Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mr. Mozina,
In regards to magnetic reconnection. Your primary criticisms appear to be based on works and statements by Hannes Alfvén. However, Alfvén acknowledged the reconnection phenomenon

In this excerpt from Cosmic Plasma, he lays out the specific conditions for magnetic reconnection to be valid.



From Double Layers in Astrophysics (pg. 8).



He did not dispute the existence of the magnetic reconnection process, rather, he did not believe mainstream assertion that reconnection was the energy transfer mechanism in solar and magnetospheric phenomena.

I believe it would be in your best interest to proceed along this line since there is some direct support of this criticism. I would direct you to the works of Syun-Ichi Akasofu and Walter J. Heikkila. Both men were colleagues of Alfven and have largely adopted his views on reconnection. Akasofu had written a criticism of the subject in his book Exploring the Secrets of the Aurora. Please take note of section 5.6 Magnetic Reconnection on page 162. I recommend you obtain the book from your local library as it is a relatively expensive purchase.

Furthermore, you may wish to peruse these abstracts:
http://www.springerlink.com/content/n2n3151r56j623gr/

http://www.springerlink.com/content/w21k14840j44g000/

I would like to add as a disclaimer, that I support the mainstream view of magnetic reconnection. IMO the evidence for it is quite strong and it would take a considerable effort to oust it as the preferred theory. I only present this information as an (possibly vain) attempt to move this discussion forwards.

Thank you for those references. You will need to be patient with me. I still have about 1/5th of another paper to finish for Humanzee and Tim before I take on more papers at the moment, but I will check them out as I get time. I appreciate it.

Keep in mind that I am not denying that the PROCESS is correct, I'm simply arguing that it has a TERRIBLE name. I would simply prefer "current reconnection' or "circuit reconnection' to keep it consistent with other branches of physics.
 
Last edited:
No. You didn't hear me, and you didn't listen. That's not amazing, it's rather typical in my experience. I *HAVE* told you *EXACTLY* what *I* mean by that term. Dungey's work fit's PERFECTLY underneath of Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge in a plasma. Peratt's definition also perfectly describes the "electrical discharges" of *OTHER* atmospheres (which happen to include gas), not just the SOLAR atmosphere. You just don't like the definition because the moment you agree to it, the hate-go-round finally comes to an end.
Why can't you simply state if you believe a dielectric is involved in discharges in plasma?
 
I would like to add as a disclaimer, that I support the mainstream view of magnetic reconnection. IMO the evidence for it is quite strong and it would take a considerable effort to oust it as the preferred theory. I only present this information as an (possibly vain) attempt to move this discussion forwards.


Here's your answer, mimada...

Keep in mind that I am not denying that the PROCESS is correct, I'm simply arguing that it has a TERRIBLE name. I would simply prefer "current reconnection' or "circuit reconnection' to keep it consistent with other branches of physics.


So the process of magnetic reconnection exists. It reasonably explains the energy release of solar flares and the heating of the corona. And even though magnetic reconnection amounts to magnetic fields reconnecting, James Dungey gave it a crummy name. :rolleyes: This entire discussion from the beginning has been about the term "magnetic reconnection" and the complaint that it is an inappropriate way to describe magnetic reconnection. And all that nonsense because...

The electric Sun conjecture is unsupportable. The claim that solar flares are some kind of massive sparks like lightning on Earth cannot be demonstrated, pretty much because it is not physically possible. The claim that the Sun acts like some kind of giant cathode has not been demonstrated, probably mostly because it cannot be. But if all the scientists on Earth can be persuaded to call magnetic reconnection an "electrical discharge", the electric Sun proponents can dishonestly claim that they have demonstrated their nonsensical conjecture to be true. (Note how much traction that strategy has gotten in this nearly 5000 post thread. ;))

As for moving the discussion forward, the burden of proof is on the electric Sun proponents. They abandoned that responsibility way back at the beginning. But in continuing to demand that everyone else teach them physics (which, you will also note, hasn't gained any ground), there is much interesting conversation about solar and plasma physics. So stick around. You'll probably learn a few things about physics and about critical thinking. :)
 
Why can't you simply state if you believe a dielectric is involved in discharges in plasma?

I can't answer your question because it's technically OPTIONAL in Peratt's definition and it's optional in EU theory, it's not one or the other.

You're going to have to think on COSMIC scales here for a second PS and wrap your head around the whole EU idea, even if you don't accept it. You need to at least UNDERSTAND it from my perspective, even if you disagree.

PC/EU theory needs and requires a "Cosmic scale" definition of an electrical discharge process in a plasma. Why? Because it occurs CONSTANTLY in EU/PC theory and most of the universe is plasma. Peratt's definition is a "cosmic scale" definition that works for a universe that is almost entirely composed of plasma. Even in Birkeland's model on my website, the solids would compose a small fraction of the total mass.

Peratt's definition isn't "necessarily" state specific in terms of the environments in which it might be applied. It "could" apply to electrical discharges in planetary atmospheres or in solar atmospheres. The "triggering/storage" mechanisms would necessarily need to be RADICALLY different in a gas than the circuits that store energy and reconnect in plasma, but it's still the same fast release of stored EM energy in the form of current, even in a gas.

Cosmic plasma cosmology theories require cosmic scale definitions that can be applied to the whole plasma of spacetime, and to things EMBEDDED INSIDE OF that plasma. It has to be a BROAD definition PS.
 
Last edited:
So stick around. You'll probably learn a few things about physics and about critical thinking. :)

Actually, I've been lurking for quite some time. I've also read most of the posts that I've found interesting. The factor that has compelled me to participate in this thread is Dr. Clinger's derivation of magnetic reconnection through Maxwell's equations. I appreciate his presentation and I hope he continues.

On another note, I have only briefly flipped through the book Cosmic Plasma. My understanding is that Alfvén proposed plasma double layers as the energy transfer mechanism that accelerates the solar wind and heats the corona (as opposed to reconnection). However, I am not clear as to the mechanism that initiates the formation of these layers. Does anyone here know of this offhand? I get the impression that the layers form spontaneously from perturbations in the plasma but how do these perturbations transfer the sun's internal energy and what initiates them? If magnetic flux tubes are involved, then this isn't much different than reconnection is it?
 
On another note, I have only briefly flipped through the book Cosmic Plasma. My understanding is that Alfvén proposed plasma double layers as the energy transfer mechanism that accelerates the solar wind and heats the corona (as opposed to reconnection). However, I am not clear as to the mechanism that initiates the formation of these layers. Does anyone here know of this offhand? I get the impression that the layers form spontaneously from perturbations in the plasma but how do these perturbations transfer the sun's internal energy and what initiates them? If magnetic flux tubes are involved, then this isn't much different than reconnection is it?

http://www.thesurfaceofthesun.com/A...r Atmosphere And A Theory Of Solar Flares.pdf
 
It's not actually necessarily any "different from", it's just the E orientation of the same process IMO. One does however have to accept that it is the electric horse that does the actual work, not the magnetic cart that contains the current in filaments.
 
Last edited:
It's essentially the twirling motion of the photosphere in the areas around sunspots according to Alfven that induces an E field at different points on the photosphere. Keep in mind that we're talking up to a billion volts.
 
You'll probably learn a few things about physics and about critical thinking. :)
For my part, I hope to learn some physics from mimada.

The factor that has compelled me to participate in this thread is Dr. Clinger's derivation of magnetic reconnection through Maxwell's equations. I appreciate his presentation and I hope he continues.
Thanks. I'm not quite done with producing the animations and cleaning up the graphs, but I should be able to post part 4 this weekend and part 5 next week.

If this were a freshman basic EM physics class, you just earned a GIANT *F*. That was an EPIC FAIL!
I feel so lucky you weren't teaching the Berkeley section of PHY 316 that semester.

I now know from a year of your nasty lies that you can't tell the difference between "solid magnet reconnection" and an "electrical discharge process in plasma". You don't know the difference between magnetic flux density changes and "magnetic reconnection". I now know that you are clueless about those lines "beginning and ending" in the X as you have claimed. I now know that you don't even understand BASIC theory because if you did, you'd know that B fields have no beginning or ending! You don't grasp the fact that permeability is measured in INDUCTANCE per unit length, not "reconnections" per unit length. You don't understand that FUTZING with the units make no damn difference in terms of the actual PHYSICS! (FYI, you unfairly SCREWED Tim over that lie. You owe Tim a public apology IMO).
Tim Thompson, I apologize.

(If you know why I'm apologizing to you, please let me in on the secret.)
 
Michael, do you ever feel like your wasting your life here? :eye-poppi

I really would just swallow your pride and run from the argument. :scarper:

Or do you actually enjoy this type of seemingly never ending argument? :)
 
Michael, do you ever feel like your wasting your life here? :eye-poppi

I really would just swallow your pride and run from the argument. :scarper:

Or do you actually enjoy this type of seemingly never ending argument? :)

Call me an optimist, but they can't *ALL* be lost causes IMO. :)
 
Thanks. I'm not quite done with producing the animations and cleaning up the graphs, but I should be able to post part 4 this weekend and part 5 next week.

Part 4 damn well better include a BRAND NEW GRAPH contained STRICTLY in the POSITIVE quadrant of the X,Y grid, showing all four magnetic fields IN FULL, and the NULL region better be nowhere close to the "origin" of the graph!
As much as I appreciate your invaluable advice, I'll continue to decide the content of my own posts.

But I tell you what: If you'll give me a mathematically precise, closed-form equation for the magnetic field B you're asking me to graph (such as the equation I gave in part 3 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection), and tell me exactly which rectangular region of which planar slice of B you'd like to see, then I'll post that graph for you.

(I'm not going to try to guess what you think you mean by "all four magnetic fields" or "IN FULL".)
 
As much as I appreciate your invaluable advice, I'll continue to decide the content of my own posts.

You WON'T keep trying to pass off the origin of the graph for the origin of the B fields however. Once was enough.

But I tell you what: If you'll give me a mathematically precise, closed-form equation for the magnetic field B you're asking me to graph (such as the equation I gave in part 3 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection), and tell me exactly which rectangular region of which planar slice of B you'd like to see, then I'll post that graph for you.

(I'm not going to try to guess what you think you mean by "all four magnetic fields" or "IN FULL".)

This is YOUR handwavy claim, not mine. I'm not going to help you in any way shape or form, other than to understand exactly what I mean and expect of you this time.

VFPt_quadrupole_coils_1.svg


I want you to position an image like this in the POSITIVE X,Y QUADRANT of whatever image you post, making sure to show all four the electromagnets and a number of lines/field strengths around all sides of the magnet. If you simply put the left bottom corner of this image at 0,0 of your graph, I'll be fine with anything you come up with. What you WON'T do this time is put that NULL region anywhere near an origin of the graph and confuse the origin of the graph with the origin of B fields.
 
Last edited:
What you WON'T do this time is put that NULL region anywhere near an origin of the graph and confuse the origin of the graph with the origin of B fields.

You are aware that translation of position axes does not change the result of a calculation based on relative position, are you not?
 
You are aware that translation of position axes does not change the result of a calculation based on relative position, are you not?

He can make the bottom left of the image 0,0 if he likes. What he won't keep doing is keep referring to the null region as an "origin".
 
You WON'T keep trying to pass off the origin of the graph for the origin of the B fields however. Once was enough.
I don't know what you mean by the highlighted phrase.

When I have used the word "origin", it has always meant the origin of the coordinate system. I have never tried to pass it off as anything else.

But I tell you what: If you'll give me a mathematically precise, closed-form equation for the magnetic field B you're asking me to graph (such as the equation I gave in part 3 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection), and tell me exactly which rectangular region of which planar slice of B you'd like to see, then I'll post that graph for you.

(I'm not going to try to guess what you think you mean by "all four magnetic fields" or "IN FULL".)
This is YOUR handwavy claim, not mine. I'm not going to help you in any way shape or form, other than to understand exactly what I mean and expect of you this time.
I don't know what you mean by the highlighted phrase.

[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/7b/VFPt_quadrupole_coils_1.svg[/qimg]

I want you to position an image like this in the POSITIVE X,Y QUADRANT of whatever image you post, making sure to show all four the electromagnets and a number of lines/field strengths around all sides of the magnet.
I'm not sure what you mean by electromagnets or magnets.

The magnetic field B4 that I graphed is generated by the current running within four rods. As I stated quite carefully in part 3 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, those rods are perpendicular to the z axis at the four points pE, pW, pN, and pS. The following graph shows a 2x2 meter square centered on the origin:
[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/figure1.png[/qimg]

I'm not sure whether you want me to show only the 1x1 meter square of the NE quadrant (which would be equivalent to eliminating the other three quadrants from the picture), or to translate all of the rods into the NE quadrant (in which case a graph with the four rods at the centers of its four edges would be identical to the one above), or to zoom out so you can see what the field looks like outside the rods, or to graph a different magnetic field entirely, or to do some combination of the above.

Knowing you, it's entirely possible that what you want me to do is so bizarre that it hasn't even occurred to me. That's why I'm not even going to try to guess at what you want me to do.

If you simply put the left bottom corner of this image at 0,0 of your graph, I'll be fine with anything you come up with. What you WON'T do this time is put that NULL region anywhere near an origin of the graph and confuse the origin of the graph with the origin of B fields.
With the magnetic field B4 as defined in part 3 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, the neutral point is at the origin. There's nothing you or I can do about that, short of changing the coordinate system or the magnetic field.

Once again, I don't know what you mean by the highlighted phrase. Might you be a little confused about the distinction between magnetic fields and magnetic field lines?
 
I have never tried to pass it off as anything else.

Based on your previous posts I believe that it is entirely possible that you don't realize it (yet), but you did, and you probably confused yourself in the process. Try again, but you may not use the term "origin".
 
Last edited:
When I have used the word "origin", it has always meant the origin of the coordinate system. I have never tried to pass it off as anything else.

Based on your previous posts I believe that is it is entirely possible that you don't realize it (yet), but you did, and you probably confused yourself in the process. Try again, but you may not use the term "origin".
You're wrong.

I did not use the word "origin" in part 1 or its erratum. I used the word "origin" once in part 2 and 7 times in part 3 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection. Every one of those 1+7=8 uses referred to the origin of a Cartesian coordinate system.

I am not going to guess which of those 8 uses you are wrong about. If you can't quote the sentence in which you believe I misused the word "origin", then I will assume you are once again engaging in an activity that's hard to describe without violating the Membership Agreement.

I'm going to give you one last chance. If your next post doesn't explain what you're pretending to say, then I will respond to you only by highlighting your unique posture.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom