Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
There is nothing uncivil about asking you questions and noting your answers in threads in which you WILLINGLY participate.


Even after many attempts to solicit support for the claim, nobody has objectively demonstrated that Dungey meant something other than magnetic reconnection when he said magnetic reconnection.

Get over it, and admit already that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares and Dungey claimed! You can't use only 1/2 his work and ignore the other half *ENTIRELY*.


James Dungey was one of the pioneers in the science of magnetic reconnection as it applies to solar and plasma physics. No evidence has been provided to suggest he was an advocate of some kind of bizarre lightning-like cause for solar flares and CMEs, quite probably because no such evidence exists.

Now that it's clear the alleged "single best piece of support" cannot be produced, and the claim that it exists was effectively demonstrated to be a falsehood, we can move forward... What is the second best piece of objective support for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?
 
Even after many attempts to solicit support for the claim, nobody has objectively demonstrated that Dungey meant something other than....


....an *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE* in plasma and flares when he said *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE*. Deal with reality. It only stings a little. Well, in your case probably A LOT, but at least it's finally done.
 
Last edited:
James Dungey was one of the pioneers in the science of magnetic reconnection as it applies to solar and plasma physics.

He was also one of the PIONEERS in the science of electrical discharges in plasma and solar flares. :covereyes
 
Last edited:
He was also one of the PIONEERS in the science of electrical discharges in plasma and solar flares.


The claim that Dungey actually meant a lightning-like electrical discharge when he said magnetic reconnection, having been demonstrated unsupportable, has been rejected. On to the next thing... What is the second best piece of objective support for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?
 
The claim that Dungey actually meant anything other than an electrical discharge when he said electrical discharge, having been demonstrated unsupportable, has been rejected. Denial won't save you.
 
Last edited:
The claim that Dungey actually meant anything other than an electrical discharge when he said electrical discharge, having been demonstrated unsupportable, has been rejected. Denial won't save you.


Maybe some children on another forum will play that juvenile game.

Is there a second best piece of objective support for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?
 
Is there a second best piece of objective support for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge ....

You haven't addressed or embraced the first piece, so what's the point of looking at any other pieces? If you expect to use "magnetic reconnection" theory as it relates to solar physics, you'll need to get over your aversion to ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES in plasmas and solar flares!
 
Last edited:
You haven't addressed or embraced the first piece, so what's the point of looking at any other pieces? If you expect to use "magnetic reconnection" theory as it relates to solar physics, you'll need to get over your aversion to ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES in plasmas and solar flares!


The dishonest uncivil personal attack aside, that seems to indicate there is no second best piece of objective support for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball.
 
The dishonest uncivil personal attack aside,

There is nothing uncivil about noting when someone is in denial of scientific fact. If one intends to hold up Dungey as the mainstream superhero, one can't turn around and then deny the validity of his work related to electrical discharges in solar flares. It's pitiful and hypocritical behavior. :covereyes
 
Last edited:
It's pitiful and hypocritical behavior.


So there is no best piece of objective support for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball. And there is no second best piece of objective support. Is there a third best piece of objective support?
 
Last edited:
Ok, I've wandered through this thread, read some links, and I can't find a single link or anything else that describes, in any kind of way that I can't reject from something very near to a kitchensink experiment, that describes the "electric sun" theory, which, in fact, I can't even find a clean statement of.

For this discussion to go forward and have even a whiff of a sniff of a cachet of science, this theory first needs to be directly, clearly, and concisely stated. Please, somebody do that, if anyone even knows what it is in the first place.
 
Ok, I've wandered through this thread, read some links, and I can't find a single link or anything else that describes, in any kind of way that I can't reject from something very near to a kitchensink experiment, that describes the "electric sun" theory, which, in fact, I can't even find a clean statement of.

For this discussion to go forward and have even a whiff of a sniff of a cachet of science, this theory first needs to be directly, clearly, and concisely stated. Please, somebody do that, if anyone even knows what it is in the first place.

You might read through the work of Hannes Alfven as it relates to solar flare events to get your feet wet.

http://www.thesurfaceofthesun.com/A...r Atmosphere And A Theory Of Solar Flares.pdf

Essentially, I should start by pointing out that there are MULTIPLE "electric sun" models to choose from. :) Hannes Alfven used a relatively "standard" solar theory (plasma solar model) to start with. He simply added an electromagnetic interaction with the heliosphere and the universe to the electromagnetic "process".

Kristian Birkeland's version of an "electric sun" was more of a "cathode in space" that emitted both positive and negative charges toward the heliosphere/space.

http://query.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=F50A11FB385F13738DDDAA0A94DA405B838DF1D3

This solar model would be an example of a "Birkeland" solar model. A generic Birkeland solar model wouldn't "necessarily" need to have a "solid" surface, just a "rigid" (potentially more dense plasma) subsurface layer underneath of the surface of the photosphere.

http://www.thesurfaceofthesun.com/

FYI, both of the above mentioned solar models are "internally powered" models. There was actually an externally powered "electric sun" concept put forth by Jergens, but that's not particularly popular even among "electric sun" enthusiasts.

http://www.velikovsky.info/Ralph_Juergens
 
Last edited:
That's known as a non sequitur, a logical fallacy where the conclusion does not follow from its premises. Or possibly circular reasoning. Either way it's a vacuous argument and fails to support the claim, objectively or otherwise.

Round and round you go......
 
For this discussion to go forward and have even a whiff of a sniff of a cachet of science, this theory first needs to be directly, clearly, and concisely stated. Please, somebody do that, if anyone even knows what it is in the first place.


There is nothing that might be reasonably considered a coherent electric Sun model.
 
Is this an electric sun thread?

For this discussion to go forward and have even a whiff of a sniff of a cachet of science, this theory first needs to be directly, clearly, and concisely stated. Please, somebody do that, if anyone even knows what it is in the first place.


Personally, I think we left "cachet of science" in the dust a long time ago. But the thread title is deceptive, in that we are really not discussing "the electric sun", but rather "the Mozina sun".

The group that holds most strongly to the title of "electric sun" (a special case of "electric star") claims that the sun is not powered by internal nuclear fusion, but rather by electric currents that flow through space and energize the sun (see, e.g., The Electric Sun Hypothesis and/or The Electric Sky). This is definitely a set of wildly crackpot ideas and the webpages are slanted towards selling the book (and see the thread Electric universe theories here).

This thread is actually not about the electric sun at all, but rather the ideas concerning electrical activity in/on the sun proposed by Michael Mozina whose complete model is found on his webpage The Surface of the Sun. Most of us, myself included, consider Mozina's ideas to be equally wildly crackpot ideas. But Mozina is here to dispute that claim. The broader idea of the sun having a firm or rigid iron surface is found in other older threads (e.g., Iron sun with Aether batteries)

The major point of contention at the moment is Mozina's highly iconoclastic claim that magnetic reconnection is not physically real, in clear opposition to mainstream physics (also see the thread Magnetic reconnection and physical processes).
 
The major point of contention at the moment is Mozina's highly iconoclastic claim that magnetic reconnection is not physically real, in clear opposition to mainstream physics (also see the thread Magnetic reconnection and physical processes).

I never made any such claim Tim. It's a "real" process alright. I acknowledge that the electrical discharge process in plasma is a REAL process, I just lack belief that it involves B *LINE* reconnection. I'm fine with calling the PROCESS something less confusing like "circuit reconnection".
 
Dungey & Magnetic Reconnection V

Get over it, and admit already that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares and Dungey claimed! You can't use only 1/2 his work and ignore the other half *ENTIRELY*. :)


Does your admonition to others not apply equally to yourself?

Dungey's paper discussed *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES* in PLASMA.


Dungey's paper (and Dungey himself one might assume) also explicitly identify the source of energy for the electrical discharges as the reconnection of the lines of force of the magnetic field. See below:

See The Neutral Point Discharge Theory of Solar Flares. a Reply to Cowling's Criticism, J.W. Dungey, 1958 (this is the paper that Mozina's "Dungey" comment above refers to).

"Certain other features of flares may be accounted for by the bulk motion resulting from a discharge at a neutral point. The effect of the discharge is to 'reconnect' the lines of force at the neutral point, and this happens quickly. The 'reconnection' upsets the mechanical equilibrium in the neighborhood in a way that can be visualized, if the lines of force are seen as strings. Then the mechanical disturbance will spread from the neutral point and may have energy comparable to the energy of the spot field in the solar atmosphere."
Dungey, 1958, page 139
​


So, did Dungey correctly identify the energy source or not?


Sure, but his "lines of force" were in the form of charged particles flowing up through the Z axis Tim. They weren't massless, simple B lines.


OK, now I have to understand this more clearly ...
Did Dungey say "lines of force" but actually mean something else?
Was Dungey unable to tell the difference between "lines of force" and "lines of current"?

You see, what's going on here is that Dungey is quite explicit in the words he uses, "lines of force", but you have decided to substitute other words in their place. Why should we trust you and your words, instead of simply taking Dungey's own words at face value, and assume that Dungey actually said what he intended to say?


You work hard to make hay out of the fact that it was Dungey who used the words "electric discharge".

The claim that Dungey actually meant anything other than an electrical discharge when he said electrical discharge, having been demonstrated unsupportable, has been rejected. Denial won't save you.


Does your admonition to others not apply equally to yourself? You are adamant that Dungey meant "electrical discharge" when he said "electrical discharge". So why do you refuse to believe that when Dungey said "The effect of the discharge is to 'reconnect' the lines of force at the neutral point, and this happens quickly", that he also meant what he said in this case as well?
 
Mozina and magnetic reconnection

I never made any such claim Tim.

Oh yes you have!! You can't sneak out that easy. "Magnetic reconnection" is an extremely explicit description of an extremely well defined process: The literal reconnection of magnetic field lines. You are adamant and explicit in your repeated claims that the reconnection of magnetic field lines is impossible. Therefore you necessarily claim that magnetic reconnection is not a real physical process. You claim that it's a vague process involving the "reconnection" of electric currents. It's not just words it's physics and you absolutely do, without question, claim that magnetic reconnection is not physically real, whether you want to admit it or not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom