
That leaves no hope for any of the "underwear gnome" theories of the sun since another scientific model of the Sun will replace it.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for the clarification.

I hadn't appreciated just how radically different your 'electric sun' idea is from that of Thornhill, Scott, and Talbott.

Mutually inconsistent, the two, they are.

To a degree, yes, they are mutually exclusive. There's nothing preventing/precluding the sun from picking up external energy in this model, but it does rely upon an predominantly INTERNALLY produced energy source. I've never quizzed them individually however.

I'm not so sure of this, but it doesn't matter, does it? I mean, your 'electric sun' idea is radically different from that of 'Jergens'.

Definitely.

It's also radically different from that of Alfvén.

Yes and no. Although I prefer a Birkeland solar model, I'd consider Alven's model the first "runner up" for a variety of "practical" reasons.

And that of Birkeland.

In other words, it has but one proponent (you).

Have I got that right?

No. You missed the last one. I consider the solar model on my website to be a "pure" Birkeland solar model, including the fact that I STILL consider fission to be a viable energy source, even if it's a minority energy source.

My personal belief is that Birkeland got it right. The sun isn't simply a homopolar generator as Alfven believed, it does in fact act as a "cathode in space" as Birkeland predicted. That IMO is the MOST IMPORTANT difference between Alfven's model and Birkeland's model. The mass flows in the solar wind patterns tend to suggest the flow is continuously away from the sun except for rare circumstances. That's true at the poles as well, perhaps PARTICULARLY true since the solar wind move FASTER in the polar regions than near the equator.

Good question.

What are the key points of commonality between your 'electric sun' idea and Peratt's 'electric sun' idea? What are the key points of disagreement?

I've never asked him that question actually. I would "assume" that he favors Alfven's basic model. I'm not sure how he would justify the lack of plasma inflow at the poles, which would in fact be my first question to him. :)


I'm sorry MM, would you please be so kind as to remind me of the relationship between "that paper by Mann and Onel" and your 'electric sun' idea? Thanks.

I really don't want to make the mistake (again) of mis-representing your 'electric sun' idea.

Sure. In Birkeland's "cathode sun" model, current carrying "loops" are in face an "experimental prediction" of his working simulation. They are in fact a primary means to FALSIFY his cathode sun theories were they to be absent in the solar atmosphere. That would pretty much shoot his theory dead on the spot. The other key "prediction" from his experiments relates to the flow of particles (predominantly away from the sun), and the interactions with the heliosphere which he simply referred to as "space".

The flow of matter in the solar atmosphere was "predicted" by Birkeland's model to work in VERY specific ways. There's no way to continue to accept his model for instance were those high energy coronal loops ABSENT from solar satellite images. A cathode sun operating at 600 million volts damn well BETTER produce "electrical discharges" in the solar atmosphere as he predicted, or his predictions were worthless. Fortunately he hit the nail on the head. :)
 
Last edited:
There is no opinion needed.
The core concept that DeiRenDopa emphasized (and you highlighted)
(i.e. that the Sun is - predominantly - powered by giant, interstellar (or intergalactic) Birkeland currents)! :jaw-dropp :eek:
​
is so easily debunked that it makes people who believe in this concept very ignorant and a persistent belief idiotic.

It's also utterly irrelevant since Birkeland's solar model is *INTERNALLY* powered.
 
"You say X contradicts my model. But X may be wrong! You can't prove it isn't!"

How many DECADES did the mainstream cling to FUSION as the only energy source of the sun even AFTER it utterly *FAILED* to predict the correct type of neutrinos, and BEFORE it found *ANY* evidence of flavor changing?
 
Just as a point of correction, normally a solar model is thought of as a quantitative description of the Sun, usually explaining at least some of its characteristics often including things like composition,

That's perfectly defined in numbers produced by Manual.

density, mass,

The AVERAGE density and TOTAL mass are the same in this model as ANY OTHER solar model, namely a POSTICTED FIT to what we already know.

thermal characteristics, and luminosity.

A Birkeland solar model has very UNIQUE characteristics in terms of the thermal release of energy in coronal loops and the luminosity would would expect from EVERY SINGLE coronal loop in the solar atmosphere. The mainstream really has a tough time explaining how a SINGLE coronal loop is itself already a MILLION+ degrees even BEFORE it "reconnects" with any other loops in the atmosphere.

Carry on.

Carry on ignoring Birkeland's work just like the mainstream did for 60+ years before they found out his auroral theories were correct, and just a they do today as it relates to his solar theories. The very next question Birkeland asked himself about the power to the aurora was their power source which is what led him to experiment with his "cathode sun" theories. Keep ignoring them all you like, but in this information age, they won't go away. They will only serve as a obvious billboard and make such utter ignorance seem incomprehensible to others in the future that finally DO ACCEPT HIS FULL BODY OF WORK. IMO EU haters are going to look like the world's last "flat earth" peddlers to astronomers of the future. They won't even understand how anyone could be in denial of those electrical discharges in the solar atmosphere.
 
Last edited:
It's also utterly irrelevant since Birkeland's solar model is *INTERNALLY* powered.


Birkeland's "model" was a hollow brass ball with an electromagnet inside. The electromagnet was connected to the outside by wires. Those wires, connected to the power outside of the ball, and bringing that power in from the outside, means it was not "*INTERNALLY* powered", regardless of the shouting. This is pretty commonly known stuff among those who have read Birkeland's descriptions of his experiments. Perhaps not so commonly known to those who haven't read it, choose to be ignorant, or choose to lie about Birkeland's work.
 
Birkeland's "model" was a hollow brass ball with an electromagnet inside. The electromagnet was connected to the outside by wires. Those wires, connected to the power outside of the ball, and bringing that power in from the outside, means it was not "*INTERNALLY* powered", regardless of the shouting. This is pretty commonly known stuff among those who have read Birkeland's descriptions of his experiments. Perhaps not so commonly known to those who haven't read it, choose to be ignorant, or choose to lie about Birkeland's work.

What's also "common stuff" is the fact he talked about getting energy from the transmutation of elements *INSIDE* the sun.
 
That's perfectly defined in numbers produced by Manual.


Oliver Manuel is a crackpot who has postulated a wholly impossible version of the way the Sun is constructed. His numbers are nonsense. His papers on the issue are constructed, at least in part, on complete lies. He's a fraud.

The AVERAGE density and TOTAL mass are the same in this model as ANY OTHER solar model, name a POSTICTED FIT to what we already know.


No need to shout. Shouting isn't numbers.

A Birkeland solar model has very UNIQUE characteristics in terms of the thermal release of energy in coronal loops and the luminosity would would expect from EVERY SINGLE coronal loop in the solar atmosphere.


There is no "Birkeland solar model" that describes thermal characteristics and luminosity in any way that is relevant to contemporary physics. Kristian Birkeland, although he was correct on some issues particularly in his research of the Aurora Borealis effects, made a lot of really crappy guesses about how the Universe works. For example, he thought the Sun spits out corpuscles which will eventually coalesce into planets, and he thought the rings of Saturn were basically the same thing as Auroras. All in all he was probably wrong about way more stuff than he was right about. He didn't have the advantage of the past 100 years of progress in the science of physics. To the detriment of his disciples, they seem intent on neglecting those years of progress.

But most germane to this discussion, he isn't here to tell us what his alleged quantitative description might have meant. And apparently nobody alive today seems to be able to describe what they believe Birkeland meant in a way that any moderately intelligent English speaking people can understand.

The mainstream really has a tough time explaining how a SINGLE coronal loop is itself already a MILLION+ degrees even BEFORE it "reconnects" with any other loops in the atmosphere.


And without a quantitative analysis and quantitative description of the necessary physics, no electric Sun proponent will ever be able to explain any of the mysteries of the Sun, either. The notion that there are gigantic bolts of lightning dancing on the Sun is just a plain stupid argument.

Carry on ignoring Birkeland's just like the mainstream did for 60+ years before they found out his auroral theories were correct, and just a they do today as it relates to his solar theories. The very next question Birkeland asked himself about the power to the aurora was their power source which is what led him to experiment with his "cathode sun" theories. Keep ignoring them all you like, but in this information age, they won't go away.


Birkeland, almost singlehandedly, did his aurora research over just a couple years time. In this amazing information age with at least six years under their belts, the electric Sun proponents haven't budged a single iota, haven't made a speck of progress, haven't done a lick of math that actually supports their claims (some haven't done a lick of math period), and haven't published any papers which have received any attention from any legitimate physicists.

They will only serve as a obvious billboard and make such utter ignorance seem incomprehensible to others in the future that finally DO ACCEPT HIS FULLY BODY OF WORK. IMO EU haters are going to look like the world's last "flat earth" peddlers to astronomers of the future. They won't even understand how anyone could be in denial of those electrical discharges in the solar atmosphere.


I did mention before how the persistent incivility hasn't been a very effective strategy for advancing the electric Sun conjecture. It's still not working. But more notably and more relevant to this thread, all that complaining with zero quantitative support adds up to, well, zero quantitative support.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom