Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
You're wrong.

I did not use the word "origin" in part 1 or its erratum. I used the word "origin" once in part 2 and 7 times in part 3 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection. Every one of those 1+7=8 uses referred to the origin of a Cartesian coordinate system.

I'll tell you what. Let's make this easy and simple. SIMPLY DO NOT USE THE TERM ORIGIN ANY LONGER and I'll be fine, as long as you explain what the hell you mean by B lines "beginning and ending" at the X. I literally had to find an interpreter to even get a clue what to think about that claim. He says you're wrong and even chastised me for asking him about it. Whom shall I believe, the plasma physicist or some guy I met on the internet that thinks B lines have a beginning and an ending in a magic magnetic NULL point in a vacuum? As far as I can tell you completely confused yourself by moving the null point to the origin and now you think it's the center of the EM field line universe.
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina
I can't answer your question because it's technically OPTIONAL in Peratt's definition and it's optional in EU theory, it's not one or the other.

... but it's still the same fast release of stored EM energy in the form of current, even in a gas.
Finally -- an answer!
So, when a surge of electrical current occurs in plasmas, which are necessarily conducting mediums, you call that a discharge -- no dielectric break down is necessarily involved. So that's it; all this discussion has been about you insisting on an idiosyncratic semantic hang-up.

OK, I now fully agree that discharges* can occur in plasmas and solar flares. I suspect others may not prefer this definition but will agree that surges in electrical current (discharges, in your preferred usage) can occur in plasmas.
See, now you can move on to the real physics of solar flares, which I'm sure you will readily admit, are not like lightning on earth, which do involve the breakdown of a dielectric, namely the atmosphere.

*(Mozina usage) Discharge = surge in electrical current, with or without the breakdown of a dielectric.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm. Define "good evidence" for me. I have "lab evidence" that electrical discharges produce all of the key and important observations related to solar flares, including million degree plasmas, heavily ionized iron, neutron capture signatures, gamma rays, x-rays, etc.

Now that you know that "magnetic reconnection" is a PROCESS IN PLASMA that involves the inducement of an E field in the plasma, followed by an electrical discharge in the plasma, I can happily provide you with any number of papers on MR theory. What kind of evidence do you want?

I didn't ask for "good evidence, please." I said "Good. Evidence, please." It would be nice if you took the time to read properly.

I'm still waiting for evidence.
 
He can make the bottom left of the image 0,0 if he likes. What he won't keep doing is keep referring to the null region as an "origin".

Oh for goodness sake, the fact that you don't understand that "origin" is a well defined word in graphs is just typical for all discussions with you. I guess you now want to rename the term "origin" for graphs as zerozero(zero) point or whatever your mind can come up with.

The fact that Clinger puts the origin (THAT IS THE GRAPH POINT (ZERO, ZERO)) where he does,, is quite clear to anyone who has done some actual calculations of electromagnetic fields, but apparently you have never done something like that. It has to do with the simplification of the equations that you have to use, but hey, equations is not really your forte now, is it.

Okay peeps, let's get ready for several pages of discussion about the term origin and where it should be put in a graph in order not to confuse the only person on the world who might be confused by this: Michale Mozina.
 
Oh for goodness sake, the fact that you don't understand that "origin" is a well defined word in graphs is just typical for all discussions with you.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7745732&postcount=4801

Nah. I think he just confused HIMSELF when he used that term. What the heck is he talking about when he says the B lines have a beginning and ending in the NULL region? I am pretty sure that he just confused himself when he moved the null region to the origin. I believe that the origin of his graph suddenly became the center of the B field universe in his mind the moment he linked it to a graph and put the null region in the middle. I can't think of any other logical reason for him to be talking about the beginning and ending of B lines at the null point.
 
Last edited:
Wow. I can't believe you folks removed my recent post to Clinger where I gave him a grade on his experiment. It's evidently fine for you folks to call me a fraud, and lie about my physics skills on a daily basis, but God forbid I should point out that Clinger KLUDGED a simple quadrapole magnetic field experiment.
 
Last edited:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7745732&postcount=4801

Nah. I think he just confused HIMSELF when he used that term. What the heck is he talking about when he says the B lines have a beginning and ending in the NULL region? I am pretty sure that he just confused himself when he moved the null region to the origin. I believe that the origin of his graph suddenly became the center of the B field universe in his mind the moment he linked it to a graph and put the null region in the middle. I can't think of any other logical reason for him to be talking about the beginning and ending of B lines at the null point.

That link goes to a post of yours, that does not include "origin", nor does the link to the post by Clinger include the word "origin" except in "originally posted by", so ....

At the null-point or X-point the magentic field is zero, in this model. The separatrices, the big X in the figure, are actually degenerate field lines, in the way that they separate one kind of lines from another kind of lines (with respect at to how they are bent). It is two field lines that touch and in this case this can only happen (because of the extreme different directions at X location) when the field is 0, otherwise the field would have different directions at the X point, which naturally it cannot. This way one could say that the field lines along the big X "start" and "end" at the X, as the definition of a field line loses its meaning when there is no field.

Whether or not Clinger puts the origin of the map exactly at the X point, is only a question of doing the math more easily. When you put the X point there, it means that you don't have to worry about the different |x-a| in the denominator, because a will be at the same location in the four differen quadrants. That makes it much much easier to calculate then when, like you want, you put all four currents in the first quadrant and then you have to work with a, b, c and d.

The origin of the graph never ever became the centre of the magnetic universe for Clinger, that you may have read it that way, would not really surprise me.
 
The origin of the graph never ever became the centre of the magnetic universe for Clinger, that you may have read it that way, would not really surprise me.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7743145&postcount=4747

Although I have shown computer-generated graphs of the B field and some of its magnetic field lines, including the four magnetic field lines that begin or end at the neutral point of the X-shaped field in Dungey's figure 1, it is true that I have not shown every single step of the calculations that prove those lines begin or end at the X point.


I need to hear Clinger explain *IN HIS OWN WORDS* what he means by claiming that magnetic lines have a beginning and ending at the X. Keep in mind, that until he gets to part 5 (evidently the plasma switcheroo installment of his presentation), he doesn't have a single atom, proton or electron to his name, just a vacuum. If and when he ever gets to part 5, we'll talk, but any beginning and endings of any B lines have to be explained in step 4, and he may NOT use the term origin in step 4, and it may not include plasma. I do not care what else he does, but I need an explanation from his lips about B lines beginning and ending in the null region in a vacuum and it can't include the term "origin".
 
Last edited:
I'm not asking for much. All Clinger has to do is put a variable name at the X and use positive x,y coordinates at that location. That's it. I have simplified my request to one small change. It's a reasonable request.
 
I need to hear Clinger explain *IN HIS OWN WORDS* what he means by claiming that magnetic lines have a beginning and ending at the X.


Here.

Keep in mind, that until he gets to part 5 (evidently the plasma switcheroo installment of his presentation), he doesn't have a single atom, proton or electron to his name, just a vacuum. If and when he ever gets to part 5, we'll talk, but any beginning and endings of any B lines have to be explained in step 4, and he may NOT use the term origin in step 4, and it may not include plasma. I do not care what else he does, but I need an explanation from his lips about B lines beginning and ending in the null region in a vacuum and it can't include the term "origin".


The term "origin" refers to a location on the graph. It looks like if we substitute "the origin" with "(0,0)" in W.D.Clinger's explanation (something like "s/the origin/\(0\,0\)/ig" should work in a script) it will be exactly the same without using the word "origin".
 
Here.




The term "origin" refers to a location on the graph. It looks like if we substitute "the origin" with "(0,0)" in W.D.Clinger's explanation (something like "s/the origin/\(0\,0\)/ig" should work in a script) it will be exactly the same without using the word "origin".

That so called "explanation" defies the laws of physics. Physical *THINGS* like magnets and CURRENT (moving charged particles) can produce B fields, but no B field lines begin anywhere, or end anywhere. They are all continuous lines, even at their zero points, actually they are whole continuous FIELDS, not even discrete lines! All Clinger's graph shows is a NULL region where NOTHING exists in terms of kinetic energy/magnetic field energy to 'disconnect' or to 'reconnect' to anything else. 0+0=0. His explanation thus far amounts to a freshman bush-league mistake about the fact the the ZERO point of *ANY* magnetic line or lines is *NOT* the "beginning", nor the "ending" of the line(s). It's just another point along it's path! That NULL region isn't even A CREATION POINT of any of those ZERO strength lines, let alone the "beginning" or the "ending" of any of them! Holy cow.
 
Last edited:
I'm not asking for much. All Clinger has to do is put a variable name at the X and use positive x,y coordinates at that location. That's it. I have simplified my request to one small change. It's a reasonable request.

put a variable name at the X???????????????????????

It a stupid request, as I explained above, of which you only seem to be interested in showing where you don't understand Clinger, and anything else I may have said it just lost.

It's always this semantics, isn't it Michael. YOU always want mainstream science to use other words than that they use, not magnetic reconnection but circuit/current/flux reconnection or induction, not origin but "that point at which the axes cross at a value of zero" and so on and so forth. Don't you think it is time that YOU adjust your vocabulary, as any book that you will read will use the mainstream definitions of reconnection, induction, origin, etc. The world does not turn around MM, that's the moziverse.
 
That so called "explanation" defies the laws of physics. Physical *THINGS* like magnets and CURRENT (moving charged particles) can produce B fields, but no B field lines begin anywhere, or end anywhere. They are all continuous lines, even at their zero points, actually they are whole continuous FIELDS, not even discrete lines! All Clinger's graph shows is a NULL region where NOTHING exists in terms of kinetic energy/magnetic field energy to 'disconnect' or to 'reconnect' to anything else. 0+0=0. His explanation thus far amounts to a freshman bush-league mistake about the fact the the ZERO point of *ANY* magnetic line or lines is *NOT* the "beginning", nor the "ending" of the line(s). It's just another point along it's path! That NULL region isn't even A CREATION POINT of any of those ZERO strength lines, let alone the "beginning" or the "ending" of any of them! Holy cow.

Jebus, have you actually read what I have written about the separatrices?
Do you know that magnetic field lines are not physical entities?
Do you know that magnetic fields generated by a current in a wire do not need a plasma to exist, but also expand into vacuum?
Did you ever go back to Petschek and Sweet-Parker reconnection to actually try to understand what is happening in the most simple case?

Answer: NO
 
It's always this semantics, isn't it Michael.

No, absolutely not. It's about physics with me. I came to you to get a "plasma physics" translation of what he was trying to describe, but that doesn't happen till step 5. A degenerate field as you put it is just another polite way of saying that none of those lines have a pennies worth of magnetic energy to their name at that location. It is simply a collection of NON ENDING B lines, with no energy, at that location, nothing more, nothing less. It's literally NOTHING in terms of kinetic energy. That does not justify him claiming that's it's a "beginning" or an "ending" of any of those lines!

My only intent in getting him to move the Null point away from the origin is so he realizes his mistake. Why in the world are you trying to "cover up" his mistake and/or rationalize it away?
 
Last edited:
According to Wikipedia's current article on magnetic fields:

As I'll prove below, that isn't quite true. (To be fair, I've taken that excerpt a little out of context. In the Wikipedia article, those words are immediately qualified by a parenthetical statement that states the complete truth in a mathematically correct way.)

Magnetic B field lines can begin or end at the same neutral points where magnetic reconnection can occur. In what follows, I'll provide a mathematically rigorous proof of that fact, using a simple counterexample to Wikipedia's informal statement above. That counterexample involves the same X-shaped magnetic field that's often used to illustrate magnetic reconnection. First, however, we need a mathematically precise definition of magnetic field lines.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7746071&postcount=4813

Notice here that Clinger's intent seems to be to show us that there is a mathematical exception to the "no beginning, no ending" rule? His *ENTIRE INTENT* was to demonstrate that the NULL POINT was the "beginning and the ending" of every single line. This wasn't a "minor" mistake folks.
 
Last edited:
In terms of posting, welcome to the board and to the discussion by the way. :)

Thank you for the welcome. I am not a prolific poster so please excuse me if I don't reply right away. Thank you for the link to Currents in the Solar Atmosphere and a Theory of Solar Flares. It's actually an interesting read especially from a historical perspective. I am still reading it and studying the implications. To be honest, I'm actually a bit more intrigued with Severny's paper that mapped magnetic fields on the sun. Unfortunately, the only source I've found so far is behind a paywall. I may research it at my local library though.

By the way, if you don't mind me asking, do you keep a personal science journal?
 
Still waiting, Mike.

I'm terribly sorry Belz. It was a busy week at work last week and Clinger had me distracted trying to figure out his mistake. While he figures out his confusion over the origin of the graph and the origin of B fields, let's see if you and I can bring this horrifically derailed thread back on track, shall we?

Let's start by relating this information to some absolutely beautiful satellite images.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=193096&page=84

FYI, before we get started, that link above is a link to a number of related papers that you are welcome to delve into as you get more time.

Now that Dungey has provided us with a "key" to understanding high energy plasma events that are related to electrical discharges in plasma, and to solar flares, let's start by empirically relating (in the lab) those electrical discharge processes to solar flares and solar satellite imagery.

http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1974ApJ...190..467L/0000467.000.html

This paper by Lee is an excellent place to begin because it relates those electrical discharge processes back to SDO (and many other) solar satellite images, specifically all the iron ion wavelengths.

It's early here my time. Let me grab a cup of coffee and I'll post a bit more and round up a few solar satellite images we should look at.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom