Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Again with the "magnetic reconnection" in quotes as if you mean something other than, well, magnetic reconnection. There is no need to put it in quotes if you honestly mean magnetic reconnection. Tthe nonsense continues to be deliberately just yours.

Your fixation on quotes is nonsense. There is a physical difference between an electrical discharge process in plasma and "B LINES BEGINNING" in a NULL in a vacuum. Get real.

So you don't mean magnetic reconnection (the reconnection of magnetic field lines) when you assert "I never did claim that "magnetic reconnection" requires monopoles!". Evidently you do assert magnetic reconnection requires " actual MONOPOLES".

No. I've said very clearly to you at least twice now that monopoles would be required for B lines to 'begin' and/or 'end' at some point rather than form continuous loops.

Does this "magnetic reconnection process" you refer to that "REQUIRES plasma" involve the reconnection of magnetic field lines?

That depends on what *EXACTLY* you are calling a 'field line'? Does this LINE include or exclude *PLASMA*?

Why do you feel you have to so dishonestly represent your own "actual claim"?

Do you ACTUALLY believe that's even a rational question?

You evidently feel this is some clever word play on your part but it is vapid and transparent simply demonstrating your continuing dishonesty.

The DISHONEST BEHAVIOR directly relates to your fixation on persons and HONESTY rather than PHYSICS. At the level of PHYSICS Clinger's claim about B lines 'beginning" somewhere would require a MONOPOLE. Are you HONESTLY going to address that point? Yes or no? Stop dodging.
 
Last edited:
BZZZZZZZZZT! Priest's math's are based on movements of plasma in the photosphere and MHD theory!
BZZZZZZZZZT! This is nothing to do with his math. Learn to rerad MM.

Magnetic reconnection on the sun, Priest 1990
"In a vacuum, reconnection is a trivlal process..." and goes onto the non-trrivial MR in plasma.

He does not say the MR is impossible in a vacuum (your assertion).
He states that MR in a vacuum is a trival process (i.e. it happens!).
 
:id:

Ya know....

I've seen ridiculous arguments before, but your argument simply takes the cake. It's not a "scientific" argument at all. It's not based on mathematics. It's not based on physics. It's evidently based *ENTIRELY* on the symbols 0->00 which you personally evidently equate with "B LINE reconnection".

Wow! Talk about totally "WRONG"!

You don't like my analogy. Well, then it should be quite simple for you to show us how the topology of the magnetic lines when the magnets are in series can become the topology of the lines when the magnets are separated without breaking and reconnecting. Give us a topological lesson and show us how this can happen.
Remember: Some of us have studied topology.
 
What a stupid link:

That was an absolutely stupid response because evidently you don't like dealing with REALITY. In OUR UNIVERSE, not one involving MONOPOLES, B lines DO NOT under any circumstances, BEGIN, END, have a SOURCE or a SINK! They form as continuous loops EVERYWHERE they go. Some places they do not go. That does not mean that the places they do NOT go are the BEGINNINGS or the ENDINGS of any B lines!
 
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection

The Man dies not have to deal with your ignorance and delusions about W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection .


The Man can probably understand the precise definition of a field line includes that:
  • It does not exist where there is no vector field.
  • Where the vector field magntitude is zero, the density of fleld lines is zero.
At a null point the magnetic field does not exist (B=0). Thus there can be no field line thre because
  • There is no field there.
  • The density of field lines there is zero.
This does not violate Gauss's law for magnetism because there are no sources or sinks of magnetic field.
 
You don't like my analogy. Well, then it should be quite simple for you to show us how the topology of the magnetic lines when the magnets are in series can become the topology of the lines when the magnets are separated without breaking and reconnecting. Give us a topological lesson and show us how this can happen.
Remember: Some of us have studied topology.

I have a hard time even relating to discrete LINES as you imagine them to be in your little 2D world. In my FIELD orientation, it's a TOPOLOGY that relates to ENTIRE FIELDS, not to individual LINES. Do you understand that field concept?
 
BZZZZZZZZZT! This is nothing to do with his math. Learn to rerad MM.

Magnetic reconnection on the sun, Priest 1990
"In a vacuum, reconnection is a trivlal process..." and goes onto the non-trrivial MR in plasma.

He does not say the MR is impossible in a vacuum (your assertion).
He states that MR in a vacuum is a trival process (i.e. it happens!).

Of course it's "trivial" when one's "vacuum" is actually a corona *WITH* plasma columns rising out of the photosphere and MHD theory is used!
 
All those thousands of papers and references demonstrate is that PLASMA IS NOT OPTIONAL in the 'reconnection' process RC.

Magnetic lines form as full continuous loops, without a beginning, without a ending, without the ability to DISCONNECT from, nor reconnect to any other magnetic line.

Magnetic reconnection is an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE PROCESS IN PLASMA. Plasma is not OPTIONAL in the ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE PROCESS called "magnetic reconnection".
 
Of course it's "trivial" when one's "vacuum" is actually a corona *WITH* plasma columns rising out of the photosphere and MHD theory is used!
Another delusion, Michael Mozina?

Magnetic reconnection on the sun, Priest 1990
"In a vacuum, reconnection is a trivlal process..." and goes onto the non-trivial MR in plasma, i.e the solar atmosphere.

So you are now claiming that
  • vacuum is a plasma and
  • MR in a vacuum (in your head this means plasma) is a trivial process :jaw-dropp.
Anton who can read English knows that vacuum is not plasma.
Anyone who has read about MR in plasma knows that it is an incredibly complex process.
 
His movies were based on movements in a PHOTOSPHERE, they involved PLASMA, and MHD theory. Clinger *INTENTIONALLY* left out the HYDRO part of MagnetoHydroDynamic theory. He therefore cannot benefit from Priest's computer models that are based on MHD theory.
 
Last edited:
I have a hard time even relating to discrete LINES as you imagine them to be in your little 2D world. In my FIELD orientation, it's a TOPOLOGY that relates to ENTIRE FIELDS, not to individual LINES. Do you understand that field concept?

Obviously, better than you do. Yes, magnetic fields have a three dimensional topology. So, the same question applies: Then it should be quite simple for you to show us how the topology of the magnetic field when the magnets are in series can become the topology of the two fields when the magnets are separated without breaking and reconnecting. Give us a topological lesson and show us how this can happen.
Just imagine that O→00 are the outlines of three dimensional objects.
Remember: Some of us have studied topology -- the number of dimensions is not an issue.
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina;782...8596 said:
All those thousands of papers and references demonstrate is... .
All that post demonstrates is your inability to read and the delusion that vacuum is plasma.

MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III includes MR in vacuum but then we have:

Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI

And a possible new delusion that MR in a plasma is a trivial process (where in your head plasma = vacuum)
Magnetic reconnection on the sun, Priest 1990
"In a vacuum, reconnection is a trivlal process..." and goes onto the non-trrivial MR in plasma.
 
All you're doing RC is adding things to your own personal "denial-go-round". Deny that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares all you like, but you can't change the fact that Dungey called it an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE. Deny the fact that B lines *DO NOT* begin or end all you like, but they do not. Deny the fact that plasma is not optional in the ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE PROCESS known as 'magnetic reconnection', but it's not optional. Deny the fact that "currents" are non-neutral plasmas if you like, but those currents are plasmas. Your denial-go-round is getting pretty full these days.
 
No. What is your problem? Even when I TOOK BACK my statement about them "crossing", you're still whipping a dead horse!

Then chose to just make a "JOKE" of you taking back your "statement about them "crossing"", prop up your dead horse again and I'll whip it again.



No. Why would it require monopoles? All that discharges process in plasma requires is *PLASMA*!

Magnetic reconnection doesn't require monopoles or plasma, just the reconnection of magnetic field lines.


I know EXACTLY what *I* mean by the term, but I have no idea what CLINGER means by that term. Plasma isn't OPTIONAL in "magnetic reconnection".

Magnetic reconnection means the reconnection of magnetic field lines as you have been informed many times. Whatever you mean by "magnetic reconnection" if it doesn't involve the reconnection of magnetic field lines then it isn't magnetic reconnection.


You can't have a conversation that isn't BLATANTLY fixated BASHING PEOPLE, can you? The only BLATANTLY DISHONEST BEHAVIOR IS YOUR AVOIDANCE OF CLINGER'S CLAIMS ABOUT B LINES BEGINNING SOMEWHERE!

You can't have a conversation without blatantly misrepresenting positions, including and primarily your own.



Helping me by accusing me falsely EVEN AFTER I took back my statement? How are you HELPING?

The assertion that you were attempting to ascribe your own claim to "W.D.Clinger" wasn't false (even after you took it back for 4 minutes). You still evidently fail to see that. That you finally retracted it, even just to make a joke of your retraction, at all shows I have helped you, no need to thank me.




No lines BEGIN there. No lines END there. No LINES necessarily even PASS THROUGH that location!



The last one.


See that, I even got you to finally go with a singular assertion, more help will follow at a later time.
 
Obviously, better than you do. Yes, magnetic fields have a three dimensional topology. So, the same question applies: Then it should be quite simple for you to show us how the topology of the magnetic field when the magnets are in series can become the topology of the two fields when the magnets are separated without breaking and reconnecting. Give us a topological lesson and show us how this can happen.
Just imagine that O→00 are the outlines of three dimensional objects.
Remember: Some of us have studied topology -- the number of dimensions is not an issue.

Start with just ONE field for moment. What's going to happen to that ONE field when we CHANGE the current in one of the rods? Will the TOPOLOGY change accordingly?
 
Magnetic reconnection doesn't require monopoles or plasma, just the reconnection of magnetic field lines.

Nope. You'll need "plasma" to get "magnetic reconnection" (the process), and you'll need a monopole to get a B line to "begin" at Origin the DUD!

See that, I even got you to finally go with a singular assertion, more help will follow at a later time.

It seems to me that you need to help yourself now. You just made a "claim" that you cannot support, namely the first one I listed. Magnetic reconnection (the electrical discharge process described by Dungey) isn't a "plasma optional" process. It never will be a PLASMA OPTIONAL process either.

B LINES do not "begin" anywhere without a monopole and Gauss's laws are satisfied *EVERYWHERE*.
 
Last edited:
I've seen ridiculous arguments before, but your argument simply takes the cake. It's not a "scientific" argument at all. It's not based on mathematics. It's not based on physics. It's evidently based *ENTIRELY* on the symbols 0->00 which you personally evidently equate with "B LINE reconnection".


It's a scientific argument whittled down to such a simple level it doesn't require words or numbers. It's an illustration of the physics of magnetic reconnection using the mathematical concept of topology. The O's and 0's are just symbols, not letters or numbers. Although it would be a bit more difficult to visualize the topological equivalence, the symbols could just as easily be lengths of garden hose or skeleton keys.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom