Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
http://www.answers.com/topic/magnetic-monopole
Magnetically charged particles. Such particles are predicted by various physical theories, but so far all experimental searches have failed to demonstrate their existence.

The fundamental laws governing electricity and magnetism become symmetric if particles exist that carry magnetic charge. Current understanding of electromagnetic physical phenomena is based on the existence of electric monopoles, which are sources or sinks of electric field lines (illus. a), and which when set into motion generate magnetic fields. The magnetic field lines produced by such a current have no beginning or end and form closed loops. All magnetic fields occurring in nature can be explained as arising from currents.
 
That's not how topology works. It's pretty simple math stuff. But just taking wild uninformed guesses is likely to result in an incorrect answer. As it has above. In spades.

Wild uniformed guesses are for those who don't actually own, nor have read any books on plasma physics.
 
CE397800FG0010.gif


Only in MYTHICAL MONOPOLE world (b) would any B lines "begin" anywhere. In our universe (a), nothing like that can happen. :)
 
I "think" that PS is willing to admit that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares, but are any of the other three hard core haters ready to come out of the (electrical) closet yet?
 
Wild uniformed guesses are for those who don't actually own, nor have read any books on plasma physics.


Perpetual Student's simple topology question is about math. Topology. Math. He has demonstrated that the topology of the magnetic fields requires reconnection to occur.

Either accept that magnetic lines break and reconnect or show us all how O → 00 without lines breaking and reconnecting.


This is an incorrect answer...

All one would have to do is draw TWO LOOPS in the second image, one that CHANGES TOPOLOGY (doesn't disconnect, just shrinks/stretches) and a NEW ONE on the second magnet that weaker and wasn't shown in the first image. It's simply gotten STRONGER since the first image, so it's shown in the second image!


So terribly incorrect it arguably couldn't even be considered a rational response to the question.
 
Nothing "requires" there to "magnetic B *LINE* reconnection" in a couple of O's. Get real. Haters are just bizarre in terms of what they think a "scientific argument" is supposed to look like.

"Here's a couple of 0's. O->00. How is that "NOT" magnetic B line reconnection? Stop avoiding the questions!"

Oy Vey!
 
So terribly incorrect it arguably couldn't even be considered a rational response to the question.

No Clinger's Kludged part 3 was so terribly incorrect as it relates to the "beginnings" of B lines, it can't even be considered a rational argument. Gauss's laws are satisfied *EVERYWHERE*, including Origin the DUD, but NO POINT is a "beginning" of a B line, because B lines do not have beginnings or endings. They only form in CONTINUOUS LOOPS, actually ENTIRE CONTINUOUS FIELDS.
 
Last edited:
Nothing "requires" there to "magnetic B *LINE* reconnection" in a couple of O's. Get real. Haters are just bizarre in terms of what they think a "scientific argument" is supposed to look like.

"Here's a couple of 0's. O->00. How is that "NOT" magnetic B line reconnection? Stop avoiding the questions!"

Oy Vey!


It's about math. Perpetual Student's use of the O's and 0's was like a trick question, a sort of secret code only math savvy people would understand. :D
 
The following post and quote will hereby be referred to as 'Clinger's KLUDGE of EM theory':

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7739880&postcount=4661

Myth 3: Magnetic field lines can neither begin nor end

In my two colored graphs of the magnetic field around four conducting rods, there are two magnetic field lines that begin at the neutral point and two other magnetic field lines that end at the neutral point.

The magnetic field line that runs from the northeast toward the neutral point is decreasing in intensity as it approaches the neutral point, and ends completely at that neutral point. The same is true of the magnetic field line that runs from the southwest toward the neutral point.

The magnetic field line that runs from the neutral point toward the northwest begins at the neutral point. The same is true of the magnetic field line that runs from the neutral point toward the southeast.

Do these magnetic field lines violate Gauss's law for magnetism? Not at all!

I have already sketched a geometric proof that Gauss's law holds for the magnetic field generated by a single current-carrying rod. That result is confirmed by starting from its equation and calculating the divergence. By linearity, Gauss's law must therefore hold for the magnetic field around four such rods. That result can also be confirmed by starting from the equation for B4 and calculating its divergence.

The idea that Gauss's law prevents magnetic field lines from beginning or ending is a fairy tale. Gauss's law doesn't really talk about magnetic field lines at all. Gauss's law is really about certain integrals and limits.

Gauss's law for magnetism says the magnetic flux through any smooth closed surface is zero. That's true at the neutral point: Intuitively speaking, the two lines that end there are offset by the two lines that begin there.

(Those four lines have measure zero anyway, but those who know what that means will be able to confirm Gauss's law for themselves. Throughout this derivation, I've been trying to limit myself to math that sophomore physics majors should understand.)

In the real world of actually PHYSICS (not Clinger's fantasy world), B lines do not have beginnings or endings. They form closed loops.

http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/...-maxwells-equations/MIT8_02SC_notes26to30.pdf

This implies that the number of magnetic field lines entering a closed surface is equal to the number of field lines leaving the surface. That is, there is no source or sink. In addition, the lines must be continuous with no starting or end points. In fact, as shown in Figure 13.2.1(b) for a bar magnet, the field lines that emanate from the north pole to the south pole outside the magnet return within the magnet and form a closed loop.
 
Huh? HE DREW THE LINES COMING TO A POINT, NOT ME! He also claimed that lines BEGIN there, not me!

So now you admit he did not make the claim you want to attribute to him.

...*CLINGER'S* (not my) claim that all lines CROSS in the middle...


Your honesty is improving a bit.


So " HE DREW THE LINES COMING TO A POINT, NOT ME! He also claimed that lines BEGIN there" but he did not calim as you falsely asserted before that they "CROSS in the middle". You however did assert of those lines that

They simply pass through the NULL with a zero field strength.

Are you starting to see where your problem of misunderstanding and attributing to others claims they did not make originates?


I'd recommend you quit DISHONESTLY trying to shift the burden of proof. I'm not leaning on him to prove lines CROSS, I'm leaning on him to prove lines *BEGIN*. That was the CLAIM that I balked at!

Recommend whatever you want and I don't care what you're "leaning on him" for. Until you start approaching this conversation honestly your attempts to shift your own nonsensical claims to others will end poorly for you.

Where's the PUBLISHED EVIDENCE? QUIT DISHONESTLY dodging THE ISSUE! I didn't ask him to prove ANYTHING about them CROSSING. I asked him to demonstrate they have a BEGINNING!

No you didn't ask him to "prove ANYTHING about them CROSSING" and I don't recall anyone claiming that you did (more simple dishonesty on your part). However, you did certainly and falsely assert that he claimed those "lines CROSS in the middle" "QUIT DISHONESTLY dodging" by trying to ascribe your own nonsensical claims to others. I've asked you to demonstrate your self-contradicting claims that

They simply pass through the NULL with a zero field strength.


...NO lines reach X to begin with, the PRESSURE keeps them from actually crossing.


How's that coming.
 
So now you admit he did not make the claim you want to attribute to him.

The crossing line thing? I don't CARE! It's not an ISSUE except to you personally. If it makes you feel better, I retract that ONE statement. Are you happy yet? Are you going to provide EXTERNAL PUBLISHED references to support Clinger's claim that B lines "begin" anywhere?

I can't believe how pitifully fixated you are on trivial issues while UTTERLY avoiding the "big issue". Unless one of you have a monopole in your pocket, B lines CANNOT begin or end!
 
That's what really sucks about this "handwaving" BS in the first place. I had to sit through 11 months of verbal abuse before he presented a damn thing. His diagrams were KLUDGED from the start in terms of showing the lines CROSSING at the X, and his explanation was KLUDGED TO THE MAX when he claimed that B lines "begin" or "end" anywhere! I didn't even get a FULL PRESENTATION to look at, I got it in partial 'installments'. Worse yet, each installment from part three forward was FUBAR in terms of basic EM theory and KLUDGED line diagrams!
 
Last edited:
It evidently means that you folks have NOTHING. :)


Actually it means the topology of W.D.Clinger's explanation of magnetic reconnection is trivially demonstrable using mathematical concepts I was first exposed to in 4th grade. Now I'll admit I was in some accelerated classes, but it is some pretty rudimentary stuff which, at a conceptual level, doesn't even require numbers. Hell, the O's and 0's in Perpetual Student's secret code could be wedding rings or automobile tires. I even have some cast iron frying pans, a circular saw blade, and a box of soda straws that could be substituted just as readily. I'm sure Perpetual Student would understand and agree.
 
Clinger needs a refresher course on basic EM theory from his own college:

http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/...-maxwells-equations/MIT8_02SC_notes26to30.pdf

This implies that the number of magnetic field lines entering a closed surface is equal to the number of field lines leaving the surface. That is, there is no source or sink. In addition, the lines must be continuous with no starting or end points. In fact, as shown in Figure 13.2.1(b) for a bar magnet, the field lines that emanate from the north pole to the south pole outside the magnet return within the magnet and form a closed loop.

Somebody at MIT understands basic EM theory, but it sure as hell isn't Clinger.
 
This physical universe has no monopoles, and B lines have no source or sink, making it *IMPOSSIBLE* for B lines to "begin" anywhere. Deal with it.

More of your "CONCEPTUAL in nature" dogma Michael Mozina? Technically we don't know if "This physical universe has no monopoles". However, since you're the only here who asserts reconnection requires monopoles that monopolistic problem remains entirely yours as well as demonstrably false (otherwise magnetic reconnection would confirm that "This physical universe" has monopoles). As no one is touting magnetic reconnection as poof of monopoles it should be obvious to you that you're the only one asserting that it requires monopoles. Not to worry, keep dragging out and beating up your monopolistic strawman whenever you like. Until you realize it's just an aspect of your own "CONCEPTUAL in nature" dogma you're only beating on yourself. Perhaps you best "Deal with it" with it instead.
 
Actually it means the topology of W.D.Clinger's explanation of magnetic reconnection is trivially demonstrable using mathematical concepts I was first exposed to in 4th grade.

That claim doesn't mean much coming from a guy that is in denial of the fact that electrical discharges can and do occur in plasmas and flares.

Now I'll admit I was in some accelerated classes, but it is some pretty rudimentary stuff which, at a conceptual level, doesn't even require numbers.

Evidently you must have DECELERATED rapidly when you got to plasma physics and purchased a total of zero textbooks on that topic.

I'm sure Perpetual Student would understand and agree.

No doubt. Haters think alike which is why neither of you have presented a scientific argument.
 
More of your "CONCEPTUAL in nature" dogma Michael Mozina?

My dogma? Absolutely not. I presented PUBLISHED REFERENCES to support my statements. You folks did not. See the distinction?

Technically we don't know if "This physical universe has no monopoles".

Technically we don't know "God didn't do it" either. So what? We don't know MAGIC doesn't exist either for that matter. Unicorns?

However, since you're the only here who asserts reconnection requires monopoles

BZZT. I asserted (AS MANY REFERENCES ALSO ASSERTED) that B lines cannot "begin" or "end" without monopoles. I further asserted that "reconnection" is a PROCESS involving PLASMA as those 1000's of references demonstrate.

How HONEST are you being when you fail to acknowledge my actual claim, and you build your own strawman?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom