GeeMack
Banned
- Joined
- Aug 21, 2007
- Messages
- 7,235
There's nothing uncivil about noting that there are less than a dozen hard core EU "pseudo-skeptics" that spend their time in cyberspace bashing EU concepts.
To categorize critics of the electric Sun conjecture in its various renditions as "haters" is a dishonest attempt to re-frame the issue as one where electric Sun conjectures are somehow actually scientific, and where legitimate scientists are somehow persecuting electric Sun proponents by pointing out the lack of objective quantitative support. And yes, that dishonesty is indeed uncivil. There are ways to promote against-the-mainstream conjectures that are far more honest and civil than complaining about failing to support it, referring to criticism as "bashing", referring to critics as "pseudo-skeptics" and "haters", and blaming the critics for the continued failure.
Also, it seems there are exactly zero professional physicists on the planet who accept the electric Sun conjectures as valid. It is also reasonably certain there are exactly zero professional physicists on Earth who accept the unsupported claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by electrical discharges. Certainly no scientific references have been offered in this discussion which would indicate that there are any.
Just as creationists simply DENY the existence of "evidence" that they simply can't deal with, EU "critics" act exactly the same as your next sentence demonstrates:
Rather than continuing to blame the critics for the repeated failures of the electric Sun advocates, maybe actually attempting to support the conjectures mathematically, scientifically, objectively, and quantitatively would be a more productive endeavor. The critics are not ignoring any alleged evidence. Several knowledgeable scientists have participated in this discussion and pointed out the failings of the electric Sun conjectures. The critics understand the alleged evidence well enough to recognize that it is not actually evidence to support the claims. The valid objective quantitative criticism is not the hold-up here. The willful ignorance and off hand dismissal of that criticism is.
Both of the last two links I handed you 'address' the E orientation of coronal loop activity. The fact you RUN from that evidence is no skin off my personal nose. The DENIAL process however is exactly the same as one experiences with a typical conversation with a creationist. No amount of "evidence" ever actually "registers".
It doesn't matter how much of Mann of Onel's maths or Alfven's maths I put before a "hater". They simply refuse to drink.
The persistent uncivil personal attacks are noted, and will continue to be reported according to the rules of the forum.