Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
MM: Show the mistakes in a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 3

And he did show that "The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can be reproduced without plasma." in a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 3.

You reply with a rant about kludging and incoherent gibberish. Either put up or shut up:
MM: Show the mistakes (kludges) in a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 3
​
You already demonstrated that Somov's "vacuum" contains current and plasma. Epic fail.
Epic fail: Somov states that his vacuum contains 2 parallel currents and shows that the MR happens in vacuum away from the currents.
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section II
 
Clinger's derivation amounts to 0+0=0 in a vacuum and his derivation is fine.
That is gibberish.
Clinger's derivation amounts to magnetic reconnection in a vacuum exists. He never adds zero to zero.

Origin the vacuum NULL is a fraud.
More gibberish


He's no B line source, nor any B line sink, nor the beginning or ending of any B line.
Yes, there is no B line source in his posts (that would violate Gauss's law for magnetism).
Yes, there is no B line sink in his posts (that would violate Gauss's law for magnetism).

But you persist with your ignorance - B lines do break, i.e. end and start (and this does not violate Gauss's law for magnetism because the breakage does not form form sources or sinks):
and MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II

P.S.
Your statement merely demonstrates Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma.



And more unsupported statements
  • Dungey never uses the term "electrical discharge process"
  • Dungey does not state that a electrical discharge is magnetic reconnection.
I will give you a chance to retract these assertions before adding then to the delusions post.
Since these assertions are obviously wrong from reading his paper, it will be easy for you to retract them.
Unless I am wrong, in which case you can quote the usage of "electrical discharge process" from his paper and his statement that a electrical discharge is magnetic reconnection.
 
Last edited:
Get off the denial/hate-go-round already! No amount of questioning my scientific integrity is going to save you from Dungey's use of the term "electrical discharge" GM.


This uncivil personal attack doesn't seem like a relevant response to this exchange...

What is the single best piece of support anyone has seen in this discussion, objective support if any exists, for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?

That would be Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.


If James Dungey allegedly suggested solar flares and CMEs were somehow analogous to lightning here on Earth, and since lightning requires the breakdown of a dielectric medium, then Dungey surely mentioned how that dielectric medium plays into his theory of magnetic reconnection. This part of my comment was ignored...

An electrical discharge like lightning on Earth requires the breakdown of a dielectric medium. Apparently Dungey's description of the process of magnetic reconnection in a solar flare doesn't actually support the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball. So the very best piece of support for the claim doesn't support the claim at all.​

A specific reference to Dungey's description of that lightning-like electrical discharge would go a long way towards supporting the claim that he was in fact making such a suggestion. An objective reference. That means when we all review the alleged support, neutrally, without the bias of being an electric Sun believer, we all come to the conclusion that Dungey did indeed mean his "magnetic reconnection" wasn't magnetic reconnection after all. Objectively, meaning we independently agree that what he really meant by "magnetic reconnection" was actually some kind of electrical phenomenon like lightning or the sparks in a toy plasma ball. It is essentially the answer to Reality Check's concern quoted here...

Unless I am wrong, in which case you can quote the usage of "electrical discharge process" from his paper and his statement that a electrical discharge is magnetic reconnection.
 
with apologies to Edward FitzGerald and Omar Khayyám

Clinger's derivation is solid, and your objections to it are nonsensical. I hope you believe me when I say that this is not a personal judgement; I am only looking at the math, and Clinger's math works.

Clinger's derivation amounts to 0+0=0 in a vacuum and his derivation is fine. It's his *INTERPRETATION* of his own maths that stink to high heaven. Origin the vacuum NULL is a fraud. He's no B line source, nor any B line sink, nor the beginning or ending of any B line.

If there is a fault in it, you'll have to show it explicitly through mathematics.

Contrary to popular mythology around here, not all KNOWLEDGE is "mathematical" in nature, and not all ERRORS are mathematical in nature! Holy cow. His math simply shows the flow of magnetic lines through a quadropole NULL. His arrows just show the lines as they traverse the NULL. The only *POSSIBLE* way to get B LINE reconnection is via a monopole. There are no SHORTCUTS in physics. No "magnetic B line reconnection" could ever occur in a vacuum. At BEST case he will achieve "magnetic flux changes" by tinkering with the poles. A NULL could never be a "beginning" or an "ending" of any B line. It's a NULL! It's literally NOTHING. It's like saying Origin the great vacuum NULL is the grandfather of my children. That's absurd.



Magnetic field lines form and, as they move,
Combine: nor can thy shouting "NULL!" remove
The math that says they reconnect
In vacuo, sans plasma, though you disapprove:
​


mr100.gif


http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/
 
It also demonstrates, Belz, an inherent lack (by MM) of understanding that math is a just a language (though more structured and rigorous than most others). It’s like claiming “not all KNOWLEDGE” “and not all ERRORS are” Latin, English or even pig-Latin “in nature”. They are all just languages we can use to express such knowledge and hopefully find such errors, the more structured and rigorous the language (like mathematics) the easier it is to do both.
 
Ok, lets' assume they don't touch for a moment. How exactly are magnetic flux changes over time due to the movement of the magnets, *DIFFERENT FROM* "reconnection"? As far as I can tell, you're taking ordinary magnetic flux changes due to magnetic movements and simply relabelling that flux change "reconnection". How is FLUX CHANGE fundamentally different from "reconnection" in your mind? What is the PURPOSE of looking for monopole in your opinion?

The change in magnetic flux around the moving magnets will indeed induce current in plasma (not a vacuum). No B LINES need to disconnect or reconnect to get induced current. What need do we have for "reconnection" when we can explain the same thing with 'magnetic flux change"?

How are poodles different from dogs? While all poodles are dogs not all dogs are poodles. Similarly while all magnetic reconnection events are changes in the field topography not all changes in field topography are reconnection events. Again try it, as you slide the business card type refrigerator magnets past each other you will feel (at some point) some resistance to the sliding. The “magnetic flux changes over time due to the movement of the magnets” are now storing some of the energy you are putting into the motion of the magnets. At some other point the magnets will go from resistance in the direction of motion, an opposing magnetic force, to a magnetic force in the direction of motion (a reconnection event has occurred) and you get some of that stored energy back as “flux changes over time due to the movement of the magnets” as the magnets snap forward. Magnetic reconnection is a specific type of “FLUX CHANGE” that involves some, well, magnetic reconnection. To try to explain it for you non-mathematically, when the magnets in this example are resisting the forward motion you have to put energy into the system to get those “flux changes over time due to the movement of the magnets”. Basically compressing the opposing magnetic fields and stretching the fields of magnetically linked regions. Moving backwards is a lower energy state so the magnetic fields resist that forward motion storing some of the applied energy. Much like compressing and starching springs (as already explained to you before).Eventually you reach a threshold point in the compression, stretching and the position of the magnetic regions such that they can reconnect. Moving forward now becomes a lower energy state and magnets now snap forward releasing some of that stored energy. Again it’s not like we haven’t been over all this before on the other thread.


“What is the PURPOSE of looking for monopole in your opinion?” Well you’re the one that claimed they were required for magnetic reconnection. The latter you can find with a couple of refrigerator magnets, please let us know when you have found the former.
 
After my own attempt to get some traction on this subject by discussing bar magnets with Mozina, I'm not so sure dishonesty alone is the problem here. I sense a real lack of intellectual capacity; Mozina's responses were not unlike what I might expect from a defective Turing machine.


I and others have been over this many times with Michael Mozina before, his continued pretence that these are somehow issues that still need to be specifically addressed is nothing but dishonest.
 
And here you reveal another interesting bit: trying to cover your mathematical inability with some rhetoric about how math isn't important. It is in physics, son.

Emphasis mine.

You're right, its *PHYSICS* son, specifically CHARGED PARTICLES not monopoles.

Some forms of knowledge are NOT mathematical in nature. In fact I would argue that MOST forms of knowledge are not mathematical in nature, they are CONCEPTUAL in nature.

Dungey conceptually understood that electrical discharges occurred in plasmas and specifically in the solar flare processes of the sun. IMO he is ABSOLUTELY correct.

Conceptually however, RC and GM and Clinger are incapable of accepting that CONCEPTUAL FACT. If one accepts the math, one must also embrace the CONCEPTUAL KNOWLEDGE that the math represents. It's entirely possible as this thread demonstrates for one to "do the math" without conceptually embracing it, or even UNDERSTANDING IT AT ALL!

Conceptually speaking, and PHYSICALLY speaking, the NEUTRAL in Dungey's paper is a CURRENT. It's not simply "ORIGIN the fake NULL god of the vacuum" because Dungey is discussing PLASMA PHYSICS and CHARGED PARTICLES. His descriptions cannot and never could occur in the absence of plasma as Clinger has claimed from the start.

At the level of PHYSICS, it's charged particles, typically electrons that discharge from the neutral into the X,Y plane. The CURRENT then continues up through the CURRENT CHANNELS that flowing with the magnetic lines *IN PLASMAS*. Priest does the conversion from charged particle kinetic energy into "magnetic charge" in equations 16 and 17 (which are in fact entirely relevant and applicable to this discussion).

Conceptually speaking, Clinger does not even BEGIN to understand the mathematical formulas he has written. All they actually describe are the 4 magnetic fields and their relationship to one another, including that NULL region in a vacuum that equates to ZERO! In a vacuum however there are no charged particles to flow through Origin the big fat NOTHING. Origin is a total wuss in a vacuum. He doesn't have an electron or monopole to his name. He's incapable of being a source or a sink of a B line. He's not the beginning of any B line. He's not the ending of any B line. In fact *IF* Clinger understood his own maths, he'd realize that 0+0=0 and absolutely NOTHING begins there, ends there, or exists there.

Mathematically speaking, my personal math skills aren't even relevant to this discussion. Alfven rejected their nonsense and terminology for HIS ENTIRE LIFE and had their math skills and more.

FYI, in case you are in fact interested in my *ACTUAL* background, rather than the beat up strawman they would like you to believe, I've studied Calculus formally for years, starting in *HIGH SCHOOL* and my passion is solar physics. While my profession doesn't require much calculus (self employed software programmer by trade), my hobbies have kept me relatively brushed up over the years. I can at least follow along in most papers that I read, although I admit that eigenstates of neutrino maths are still murky to me personally. Most of the rest of it is straight forward from my perspective, including Priest's little manipulations at equations 16 and 17.

I've also studied basic EM theory and spent more than a decade repairing circuit boards and doing basic repair work on general electronics equipment related to the security industry. I'm pretty competent with basic theory and I've read through at least 5 textbooks on plasma physics over the past decade, more than all the true haters in this thread combined.

The basic problem for Clinger is that he backed himself into a monopole corner *WITHOUT* plasma. With plasma one can get CURRENT to run through ORIGIN the NULL and ORIGIN grows up and becomes a NEUTRAL in the realm of plasma physics. None of Clinger's mathematical equations are particularly impressive to me, and the fact he hasn't understood them and the fact that 0+0=0 is the whole problem.

Let's be honest now. Clinger claimed he could pull off Dungey's definition of "magnetic reconnection" *WITHOUT* plasmas. Part 5 was pure bait and switch. Part 4 doesn't work as described. Epic fail IMO. He may understand how to produce those maths, but he has no CONCEPTUAL understanding of what they actually mean at the level of PHYSICS.

Like you said, this is PHYSICS.
 
Last edited:
It also demonstrates, Belz, an inherent lack (by MM) of understanding that math is a just a language (though more structured and rigorous than most others). It’s like claiming “not all KNOWLEDGE” “and not all ERRORS are” Latin, English or even pig-Latin “in nature”. They are all just languages we can use to express such knowledge and hopefully find such errors, the more structured and rigorous the language (like mathematics) the easier it is to do both.

But when I showed you the mathematical "error/requirements" in equations 16&17 that kill Clinger's claims about reconnection without a plasma, you folks don't want to deal with it. What's the point of trying to speak pig-Latin with you, when you folk run from the pig-Latin questions? Holy smokes! Tim was the one to provide the relevant source/sink paper so we could look at the pig-Latin. I picked out the pig-Latin problem in Clinger's presentation, and now none of you want to deal with it! Oy Vey. You don't speak your own pig-Latin when it works against your case. In fact you folks provided the paper, and then claimed it wasn't RELEVANT when the pig-Latin jig was up! :)
 
Last edited:
Sheesh, are we now going to get 10 pages of monopole discussion, based on an outdated mathematical tool that has long been replaced by other stuff?

Ah well, anything is better that actually presenting some real physics, is it not MM?

electric discharge, monopole, current reconnection, electric monopole, current discharge, mono, monocharge, electric current. dischargepole.

Man, there is at least the possibility for another 50 pages of this thread.

Maybe you should show us in mathematical detail how you interprete and work with these ominous equations 15 and 16 and 17.
 
Last edited:
I and others have been over this many times with Michael Mozina before, his continued pretence that these are somehow issues that still need to be specifically addressed is nothing but dishonest.

I assure you that whatever disagreements you and I may have, they are honest disagreements. I'm simply trying to understand how you're personally trying to differentiate between ordinary magnetic flux changes in a vacuum and something that requires a monopole, specifically B field *LINE* reconnection.

:confused:
 
“What is the PURPOSE of looking for monopole in your opinion?” Well you’re the one that claimed they were required for magnetic reconnection. The latter you can find with a couple of refrigerator magnets, please let us know when you have found the former.

Let's set the record straight. "Magnetic reconnection" is PROCESS that occurs *INSIDE OF PLASMA* that has NOTHING to do with B *LINE* reconnection. I have claimed and still claim that CURRENT is a requirement for "magnetic reconnection", not monopoles. Your side (specifically Clinger) is the one trying to claim that B lines "reconnect" in the absence of plasma in a NULL! The only maths (pig-Latin) he produced demonstrates conclusively that NOTHING reconnects at the X in a vacuum!

No plasma, no current, no "magnetic reconnection". No monopoles, no B LINE reconnection either.
 
Last edited:
If James Dungey allegedly suggested solar flares and CMEs were somehow...

....related to electrical discharges in plasma, you'd think that you and RC would accept that conceptual understanding of plasma physics. Any particularly LOGICAL reason you don't?
 
How are poodles different from dogs? While all poodles are dogs not all dogs are poodles. Similarly while all magnetic reconnection events are changes in the field topography not all changes in field topography are reconnection events. Again try it, as you slide the business card type refrigerator magnets past each other you will feel (at some point) some resistance to the sliding. The “magnetic flux changes over time due to the movement of the magnets” are now storing some of the energy you are putting into the motion of the magnets. At some other point the magnets will go from resistance in the direction of motion, an opposing magnetic force, to a magnetic force in the direction of motion (a reconnection event has occurred) and you get some of that stored energy back as “flux changes over time due to the movement of the magnets” as the magnets snap forward. Magnetic reconnection is a specific type of “FLUX CHANGE” that involves some, well, magnetic reconnection. To try to explain it for you non-mathematically, when the magnets in this example are resisting the forward motion you have to put energy into the system to get those “flux changes over time due to the movement of the magnets”. Basically compressing the opposing magnetic fields and stretching the fields of magnetically linked regions. Moving backwards is a lower energy state so the magnetic fields resist that forward motion storing some of the applied energy. Much like compressing and starching springs (as already explained to you before).Eventually you reach a threshold point in the compression, stretching and the position of the magnetic regions such that they can reconnect. Moving forward now becomes a lower energy state and magnets now snap forward releasing some of that stored energy. Again it’s not like we haven’t been over all this before on the other thread.

Emphasis mine. I'm honestly trying to understand you, but I can't even find anything I actually disagree with in your post except I'm confused by the part I highlighted. Now I'm totally confused. I'm still DESPERATELY trying to understand how YOU perceive the difference between very ordinary magnetic flux CHANGES and their effect on OBJECTS (cards, charged particles) and "magnetic reconnection". The term "reconnection" seem utterly unnecessary in your description. :confused:
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom