Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Assuming that's true, I still don't see how that helps Clinger out with his KLUDGED claim about B lines "beginning" and "ending".


W.D.Clinger's explanation was mathematical. Magnetic field lines are just a math thing. It seems those who understand that aren't having much difficulty with it.
 
W.D.Clinger's explanation was mathematical. Magnetic field lines are just a math thing. It seems those who understand that aren't having much difficulty with it.

I understand his math just fine. I also understand why it's INAPPROPRIATE in the first place. He's treating B fields like E fields, and that's simply not acceptable. B lines do NOT have a source, so they can't "begin" anywhere. E fields can have a beginning, but not B fields.
 
Last edited:
I understand his math just fine. I also understand why it's INAPPROPRIATE in the first place. He's treating B fields like E fields, and that's simply not acceptable. B lines do NOT have a source, so they can't "begin" anywhere. E fields can have a beginning, but not B fields.


That argument demonstrates a thorough misunderstanding of W.D.Clinger's explanation.
 
You evidently missed a whole conversation I had with PS about non-neutral plasmas.

apparently I did, and I cannot find it either
the only claim I found was to RC that a current is a non-neutral plasma, which ofcourse is baloney
I would love to read your converstation, so please point me to it (or maybe PS knows where he was enlightened)

It DOES NOT say anything about 'wires'. Again, you're just making that up.

It also say NOTHING about there being a plasma, you are making that up.

Pray tell: can there be a vacuum when there is a plasma?
 
Last edited:
They don't cross, they are tangent to each other.

Assuming that's true, I still don't see how that helps Clinger out with his KLUDGED claim about B lines "beginning" and "ending".

No, they do "cross" in the X-point, however at the X-point the magnetic field strength is zero and the field has no direction as it is a null-vector. Just infinitessimaly outside the X-point the field lines are indeed anti-tangent.

Therefore it can be said that the four special field lines, called separatrices, begin (two of then) and end (two of them) at the X-point. As there is no field and no direction, the separatrices that near the X-point have nowhere to go. However, there are only four of these, two pairs, and thus there is continuity and because to end and two begin there is no violation of Gauss' Law.
 
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo VII

This should not have been necessary. If you really understood the math & physics, as you claim you do, then you would realize, as I have pointed out before, that a change in the topology of the field requires the breaking and reconnection of field lines in an absolute & logically necessary sense.
No it DOES NOT!
YES IT DOES.
No, it doesn't.
Yes it does. This is getting monotonous.


Tim, that last reference by Priest was ALL ABOUT THE PHOTOSPHERE AND CORONA. They didn't even draw full loops ANYWHERE, and the whole thing is based on plasma movements in the photosphere! Whatever code they use *MUST* involve MHD theory.

Reference Priest & Schrijver, 1999.

As usual, you are wrong. The simulation places magnetically polarized sources on an electrically conducting surface. The surface is surrounded by a vacuum. The magnetic fields from the sources extend into the vacuum. As the sources move on the surface, the magnetic field lines necessarily move through the vacuum to follow the motion of the sources. As the sources move, the magnetic fields merge and reconnect, as shown in the video and as diagrammed in figures 12 through 14 of the paper. They do not use MHD. They do not need to use MHD. The magnetic field lines are in a vacuum, they reconnect in a vacuum. There is no plasma in the vacuum. What part of the word vacuum did you fail to understand?

Face the physics. It will do you good.
Speaking of facing facts, when did you intend to face that fact that without a MONOPOLE, it's impossible for B *LINES* to have beginnings and endings? When did you intend to face the fact that plasma and current are not OPTIONAL in the 'reconnection' process Tim?

Those are not facts. Here are the real facts:
B-lines end & begin at null points, no monopole required (that's a fact).
Plasma and current are optional; B-line reconnection occurs in a vacuum (that's a fact).

Why do you think that you know more about plasma physics than all of the physicists and engineers involved in the magnetic reconnection experiments that you summarily rejected?
Why do you think that you know more about plasma physics than Priest, Schrijver, Yamada, Kulrsrud and Ji?
Why do you think that you know more about plasma physics than Dungey?

Why do you think that you are the one and only living human being who understands plasma physics & electromagnetism?
 
apparently I did, and I cannot find it either
the only claim I found was to RC that a current is a non-neutral plasma, which ofcourse is baloney
I would love to read your converstation, so please point me to it (or maybe PS knows where he was enlightened)



It also say NOTHING about there being a plasma, you are making that up.

Pray tell: can there be a vacuum when there is a plasma?

This is just another Mozina semantic morass. I found a description of non-neutral plasma in wiki (HERE). The discussion with Mozina was about electrons moving from the cathode to the anode in a vacuum tube, which is not very relevant to this discussion.

Non-neutral plasma
The strength and range of the electric force and the good conductivity of plasmas usually ensure that the densities of positive and negative charges in any sizeable region are equal ("quasineutrality"). A plasma with a significant excess of charge density, or, in the extreme case, is composed of a single species, is called a non-neutral plasma. In such a plasma, electric fields play a dominant role. Examples are charged particle beams, an electron cloud in a Penning trap and positron plasmas.
 
At least GBT is *TRYING* to communicate. :) I really didn't think it would matter to you, but I was curious how you would respond. :)

If you cut the magnet in half, you simply have two MAGNETS and B lines from each part of the magnet! The H lines will "disconnect" of course.

Is that really your answer? This question is not about H lines! How can the B lines in the original magnet (which were continuous from the N to S poles) become the B lines in the resulting two magnets (when separated) without breaking and reconnecting?
 
Yes it does. This is getting monotonous.

No, it doesn't, and yes it is. :)


Reference Priest & Schrijver, 1999.

As usual, you are wrong. The simulation places magnetically polarized sources on an electrically conducting surface. The surface is surrounded by a vacuum......What part of the word vacuum did you fail to understand?

Er, what part of PHOTOSPHERE do you not understand?

5. Toy Model for Vacuum Reconnection
We have constructed a simple toy model for vacuum reconnection driven by the motion of photospheric sources and have presented the results in the accompanying CD-ROM. We calculate the potential magnetic field due to two, three or four sources in the solar surface and then extend it to a many-source case in which the surrounding fields generally limit the motions of the field lines in response to the footpoint motions to much smaller amplitudes than in the few-source case.

Your electrically conductive surface is composed of PLASMA and it's surrounded by plasma (a corona) too Tim!

Those are not facts. Here are the real facts:
B-lines end & begin at null points, no monopole required (that's a fact).
Plasma and current are optional; B-line reconnection occurs in a vacuum (that's a fact).

Those are not FACTS at all, in fact they're are all FACTUALLY FALSE STATEMENTS which is why you're having a DEVIL of a time finding appropriate references. :)

Why do you think that you know more about plasma physics than all of the physicists and engineers involved in the magnetic reconnection experiments that you summarily rejected? Why do you think that you know more about plasma physics than Priest, Schrijver, Yamada, Kulrsrud and Ji?
Why do you think that you know more about plasma physics than Dungey?

I don't know more than they do. They all USE PLASMA and MHD theory to achieve "reconnection'. I just know more about plasma physics than Clinger does because he's never read a book on the subject. Apparently he's not even particularly knowledgeable in basic EM theory in fact or he wouldn't be claiming that B lines "begin" somewhere!

Why do you think that you are the one and only living human being who understands plasma physics & electromagnetism?

No, of course not. I just understand more about plasma physics than all the haters combined because none of them own, let alone have read a book on the topic of plasma physics. I also believe that somewhere deep down inside, you also must realize that plasma isn't OPTIONAL in Dungey's FLARE/DISCHARGE process Tim.
 
Last edited:
I just understand more about plasma physics than all the haters combined because none of them own, let alone have read a book on the topic of plasma physics.
As a layman who admittedly has no expertise in plasma physics, but has followed the discussion here, I can say that the above statement is hogwash! Reading books about plasma physics without the prerequisite education in physics and mathematics, would be like someone who does not understand French reading a book in French.
 
Your fixation on quotes is nonsense. There is a physical difference between an electrical discharge process in plasma and "B LINES BEGINNING" in a NULL in a vacuum. Get real.

As evidently there is a difference between your “magnetic reconnection” and, well, magnetic reconnection that nonsensical quote fixation remains entirely yours. Get honest, if not with yourself then at least with us.


No. I've said very clearly to you at least twice now that monopoles would be required for B lines to 'begin' and/or 'end' at some point rather than form continuous loops.

As fields lines do terminate at a null point and no one has claimed that as proof of monopoles your claim is demonstrably false. You do understand what ‘monopole’ means right, “one pole”? As such field lines can not “'begin' and 'end'” at only one pole. Additionally we have already agreed that a null point satisfies Gauss's law and a monopole wouldn’t. So a null point can not be a monopole because it would not satisfy Gauss's law and opposing field lines can not terminate at a monopole as they do a null point because it is only, well, “one pole”.

As I have said before, and phunk alluded to recently, all that is required for magnetic reconnection is for two different opposing field configurations to be topologically the same (see the traffic circle analogy I posted before). The null point does exactly that since opposing field lines terminate at that point.




That depends on what *EXACTLY* you are calling a 'field line'? Does this LINE include or exclude *PLASMA*?

A field line is a graphical representation of the magnitude and direction of the field vectors.

How exactly would a “LINE include or exclude *PLASMA*”?

If you are asking if a particular system for which field lines can be drawn “include or exclude *PLASMA*”. Then the drawing of a field line (and the presence of field vectors) does not necessitate the presence of plasma in the system nor does it exclude it.


Do you ACTUALLY believe that's even a rational question?

The question certainly is, though whether your answer is or not still remains to be seen.


The DISHONEST BEHAVIOR directly relates to your fixation on persons and HONESTY rather than PHYSICS. At the level of PHYSICS Clinger's claim about B lines 'beginning" somewhere would require a MONOPOLE. Are you HONESTLY going to address that point? Yes or no? Stop dodging.

Wait, so you would be more honest if your dishonesty simply wasn’t a matter of contention? Here’s a hint, it is your dishonesty that has been keeping you from understanding “PHYSICS”. Flied lines do terminate at a null point and it can not be a monopole for reasons that should be obvious even to you.
 
Just so I am clear....

This would be a sink;




This would be a monopole;




And this is what was shown in WD Clingers presentation;


Doesn't look like a sink or a monopole to me. Have I gotten it all wrong?
 
This is just another Mozina semantic morass. I found a description of non-neutral plasma in wiki (HERE). The discussion with Mozina was about electrons moving from the cathode to the anode in a vacuum tube, which is not very relevant to this discussion.

Thanks PS, for clarification.

I already doubted that MM was capable of actually giving a real foundation of why a current is a "non-neutral plasma," however he is right in a vacuum tube with only electrons moving from one side to the other. However, like you say, that has absolutely nothing to do with natural plasmas.

Not that this question has not been raised before, I am sure I can find a post of mine at least 4 years old that askes the same question, why a current in a plasma is a "non-neutral plasma." Up to now I have never obtained an answer.
 
Just so I am clear....

This would be a sink;
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_285254ee2bbf88d83e.jpg[/qimg]



This would be a monopole;
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_285254ee2bc3bd56c6.jpg[/qimg]

And this is what was shown in WD Clingers presentation;
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_285254ee2bc6f45f5c.jpg[/qimg]

Doesn't look like a sink or a monopole to me. Have I gotten it all wrong?

thou art correct!

From humanay to humanzee: Not that it will matter though, but I guess you have figured that out already.
 
Just so I am clear....

This would be a sink;
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_285254ee2bbf88d83e.jpg[/qimg]



This would be a monopole;
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_285254ee2bc3bd56c6.jpg[/qimg]



And this is what was shown in WD Clingers presentation;
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_285254ee2bc6f45f5c.jpg[/qimg]

Doesn't look like a sink or a monopole to me. Have I gotten it all wrong?


As tusenfem already noted you are correct, though with one slight clarification. The first is a sink and a monopole, the second is a source and a monopole. The last is of course the configuration we are discussing in magnetic reconnection.

Now, while it is true that not all field null points have such a configuration (consider a point along the null line at the symmetrical axis of a single current carrying conductor). When we talk about the null point in a field that has potentially two different configurations of opposing field lines that are topologically the same (as in magnetic reconnection) it is that last one that we are specifically talking about.
 
The Man dies not have to deal with your ignorance and delusions about W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection .


The Man can probably understand the precise definition of a field line includes that:
  • It does not exist where there is no vector field.
  • Where the vector field magntitude is zero, the density of fleld lines is zero.
At a null point the magnetic field does not exist (B=0). Thus there can be no field line thre because
  • There is no field there.
  • The density of field lines there is zero.
This does not violate Gauss's law for magnetism because there are no sources or sinks of magnetic field.

Indeed, but also as already noted before, by myself and others, the direction of a null (non existent) vector is ambiguous (technically a non-existent vector has no direction as well as no magnitude). So of the two possible opposing field configurations that are topologically the same the configuration with potentially lower energy tends to result.

Now one can, for example, drive a system to a higher energy configuration by inputting energy. If we consider a bar magnet aligned to (and thus connected to) the Earth's magnetic field, that would represent the lowest energy (in the field) configuration. We can apply a force and turn the bar magnet 180 degrees so that it is no longer aligned to the Earth's magnetic field. We have now added energy to the field configuration (much like the two images you posted before Reality Check). What was primarily an open configuration (the Earth and magnet fields connected to each other) has now become a primarily closed configuration (the magnet's field connects to the magnet and the Earth's to the Earth). Barring any restraining forces (like friction or whatever) when we release the magnet it will realign to the Earth's magnetic field due to the energy we stored in the field configuration by turning the magnet. Once realigned the magnet's and Earth's fields are now reconnected, the configuration is open again and at a lower energy state. As you already noted before such reconnections are trivial and reconnection in plasma far more interesting and of substantial research. However if Michael Mozina just can't get past his own personal distain of, and disconnect (pun intended) with, the fundamentals of such trivial magnetic reconnection. Discussing the more interesting and intricate aspects of magnetic reconnection in plasma is simply a non-started and he keeps running around is circles simply repeating the same patently false nonsense.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom