does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

These reports, as you are aware do not concur.
I'm aware that they do. All three concur in that the cause of the collapse was the fire.

They differ in the assumptions. As I have already noted several times, and will continue to do so until it sinks, all they can do is speculate about the actual conditions of the building's interior, and using that speculation, they make assumptions and reach conclusions based on them. It's unlikely that any of them got the actual initiation mechanism right, anyway, and it's unlikely that any other investigation does, because no one can know what actually happened inside the building.


I presume that when you say "there's another report" you are referring to ARUP?
Yes.


If you are hanging your hat on the WAI report, then you should clearly state that so that we can accept NIST's hypothesis as invalid before moving on.
I'm not hanging my hat on any. That would not be rational, as all reports contain some degree of speculation. They must, as we don't have enough information about the exact intensity of fire on each area, for example.

For the same reason, they are all hypotheses, and they aren't exclusive. All three could be valid.


These are engineering reports, and collectively do not present you with an a la carte menu that you can mix and match from.
Says who? Couldn't one of the failure mechanisms in the Arup report be a valid initiation mechanism that would cause the collapse of the weakened floor 12 as NIST says happened, and the rest be essentially like NIST said? That'd be a valid hypothesis too. As I said, there are hundreds of possibilities. I don't reject anything beforehand.


So you are hanging your hat on the WAI report or not ?
Again, all three could be valid, as all they present is a plausible initiation hypothesis each. So, no, I'm not hanging on any in particular. I'm familiar with the criticisms to NIST's and Arup's reports, though, and so far the criticisms on the WAI report I've seen are based on incredulity at best, so I was curious as to what's your issue with it.

You've asked straight questions and I've given straight answers. Now let me ask you another straight question for which I expect a straight answer:

Do you agree that it's impossible to know the exact location and intensity of the fires, and the exact location of the initial failure in WTC7?
 
Again all u have is a lot of pompous ranting that avoids actually addressing anything I said, by either ignoring it or circumventing it.

Lets start w what u do not dare to even mention:

1) You are unable to defend your dishonesty and hypocrisy:


2) U are unable to summon enough intellectual honesty to examine your sand foundations:



3) You are not man enough to admit you were wrong about Korol:



- No amount of pompous ranting can cover up any of the above. Finally, what is...
?

Korol said:

I said:

You said:


NIST is studying a normal office fire, which means 20 to 30 mins of fire in each spot. Having one location heated up for longer than that means u are getting extra heat from other spots. Your F47 nears 3 hours of heating and does not start to go over 600C until after about 1 hour of heating. In relation to your normal office, this is your preheating from fuel in a larger area. As Korol shows, another way to simulate preheating is to run your 30 min simulation with excessive fuel, in his case about double the std for a normal office fire. Your F47 does that as well, at 40kg. The combination gives an extreme boundary result given perfect controlled conditions, and somewhat small columns and beams = 700 - 750 C. This is Disney territory compared to real life event of WTC7, much more massive structure with much less fuel and imperfect ventilation etc..

U can see that most of the Cardington results are actually in the 400 -600 range.

Interestingly, Korol shows 200 -300 C for 30 min normal office fire with std 20kg load to 40 kg double load given WTC7 floor beams, and Weid claims 200 -300 C preheat given 4 hours and, WTC7 floor beams, so adding both upp u are in that 400 to 600 C range..which makes sense. U need the xtreme double fuel load for the actual main flame heating plus the extreme 300C preheat (that matches the heating from the double fuel fire!) to get to 600C WTC7 floor beams! And this is given simulations allowing u to assume u have all the supply of fresh air u need.

As I told you:

There is no support in your post or anywhere else for using a 20-30 min heating timeframe as the basis for estimating the maximum temperature reached in WTC7. Notice that? And you are just pulling numbers out of thin air re how much different fire loads would have incluenced the heating of beams. Why should I care about your made up numbers? Tony cited the Cardington Studies because they are the gold standard for experimental heating observations. They just happen to also prove him and you wrong. And you are comically misreading the '93 Cardington Study compartmental fire if you think that those fires burned for anywhere near 3 hours (or were a "double fuel fire"). Check your eyes and reading comprehension if you want to have an adult conversation or just go back to scamming people.
 
Do you agree that it's impossible to know the exact location and intensity of the fires, and the exact location of the initial failure in WTC7?

In reality yes. In the models, NO. Clearly the data in the models are known quantities and represent the temperature effects of the fire that was alleged to have produced the failure of the girder.
Let's be clear and distinguish between real world and computer analysis, and not conflate the two.
The column 79 and the girder connection in particular were chosen as the most likely location of failure based on real world analysis of the drawings. The simulations were then run on that basis, looking for a failure at what was deemed to be the most likely point of failure. If there had been a more likely location of initiation NIST would have chosen it.
 
In reality yes. In the models, NO. Clearly the data in the models are known quantities and represent the temperature effects of the fire that was alleged to have produced the failure of the girder.
Let's be clear and distinguish between real world and computer analysis, and not conflate the two.
The column 79 and the girder connection in particular were chosen as the most likely location of failure based on real world analysis of the drawings. The simulations were then run on that basis, looking for a failure at what was deemed to be the most likely point of failure. If there had been a more likely location of initiation NIST would have chosen it.
Wow, you got NIST on the ropes...

this would be funny stuff if not for ignoring 19 murderers and promoting the inside job fantasy. Attacking NIST makes no sense. Present the evidence for CD, and try not to expose ignorance of engineering by making up BS about NIST.

Fire did it according to all rational studies. Better luck with Bigfoot.

Yes, in the real world, without simulation, WTC 7 fell due to fire. Debunked by reality. Good job
 
Interestingly, Korol shows 200 -300 C for 30 min normal office fire with std 20kg load to 40 kg double load given WTC7 floor beams, and Weid claims 200 -300 C preheat given 4 hours and, WTC7 floor beams, so adding both upp u are in that 400 to 600 C range..which makes sense. U need the xtreme double fuel load for the actual main flame heating plus the extreme 300C preheat (that matches the heating from the double fuel fire!) to get to 600C WTC7 floor beams! And this is given simulations allowing u to assume u have all the supply of fresh air u need.

As I told you:


Let's take a look here.

Private jet crashes into hangar at California airport, sparks inferno

A multimillion dollar private jet crashed into a hangar at a California airport creating an “unsurvivable” inferno on the ground, a fire official said.

Santa Monica Fire Department Captain John Nevandro told NBC Los Angeles that the crash was "unsurvivable.” He added: "The building actually collapsed and wrapped itself around the plane."
http://www.nbcnews.com/news/other/p...california-airport-sparks-inferno-f8C11292403


Now, you know why steel structures require protection from fire.
 
So you never posted the following...
"Supplemental and Amended Second Declaration of Colin G. Bailey"

oops, he said fire did it. Don't worry, there are a fringe few engineers who believe in the fantasy of CD, they have no evidence like all of 9/11 truth.
 
I posted copies of the declarations (which are not the expert reports) on reddit a long time ago, so maybe.

MAYBE ?????

You just plain lied about the existence of a second declaration by Mr Bailey, you WERE aware of it yet tried to hide it from this discussion.
Very questionable. I will allow the viewers of this thread to make up their own minds as to your previous assertion that
"Bailey's full expert report is available at metabunk where I posted it long ago. That is from the appellate case record and would be inclusive of any amendments (and there appears to be none)" (my emphasis)

As I said previously, your posts read like those of a lawyer rather than an engineering professional, and I stand by my earlier statement that any honest and genuine engineering professional can see NIST for what it is.
 
MAYBE ?????

You just plain lied about the existence of a second declaration by Mr Bailey, you WERE aware of it yet tried to hide it from this discussion.
Very questionable. I will allow the viewers of this thread to make up their own minds as to your previous assertion that
"Bailey's full expert report is available at metabunk where I posted it long ago. That is from the appellate case record and would be inclusive of any amendments (and there appears to be none)" (my emphasis)

As I said previously, your posts read like those of a lawyer rather than an engineering professional, and I stand by my earlier statement that any honest and genuine engineering professional can see NIST for what it is.

Lied about what? You asked if he amended his expert report. He didn't according to the court record. Not my fault you don't understand the difference between his declarations and his expert report. You are just as ignorant about civil procedure as you are about these engineering reports, apparently.

ETA and the Second Amended Declaration is actually attached to the expert report record I posted, so what, exactly, do you think I was trying to hide by providing you with that part of the court record?
 
Last edited:
MAYBE ?????

You just plain lied about the existence of a second declaration by Mr Bailey, you WERE aware of it yet tried to hide it from this discussion.
Very questionable. I will allow the viewers of this thread to make up their own minds as to your previous assertion that
"Bailey's full expert report is available at metabunk where I posted it long ago. That is from the appellate case record and would be inclusive of any amendments (and there appears to be none)" (my emphasis)

As I said previously, your posts read like those of a lawyer rather than an engineering professional, and I stand by my earlier statement that any honest and genuine engineering professional can see NIST for what it is.

How many engineers do you have on the CD fantasy wagon of woo? got a number... oops, you got less than 0.1 percent of all engineers who signed Gage's petition of lies and fantasy.

Less than 0.1 percent, and not one of your engineering professionals has evidence to debunk all the studies which have fire as the cause.

15 years, no evidence. 15 years of failure. ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e0sI8KjH0DE
 
MAYBE ?????


Let's do a review since you continue to believe that fire cannot collapse steel-framed buildings.

The Kader Fire

Monday, May 10, was a normal workday at the Kader facility. At approximately 4:00 p.m., as the end of the day shift approached, someone discovered a small fire on the first floor near the south end of Building One.

Despite the fire-fighters’ efforts, Building One collapsed completely at approximately 5:14 p.m. Fanned by strong winds blowing toward the north, the blaze spread quickly into Buildings Two and Three before the fire brigade could effectively defend them. Building Two reportedly collapsed at 5:30 p.m., and Building Three at 6:05 p.m.
http://www.iloencyclopaedia.org/com...logical/case-study-the-kader-toy-factory-fire


Those were steel-framed buildings that collapsed due to fire.
 
Lied about what? You asked if he amended his expert report. He didn't according to the court record. Not my fault you don't understand the difference between his declarations and his expert report. You are just as ignorant about civil procedure as you are about these engineering reports, apparently.

NO

What I specifically said as you can see by scrolling up was EXACTLY THIS

"Did Bailey make any amendments to his original evidence to the court that you are aware of?"

Not my fault you don't understand the difference between his declarations and his expert report.
Luckily for you, this is a blog and not a court, because your reputation would be shredded in a more serious venue if it were.
 
NO

What I specifically said as you can see by scrolling up was EXACTLY THIS

"Did Bailey make any amendments to his original evidence to the court that you are aware of?"

Not my fault you don't understand the difference between his declarations and his expert report.
Luckily for you, this is a blog and not a court, because your reputation would be shredded in a more serious venue if it were.

The declaration is not "original evidence". It is based on the report (which would make the report "original evidence"). Just laughable that this is what this back-and-forth has been reduced to, by the way.
 
Do you agree that it's impossible to know the exact location and intensity of the fires, and the exact location of the initial failure in WTC7?
In reality yes. In the models, NO. Clearly the data in the models are known quantities and represent the temperature effects of the fire that was alleged to have produced the failure of the girder.
Alleged? Each report makes a different model of the fire behaviour. They obviously can't all result in a uniform, unique behaviour.


Let's be clear and distinguish between real world and computer analysis, and not conflate the two.
I don't think I'm conflating them. Something happened in the real world, but we can't know what it was. Computer models can approximate the real world behaviour based on the assumptions they are given, that's all they can do. That different assumptions lead to different results should not be a surprise to anyone. A fire model in particular is one assumption on the behaviour of the fires.

It doesn't matter whether the reports are right or wrong. We know there was fire; we know that fire damages steel; we know that buildings do collapse due to fire; we know that even firefighters thought it was going to collapse. The rational conclusion is that it collapsed due to fire. That's the null hypothesis. If you want to disprove the null hypothesis, you'll need hard evidence on the contrary. The burden of proof is on you.

So let me ask you: what evidence do you have that fire did not do it? In particular, that it was controlled demolition that did it?
 
NO

What I specifically said as you can see by scrolling up was EXACTLY THIS

"Did Bailey make any amendments to his original evidence to the court that you are aware of?"

Not my fault you don't understand the difference between his declarations and his expert report.
Luckily for you, this is a blog and not a court, because your reputation would be shredded in a more serious venue if it were.
I guess you don't have evidence.

Tangential quibbling, and failure to understand WTC 7 failed due to fire. Do you have evidence yet? 15 years


the CD fantasy, dening fire did it, would be laughed out of court.
 
The declaration is not "original evidence". It is based on the report (which would make the report "original evidence"). Just laughable that this is what this back-and-forth has been reduced to, by the way.

It is not so much laughable, as pathetic that you clearly ignore the fact that you yourself quoted elsewhere, the "Supplemental and Amended Second Declaration of Colin G. Bailey"
Then denied any knowledge of same.

Do you not know what the word AMENDED means?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom