does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

To "rig" the building with explosives would require night access for a team for say 6 hours or so per night over the period of a week, depending on the size of the team.


A steel-framed building cannot be properly rigged with explosives in only a few hours because it takes many months to prepare the steel structure even before the first explosive charge is placed.
 
A steel-framed building cannot be properly rigged with explosives in only a few hours because it takes many months to prepare the steel structure even before the first explosive charge is placed.

So no access would be required for many months until the placing of the explosives was physically done on site.
How long do you think that the physical placement of the explosives would take ?

ETA still waiting for a plausible fire based hypothesis that leads to the progressive collapse of the building.
 
So no access would be required for many months until the placing of the explosives was physically done on site.
How long do you think that the physical placement of the explosives would take ?


For WTC 7, months, because the emplacement of explosives would have to be placed over much of the building. Explosives alone are not very effective against steel-framed buildings, which was evident in 1993 when WTC 1 was bombed that left its steel structure standing within that huge bomb crater.

People get the wrong impression that you can place explosives in a steel-framed building and that's all it takes, but that is not true at all. I have seen steel-framed buildings absorb blast effects from bombs, which left the steel structures intact.


ETA still waiting for a plausible fire based hypothesis that leads to the progressive collapse of the building.


I've worked with metals for decades and can also tell you that if you leave a steel railroad track over a wood fire for an hour, you and a few if your friends can bend that steel railroad track by hand. I fact, the steel rail will bend as you lift the rail from the fire. There was an aircraft accident in California where the resulting fire weakened the steel structure of a hangar, causing the building to collapse on the aircraft. Fire will weaken exposed steel and that is why fire protection is added to steel structures of buildings. Another good example was the internal collapse of WTC 5, which was due to fire only.
 
Last edited:
Well as far as you and I are concerned, the reason that I believe there is one is your apparent inability to present a viable fire based hypothesis.
If you have such a hypothesis you would have presented it by now surely.

I have seen a viable hypothesis - the building was on fire, and parts if it got sufficiently hot to expand and deform therefore induce a collapse. If you don't see that as viable, that's because of your own perception, because you do not know how hot parts of it got and how much the structural members expanded and deformed. No one does, although several have constructed models to make educated guesses. Where is your model?

As far as CD, no auditory or visual evidence of demolition exists so that hypothesis has zero basis. There is also no evidence of perpetrators nor their supply chain, nor evidence of their presence, so it is a fantasy at this point.
 
So no access would be required for many months until the placing of the explosives was physically done on site.
How long do you think that the physical placement of the explosives would take ?

ETA still waiting for a plausible fire based hypothesis that leads to the progressive collapse of the building.

You would first have to pre weaken the building, remove fireproofing, then it would take weeks to insulate the explosives so fires of over 1300C would not damage them.

Nothing could be done with regular explosives, given the use of portable radios,an errant signal could have set the explosives off at anytime.

You have very significant problems with CD, more than fire induced collapse has.
 
I hope you don't mind me crashing this thread, as I do not want to distract anyone away from Tony's offer of a debate. I looked at the first debate that he had with "TFK" and frankly, the weakness of your position was laid bare for all to see.
Whose position exactly?

Mind you, TFK has not been speaking for me. I don't think he has been speaking for anyone in this forum except himself.
 
Well as far as you and I are concerned, the reason that I believe there is one is your apparent inability to present a viable fire based hypothesis.

I say it could have just as easily been a billy goat ramming the foundation. so that must be what really happened since you can not prove CD.
 
For WTC 7, months, because the emplacement of explosives would have to be placed over much of the building. Explosives alone are not very effective against steel-framed buildings, which was evident in 1993 when WTC 1 was bombed that left its steel structure standing within that huge bomb crater.

People get the wrong impression that you can place explosives in a steel-framed building and that's all it takes, but that is not true at all. I have seen steel-framed buildings absorb blast effects from bombs, which left the steel structures intact.





I've worked with metals for decades and can also tell you that if you leave a steel railroad track over a wood fire for an hour, you and a few if your friends can bend that steel railroad track by hand. I fact, the steel rail will bend as you lift the rail from the fire. There was an aircraft accident in California where the resulting fire weakened the steel structure of a hangar, causing the building to collapse on the aircraft. Fire will weaken exposed steel and that is why fire protection is added to steel structures of buildings. Another good example was the internal collapse of WTC 5, which was due to fire only.

Doesn't take months at all. You haven't thought this through. It is ridiculous to believe on one hand that fire could do this, whilst at the same time asserting that such a huge amount of explosives would be required to produce a similar result.

I presume there is no fire based hypothesis that leads to a progressive collapse that will come forth from here.
 
100% correct. I have never seen a hypothesis presented that illustrates the specific CD of WTC7. Neither have I ever seen a specific hypothesis presented that plausibly indicates that fire could have brought the building down.
Except, there's ample evidence of fire, and zero evidence of explosives.


I do however know that controlled demolition has the ability to bring down such structures, and presume you do too. It is obvious that you do not have a plausible hypothesis for fire though, and this is the weakness in your position that is laid bare.
That's an irrational position. It doesn't matter if no report produces a plausible hypothesis; fire can still be the cause. There are hundreds of ways in which fire could bring down the buildings. It may well be, for example, that every report models fires that were not realistically intense, because of some conditions that are not known to us, since no one was there to see them. We don't know what happened there and all that is possible is to speculate. Every report so far assumes conditions that seem reasonable, but may well be wrong in their assumptions. You don't have enough information to discard fire as a hypothesis, regardless of the accuracy of currently published reports.

And in order to be able to propose CD as a theory, it should first be able to explain the observables in at least the same excruciating detail as that which the current reports have been examined under. And then, in order to prove that it was actually CD, that would not be enough: hard proof would be necessary.
 
Do you doubt fire can bring down a building? The exact specifics are not important absent an plausible alternative. Do you not agree?

I have never seen a plausible mechanism presented that would indicate that fire or fire + damage can bring down such a structure no. If you have one, I would be open to looking at it.
The question was not if a plausible mechanism has been presented. The question was if you doubt that fire can bring down a building.

I'm interested in your answer too.
 
Doesn't take months at all. You haven't thought this through. It is ridiculous to believe on one hand that fire could do this, whilst at the same time asserting that such a huge amount of explosives would be required to produce a similar result.

I presume there is no fire based hypothesis that leads to a progressive collapse that will come forth from here.

You haven't thought it though how do you prevent explosives from burning up?

How do you keep the aluminum in the thermite, from melting and separating out the Iron oxide?
 
You haven't thought it though how do you prevent explosives from burning up?

How do you keep the aluminum in the thermite, from melting and separating out the Iron oxide?

You put it in a box and you insulate it.

Now.... that fire based hypothesis that leads to a progressive collapse?
 
Doesn't take months at all. You haven't thought this through. It is ridiculous to believe on one hand that fire could do this, whilst at the same time asserting that such a huge amount of explosives would be required to produce a similar result.

I presume there is no fire based hypothesis that leads to a progressive collapse that will come forth from here.

Fire did it, and you are off making up how someone would be able to rig the building with explosives. You got the fantasy of CD and ignore all science on fire and steel. This is all you have, fantasy based on ignorance of fire and steel. Who did your version of 9/11?
 
Fire did it, and you are off making up how someone would be able to rig the building with explosives. You got the fantasy of CD and ignore all science on fire and steel. This is all you have, fantasy based on ignorance of fire and steel. Who did your version of 9/11?

So where is your alternative fire based hypothesis that leads to a progressive collapse?
 
So where is your alternative fire based hypothesis that leads to a progressive collapse?

Fire did it, there were fires not fought. And when I did study WTC 7, I can see how the failure could happen and lead to a progressive collapse. But I am an engineer, and I don't make up fantasy CD claims based on BS. There were zero sounds of explosives, and no thermite products found on WTC steel.

19 terrorists did 9/11, not some MIB evil doers you can't identify. Who in your fantasy version would kill fellow Americans besides idiots like McVeigh? Who murdered 3,000 people on 9/11? 19 terrorists who were fooled by UBL, and you are fooled by your shallow research, and ignorance of fire and steel (science).

Where is your evidence for CD. BTW, you keep ignoring fire science, and the fact steel fails in fire. You have to ignore reality and science to have the fantasy of CD done by imaginary bad guys you can't name. Did you tweet trump with your fantasy findings based on evidence free opinions.
 
Last edited:
Look at my post #1429 above. It moots your question.

Yes. I doubt that fire can bring down a high rise steel framed structure. I KNOW that it cannot do so in the manner proffered by NIST, however I am open to looking at an alternative fire based hypothesis that could lead to a progressive collapse in such a structure if you have one.
 
You put it in a box and you insulate it.

Now.... that fire based hypothesis that leads to a progressive collapse?

Then the explosives blow off the steel, you have to place monrue effect cutter charges directly on the steel to be cut.

You probably didn't know that did you seeing you never used explosives.
 
Last edited:
Then the explosives blow off the steel, you have to place monrue effect cutter charges directly on the steel to be cut.

You probably didn't know that did you seeing you never used explosives.

Firstly. You have no clue what I have and have not used.
Secondly, steel/titanium encasements can typically withstand 3500 x gravity force and sustained temperatures of 1100C for 60 minutes, as per aircraft black boxes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom