I'm aware that they do. All three concur in that the cause of the collapse was the fire.These reports, as you are aware do not concur.
They differ in the assumptions. As I have already noted several times, and will continue to do so until it sinks, all they can do is speculate about the actual conditions of the building's interior, and using that speculation, they make assumptions and reach conclusions based on them. It's unlikely that any of them got the actual initiation mechanism right, anyway, and it's unlikely that any other investigation does, because no one can know what actually happened inside the building.
Yes.I presume that when you say "there's another report" you are referring to ARUP?
I'm not hanging my hat on any. That would not be rational, as all reports contain some degree of speculation. They must, as we don't have enough information about the exact intensity of fire on each area, for example.If you are hanging your hat on the WAI report, then you should clearly state that so that we can accept NIST's hypothesis as invalid before moving on.
For the same reason, they are all hypotheses, and they aren't exclusive. All three could be valid.
Says who? Couldn't one of the failure mechanisms in the Arup report be a valid initiation mechanism that would cause the collapse of the weakened floor 12 as NIST says happened, and the rest be essentially like NIST said? That'd be a valid hypothesis too. As I said, there are hundreds of possibilities. I don't reject anything beforehand.These are engineering reports, and collectively do not present you with an a la carte menu that you can mix and match from.
Again, all three could be valid, as all they present is a plausible initiation hypothesis each. So, no, I'm not hanging on any in particular. I'm familiar with the criticisms to NIST's and Arup's reports, though, and so far the criticisms on the WAI report I've seen are based on incredulity at best, so I was curious as to what's your issue with it.So you are hanging your hat on the WAI report or not ?
You've asked straight questions and I've given straight answers. Now let me ask you another straight question for which I expect a straight answer:
Do you agree that it's impossible to know the exact location and intensity of the fires, and the exact location of the initial failure in WTC7?