Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh yes you have!! You can't sneak out that easy. "Magnetic reconnection" is an extremely explicit description of an extremely well defined process: The literal reconnection of magnetic field lines.

But that's just it. The process does NOT describe the literal reconnection of B field lines. That would require a monopole!

It involves an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE, from/to an ELECTRICAL neutral (not Origin the Null, the great NOTHING), and the E field is the source and sink of kinetic energy. Whatever transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy that might occur, occurs as a result of INDUCTION as the current (and magnetic field energy) comes up and through the Z axis.

The electrical discharge process in plasma is VERY REAL IMO. It does not however involve the reconnection of B lines, but rather it involves the reconnection of CURRENT from the Z axis to the X,Y axis.

Why change the name Tim? Look at this mess of a thread. That's why. You and I should have been able to agree that currents reconnect. To this day you evidently believe that B *LINES* themselves reconnect in spite of the fact that none of you has a monopole in your pocket.

:covereyes:boggled::eek::eye-poppi:jaw-dropp
 
Last edited:
Does your admonition to others not apply equally to yourself?




You work hard to make hay out of the fact that it was Dungey who used the words "electric discharge".




Does your admonition to others not apply equally to yourself? You are adamant that Dungey meant "electrical discharge" when he said "electrical discharge". So why do you refuse to believe that when Dungey said "The effect of the discharge is to 'reconnect' the lines of force at the neutral point, and this happens quickly", that he also meant what he said in this case as well?

But those "lines of force" are NOT simple magnetic lines Tim! He's talking about an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE process from the neutral to the X,Y axis. Those LINES OF FORCE from the neutral to the X,Y axis are in the form of CURRENT, and the source and sink of the kinetic energy of the discharge are the E fields, not Origin the great NULL, the great NOTHING, the great FRAUD!
 
Last edited:
MM explains his confusion, part 11

There is nothing uncivil about noting when someone is in denial of scientific fact.
Michael Mozina is in denial of scientific fact.

I'm glad Michael Mozina agrees there is nothing uncivil about noting his denials of scientific fact.

The major point of contention at the moment is Mozina's highly iconoclastic claim that magnetic reconnection is not physically real, in clear opposition to mainstream physics (also see the thread Magnetic reconnection and physical processes).

I never made any such claim Tim.

Oh yes you have!! You can't sneak out that easy. "Magnetic reconnection" is an extremely explicit description of an extremely well defined process: The literal reconnection of magnetic field lines. You are adamant and explicit in your repeated claims that the reconnection of magnetic field lines is impossible.

But that's just it. The process does NOT describe the literal reconnection of B field lines. That would require a monopole!
No. As has been explained countless times, literal reconnection of B field lines does not require a monopole.

I have presented mathematical proof of magnetic reconnection in a time-varying B field.

I have also presented mathematical proof that those those B fields contain no monopole.

Michael Mozina may not be competent to understand mathematical proofs. If so, he can use his incompetence as an excuse for his denials of scientific fact.

On the other hand, Michael Mozina claims to have "studied Calculus formally for years". I suppose it is possible to study calculus for years without acquiring any competence, but most people who take two years of calculus at the college level acquire some basic competence in vector calculus.

If Michael Mozina is competent in vector calculus, as he wants us to believe, then he is simply lying when he claims that B field reconnection implies monopoles. If Michael Mozina is not lying about monopoles, then he is either lying about his competence or is vastly overestimating his competence.

Because the Dunning-Kruger effect is real, we cannot eliminate the possibility that Michael Mozina's denials of scientific fact have less to do with dishonesty than delusion.

Why change the name Tim? Look at this mess of a thread. That's why. You and I should have been able to agree that currents reconnect. To this day you evidently believe that B *LINES* themselves reconnect in spite of the fact that none of you has a monopole in your pocket.

:covereyes:boggled::eek::eye-poppi:jaw-dropp
Michael Mozina is the only person here who wants to change the name.

Magnetic reconnection is the accepted name for the reconnection of B field lines that Hannes Alfvén described in his 1986 keynote address:
Hannes Alfvén said:
[Maxwell] defined a magnetic field line as a line which everywhere is parallel to the magnetic field. If the current system which produced the field changes, the magnetic field changes and field lines can merge or reconnect.
Michael Mozina wants to change the name of magnetic reconnection.

The reason Michael Mozina gives for wanting to change the name is that he believes it is current that reconnects, not field lines.

As can be seen from Alfvén's statement above, when Michael Mozina denies reconnection of magnetic field lines, Michael Mozina is arguing with Hannes Alfvén.

See W.D.Clinger's webpage Deniers of Magnetic Reconnection.

...snipped detailed refutation of Michael Mozina's argument...

Mozina calls Clinger's website "an outright lie". As we can see above, in Mozina's own words, he definitely does deny the reality of magnetic reconnection as it is defined by mainstream science, and that is the claim that Clinger in fact makes. I submit these facts as objective evidence, using Mozina's own words, that Mozina lies about Clinger lying, by falsely claiming that Clinger makes claims that he does not make. Clinger is explicit about Mozina denying magnetic reconnection, and Mozina in his own words is equally explicit in denying the reality of magnetic reconnection.


Just moments ago, Michael Mozina denied a basic scientific fact about J W Dungey's 1958 paper, which Michael Mozina has been citing incessantly for most of the past year:

But those "lines of force" are NOT simple magnetic lines Tim! He's talking about an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE process from the neutral to the X,Y axis. Those LINES OF FORCE from the neutral to the X,Y axis are in the form of CURRENT, and the source and sink of the kinetic energy of the discharge are the E fields, not Origin the great NULL, the great NOTHING, the great FRAUD!
The fraud here is being perpetrated by Michael Mozina.

As can be seen from J W Dungey's figure 1, the lines of force lie within the xy plane. The current that Dungey considers is parallel to the z axis. Hence Dungey's lines of force cannot be current.

While denying the scientific facts of Dungey's paper, Michael Mozina reveals his mathematical incompetence. The neutral point of Dungey's figure 1 is at the origin, but Michael Mozina twice writes "from the neutral to the X,Y axis". Since the origin already lies at the intersection of the x and y axes, that makes absolutely no sense.

Furthermore there are no E fields in Dungey's paper outside of the first paragraph of section 4, which has nothing to do with the lines of force in figure 1. Just nine days ago, on 18 November, Michael Mozina admitted he had been jabbering about an "E field" when he had intended to jabber about "electrical current". Almost immediately, he went back to jabbering about E fields.

That may be what Michael Mozina's doing in the quotation above, but who can tell? Michael Mozina's denials of scientific fact are often so bizarre as to become not even wrong, but completely meaningless.
 
Last edited:
No. As has been explained countless times, literal reconnection of B field lines does not require a monopole.

No. When you get your crap PUBLISHED, then (and only then) can you make that claim. I'm tired of your ridiculous handwaves. Origin the NULL is a false god. He's no beginnor or endor of B field lines. He's literally *NOTHING* without plasma and current. You pray to a false god of NOTHING.

Your presentation was an *UTTER KLUDGE* of basic EM theory from start to finish. You don't even begin to understand your own math formulas. If you did understand them you would already know that 0+0=0 and NOTHING ever could "begin", "end", be a sink or a source in a VACUUM NULL! OMG. Pitiful.

Plasma and CURRENT are not "optional" in the 'reconnection' process. B *LINE* reconnection is impossible without a monopole. You're just in hard core denial of scientific fact. For instance, do you yet accept that ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES occur in plasmas? You've been attempting to ride his coattails for months now *WITHOUT* a plasma no less. ;)
 
Last edited:
Comments on magnetic reconnection (again) III

Oh yes you have!! You can't sneak out that easy. "Magnetic reconnection" is an extremely explicit description of an extremely well defined process: The literal reconnection of magnetic field lines.
But that's just it. The process does NOT describe the literal reconnection of B field lines. That would require a monopole!


:covereyes:boggled::eek::eye-poppi:jaw-dropp
Both of your claims here are brain-dead wrong. Yes, it does describe the literal reconnection of B-field, magnetic field lines. No, it does not require a monopole. You are peddling nonsense here. The reality of the literal reconnection of magnetic field lines is heavily documented and only a serious case of true denial on your part can explain your unreasonable objections to the obvious.

For example, from 13 February 2009 ...
Representative comments; clearly Mr. Mozina, and others no doubt, reject the concept of "magnetic reconnection" altogether. This is an uncomfortable position to take, since "magnetic reconnection" is directly observed in controlled laboratory plasma physics experiments (i.e., Lawrence & Gekelman, 2008; Cheng, et al., 2008; Yamada, et al., 2007; Yamada, Ren & Ji, 2007; Yamada, et al., 2006; Sarff, et al., 2005 & etc.; Yamada, 1999 reviews the previous 20 years of laboratory plasma studies of magnetic reconnection).

The argument that magnetic field lines are without physical substance, and therefore cannot reconnect, is purely a semantic argument with no basis in physics. The lines represent the topology of the magnetic field, and the change in the topology of the magnetic field is the physical manifestation of magnetic reconnection. The phenomenological consequence is a transfer of energy from the magnetic field (which loses internal energy) to the plasma (which gains kinetic energy). As noted in the papers cited above, the observations of laboratory plasma are consistent with the predictions based on magnetic reconnection theory. Furthermore, we know that double layers are not involved, because the topology of the field is observable before, during and after reconnection, so double layers would be obviously visible. Furthermore, the result of a collapsing double layer is observationally distinguishable from that of reconnection. The observations in fact are consistent with the latter, and inconsistent with the former.

Magnetic reconnection is a phenomenon verified by controlled laboratory plasma physics experiments. See, for instance, the Magnetic Reconnection Experiment (MRX) at the Princeton University Plasma Physics Laboratory. MRX has been measuring magnetic reconnection in laboratory plasma since 1995, but there are experimental observations of reconnection that predate that.

One must also observe that the theory of magnetic reconnection is well developed, and is commonly described in plasma physics text books (i.e., Magnetic Reconnection: MHD Theory and Applications, Priest & Forbes, Cambridge University Press, 2000, concentrates in detail on magnetic reconnection; other books typically include chapters on magnetic reconnection, i.e., Fundamentals of Plasma Physics, Paul M. Bellan, Cambridge University Press, 2006 (Bellan heads the Bellan Plasma Group at Caltech, which does an outstanding job of simulating solar prominences in in the laboratory); Plasma Physics for Astrophysics, Russell M. Kulsrud, Princeton University Press, 2005; The Physics of Plasmas, Boyd & Sanderson, Cambridge University Press, 2003; Nonlinear Magnetohydrodynamics, Dieter Biskamp, Cambridge Monographs on Plasma Physics, 1993).

Magnetic reconnection, as a physical phenomenon, regardless of the argument over words, is an integral & fundamental aspect of plasma physics. Denying the validity of magnetic reconnection is quite the same as simply denying the validity of laboratory plasma physics altogether.
It involves an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE, from/to an ELECTRICAL neutral (not Origin the Null, the great NOTHING), and the E field is the source and sink of kinetic energy. Whatever transfer of magnetic field energy into particle kinetic energy that might occur, occurs as a result of INDUCTION as the current (and magnetic field energy) comes up and through the Z axis.
How does anything with no net electric charge ("ELECTRICAL neutral" as you say) produce an "electrical discharge"? As for the appeal to "induction", that was proven to be impossible a ling time ago too ... From the post Magnetic Reconnection Redux V dated 30 December 2009 (this is a long post with included quotes so see the original for full details):
Reference the book Magnetic Reconnection: MHD Theory and Applications by Eric Priest & Terry Forbes, Cambridge University Press, 2000. Magnetic reconnection is not induction. Here is the induction equation in a plasma as given in Priest & Forbes, page 5: [latex](1) $ \partial \boldsymbol B / \partial t = \nabla \times (\boldsymbol v \times \boldsymbol B) - \nabla \times (\eta \nabla \times \boldsymbol B) $ [/latex] Here [latex]\eta[/latex] is the magnetic diffusivity. If [latex]\eta[/latex] is uniform then the induction equation reduces to ... [latex](2) $ \partial \boldsymbol B / \partial t = \nabla \times (\boldsymbol v \times \boldsymbol B) + \eta \nabla^2 \boldsymbol B $ [/latex] { ... } Given the equation I have labeled (2) above, we find ...
"This is the basic equation of magnetic behavior in MHD, and it determines B once v is known. In the electromagnetic theory of fixed conductors, the electric field and electric current are primary variables with the current driven by electric fields. in such a fixed system the magnetic field is a secondary variable derived from the currents. However, in MHD the basic physics is quite different, since the plasma velocity (v) and magnetic field (B) are the primary variables, determined by the induction equation and the equation of motion, while the resulting current density (j) and electric field (E) are secondary and may be deduced from equations (1.8) and (1.10a) if required (Parker, 1996)." Priest & Forbes, page 14.​
The conversion of magnetic energy into a current always operates on a time-scale characteristic of the system, and that time scale is controlled by the ability of the magnetic field to move through the conductor, in order to create a dB/dt term from which the current is generated. That time-scale in a plasma is rather different than it is for a fixed conductor. Here we find the real deal once again in Priest & Forbes:
"In space physics the distinction between ideal and non-ideal processes is important because simple estimates imply that magnetic dissipation acts on a time-scale which is many orders of magnitude slower than the observed time-scale of dynamic phenomena. For example, solar flares release stored magnetic energy in the corona within a period of 100 s. By comparison, the time-scale for magnetic dissipation based on a global scale length of 105 km is of the order of 106 yrs." Priest & Forbes, page 6​
Can you explain why & how the induction equation shown here is wrong? The only way you can continue to deny the obvious literal reconnection of B-field lines, without any monopole involvement at all, is to set yourself up as more capable & knowledgeable in the discipline of plasma physics than entire generations of professional plasma physicists & engineers. That's one reason why nobody believes you. Why should they?
Why change the name Tim? Look at this mess of a thread. That's why. You and I should have been able to agree that currents reconnect. To this day you evidently believe that B *LINES* themselves reconnect in spite of the fact that none of you has a monopole in your pocket.
I don't just "believe" it, I know it for a fact, and I know that your own understanding of the physics involved is truly & genuinely pathetic. Essentially everything you ever say about plasma physics in this, or any other thread, is obviously & completely wrong (there may be a rare lucky exception). You are tilting at the windmill of genuine plasma physics.
Michael Mozina is in denial of scientific fact. {...} Michael Mozina's denials of scientific fact are often so bizarre as to become not even wrong, but completely meaningless.
 
Magnetic reconnection is the accepted name for the reconnection of B field lines that Hannes Alfvén described in his 1986 keynote address:

You mean THIS keynote address?

B. Magnetic Merging — A Pseudo-Science
Since then I have stressed in a large number of papers the danger of using the frozen-in concept. For example, in a paper "Electric Current Structure of the Magnetosphere" (Alfvén, 1975), I made a table showing the difference between the real plasma and "a fictitious medium" called "the pseudo-plasma," the latter having frozen in magnetic field lines moving with the plasma. The most important criticism of the "merging" mechanism of energy transfer is due to Heikkila (1973) who with increasing strength has demonstrated that it is wrong. In spite of all this, we have witnessed at the same time an enormously voluminous formalism building up based on this obviously erroneous concept. Indeed, we have been burdened with a gigantic pseudo-science which penetrates large parts of cosmic plasma physics. The monograph CP treats the field-line reconnection (merging) concept in 1.3, 11.3, and 11.5. We may conclude that anyone who uses the merging concepts states by implication that no double layers exist.

A new epoch in magnetospheric physics was inaugurated by L. Lyons and D. Williams' monograph (1985). They treat magnetospheric phenomena systematically by the particle approach and demonstrate that the fluid dynamic approach gives erroneous results. The error of the latter approach is of a basic character. Of course there can be no magnetic merging energy transfer.

I was naive enough to believe that such a pseudo-science would die by itself in the scientific community, and I concentrated my work on more pleasant problems. To my great surprise the opposite has occurred; the "merging" pseudo-science seems to be increasingly powerful. Magnetospheric physics and solar wind physics today are no doubt in a chaotic state, and a major reason for this is that some of the published papers are science and part pseudoscience, perhaps even with a majority for the latter group.

In those parts of solar physics which do not deal with the interior of the Sun and the dense photospheric region (fields where the frozen-in concept may be valid), the state is even worse. It is difficult to find theoretical papers on the low density regions which are correct. The present state of plasma astrophysics seems to be almost completely isolated from the new concepts of plasma which the in situ measurements on space plasma have made necessary (see Section VIII).

I sincerely hope that the increased interest in the study of double layers — which is fatal to this pseudoscience — will change the situation. Whenever we find a double layer (or any other E ll # 0) we hammer a nail into the coffin of the "merging" pseudo-science.

Is that the speech you're talking about?
 
Last edited:
I don't just "believe" it,.....

That's ultimately the problem too Tim. You just REFUSE to 'believe' that a monopole would be required for B lines to begin, end, to be a source or a sink. It's not optional to simply toss out monopoles and claim B lines still "begin and end". That's physically *IMPOSSIBLE*.

I know it for a fact, and I know that your own understanding of the physics involved is truly & genuinely pathetic.

No, that's a "false belief" you hold and it's one of the primary obstacles in terms of us being able to communicate, as is the fact you keep RUNNING LIKE HELL from equations 16 and 17 in the source/sink paper that YOU PERSONALLY provided! Sheesh.

The E field is the source and sink, not only in Dungey's *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE* process from the neutral, but also in Priests "source/sink" paper. That mathematical, verbal and physical evidence is staring you in face but you "don't believe it".
 
Dungey & Magnetic Reconnection VI

Remember that Dungey explicitly used the words "lines of force" ...

See The Neutral Point Discharge Theory of Solar Flares. a Reply to Cowling's Criticism, J.W. Dungey, 1958 (this is the paper that Mozina's "Dungey" comment above refers to).

"Certain other features of flares may be accounted for by the bulk motion resulting from a discharge at a neutral point. The effect of the discharge is to 'reconnect' the lines of force at the neutral point, and this happens quickly. The 'reconnection' upsets the mechanical equilibrium in the neighborhood in a way that can be visualized, if the lines of force are seen as strings. Then the mechanical disturbance will spread from the neutral point and may have energy comparable to the energy of the spot field in the solar atmosphere."
Dungey, 1958, page 139
​


But Mozina does not like Dungey's words and wants to change them ...

Sure, but his "lines of force" were in the form of charged particles flowing up through the Z axis Tim. They weren't massless, simple B lines.


So, I asked Mozina ...

OK, now I have to understand this more clearly ...
Did Dungey say "lines of force" but actually mean something else?
Was Dungey unable to tell the difference between "lines of force" and "lines of current"?

You see, what's going on here is that Dungey is quite explicit in the words he uses, "lines of force", but you have decided to substitute other words in their place. Why should we trust you and your words, instead of simply taking Dungey's own words at face value, and assume that Dungey actually said what he intended to say?


I never got a direct answer to these. But we do see some interesting posts from Mozina. First, we see Mozina complain that others do not give Dungey proper credit for Dungey's words ...

The claim that Dungey actually meant anything other than an electrical discharge when he said electrical discharge, having been demonstrated unsupportable, has been rejected. Denial won't save you.


And we see Mozina make another, seemingly obvious point regarding Dungey ...

You can't use only 1/2 his work and ignore the other half *ENTIRELY*. :)


But you see in the quotes above that Mozina wants to do exactly what he blames others for doing, namely that he wants to use only the 1/2 of Dungey that he likes, and ignore the rest. And this he continues to do ...

But those "lines of force" are NOT simple magnetic lines Tim! He's talking about an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE process from the neutral to the X,Y axis. Those LINES OF FORCE from the neutral to the X,Y axis are in the form of CURRENT, and the source and sink of the kinetic energy of the discharge are the E fields, not Origin the great NULL, the great NOTHING, the great FRAUD!


This pure & unadulterated hypocrisy on Mozina's part. He demands of everyone else that they accept the words "electrical discharge" or "electric discharge", because Dungey said so; he uses Dungey's name as an authority to support his claim. However, Dungey also uses the words "lines of force" and that Mozina cannot abide. So he chooses to simply ignore Dungey's words, Dungey's physics, and replace it with his own version of what he unreasonably claims Dungey really meant to say. Mozina is taking the 1/2 of Dungey he likes, and ignoring the rest entirely; he is doing something himself, which he claims to be wrong for others to do. This is hypocrisy in pure form.
 
MM explains his confusion, part 12

No. As has been explained countless times, literal reconnection of B field lines does not require a monopole.

No. When you get your crap PUBLISHED, then (and only then) can you make that claim.
Michael Mozina is unable to assess whether a mathematical proof is correct, so he must rely on the peer review process to tell him what is true.

Except he ignores the many peer-reviewed publications that describe magnetic reconnection. Consider, for example, the survey paper by Yamada et al, which I have cited many times:
[Yamada et al 2010] Masaaki Yamada, Russell Kulsrud, and Hantao Ji. Magnetic reconnection. Reviews of Modern Physics volume 82, January-March 2010, pages 603-664.​

That survey paper cites 308 references. Michael Mozina is ignoring hundreds of peer-reviewed papers that contradict his claims.

Meanwhile, Michael Mozina is asking us to take his word for it that magnetic reconnection (in the correct sense of B field line reconnection) requires monopoles. He has never cited any published paper in support of his claim, because he can't. His claim is false.

When Michael Mozina pretends to respect only published claims, he is being hypocritical. Michael Mozina does not respect scientific publications that contradict his delusions, but he asks us to believe his denials of scientific fact on the basis of his own, personal, soi-dissant mathematical competence.

I'm tired of your ridiculous handwaves.
div B = 0 is not a handwave. I have presented at least three separate proofs of div B = 0 for the magnetic fields in my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection:
It's a scientific fact that div B = 0 implies there are no monopoles, so I have proved there are no monopoles in any of the fields involved in my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

Michael Mozina refers to those proofs as handwaves. It doesn't really matter whether his denials of scientific fact are dishonest or incompetent. He's in denial.

Origin the NULL is a false god. He's no beginnor or endor of B field lines. He's literally *NOTHING* without plasma and current. You pray to a false god of NOTHING.

Your presentation was an *UTTER KLUDGE* from start to finish. You don't understand your own math formulas. If you did understand them you would already know that 0+0=0 and NOTHING ever could "begin", "end", be a sink or a source in a VACUUM NULL! OMG. Pitiful.
Michael Mozina writes that kind of stuff because he can't make a scientific argument.

Michael Mozina's in a tough spot. Hundreds of scientific papers contradict him. Vector calculus contradicts him. Freshman electromagnetism contradicts him. Denial is all he's got.
 
Michael Mozina
But that's just it. The process does NOT describe the literal reconnection of B field lines. That would require a monopole!
I've lost count of the number of times this straw-man has been regurgitated. This kind of mindless blathering is all we seem to get from you, Mozina. However, here's your chance to redeem yourself for all to see and witness. I, and quite likely, many others would be impressed with your knowledge in this area and think twice about criticising your opinions with this simple act:
Present a rigorous mathematical demonstration that monopoles are required for magnetic reconnection. No links; just a straightforward mathematical demonstration of this very obvious truth. That's it!
Certainly, since you are so adamantly certain of this truth, you must have such a proof at your side. See -- how easy for you silence so many critics! I am anxiously waiting to be converted to your "side."
:popcorn1
 
Last edited:
I've lost count of the number of times this straw-man has been regurgitated. This kind of mindless blathering is all we seem to get from you, Mozina. However, here's your chance to redeem yourself for all to see and witness. I, and quite likely, many others would be impressed with your knowledge in this area and think twice about criticising your opinions with this simple act:
Present a rigorous mathematical demonstration that monopoles are required for magnetic reconnection. No links; just a straightforward mathematical demonstration of this very obvious truth. That's it!
Certainly, since you are so adamantly certain of this truth, you must have such a proof at your side. See -- how easy for you silence so many critics! I am anxiously waiting to be converted to your "side."
:popcorn1

Nothing like BLATANTLY SHIFTING the burden of proof. Right *AFTER* you get Clinger's Null B line beginnor/endor god of the vacuum nonsense *PUBLISHED*, come talk to me again. :)

OMG. Haters are all alike. All any of you have done thus far is handwave a couple of math formulas related to a NULL in a quadrapole experiment and equations that amount to 0+0=0 in the absence of plasma! I've yet to see ANY mathematical proof of the TWO MAGNET concept (without a NULL) provided as you have ALL handwaved (except Tim). When might I expect to see THOSE maths?

Give me a break and quit expecting ME to personally *PROVE* what is already accepted in basic physics. B lines have no source, no sink, no beginning, no end, no ability to "disconnect" nor to "reconnect" to any other magnetic line. If and when one of pulls a monopole out of pocket, let me know. Until then the burden of proof remains on you. Clinger's claims are utterly absurd. NOTHING begins in a NULL!
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina is unable to assess whether a mathematical proof is correct, so he must rely on the peer review process to tell him what is true.

No, I already know what is true because I own, have read and understand the plasma physics textbooks I've read on this topic. You do not even understand BASIC EM theory or you wouldn't *STILL* (to this very day) be one your knees in steadfast prayer to ORIGIN the fake beginor and endor of B line god of the universe.

If and when you get your nonsense published in a reputable magazine related to electromagnetic theory, let me know. You're clueless, and up a metaphysical creek without a plasma particle or monopole to your name IMO.

Utter KLUDGE! EPIC FAIL!
 
Last edited:
When can I expect you to submit your work for publication to a reputable magazine related to EM theory Clinger? You've *CLAIMED* to have achieved B line reconnection without a plasma and without a monopole. I've never seen *ANYTHING LIKE* it in print, nor could you provide me with any references to support that claim. Since it's obviously "new and uncharted territory", you're sure to be famous, right?
 
Last edited:
Remember that Dungey explicitly used the words "lines of force" ...




But Mozina does not like Dungey's words and wants to change them ...

Um, no Tim, it's *YOU* that keeps trying to change them, and REMOVE that whole ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE process from the LINES OF FORCE he's describing.

I never got a direct answer to these.

Yes you did, you just didn't like the answer evidently. Dungey's "lines of force" include DISCHARGE CURRENTS Tim. The CURRENTS discharge from the NEUTRAL to the X,Y axis. I've answered your questions repeatedly and even pointed out the mathematical expression Priests uses in equations 16 and 17.

This pure & unadulterated hypocrisy on Mozina's part. He demands of everyone else that they accept the words "electrical discharge" or "electric discharge", because Dungey said so; he uses Dungey's name as an authority to support his claim. However, Dungey also uses the words "lines of force" and that Mozina cannot abide.

Bull. I can in fact abide by them whereas you cannot. I can *INCLUDE* that discharge current in the "lines of force", whereas YOU CANNOT.

I simply *PREFER* the term "current reconnection". It's your own bigotry that prevents you from meeting me in the middle. You folks are like the flip side of Hannes Alfven. You only see on side of Maxwell equations and ignore the other. Neither of those positions is tenable in the final analysis because Maxwell's equations solve in both directions.
 
Michael Mozina's in a tough spot. Hundreds of scientific papers contradict him. Vector calculus contradicts him. Freshman electromagnetism contradicts him. Denial is all he's got.

Um, no.

All those "scientific papers" you talk about *INCLUDE* (do not exclude plasmas). You're on your own on that score.

Vector calculus is my friend in this instance, and your personal worst nightmare:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Field_line

For example, Gauss's law states that an electric field has sources at positive charges, sinks at negative charges, and neither elsewhere, so electric field lines start at positive charges and end at negative charges. (They can also potentially form closed loops, or extend to or from infinity). A gravitational field has no sources, it has sinks at masses, and it has neither elsewhere, gravitational field lines come from infinity and end at masses. A magnetic field has no sources or sinks (Gauss's law for magnetism), so its field lines have no start or end: they can only form closed loops, or extend to infinity in both directions.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_field

One important property of the B-field produced this way is that magnetic B field lines neither start nor end (mathematically, B is a solenoidal vector field); a field line either extends to infinity or wraps around to form a closed curve.[nb 9] To date no exception to this rule has been found. (See magnetic monopole below.)

In a vacuum, your vector calculus amounts to 0+0=0, demonstrating conclusively that NOTHING begins in Origin the fake B line creator of the universe.
 
Last edited:
MM: W.D. Clinger did demonstrate his claim

Sorry, but it also mentions *PLASMA*. Clinger claimed he could duplicate Dungey's definition of "magnetic reconnection" *WITHOUT* plasma. That paper is therefore clearly inapplicable to Clinger's claim.
Sorry but you are confused.


Relaxation and magnetic reconnection in plasmas is a paper for which you claimed "It's all a "current" driven process.". That is ignorant of you and denomstrates that have nor read or understood the paper:
  1. No currents.
  2. The abstract mentions reconnection of magnetic field lines
It is cited in the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper.

This is nothing to do with W.D. Clinger's claim:
which he then demonstrated:
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper IV
MM: Show the mistakes in a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 3
 
http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/figure1zoom.png

http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/b5zoom.png

Let's play a game Clinger. Let's play that game, "What's different about these two images?" You created them so you certainly should be able to tell us the difference between "Origin the NULL (without plasma)" and "Origin the Neutral" (with plasma). Can you tell us the difference(s) between them? Hint: What's the white dot thingy in the middle of Origin the Neutral? Why is it missing from Origin the Null?
Let's play a game Michael Mozina. How ignorant can you make your posts look by using gibberish phrases and not understanding images?

One thing we can extract from thes "Origin the Null" gibberish is that you have no idea what a point is :D!

There is no "white dot" (B=0) shown in the first diagram because it includes the X-shaped field lines that pass across the neutral point. Overlay a white dot with the grayish line and your get a grayish dot!
 
Sure, but his "lines of force" were in the form of charged particles flowing up through the Z axis Tim. They weren't massless, simple B lines.
I just have to correct this bit of ignorance: "lines of force" are magnetic field lines!
Those are the diagrams in Dungey's paper. They were "massless, simple B lines".
 
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper V?

Originally Posted by tusenfem
What does this even mean?
Can you please explain in full detail why lines of force would be flowing charged particles? Including the math, thank you.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7770456&postcount=5065
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper IV
Nothing in the paper states that lines of force are flowing charged particles.
Shoud this be added to your delusions about the paper, MM?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom