Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
If James Dungey allegedly suggested solar flares and CMEs were somehow...
....related to electrical discharges in plasma, you'd think that you and RC would accept that conceptual understanding of plasma physics. Any particularly LOGICAL reason you don't?


Quoting the first eleven words of my comment, ignoring the rest, and following with a juvenile non sequitur and uncivil personal attack does not in any way address the concern. My entire comment follows...

If James Dungey allegedly suggested solar flares and CMEs were somehow analogous to lightning here on Earth, and since lightning requires the breakdown of a dielectric medium, then Dungey surely mentioned how that dielectric medium plays into his theory of magnetic reconnection. This part of my comment was ignored...

An electrical discharge like lightning on Earth requires the breakdown of a dielectric medium. Apparently Dungey's description of the process of magnetic reconnection in a solar flare doesn't actually support the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball. So the very best piece of support for the claim doesn't support the claim at all.​

A specific reference to Dungey's description of that lightning-like electrical discharge would go a long way towards supporting the claim that he was in fact making such a suggestion. An objective reference. That means when we all review the alleged support, neutrally, without the bias of being an electric Sun believer, we all come to the conclusion that Dungey did indeed mean his "magnetic reconnection" wasn't magnetic reconnection after all. Objectively, meaning we independently agree that what he really meant by "magnetic reconnection" was actually some kind of electrical phenomenon like lightning or the sparks in a toy plasma ball. It is essentially the answer to Reality Check's concern quoted here...


No specific objective reference to Dungey describing magnetic reconnection as a lightning-like electrical discharge, as something akin to the sparks in a toy plasma ball, has been provided. It has not been objectively shown that Dungey meant something other than magnetic reconnection when he used the term magnetic reconnection.

In regards to this exchange...

What is the single best piece of support anyone has seen in this discussion, objective support if any exists, for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?

That would be Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.


The single best piece of support for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball is Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory. So since that is the best piece of support available, show us exactly and objectively where he wrote that. Objectively. So that different people can assess the reference and independently come to the conclusion that he did mean a lightning-like electrical discharge and that he did not mean magnetic reconnection.

And if it can't be objectively shown that Dungey actually took that position, then that alleged single best piece of support does not exist.
 
The math that says they reconnect

:) NO!

You don't even understand your own math. Without plasma, they say NOTHING reconnects. 0+0=0 so literally *NOTHING* begins, ends or RECONNECTS there.

When Michael Mozina quoted me, he left out the link to a mathematically rigorous proof that reconnection occurs without plasma, within a region of complete vacuum.

Must have been an honest mistake. Here, I'll fix it for him:

Magnetic field lines form and, as they move,
Combine: nor can thy shouts of "NULL!" remove
The math that says they reconnect sans
Plasma, in a vacuum, though you disapprove:
​

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/mr100.gif[/qimg]

That animation, by the way, shows magnetic reconnection sans plasma, in a vacuum. That animation was derived directly from Maxwell's equations:

http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/

Mathematically speaking, my personal math skills aren't even relevant to this discussion.
That would be true if Michael Mozina weren't making any mathematical claims, or were presenting solid mathematical arguments, instead of expecting us to accept said claims on his own authority.

Unfortunately, Michael Mozina has been making mathematical claims without presenting valid mathematical arguments in support of his claims. (In fact, the first quotation above contains one of the many incorrect claims that Michael Mozina left unsupported in that one post.)

He seems to think we should trust his personal math skills.

Alfven rejected their nonsense and terminology for HIS ENTIRE LIFE and had their math skills and more.
The first part of that sentence is untrue (see below).

The second (highlighted) part is unlikely.

Alfvén's mathematical skills were comparable to what you'd expect of someone with a PhD in electrical engineering or physics. He was certainly competent in vector calculus and differential equations, but Michael Mozina has presented no evidence that Alfvén ever studied mathematical logic (including model theory, computability theory, set theory, proof theory), partial orders, algebraic structures (such as groups, rings, fields), measure theory, functional analysis (including Banach and general Hilbert spaces), differential geometry, point set or algebraic topology, numerical analysis, computer science, or optimization theory.

In each of those topics (which were selected from a standard Mathematics Subject Classification), it is likely that "their math skills" exceed Alfvén's.

As for the first part of Michael Mozina's sentence, Alfvén explicitly acknowledged the fact that magnetic reconnection is a consequence of Maxwell's equations:

Alfvén said:
[Maxwell] defined a magnetic field line as a line which everywhere is parallel to the magnetic field. If the current system which produced the field changes, the magnetic field changes and field lines can merge or reconnect.
That's what all of the competent participants in this thread have been saying. When Michael Mozina denies magnetic reconnection (which he has been doing for years), Michael Mozina is arguing with Hannes Alfvén.
 
Useless (?) Book List

None of the four of you real EU haters even owns a book on plasma physics, let alone have read one.
Tim Thompson has displayed a good knowledge of plasma physics and cited books on plasma physics, e.g. Priest & Forbes. He probably owns at least 1 book on plasma physics.


I suspect that comment was not intended to include me. Although Mozina suffers from the delusion that I choose "hate" over physics, he surely know by now that I own as least one plasma physics book. But this did start me to wonder how many plasma physics books I actually do own. Once I started looking through my library of about 3000 or so books (mostly math, physics, astronomy, chess, & history) I surprised myself. So, for what it's worth, I will include here an exhaustive list of all the plasma physics books I own.
  • Fundamentals of Plasma Physics, Paul M. Bellan; Cambridge University Press, 2006
  • Plasma Physics for Astrophysics, Russell M. Kulsrud; Princeton University Press, 2005
  • The Physics of Plasmas, T.J.M Boyd & J.J. Sanderson; Cambridge University Press, 2003
  • Magnetic Reconnection: MHD Theory and Applications, Eric Priest & Terry Forbes; Cambridge University Press, 2000
  • Space Physics: An Introduction to Plasmas and Particles in the Heliosphere and Magnetospheres, May-Britt Kallenrode; Springer 2001 (2nd edition)
  • Plasma Astrophysics, Toshiki Tajima & Kazunari Shibata; Advanced Book Program, Perseus Publishing, 2002 (this is a reprint of the book originally published in 1997 or 1998 by Addison Wesley in the Frontiers in Physics series)
  • Strong Double Layers in Astrophysical Plasmas, Martin Volwerk; PhD thesis, University of Utrecht, Netherlands, 1993 (complements of the author; I will leave it to the attentive reader of this thread to see if they might recognize who this is)
  • Nonlinear Magnetohydrodynamics, Dieter Biskamp; Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Monographs on Plasma Physics I, 1993 & 1997
  • Cosmic Plasma, Hannes Alfven; D. Reidel Publishing Co., 1981
  • Space Physics: The Study of Plasmas in Space, R.L.F. Boyd; Oxford University Press, Oxford Physics Series 1974
  • Foundations of Plasma Dynamics, E.H. Holt & R.E. Haskell; Mac Millan Co., 1965
  • Elementary Plasma Physics, Conrad Longmire; Interscience Publishers (John Wiley & Sons) 1963
  • Interplanetary Dynamical Processes, E.N. Parker; Interscience Monographs and Texts in Physics and Astronomy, 1963
  • The Theory of Plasma Waves, Thomas Stix; McGraw-Hill Book Co., Advanced Physics Monographs Series, 1962
  • Plasma Physics, J.G. Linhart; North-Holland Publishing Co., 1961 (2nd edition)
  • Introduction to the theory of ionized gases, J.-L. Delacroix; Interscience Tracts on Physics and Astronomy #8, 1960
  • Physics of fully ionized gases, Lyman Spitzer, Jr.; Interscience Tracts on Physics and Astronomy #3, 1956

One downside of having too many books is that I have occasionally forgotten that I have a book and buy another one. So I have two copies of several books. One of them is on this list; I have two copies of Alfven's Cosmic Plasma, one which I bought when it came out in 1981, and the other I bought about 20 years later when I forgot or didn't notice that I already had it. I can't claim to have literally read every single book from cover to cover, but I have used them all as references from time to time. For the discussion in this thread, and related JREF threads, I have mostly used the top 4 books on the list, plus Biskamp's book and Volwerk's PhD thesis.

My degrees were earned in the Physics Department at California State University, Los Angeles. There were no specific courses in plasma physics so my formal, academic education in plasma physics is limited to the general overview that comes naturally in the courses I did take in electromagnetism, solid state physics and astrophysics. Other than that, I am essentially self-taught. Not the easiest thing in the world perhaps, but not a huge strain either; a master's degree in physics is pretty good preparation for that sort of self teaching, a fact I have come to appreciate over the years. I also encountered plasma physics in my professional career, and even have coauthored one published paper in the field of solar system space plasma physics (Bolton, et al., 1989) in which our group describes the infiltration of solar wind plasma through the "back door" of the Jovian magnetic field and into the inner magnetosphere.

Of course, I also own a long list of books on the general topic of electromagnetism, but I will not bore you further with another list (but I do have all 3 editions of Jackson's Classical Electrodynamics, which is quite useful, since the chapter on plasma physics in the 2nd edition was deleted to make room for other subjects in the 3rd edition).

Only the books specifically on plasma physics or magnetohydrodynamics make mention of magnetic reconnection, and none of them make any reference to magnetic monopoles. This is not because the authors are all too biased or too stupid to include them, it's because they are genuinely & really irrelevant to the process.
 
I suspect that comment was not intended to include me.

No, it wasn't. You always (never otherwise) argue with PUBLISHED materials and you've at least READ them. You get grumpy sometimes and attack the individual, but hey, at least most of your posts are worth the read.

Only the books specifically on plasma physics or magnetohydrodynamics make mention of magnetic reconnection, and none of them make any reference to magnetic monopoles. This is not because the authors are all too biased or too stupid to include them, it's because they are genuinely & really irrelevant to the process.

Of course monopoles are irrelevant to the reconnection process because there is no B field LINE reconnection occurring in "magnetic reconnection". Magnetic reconnection is an electrical discharge process in *PLASMA*. :)
 
Last edited:
When Michael Mozina denies magnetic reconnection (which he has been doing for years), Michael Mozina is arguing with Hannes Alfvén.

That absurd lie is so ridiculous it's hard to know where to start. Alfven utterly REJECTED MR theory as *PSEUDOSCIENCE* and REPLACED IT with a double layer in any current carrying environment. He's like you guys only in reverse. He ONLY talked about the E orientation. I personally *DO NOT* reject the PROCESS called "reconnection", I rejected the NAME given to the PROCESS because it's confusing as your 11 month ordeal clearly demonstrates. You don't even understand your own math formulas!

In a VACUUM, your formulas amount to 0+0=0, demonstrating CONCLUSIVELY that NOTHING could possibly be a source a sink, a beginning or end in ORIGIN, the magic EMPTY NULL. Get off your damn knees already. Origin is a false B god. He's no source or sink, no beginning or end of any B line. It's just a NULL for goodness sake!

You STILL do not accept or understand that plasma and current are NOT OPTIONAL in the "magnetic reconnection' process. That's why I reject the name. You're all clueless as to the fact you would NEED a monopole to get B field line reconnection in a vacuum (or anywhere else), and you'll need PLASMA AND CURRENT to get "magnetic reconnection"! Holy cow.

Pitiful.
 
Last edited:
Well I know you don't have any integrity at all, so I won't be losing any sleep over your perception of my lack of humour.

Eh? For a supposed 'skeptic' that hasn't spent any time at all quizzing the other side yet, you sure are pretty cavalier about integrity.
 
Quoting the first eleven words of my comment, ignoring the rest,

The rest isn't relevant. The first part demonstrates conclusively that you're *STILL* in pure denial of the scientific fact that the term "magnetic reconnection" refers to a PROCESS in plasma and solar flares that results in an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE in the plasma. If you can't embrace *THAT SIMPLE SCIENTIFIC FACT*, there's no hope you'll embrace reality as a whole.
 
That would be true if Michael Mozina weren't making any mathematical claims, or were presenting solid mathematical arguments, instead of expecting us to accept said claims on his own authority.

Um, that behavior is called "projection". You're the one MAKING UP materials as you go, materials that have NOT EVER been "published" or peer reviewed in any way and that could never GET published because they're so ridiculous.

You set yourself up as the THE authority on DUNGEY's brand of "reconnection" over 11 months ago. You claimed you could generate magentic reconnect *WITHOUT* plasma, and then you perpetrated BLATANT FRAUD at the end of your presentation and put plasma back in! You're the one insisting that your own NON PUBLISHED BS is the "be-all-end-all" of "magnetic reconnection' truth without ever reading a book on plasma physics!

I've ALWAYS cited published materials to support my case, whereas you have NEVER done so.
 
Last edited:
The rest isn't relevant. The first part demonstrates conclusively that you're *STILL* in pure denial of the scientific fact that the term "magnetic reconnection" refers to a PROCESS in plasma and solar flares that results in an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE in the plasma. If you can't embrace *THAT SIMPLE SCIENTIFIC FACT*, there's no hope you'll embrace reality as a whole.


The persistent juvenile, uncivil personal attacks and total avoidance of the substantive issue is noted. Here's the exchange I'm working from...

What is the single best piece of support anyone has seen in this discussion, objective support if any exists, for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?

That would be Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.


Either this is true...

The single best piece of support for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball is Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.​

... or it isn't. If it is true, it should be easy enough to support specifically and objectively. If it is true, there shouldn't be any reason on Earth to avoid providing support for it. If it's objectively true, it shouldn't require anyone to already believe some particular thing or other to accept it. It's either objectively supportable or it isn't. It's either true or it isn't. As long as there is no objective support -- and objective doesn't mean some stupid argument like someone used this term here and that phrase there... voila -- as long as there is no objective support, the claim can and will be dismissed. That's science.

So if it is true, provide the support. And if it's not true, acknowledge that and leave it behind.
 
figure1zoom.png


b5zoom.png


Let's play a game Clinger. Let's play that game, "What's different about these two images?" You created them so you certainly should be able to tell us the difference between "Origin the NULL (without plasma)" and "Origin the Neutral" (with plasma). Can you tell us the difference(s) between them? Hint: What's the white dot thingy in the middle of Origin the Neutral? Why is it missing from Origin the Null?
 
Last edited:
There is nothing uncivil in asking you if you agree with Dungey that electrical discharges occur in flares and plasma? Do you?


The juvenile and uncivil taunting above doesn't appear to address the substantive issue of Dungey's use of the term "magnetic reconnection" and whether he actually meant something entirely different when he used it. Without any support for the alleged truth of this claim...

The single best piece of support for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball is Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.​

... the question has no relevance. If there is no objective support for the claim, if the claim is simply subjective, a silly argument based on Dungey's use of a word here and a phrase there, then it will be dismissed. So far it appears that the claim is unsupportable.

I predict that this...

What is the single best piece of support anyone has seen in this discussion, objective support if any exists, for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?

That would be Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.


... will be avoided forever, and that no objective support for this claim...

The single best piece of support for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball is Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.​

... will ever be provided. I predict that although this is supposedly about "the single best piece of support", every effort will be made to abandon it in favor of more silly semantic arguments. As with 100% of other alleged support for the electric Sun conjecture, this "single best piece of support" will fail to materialize.
 
Last edited:
The juvenile and uncivil taunting above doesn't appear to address the substantive issue of Dungey's use of the term "magnetic reconnection" and whether he actually meant something entirely different when he used it.

That's quite an irony overload all things considered. You won't answer even a simple direct question related to Dungey's ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE claims. You'll accept his maths, and evidently SOME of the terms that you like to parrot, but you refuse to embrace or fully discuss ALL of them. There's no point in you and I trying to have a discussion on Dungey's paper related to the reconnection processes that lead to electrical discharges in plasmas and flares if you refuse to embrace the fact that electrical discharges occur in plasma. :) What's the point? About the only motive I can think of for you avoiding such simple direct questions is you won't be able to continue your constant cyber-harassment if you answer them directly.
 
Last edited:
MM explains his confusion, part 10

I've ALWAYS cited published materials to support my case, whereas you have NEVER done so.
Michael Mozina must have missed this reference to published material:

Alfvén said:
[Maxwell] defined a magnetic field line as a line which everywhere is parallel to the magnetic field. If the current system which produced the field changes, the magnetic field changes and field lines can merge or reconnect.
Come to think of it, Michael Mozina must have overlooked my references to another paper by Alfvén, as well as my citations of Purcell's Electricity and Magnetism, Jackson's Classical Electrodynamics, Yamada et al's survey of magnetic reconnection, and Priest and Forbes' Magnetic Reconnection.

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/figure1zoom.png[/qimg]

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/b5zoom.png[/qimg]

Let's play a game Clinger. Let's play that game, "What's different about these two images?" You created them so you certainly should be able to tell us the difference between "Origin the NULL (without plasma)" and "Origin the Neutral" (with plasma). Can you tell us the difference(s) between them? Hint: What's the white dot thingy in the middle of Origin the Neutral? Why is it missing from Origin the Null?
As I have explained both here and at my web site, the first image above shows the magnetic field that Michael Mozina would have observed had he not run away from the experiment I've been recommending to him since last December, and the second image above is the magnetic field he would have observed in a slight variation of that experiment that adds a fifth rod at the origin.

Both of those images show magnetic fields within a vacuum, without plasma.

Both of those magnetic fields would look almost exactly the same if a uniform thin plasma were at rest with respect to the coordinate system shown.

For the first of those images, I have presented a mathematical proof that magnetic reconnection occurs when the current running through the north and south rods (which are both well out of the picture) is varied.

I have also produced several animations of that magnetic reconnection, including these two:

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/mr100.gif[/qimg]

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/mr00.gif[/qimg]

The first of those two animations shows magnetic reconnection that occurs when the current running through the north and south rods is varied between 999.9 and 1000.1 amperes. The second animation shows the more dramatic magnetic reconnection that occurs when the current within the north and south rods is reduced from 1000 amperes to zero and back to 1000.

I have not presented a proof that magnetic reconnection occurs with the second image when the current running through the fifth rod (at the origin) is increased, but magnetic reconnection does in fact occur under those circumstances as well, and I have presented an animation of that magnetic reconnection:

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/mr5origin.gif[/qimg]

Michael Mozina has displayed extreme confusion concerning the following point, so it bears repeating:
All of the magnetic fields shown in those images and all of the magnetic reconnections shown in those animations can be demonstrated without plasma, in a vacuum, with current running only through the four or five rods whose arrangement is described within parts 3, 4, and 5 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.
​

Although it would violate forum rules to list all sources of Michael Mozina's confusion, he is probably confused in part by the fact that both of the images above (showing the magnetic fields generated by four or five current-carrying rods) are highly relevant to J W Dungey's 1958 paper, which I discussed at some length in part 5 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

As I showed in part 3 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, both of Dungey's two figures can be duplicated using only the four rods that generate the first image above.

Adding the fifth rod as in the second image above allows us to generate a plasma-free magnetic field in a vacuum that serves as an idealized mathematical model for understanding the reversal of Lenz's law in plasma, which is the main result of Dungey's paper. I went through all that in part 5 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

For the easily amused and for those who remain skeptical of the Dunning-Kruger effect, I have put together a severely abridged history of Michael Mozina's attempts to avoid learning anything about magnetic reconnection or about the plasma physics discussed in J W Dungey's 1958 paper.
 
As I have explained both here and at my web site, the first image above shows the magnetic field that Michael Mozina would have observed had he not run away from the experiment I've been recommending to him since last December, and the second image above is the magnetic field he would have observed in a slight variation of that experiment that adds a fifth rod at the origin.

Edit: Why did you add a fifth rod at that location Clinger?

Adding the fifth rod as in the second image above allows us to generate a plasma-free magnetic field in a vacuum that serves as an idealized mathematical model for understanding the reversal of Lenz's law in plasma, which is the main result of Dungey's paper. I went through all that in part 5 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

Essentially all you're doing is adding MORE RODS to the experiment then? The last rod is supposed to represent CURRENT in the plasma I presume?

Did you write Scientific American yet and tell them you could demonstrate B field line sources and sinks, the beginning and endings and B lines in the NULL of a vacuum, and do it *WITHOUT* monopoles yet? I'm sure they'll be fascinated.
 
Last edited:
with apologies to Coleridge, Carroll, Marvell, Housman


In certainty did Michael M
a pseudoscience thread decree.​
All fluxy did his plasma swim
with jubjubicity.​


Had we but world enough, and time,
Debating Mike would be no crime.​
Kruger-Dunning threads could grow
Vaster than empires, and more slow.​


But iron-shelled suns are not real stuff.
Two thousand posts were quite enough.​
Tequila, more than Michael, can
Reveal Mozina's mind to man.​
​
 
For the easily amused and for those who remain skeptical of the Dunning-Kruger effect, I have put together a severely abridged history of Michael Mozina's attempts to avoid learning anything about magnetic reconnection or about the plasma physics discussed in J W Dungey's 1958 paper.

Dungey's paper discussed *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES* in PLASMA. Your part 4 was a *KLUDGED DISASTER*. No discharge. No sources, sinks, beginnings or endings of B lines from Origin the NULL as you claimed. EPIC FAIL.
 
Last edited:
I don't recall if you came out of the closet Clinger and stated publicly that electrical discharges can and do occur in "reconnection" processes, plasmas and solar flares yet? Yes or no?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom