Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
FYI, I'm dying to know if Clinger comes out of the closet in part 5 and finally admits that, yes indeed, it does indeed take a plasma to get an "electrical discharge" process like Dungey described, and (drum roll please), whether he finally admits that electrical discharges occur in solar flares. :)
 
I changed my mind about even posting that post. No, he just pulled a fast one. He renamed the center of the quadripolar field an "origin" and away he went. (rotating it appropriately to match Dungey's "electrical discharge/reconnection" diagram of course)

He didn't rename it origin, origin means 0,0 coordinates on the graph.
 
He didn't rename it origin, origin means 0,0 coordinates on the graph.

But it's just the origin of the graph, not the origin of the magnetic lines. The magnetic lines simply go through that point (at a zero field strength). It's just like any other point as far as any magnetic lines are concerned. They all are created in the electromagnets. None of them 'begin', or end in the "origin" of his graph.
 
Last edited:
FYI, I'm dying to know if Clinger comes out of the closet in part 5 and finally admits that, yes indeed, it does indeed take a plasma to get an "electrical discharge" process like Dungey described, and (drum roll please), whether he finally admits that electrical discharges occur in solar flares. :)

Your position on this is wholly adolescent. It has been made abundantly clear by so many people here that the term discharge has been used inconsistently over the years. Some usages require the breakdown of an insulator while others refer merely to surges in current, as when a capacitor discharges. So, if you are saying that there are surges in current in solar flares or plasmas, you will have agreement; if you are saying that a dielectric material has broken down in plasmas and solar flares, you will not have agreement. So, rather than persisting in using this ambiguous word (and just going around and around), why don't you specify if you mean a surge in current or the breakdown of a dielectric. Then, the people here will say yes or no and we will all know what you are talking about and perhaps end this useless discussion (at least that one aspect of these discussions).
 
Your position on this is wholly adolescent. It has been made abundantly clear by so many people here that the term discharge has been used inconsistently over the years.

So what? I'm sure the term "electrical discharge" in the Earth's atmosphere has been used inconsistently by various human beings over the span of human history too. That doesn't mean that electrical discharges do not occur in the Earth atmosophere or in plasma! What a weird rationalization. You also seem to forget that I provided you with Peratt's CLEAR definition of an electrical discharge *IN* a plasma, well over a year ago at this point.

You guys talk about wanting to be "Big Dogs", but you all cower away like thunderstruck wimpering little puppies from the sound of Dungey's electrical discharge in a solar flare! Bah! Haters are incapable of 'meeting in the middle', else the hate ends. Hence the denial go round continues.

Sooner or later Clinger is going to get fried by that missing electrical discharge in his vacuum contraption that doesn't do squat in terms of "magnetic reconnection".

FYI, as best as I can tell (aside from all his ridiculous handwaving about magnetic lines beginning and ending in the null region), his vacuum contraption turns out to be nothing more than a quadrapole magnetic field generator (for lack of a better term). I guess I went through a years worth of verbal abuse for nothing. I think if you get Clinger to rerun his graph, keeping the whole experiment in the POSITIVE X,Y quadrant, and include all the lines starting at the four poles, he'll see the error of his ways pretty quickly. Magnetic lines don't begin or end in the NULL zone, they simply don't have any strength in that region. No kinetic field or plasma particle energy, no "reconnection" in the null zone. It's nothing more than a 'dead party zone' where no kinetic energy action is happening. You might also want to clue him in that he'll also need "rapidly changing magnetic flux" to get Dungey's electrical discharge, not a slow dB/dt increase/decrease, oh ya *AND PLASMA*.

Watching this denial-go-round unfold and unravel is like watching a train wreck in slow motion.

:popcorn1
 
Last edited:
If Perpetual Student calls W.D.Clinger a fraud, he has taken your side and directly contradicted his statement of neutrality.

He already did that when called me a fraud for not reading his mind while he refused to answer my questions. At least he'd be an equal opportunity offender. :)
 
Again:

Some usages require the breakdown of an insulator while others refer merely to surges in current, as when a capacitor discharges. So, if you are saying that there are surges in current in solar flares or plasmas, you will have agreement; if you are saying that a dielectric material has broken down in plasmas and solar flares, you will not have agreement. So, rather than persisting in using this ambiguous word (and just going around and around), why don't you specify if you mean a surge in current or the breakdown of a dielectric. Then, the people here will say yes or no and we will all know what you are talking about and perhaps end this useless discussion (at least that one aspect of these discussions).
So, which is it? Why not end this silly semantic bickering? It's very simple: when you say discharge do you mean a surge in current or do you mean that a dielectric has broken down?
 
Last edited:
Actually, I'd like to know if there are or not.

That all depends on how you define an electrical discharge. (and no that is not a "Clinton") Let me find the message where I went through several of the books/papers that MM "trusts" and how electrical discharge was defined in those. Okay, that took some effort, because I posted that in January, pose 1441 (actually easy to remember).

In that post I give a list about how differnt authors use the term "electrical discharge" in different ways. In some it will be an atmospheric lightning process (charge build up with an abrupt release through break down of the insulator), whereas in other papers an "electrical discharge" is just an increase in the current that is flowing in the plasma (Dungey for example).

So, it is totally useless to talk about electrical discharges unless you specify in a detailed way what exactly you mean by that. Therefore, I decided not to discuss this anymore, it's a waste of time, and prefer to talk about the actual physical processes that are taking place in the various situations.
 
Last edited:
With regard to

J W Dungey. The neutral point discharge theory of solar flares. A reply to Cowling's criticism. Proceedings of Electromagnetic Phenomena in Cosmical Physics, edited by Bo Lehnert. International Astronomical Union number 6, Cambridge University Press, page 135. 1958​

On second thought, if you are in fact asking if Dungey's paper is correct, it's correct.

Good. Evidence, please.
We must distinguish
  1. what Dungey wrote in that paper
  2. what Michael Mozina thinks Dungey wrote in that paper
So far as I can tell, what Dungey wrote is correct. (I'll give some evidence for that in part 5 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.)

As for what Michael Mozina thinks Dungey wrote, that's completely bonkers. If you want evidence for that, just read the last few pages of this thread:
  • Michael Mozina doesn't understand that Dungey's two figures show magnetic field lines.
  • Michael Mozina doesn't understand that Dungey is talking about reconnection of magnetic field lines.
  • Michael Mozina doesn't understand that the magnetic field can be nonzero at points where no current is flowing and the E field is zero.
  • Michael Mozina doesn't understand basic concepts of electromagnetism such as "magnetic flux" and "magnetic flux density".
  • Michael Mozina doesn't know what Dungey is talking about when Dungey uses basic technical phrases such as "magnetic field line", "neutral point of the magnetic field", "magnetic force density", "magnetic force", "lines of force".
Don't ask me how Michael Mozina managed to read five books on plasma physics without learning even the basics of electromagnetism. I can only speculate.
 
Last edited:
So, which is it? Why not end this silly semantic bickering? It's very simple: when you say discharge do you mean a surge in current or do you mean that a dielectric has broken down?

That's actually a false dichotomy fallacy IMO. Technically all planets are embedded in cosmic plasma and that kind of 'electrical discharge' is just a SUBSET of the definition of all possible types of electrical discharges that occur in and inside of atmospheres of objects that are embedded in plasma.

1 .5 Electrίcal Discharges in Cosmic Plasma

An electrical discharge is a sudden release of electric or magnetic stored energy. This generally occurs when the electromagnetic stress exceeds some threshold for breakdown that is usually determined by small scale properties of the energy transmission medium. As such, discharges are local phenomena and are usually accompanied by violent processes such as rapid heating, ionization, the creation of pinched and filamentary conduction channels, particle acceleration, and the generation of prodigious amounts of electromagnetic radiation. As an example, multi-terawatt pulsed-power generators on earth rely on strong electrical discharges to produce intense particle beams, Χrays, and microwανes . Megajoules of energy are electrically stored in capacitor banks, whose volume may encompass 250 m^3 . This energy is then transferred to a discharge regίοn, located many meters from the source, viα a transmission line.

The discharge region, or load, encompasses at most a few cubic centimeters of space, and is the site of high-variability, intense, electromagnetic radiation (Figure 1 .2). On earth, lightning is another example of the discharge mechanism at work where electrostatic energy is stored in clouds whose volume may be of the order of 3,000 km3. This energy is released in a few cubic meters of the discharge channel.
 
Last edited:
Good. Evidence, please.

Hmmm. Define "good evidence" for me. I have "lab evidence" that electrical discharges produce all of the key and important observations related to solar flares, including million degree plasmas, heavily ionized iron, neutron capture signatures, gamma rays, x-rays, etc.

Now that you know that "magnetic reconnection" is a PROCESS IN PLASMA that involves the inducement of an E field in the plasma, followed by an electrical discharge in the plasma, I can happily provide you with any number of papers on MR theory. What kind of evidence do you want?
 
Last edited:
That's actually a false dichotomy fallacy IMO. Technically all planets are embedded in cosmic plasma and that kind of 'electrical discharge' is just a SUBSET of the definition of all possible types of electrical discharges that occur in and inside of atmospheres of objects that are embedded in plasma.

Why all the dodging and dancing? My question is quite simple: What do you mean when you say discharge in solar flares or plasmas? Is it the breakdown of a dielectric or is it a current surge? If we knew that, we would have a context for your mantra that discharges occur in plasmas. Why won't you answer that simple question?
 
Why all the dodging and dancing?

Honestly PS, Peratt's definition is exactly that I mean. I'm honestly not trying to dodge any questions. I'm not a plasma physicist by trade either. I simply selected *A* (an appropriate) definition of an electrical discharge in a plasma from a textbook on plasma physics. It defines and describes an electrical discharge *IN* cosmic plasma, and all objects that are embedded in that cosmic plasma. IMO it's a broad enough definition to be INCLUSIVE, not EXCLUSIVE, and it's exactly what I mean by the term. In fact it's where I got the term (in plasma).
 
Last edited:
Honestly PS, Peratt's definition is exactly that I mean. I'm honestly not trying to dodge any questions. I'm not a plasma physicist by trade either. I simply selected *A* (an appropriate) definition of an electrical discharge in a plasma from a textbook on plasma physics. It defines and describes an electrical discharge *IN* cosmic plasma, and all objects that are embedded in that cosmic plasma. IMO it's a broad enough definition to be INCLUSIVE, not EXCLUSIVE, and it's exactly what I mean by the term. In fact it's where I got the term (in plasma).

In other words, you don't know! You have been arguing about discharges in plasmas for how long here? How many posts? And -- you do not know what you mean by discharge -- you don't know if you mean a breakdown of a dielectric or a surge in current?
The question of whether there is a dielectric to break down in a plasma has been the crux of the issue of this question for all these months and you now say you do not know. Amazing!
 
In other words, you don't know! You have been arguing about discharges in plasmas for how long here? How many posts? And -- you do not know what you mean by discharge -- you don't know if you mean a breakdown of a dielectric or a surge in current?
The question of whether there is a dielectric to break down in a plasma has been the crux of the issue of this question for all these months and you now say you do not know. Amazing!

No. You didn't hear me, and you didn't listen. That's not amazing, it's rather typical in my experience. I *HAVE* told you *EXACTLY* what *I* mean by that term. Dungey's work fit's PERFECTLY underneath of Peratt's definition of an electrical discharge in a plasma. Peratt's definition also perfectly describes the "electrical discharges" of *OTHER* atmospheres (which happen to include gas), not just the SOLAR atmosphere. You just don't like the definition because the moment you agree to it, the hate-go-round finally comes to an end.
 
Mr. Mozina,
In regards to magnetic reconnection. Your primary criticisms appear to be based on works and statements by Hannes Alfvén. However, Alfvén acknowledged the reconnection phenomenon

In this excerpt from Cosmic Plasma, he lays out the specific conditions for magnetic reconnection to be valid.

Hannes Alfvén said:
II.5.3. 'MAGNETIC MERGING' THEORIES

What we have found means that we can describe plasma phenomena inside a finite volume only if no electric current crosses the surface. In the terminology of the magnetic field description, this means that we can describe plasma phenomena inside a finite volume only if the perpendicular component of the curl is zero at every point of the surface.
All theories of 'magnetic merging' (or 'field line reconnection') which do not satisfy this criterion are misleading or erroneous, and deserve no attention. This does not mean that all papers in which 'magnetic merging' is used are of no interest, because there exist some good papers (e.g., Hill, 1975) in which the term is merely a synonym for “current-sheet acceleration.”

From Double Layers in Astrophysics (pg. 8).

Hannes Alfvén Double Layers in Astrophysics said:
The "frozen-in" picture of magnetic field lines differs from Maxwell's views. He defined a magnetic field line as a line which everywhere is parallel to the magnetic field. If the current system which produced the field changes, the magnetic field changes and field lines can merge or reconnect. However, if the current system is constant the magnetic field is also constant. To speak of magnetic field lines moving perpendicular to the field makes no sense. They are not material.

He did not dispute the existence of the magnetic reconnection process, rather, he did not believe mainstream assertion that reconnection was the energy transfer mechanism in solar and magnetospheric phenomena.

I believe it would be in your best interest to proceed along this line since there is some direct support of this criticism. I would direct you to the works of Syun-Ichi Akasofu and Walter J. Heikkila. Both men were colleagues of Alfven and have largely adopted his views on reconnection. Akasofu had written a criticism of the subject in his book Exploring the Secrets of the Aurora. Please take note of section 5.6 Magnetic Reconnection on page 162. I recommend you obtain the book from your local library as it is a relatively expensive purchase.

Furthermore, you may wish to peruse these abstracts:
http://www.springerlink.com/content/n2n3151r56j623gr/

http://www.springerlink.com/content/w21k14840j44g000/

I would like to add as a disclaimer, that I support the mainstream view of magnetic reconnection. IMO the evidence for it is quite strong and it would take a considerable effort to oust it as the preferred theory. I only present this information as an (possibly vain) attempt to move this discussion forwards.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom