Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
figure1zoom.png


I'll play your games:

It sure *LOOKS* like they CROSS.


It's not really a game. It's a graphic which pretty clearly illustrates the results of W.D.Clinger's demonstration that the magnetic field lines end at the origin. Also, a thorough and objective analysis of the graphic indicates that they don't cross.
 
http://www.answers.com/topic/magnetic-monopole

Magnetically charged particles. Such particles are predicted by various physical theories, but so far all experimental searches have failed to demonstrate their existence.

The fundamental laws governing electricity and magnetism become symmetric if particles exist that carry magnetic charge. Current understanding of electromagnetic physical phenomena is based on the existence of electric monopoles, which are sources or sinks of electric field lines (illus. a), and which when set into motion generate magnetic fields. The magnetic field lines produced by such a current have no beginning or end and form closed loops. All magnetic fields occurring in nature can be explained as arising from currents.

In this universe, it works like figure a), not figure b). Deal with it!

CE397800FG0010.gif
 
The crossing line thing? I don't CARE! It's not an ISSUE except to you personally. If it makes you feel better, I retract that ONE statement. Are you happy yet? Are you going to provide EXTERNAL PUBLISHED references to support Clinger's claim that B lines "begin" anywhere?


How truly sad it is that your dishonest representation of the claims of others is not an " ISSUE" "to you personally".

"Are you going to provide EXTERNAL PUBLISHED references to support" your self-contradicting claims?


They simply pass through the NULL with a zero field strength.


...NO lines reach X to begin with, the PRESSURE keeps them from actually crossing.


I can't believe how pitifully fixated you are on trivial issues while UTTERLY avoiding the "big issue". Unless one of you have a monopole in your pocket, B lines CANNOT begin or end!

I can believe that you still don't understand or simply don't want to accept that it is only you that claims reconnection requires a monopole, but hey, kick yourself while you're down as many times as you want. All we can do is try to help you to help yourself, if you'd rather just beat on yourself that's your choice.



[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/figure1zoom.png[/qimg]

I'll play your games:

It sure *LOOKS* like they CROSS. :)

"*LOOKS*" more like your purported retraction didn't last very long at all, though I doubt anyone expected you to be honest about it.

Nope, not my game, when you finally decide to stop just playing with yourself, you be sure to let us know.
 
How truly sad it is that your dishonest representation of the claims of others is not an " ISSUE" "to you personally".

How truly sad you're fixated on something I already "took back", but you refuse to address the actual issue:

I can believe that you still don't understand or simply don't want to accept that it is only you that claims reconnection requires a monopole, but hey, kick yourself while you're down as many times as you want.

Hey, lie about it all you want too. That's not what I said. I said "magnetic reconnection" requires plasma, and B LINES cannot "begin" or "end" without monopoles.

How about YOUR honesty now? When did you intend to deal with that BOGUS claim about B lines "beginning" somewhere? Is it HONEST of you to AVOID that issue in post after post?
 
Last edited:
My dogma? Absolutely not. I presented PUBLISHED REFERENCES to support my statements. You folks did not. See the distinction?

So now you don't require monoples for reconnections? Cancepts are flasafiable dagma isn't. "See the distinction?"

Where have you supported these statements with "PUBLISHED REFERENCES"?


They simply pass through the NULL with a zero field strength.


...NO lines reach X to begin with, the PRESSURE keeps them from actually crossing.



Technically we don't know "God didn't do it" either. So what? We don't know MAGIC doesn't exist either for that matter. Unicorns?

Do you claim they are required for magnetic reconection as well (that wouldn't suprise me)?


BZZT. I asserted (AS MANY REFERENCES ALSO ASSERTED) that B lines cannot "begin" or "end" without monopoles. I further asserted that "reconnection" is a PROCESS involving PLASMA as those 1000's of references demonstrate.

How HONEST are you being when you fail to acknowledge my actual claim, and you build your own strawman?

So now you do not require monopoles for magnetic reconnection? You can acknowledge your own "actual claim" can't you? I doubt it, because on the one hand you monopole strawman becomes moot and on the other the assertion that your claim is being misrepresented becomes patently false.
 
Clinger's KLUDGE

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7739880&postcount=4661

Myth 3: Magnetic field lines can neither begin nor end In my two colored graphs of the magnetic field around four conducting rods, there are two magnetic field lines that begin at the neutral point and two other magnetic field lines that end at the neutral point.
....
The idea that Gauss's law prevents magnetic field lines from beginning or ending is a fairy tale. Gauss's law doesn't really talk about magnetic field lines at all. Gauss's law is really about certain integrals and limits.

How about those claims The Man? Do you intend to deal with them HONESTLY?
 
Last edited:
So now you do not require monopoles for magnetic reconnection?

I never did claim that "magnetic reconnection" requires monopoles! That was RC's nonsense, not mine. I have said repeatedly that the magnetic reconnection process REQUIRES plasma. B line "beginnings' and "endings' however require actual MONOPOLES.
 
Last edited:
How truly sad you're fixated on something I already "took back", but you refuse to address the actual issue:

"took back", for a whole 4 minutes, wow.


Hey, lie about it all you want too. That's not what I said. I said "magnetic reconnection" requires plasma, and B LINES cannot "begin" or "end" without monopoles.


So you are claiming that magnetic reconnection does not require monopoles? Why type "magnetic reconnection" as if you mean something other than, well, magnetic reconnection? You still can't get away from that whole blatantly dishonest approach to a conversation can you?

How about YOUR honesty now? When did you intend to deal with that BOGUS claim about B lines "beginning" somewhere? Is it HONEST of you to AVOID that issue in post after post?

My "honesty now?" same as before, I'm still honestly trying to help you and there is very little, if anything, you can do that would change that.

Terminate would probably be a better word as some lines begin and others end at the null point.

Well again which claim are you going with now...


They simply pass through the NULL with a zero field strength.


...NO lines reach X to begin with, the PRESSURE keeps them from actually crossing.


The former is basically what you wanted to ascribe to W.D.Clinger and probably why you misinterpreted the diagram. The latter simply asserts multiple null points or a null region and any field lines entering or leaving that region must terminate in that region. The problem still is Michael Mozina that you just don't understand vectors and more specifically vector fields and it doesn't seem that you really want to.
 
"took back", for a whole 4 minutes, wow.

No. What is your problem? Even when I TOOK BACK my statement about them "crossing", you're still whipping a dead horse!

So you are claiming that magnetic reconnection does not require monopoles?

No. Why would it require monopoles? All that discharges process in plasma requires is *PLASMA*!

Why type "magnetic reconnection" as if you mean something other than, well, magnetic reconnection?

I know EXACTLY what *I* mean by the term, but I have no idea what CLINGER means by that term. Plasma isn't OPTIONAL in "magnetic reconnection".

You still can't get away from that whole blatantly dishonest approach to a conversation can you?

You can't have a conversation that isn't BLATANTLY fixated BASHING PEOPLE, can you? The only BLATANTLY DISHONEST BEHAVIOR IS YOUR AVOIDANCE OF CLINGER'S CLAIMS ABOUT B LINES BEGINNING SOMEWHERE!


My "honesty now?" same as before, I'm still honestly trying to help you and there is very little, if anything, you can do that would change that.

Helping me by accusing me falsely EVEN AFTER I took back my statement? How are you HELPING?

Terminate would probably be a better word as some lines begin and others end at the null point.

No lines BEGIN there. No lines END there. No LINES necessarily even PASS THROUGH that location!

Well again which claim are you going with now...

The last one.
 
My point has been that the magnetic field surrounding two magnets in series and the resulting fields when the magnets are totally separated is analogous to
O→00.
This is a simple topological analogy. One cannot deform O by twisting and stretching to create 00 without breaking and reconnecting the lines, just as one cannot deform (by twisting and stretching) the magnetic lines when the magnets are in series to become the fields when the magnets are separated without breaking and reconnecting. It's simple and it's obvious.
At this point, I really can't tell if Mozina does not have the intellectual capacity to understand this simple analogy, or if it's the working of some kind of EU dogmatic mental paralysis or -- if he is so invested in his position here that he is unwilling to admit he is wrong -- even though he knows he is obviously, transparently, unreservedly, totally WRONG!
 
Micheal Mozina you require actual MONOPOLES for MR.

I never did claim that "magnetic reconnection" requires monopoles! That was RC's nonsense, not mine. I have said repeatedly that the magnetic reconnection process REQUIRES plasma. B line "beginnings' and "endings' however require actual MONOPOLES.
My statement was that your "B line "beginnings' and "endings' however require actual MONOPOLES" assertion was wrong.
Since B lines actually begin and end this means that you require actual MONOPOLES.
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II

ALso MR is the breaking and reconnection of B field lines (MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III).
Thus once again you require actual MONOPOLES.

Luckily actual scientists know that B lines actually begin and end without monopoles: MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III .

You are wrong: MR happens without plasma
 
My point has been that the magnetic field surrounding two magnets in series and the resulting fields when the magnets are totally separated is analogous to
O→00.
This is a simple topological analogy. One cannot deform O by twisting and stretching to create 00 without breaking and reconnecting the lines, just as one cannot deform (by twisting and stretching) the magnetic lines when the magnets are in series to become the fields when the magnets are separated without breaking and reconnecting. It's simple and it's obvious.
At this point, I really can't tell if Mozina does not have the intellectual capacity to understand this simple analogy, or if it's the working of some kind of EU dogmatic mental paralysis or -- if he is so invested in his position here that he is unwilling to admit he is wrong -- even though he knows he is obviously, transparently, unreservedly, totally WRONG!

:id:

Ya know....

I've seen ridiculous arguments before, but your argument simply takes the cake. It's not a "scientific" argument at all. It's not based on mathematics. It's not based on physics. It's evidently based *ENTIRELY* on the symbols 0->00 which you personally evidently equate with "B LINE reconnection".

Wow! Talk about totally "WRONG"!
 
I never did claim that "magnetic reconnection" requires monopoles! That was RC's nonsense, not mine.

Again with the "magnetic reconnection" in quotes as if you mean something other than, well, magnetic reconnection. There is no need to put it in quotes if you honestly mean magnetic reconnection. Tthe nonsense continues to be deliberately just yours.

I have said repeatedly that the magnetic reconnection process REQUIRES plasma. B line "beginnings' and "endings' however require actual MONOPOLES.

So you don't mean magnetic reconnection (the reconnection of magnetic field lines) when you assert "I never did claim that "magnetic reconnection" requires monopoles!". Evidently you do assert magnetic reconnection requires " actual MONOPOLES".

Does this "magnetic reconnection process" you refer to that "REQUIRES plasma" involve the reconnection of magnetic field lines? If not then your are still deliberately not talking about magnetic reconnection.


Why do you feel you have to so dishonestly represent your own "actual claim"?


You evidently feel this is some clever word play on your part but it is vapid and transparent simply demonstrating your continuing dishonesty.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom