Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
"Without a monopole"...? How may times has this straw man been attacked by that fearless pseudoscientific ditherer, Mr. Mozina. Is this really designed to be persuasive commentary or is it a form of dialectic masturbation?

I refuse to let you try to pass off a PHYSICAL and EMPIRICAL FACT as form of dialectic masturbation. Sorry, you'll have to abide by the laws of physics. You can't just claim *BOTH* monopoles *AND* current are "optional" in "B field line reconnection". That argument is dead in the water in terms of empirical physics.

Clinger's whole presentation was one GIGANTIC fraud, perpetuated over 11 full months. At the end we find out what *I* (at least) knew from the start, he CANNOT achieve even "magnetic reconnection" without "plasma", and he sure as hell won't get "B field line reconnection" in a vacuum without a monopole! Get real. You're starting to sound like a metaphysical cult at this point. You all seem to be in steadfast prayer to "Origin the great NULL, the "beginor and endor" and the magnetic field line universe!" Wake up and smell the coffee. Without CURRENT running through the Z axis, ORIGIN is quite literally *NOTHING*.
 
Last edited:
To answer your question: Michael Mozina probably thinks it is persuasive

Michael Mozina doesn't bark math, so he can't calculate the divergence of a magnetic field, nor can he calculate the magnetic flux of a magnetic field through a closed surface, so Mozina simply cannot tell whether the magnetic fields that demonstrate magnetic reconnection in vacuo obey Gauss's law for magnetism.

NOTHING pretty much obeys ANY LAW on the books Clinger! All you demonstrated *IN A VACUUM* (part four BEFORE the fraud part), was that Origin is a big fat DUD in term of energy. 0+0=0. So what? You conclusively shot yourself in the foot. You conclusively demonstrated that NOTHING happens at X, nothing "begins" at X and nothing ENDS at X either!

Origin is one big wussy of a NULL beginor and endor of B lines god in a vacuum. Give him up already.

Even when you play with the poles, all you'll get is "magnetic flux change" EVERYWHERE, not just in the previous NULL. Again, so what?

Mozina must realize that everyone with basic competence in mathematics or physics is telling him that the divergence is zero,

I never doubted that for a second by the way. So what? It's NOTHING in terms of B field line energy. Big deal. It's not the beginning or the ending of any B line, nor is it a B line sink, or a B line source. It's quite literally NOTHING. When you play with the poles, you'll get "magnetic flux changes over time". Again, no big deal and NOT B line reconnection.

but Mozina doesn't trust mathematical or scientific competence.

Sure I do. I just do not trust that YOU PERSONALLY are scientifically competent as it relates to even *BASIC* EM theory, or you wouldn't be on your knees in prayer to a false B line creation NULL god!

As much as you and PS would love to sweep your missing monopole problem under the rug, it's not going to happen. *ONLY* if monopoles existed *COULD* B line reconnection occur. In the absence of monopoles you'll certainly need PLASMA to get "magnetic reconnection" and that DISCHARGE Dungey describes.

Your whole presentation was a sham, a fraud, and 11 months of angry ranting about maths skills that were utterly irrelevant from the start. You're still in pure denial of the fact that you NEED plasma to get "magnetic reconnection" as defined by Dungey. PERIOD. You lied from day one about being able to do it without plasma, and you UTTERLY refuse to correct your own mistake. Even more amazing IMO is that you have the absolute audacity to blame me for YOUR error! Wow.
 
Last edited:
Okay, so the single best piece of support for the claim that solar flares are electrical discharges like lightning or the sparks in a toy plasma ball is Dungey's description of a solar flare in his description of the process of magnetic reconnection. Maybe we can get some traction here. Specifically, and objectively, how did Dungey state that magnetic reconnection is like lightning? Where, specifically, did he mention the breakdown of a dielectric medium?

Where did Dungey ever claim that a dielectric breakdown was a requirement for an "electrical discharge" to occur in a plasma or a flare?
 
You need to quote this claim rather than persisting with it as a strawman argument.

His claim was:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7782183&postcount=5275

I suggested that experiment to you because it would have helped you to understand that

Dungey is describing magnetic reconnection.
There is no "circuit reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
There is no "current reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can be reproduced without plasma.
The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can occur with a near-zero electric (E) field.

a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 1

Ya, and I had to wait over 10 months for him to handwave a few equations at me, not one of which demonstrates "magnetic reconnection", let alone magnetic reconnection *WITHOUT* plasma.


Part three was a KLUDGED MESS! What a *DISASTER*! That's where he foolishly knelt in prayer to Origin the NULL, the false beginor and endor of all B lines in the UNIVERSE!

MR without plasma is possible as he showed.

Er, no, what he showed is that he didn't even UNDERSTAND his own math, and he KLUDGED basic EM theory! Origin isn't the begining or the ending of ANYTHING because it's NOTHING! Change the poles and it experiences magnetic flux AS DOES THE WHOLE CONTRAPTION, not just X.

You would know this if you could understand Somov's textbook

You already demonstrated that Somov's "vacuum" contains current and plasma. Epic fail.
 
Last edited:
Where did Dungey ever claim that a dielectric breakdown was a requirement for an "electrical discharge" to occur in a plasma or a flare?


I don't think Dungey was stupid enough to make any claim about a lightning-like electrical discharge occurring in a plasma or flare. The dishonest attempt to distract from the actual question is noted.

What is the single best piece of support anyone has seen in this discussion, objective support if any exists, for the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball?

That would be Dungey's description of a solar flare as an "electrical discharge" in his description of the process called "magnetic reconnection" theory.


An electrical discharge like lightning on Earth requires the breakdown of a dielectric medium. Apparently Dungey's description of the process of magnetic reconnection in a solar flare doesn't actually support the claim that solar flares and CMEs are or are caused by an electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth or the sparks in a toy plasma ball. So the very best piece of support for the claim doesn't support the claim at all.
 
I don't think Dungey was stupid enough to make any claim about a lightning-like electrical discharge occurring in a plasma or flare. The dishonest attempt to distract from the actual question is noted.

Get off the denial/hate-go-round already! No amount of questioning my scientific integrity is going to save you from Dungey's use of the term "electrical discharge" GM.
 
Get off the denial/hate-go-round already! No amount of questioning my scientific integrity is going to save you from Dungey's use of the term "electrical discharge" GM.

You have no "scientific integrity". To suggest you do would be to suggest you firstly have integrity, (which you apparently do not if your posts are taken at face value), and secondly that you do science, (which you do not, because quantitative science seems completely opaque to you.)

It's not like it's one or two people telling you you're wrong Michael. It's everyone. Every, single, person, who has ever come across your diatribes who has any inkling of physics and mathematics has not just told you you're wrong, but shown you why.

But you persist in this pseudo-intellectual babble about cosmic plasma being the be-all and end-all of physics.

I'm done with this thread. It's gone on far too long to begin with, and just goes in circles as people show why your nonsense, is, well, nonsense over and over again.

I hope others here keep it up. I have more important things to read.
 
IMO The Man, you are confusing magnetic flux changes over time, and the reconnection of solid *OBJECTS* (like magnets or plasma particles), with B field *LINE* reconnection. In plasma (or the vacuum) it's not the monopole that does the work in terms of the kinetic energy transfer, and the making and breaking of B lines. It's the CURRENT through the Z axis that get's "redirected" and INDUCED current in the plasma that does all the actual work in terms of kinetic energy. It's the E field that provides the source and sink for charged particle kinetic energy.

Well then that would make your ‘honest opinion’ an obvious fallacy. As noted before in the other thread the refrigerator magnets need not touch each other. So no “reconnection of solid *OBJECTS*” as you apparently still like to pretend. The only way the magnets are connected are by their magnetic fields. Again get some refrigerator magnets do some experimenting and when you have found your “monopole”, “CURRENT through the Z axis” and “plasma” that you require you be sure to let us know. In all honesty Michael Mozina were these issues not addressed before and on the other thread I might conceded that your opinion was honest but simply misinformed. As we have been over this, no requirement for plasma, no requirement for contact between the magnets and no need for “CURRENT through the Z axis” that you can demonstrate yourself with a couple of refrigerator magnets. Exemplifies that whatever your opinion may be about magnetic reconnection it sure as heck ain’t honest.
 
Last edited:
Well then that would make your ‘honest opinion’ an obvious fallacy. As noted before in the other thread the refrigerator magnets need not touch each other. So no “reconnection of solid *OBJECTS*” as you apparently still like to pretend. The only way the magnets are connected are by their magnetic fields. Again get some refrigerator magnets do some experimenting and when you have found your “monopole”, “CURRENT through the Z axis” and “plasma” that you require you be sure to let us know. In all honesty Michael Mozina were these issues not addressed before and on the other thread I might conceded that your opinion was honest but simply misinformed. As we have been over this, no requirement for plasma, no requirement for contact between the magnets and no need for “CURRENT through the Z axis” that you can demonstrate yourself with a couple of refrigerator magnets. Exemplifies that whatever your opinion may be about magnetic reconnection it sure as heck ain’t honest.

After my own attempt to get some traction on this subject by discussing bar magnets with Mozina, I'm not so sure dishonesty alone is the problem here. I sense a real lack of intellectual capacity; Mozina's responses were not unlike what I might expect from a defective Turing machine.
 
You have no "scientific integrity".

More lies and more personal attacks. :( This place is *SO* predictable.

To suggest you do would be to suggest you firstly have integrity, (which you apparently do not if your posts are taken at face value), and secondly that you do science, (which you do not, because quantitative science seems completely opaque to you.)

PURE BS. I have provided LOTS of quantitative support, to support my claims for electrical discharges in plasma starting with Dungey's work and Alfven's work. It's all PUBLISHED WORK.

Clinger took 11 months, handwaved a little bit, and then he pulled a HUGE bait and switch at the end of his presentation. None of you had the intellectual integrity to say a single thing about his bait and switch routine. He has NEVER ONCE yet admitted he NEEDS plasma to get "reconnection", even though part five was a pure bait and switch form of fraud.

It's not like it's one or two people telling you you're wrong Michael. It's everyone. Every, single, person, who has ever come across your diatribes who has any inkling of physics and mathematics has not just told you you're wrong, but shown you why.

Er, no. It's "a number of haters" (and a couple of others) at this one website that *CLAIM* I'm wrong based on materials that:

A) were never published
B) never will be published.
C) could never GET published in the first place!

Holy cow. Not *ONE* of them has produced a published experiment in a vacuum that will produce "reconnection". What I got instead was a completely KLUDGED presentation of basic EM theory followed by a LEAP OF FAITH in something that is PHYSICALLY IMPOSSIBLE without a monopole.

But you persist in this pseudo-intellectual babble about cosmic plasma being the be-all and end-all of physics.

It is a unique and specific branch of physics that just so happens to include "reconnection" theory.

I'm done with this thread. It's gone on far too long to begin with, and just goes in circles as people show why your nonsense, is, well, nonsense over and over again.

I hope others here keep it up. I have more important things to read.

FYI, that's fine by me.
 
Last edited:
Well then that would make your ‘honest opinion’ an obvious fallacy. As noted before in the other thread the refrigerator magnets need not touch each other. So no “reconnection of solid *OBJECTS*” as you apparently still like to pretend.

Ok, lets' assume they don't touch for a moment. How exactly are magnetic flux changes over time due to the movement of the magnets, *DIFFERENT FROM* "reconnection"? As far as I can tell, you're taking ordinary magnetic flux changes due to magnetic movements and simply relabelling that flux change "reconnection". How is FLUX CHANGE fundamentally different from "reconnection" in your mind? What is the PURPOSE of looking for monopole in your opinion?

The change in magnetic flux around the moving magnets will indeed induce current in plasma (not a vacuum). No B LINES need to disconnect or reconnect to get induced current. What need do we have for "reconnection" when we can explain the same thing with 'magnetic flux change"?
 
Last edited:
Oh, so you're done talking about haters ?

Probably not. I will probably always have to differentiate between a typical sort of "hater" argument (usually aimed at the individual) and a real argument related to the topic of discussion, in this case plasma physics.

If the topic were evolutionary theory and this was a religious website, hater arguments would be very different from arguments related to the actual topic of evolutionary theory. Most haters in that case would not own, nor have ever read a book on the topic of evolutionary theory, and a I'd be an "ignorant/evil" spawn/tool of satan with the intellectual capacity of a flee. :)
 
Last edited:
Not in this thread you haven't. If you're talking about Clinger's math, his derivation amounts to 0+0=0, demonstrating conclusively that NOTHING begins, ends or "reconnects" in the NULL in a vacuum.

You have failed to understand, and demonstrated that you're not willing to listen to the explanations so patiently given. Clinger's derivation is solid, and your objections to it are nonsensical. I hope you believe me when I say that this is not a personal judgement; I am only looking at the math, and Clinger's math works.

If there is a fault in it, you'll have to show it explicitly through mathematics. I'll illustrate this with an example.

If Clinger said this:

hypothetical math argument said:
x = y.
Then x2 = xy.
Subtract the same thing from both sides:
x2 - y2 = xy - y2.
Dividing by (x-y), obtain
x + y = y.
Since x = y, we see that
2 y = y.
Thus 2 = 1, since we started with y nonzero.
Subtracting 1 from both sides,
1 = 0.

You would have to say:
hypothetical rebuttal said:
Ah, but you divided by (x - y) at one point. If x = y, then you have divided by zero. This invalidates the proof.

And Clinger would say, "Oh. Woops! Thanks, I found that result rather disturbing."

But if you say:
hypothetical rebuttal said:
One does not equal zero. Your math is wrong.

Clinger would say, "I know the result looks odd, but where is my error?"

If you're not in a position to point out the error in such a way that it is mathematically unambiguous, then you're not in a position to argue with the result in the first place.

PS: Thanks for the note on fixing my tag, Clinger!
 
Last edited:
You have failed to understand, and demonstrated that you're not willing to listen to the explanations so patiently given.

Patiently given? He spent 10 months BERATING my math skills and produced NOTHING during that entire time. Part 1 took FOREVER to drag out of him! I had to SHAME him into do producing anything. The last part of his presentation was pure bait (without plasma) and switch (with plasma) fraud.

Clinger's derivation is solid, and your objections to it are nonsensical. I hope you believe me when I say that this is not a personal judgement; I am only looking at the math, and Clinger's math works.

Clinger's derivation amounts to 0+0=0 in a vacuum and his derivation is fine. It's his *INTERPRETATION* of his own maths that stink to high heaven. Origin the vacuum NULL is a fraud. He's no B line source, nor any B line sink, nor the beginning or ending of any B line.

If there is a fault in it, you'll have to show it explicitly through mathematics.

Contrary to popular mythology around here, not all KNOWLEDGE is "mathematical" in nature, and not all ERRORS are mathematical in nature! Holy cow. His math simply shows the flow of magnetic lines through a quadropole NULL. His arrows just show the lines as they traverse the NULL. The only *POSSIBLE* way to get B LINE reconnection is via a monopole. There are no SHORTCUTS in physics. No "magnetic B line reconnection" could ever occur in a vacuum. At BEST case he will achieve "magnetic flux changes" by tinkering with the poles. A NULL could never be a "beginning" or an "ending" of any B line. It's a NULL! It's literally NOTHING. It's like saying Origin the great vacuum NULL is the grandfather of my children. That's absurd.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom