Reality Check
Penultimate Amazing
As you can see from Michael Mozina's reply there is no actual 'electric sun' theory, just a mishmash of his misinterpretations of various bits of science and non-science.Ok, I've wandered through this thread, read some links, and I can't find a single link or anything else that describes, in any kind of way that I can't reject from something very near to a kitchensink experiment, that describes the "electric sun" theory, which, in fact, I can't even find a clean statement of.
For this discussion to go forward and have even a whiff of a sniff of a cachet of science, this theory first needs to be directly, clearly, and concisely stated. Please, somebody do that, if anyone even knows what it is in the first place.
If you really want to be blow away with the insanity behind an 'electric sun' theory then look at his web site where he actually claims to see iron mountain ranges in solar images
!He ignores that fact that he places his imaginary mountains below the photosphere where they cannot be seen (the photosphere is where light escapes from the Sun). Given the depth that he places the surface we would expect less than a photon a year to get through the photosphere.
He ignores the fact that the solar images he is so fond of are of the corona, not the photosphere. The iron is at a tempertaure of 160,000 to 2,000,000 K.
He ignores the measured temperature of the photosphere (~5700 K) and that it is measured to increase with depth (as expected by a "internally powered" model). So no solid iron. Not even any liquid iron. Turbulence then means no layers of iron gas or even iron rich plasma!
He is a fan of a model where the elements in the Sun are magically graded into layers. So above the iron layer there are silicon, etc layers. But this is impossible since the solar plasma is turbulent. Sunspots are especially good at mixing up plasma.
His confusion is obvious - he wants all the H to be outside his iron surface but he also need an internal power source. The observations are that this is fusion at the core of the Sun (we detect the neutrinos due to fusion but not the gamma rays). That means the core of the Sun is hydrogen thus disproving the layering.
Are you going to justify this extraordinary claim with evidence or are you going to expose yourself once again as a petulant peddler of pseudo scientific babble?