Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Start with just ONE field for moment. What's going to happen to that ONE field when we CHANGE the current in one of the rods? Will the TOPOLOGY change accordingly?

Why are you changing the subject? I have been discussing two bar magnets, where there are no currents.
Again:
Then it should be quite simple for you to show us how the topology of the magnetic field when the magnets are in series can become the topology of the two fields when the magnets are separated without breaking and reconnecting. Give us a topological lesson and show us how this can happen.
Just imagine that O→00 are the outlines of three dimensional objects.
(I have studied topology and will do my best to follow your argument.)
 
Give us a topological lesson and show us how this can happen.
Just imagine that O→00 are the outlines of three dimensional objects.
(I have studied topology and will do my best to follow your argument.)

Ok, if you'll give me three dimensions to work with, I think I can help you. The first O is actually TWO O's, one right BEHIND the other. Over time, the TWO circles move, and then they look like ->OO. Does that work for you? If not, why not?
 
Ok, if you'll give me three dimensions to work with, I think I can help you. The first O is actually TWO O's, one right BEHIND the other. Over time, the TWO circles move, and then they look like ->OO. Does that work for you? If not, why not?

Two Os -- one behind the other? Are you kidding?
OK, let's take a single bar magnet. It has one magnetic field that surrounds it in the familiar way we all have seen and understand. Let the analogy for that be our three dimensional O. (there are not two Os)
Now we get a hacksaw and cut it in half creating two smaller bar magnets. When we separate them so their magnetic fields are distinct we have our 00. How could we have gotten from O to 00 without the magnetic fields and their B lines breaking and reconnecting? This is a straightforward topological question!
 
Oh, I *think* I get what Mozina is trying to say.

Suppose we have two hula-hoops laying on the floor some distance apart. From our view standing up it would look like O O.

Next we push them closer together: OO

We keep pushing them. Using a clock reference (total amateur here), they first touch each other at 3:00 and 9:00. As we push them together, they deform such they are touching at 2:00<->10:00 and 4:00<->8:00.

At some point the hoops snap back into the normal shapes with one on top of the other such that it looks like a single hoop when it is in fact one on top of the other. Neither hoop actually broke. The two just kind of merged together for a bit.

Of course, this description (if you can follow it - it is very clear to me, but I wrote it) does not address the fact that the hoops are still touching at 3:00 and 9:00 as they are pushed together. The animations I see show lines that only touch at certain points, appearing to break and reconnect.

Is that right, Mozina?
 
[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/figure1zoom.png[/qimg]

I'll play your games:

It sure *LOOKS* like they CROSS. :)

Yes, they "cross" but only because in the middle the magnetic field is ZERO, so there is not magnitude and no direction of the field in the X-point.

And indeed there is no source or sink at the X-point, because there are two field lines that end there and two field lines that begin there, and thus Gauss' Law is satisfied, because equal amount of field lines enter and exit the region around the X-point.
 
Last edited:
BZZZZZZZZZZZZZT! Somov's experiment *INCLUDES* non-neutral plasmas!

BZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT NONE of Somov's experiments include non-neutral plasmas.

Basically, MM does not understand what non-neutral plasmas are.

Let's go through this yet again.

The charge density of a plasma is given by the total sum of all available charges:

[latex]\rho = \Sigma_i n_i q_i [/latex]

where i is the species of the plasma, so electrons and all available ions, n is the density of that species and q is the charge of that species. In all natural plasmas there is "quasi neutralily" which means that over "large" volumes, greater than the Debye sphere, the total charge density is zero, on smaller scales there can be slight variations, and in special cases like double layers.

The current in a plasma is given by the total sum of all moving charges:

[latex]{\bf j} = \Sigma_i n_i q_i {\bf v}_i [/latex]

where v is the velocity of the species that is looked at.

Note that the first equation, giving the charge, when set to zero (and for simplicity assuming only protons and electrons) is says that the number of protons is equal to the number of electrons in a unit volume. However, these may just have different bulk velocities, that just have to satisfy that:

[latex]{\rm div}(\rho_i {\bf v}_i}) = 0 [/latex]

meaning that there is no building up of density or charge in the volume.

So, it is a mystery why MM keeps on insisting that a plasma with a current is "non-neutral." Of course, that could lie in the fact that MM "does not adhere to the correct physical terminology" (as stated 2 pages ago) and in the Moziverse "non-neutral" means that there cannot be an EMF working on the plasma, driving the current. Naturally, that is silly, because his beloved induction works on the whole loop that he looks at and drives the current not through any charge separation but through ... wel induction.
 
Two Os -- one behind the other? Are you kidding?
OK, let's take a single bar magnet. It has one magnetic field that surrounds it in the familiar way we all have seen and understand. Let the analogy for that be our three dimensional O. (there are not two Os)
Now we get a hacksaw and cut it in half creating two smaller bar magnets. When we separate them so their magnetic fields are distinct we have our 00. How could we have gotten from O to 00 without the magnetic fields and their B lines breaking and reconnecting? This is a straightforward topological question!

At least GBT is *TRYING* to communicate. :) I really didn't think it would matter to you, but I was curious how you would respond. :)

If you cut the magnet in half, you simply have two MAGNETS and B lines from each part of the magnet! The H lines will "disconnect" of course.
 
Oh, I *think* I get what Mozina is trying to say.

Suppose we have two hula-hoops laying on the floor some distance apart. From our view standing up it would look like O O.

Next we push them closer together: OO

We keep pushing them. Using a clock reference (total amateur here), they first touch each other at 3:00 and 9:00. As we push them together, they deform such they are touching at 2:00<->10:00 and 4:00<->8:00.

At some point the hoops snap back into the normal shapes with one on top of the other such that it looks like a single hoop when it is in fact one on top of the other. Neither hoop actually broke. The two just kind of merged together for a bit.

Of course, this description (if you can follow it - it is very clear to me, but I wrote it) does not address the fact that the hoops are still touching at 3:00 and 9:00 as they are pushed together. The animations I see show lines that only touch at certain points, appearing to break and reconnect.

Is that right, Mozina?

Yes. Thanks and welcome to the conversation. At least I know SOMEONE is actually TRYING to communicate. :)
 
http://www.answers.com/topic/magnetic-monopole



In this universe, it works like figure a), not figure b). Deal with it!

[qimg]http://content.answcdn.com/main/content/img/McGrawHill/Encyclopedia/images/CE397800FG0010.gif[/qimg]

You have failed again. Div B = 0 means there is no source or sink. It means the sum of lines going in equals the sum of lines going out, which is the case in clinger's diagram. 2 lines go in, 2 go out.
 
You have failed again. Div B = 0 means there is no source or sink. It means the sum of lines going in equals the sum of lines going out, which is the case in clinger's diagram. 2 lines go in, 2 go out.

If I've failed to reach you, it's not my fault. I've provided you with over a dozen published curriculum textbooks that all clearly explain that all magnetic B lines form as FULL LOOPS, without a "beginning" or an "end". Literally NOTHING begins in origin the dud, in fact nothing NECESSARILY needs to traverse the NULL in the first place. All loops are continuous. All points satisfy Gauss's law. Nothing is SPECIAL about Origin the NULL. No lines begin there or anywhere else. No lines end there or anywhere else.
 
You do know that magnetic field lines don't actually exist, they are simply visualization tools, right?
 
I have a hard time even relating to discrete LINES as you imagine them to be in your little 2D world. In my FIELD orientation, it's a TOPOLOGY that relates to ENTIRE FIELDS, not to individual LINES. Do you understand that field concept?

If you understood the topology of the magnetic field in Clinger's example, you would know that reconnection is necessary to go from once configuration to the other.
 
If I've failed to reach you, it's not my fault. I've provided you with over a dozen published curriculum textbooks that all clearly explain that all magnetic B lines form as FULL LOOPS, without a "beginning" or an "end". Literally NOTHING begins in origin the dud, in fact nothing NECESSARILY needs to traverse the NULL in the first place. All loops are continuous. All points satisfy Gauss's law. Nothing is SPECIAL about Origin the NULL. No lines begin there or anywhere else. No lines end there or anywhere else.

And when 2 loops share a point, they can swap connections without ever having a beginning or end. Reconnection does not require disconnection, beginnings, or endings. It only requires the 2 fields to share a common topology at a shared point.
 
If you understood the topology of the magnetic field in Clinger's example, you would know that reconnection is necessary to go from once configuration to the other.

Clinger's example is KLUDGED! Nothing even needs to go THROUGH that NULL point in the first place, let alone "begin" there.

http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/...-maxwells-equations/MIT8_02SC_notes26to30.pdf

This implies that the number of magnetic field lines entering a closed surface is equal to the number of field lines leaving the surface. That is, there is no source or sink. In addition, the lines must be continuous with no starting or end points. In fact, as shown in Figure 13.2.1(b) for a bar magnet, the field lines that emanate from the north pole to the south pole outside the magnet return within the magnet and form a closed loop.
 
Lets go through again that according to his description, CURRENTS exist in SOMOV's experiment. Nobody here doubts that CURRENTS can "reconnect". ;)

And clearly this went well over your head again.
Not even a single word about the how and why of your "non-neutral" plasmas.
And in the chapter about vacuum reconnection, there is no mention whatsoever about plasmas. There are currents, which can only be currents in wires, otherwise on cannot have a vacuum.
 
Last edited:
And when 2 loops share a point,

We don't actually KNOW that they "share a point" in the first place since technically speaking LINES CANNOT CROSS.

they can swap connections without ever having a beginning or end.

Tell it to Clinger:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7739880&postcount=4661

Myth 3: Magnetic field lines can neither begin nor end

In my two colored graphs of the magnetic field around four conducting rods, there are two magnetic field lines that begin at the neutral point and two other magnetic field lines that end at the neutral point.
 
Last edited:
And clearly this went well over your head again.
Not even a single word about the how and why of your "non-neutral" plasmas.

You evidently missed a whole conversation I had with PS about non-neutral plasmas.

And in the chapter about vacuum reconnection, there is no mention whatsoever about plasmas. There are currents, which can only be currents in wires, otherwise on cannot have a vacuum.

It DOES NOT say anything about 'wires'. Again, you're just making that up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom