does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Yes. I doubt that fire can bring down a high rise steel framed structure. I KNOW that it cannot do so in the manner proffered by NIST, however I am open to looking at an alternative fire based hypothesis that could lead to a progressive collapse in such a structure if you have one.
Even if NIST had some details on the initiation wrong, there's another report with the same initiation point, and the rest of the analysis by NIST still stands.

And then there's another report that proposes a different initiation point.

All three propose fire as a cause. The WAI report in particular seems quite reasonable, even if I'm fairly confident that it may get one or two details wrong.

So tell me, what's wrong with the WAI report?
 
So where is your alternative fire based hypothesis that leads to a progressive collapse?

Well, NIST, ARUP, WAI, etc.
Moot point though. Impact damage and fire are well known to have occurred. That much is patently obvious..

There is however, zero evidence for explosives/thermite as cause of collapse.

So where again can we find the evidence backed hypothesis for controlled demolition?
 
Firstly. You have no clue what I have and have not used.
Secondly, steel/titanium encasements can typically withstand 3500 x gravity force and sustained temperatures of 1100C for 60 minutes, as per aircraft black boxes.

I have a pretty good Idea you have no explosive knowledge.

Yes but since steel and titanium are good conductors that makes the harder to insulate, and Titanium is very flamible so where is the Titanium oxide in the dust?
 
Even if NIST had some details on the initiation wrong, there's another report with the same initiation point, and the rest of the analysis by NIST still stands.

And then there's another report that proposes a different initiation point.

All three propose fire as a cause. The WAI report in particular seems quite reasonable, even if I'm fairly confident that it may get one or two details wrong.

So tell me, what's wrong with the WAI report?

These reports, as you are aware do not concur. I presume that when you say "there's another report" you are referring to ARUP?

If you are hanging your hat on the WAI report, then you should clearly state that so that we can accept NIST's hypothesis as invalid before moving on. These are engineering reports, and collectively do not present you with an a la carte menu that you can mix and match from.

So you are hanging your hat on the WAI report or not ?
 
Edited by jsfisher: 
<snip> Moderated content redacted.
...and totally clueless about explosives and CD.

Why the insults? Is there really a need for that.

You do not know what experience or qualifications I have and resorting to ad homenim attacks is infantile of you.

It is insulting to be called "clueless" and exactly the kind of nonsense that has prevented me from participating here previously.

ETA so it his kind of infantile nonsense acceptable on this site?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
These reports, as you are aware do not concur. I presume that when you say "there's another report" you are referring to ARUP?

If you are hanging your hat on the WAI report, then you should clearly state that so that we can accept NIST's hypothesis as invalid before moving on. These are engineering reports, and collectively do not present you with an a la carte menu that you can mix and match from.

So you are hanging your hat on the WAI report or not ?

You make the same fundamental mistake that Tony Szamboti does in assuming that these reports invalidate each other. They do not. They use different assumptions about unknowable variables--the timing and intensity of the fires on multiple floors--and come to different conclusions on the locus of the collapse initiation as a result. Given that the various reports are based on building simulations that are just massively complicated functions of the modeled elements exposed to different temperatures across different timeframes, this should be no surprise to you. Unless you know exactly which fire scenario is correct, then you can never say which model is most correct. All that matters is that the models used reasonable assumptions about the building structure and fires, and they all did. Their conclusions in the aggregate just show that there were multiple ways the fires could have led to the observed collapse.
 
Last edited:
Why the insults? Is there really a need for that.

You do not know what experience or qualifications I have and resorting to ad homenim attacks is infantile of you.

It is insulting to be called "clueless" and exactly the kind of nonsense that has prevented me from participating here previously.

ETA so it his kind of infantile nonsense acceptable on this site?

What insult? Don't dig holes you cannot fill. Good day and Godspeed...
 
Why the insults? Is there really a need for that.

You do not know what experience or qualifications I have and resorting to ad homenim attacks is infantile of you.

It is insulting to be called "clueless" and exactly the kind of nonsense that has prevented me from participating here previously.

What experience do you need to be wrong, and to have misapplied the scientific method?

We don't have to disprove CD, you have to prove it.

Fire induced Collapse, is scientificly viable by observed evidence, CD is not, nor have any of the studies been proven impossible.
 
Dave Thomas! Mr. president! It does not give a flattering impression of u, to claim that truthers fear your analytical powers in a debate and then disappear when challenged. Are u not up to defending the NIST reports? Are u afraid of exposing them as woo-woo? Do u not live up to your spiel?

The NIST reports are not my area of expertise. I think it's quite obvious, however, that truthers are stuck on the "Black and White Logical Fallacy" (a.k.a. False Dilemma). Because the NIST reports might have a "t" uncrossed or an "i" undotted does not help in any way to prove that 9/11 was a "Controlled Demolition."

You guys are just gonna have to find someone else to play the role of Satan in your cheesy Passion Play. Good luck with that! :rolleyes:
 
Firstly. You have no clue what I have and have not used.
Secondly, steel/titanium encasements can typically withstand 3500 x gravity force and sustained temperatures of 1100C for 60 minutes, as per aircraft black boxes.

You don't use science. You claim fire can't do what it does in steel/iron buildings for over 100 years. You deny science and have a fantasy version of people you can't name setting explosives/thermite in a building.

Steel in your fantasy world of CD woo, indestructible. Cool, fantasy properties of steel, for a fantasy version of 9/11. The terrorists would be laughing at your opinion, when they came to kill Americans.

Got some evidence for your claims? No.

Bad news for your opinion of CD and NIST is wrong... you can't explain how and why. 15 years after 19 terrorists did it, you failed at backing in a fantasy based inside job you can't explain, can't support with evidence.
 
Last edited:
What experience do you need to be wrong, and to have misapplied the scientific method?

We don't have to disprove CD, you have to prove it.

Fire induced Collapse, is scientificly viable by observed evidence, CD is not, nor have any of the studies been proven impossible.

Your statement speaks for itself. NIST themselves undertook a real world study on the basis of ARUP's report's contradictory outcome as far as failure mechanism is concerned.
It is NIST that pro-ports to demonstrate the viability of the official explanation that fire induced progressive collapse occurred and they are yet to amend their report to reflect their results. If you are happy to abandon their previously stated impossible failure mechanism, then I suggest that you say so clearly.
 
You put it in a box and you insulate it.

Now.... that fire based hypothesis that leads to a progressive collapse?


That's simple. Just before WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 collapsed, observers noted that those buildings were buckling. That is a major clue that fire, not explosives, was slowly weakening the steel structures of those buildings.
 
Your statement speaks for itself. NIST themselves undertook a real world study on the basis of ARUP's report's contradictory outcome as far as failure mechanism is concerned.
It is NIST that pro-ports to demonstrate the viability of the official explanation that fire induced progressive collapse occurred and they are yet to amend their report to reflect their results. If you are happy to abandon their previously stated impossible failure mechanism, then I suggest that you say so clearly.

ARUP never tested the NIST temperature model. How could they have invalidated NIST's conclusion without testing it?
 
I note DGM's failure to state an alternative fire based collapse mechanism that could lead to a progressive collapse thus far.
 
ARUP never tested the NIST temperature model. How could they have invalidated NIST's conclusion without testing it?

The temperature at which the girder would expand to the inside of the column 79 is attained early on in both studies. It is this axial expansion that prevents a failure in the heating phase of either analysis.
 
Yes. I doubt that fire can bring down a high rise steel framed structure. I KNOW that it cannot do so in the manner proffered by NIST, however I am open to looking at an alternative fire based hypothesis that could lead to a progressive collapse in such a structure if you have one.


Fires were in fact, responsible for the collapse of WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7. Other than structural buckling, the WTC buildings were also tilting in the moments before they collapsed, and that was another clue that fire, not explosives, was responsible for their collapse.

The outer steel structure of the Windsor building collapsed due to fire only, which left only concrete standing.
 
The temperature at which the girder would expand to the inside of the column 79 is attained early on in both studies. It is this axial expansion that prevents a failure in the heating phase of either analysis.

The girder was never a uniform temperature. And its lateral walk was influenced by the expansion of the beams attached to it, which were also never uniform temperatures. All of those temperatures across all areas of the locations in question were functions of the temperature input model. How much and when the structural elements were heated changes how they behave as a system. ARUP never tested NIST's inputs and hence it could not invalidate NIST's outputs (unless it knew there was a flaw in NIST's inputs, which it did not). By the way, not even ARUP claims lateral walk-off was impossible. You may want to re-read the relevant reports more closely, looking first to Dr. Bailey's report. You are stuck arguing from a position that is both fundamentally and technically incorrect.
 
Last edited:
... You appear to be willing to accept the impossible from NIST, as far as their failure mechanism is concerned. That's not just contradictory as far as ARUP and others have illustrated, but it's offensive to anyone in the industry who has looked at the evidence in the various reports and come to the inevitable conclusion that the failure mechanism presented by NIST is not a valid one. If it were even possible, I wouldn't be writing this. So, I guess that is my question - Do those here, who are in opposition to Tony really believe that it is possible for the girder to have failed via the mechanism proffered by NIST ? ...

ARUP, fire did it. NIST, fire did it. You have no valid studies or claims which show NIST's probable cause to be impossible. Do you know what probable means?

You offer talk, silly opinions, and fantasy.


You ignore science.

onemeridiansag.jpg

A fire fought, yet, the steel failed; unless you think a 3 foot sagging floor is not failure... you don't know what steel does in fire, so you make up the lie NIST's probable cause can't be right. Got some physics, math and engineering to go with your opinion? No.

woodbeambentsteel-full.jpg

Why does structural wood beat steel in fire? Did you try to look up some science, or do you make it up as you go to match the fantasy world where steel can't fail.

After 15 years, where is your evidence? Even gerrycan failed to produce evidence. Why can't you? Why is all of 9/11 truth unable to do more than spread the lie of CD, and fail to present evidence. Dog ate it? It burned up, or is it locked safely in Al Gore's lockbox?
 
Last edited:
Your statement speaks for itself. NIST themselves undertook a real world study on the basis of ARUP's report's contradictory outcome as far as failure mechanism is concerned.
It is NIST that pro-ports to demonstrate the viability of the official explanation that fire induced progressive collapse occurred and they are yet to amend their report to reflect their results. If you are happy to abandon their previously stated impossible failure mechanism, then I suggest that you say so clearly.

We don't need any reports. NIST, ARUP, WAI could all go away tomorrow and fire would still be the only plausible proximate cause of 7 WTC collapse.

As mentioned earlier each report deals with a healthy dose of unknowns so not surprising that they differ at the detail level. They do not by any means cancel each other out. To say so demonstrates gross ignorance of the subject matter. All agree on the proximate cause of fire + time + gravity = collapse and they demonstrate it could have happened in more than one way.

We will never get any closer than that.

One can argue to eternity which bit failed first - no way to prove it given the available evidence - but there is no question that whatever bit failed first, fire caused it.

If you have some other plausible scenario which does not have fire as the proximate cause and which better explains all observations of the event them by all means bring it.

Otherwise I am sort-a thinking we are done here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom