does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

The temperature at which the girder would expand to the inside of the column 79 is attained early on in both studies. It is this axial expansion that prevents a failure in the heating phase of either analysis.


Once again, fire was responsible for the collapse of WTC 7, and firefighters also noted that not only did WTC 7 sustained massive impact damage, buckling, and even tilting, but they could hear its steel structure weakening under the effects of uncontrolled fires raging out of control from within.
 
The girder was never a uniform temperature. And its lateral walk was influenced by the expansion of the beams attached to it, which were also never uniform temperatures. All of those temperatures across all areas of the locations in question were functions of the temperature input model. How much and when the structural elements were heated changes how they behave. ARUP never tested NIST's inputs and hence it could not invalidate NIST's outputs (unless it knew there was a flaw in NIST's inputs, which it did not). By the way, not even ARUP claims lateral walk-off was impossible. You may want to re-read the relevant reports more closely, looking first to Dr. Bailey's report. You are stuck arguing from a position that is both fundamentally and technically incorrect.

Nothing here changes the fact that the girder expands axially into the inside of column 79. ARUP did not see a failure in the heating phase because of this in ANY of their simulations. NIST however did claim a failure in the heating phase at a significantly lower temperature.
You have no viable alternative fire based hypothesis that could lead to a progressive collapse of the building. If you did, you would be shouting it from the rooftops. This is why your answers read like those of a lawyer, and not an engineering professional.

ETA Further, you should explain how NIST DID manage to suppose said failure occurring, because that exposes the fundamental error in their analysis.
 
Last edited:
Nothing here changes the fact that the girder expands axially into the inside of column 79. ARUP did not see a failure in the heating phase because of this in ANY of their simulations. NIST however did claim a failure in the heating phase at a significantly lower temperature.
You have no viable alternative fire based hypothesis that could lead to a progressive collapse of the building. If you did, you would be shouting it from the rooftops. This is why your answers read like those of a lawyer, and not an engineering professional.

The girder expanded as a result of its temperature (not just in one place along the girder, but in all places simultaneously). NIST and ARUP used different assumptions as to how, when, where, and how quickly the girder, and all of the elements around it, got heated. Of course they came to different conclusions about how it behaved. Think about it. You'll get it.
 
The girder expanded as a result of its temperature (not just in one place along the girder, but in all places simultaneously). NIST and ARUP used different assumptions as to how, when, where, and how quickly the girder, and all of the elements around it, got heated. Of course they came to different conclusions about how it behaved. Think about it. You'll get it.

NIST's error was to presume failure of the girder element and remove it along with the elements attached to it once it was deemed to have failed. THIS is a fundamental error in their analysis, and an error which allowed them to assert a failure in the heating phase, where ARUP or nobody else concurred.
It is this single error in NIST's analysis model protocol that resulted in their stating of an impossibility as a plausibility and any genuine and honest engineering professional who has studied their analysis will and has seen this.
 
NIST's error was to presume failure of the girder element and remove it along with the elements attached to it once it was deemed to have failed. THIS is a fundamental error in their analysis, and an error which allowed them to assert a failure in the heating phase, where ARUP or nobody else concurred.
It is this single error in NIST's analysis model protocol that resulted in their stating of an impossibility as a plausibility and any genuine and honest engineering professional who has studied their analysis will and has seen this.

You can assert something without evidence till you are blue in the face, but it's not going to make it so. ARUP never tested NIST's heating scenario, so we don't know what ARUP would have concluded happened in that scenario. It's really that simple. You want to build a bridge too far.
 
... ARUP did not see a failure in the heating phase because of this in ANY of their simulations. ...
Are you saying ARUP is right, fire did it? If you don't believe ARUP, you can't use it to say NIST is wrong. Was ARUP right, it was fire? (cooling is part of the effects of fire)
The collapse was caused by fire. How did they plant your CD stuff, and who did it? Attacking studies is a proof you don't have an alternate theory backed with evidence. Where is your fantasy study for CD?

How can we debate NIST, when you don't understand what probable means?
 
Last edited:
You can assert something without evidence till you are blue in the face, but it's not going to make it so. ARUP never tested NIST's heating scenario, so we don't know what ARUP would have concluded happened in that scenario. It's really that simple. You want to build a bridge too far.

ARUP performed over a hundred simulations. The ones presented in the reports are not a summation of their study, but rather the 4 that best supported the case that they were making to the court.
It is therefor wrong of you to state that they did not replicate NISTs temperatures because they undoubtedly would have. The fact is that they obviously did not find an analysis at those temperatures that did anything whatsoever to support their case.
 
The girder expanded as a result of its temperature (not just in one place along the girder, but in all places simultaneously). NIST and ARUP used different assumptions as to how, when, where, and how quickly the girder, and all of the elements around it, got heated. Of course they came to different conclusions about how it behaved. Think about it. You'll get it.

That's the problem, he's THINKING about it. His own brain could not contain all possible heating, and expansions and distortions of the beams, girders and columns. And yet he has already come to a conclusion and is sure of himself.

Dunning-Kruger.
 
ARUP performed over a hundred simulations. The ones presented in the reports are not a summation of their study, but rather the 4 that best supported the case that they were making to the court.
It is therefor wrong of you to state that they did not replicate NISTs temperatures because they undoubtedly would have. The fact is that they obviously did not find an analysis at those temperatures that did anything whatsoever to support their case.

Show me where they tested NIST's scenario and came to a different conclusion than NIST then. Bailey's final conclusion was that NIST's lateral walk-off was "unlikely". If anything, that would suggest that ARUP found scenarios in which lateral walk off occurred, no? Were they NIST's temperature scenarios? We'll never know and you are left to speculate. Of course, you only speculate towards your pre-conceived conclusion, which is typical. I can see now that you see your error.
 
Okay, let's draw a breath and state clearly if we trust NIST's recent real world study into composite floor systems and their reaction to fire, over their failed and flawed computer simulations that are not supported by any other analysis ?
 
Okay, let's draw a breath and state clearly if we trust NIST's recent real world study into composite floor systems and their reaction to fire, over their failed and flawed computer simulations that are not supported by any other analysis ?

Let's not gish gallop away, actually. Do you have evidence that ARUP tested NIST's temperature model or not?
 
Show me where they tested NIST's scenario and came to a different conclusion than NIST then. Bailey's final conclusion was that NIST's lateral walk-off was "unlikely". If anything, that would suggest that ARUP found scenarios in which lateral walk off occurred, no? Were they NIST's temperature scenarios? We'll never know and you are left to speculate. Of course, you only speculate towards your pre-conceived conclusion, which is typical. I can see now that you see your error.

Bailey repeated NIST's error of underestimating the seat plate width as 11". How could he possibly have made that same error if he had taken his data from the structural drawings that were available to him at the time, and not NISt's flawed yet convenient assertion that the seat plate was 11" ?
 
Doesn't take months at all.


Oh yes, it does! It would have taken about a year to prepare the WTC Towers for demolition. In fact, it took months just to prepare a steel-framed bridge in Corpus Christi, Texas for demolition with explosives.

You haven't thought this through.

Let's just say that I am very familiar with what it takes to bring down a steel-framed building with explosives. The fact that the WTC Towers and WTC 7 withstood massive impacts and remained standing, is a clue that explosives alone would have been ineffective, and once again, I bring up the 1993 bombing of WTC 1 as an example. In addtion, the Chinese embassy absorbed multiple bomb strikes and yet, the building remained standing.

It is ridiculous to believe on one hand that fire could do this, whilst at the same time asserting that such a huge amount of explosives would be required to produce a similar result.

From my own experience in war, I know what I am talking about. The blast wave from a bomb blast simply flows around steel structures like wind flowing around a flag pole. Figure why the steel structure of WTC 1 remained standing within that huge bomb crater in 1993. Did WTC 1 and WTC 2 collapse due to those aircraft impacts? No. Why?! The steel structures simply redistributed structural loads around their damaged structures and remained standing. However, the fires would eventually weakened the steel structures carrying those redistributed structural loads where eventually the steel structures carrying the redistributed structural loads failed.

Look what fire did to WTC 5.


WTC 5 Collapse

https://web.wpi.edu/Pubs/ETD/Available/etd-042907-214619/unrestricted/LaMalva.pdf


I presume there is no fire based hypothesis that leads to a progressive collapse that will come forth from here.

Explosives alone can't do it and the evidence we have is uncontrolled fires, structural buckling and tilting, audible sounds of structural weakening and direct structural evidence.
 
Okay, let's draw a breath and state clearly if we trust NIST's recent real world study into composite floor systems and their reaction to fire, over their failed and flawed computer simulations that are not supported by any other analysis ?

What failed and flawed computer simulation? BTW...it is called a computer model not a simulation. Purdue University produced a computer simulations...see the difference?
 
What failed and flawed computer simulation? BTW...it is called a computer model not a simulation. Purdue University produced a computer simulations...see the difference?

Would you like to review that comment ???

ETA what was that word you used to describe me earlier in your infantile insult?
 
Last edited:
You don't even need a traveling fire to heat a protected beam over 700 C, Ziggi. The Cardington studies observed a protected beam reaching 750 C in a controlled compartmental fire. It's all laid out for you in my "pompous rant", so don't pretend like you've never seen it the same way you pretended you couldn't read the NIST temperatures. It's a waste over everyone's time, which is all you ever seem to be good for besides defrauding your fellow travelers over studies that your colleagues never intend to publish. At least Tony doesn't pretend he can't read; he just has a bad habit of jumping to conclusions before he's done the reading and then disappearing after he has.

Also, you do realize that Tony and Korol claim to be relying on the NIST temperatures, right?

By the way, after you're done looking at page F47 of the '93 Cardington Study per the "pompous rant" of mine in which I had the nerve to lay out actual sourced facts for you, you might want to take a look at page 17 of the WAI report. You feeling stupid yet? If you understand the connection between the two, you should be. If you don't understand the connection between the two, then I feel a little bit worse about it, but you should still be feeling pretty stupid.

Again all u have is a lot of pompous ranting that avoids actually addressing anything I said, by either ignoring it or circumventing it.

Lets start w what u do not dare to even mention:

1) You are unable to defend your dishonesty and hypocrisy:
You are trying to accuse and ridicule others for relying on faith, while u are in fact the one that is defending the super hot Nistical fire analysis even though it is not backed up w experiments or verifiable data since NIST refused to release it. And u are also PREACHING faith in a Weidlinger fire analysis that reports even more extreme temps even though it is not even available for scrutiny.

2) U are unable to summon enough intellectual honesty to examine your sand foundations:

u can still summon some intellectual honesty and move towards reality, u will have to start at the beginning and see if you can actually scientifically verify that even NISTs lower temp simulation results hold up on their own under skeptical scrutiny, and then see if they are plausible in reality for WTC7 that day. If u do u might find that NIST claims of 600 to 680 C are about as reliable as its physically impossible 6.25 inch expansion and girder walk off to the west claims in the same report. Only then will u start to understand the sand foundation on which the publicly unavailable for some reason 850C Weidlinger simulation stands.

3) You are not man enough to admit you were wrong about Korol:
As for the Korol study u like to rant about for not considering possible higher temps due to pre-heating by traveling fires, it actually does just that by proxy by doubling the fuel load


- No amount of pompous ranting can cover up any of the above. Finally, what is...
plausible in reality for WTC7 that day.
?

Korol said:
even higher value of 45 kg/m 2 . This lat-
ter estimate is included to account for the case of travel-
ling fires, shown to augment the maximum temperature
at a specific location by virtue of “far afield” fires
I said:
it actually does just that by proxy by doubling the fuel load
You said:
The Cardington studies observed a protected beam reaching 750 C in a controlled compartmental fire... F47 of the '93 Cardington

NIST is studying a normal office fire, which means 20 to 30 mins of fire in each spot. Having one location heated up for longer than that means u are getting extra heat from other spots. Your F47 nears 3 hours of heating and does not start to go over 600C until after about 1 hour of heating. In relation to your normal office, this is your preheating from fuel in a larger area. As Korol shows, another way to simulate preheating is to run your 30 min simulation with excessive fuel, in his case about double the std for a normal office fire. Your F47 does that as well, at 40kg. The combination gives an extreme boundary result given perfect controlled conditions, and somewhat small columns and beams = 700 - 750 C. This is Disney territory compared to real life event of WTC7, much more massive structure with much less fuel and imperfect ventilation etc..

U can see that most of the Cardington results are actually in the 400 -600 range.

Interestingly, Korol shows 200 -300 C for 30 min normal office fire with std 20kg load to 40 kg double load given WTC7 floor beams, and Weid claims 200 -300 C preheat given 4 hours and, WTC7 floor beams, so adding both upp u are in that 400 to 600 C range..which makes sense. U need the xtreme double fuel load for the actual main flame heating plus the extreme 300C preheat (that matches the heating from the double fuel fire!) to get to 600C WTC7 floor beams! And this is given simulations allowing u to assume u have all the supply of fresh air u need.

As I told you:
If u do u might find that NIST claims of 600 to 680 C are about as reliable as its physically impossible 6.25 inch expansion and girder walk off to the west claims in the same report. Only then will u start to understand the sand foundation on which the publicly unavailable for some reason 850C Weidlinger simulation stands.
 
Bailey repeated NIST's error of underestimating the seat plate width as 11". How could he possibly have made that same error if he had taken his data from the structural drawings that were available to him at the time, and not NISt's flawed yet convenient assertion that the seat plate was 11" ?

Bailey states plainly in his affidavit that he examined the building plans. If he, as a world renowned forensic engineer who is qualified to opine on such matters in federal court came to a different reading of the building plans than you, then the burden is on you to demonstrate him wrong. In any case, even if he was mistaken about that detail (and your naked assertions don't make that so), it does not follow that he, NIST, ARUP, nor anyone else were wrong in their conclusions as you haven't established said detail was material to their analyses.
 
Nothing here changes the fact that the girder expands axially into the inside of column 79. ARUP did not see a failure in the heating phase because of this in ANY of their simulations. NIST however did claim a failure in the heating phase at a significantly lower temperature.


Take a look at these railroad tracks and take note they were not exposed to fire.


Buckled Railroad Tracks Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJeiYaSFCf0
 
Bailey states plainly in his affidavit that he examined the building plans. If he, as a world renowned forensic engineer who is qualified to opine on such matters in federal court came to a different reading of the building plans than you, then the burden is on you to demonstrate him wrong. In any case, even if he was mistaken about that detail (and your naked assertions don't make that so), it does not follow that he, NIST, ARUP, nor anyone else were wrong in their conclusions as you haven't established said detail was material to their analyses.

Did Bailey make any amendments to his original evidence to the court that you are aware of?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom