Michael Mozina
Banned
- Joined
- Feb 10, 2009
- Messages
- 9,361
Mr. Mozina,
In regards to magnetic reconnection. Your primary criticisms appear to be based on works and statements by Hannes Alfvén. However, Alfvén acknowledged the reconnection phenomenon
In this excerpt from Cosmic Plasma, he lays out the specific conditions for magnetic reconnection to be valid.
From Double Layers in Astrophysics (pg. 8).
He did not dispute the existence of the magnetic reconnection process, rather, he did not believe mainstream assertion that reconnection was the energy transfer mechanism in solar and magnetospheric phenomena.
I believe it would be in your best interest to proceed along this line since there is some direct support of this criticism. I would direct you to the works of Syun-Ichi Akasofu and Walter J. Heikkila. Both men were colleagues of Alfven and have largely adopted his views on reconnection. Akasofu had written a criticism of the subject in his book Exploring the Secrets of the Aurora. Please take note of section 5.6 Magnetic Reconnection on page 162. I recommend you obtain the book from your local library as it is a relatively expensive purchase.
Furthermore, you may wish to peruse these abstracts:
http://www.springerlink.com/content/n2n3151r56j623gr/
http://www.springerlink.com/content/w21k14840j44g000/
I would like to add as a disclaimer, that I support the mainstream view of magnetic reconnection. IMO the evidence for it is quite strong and it would take a considerable effort to oust it as the preferred theory. I only present this information as an (possibly vain) attempt to move this discussion forwards.
Thank you for those references. You will need to be patient with me. I still have about 1/5th of another paper to finish for Humanzee and Tim before I take on more papers at the moment, but I will check them out as I get time. I appreciate it.
Keep in mind that I am not denying that the PROCESS is correct, I'm simply arguing that it has a TERRIBLE name. I would simply prefer "current reconnection' or "circuit reconnection' to keep it consistent with other branches of physics.
Last edited:

