Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
15%20April%202001%20WL.gif


While you're taking a gander at that paper by Lee, let's start by relating Dungey's electrical discharge processes in flares back to some satellite imagery. I started with this TRACE white light image of a solar flare over a sunspot because it's what we would actually observe of a flare with the naked eye.

That wonderful paper by Lee allows us to understand and discuss all the Yohkoh, SOHO, GOES, TRACE, Hinode, STEREO, SDO, many other satellites I can't recall off the top of my head, and pretty much all future satellite images. It's important that you read through it and understand it if you want to understand the higher energy wavelengths we observe in solar flare images. If you have any questions while I'm working on rounding up links to relevant images, let me know. I'll try not to bombard you with too much math all at once. Instead I'll work on trying to bring in a little visual appeal to the thread. Let me go check out the sun right now and maybe I'll just start with current events.
 
Last edited:
http://sdo.gsfc.nasa.gov/assets/img/latest/latest_1024_0131.mpg

FYI Belz, I'm not sure about your bandwidth and/or hardware limitations (or lack thereof), so let me know if you're having any trouble with any of the visual links I provide you with.

Once you get comfortable with Lee's presentation you can begin to understand the "iron ion wavelength" (and high energy wavelengths) that are observed in SDO and many other images. We might as well begin with SDO since it is the newest solar gear on the job, it's got high resolution capabilities and very high cadence capabilities.

That link at the top will provide you with a high energy view of the the sun as it appears "right now" (as of the time you click it). It gets updated on a regular basis, so anything you see right now, won't necessarily look exactly the same if you click that same link tomorrow. :)

The other word that you should start to become comfortable with as we progress is the term "magnetic flux loop". Don't let the term fool you, it's a highly energized, *CURRENT CARRYING* filament. It's shaped like a tightly wound tornado filament near the area where it touches the Earth. It looks pretty much like the filaments you might observe in an ordinary plasma ball from the store. That current carrying plasma filament is something that Alfven called a "circuit" or a "Bennett Pinch" in plasma.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for the welcome. I am not a prolific poster so please excuse me if I don't reply right away. Thank you for the link to Currents in the Solar Atmosphere and a Theory of Solar Flares. It's actually an interesting read especially from a historical perspective. I am still reading it and studying the implications. To be honest, I'm actually a bit more intrigued with Severny's paper that mapped magnetic fields on the sun. Unfortunately, the only source I've found so far is behind a paywall. I may research it at my local library though.

By the way, if you don't mind me asking, do you keep a personal science journal?

I have a few eJournals (more like collections of files including word documents) related to several solar physics projects I'm working on, but I can't say that I've actually kept any journals of my overall learning process per se. Why do you ask?
 
Last edited:
Finally -- an answer!
So, when a surge of electrical current occurs in plasmas, which are necessarily conducting mediums, you call that a discharge -- no dielectric break down is necessarily involved. So that's it; all this discussion has been about you insisting on an idiosyncratic semantic hang-up.

OK, I now fully agree that discharges* can occur in plasmas and solar flares. I suspect others may not prefer this definition but will agree that surges in electrical current (discharges, in your preferred usage) can occur in plasmas.
See, now you can move on to the real physics of solar flares, which I'm sure you will readily admit, are not like lightning on earth, which do involve the breakdown of a dielectric, namely the atmosphere.

*(Mozina usage) Discharge = surge in electrical current, with or without the breakdown of a dielectric.

Hey cool! We're getting close to being able to finally communicate. If I can just get you to remove the asterisk, or swap Peratt's name with mine, or just put "EU/PC physicists" if you like, I'd be a happy camper. :)
 
Hey cool! We're getting close to being able to finally communicate. If I can just get you to remove the asterisk, or swap Peratt's name with mine, or just put "EU/PC physicists" if you like, I'd be a happy camper.


Then we can dispense with that nonsense about an impossible electrical discharge akin to lightning on Earth happening in the conductive plasma of the solar atmosphere.
 
PS...

The more FUNDAMENTAL KIND of an "electrical discharge" is the one that occurs in plasma because the universe is fundamentally (mostly) made of plasma. The electrical discharge process described in Peratt's definition makes it clear that an electrical discharge in the Earth's atmosphere is LIKE (akin to) the electrical discharges that occur in flares and in cosmic plasmas in general, but the storage and release mechanisms are somewhat different. It's still a GIANT CURRENT that continues until the DISCHARGE process is completed.

Your strong emotional desire to consider them entirely different (not akin) is apparent. Embrace the E side. It's inevitable since Maxwell's equations solve in either direction. :)
 
Last edited:
PS...

The more FUNDAMENTAL KIND of an "electrical discharge" is the one that occurs in plasma because the universe is fundamentally (mostly) made of plasma. The electrical discharge process described in Peratt's definition makes it clear that an electrical discharge in the Earth's atmosphere is LIKE (akin to) the electrical discharges that occur in flares and in cosmic plasmas in general, but the storage and release mechanisms are somewhat different. It's still a GIANT CURRENT that continues until the DISCHARGE process is completed.

Your strong emotional desire to consider them entirely different (not akin) is apparent. Embrace the E side. It's inevitable since Maxwell's equations solve in either direction. :)

Trying to crawl out of that hole? :dig:
 
I have a few eJournals (more like collections of files including word documents) related to several solar physics projects I'm working on, but I can't say that I've actually kept any journals of my overall learning process per se. Why do you ask?

If you don't keep a physical journal, I highly recommend it as a good practice. Because of the prevalence of online resources, I too, have OpenDoc files for reference notes. However, I find it's much easier and less time consuming to write and perform mathematics and draw doodles (relevant to science or not :)) in a physical journal.

Most, if not all, of the professional scientists I know keep physical journals as well. The contents of such are really not a matter for open discussion as the journals often contain private and sometimes potentially embarrassing musings (i.e., my early volumes contain copious tyro mistakes). And, although I cannot speak for others, as a student, I used to tote my journal around obsessively like a child's teddy bear.

I mention this because a student I spoke to recently was lamenting the fact that his computer files had gone MIA after a hard drive failure and I was surprised that he did not keep a physical journal. I suppose this is a sign of the times.

BTW, I caution you to not enter anything too intimate in your journal. If you ever become famous, it may wind up in a museum someday. ;)
 
Trying to crawl out of that hole? :dig:

No. You evidently just don't get the whole EU concept yet. The "electrical discharge" in plasma that is described by Peratt is the primary brand of electrical discharge. Objects embedded in that Cosmic Plasma also experience "electrical discharges" due to the fact they are embedded in an electric universe. The whole ionization requirement is ARBITRARY in cosmic plasma electrical discharge processes.
 
Originally Posted by Perpetual Student
Trying to crawl out of that hole? :dig:
No. You evidently just don't get the whole EU concept yet. The "electrical discharge" in plasma that is described by Peratt is the primary brand of electrical discharge. Objects embedded in that Cosmic Plasma also experience "electrical discharges" due to the fact they are embedded in an electric universe. The whole ionization requirement is ARBITRARY in cosmic plasma electrical discharge processes.

:v:
 
I have recently acquired a book through my local library entitled The Sun from Space (2nd Edition) by Kenneth Lang. It is an excellent overview of the Standard Solar Models and I highly recommend it to the participants and lurkers in this thread. I feel that the text is not overly technical so it is accessible to laypersons, yet it provides a concise and clear presentation of mainstream concepts so as to provide a good base reference for those who are more of that mind.

Mr. Mozina, this book may be of special interest to you as it provides the mainstream interpretations of the data sets provided by Yohkoh, Ulysses, Wind, SOHO, ACE, TRACE,RHESSI, Hinode, and STEREO. Be sure to pick up the 2nd edition as the previous edition was published prior to the availability of information from the newer probes. There is also some discussion of the weakness' of the SSM which may be of some interest.
 
Last edited:
Dungey & Magnetic Reconnection II

It's a little surreal that some of you expect me to discuss Dungey's work on "magnetic reconnection" theory *WITHOUT* using the actual terms that he used. It's like trying to discuss GR theory but not use any of the terms or variables that Einstein used. Wow! Why complicate the process?


So what is your objection to affording others the luxury of the same condition that you claim for yourself? Consider this:

Okee-Dokee ... Dated 7 Dec 2010 ...

See The Neutral Point Discharge Theory of Solar Flares. a Reply to Cowling's Criticism, J.W. Dungey, 1958 (this is the paper that Mozina's "Dungey" comment above refers to).

"Certain other features of flares may be accounted for by the bulk motion resulting from a discharge at a neutral point. The effect of the discharge is to 'reconnect' the lines of force at the neutral point, and this happens quickly. The 'reconnection' upsets the mechanical equilibrium in the neighborhood in a way that can be visualized, if the lines of force are seen as strings. Then the mechanical disturbance will spread from the neutral point and may have energy comparable to the energy of the spot field in the solar atmosphere."
Dungey, 1958, page 139
​
So, you're fine, I take it, with Dungey pegging the reconnection of the magnetic field lines of force as the source of the energy for his "electric discharge"?
I'm fine as long as you and I can agree that the lines of force and "strings" include plasma filaments and include a discharge current that is flowing through it. That is why I'm fine with the term "current reconnection". Honestly Tim, I wish you would just meet me in the middle. :(


You will not afford to me the condition you claim for yourself, namely using Dungey's actual terms, unless I agree to further conditions regarding currents and filaments. Is this not a double standard, you demanding the easy way out for yourself, but holding everyone else to a different standard than your own? Beside, this is not a political negotiation, where deals need to be cut and quid pro quo achieved. It's supposed to be a discussion of scientific facts, which exist on their own, quite independently from opinions & negotiations.

Dungey said what Dungey said, and either you agree and accept that Dungey is correct, or you disagree and think that Dungey is wrong. Dungey said "reconnect". Dungey said "lines of force"; those are not my words, they are Dungey's words. I fail to see why your opinion of Dungey & Dungey's words should depend in any way on my opinion of you and your words. So, for the record if I may, are you now telling us that you decline to give an opinion on Dungey and/or Dungey's words, in this specific case?


All Clinger's graph shows is a NULL region where NOTHING exists in terms of kinetic energy/magnetic field energy to 'disconnect' or to 'reconnect' to anything else. 0+0=0.
It's literally NOTHING in terms of kinetic energy.


Look again at the quotes from Dungey I provide above. The title of his paper is "Neutral Point Discharge Theory". Dungey goes on to say: "Certain other features of flares may be accounted for by the bulk motion resulting from a discharge at a neutral point." and "Then the mechanical disturbance will spread from the neutral point and may have energy comparable to the energy of the spot field in the solar atmosphere." Dungey thinks that the kinetic energy comes from the neutral point, and he is quite clear & explicit about that. You, however, tell us "It's literally NOTHING in terms of kinetic energy." How do you account for the apparent difference of opinion between you and Dungey, as to the ability of the neutral point to provide kinetic energy?
 
Gekelman, Collette & Vincena: Magnetic Reconnection II

It's a little surreal that some of you expect me to discuss Dungey's work on "magnetic reconnection" theory *WITHOUT* using the actual terms that he used. It's like trying to discuss GR theory but not use any of the terms or variables that Einstein used. Wow! Why complicate the process?


I agree that we should stick to the words the authors actually use. So consider this:

The paper is Three-dimensional current systems generated by plasmas colliding in a background magnetoplasma by Gekelman, Collette & Vincena; Physics of Plasmas 14(6): 062109, June 2007. The claim is found in the final section, summary and conclusions: "In the first microsecond of the process, it seems that the initial electron current is driven by magnetic field-line reconnection." There is a similar later comment, but I am not sure whether the authors are referring to their own experiment, or another that they are also talking about: In this experiment, magnetic field line reconnection sites pepper the plasma volume and are identified with the Alfven wave structures."
That other paper, the 1958 Dungey paper, also explicitly identifies the reconnection of magnetic field lines as the initial source of energy for his "electric discharge". Not, mind you, the reconnection of "field aligned currents", but rather the reconnection of the lines of force of the magnetic field.


Actually Tim, you caught me. I haven't finished that entire paper yet, and I haven't gotten to the summary yet. It was a busy day yesterday and I took my time reading through the whole paper rather than just reading the abstract and conclusion. I've seen the concept of induced E field and field aligned currents used a TON of times. I'll have to wait to comment on those FEW instances where the used the term 'line'. It's not clear yet to me if he means the 'field aligned current line', or an actual magnetic line. I won't forget your question, but you'll need to be patient. I'm not done.

In terms of the inducement of an E field as Dungey and Somov describe it, that actually only requires "changing magnetic flux" (bending, twisting), not necessarily "reconnection". Therein lies the rub for me (and Alfven as well). How can any of you be POSITIVE that the MAGNETIC lines actually disconnect or reconnect rather than simply 'flux', particularly when were talking about FIELD ALIGNED CURRENTS, not just magnetic lines?


Does it really matter how many times the authors use the word "line"? If the point is to describe a physical process, or assign a physical process as an energy source, it seems to me that once and once only is quite a sufficient number of times to get the point across.

But see, when it comes to Dungey, you insist on the words "electric discharge" because those are the words Dungey used. But those are clearly words that you like. On the other hand, from Gekelman, Collette & Vincena we find the words "magnetic field line reconnection". Those are words that you don't like, and suddenly your own criterion is no longer such a good idea. You are no longer willing to settle for the words the authors use, their own words, but consider substituting your own words in their place. Is this not a double standard; when they give you what you want, only the authors own precise words will do, but when they fail to yield the desired conclusion, suddenly the authors' own words are to be abandoned for something you think is better?

Aside from the appearance of another double standard, what about our opinions about the general intelligence of the authors of this paper? Do you think they don't know the difference between "magnetic field line" (their own words) and "field aligned current" (your substitute words)? I submit that the two physical concepts are so radically different from each other that one can hardly imagine rising to the level of repeatedly funded, independent research scientists without being starkly aware of the difference between a magnetic field line and a field aligned current. How anyone could even suspect for a moment that the authors would say one, but actually mean the other, is quite mysterious to me.

Why not apply your own claimed standard and accept the words the authors use as if they were the words the authors intended to use (seems a reasonable assumption to me)? "Magnetic field-line reconnection" looks like a pretty explicit and straight forward collection of words to me.

Regarding this paper, you have already said ...

FYI, it's going to take me awhile to get through this paper, mostly because it's an EXCELLENT paper and I want to enjoy it.


Can you continue to assess this paper as "excellent" if we allow ourselves the luxury of assuming that all of the words actually used by the authors are the words they actually intended to use?
 
Dungey said what Dungey said, and either you agree and accept that Dungey is correct, or you disagree and think that Dungey is wrong. Dungey said "reconnect". Dungey said "lines of force"; those are not my words, they are Dungey's words. I fail to see why your opinion of Dungey & Dungey's words should depend in any way on my opinion of you and your words. So, for the record if I may, are you now telling us that you decline to give an opinion on Dungey and/or Dungey's words, in this specific case?

Bear with me Tim while I get some feelings off my chest and explain myself clearly.

I want to start by telling you that of all the scientists that I've met in cyberspace, there's no one else that I've appreciated more, or learned more from than you. I actually look up to you on many levels. I can't begin to explain how much you've taught me over the past seven or eight years Tim. You've provided me with a TREASURE TROVE of information. If you think I haven't appreciated your efforts, or I've ignored the materials you've put before me, you're dead wrong. In a way I've tried to earn your respect over the years, and it truly saddens me that you and I cannot see eye to eye on this issue.

I'm also sorry that Space.com took down their board because I personally did not save the very first paper on "magnetic reconnection" that I was asked to read through on a public forum. I'd like to find that paper so you can fully appreciate where I'm coming from.

The paper was by Priest. In retrospect it taught me something very important, and Priest did me a great favor. That *particular* paper (I'm sure he's written many others because I've personally read many others) just so happened to be a "speculation" paper, a "what if" sort of paper. He was speculating mathematically about "B field line reconnection" *IF* monopoles actually existed in nature. It's important in my learning process in retrospect that I started there actually because I could "in theory" understand what an actual "B field line reconnection" might look like if B field lines *DID* have a "beginning and ending", if they could be taken apart into discrete units. I could CLEARLY understand what he was trying to convey, but I DISMISSED the paper because monopoles do not exist in nature and they violate Gauss's law of magnetism.

It just so happens that the very next paper by Birn was put before me. It was different from the previous paper because it clearly described the process in terms of current running along the "line" and it it was and induced E field oriented paper. That made me realize very quickly that the E induced field was a "critical step" in the process, not just a "minor issue".

I think it's VERY unfortunate that Dungey didn't fully consider the ramifications of the name he gave to an electrical discharge process in plasma. If one is an "expert" like Dungey, they can understand the PROCESS from either the B or the E orientation of Maxwell's equations. From his perspective (an expert perspective) it was "six of one, half a dozen of the other". I think however that he underestimated the power of ignorance and the confusion factor that term introduces.

This whole thread to this point in time is a testament to the confusion it introduces IMO. To the poor uninitiated joe, it's highly easy to confuse an actual B field line reconnection as Priest was trying to describe, and an E induced DISCHARGE process in plasma. They may actually start to believe that B field lines do have a beginning and and ending. They don't.

You and I should be able to look each other in the eye Tim and you should be able to accept the term "current reconnection". The magnetic reconnection PROCESS cannot and is not complete without "current flow". The transfer of magnetic field energy is an INDUCED E field, followed by an "electrical discharge".

Why can't we just let our differences go on this ONE ISSUE and start talking about "magnetic flux tubes" and the plasma structures that actually "reconnect"?
 
Last edited:
I think it's VERY unfortunate that Dungey didn't fully consider the ramifications of the name he gave to an electrical discharge process in plasma.


Nonsense. Leaving aside the arguments from ignorance and demands that all of physics modify appropriate terminology because the against-the-mainstreamers just don't like it, Dungey called the process of magnetic reconnection by a very suitable name, "magnetic reconnection".
 
Why can't we just let our differences go on this ONE ISSUE and start talking about "magnetic flux tubes" and the plasma structures that actually "reconnect"?


Answered here...

[...] this is not a political negotiation, where deals need to be cut and quid pro quo achieved. It's supposed to be a discussion of scientific facts, which exist on their own, quite independently from opinions & negotiations.


Yeah, sure. Let's meet half way where legitimate scientists who actually understand the material under discussion allow the made up nonsense and unsupported claims of the electric Sun contingent to carry equal weight with reality. :rolleyes:
 
Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma

OMG are you confused. He won't get an "electrical discharge" *WITHOUT* a plasma! No electrons, no protons, no discharge. Get it?
OMG are you deluded. There is no such thing as a "electrical discharge" *WITHIN* a plasma until you state the defintion of an "electrical discharge" *WITHIN* a plasma.

W.D. Clinger will never get to electrical discharges in plasma because no one would be idiotic enough to think that they happen in plasma. He may get to current densities in plasma (see below).

Your delusion starts with the inability to understand that various authors in various contexts have different definitions for electrical discharge. Thus the term "electrical discharges in plasma" is meaningless without specifying at one and only definition that you are using.

There is the usual definition of electrical discharge which makes the term "electrical discharge in plasma" physically impossible (no dielectric to break down).

The next problem is your lie (quote mining) about Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge . The inability to understand that there is no discussion of "electrical discharges in cosmic plasma" in his book (or any other textbook) lead to


Michael Mozina's fantasy about Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge!
What remains is Dungey's obsolete usage
  1. Dungey's and Peratt's definition of discharge are different.
    13th January 2011 (10 months and counting)
  2. Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection
    18th October 2011
  3. MM: Citing Dungey means that cause of solar flares is magnetic reconnection!
    8th November 2011
If you want to continue to documenting your obsession that electrical discharges cause solar flares then please do so and we will conintinue to point out that it is a delusion.

If you want to change that assertion to "electrical discharges happen solar flares" then all you are doing is documenting your ignorance by using an obsolete term (or an obsession with the term "electrical discharge").
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom