Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ok, I've wandered through this thread, read some links, and I can't find a single link or anything else that describes, in any kind of way that I can't reject from something very near to a kitchensink experiment, that describes the "electric sun" theory, which, in fact, I can't even find a clean statement of.

For this discussion to go forward and have even a whiff of a sniff of a cachet of science, this theory first needs to be directly, clearly, and concisely stated. Please, somebody do that, if anyone even knows what it is in the first place.
As you can see from Michael Mozina's reply there is no actual 'electric sun' theory, just a mishmash of his misinterpretations of various bits of science and non-science.

If you really want to be blow away with the insanity behind an 'electric sun' theory then look at his web site where he actually claims to see iron mountain ranges in solar images :jaw-dropp!
He ignores that fact that he places his imaginary mountains below the photosphere where they cannot be seen (the photosphere is where light escapes from the Sun). Given the depth that he places the surface we would expect less than a photon a year to get through the photosphere.
He ignores the fact that the solar images he is so fond of are of the corona, not the photosphere. The iron is at a tempertaure of 160,000 to 2,000,000 K.
He ignores the measured temperature of the photosphere (~5700 K) and that it is measured to increase with depth (as expected by a "internally powered" model). So no solid iron. Not even any liquid iron. Turbulence then means no layers of iron gas or even iron rich plasma!
He is a fan of a model where the elements in the Sun are magically graded into layers. So above the iron layer there are silicon, etc layers. But this is impossible since the solar plasma is turbulent. Sunspots are especially good at mixing up plasma.
His confusion is obvious - he wants all the H to be outside his iron surface but he also need an internal power source. The observations are that this is fusion at the core of the Sun (we detect the neutrinos due to fusion but not the gamma rays). That means the core of the Sun is hydrogen thus disproving the layering.
 
Most of the rest of it is straight forward from my perspective, including Priest's little manipulations at equations 16 and 17.
I am afraid that your statements about equations 16 and 17 reveal just how little you know or can understand.
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper III, etc.
Equation 16 is Demoulin & Priest's application of Ampere's theorem on equation 15 (the magnetic field) to get the current.
Equation 17 is Demoulin & Priest's application of Gauss' theorem on equation 15 (the magnetic field) to get the 'magnetic charge' density.

N.B. They put 'magnetic charge' in quotes in the hope that that no one would be ignorant enough that they mean real monopoles and then in section 3.3 show that there are no isolated 'magnetic charges'.
This is because the l=0 term in a multipole expansion of an equation is often refered to as the monopole term.

And of course one wonders why you do not show the mistakes in calculus (or any other math or in science) that W.D. Clinger made in his posts:
MM: Show the mistakes in a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 3
 
Vector calculus is my friend in this instance, and your personal worst nightmare:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Field_line

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_field
A reliance on Wikipedia is your personal worst nightmare in this case, Michael Mozina.
Wikipedia is wrong in this case are the hundreds of publications on magnetic reconnection state.

Buut if you want to obsess with a source that anyone can edit: Magnetic reconnection
The qualitative description of the reconnection process is such that magnetic field lines from different magnetic domains (magnetic domains is a misnomer because that applies to solid materials, we are referring to a plasma) are spliced to one another, changing their patterns of connectivity with respect to the sources.
This is a rather ornate way of saying magnetic field lines break and reconnect.

A more reliable source is Scholarpedia which is peer-reviewed
MHD reconnection
Figure 1: Breaking and reconnection of magnetic field lines when a localised diffusion region (shaded) leads to a change of connectivity of plasma elements (AB to AC)

Or you could believe in any of the ~18,000 results in Google Scholar for "magnetic reconnection field lines break"

Or you could read a book on magnetic reconnection such as Priest & Forbes or Somov.

Not that you will do this or even believe them if they state that B filed lines break and reconnect.
 
Michael Mozina
But that's just it. The process does NOT describe the literal reconnection of B field lines. That would require a monopole!
Present a rigorous mathematical demonstration that monopoles are required for magnetic reconnection. No links; just a straightforward mathematical demonstration of this very obvious truth.
Still waiting! :popcorn1Are you going to justify this extraordinary claim with evidence or are you going to expose yourself once again as a petulant peddler of pseudo scientific babble?
 
Last edited:
Still waiting! :popcorn1Are you going to justify this extraordinary claim with evidence or are you going to expose yourself once again as a petulant peddler of pseudo scientific babble?

Your side is the one HANDWAVING away, not me. Get busy. When can I expect to see Clinger's work get PUBLISHED?
 
Still waiting! :popcorn1Are you going to justify this extraordinary claim with evidence or are you going to expose yourself once again as a petulant peddler of pseudo scientific babble?

Your side is the one HANDWAVING away, not me. Get busy. When can I expect to see Clinger's work get PUBLISHED?


Translation: There will be no mathematical demonstration that monopoles are required for magnetic reconnection, rigorous or otherwise.
 
There is no "white dot" (B=0) shown in the first diagram because it includes the X-shaped field lines that pass across the neutral point. Overlay a white dot with the grayish line and your get a grayish dot!

What? Clinger already explained the gray dot was a *FIFTH* pole (evidently to simulate the current he's missing in his vacuum)! Nothing like misinformation.....
 
Last edited:
Translation: There will be no mathematical demonstration that monopoles are required for magnetic reconnection, rigorous or otherwise.

Translation: There is no way in Hell you're going to shift the burden of proof. When were you guys intending to submit Clinger's work for publication?
 
Still waiting! :popcorn1Are you going to justify this extraordinary claim with evidence or are you going to expose yourself once again as a petulant peddler of pseudo scientific babble?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7791672&postcount=5390

FYI, you've yet to deliver on YOUR claims PS. I've provided PUBLISHED works to support my case.

http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/...-maxwells-equations/MIT8_02SC_notes26to30.pdf

This implies that the number of magnetic field lines entering a closed surface is equal to the number of field lines leaving the surface. That is, there is no source or sink. In addition, the lines must be continuous with no starting or end points. In fact, as shown in Figure 13.2.1(b) for a bar magnet, the field lines that emanate from the north pole to the south pole outside the magnet return within the magnet and form a closed loop.
 
Translation: Dungey's explanation was too difficult to understand so any old nonsense that sounds electrical will do.

It's actually quite easy to understand *IF* one has actually read a book on plasma physics. Unfortunately that leaves the hardcore haters out in the cold. :(
 
Your side is the one HANDWAVING away, not me. Get busy. When can I expect to see Clinger's work get PUBLISHED?

Look, I do not claim to have any expertise in this area nor do I have a "side."
Even though I have a master's degree in mathematics, minored in physics and studied and worked in electronics for six years, I cannot fully understand Clinger's demonstration. Unlike you, unless I can actually follow the logic and science of any demonstration, I am not able to evaluate it one way or another. Nevertheless, I do know that magnetic reconnection is accepted by mainstream physics so I suspect that if his demostration is not correct, someone else could create a correct one.
You are the one that is claiming to have special knowledge that is contrary to mainstream physics, so when you say:
But that's just it. The process does NOT describe the literal reconnection of B field lines. That would require a monopole!
...all I am asking is for a demontration of this truth. So:
Present a rigorous mathematical demonstration that monopoles are required for magnetic reconnection. No links; just a straightforward mathematical demonstration of this very obvious truth.
Still waiting!:popcorn6
 
I guess you missed that *IN PLASMA* part eh? Sorry, Clinger claimed he could get B *LINE* reconnection *WITHOUT* plasma, remember?
Wow, you really did not read what I posted so here it is again:
Sorry but you are confused.


Relaxation and magnetic reconnection in plasmas is a paper for which you claimed "It's all a "current" driven process.". That is ignorant of you and denomstrates that have nor read or understood the paper:
  1. No currents.
  2. The abstract mentions reconnection of magnetic field lines
It is cited in the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper.
This is nothing to do with W.D. Clinger's claim:
which he then demonstrated:
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper IV
MM: Show the mistakes in a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 3
(emphasis added)


W.D. Clinger's claim (a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 1 ) which he then demonstrated (a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 3) did not cite the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper.

ETA
He did what he said he would do - replicate the diagrams in Dungey's paper and other places.
He then went further and showed that MR happens and analysed Dungey's paper further.
We know that his work is correct because MR in a vacuum is described in at least one textbook.
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section II
 
Last edited:
It's actually quite easy to understand *IF* one has actually read a book on plasma physics. Unfortunately that leaves the hardcore haters out in the cold.


Nonsense. Dungey's description of magnetic reconnection was, as a concept, pretty simple to understand. W.D.Clinger's explanation was equally as simple. Both of their explanations reasonably coincide with the contemporary consensus view of magnetic reconnection as it relates to solar and plasma physics. There doesn't seem to be any significant controversy out in the real world of real science.

The tiny handful of people who might disagree with Dungey's description, essentially that which W.D.Clinger was explaining, have so far been unable to present an argument that is compelling enough to get the attention of what amounts to the entire current scientific community. That isn't Dungey's fault, and it surely isn't W.D.Clinger's fault. The failure belongs to that tiny handful of people who are unable to make a cogent argument against magnetic reconnection or in support of some disjointed electric Sun conjecture.

The burden of proof rests on those who don't understand magnetic reconnection, who believe there is a better alternative explanation for the phenomenon that has been observed and measured to be magnetic reconnection, or who believe Dungey was wrong about magnetic reconnection.
 
Look, I do not claim to have any expertise in this area nor do I have a "side."

Bull. You already called me a fraud and now you're leaning on me to DISPROVE a negative, not to mention DISPROVE nothing more than a handwave! The HELL you don't have a "side".

If you're waiting on me for anything, you'll be waiting a long time. I'm still waiting on you and Clinger and rest of the real haters to deliver something to be submitted for PUBLICATION that you'll put your personal names on. Still waiting....

:popcorn1
 
Last edited:
Nonsense. Dungey's description of magnetic reconnection was, as a concept, pretty simple to understand.

Not for you evidently since you're personally still in denial of the fact that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares and apparently so is your hero Clinger.

W.D.Clinger's explanation was equally as simple.

Ya. It's a pity it violates the laws of physics. :) Magnetic B lines do not have a source or a sink, a beginning or an end. No monopole, no B line beginnings or endings.

Both of their explanations reasonably coincide with the contemporary consensus view of magnetic reconnection as it relates to solar and plasma physics.

Er, no. Clinger claimed to do it *WITHOUT* plasma. That's a horse of an *ENTIRELY* different color

Neither you or Clinger or RC understands reconnection theory because none of you three has admitted that electrical discharges occur in such events! It's like the three blind mice too since not a single one of you owns nor has read a book on plasma physics. Oy Vey.
 
Last edited:
Wow, you really did not read what I posted so here it is again:

Wow, you really did not read what I posted so here it is again:

EPIC FAIL!

His explanation amounts to nothing more than a bush-league freshman mistake on basic EM theory. B field lines do not have a source, a sink, a beginning or an end! Origin the NULL is a big fat ZERO, a big fat NULL, he's NOTHING. He's the beginning of NOTHING, and certainly the beginning of NO B LINE! No monopole, not beginning or ending of B lines. They CROSS at ZERO and FLUX CHANGE HAPPENS. So what? That is not "reconnection". "Reconnection" requires plasma and current.
 
Ya. It's a pity it violates the laws of physics. :) Magnetic B lines do not have a source or a sink, a beginning or an end. No monopole, no B line beginnings or endings.
It is a pity that you do not understand the laws of physics. :)
Magnetic B lines do not have a source or a sink.
Magnetic B lines do have an end and a start when they cross a null point because that is their definition (no field = no field lines :jaw-dropp ).
Wikipedia says so: Magnetic reconnection :D
Scholarpedia says so: MHD reconnection

As do these books:
Magnetic Reconnection: MHD Theory and Applications - Page 116
Then the field lines may diffuse, break, and reconnect, so that element A becomes linked instead to element C (Fig. 4.1). ...
Electric fields and current sheet structure in magnetospheric plasmas - Page 5
The field topology is changed as the field lines break and reform with a different connectivity...
Plasma science: advancing knowledge in the national interest - Page 22
To break a line and reconnect it to another line — a process called magnetic reconnection — the plasma must slip across the field. ...
Magnetic Coupling Between the Interior and Atmosphere of the Sun - Page 264
In 3D, magnetic reconnection can occur both at 3D nulls, but more commonly it will occur in a null-less region of ... Pairs of field lines break and 3. Pairs of field lines or even pairs of recombine into two new pairs of surfaces break ...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom