does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

I have never seen a plausible mechanism presented that would indicate that fire or fire + damage can bring down such a structure no.


We can take a look back into history because there have been cases where steel-framed buildings collapsed due to fire.
 
Well as far as you and I are concerned, the reason that I believe there is one is your apparent inability to present a viable fire based hypothesis.
If you have such a hypothesis you would have presented it by now surely.
So you really have nothing other then a belief? You do know fire has actually destroyed buildings in the past? It's the reason fire proofing is so critical and regulated so closely.
 
Last edited:
Nice desperate try.

I am not desperate at all. If you have a fire based alternative hypothesis with a viable failure mechanism that leads to progressive collapse then present it to me. If you don't then just admit that, and we can move the debate on.
 
Well as far as you and I are concerned, the reason that I believe there is one is your apparent inability to present a viable fire based hypothesis.
If you have such a hypothesis you would have presented it by now surely.

We saw the fires we didn't see thermite placing magical leprechauns.

If you want to advance the CD, claims it is up to you to propose a CD theory that better explains the entire event of 9/11/2001.

I await your complete published and peer reviewed hypothesis.
 
This is the classic truther ruse. First, pretend that the idea of a building collapsing due to fire is unthinkable; second, pretend that the idea of a building being rigged for demolition without the knowledge of its occupants is commonplace (or simply evade the question, trying to sneak it past by omission); then reverse the burden of proof and claim NIST has not met that burden. It's not about to fool anybody here any more than the old "I'm not a conspiracy theorist but..." ruse; one wonders why they bother.

Dave
 
I am not desperate at all. If you have a fire based alternative hypothesis with a viable failure mechanism that leads to progressive collapse then present it to me. If you don't then just admit that, and we can move the debate on.

If you have a viable hypothesis for how the building could have been rigged for demolition without its occupants noticing, why the characteristic sounds of demolition charges were not heard prior to its collapse, and why the exhaustive search through the debris revealed no evidence of explosives or associated parts of demolition devices, then present it to us. If you don't then just admit that; but of course you don't, and you won't.

Dave
 
We can take a look back into history because there have been cases where steel-framed buildings collapsed due to fire.
Did you miss the fact the fires on 9/11 in 1, 2, and 7 were NOT fought? Did you figure this was a big reason for steel failing? No? Why not?

It is called heat, and if you studied fire and steel... which you did not... you come up with BS.

http://www.fireengineering.com/arti...-strategies-for-steel-frame-construction.html

http://www.steelconstruction.info/Fire_and_steel_construction

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rT_gBysqfSo
The office fires in the WTC towers caused collapse, twice... WTC 7 too. Steel fails in fire.

https://books.google.com/books?id=F...IOTAF#v=onepage&q=steel fails in fire&f=false

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8XMTALBYRNA
Collapse, darn, you thought you had something. The steel only section of the Madrid building failed in fire. Fires were fought... oops

https://web.wpi.edu/Pubs/ETD/Available/etd-050406-105306/unrestricted/rnacewicz.pdf

https://sites.google.com/site/wtc7lies/somelinkstostudiesandexamplesofthebehavi

Did you try to learn about fire and steel, or skip right to the CD stuff based on nonsense.
 
Then correct me on heat transfer, Tony. You ran away from our discussion weeks ago. You've had plenty of time to review the relevant literature.

It didn't take me long to learn enough about heat transfer did figure out the fundamental error you and Korol were making. If you are such an expert on the subject, why didn't you realize it sooner? Do you still defend Korol's approach? If so, why do you still insist on believing in something for which there is no experimental or even theoretical support in the literature? You can still summon some intellectual honesty and move towards reality, Tony.


Who do you think you are kidding with your pompous ranting? You are trying to accuse and ridicule others for relying on faith, while u are in fact the one that is defending the super hot Nistical fire analysis even though it is not backed up w experiments or verifiable data since NIST refused to release it. And u are also PREACHING faith in a Weidlinger fire analysis that reports even more extreme temps even though it is not even available for scrutiny. What a joke.

If u can still summon some intellectual honesty and move towards reality, u will have to start at the beginning and see if you can actually scientifically verify that even NISTs lower temp simulation results hold up on their own under skeptical scrutiny, and then see if they are plausible in reality for WTC7 that day. If u do u might find that NIST claims of 600 to 680 C are about as reliable as its physically impossible 6.25 inch expansion and girder walk off to the west claims in the same report. Only then will u start to understand the sand foundation on which the publicly unavailable for some reason 850C Weidlinger simulation stands.

As for the Korol study u like to rant about for not considering possible higher temps due to pre-heating by traveling fires, it actually does just that by proxy by doubling the fuel load:


..This appears to be a reasona-
ble estimate, as the assumed amount of wood and plastic
materials equivalent per m 2 is often cited as 20 kg/m 2
(typical for office buildings). On the other hand, this esti-
mate, although reasonable for most office buildings, may
not account for the unusual situation wherein excessively
high fuel loading may result in some compartments ver-
sus that in others. Indeed, the NIST report indicates a load-
ing of 32 kg/m 2 to be appropriate, a case to be examined,
together with an even higher value of 45 kg/m 2 . This lat- ter estimate is included to account for the case of travel- ling fires, shown to augment the maximum temperature at a specific location by virtue of “far afield” fires(Jonsdottir et al., 2010).
 
Thank you - this is more to the point. This still means that there can be no failure to the west, so invalidating NIST's hypothesis which is impossible. Refreshing to get that out the way in a debate such as this. Are you saying that the girder sags and fails to the north, in the cooling phase?


As for the other models, which ones specifically are you referring to? I have studied them and there is no viable failure mechanism there in any of them that can possibly occur in the heating phase.

Is it fair then to say that we are now considering a failure in the cooling phase of the analysis, presumably ARUP's ?

ETA, could you point me to the reference for that temperature please?

Sorry I didn't really read this and No the experimental evidence supports Tony being wrong about bolt sheer, so NIST has a plausible theory!

I have repeatedly asked Tony to back up his claims with experimental evidence and he has repeatedly ignored my requests trying to hide the fact he has none.
 
Who do you think you are kidding with your pompous ranting? You are trying to accuse and ridicule others for relying on faith, while u are in fact the one that is defending the super hot Nistical fire analysis even though it is not backed up w experiments or verifiable data since NIST refused to release it. And u are also PREACHING faith in a Weidlinger fire analysis that reports even more extreme temps even though it is not even available for scrutiny. What a joke.

If u can still summon some intellectual honesty and move towards reality, u will have to start at the beginning and see if you can actually scientifically verify that even NISTs lower temp simulation results hold up on their own under skeptical scrutiny, and then see if they are plausible in reality for WTC7 that day. If u do u might find that NIST claims of 600 to 680 C are about as reliable as its physically impossible 6.25 inch expansion and girder walk off to the west claims in the same report. Only then will u start to understand the sand foundation on which the publicly unavailable for some reason 850C Weidlinger simulation stands.

As for the Korol study u like to rant about for not considering possible higher temps due to pre-heating by traveling fires, it actually does just that by proxy by doubling the fuel load:

Great you just debunked both Tony and Korol, thanks Ziggi, you were very helpful.
 
Who do you think you are kidding with your pompous ranting? You are trying to accuse and ridicule others for relying on faith, while u are in fact the one that is defending the super hot Nistical fire analysis even though it is not backed up w experiments or verifiable data since NIST refused to release it. And u are also PREACHING faith in a Weidlinger fire analysis that reports even more extreme temps even though it is not even available for scrutiny. What a joke.

If u can still summon some intellectual honesty and move towards reality, u will have to start at the beginning and see if you can actually scientifically verify that even NISTs lower temp simulation results hold up on their own under skeptical scrutiny, and then see if they are plausible in reality for WTC7 that day. If u do u might find that NIST claims of 600 to 680 C are about as reliable as its physically impossible 6.25 inch expansion and girder walk off to the west claims in the same report. Only then will u start to understand the sand foundation on which the publicly unavailable for some reason 850C Weidlinger simulation stands.

As for the Korol study u like to rant about for not considering possible higher temps due to pre-heating by traveling fires, it actually does just that by proxy by doubling the fuel load:

You don't even need a traveling fire to heat a protected beam over 700 C, Ziggi. The Cardington studies observed a protected beam reaching 750 C in a controlled compartmental fire. It's all laid out for you in my "pompous rant", so don't pretend like you've never seen it the same way you pretended you couldn't read the NIST temperatures. It's a waste over everyone's time, which is all you ever seem to be good for besides defrauding your fellow travelers over studies that your colleagues never intend to publish. At least Tony doesn't pretend he can't read; he just has a bad habit of jumping to conclusions before he's done the reading and then disappearing after he has.

Also, you do realize that Tony and Korol claim to be relying on the NIST temperatures, right?

By the way, after you're done looking at page F47 of the '93 Cardington Study per the "pompous rant" of mine in which I had the nerve to lay out actual sourced facts for you, you might want to take a look at page 17 of the WAI report. You feeling stupid yet? If you understand the connection between the two, you should be. If you don't understand the connection between the two, then I feel a little bit worse about it, but you should still be feeling pretty stupid.
 
Last edited:
I don't see how fire could do this,....

You would be surprised what fire can do to steel-framed buildings.

FAILURE ANALYSIS OF THE WORLD TRADE CENTER 5 BUILDING

This project involves a failure analysis of the internal structural collapse that occurred in World Trade Center 5 (WTC 5) due to fire exposure alone on September 11, 2001.

https://web.wpi.edu/Pubs/ETD/Available/etd-042907-214619/unrestricted/LaMalva.pdf


What fire can do to steel photos

http://i662.photobucket.com/albums/uu347/911conspiracytv/horseshoe_steel.jpg

http://drjudywood.com/articles/JJ/pics/DSCN0941_s.jpg

http://drjudywood.com/articles/JJ/pics/horseshoe_r1_c2_s_s.jpg

https://www.metabunk.org/data/MetaM...ket_Street_near_the_Ferry_20120423_102129.jpg


Fire Collapses Oakland Freeway as Steel Supports Fail

At about 3:30 AM on Sunday, April 29, 2007, a tanker truck collided into the right side guard rail of a freeway ramp from Highway 80 east (Richmond, Berkeley) to Highway 880 gsouth (San José), rolled onto its right side and exploded into fire. The metal supports below the upper ramp heated and expanded. The heating and expansion were far beyond design expectations.

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/29/us/29cnd-collapse.html



Kader Toy Factory Fire


Despite the firefighters’ efforts, Building One collapsed completely at approximately 5:14 p.m. Fanned by strong winds blowing toward the north, the blaze spread quickly into Buildings Two and Three before the fire brigade could effectively defend them. Building Two reportedly collapsed at 5:30 p.m., and Building Three at 6:05 p.m.

The building was reinforced with un-insulated steel girders which quickly weakened and collapsed.
The Kader buildings,...collapsed relatively early in the fire because their structural steel supports lacked the fireproofing that would have allowed them to maintain their strength when exposed to high temperatures. A post-fire review of the debris at the Kader site showed no indication that any of the steel members had been fireproofed.

http://www.iloencyclopaedia.org/com...logical/case-study-the-kader-toy-factory-fire


... and the obvious conclusion is that the building was brought down in a controlled demolition...

It never happened. First of all, demolition explosions make a lot of noise, which was not heard as WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 collapsed, and furthermore, demolition explosives leave behind physical and hardware evidence, yet no such evidence was ever found at ground zero.

Truthers get the wrong impression that explosives could have been planted in secret, but that didn't happen either. It takes many months of preparation to the steel structure before CD explosives are placed. The 1993 WTC 1 bombing provides a major clue when the job is not done right.

So, if you have such a mechanism, I am open to hearing it, and if not, I am happy to move onto the CD issue and discuss that.


There's no CD evidence regarding 9/11. In fact, videos depicting the collapse of the WTC buildings automatically debunk claims that explosives were used. For an example, no sound of CD explosions as those buildings collapsed. in addition, there was no seismic data relating to CD explosives, no blast effect evidence, no physical or hardware evidence. The fact that the WTC buildings absorbed major impacts, yet remained standing, shows that you cannot plant explosives in steel-framed buildings and expect the building to collapse if proper preparation was not carried out.

Have you ever seen videos of steel-framed buildings withstanding shockwaves from nuclear detonations?
 
Last edited:
If you have a viable hypothesis for how the building could have been rigged for demolition without its occupants noticing,

Hi Dave. So let's deal with these issues separately and distinctly.
To "rig" the building with explosives would require night access for a team for say 6 hours or so per night over the period of a week, depending on the size of the team.
To prevent detection or disturbance, the alarm system would need to also be rigged so that any systematic hot work or dust or any other potential sensor triggering events would not show up on the alarm printouts. I would propose in that circumstance that the alarm be set to test for this period in order that any trigger event would show as a single zone wherever it occurred in the building.
Putting such a system as existed in WTC7 on "test" would achieve this, thus allowing access with no systematic paper trail being left to be found.

This is indeed the case for WTC7 in the days leading up to the collapse of the building, which is suspicious to say the least. I understand that this would require the security at the building to either be absent, changed or complicit with such actions also, for which I have no explanation.

I do presume however that you are aware of the alarm being set to "test" for these periods leading up to the day of the collapse of the building.
 
Last edited:
For starters, there's my 10-year anniversary review in the Skeptical Inquirer, Vol. 35.4, July-August 2011. (Nice PDF version here.) You can whine that this is "refuted sleight-of-hand" all you want....

....Fact is, Gage was eager to debate me until the S/I piece came out. Since then he hasn't asked me for further debate, realizing that any possible benefit of appearing onstage with a real physicist was offset by the risk of having his followers read my non-nonsense, fact-based rebuttal of so-called "9/11 Truth".
Originally Posted by Tony Szamboti
...I am glad you brought up debates, as that is what this thread is about. Do you want to debate me on the 911 free forum? Let's see if what you have to say is really non-nonsense.
Originally Posted by Ziggi
Tony, it would be really interesting to see you and Dave Thomas the president of NMSR go over the gross NIST omissions and distortions that it used to arrive at physically impossible conclusions...

Dave does appear to dismiss such things as minor details, but the president is supposedly representing an organization that opposes "groups who misuse and misrepresent science...to suit their own ends."

http://www.nmsr.org/about.htm

We are skeptical, however, of those groups who misuse and misrepresent science. We oppose the use of fabrication, flawed logic, distortion of facts, and pseudoscientific propaganda by any and all groups who twist science to suit their own ends
Perhaps they just forgot to add the the # by the "any and all groups" that leads to a disclaimer in a footnote saying #"except for identities set out to prove the official 9/11 narrative.
Are the so-called debunkers here perhaps trying to come up with excuses to avoid a debate were they would be set to defend the nist reports because they want to avoid the prospect of having to acknowledge and then condemn the omissions and distortions in those reports Lets see if president Dave lives up to his spiel.

Dave Thomas! Mr. president! It does not give a flattering impression of u, to claim that truthers fear your analytical powers in a debate and then disappear when challenged. Are u not up to defending the NIST reports? Are u afraid of exposing them as woo-woo? Do u not live up to your spiel?
 
Did you miss the fact the fires on 9/11 in 1, 2, and 7 were NOT fought? Did you figure this was a big reason for steel failing? No? Why not?

It is called heat, and if you studied fire and steel... which you did not... you come up with BS.


It is no secret the fires were not fought and to me, it is of no surprise that fire caused the collapse of those buildings. I've worked with aerospace metals for decades to know what heat can do to metal. In fact, I have been aware that the SR-71 expands due to heat at its cruising speed because titanium is one of a number of metals that I have worked with.
 
Dave Thomas! Mr. president! It does not give a flattering impression of u, to claim that truthers fear your analytical powers in a debate and then disappear when challenged. Are u not up to defending the NIST reports? Are u afraid of exposing them as woo-woo? Do u not live up to your spiel?

It would be really interesting if you would return the money from the non existent Mark Baslie study.
 
Are u not up to defending the NIST reports?


Not to say that I agree with everything that NIST has said, but I do know that fire, in conjunction with impact damage, was responsible for the collapse of the WTC buildings. There is no evidence that explosives were used to bring down the WTC buildings.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom