Edge dowsing # 2

Edge said:
Talk about closed a mind.
There’s a radio interview and written version by Dr.Greer what ever the out come of such said devices, if real the implications are staggering.
It would be better for the world in many ways.
Or do you prefer the fossil fuel era to stay forever along with the pollution?

Onward and upward that’s the key to a better world.

:rolleyes:
#1- The radio interview was on the Art Bell show.

#2- The interview was with Dr. Steven Greer, a UFO Kook who has such a history of outrageously false claims, that even his fellow UFO KooKs can't take him seriously.

#3- Implications, however staggering, do not override probabilities, and possibilities. The implications of you waving your kwazy witching sticks, and successfully snatching Randi's million would be staggering... those implications, and three bucks, will get you about a jug of Thunderbird.

#4- Fossil fuel is a necessary evil until something better comes along. Until the day Steven Greer is collecting bonus checks from his utility company, He, and all his other, "Watch me pull energy out of my ass! Nothing up my sleeve... Presto!" buddies can just shut the hell up.

#5- Hey, Edge... pull my finger.
 
Cute though your pictures are, Edge, there is a place called the "Banter" section for the fun stuff.

Let's get back to the topic of this thread. I'm curious as to how your search for "neutral ground" is going. How are you conducting the search? Are you double-checking by letting someone hide gold targets once you have established the ground as non-responsive?
 
It's just edge reverting back to his old pattern.

When he's asked questions he can't *or won't* answer, he starts posting off topic nonsense and pictures.

There exists a topic specifically for his UFO stuff.

This topic was created specifically to address his dowsing claims.

Now.

Once again back to dowsing.


Tell us Edge.

It's now March.

This very month marks the year anniversary of your abject failure to sucessfully dowse under test conditions designed by, and approved 100% by yourself.


http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html

Since you claim to have a "secret weapon" that will assure your victory in a re-test, why haven't you contacted Randi and the JREF yet?

And if you have, please tell us the some of the details so that we can help you get another fair test. (at which you'll fail once again)

Here's a snippet from your first test with Randi.

Note the bolded text.

Mike was to be tested for finding gold, his specialty. The target material he had chosen, and brought along with him, consisted of five quartz stones, nine "Sacagawea" dollar coins, a gold ring, a gold nugget, and a small vial containing water and a few panned flakes. He said he had always been successful in detecting each and all of these seventeen items, when his forked stick was specifically "tuned" to pick up gold — by having a small scrap of gold fastened to its tip.

Now all of these items are man made.

It's quite evident that you didn't "mine" to find them.

If you weren't lying about your ability to have "always been successful" about being able to dowse these items, it's clear that you should be able to find them under test conditions.

Now you can go on and on about "interferences", but the very fact that you proclaimed your dowsing powers to be working in the "open" test gives lie to these claims.

Of course, you've pretty much admitted that you lied about your results in the open test, so your credibility in just about anything else you might say is completely suspect.

Tell me Edge.

When you tested those "target" ideas sucessfuly before, where did you get such great results? And why wouldn't that place be a fine candidate for your retest?

Also, you've stated that your sisters old house was good for dowsing.

What would rule that place out a potential site for a re-test?

But really, these are small questions.

I really want to know why you haven't been in contact with Randi about winning the million if you truly feel that your "secret weapon" will prevail.

Every day you put it off is another day that we see that you're simply putting off your inevitable failure in a fair re-test.

Perhaps we should start a "Mike Guska Clock" starting from this month to tick off the days until you work up the courage to fail again. :)
 
edthedoc said:
What now is the point of this thread? ;)
To discuss the dowsing claims of Edge (aka Mike Guska) and his re-test with the JREF that he says he will pass with a "secret weapon".

When asked questions about when he will contact the JREF again for his re-test (as he said he would), he wriggles and squirms to avoid another complete and total failure as seen in the following link.

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
wert said:
To discuss the dowsing claims of Edge (aka Mike Guska) and his re-test with the JREF that he says he will pass with a "secret weapon".

When asked questions about when he will contact the JREF again for his re-test (as he said he would), he wriggles and squirms to avoid another complete and total failure as seen in the following link.

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html

According to my sources, the test was set up to fail there was no way to pass it.
Here you can even look it up for the proof!
http://www.google.com/:D
 
Few people would be more thrilled than I if dowsing were proved to work. A whole new field of physical research would open up, the present-day laws of physics would have to be rewritten or at least expanded. This scenario is a dream of many a physicist; to find new fundamental laws of physics that better explain the world in which we live. But in the case of dowsing, proponents have had the possibility to prove that their ideas hold for centuries without any greater success in capturing the interest of the science community. The science community itself has flaws and is often narrow-minded to new ideas, but given several hundred years of time for evaluation of a few simple claims I believe the critical standpoint is taken on solid grounds. However, I encourage anyone interested in the field to continue research as long as the approach is serious. Simple truths about nature can't choose to hide from the skeptical minds and be seen by the gullible at the same time.

This is a good site to look at.
http://www.lysator.liu.se/~rasmus/skepticism/dowsing.html


Taken from bakers link.



This could be a link to zero point.


Like I said if it just moved I would say your right but I can stop the movement and it continues to arch, I cannot make it do this on purpose no matter how I try.

In the field it's one hundred % accurate and that’s where it needs to be tested where mining is done.
The other way to check it is, when it's gone there, there is no reaction.

These things I have learned and checked on the spots where I have mined.

When your finding ounces of gold you just can’t believe that it’s gone as suddenly as it appears so you check and you find that you were right the first time that you checked with the dowsing rod and it is remarkable.

I haven’t been down south yet to see if I can find neutral ground yet, so I’m waiting, I might be in the field in Calli; before that happens.

I think many more experiments should be done and maybe they will and maybe they won’t.
 
Edge said:
Few people would be more thrilled than I if dowsing were proved to work. A whole new field of physical research would open up, the present-day laws of physics would have to be rewritten or at least expanded. This scenario is a dream of many a physicist; to find new fundamental laws of physics that better explain the world in which we live. But in the case of dowsing, proponents have had the possibility to prove that their ideas hold for centuries without any greater success in capturing the interest of the science community. The science community itself has flaws and is often narrow-minded to new ideas, but given several hundred years of time for evaluation of a few simple claims I believe the critical standpoint is taken on solid grounds. However, I encourage anyone interested in the field to continue research as long as the approach is serious. Simple truths about nature can't choose to hide from the skeptical minds and be seen by the gullible at the same time.

This is a good site to look at.

I might mention here that the above is a "cut 'n' paste" from the site linked.

The grammar and spelling was a dead giveaway that Edge is once again presenting the work or others as his own.


This could be a link to zero point.
The discussion at hand is about your claimed dowsing skill Edge. Not discussions or "zero point". Another lame attempt to change the subject.

Please answer the questions from my last Post.

Please tell us why you haven't contacted Randi or the JREF about your re-test.

Please tell us why you seem to have so little faith in your "secret weapon that you claim will wein the million?

In the field it's one hundred % accurate and that’s where it needs to be tested where mining is done.
so all those object you presented to Randi were "mined" every time you found them with 100% sucess via dowsing.

These things I have learned and checked on the spots where I have mined.
Babbling about mining isn't going to change the fact that you seem to be weasling out of a fair retest with the JREF.

What happened to all that big talk about taking the million in a retest edge?

I haven’t been down south yet to see if I can find neutral ground yet, so I’m waiting, I might be in the field in Calli; before that happens.
I'm guessing you'll claim it doesn't exist *as you seem to be doing* in a continuing effort to duck the test.

Once again, why not use the same spot you tested sucessfully before for the man made objects?

Why not use the ex-house of your sister that you claimed was "good for dowsing"?

I think many more experiments should be done and maybe they will and maybe they won’t.
In other words, you're simply afraid to fail again and have resorted to repeating the old excuses since you have no new or valid ones. :rolleyes:

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
Baker said:


According to my sources, the test was set there was no way to pass it.
Here you can even look it up for the proof!
http://www.google.com/:D
Having shown your complete inability to add anything substantive to this or any conversation I've seen, I'll invite you to a long stay on my ignore list.

Plonk.
 
This is the reason ass clown can't you read?

I haven’t been down south yet to see if I can find neutral ground yet, so I’m waiting, I might be in the field in Calli; before that happens.

Read this,
 
Edge said:
This is the reason ass clown can't you read?



Read this,
Hm, doesn't exactly answer any of my questions now does it edge?

Why haven't you contacted the JREF yet?

Why isn't the ground where you sucessfully tested before (on your own) no longer viable?

Why isn't your sisters old house *which you claim is "good for dowsing", not a candidate for a retest?

And lastly.

Why continue with all the lame excuses about not being able to find "neutral ground"?

We see your continuing evasions for what they are.

Attempts to put off or avoid another fair test with the JREF.

After all, it's pretty obvious that if you truly wanted another test with the JREF, you would have contacted them by now.

Otherwise, please spare us your increasingly lame excuses (and ad-hominin) and give us some real answers for a change.

We can all see your reluctance to have a repeat of your failure to dowse under fair test conditions that you approved of 100%.

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
Edge said:
Few people would be more thrilled than I if dowsing were proved to work. A whole new field of physical research would open up, the present-day laws of physics would have to be rewritten or at least expanded.

This is undoubtedly true, Edge. It would, in fact be a new field, because there is certainly no evidence for it at this time. This is in spite of the fact that dowsing has been around for a long time. All those years and still no evidence?

Yes, Edge, even I would be happy to see such a new law of physics in our arsenal. However, I refuse to engage in wishful thinking untill I see some evidence.

Edge said:
This scenario is a dream of many a physicist; to find new fundamental laws of physics that better explain the world in which we live. But in the case of dowsing, proponents have had the possibility to prove that their ideas hold for centuries without any greater success in capturing the interest of the science community.
Yes, I believe "dream" is the operative word here. And there is a good reason why it hasn't captured the interest of the science community. It doesn't work. You didn't see people refusing to believe metal detectors work when they were first invented, did you? Why? Because they actually do work.

Edge said:
The science community itself has flaws and is often narrow-minded to new ideas, but given several hundred years of time for evaluation of a few simple claims I believe the critical standpoint is taken on solid grounds. However, I encourage anyone interested in the field to continue research as long as the approach is serious. Simple truths about nature can't choose to hide from the skeptical minds and be seen by the gullible at the same time.
Yes, the science community is skeptical. Would you have it otherwise? Don't you think snake-oil salesmen should have to prove their product? And like you, I encourage any kind of serious research. And all serious research so far has shown dowsing doesn't work. Sure, keep looking if you like, but don't do the same disproven thing over and over. Try different things.

Edge said:

Like I said if it just moved I would say your right but I can stop the movement and it continues to arch, I cannot make it do this on purpose no matter how I try.
And like many have pointed out to you, this indicates there is an attractive force between the dowsing rod and the target. Remember the gold on the pendulem experiment? If there is an attractive force, then you ought to be able to move the pendulem of gold without touching it. In fact, it should move so violently that a strong man (like yourself) couldn't stop it. There is no such thing as one-way force, Edge.

Edge said:

In the field it's one hundred % accurate and that’s where it needs to be tested where mining is done.
The other way to check it is, when it's gone there, there is no reaction.
What you are suggesting is that gold in the field is somehow different between gold in the lab.
How about this for a proposed experiment then. You go out into the field and find some gold using dowsing. Then give that same exact gold to some neutral observer and do the ten target test (like in Randi's office) in the same exact field. Does that seem fair to you?

Edge said:
These things I have learned and checked on the spots where I have mined.
You cannot know this unless you excavate many cubic feet of rock/dirt around the target where you found gold. Nor can you "know" there is no gold unless you excavate and carefully scan the entire "no gold" area. Your test controls in the field are very poor.

When your finding ounces of gold you just can’t believe that it’s gone as suddenly as it appears so you check and you find that you were right the first time that you checked with the dowsing rod and it is remarkable.
And yet you cannot do this under test conditions. Doesn't that bother you in the least?

Edge said:

I haven’t been down south yet to see if I can find neutral ground yet, so I’m waiting, I might be in the field in Calli; before that happens.

I think many more experiments should be done and maybe they will and maybe they won’t.
Is this your way of saying you are not going to reapply for the Randi Million? People have been suggesting lots of ways to make the test fair, including dowsing in your "proven" fields. Surely you can do it there for a million dollars. You are behaving as if you are afraid of losing.
 
Tricky said:
You are behaving as if you are afraid of losing.
Specifically, I think he is afraid of being a two time loser.

Before, he gave us big talk how he would "take the million" with his "secret weapon" in his re-test with the JREF.

Now we get the same old excuses rehashed by him in an effort to duck the re-test.
 
Tricky said:

You didn't see people refusing to believe metal detectors work when they were first invented, did you? Why? Because they actually do work.

Errr.... well, uhhh... actually, people were skeptical toward the first metal detector. It was built by Alex. Graham Bell, in an attempt to detect the assassin's bullet inside Pres. Garfield. He failed to do so, only because, unbeknownst to Bell, Garfield was laying on a newfangled coil-spring mattress! (There's the bullet... no, there it is... wait, it's over here... dang! he's riddled with bullets!) So, it was deemed a failure, and was panned by critics. Garfield's "doctors" subsequently killed him.

The scientific community dismisses dowsing, not because of a single failure, but because of consistent failure, by a wide variety of proponents, under a wide variety of conditions. Until it can be demonstrated under controlled conditions, there is nothing to study.
 
Tricky,
You seem to have descended into politeness, clear writing, and logic.

Perhaps its time for the moderator to step in and stop this sort of thing before you bring down this thread entirely.
 
Oh yeah. Dowsing works. That's why I just shelled out $2000 for a dry well (this'll be it's own post, after I write something coherent about it) :rolleyes:

(btw, I'm new. Hi! *waves*)
 
TechHead said:


Errr.... well, uhhh... actually, people were skeptical toward the first metal detector. It was built by Alex. Graham Bell, in an attempt to detect the assassin's bullet inside Pres. Garfield. He failed to do so, only because, unbeknownst to Bell, Garfield was laying on a newfangled coil-spring mattress! (There's the bullet... no, there it is... wait, it's over here... dang! he's riddled with bullets!) So, it was deemed a failure, and was panned by critics. Garfield's "doctors" subsequently killed him.

The scientific community dismisses dowsing, not because of a single failure, but because of consistent failure, by a wide variety of proponents, under a wide variety of conditions. Until it can be demonstrated under controlled conditions, there is nothing to study.
Wow! You learn something new every day. Of course, I will have to verify the truth of this story. (sigh) It ain't easy being a skeptic.

Originally posted by davefoc
Tricky,
You seem to have descended into politeness, clear writing, and logic.

Perhaps its time for the moderator to step in and stop this sort of thing before you bring down this thread entirely.
I object, sir! Anyone with half a brain can easily tell that my post was absolutely dripping with subtle sarcasm. You are obviously more a fan of Rabelais than Voltaire. So bite me.

Originally posted by GovtSlave
Oh yeah. Dowsing works. That's why I just shelled out $2000 for a dry well (this'll be it's own post, after I write something coherent about it)

(btw, I'm new. Hi! *waves*)
I work in the oil biz and a dry hole or two can mean looking for a new job. Hope this wasn't the case with you.

And welcome. Beware the Succubus, if you value your soul.
 
Tricky said:

Wow! You learn something new every day. Of course, I will have to verify the truth of this story. (sigh) It ain't easy being a skeptic.

I would expect no less from any good skeptic. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom