Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's quite [* a load of irrelevant nonsense snipped *]


The persistent badgering is irrelevant without elaborating on Dungey's actual position. The dishonest and willful ignorance of the request for necessary support is noted. Regarding this exchange...

What is the single best piece of support anyone has seen in this discussion, objective support if any exists, for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?

That would be Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.

... is this or is this not true?...

The single best piece of support for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball is Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.​

If it is true, show where it is objectively demonstrated. If it can't be objectively demonstrated to be true, it is irrelevant, and any further yammering about Dungey and his alleged consideration of electrical discharges is just juvenile taunting.
 
Dungey & Magnetic Reconnection III

Dungey's paper discussed *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES* in PLASMA.


Dungey's paper (and Dungey himself one might assume) also explicitly identify the source of energy for the electrical discharges as the reconnection of the lines of force of the magnetic field. See below:

See The Neutral Point Discharge Theory of Solar Flares. a Reply to Cowling's Criticism, J.W. Dungey, 1958 (this is the paper that Mozina's "Dungey" comment above refers to).

"Certain other features of flares may be accounted for by the bulk motion resulting from a discharge at a neutral point. The effect of the discharge is to 'reconnect' the lines of force at the neutral point, and this happens quickly. The 'reconnection' upsets the mechanical equilibrium in the neighborhood in a way that can be visualized, if the lines of force are seen as strings. Then the mechanical disturbance will spread from the neutral point and may have energy comparable to the energy of the spot field in the solar atmosphere."
Dungey, 1958, page 139
​


So, did Dungey correctly identify the energy source or not?
 
But when I showed you the mathematical "error/requirements" in equations 16&17 that kill Clinger's claims about reconnection without a plasma, you folks don't want to deal with it. What's the point of trying to speak pig-Latin with you, when you folk run from the pig-Latin questions? Holy smokes! Tim was the one to provide the relevant source/sink paper so we could look at the pig-Latin. I picked out the pig-Latin problem in Clinger's presentation, and now none of you want to deal with it! Oy Vey. You don't speak your own pig-Latin when it works against your case. In fact you folks provided the paper, and then claimed it wasn't RELEVANT when the pig-Latin jig was up! :)

Because you were simply wrong and remain so, you can demonstrate magnetic reconnection in your kitchen with a couple of refrigerator magnets. While simply being wrong might be understandable given you aren’t familiar with the language, having been informed of your error multiple times, yet you still persist with it demonstrates that you are not simply wrong but deliberately dishonest.



I assure you that whatever disagreements you and I may have, they are honest disagreements. I'm simply trying to understand how you're personally trying to differentiate between ordinary magnetic flux changes in a vacuum and something that requires a monopole, specifically B field *LINE* reconnection.

:confused:

You can assure me of anything you want. However that simple assurance, even of honestly, doesn’t make you honest. You have been advised multiple times that magnetic reconnection is a specific type of change in the magnetic field configuration and that you can do it yourself with a couple of refrigerator magnets. Your continued insistence that it “requires a monopole” having already been informed of your error demonstrates your deliberate lack of honesty. Your professed honesty is one of our disagreements.
 
Dungey's paper (and Dungey himself one might assume) also explicitly identify the source of energy for the electrical discharges as the reconnection of the lines of force of the magnetic field. See below:




So, did Dungey correctly identify the energy source or not?

Sure, but his "lines of force" were in the form of charged particles flowing up through the Z axis Tim. They weren't massless, simple B lines.
 
Because you were simply wrong and remain so, you can demonstrate magnetic reconnection in your kitchen with a couple of refrigerator magnets.

You and PS have both made this claim. Can either of you present a PUBLISHED, preferably "peer reviewed" paper that I can read?

I HONESTY (I don't care what you think) do not understand what PHYSICAL thing you believe "reconnects". The term "reconnection" could be replaced in your description with "reconfiguration", or "realignment" and I'd be fine. Care to meet in that middle ground before we go in endless circles?

Monopoles are not optional as it relates to B *LINE* beginnings, endings, sources and sinks. Without them, magnetic lines cannot have beginning or endings. The EM universe can have a TRILLION different NULLS (where nothing happens), but not one of those NULLS is the "beginning or ending", the "source or sink" of any of the B lines in the universe.

Do any of you have published works to support these claims? Clinger seems to believe that Origin the NULL is a "necessary" "beginnor and endor", and he believes plasma and current is optional for "reconnection". You've taken it one step further (actually Clinger said it too once) and you are now claiming that even the NULL is optional. Care to provide any of the Pig-Latin math you claim is OH SO IMPORTANT to explain YOUR position *WITHOUT A NULL*?

Holy cow. Now I'm *UTTERLY* confused as to WHAT relevant maths ANY of you might provide.
 
Last edited:
You guys should put together all the parts of Clingers "presentation", and all of you that agree with it should put your names on it and add some appropriate maths to support that two magnet claim. Add in your abstract that you've proven that B line beginnings and endings, sources and sinks are possible without monopoles and without current or plasma and submit your work to a reputable electrical engineering magazine and lets see if they publish your work? What a "great" scientific discovery you've all stumbled upon. You might be famous!

If not, post their comments here for us to read, would you? :)
 
Last edited:

Since you, Clinger and The Man have all claimed that nothing more than a couple of spinning/moving magnets (NO quadrapolar NULL) constitutes "magnetic reconnection", how about providing a PUBLISHED WORK to support your claims? In absence of such PUBLISHED material, how about showing me how valuable your superior math skills are, and provide the appropriate maths for me to look at. I'd love to see them. Keep in mind, NO PLASMA, and no quadapole NULL.
 
Last edited:
The persistent badgering is irrelevant without elaborating on Dungey's actual position.

Persistent questioning of someone about related topics and relevant materials, who involves themselves in a thread that I started in cyberspace is not "persistent badgering". Persistent badgering is best exemplified by your behaviors in this thread. Nobody asked you to participate in this thread. If you don't want to participate in this topic, simply remove yourself from this topic and I will never again ask you a question related to this topic of discussion. There are plenty of other topics at this wonderful website (and other less wonderful websites) to explore and engage in. While you continue to engage me personally in discussion in ONE THREAD IN CYBERSPACE, expect me to continue to ask you questions. If you don't answer them, expect me to ask them again. Do electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares as Dungey claimed, yes or no?
 
Last edited:
Dungey & Magnetic Reconnection IV

Dungey's paper discussed *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES* in PLASMA.


Dungey's paper (and Dungey himself one might assume) also explicitly identify the source of energy for the electrical discharges as the reconnection of the lines of force of the magnetic field. See below:

See The Neutral Point Discharge Theory of Solar Flares. a Reply to Cowling's Criticism, J.W. Dungey, 1958 (this is the paper that Mozina's "Dungey" comment above refers to).

"Certain other features of flares may be accounted for by the bulk motion resulting from a discharge at a neutral point. The effect of the discharge is to 'reconnect' the lines of force at the neutral point, and this happens quickly. The 'reconnection' upsets the mechanical equilibrium in the neighborhood in a way that can be visualized, if the lines of force are seen as strings. Then the mechanical disturbance will spread from the neutral point and may have energy comparable to the energy of the spot field in the solar atmosphere."
Dungey, 1958, page 139
​


So, did Dungey correctly identify the energy source or not?


Sure, but his "lines of force" were in the form of charged particles flowing up through the Z axis Tim. They weren't massless, simple B lines.


OK, now I have to understand this more clearly ...
Did Dungey say "lines of force" but actually mean something else?
Was Dungey unable to tell the difference between "lines of force" and "lines of current"?

You see, what's going on here is that Dungey is quite explicit in the words he uses, "lines of force", but you have decided to substitute other words in their place. Why should we trust you and your words, instead of simply taking Dungey's own words at face value, and assume that Dungey actually said what he intended to say?
 
Sure, but his "lines of force" were in the form of charged particles flowing up through the Z axis Tim. They weren't massless, simple B lines.

What does this even mean?
Can you please explain in full detail why lines of force would be flowing charged particles? Including the math, thank you.
 
Persistent [* nonsensical evasion of legitimate concerns snipped *]


The steadfast ignorance of my request for Dungey's specific and objective description of magnetic reconnection as an electrical discharge akin to lightning on Earth is noted. It is irrational to persist in the uncivil badgering and taunting in an effort to get me to answer a question, the terms of which have not been defined.

I have been seeking clarification regarding this exchange...

What is the single best piece of support anyone has seen in this discussion, objective support if any exists, for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?

That would be Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.

... and the consequent required support for the resultant claim...

The single best piece of support for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball is Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.​

In the absence of any such clarification, I think we'll just accept that the claim is unsupportable. The "single best piece of support" does not exist, and the claim that it did was a falsehood. Now we can move on.

What is the second best piece of support, objective support, for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?
 
The steadfast ignorance of my request for Dungey's specific and objective description of magnetic reconnection as an electrical discharge akin to lightning on Earth is noted.

Your steadfast DENIAL of the ample evidence ALREADY presented by Dungey, along with your unwillingness to accept that electrical discharges occur in solar flares is noted.
 
Your steadfast DENIAL of the ample evidence ALREADY presented by Dungey, along with your unwillingness to accept that electrical discharges occur in solar flares is noted.


The unnecessary and uncivil personalization is again noted.

Nobody here agrees that Dungey's explanation of magnetic reconnection is actually some kind of electrical discharge analogous to lighting on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball. Nobody. Every argument made to support that nonsense claim has failed. Allow me to repeat: Absolutely nobody here agrees that Dungey's explanation of magnetic reconnection is actually some kind of electrical discharge analogous to lighting on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball. If there is any truth to the claim, the argument has been presented so poorly that it has failed to convince anyone.

So since that alleged "single best piece of support" cannot be produced, and the claim that it exists was effectively demonstrated to be a falsehood, let's move on... What is the second best piece of objective support for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?
 
The unnecessary and uncivil personalization is again noted.

There is nothing uncivil about asking you questions and noting your answers in threads in which you WILLINGLY participate. Get over it, and admit already that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares and Dungey claimed! You can't use only 1/2 his work and ignore the other half *ENTIRELY*. :)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom