Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
What's more, the B field is zero at the X point; that's why Dungey and everyone else call it a neutral (or null or zero) point. We want B to be zero at that point, because we're trying to demonstrate magnetic reconnection, which can only happen where the B field is zero.
This is what slide 7 from Priest's slides from his 2004 Bozeman lecture states.
Slide 11 emphasises that this is the 2D case.
Slide 28 mentions that reconnection can also happen at non null points (see slide 31).

What amazes me is that Michael Mozina cannot even understand a description of the process, i.e. that magnetic field lines do not exist where B = 0 so any lines entering an area where B = 0 have to end there, any lines leaving an area where B = 0 have to start there.
An alternative way to look at it is to note that magnetic field lines do not split or merge. But at an X-shaped neutral point there is no way to tell which of the 2 outward lines an inward line joins to. Thus the connection to the outward part of the field line has been broken.
 
Keep in mind that I am not denying that the PROCESS is correct, I'm simply arguing that it has a TERRIBLE name. I would simply prefer "current reconnection' or "circuit reconnection' to keep it consistent with other branches of physics.
Wrong: You are arguing your personal opinion that it has a terrible name without giving any physically pertinent reasons to change it.

The physics tells everyone else that magnetic reconnection is has the name that describes the process best. This is especially true in solar falres where
  • The energy that is released starts as stored in the magnetic field.
  • It is the change in magnetic field that releases the energy.
  • This release of energy causes the acceleration of currents. The currents actually absorb energy :eye-poppi !
 
Michael, do you ever feel like your wasting your life here? :eye-poppi

I really would just swallow your pride and run from the argument. :scarper:

Or do you actually enjoy this type of seemingly never ending argument? :)
Zeuzzz, can you tell us the definition of 'electrical discharge' that Michael asserts causes solar flares? Because he cannot :eye-poppi!
Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge is the standard definition for which Peratt gives the example of lightning.
Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection (and is obsolete).

Michael
I really would just swallow your continued display of ignorancce and run from the science. :scarper:

Or do you actually enjoy your seemingly never ending cycle of pure denial of physics (or an obsession with semantics)? :)
 
My only intent in getting him to move the Null point away from the origin is so he realizes his mistake.
That is rather insane.
W.D. Clinger is following the practice of centuries of science by putting a potentially interesting feature at the origin of his image. That is not a mistake - every scientist since at least Newton has done the same. This includes Dungey. I would expect that the books that you claim to have read and understood also have images with interesting stuff at the origin.
 
http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/1974ApJ...190..467L/0000467.000.html

This paper by Lee is an excellent place to begin because it relates those electrical discharge processes back to SDO (and many other) solar satellite images, specifically all the iron ion wavelengths.
Note that Michael Mozina lies when he states 'electrical discharge processes'.
Solar-flare and laboratory plasma phenomena by Lee, 1974 is about plasma discharge experiments. See Figure 1 for a schematic diagramn of the experiment.
It never metions 'electrical discharge processes'.
It does specifically mention the role of an electric breakdown which starts the plasma discharge.
This is just another MM fantasy.

The 'specifically all the iron ion wavelengths' is rather irrelevant. The fact is that the emission from the highly ionized Fe in the corona is used to image solar flares. The experiment has a laser used to add anode material to the plasma discharge. "The anode material for this particular experiment is iron".
 
That is rather insane.
W.D. Clinger is following the practice of centuries of science by putting a potentially interesting feature at the origin of his image. That is not a mistake - every scientist since at least Newton has done the same. This includes Dungey. I would expect that the books that you claim to have read and understood also have images with interesting stuff at the origin.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7743644&postcount=4757

Speaking of that "potentially interesting feature": Five days ago I asked you to give Clinger a hand completing what you called the "trivial" part of his freshman homework assignment. Are you two done yet? Tick...Tick.....Tick....
 
Last edited:
Tick...Tick.....Tick...Boom!
You really are unable to read: proof that magnetic field lines can begin/end at a neutral point

And nothing to do with
Originally Posted by Reality Check
That is rather insane.
W.D. Clinger is following the practice of centuries of science by putting a potentially interesting feature at the origin of his image. That is not a mistake - every scientist since at least Newton has done the same. This includes Dungey. I would expect that the books that you claim to have read and understood also have images with interesting stuff at the origin.
 
Well Clinger, now I don't even know where to tell you to go to get help from any of the "true haters" (You, PS, GM and RC) in this thread in CORRECTLY explaining part 4 when you move that potentially interesting feature away from the origin of the graph, expand the view, and you don't use the term origin.

You might try PS. He's the only one you four with some background in basic EM theory (hint: you do need help with the "theory", not with the math) that "might" actually be able to help you. The rest of the haters are probably useless to you, proving once and for all that their math skills are useless as it relates to this topic. Honestly Clinger, I think PS is the only hater that might have a clue how to explain that potentially interesting feature once you expand that view and move the NULL from the origin of the graph. Go ask PS for help. If anyone of the hard core EU haters might work some magic for you, and help you pull a rabbit out of that hat, it's PS.
 
Last edited:
Well Clinger, now I don't even know where to tell you to get help from any of the "true haters" (You, PS, GM and RC) in this thread in CORRECTLY explaining part 4 when you move that potentially interesting feature away from the origin of the graph, expand the view, and you don't use the term origin.
Multiple silliness here:
  • the 'true haters' bit.
    No one here hates anyone.
    We may be disturbed by the lack of knowledge combined by the unwillingness to learn exhibited by some people in this thread.
    Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma!
  • your inability to understand that putting interesting things at the orgin is done because they are interesting things!
  • the total ignorance that moving the neutral point away from the origin will not change the physics.
  • the insanity that you can command anyone to stop using a valid word.
 
Well Clinger, now I don't even know where to tell you to go to get help from any of the "true haters" (You, PS, GM and RC) in this thread in CORRECTLY explaining part 4 when you move that potentially interesting feature away from the origin of the graph, expand the view, and you don't use the term origin.


The term "origin" simply refers to a location on the graph. Substitute "the origin" with "(0,0)" in W.D.Clinger's explanation (use a regular expression something like "s/the origin/\(0\,0\)/ig"), and it will be exactly the same without using the word "origin". It's pretty much rank beginner's stuff for anyone capable of writing database and spreadsheet forumulas, scripts, and programs.
 
Multiple silliness here:
  • the 'true haters' bit.
    No one here hates anyone.
    We may be disturbed by the lack of knowledge combined by the unwillingness to learn exhibited by some people in this thread.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7734001&postcount=4556

It's hard to buy your claim about the "true haters" bit while you're calling me a liar and PS is calling me a "fraud" no less. Holy Cow! I haven't even seen part 4 yet, let alone the bait and switch installment yet, and already you're calling me a fraud!

I'm already on to Clinger's magic trick. I know he has electromagnets under that table (off the edge of his graph) and his "beginningandendingofBlinesgod" is a fraud. I don't know what games you, GM and PS are playing yet, but it's time for everyone to put their cards on the table, and put up or shut up.

It's time for you four haters, you, Clinger, GM and PS to help Clinger finish part 4 of his *FRESHMAN PHYSICS* homework assignment and demonstrate once and for all, for all the world to see, that I am indeed a fraud and a liar as you have all claimed, or to publicly retract those claims, right now, in this thread. Which is it going to be?

Don't any of the four of you even THINK about playing the disappearing skeptic trick. You've all called me a fraud. I want physical and mathematical proof of that claim or a public apology. Which is it going to be?
 
Last edited:
Hater of EU? Me? Not even close!
However, I will admit that, for narcissistic people who embrace pseudoscience and display willful ignorance and arrogance, I have nothing but utter contempt.
 
For my part, I hope to learn some physics from mimada.

Since the official EU hater crew seems to be utterly incapable or completely unwilling to help you Clinger, I sure hope for your sake that mimada can and does take pity on you and lend you a hand. It seems a little early to be asking a "newbie" to the thread like mimada for help, but it's entirely possible that mimada may be able to do what your friends cannot. Evidently the rest of your fellow EU hater crew cannot or will offer you any help at all. :( I guess they all fed you to the sharks eh?

FYI, I'm personally highly skeptical that you'll ever get to the plasma switcheroo part 5 of your presentation mind you, but I'm just dying to find out if you intend to come out of the closet in that chapter and finally admit that electrical discharges occur in solar flares and plasmas? Care to drop any hints?

I sure hope you eventually get through part four.

:popcorn1
 
Last edited:
Hater of EU? Me? Not even close!
However, I will admit that, for narcissistic people who embrace pseudoscience and display willful ignorance and arrogance, I have nothing but utter contempt.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7734001&postcount=4556

I've spent weeks and months trying to teach you something about "magnetic reconnection", an *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE PROCESS* in PLASMA, and for my efforts you called me a fraud? You aren't real big on scientific integrity I take it?
 
Electric discharge in plasma

I really did not want to get into this argument, much less contradict Reality Check who is usually correct in his assessments.

An electric discharge occurs when a current that is somehow blocked overcomes its impedance and begins to flow. Typically, this occurs across a potential (or between a charged object and ground). For example, a short across a capacitor would instantiate an electric discharge. Electric sparks and electric arcs are particular types of discharges that occur between potentials separated by a dielectric gas. When the potential exceeds a critical level, the gas in between becomes ionized. The ionization produces a path for the current to flow.

Arc discharges can occur in plasma if dielectric gas is present. The experiment described in the paper Currents in the Solar Atmosphere and a Theory of Solar Flares mentions an arc discharge flowing between a cathode and anode through low density mercury plasma.

The properties of plasma that are demonstrated by the experiment:
- Plasma has impedance
- The impedance of plasma is a function of its density
- When the density of the plasma is reduced, impedance can rise to the point whereupon the plasma acts as an insulator
- High potentials can be sustained by low density plasma
- There is a limit to the amount of current plasma can accommodate, thus a potential can develop between plasma even if current is flowing.

I am not an authority on plasma so I do not know if highly ionized plasma (as in the sun) can filament and produce the characteristics of an electric arc but the description of the aforementioned experiment explicitly states the existence of an arc discharge within the low density mercury plasma.

Source: H. Alfvén and P. Carlqvist, Currents in the Solar Atmosphere and a Theory of Solar Flares, pg. 222 beginning with 5. Maximum Current Through a Plasma

There are citations to other experiments in the paper that allude to similar findings as well but I have not investigated them.

Regarding magnetic reconnection: Mr. Mozina, please concede your assertions about this. The literature does not support your electric field orientation contention. If you wish, you may try to derive the process via the electric field through Maxwell's equations. I suppose you could start with a current emanating from the neutral point but I don't see this as being a fruitful or worthy pursuit.

Dismiss the point as trivial or as a misunderstanding if you must. You have a stronger argument touting the Alfvén-Carlqvist model for solar flares (albeit not much stronger in light of the more recent data sets). It would be a much worthier pursuit to update or reconcile the Alfvén-Carlqvist model with more recent data if that's possible.
 
a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 4

I have created a web page that summarizes the derivation so far, with links to parts 1, 2, and 3.

To review:
  1. Part 1 and its erratum used one of Maxwell's equations to derive the magnetic field B around a current-carrying rod.
  2. Part 2 expressed that magnetic field in both cylindrical and Cartesian coordinates.
  3. Part 3 demonstrated that the magnetic field around four current-carrying rods reproduces
  4. Part 3 also showed that magnetic lines can begin or end at a neutral point, which I later proved in more detail.
In this part 4, I will use the experiment I've been suggesting to Michael Mozina to illustrate magnetic reconnection and to prove that the topology of the magnetic field changes during a variation of that experiment. As Yamada et al explain in their appendix, that change in the topology of the magnetic field is what we mean by magnetic reconnection.


[size=+1]The experimental setup[/size]

In a well-shielded laboratory, we assemble four long conducting rods parallel to the vertical (z) axis of a Cartesian coordinate system whose y axis points north and whose x axis points roughly east. We place each rod exactly 1 meter east, west, north, or south of the coordinate origin, and run 1000 amperes of current through each rod. That current runs upward (positive z) in the east and west rods, but downward (negative z) in the north and south rods. By Maxwell's equations (as was shown in parts 1 through 3), the magnetic field for the 4x4 meter square centered on the origin looks like this:

figure1zoomout.png


As before, the colors in that graph show the magnitude of the magnetic field, ranging from white (most intense) to black (least intense). The gray lines are the magnetic field lines that run through points of the form <±1,y,0> or <x,±1,0> for x,y∈{±1.0, ±0.9, ±0.8, ±0.7, ±0.6, ±0.5, ±0.4, ±0.3}.

The four rods' individual magnetic fields cancel each other out at the origin, so the magnetic field is zero there. Within the xy plane at z=0, the origin is the only neutral point of this particular magnetic field B4.


[size=+1]Magnetic reconnection at the neutral point[/size]

Without changing the 1000 ampere current within the east and west rods, let's vary the current within the north and south rods between 999.9 and 1000.1 amperes. That tiny variation in current causes magnetic reconnection at the neutral point:

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/mr100.gif[/qimg]

When that animated GIF is running, you'll see two arrows flash briefly when the current within the north/south rods returns to its original value of exactly 1000 amperes. At that infinitesimal instant, the two magnetic field lines that are almost touching divide into four field lines that begin or end at the neutral point. That division and subsequent merger of magnetic field lines can only occur at a neutral point.

The next animation starts with the original magnetic field (B4), slowly reduces the north/south rods' current to zero, and then increases that current back to the original 1000 amperes:

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/mr00.gif[/qimg]

Wikipedia's animation of magnetic reconnection shows essentially the same phenomenon, but is rigged to run forever without any change in the magnetic field. My animation above shows what magnetic reconnection actually looks like in a theoretically simple magnetic field that's easy to reproduce experimentally.


[size=+1]Mathematical proof of topological changes[/size]

Reducing the north/south rods' current to zero yields a magnetic field for which
  1. Every field line either begins at the neutral point, ends at the neutral point, or loops back on itself.
  2. Given any 3 magnetic field lines that loop back on themselves, at least one of the 3 field lines lies within the loop formed by another of the 3 field lines.
Those are topological properties of the magnetic field lines, which means those properties are preserved by any homeomorphism of the magnetic field lines.

The original magnetic field has the first of those two topological properties, but does not have the second property. For the original magnetic field, you can have 4 magnetic field lines that loop back on themselves without any of the 4 loops being contained within any of the other loops (in that set of 4).

That implies that the topology of the magnetic field lines must change as the current within the north/south rods is increased from zero to 1000 amperes.

For reasons that should be clear from the links above, that change in the topology of the magnetic field lines is called magnetic reconnection [Yamada et al 2010].


[size=+1]Conclusion to part 4[/size]

We have now completed a mathematical proof that magnetic reconnection is a direct consequence of Maxwell's equations. For the most part, that proof used nothing beyond freshman-level vector calculus and electromagnetism. At the very end of the proof, when we proved that the topology changes, we needed a few additional facts about topology: the definition of homeomorphism and topological properties, and the fact that one of the properties listed is a topological property.

We have proved that magnetic reconnection can occur in vacuo, at a neutral point spatially separated from all currents, and with a negligible E field.

In part 5, I will explain the two main points of [Dungey 1958] by adding a little plasma to the magnetic field B4. It is not really possible to understand Dungey's paper without first understanding the neutral point and magnetic field lines of B4 or similar fields in a vacuum.


[size=+1]References[/size]

[Dungey 1958] J W Dungey. The neutral point discharge theory of solar flares. A reply to Cowling's criticism. Proceedings of Electromagnetic Phenomena in Cosmical Physics, edited by Bo Lehnert. International Astronomical Union number 6, Cambridge University Press, page 135.

[Yamada et al 2010] Masaaki Yamada, Russell Kulsrud, and Hantao Ji. Magnetic reconnection. Reviews of Modern Physics volume 82, January-March 2010, pages 603-664.
 
[*]Part 3 also showed that magnetic lines can begin or end at a neutral point, which I later proved in more detail.

Just to set the record straight, in part three you alleged (didn't "prove" at all) that "Origin" was the great "beginor and endor" of all B field lines in the B field line universe (in your experiment anyway). Care to retract the claim that B field lines have beginnings and endings first and just make this short and relatively painless?

In this part 4, I will use the experiment I've been suggesting to Michael Mozina to illustrate magnetic reconnection and to prove that the topology of the magnetic field changes during a variation of that experiment.

Wow! Bait and switch in part four too? Cool! This is going to be fun, fun, fun. I don't have any problem with magnetic field topology changes Clinger. That's not the claim that got you burned.

As Yamada et al explain in their appendix, that change in the topology of the magnetic field is what we mean by magnetic reconnection.

Until we get to the plasma bait and switch part of your presentation, I absolutely insist you stop name dropping individuals, institutions you've been involved with, and authors of books you're read. This is YOUR PERSONAL claim, not theirs. You aren't doing any of them any favors by dragging their names through the mud with you Clinger, trust me on this.

Let me go grab a cup of coffee and I'll take a look at the rest of this goofy presentation.
 
Last edited:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7734001&postcount=4556

I've spent weeks and months trying to teach you something about "magnetic reconnection", an *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE PROCESS* in PLASMA, and for my efforts you called me a fraud? You aren't real big on scientific integrity I take it?

Well , let's take a look at what I said:

This is the kind of adolescent debating that makes you so infamous as a nuisance and a fraud. You made no effort to address the substance of my comment while taking my use of an illustration out of context. Do you have any genuine interest in this subject or are you just here to gain pleasure from your obfuscating? My patience is running thin. Do you have any serious response to my comment (repeated below) or are you admitting magnetic reconnection is a real process?

I showed you an animation to clarify my question (which you dodged and danced around -- as usual) and you accused me of claiming the animation was proof! As a debating tactic it was indeed fraudulent!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom