Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
It is a pity that you do not understand the laws of physics. :)

I understand you don't have a monopole up your sleeve.

Magnetic B lines do not have a source or a sink.

Then Origin the Null is the kinetic energy source of ABSOLUTELY NOTHING!

Magnetic B lines do have an end and a start when they cross a null point because that is their definition (no field = no field lines :jaw-dropp ).

No. It's just a NULL. No B lines exist there, or you could claim B lines exist there at a ZERO strength, but they don't BEGIN there or END there! Holy cow. This is like arguing with five or six stubborn freshman that simply *REFUSE* to believe that B field lines do not begin or end.


Magnetic reconnection is a physical process in highly conducting plasmas in which the magnetic topology is rearranged and magnetic energy is converted to kinetic energy, thermal energy, and particle acceleration.

None of the highlighted things apply to Clinger's vacuum contraption, so NOTHING like "magnetic reconnection" is possible *WITHOUT* plasma! Your own references KILL your own claims!
 
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper VI?

Wow, you really did not read what I posted so here it is again:

EPIC FAIL!
Wow, you really did not read what I posted so here it is again along with your screaming in hopes that you will understand it.:
The paper is cited in the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper. W.D. Clinger did not cite this paper or the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper

Or maybe this is another delusion that you have - that the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper somehow relates to (or was cited in) W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection. Is that right?

P.S. You have not replied to
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper V? yet.

You certainly are displaying a lot of delusions for a paper that is obsolete and not used in MR :eye-poppi.

Your usual usual rant of ignorance and the usual response: MM: W.D. Clinger did demonstrate his claim
 
Tim cited the source/sink paper RC, not Clinger. Keep up with the conversation.

Clinger is up a reconnection creek without a plasma paddle. No particles could possibly experience acceleration in his vacuum contraption.

I didn't FORCE Clinger to claim he could duplicate Dungey's brand of "reconnection" *WITHOUT* a plasma. He did that to himself. The fact he STILL believes he achieved "reconnection" without a plasma or a monopole is just pitiful.
 
...
If you're waiting on me for anything, you'll be waiting a long time.
...

That's strange. If you were to do this:
Present a rigorous mathematical demonstration that monopoles are required for magnetic reconnection. No links; just a straightforward mathematical demonstration of this very obvious truth.

... you would vanquish all your detractors; you would put a new stamp on EM theory; you would either win a Nobel prize for demonstrating the existence of monopoles or you would finally stop all this wrong magnetic reconnection science. How could you let this opportunity pass?
Still waiting...:popcorn1:bigclap
 
MM: No currents in "Relaxation and magnetic reconnection in plasmas"

Tim cited the source/sink paper RC, not Clinger. Keep up with the conversation.
...usual rant of ignorance...
Try reading your own posts. You are the one mentioning this paper (which is not the source/sink paper) and then Clinger (not Tim Thompson).
Keep up with the conversation.

The the bit you are confused about remains: How you get It's all a "current" driven process." from a paper that does not have currents in it?

Is this another delusion?
Have you evidence from the paper for this assertion?
Or have you just made an mistake and are honest enough to admit it?

MM: W.D. Clinger did demonstrate his claim

P.S.
You have not replied to Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper V? yet.
 
That's strange. If you were to do this:


... you would vanquish all your detractors; you would put a new stamp on EM theory; you would either win a Nobel prize for demonstrating the existence of monopoles or you would finally stop all this wrong magnetic reconnection science. How could you let this opportunity pass?
Still waiting...:popcorn1:bigclap

Huh? Project much? You're the "side" claiming to have demonstrated "B LINE reconnection" *WITHOUT* plasma or a monopole, and in your case, not even a NULL.

You folks can't keep your stories straight. I can't possibly win a Nobel for demonstrating something EVERYONE BUT EU HATERS already knows. :) Everyone else understands that B lines do not have beginnings or endings, sources or sinks.

http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/...-maxwells-equations/MIT8_02SC_notes26to30.pdf

This implies that the number of magnetic field lines entering a closed surface is equal to the number of field lines leaving the surface. That is, there is no source or sink. In addition, the lines must be continuous with no starting or end points. In fact, as shown in Figure 13.2.1(b) for a bar magnet, the field lines that emanate from the north pole to the south pole outside the magnet return within the magnet and form a closed loop.
 
Last edited:
http://www.answers.com/topic/magnetic-monopole

Magnetically charged particles. Such particles are predicted by various physical theories, but so far all experimental searches have failed to demonstrate their existence.

The fundamental laws governing electricity and magnetism become symmetric if particles exist that carry magnetic charge. Current understanding of electromagnetic physical phenomena is based on the existence of electric monopoles, which are sources or sinks of electric field lines (illus. a), and which when set into motion generate magnetic fields. The magnetic field lines produced by such a current have no beginning or end and form closed loops. All magnetic fields occurring in nature can be explained as arising from currents.

I can't win the Nobel for teaching people what THEY already know PS. Only your hater crew seems to believe that B lines have beginnings and endings, even *WITHOUT* a monopole. Everyone else believes that monopoles are NOT optional in any B line reconnection process.

Reconnection theory is NOT plasma or current optional.
 
http://www.answers.com/topic/magnetic-monopole



I can't win the Nobel for teaching people what THEY already know PS. Only your hater crew seems to believe that B lines have beginnings and endings, even *WITHOUT* a monopole. Everyone else believes that monopoles are NOT optional in any B line reconnection process.

Reconnection theory is NOT plasma or current optional.

So, explain in your own words why magnetic reconnection requires monopoles and give us a mathematical demonstration of that requirement.
Earlier in this thread I made the point that Gauss's law requires that magnetic lines must instantly reconnect when their topology changes, as in the example of two bar magnets separating and coming back together. This should be simple for you: why are monopoles required as these lines break and instantly reconnect?
 
So, explain in your own words why magnetic reconnection requires monopoles and give us a mathematical demonstration of that requirement.
Earlier in this thread I made the point that Gauss's law requires that magnetic lines must instantly reconnect when their topology changes, as in the example of two bar magnets separating and coming back together. This should be simple for you: why are monopoles required as these lines break and instantly reconnect?

You made a HANDWAVE ALLEGATION, you made no actual "point". I guess haters REALLY do not understand the way a scientific debate is *SUPPOSED* to work. You're supposed to provide PUBLISHED references to support your case. It's not important that I can put things *IN MY OWN WORDS*, it's important that I can show published materials that support my claim, which I have done *ABUNDANTLY* from various classes in EM theory from various universities, including MIT. All of them claim that B field lines have no beginning or end, no source or sink.

You're supposed to reciprocate now and provide a PUBLISHED reference that supports your "point". Do you have one?
 
Last edited:
So, explain in your own words why magnetic reconnection requires monopoles and give us a mathematical demonstration of that requirement.
Earlier in this thread I made the point that Gauss's law requires that magnetic lines must instantly reconnect when their topology changes, as in the example of two bar magnets separating and coming back together. This should be simple for you: why are monopoles required as these lines break and instantly reconnect?

You made a HANDWAVE ALLEGATION, you made no actual "point". I guess haters REALLY do not understand the way a scientific debate is *SUPPOSED* to work.


Actually the way a scientific debate is supposed to work is those who are criticizing a well accepted position, or advocating to replace that position with an alternative, are supposed to make a compelling, quantitative, objective case to support their criticism or alternative position. In this discussion the well accepted position, the contemporary consensus view among the solar/plasma physics community, is that magnetic reconnection exists as a measurable, observable phenomenon and reasonably explains the energy release of solar flares and the heating of the corona.

If criticism or a proposed alternative fails to be objective, valid, or understandable, as it invariably has in this thread, those proposing the criticism or alternative explanation are supposed to concede that their position is untenable. At the very least they are supposed to reconstruct their presentation to make it objective, valid, or understandable.

You're supposed to provided PUBLISHED references to support your case.


No. That would be shifting the burden of proof, a logical fallacy, usually considered to be dishonest, and certain to fail as an argument.

It's not important that I can put things *IN MY OWN WORDS*, it's important that I can show published materials that support my claim, which I have done *ABUNDANTLY* from various classes in EM theory from various universities, including MIT. All of them claim that B field lines have no beginning or end, no source or sink.


If someone is attempting to criticize the state of contemporary physics and/or propose an alternative for something generally accepted as valid, the critic is supposed to make a compelling, quantitative, objective case for their position. That has not been done by any electric Sun proponents, ever, and absolutely not in this thread.

You're supposed to reciprocate now and provide a PUBLISHED reference that supports your "point". Do you have one?


That's just plain silly. Science isn't done by negotiation like haggling over the price of an item at a garage sale. Perpetual Student's point seems to be that no compelling, quantitative, objective case has been made for rejecting the contemporary consensus position that magnetic reconnection is a legitimate phenomenon which indeed does occur, measurably, empirically, and objectively.
 
Actually the way a scientific debate is supposed to work is those who are criticizing a well accepted position, or advocating to replace that position with an alternative, are supposed to make a compelling, quantitative, objective case to support their criticism or alternative position.

I just did. Clinger's "religion" and steadfast attachment to Origin the Null, demonstrates the *OBVIOUS* problem with the NAME chose to describe an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE process in plasmas and flares. It's too vague. It *IMPLIES* something that is not true, namely B field *LINE* reconnection. If you folks can be this confused about the difference between a current driven discharge process in plasma and mythical claims about B field line Beginnings in a NULL, then it's clear that the name chosen stinks to high heaven.
 
Last edited:
That's just plain silly. Science isn't done by negotiation like haggling over the price of an item at a garage sale. Perpetual Student's point seems to be that no compelling, quantitative, objective case has been made for rejecting the contemporary consensus position that magnetic reconnection is a legitimate phenomenon which indeed does occur, measurably, empirically, and objectively.

Er, no. He specifically claimed "reconnection" occurs between a couple of refrigerator magnets, no Origin the NULL required. That is called "magnetic flux change" by the mainstream EM community, not "magnetic reconnection". His claim, his burden of proof.
 
No. That would be shifting the burden of proof, a logical fallacy, usually considered to be dishonest, and certain to fail as an argument.

Huh? No. That's called presenting "real published scientific evidence" to support your case, something NONE of you have done as it relates to "reconnection" in the absence of plasma, and "reconnection" between two refrigerator magnets. In the real world of *PHYSICS*, "reconnection" requires plasma and B field line reconnection requires a monopole. Clinger has neither.

PS has NEITHER. The hater set of claims to this point in time is pure handwaving. Not one published paper supports *ANY* of it!
 
Michael Mozina's burden of proof, part 1

No. It's just a NULL. No B lines exist there, or you could claim B lines exist there at a ZERO strength, but they don't BEGIN there or END there! Holy cow. This is like arguing with five or six stubborn freshman that simply *REFUSE* to believe that B field lines do not begin or end.
Someone else might say it's like arguing physics on an Internet forum with an ignorant pseudoscientist who's in denial about basic scientific facts and cannot support his beliefs with valid arguments.

The "five or six stubborn freshman" who are arguing on the side of physics consist of roughly ten professional physicists (including a plasma physicist), several electrical engineers, and at least two people with MS or PhD degrees in mathematics. The pro-physics team has supported its arguments with references to hundreds of research papers, plenty of fact-filled posts (including more than one hundred each by tusenfem, Tubbythin, Ziggurat, and Tim Thompson), and a simple but explicit derivation of magnetic reconnection from first principles.

It all boils down to this: Michael Mozina's advocacy of an electric sun (whatever that means) has led him to deny many scientific facts. For the past month or so, he has been denying that magnetic reconnection involves magnetic (B) field lines.

In the course of his denials, Michael Mozina has made claims he can't support. He has now declared that he will not even try to support his claims, and is trying to shift his burden of proof onto those who have already proved his claims false.

...
If you're waiting on me for anything, you'll be waiting a long time.
...

That's strange. If you were to do this:
Present a rigorous mathematical demonstration that monopoles are required for magnetic reconnection. No links; just a straightforward mathematical demonstration of this very obvious truth.

... you would vanquish all your detractors; you would put a new stamp on EM theory; you would either win a Nobel prize for demonstrating the existence of monopoles or you would finally stop all this wrong magnetic reconnection science. How could you let this opportunity pass?
Still waiting...:popcorn1:bigclap
That's true. For several weeks now, Michael Mozina has claimed that magnetic reconnection requires magnetic monopoles.

In particular, Michael Mozina has claimed that, in the absence of magnetic monopoles, magnetic field lines cannot begin or end.

Unfortunately for Michael Mozina's argument, hundreds of research papers have shown that magnetic reconnection occurs without monopoles.

Furthermore, we have constructed a simple and explicit counterexample to his claims. Instead of dealing with that counterexample in a scientific way (by accepting it or by showing why it is not a real counterexample), Michael Mozina is just shouting his claims more loudly.

Nothing like BLATANTLY SHIFTING the burden of proof. Right *AFTER* you get Clinger's Null B line beginnor/endor god of the vacuum nonsense *PUBLISHED*, come talk to me again. :)
The claim was Michael Mozina's, so he bears the burden of proving it. His attempt to shift that burden onto us is especially silly because we have already given a mathematically rigorous proof that Mozina's claim is false.

Michael Mozina cannot find anything wrong with the proof, so he must invent other reasons for ignoring it. His suggestion that the proof can be ignored because it hasn't yet been published is hypocritical, because Michael Mozina has no respect for published science either. He is already ignoring hundreds of peer-reviewed papers that describe B field reconnection in space, controlled laboratory experiments, computer simulations, or theory.

Give me a break and quit expecting ME to personally *PROVE* what is already accepted in basic physics. B lines have no source, no sink, no beginning, no end, no ability to "disconnect" nor to "reconnect" to any other magnetic line. If and when one of pulls a monopole out of pocket, let me know. Until then the burden of proof remains on you. Clinger's claims are utterly absurd. NOTHING begins in a NULL!
Here Michael Mozina is demonstrating his mathematical incompetence for all to see. It is true that B field lines have no source and no sink, and Gauss's law for magnetism does indeed imply there are no monopoles.

On the other hand, Michael Mozina's claim that B field lines cannot have a beginning or end, and cannot "disconnect" or "reconnect", is false. We have shown him an explicit counterexample to those claims, and we have cited many papers, including this simple acknowledgement of magnetic reconnection by the Nobel Prize winning physicist that Michael Mozina wants us to believe is on Mozina's side:
Hannes Alfvén said:
[Maxwell] defined a magnetic field line as a line which everywhere is parallel to the magnetic field. If the current system which produced the field changes, the magnetic field changes and field lines can merge or reconnect.
Michael Mozina ignores Alfvén's clear statement, because he'd rather misinterpret Alfvén's condemnation of the frozen-in approximation.

Bull. You already called me a fraud and now you're leaning on me to DISPROVE a negative, not to mention DISPROVE nothing more than a handwave! The HELL you don't have a "side".
Michael Mozina's claim is indeed negative. It is indeed impossible for Michael Mozina to prove that negative claim, not because his claim is negative but because it's false.

The pro-physics side claims there are no sources, sinks, or monopoles. We can prove those negatives, because they're immediate consequences of Gauss's law for magnetism.

Michael Mozina's claim is widely believed to be a consequence of Gauss's law for magnetism, but it is not.

That Michael Mozina would believe the myth is understandable.

That Michael Mozina clings to the myth in the face of an explicit counterexample he cannot dispute is incompetent.

That Michael Mozina responds to the counterexample by shouting baseless allegations about the incompetence of his pro-science opponents is crackpot.

No, I already know what is true because I own, have read and understand the plasma physics textbooks I've read on this topic. You do not even understand BASIC EM theory or you wouldn't *STILL* (to this very day) be one your knees in steadfast prayer to ORIGIN the fake beginor and endor of B line god of the universe.
Michael Mozina says he understood those plasma textbooks, but Michael Mozina has proved himself to be an unreliable judge of who understands what.

You've *CLAIMED* to have achieved B line reconnection without a plasma and without a monopole. I've never seen *ANYTHING LIKE* it in print, nor could you provide me with any references to support that claim. Since it's obviously "new and uncharted territory", you're sure to be famous, right?
As Reality Check and others have noted, Somov's section 4.4.2 describes magnetic reconnection in a vacuum. As tusenfem noted, Somov's example is basically the same as mine except Somov moves the currents farther apart instead of reducing the current.

This is well-charted territory, and I'm not going to become famous for re-deriving a simple consequence of Maxwell's equations that's already been published in a book.

Note, however, that Michael Mozina says he's "never seen *ANYTHING LIKE* it in print", even though Somov's book is one of the five plasma textbooks Michael Mozina claims to have read and understood.

Wow, you really did not read what I posted so here it is again:

EPIC FAIL!

His explanation amounts to nothing more than a bush-league freshman mistake on basic EM theory.
That's the kind of argument we expect from crackpots. They can't refute the math, and they don't understand the science, so all they can do is shout, boast of the books they've read without understanding the math, and launch silly personal attacks against real scientists.

FYI, you've yet to deliver on YOUR claims PS. I've provided PUBLISHED works to support my case.

http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/...-maxwells-equations/MIT8_02SC_notes26to30.pdf

This implies that the number of magnetic field lines entering a closed surface is equal to the number of field lines leaving the surface. That is, there is no source or sink. In addition, the lines must be continuous with no starting or end points. In fact, as shown in Figure 13.2.1(b) for a bar magnet, the field lines that emanate from the north pole to the south pole outside the magnet return within the magnet and form a closed loop.
That is Michael Mozina's most useful contribution to this thread in several weeks. The highlighted text asserts the popular myth I've refuted. Although I've been looking for a statement of that myth in print, because any repetition of that myth by a reputable source would give me an excuse to publish a refutation, I hadn't found one. Now Michael Mozina has given me the citation I needed. Thanks!
 
Last edited:
So tell me Clinger,

Which scientific publication did you intend to submit your "work" to for publication and a real peer review process that you'll personally accept?

Did you find a single published work that supports your ridiculous claims that "reconnection" can occur without a plasma yet? You'll be famous if you're right!
 
Last edited:
The "five or six stubborn freshman" who are arguing on the side of physics consist of roughly ten professional physicists (including a plasma physicist), several electrical engineers, and at least two people with MS or PhD degrees in mathematics.

There are only evidently TWO of you that actually own and have read a book on plasma physics. :) Get over yourselves already. :) This is just one *HATER* board. I don't think your "presentation" would have gone over so well over at Thunderbolts for instance. You've had it *EASY* here because nobody has demanded at thing from you besides me.

When debating most "creationists" they typically rely on an EXTERNAL source of "truth", typically a single religious text. In your cases, you all evidently consider YOURSELVES to the source of all truth. Not once have you provided anything PUBLISHED to support ANY of your claims about producing "reconnection" *WITHOUT* plasma. You've set yourselves up PERSONALLY as the source of all truth. :) Wow. Your Origin the Null religion is really quite an exclusive little religion. I guess only the half dozen of so of you that buy into your Origin the beginning of B lines religion are "sources of truth" eh? Nobody else on planet EARTH has EVER published such materials eh?
 
Last edited:
So tell me Clinger,

Which scientific publication did you intend to submit your "work" to for publication and a real peer review process that you'll personally accept?

Did you find a single published work that supports your ridiculous claims that "reconnection" can occur without a plasma yet? You'll be famous if you're right!

Since Clinger's presentation is consistent with established science, it does not merit publication -- other than being a candidate for a textbook demonstration. However, your claim that magnetic connection requires monopoles, if demonstrated, would be revolutionary and would be a huge contribution to science. So, let's see your mathematical analysis that magnetic reconnection requires monopoles.
Still waiting.
:popcorn6
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom