Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
There's nothing uncivil about noting that there are less than a dozen hard core EU "pseudo-skeptics" that spend their time in cyberspace bashing EU concepts.


To categorize critics of the electric Sun conjecture in its various renditions as "haters" is a dishonest attempt to re-frame the issue as one where electric Sun conjectures are somehow actually scientific, and where legitimate scientists are somehow persecuting electric Sun proponents by pointing out the lack of objective quantitative support. And yes, that dishonesty is indeed uncivil. There are ways to promote against-the-mainstream conjectures that are far more honest and civil than complaining about failing to support it, referring to criticism as "bashing", referring to critics as "pseudo-skeptics" and "haters", and blaming the critics for the continued failure.

Also, it seems there are exactly zero professional physicists on the planet who accept the electric Sun conjectures as valid. It is also reasonably certain there are exactly zero professional physicists on Earth who accept the unsupported claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by electrical discharges. Certainly no scientific references have been offered in this discussion which would indicate that there are any.

Just as creationists simply DENY the existence of "evidence" that they simply can't deal with, EU "critics" act exactly the same as your next sentence demonstrates:


Rather than continuing to blame the critics for the repeated failures of the electric Sun advocates, maybe actually attempting to support the conjectures mathematically, scientifically, objectively, and quantitatively would be a more productive endeavor. The critics are not ignoring any alleged evidence. Several knowledgeable scientists have participated in this discussion and pointed out the failings of the electric Sun conjectures. The critics understand the alleged evidence well enough to recognize that it is not actually evidence to support the claims. The valid objective quantitative criticism is not the hold-up here. The willful ignorance and off hand dismissal of that criticism is.

Both of the last two links I handed you 'address' the E orientation of coronal loop activity. The fact you RUN from that evidence is no skin off my personal nose. The DENIAL process however is exactly the same as one experiences with a typical conversation with a creationist. No amount of "evidence" ever actually "registers".

It doesn't matter how much of Mann of Onel's maths or Alfven's maths I put before a "hater". They simply refuse to drink.


The persistent uncivil personal attacks are noted, and will continue to be reported according to the rules of the forum.
 
To categorize critics of the electric Sun conjecture in its various renditions as "haters" is a dishonest attempt to re-frame the issue as one where electric Sun conjectures are somehow actually scientific, and where legitimate scientists are somehow persecuting electric Sun proponents by pointing out the lack of objective quantitative support.

It's the DENIAL factor that is DISHONEST. No amount of maths matter to HATERS because they never register the fact that it has ALREADY been done.

And yes, that dishonesty is indeed uncivil. There are ways to promote against-the-mainstream conjectures that are far more honest and civil than complaining about failing to support it, referring to criticism as "bashing", referring to critics as "pseudo-skeptics" and "haters", and blaming the critics for the continued failure.

There has been no failure to provide the mathematical support. There has been a FAILURE to ACKNOWLEDGE IT. That's irrational hater behavior akin to the way creationists treat evidence of evolutionary theory. No amount of "evidence" is ever sufficient.

Also, it seems there are exactly zero professional physicists on the planet who accept the electric Sun conjectures as valid.

You mean except Peratt and everyone else you refuse to acknowledge as an "expert" in anything?

It is also reasonably certain there are exactly zero professional physicists on Earth who accept the unsupported claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by electrical discharges.

Dungey himself made that connection. More HATER DENIAL.

Certainly no scientific references have been offered in this discussion which would indicate that there are any.

More pure denial since Dungey himself made that connection while coining the term "reconnection'! Holy cow!

Rather than continuing to blame the critics for the repeated failures of the electric Sun advocates, maybe actually attempting to support the conjectures mathematically, scientifically, objectively, and quantitatively would be a more productive endeavor.

Evidently not since you personally didn't even acknowledge those last two citations. Yep, just it's like arguing evolutionary with a creationist.

It's uncivil of you to keep asking for things that have already been provided and not acknowledging the fact they have been provided. That's the UNCIVIL (and rather irrational) part of this conversation.
 
Last edited:
The valid objective quantitative criticism is not the hold-up here. The willful ignorance and off hand dismissal of that criticism is.

What "valid objective quantitative criticism" did you personally offer me on either of the last two papers I handed you? What error did Onel make? What error did Alfven make?
 
It's the DENIAL factor that is DISHONEST. No amount of maths matter to HATERS because they never register the fact that it has ALREADY been done.

The has been no failure to provide the mathematical support. There has been a FAILURE to ACKNOWLEDGE IT. That's irrational hater behavior akin to the way creationists treat evidence of evolutionary theory. No amount of "evidence" is every sufficient.

You mean except Peratt and everyone else you refuse to acknowledge as an "expert" in anything?

Dungey himself made that connection. More HATER DENIAL.

Evidently not since you personally didn't even acknowledge those last two citations. Yep, just it's like arguing evolutionary with a creationist.

It's uncivil of you to keep asking for things that have already been provided and not acknowledging the fact they have been provided. That's the UNCIVIL (and rather irrational) part of this conversation.


First, nothing above is an argument. It's a complaint, or more definitively, a rant. It's likely true that no conjecture which attempts to overturn virtually all of known physics has ever been successfully presented by use of complaints rather than quantitative objective arguments backed by real math and real science and framed in an honest, civil way. Maybe that's part of the reason for the failure of any electric Sun conjectures.

Furthermore, I am not a hater. I am also not denying anything except the obvious, which is the fact that the electric Sun proponents have never been able to make their case in a way that is cogent or compelling enough to be taken seriously be any contemporary professional physicists. The failure belongs exclusively to the handful of people presenting the case. They own it. The failure is not the fault of the tens of thousands of people who actually understand the relevant math and physics.

Apparently every last bit of alleged support for the electric Sun conjectures has been provided in this thread. It has either been deemed unacceptable as support for the claims, or it has not been presented in a cogent, understandable way. Rather than continuing to complain about failing, it might be more productive to re-frame the case honestly, quantitatively, and objectively, the way real physicists do, and/or offer alternative alleged evidence and support. It would seem nothing but continued failure will result from persisting with the same failed strategy.
 
Learn math, Michael. Then revisit this issue, and it will all become clear. Those of us on the other side of a math education can see how all this works, and it makes sense.

You'll be glad you took the time to learn this stuff if you do.
 
DeiRenDopa said:
This is, to me, one of the most astonishing things about this (Electric Sun) idea.

Proponents of it (the Electric Sun idea) have been all over internet fora, for many years, screaming, yelling, whining, spamming, posting links to youtube videos, posting long and wordy comments, etc, etc, etc (i.e. not just MM, not just in this forum).

And yet, among those tens of thousands (hundreds of thousands?) of posts, and millions of words, not even once has anyone posted anything remotely resembling mathematical (and that includes just plain quantitative) support for the core concept (i.e. that the Sun is - predominantly - powered by giant, interstellar (or intergalactic) Birkeland currents)! :jaw-dropp :eek:

Of course, this hasn't stopped the principals - Thornhill, Scott, Talbott, Tresman, and maybe one or two others - from making promises (of varying degrees of specificity) that exactly such support is being (furiously) worked on, and its publication is just around the corner (as in, a month or so).

In one sense this is quite remarkable: how have the principals been able to so successfully keep the con going for so long?
IMO the "con" is the part highlighted in yellow, and comes from your side of the aisle, the "haters" of electric sun (electric anything in space) theories. I don't personally know of any "electric sun" proponents that actually believe that the sun does NOT have an INTERNAL power source. You guys seem to have latched on to ONE MAN'S (can even recall his name of the top of my head but maybe Jergens?) concept of an "electric sun" and you refuse to acknowledge any OTHER concepts. When did Alfven claim the sun was EXTERNALLY powered? Birkeland? These are the two primary proponents of "electric sun" theories by the way, and both of them suggested that the sun was *INTERNALLY*, not externally powered.

I take you off ignore, only to find this?!?!

I guess, from what you write, you either do not know Thornhill, Talbott, and Scott (i.e. any one, or any combo, of the three) personally, or you are profoundly ignorant of their major works.

(Of course, it's entirely possible - likely even, given your track record - that you have deliberately distorted what I actually wrote).

But, this is easy to clear up: provide references to material by Thornhill, Talbott, and Scott (i.e. any one, or any combo, of the three) where they state (explicitly or implicitly) that the Sun is (or, is very likely) predominantly powered by a source other an external electric current.

Birkeland? Well, we've already discussed him (more MM lies, or at least highly selective memory). In any case, he hasn't posted a single comment to any internet discussion forum, nor has he himself put material under his name up on the internet (neither has Alfvén, nor "Jergens").

That leaves Tresman, of those I named explicitly. His case is a bit more complex; suffice it to say that he is named as an author (or was it technical advisor, or something similar?) of an e-book which claims that Alfvén supported - if not actually proposed - the core Electric Sun idea (i.e. that the Sun is - predominantly - powered by external currents*).

One more case of blatant dishonesty by you MM, and back on Ignore you go.

* I did not write "by giant, interstellar (or intergalactic) Birkeland currents", because, in the case of this particular document, the naming of the external currents as giant, interstellar (or intergalactic) Birkeland currents as being Alfvén's idea (or supported by him) is not explicit (strongly implied, but not explicit).
 
Learn math, Michael. Then revisit this issue, and it will all become clear. Those of us on the other side of a math education can see how all this works, and it makes sense.

You'll be glad you took the time to learn this stuff if you do.

I learned the relevant math and found the relevant math in related papers and books and handed you that math on a silver patter. You folks failed to deal with it professionally. How is that my fault?
 
I take you off ignore, only to find this?!?!

I guess, from what you write, you either do not know Thornhill, Talbott, and Scott (i.e. any one, or any combo, of the three) personally, or you are profoundly ignorant of their major works.

(Of course, it's entirely possible - likely even, given your track record - that you have deliberately distorted what I actually wrote).

But, this is easy to clear up: provide references to material by Thornhill, Talbott, and Scott (i.e. any one, or any combo, of the three) where they state (explicitly or implicitly) that the Sun is (or, is very likely) predominantly powered by a source other an external electric current.

I can't say to "know" or have met any of the three on your personal list, but what makes them representative of "electric sun" theories? The model I promote on my website (and this thread) is *INTERNALLY*, not *EXTERNALLY* powered! You keep lumping every electric sun concept into *ONE* concept, as though that ONE concept represents ALL concepts.

In fact I think Jergens was pissy because Alfven DIDN'T claim that the vast majority of the energy came from an EXTERNAL source. Birkeland certainly never suggested it was EXTERNALLY powered.

Birkeland? Well, we've already discussed him (more MM lies, or at least highly selective memory). In any case, he hasn't posted a single comment to any internet discussion forum, nor has he himself put material under his name up on the internet (neither has Alfvén, nor "Jergens").

All three of them published AMPLE materials to demonstrate their DIFFERENT views. Only Jergen's believed that suns were powered by external currents.

That leaves Tresman,

How about Peratt? How about OTHERS? What do you mean "that leaves....."


One more case of blatant dishonesty by you MM, and back on Ignore you go.

The constant stream of personal attack and any and all EU proponents is what is BLATANTLY dishonest about these discussions. Did you find any real error in that paper by Mann and Onel DRD?
 
Last edited:
No you didn't. You ALLEGED many things based on STANDARD solar theory concepts, nothing more.

Nope. I used your theory, calculated properties using standard, well-tested laboratory physics (such as Coulomb's law), and found that your theory, independent of standard solar theory, produced complete and utter gibberish.

Which "math" would *INSTANTLY* change your opinions Zig? Did you read any of Birkeland's many maths? Alfven's?

None of their math actually supports your theory. For example, you have absolutely no way of accounting for the total power output of the sun. Nothing, nada, zip, zilch. The single most important variable, and you can't even touch it. Not with Alfven's math, not with Birkeland's math, not with any math.

And what would change my mind about your crackpottery is an honest attempt to calculate even the most basic parameters, in the simplest, most back-of-the-envelope manner. Where does the power output of the sun come from, Michael? I've calculated it for an electric sun model, and it produces absurdities. Go on, try it.

But while we're on the subject, what would make you even try to test your own model quantitatively? It's your model, you're sure it's right, so why on earth aren't you chomping at the bit to explore and refine it quantitatively?

I've provided this crew with TONS of maths related to coronal loop activity from the E orientation and not a single one of you really cares.

Why would I, when you can't even get the most basic, most important number within even an order of magnitude? Hell, not even within 10 orders of magnitude.

You can't point to anything in that paper by Mann and Onel, or anything in Alfven's work that actually get's Maxwell's equations wrong, can you?

Nothing Alfven wrote even remotely resembles your theories.

Alfven did math. He rejected MR math till the day he died. Why? What then makes "math" so special in your mind?

Math quantifies things. And physics is a quantitative science. You're uncomfortable with that fact, aren't you?

I've presented maths for you.

No, you've mentioned papers which have math in them, even though that math proves different things than you claim.

You're the one that cannot escape the FILTER you impose on any and all EU oriented ideas.

No, I apply that filter to all physics ideas.

It's a FILTER that prevents you from even seeing the obvious flaw in your own argument since you can't show where Alfven misused Maxwell's equations either!

And Alfven never believed in your nonsense either, so I'm not seeing any problem here.

I'm actually less emotionally attached to being right than any of the "haters' that cannot and will not even attempt to find any mathematical flaw in Alfven's work, yet blatantly reject it anyway.

I'm not rejecting Alfven's work. Well, not most of it - his cosmology actually is nonsense, and not surprisingly has no real math to back it up. I'm rejecting yours.

No amount of bashing my personal math skills will change the historical fact that those maths exist for you to read and address anytime you feel like doing so.

And no amount of trying to ride Alfven's coat tails will work, since nothing in his work actually supports anything like your electric sun model.
 
Nope. I used your theory, calculated properties using standard, well-tested laboratory physics (such as Coulomb's law), and found that your theory, independent of standard solar theory, produced complete and utter gibberish.

No, you demonstrated that *JERGENS* concept of an EXTERNALLY powered sun is utter gibberish as I recall. When did you do that for an INTERNALLY powered sun Zig?

Alven's "electric sun" doesn't even deviate from standard theory in terms of a power source so why is that even NECESSARY from your perspective?
 
FYI Zig, Birkeland DID quantify his sun in terms of terms of total energy output and in terms of relevant voltages, as did Alfven.
 
I learned the relevant math and found the relevant math in related papers and books and handed you that math on a silver patter. You folks failed to deal with it professionally. How is that my fault?

It is clear from your arguments in this thread that you overestimate your skills with math. I really do not want to be mean or insulting. I just know what physics looks like before and after gaining a genuine understanding of the math involved.

We're supposed to attack the argument and not the arguer at this forum. But it has become clear that your understanding of math is insufficient, and this means it has become an excercise in repetion to continue attacking the mathematically-incorrect arguments you post.

So in this case, I think it is more instructive to cut to the heart of the argument, which is to say that one party is lacking the skills needed to take part in the discussion in a meaningful way. Advice has been offered on how to remedy that. Beyond that, I can't help further.
 
No, you demonstrated that *JERGENS* concept of an EXTERNALLY powered sun is utter gibberish as I recall. When did you do that for an INTERNALLY powered sun Zig?

When did you provide a model for an internally powered sun?

I can't evaluate what doesn't exist.

Alven's "electric sun" doesn't even deviate from standard theory in terms of a power source

Exactly so. So why on earth would I feel the need to refute him?

so why is that even NECESSARY from your perspective?

Because you clearly don't agree with Alfven's model.
 
FYI Zig, Birkeland DID quantify his sun in terms of terms of total energy output and in terms of relevant voltages, as did Alfven.

Alfven never thought the sun was powered by electricity, he agreed it was powered by pressure-confined thermal fusion at the core. And if Birkeland ever did quantify his model in terms of energy output, I've never seen it. But he would clearly be wrong, and I can demonstrate that easily enough if you pony up these supposed numbers of his, because nothing but fusion can explain our observations, and Birkeland didn't know about fusion. That's an entirely understandable and even unavoidable mistake at the time, but it's not a reasonable mistake to make anymore.
 
It is clear from your arguments in this thread that you overestimate your skills with math. I really do not want to be mean or insulting. I just know what physics looks like before and after gaining a genuine understanding of the math involved.

Your point is actually technically irrelevant since none of the math provided is dependent upon my personal math skills in the first place.

We're supposed to attack the argument and not the arguer at this forum. But it has become clear that your understanding of math is insufficient, and this means it has become an excercise in repetion to continue attacking the mathematically-incorrect arguments you post.

But your side has never pointed out a flaw in Alfven's double layer paper, or in that paper by Mann and Onel. You instead keep fixating (rather irrationally I might add) on the math skills of an irrelevant third party. Show me the flaw.

So in this case, I think it is more instructive to cut to the heart of the argument, which is to say that one party is lacking the skills needed to take part in the discussion in a meaningful way. Advice has been offered on how to remedy that. Beyond that, I can't help further.

You could actually "help" me by demonstrating a flaw in that paper by Mann and Onel, or Alfven's double layer paper. Short of that, you aren't 'helping' by attacking the individual in mob mentality fashion.
 
When did you provide a model for an internally powered sun?

I can't evaluate what doesn't exist.



Exactly so. So why on earth would I feel the need to refute him?



Because you clearly don't agree with Alfven's model.

Actually I don't "disagree" with it, it's just not my "preferred" solar model in terms of it's "external features'. For all I know FUSION may still be the primary source of energy from the sun.

About all you can "rule out' with the maths you provided Zig is a fully EXTERNALLY powered sun. I already agree with you on that point.
 
Alfven never thought the sun was powered by electricity, he agreed it was powered by pressure-confined thermal fusion at the core.

And AFAIK, that is the primary energy source of all suns. It COULD have a fission component as well. Either way, I'm not claiming it deviates from standard theory in terms of total energy output.

And if Birkeland ever did quantify his model in terms of energy output, I've never seen it. But he would clearly be wrong, and I can demonstrate that easily enough if you pony up these supposed numbers of his, because nothing but fusion can explain our observations, and Birkeland didn't know about fusion. That's an entirely understandable and even unavoidable mistake at the time, but it's not a reasonable mistake to make anymore.

I'll take a look after work for you. I know he came up with voltages in the 600 million volt range and did a LOT of calculations in the last half of his book. You're right in that he talked in terms of the transmutation of elements and more in terms of fission processes than fusion, at least in terms of the elements and properties (radioactivity) he mentions in his writings.
 
Short of that, you aren't 'helping' by attacking the individual in mob mentality fashion.

This is incorrect. I have looked at both sides of this argument. I agree with Clinger's analysis, because I understand the math behind it. In my opinion, if you don't agree Clinger's analysis, it's because you don't understand it, not because it is incorrect.

The burden is on you to show Clinger's analysis is incorrect by pointing out how his mathematical analysis is flawed. Your arguments against the analysis do not present mathematical reasons; they present qualitative opinions about it.
 
Actually I don't "disagree" with it, it's just not my "preferred" solar model in terms of it's "external features'. For all I know FUSION may still be the primary source of energy from the sun.

That's because you don't know much. The neutrino flux is wrong, so it cannot have a large fraction due to fission.

And you still haven't provided a model. Fusion doesn't just happen. It needs certain conditions. And the energy its producing doesn't get magically transported from the inside to the outside, it has to flow according to the laws of physics. The standard model accomplishes both providing the necessary conditions for fusion and transporting that energy to the surface of the sun. Your "model" makes no attempt to do either.

About all you can "rule out' with the maths you provided Zig is a fully EXTERNALLY powered sun. I already agree with you on that point.

Nope, I can rule out lots more than that. Including your fission-powered sun.

And AFAIK, that is the primary energy source of all suns. It COULD have a fission component as well. Either way, I'm not claiming it deviates from standard theory in terms of total energy output.

But you can't provide any other mechanism to actually produce that energy, let alone pass it through your cold iron shell.

I'll take a look after work for you. I know he came up with voltages in the 600 million volt range and did a LOT of calculations in the last half of his book.

That's far too large a voltage to be sustained for any prolonged period of time. Unlike his brass ball, plasma has no work function.

You're right in that he talked in terms of the transmutation of elements and more in terms of fission processes than fusion, at least in terms of the elements and properties (radioactivity) he mentions in his writings.

Is "more" somehow code for "exclusively"? Birkeland didn't know about fusion. Nobody at the time did.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom