does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

It is clear that no individual here, who supports the present official story for how the three high-rises in NYC collapsed on Sept. 11, 2001, is willing to leave the security of this group and defend what they claim to believe in a one-on-one situation.
That much should have been obvious from the outset Tony. Your narrow limitation of the target group to join you in "debate" clearly prevents me and any others of like mind offering to join in discussion. I stopped relying on the "official story" back in 2007. I will support NIST on the things they got right. I will disagree on the bits they got wrong. I will continue to disagree with you whenever you assert that NIST is globally wrong AND you refuse to identify which bits you are claiming are wrong.

That basically says that those of you who fit the above description have no faith in what you are actually saying and know it will not hold up to the heavy scrutiny which can and will be applied in a one-on-one situation where there is sufficient time for thoughtful responses.
Of course - actually it is a truism. Your definition excluding those like me who may otherwise have been prepared to joint in the "interaction". (Note I am avoiding playing the evasive trick of refining "debate" to suit my preferred limits on topic OR process. I understand and agree with your intended process of "interaction" via forum posts. I will NOT resort to evasive tricks either by re-defining words OR suggesting another medium. I see no problem with your preference for "discussion" on "internet forum" as a process.)

I think one can guarantee that none here who fit the above description will venture out on their own after seeing what happened to the first to do so (tfk), who was a star and leader here.
More or less agreed. I would say "tfk who saw himself as a star and leader..." - others may have agreed - I didn't for reasons that should be obvious. He appeared to be making a play for the crown left unclaimed since Ryan Mackey departed.
That is probably viewed as a gamble that didn't work out and won't be tried again.
Certainly not within the limitations of the rules that BOTH you and tfk drafted. I would insist on the relevant principles of "scientific method" and the related discussion protocols before I would engage. And there will always be the issue of "who is the judge" when it is a discussion process on forums.
The NIST has been contacted relative to the serious problems with the reports on the WTC they published. They will not engage in an honest discussion and simply say they stand behind their work while being protected politically and not forced to address the issues.
A lot of presumptions in that set of assertions Tony. If I was to engage with you you would need to cease relying on lies by partial truth or innuendo. And that would be a big step for you or any of the prominent currently active "truthers".

It would seem the function of the activity here is to maintain the charade that there is still support for the NIST explanations in the population and to denigrate those who have raised the serious problems with them and shown they are non-explanatory.
You really do need to stop relying on denigration of your opponents when you should be publishing counter arguments.

Whether or not they also play "dirty and dishonest" is not the issue. On the school buses I drive - retirement hobby job - about once every week or three I wil get grade/primary school kids fighting. They don't realise that "He hit me first" is a confession NOT a defence. "He does it also" is NOT a tactic of adult reasoned rational discourse.
 
Last edited:
Oh, and one other thing: As has been repeatedly stated by numerous posters here on many occasions, and answering what I have no doubt is your unstated agenda here, Tony, there is a crucial difference between finding faults with the NIST model - which is intended to determine the most probable collapse sequence with a view to proposing modifications to building codes that will alleviate the damage in future occurrences - and establishing any doubt that the collapse was due entirely to the damage sustained by the building due to debris impact from other collapses and fires within the building. The latter would require either that any possible debris and fire related collapse sequence, rather than the specific sequence outlined by NIST, be shown to be at the very least highly implausible, or that specific and credible evidence be produced of some other cause of collapse; this does not include quote mining, vague, ambiguous or unverified eyewitness accounts, or speculation. In short, even if someone were foolish enough to take up this challenge and fail at it, it would not produce the result you want it to.

Dave

Yep, exactly. The argument that Tony would like to use is that it must have been a CD because it couldn't have been anything else, but then all we really get is "NIST is wrong about this and left out that" ad nauseam. But even winning those points doesn't work; "anything else" is a very long list, and you'll never get very far into it. Clearly, Tony doesn't understand why that argument will never work, so there's no point in doing laps around the barn about it.
 
As all this ground has been covered countless times and been proven to be baseless, I skipped the last couple of pages knowing it would be posturing and goading by the usual suspects. If I missed anything substantive, please update me.

Am I correct in thinking that the NIST findings have been codified and are now part of building codes in many countries? IIRC a new building in China that was engulfed in flames from a fireworks mishap did not collapse because it was constructed using new guidelines inspired by the NIST report.

As an aside, if truthers could each contribute one US dollar apiece (as there are billions of truthers world wide, I am lead to believe) they could buy the BOK Tower ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BOK_Tower ) in Tulsa OK, buy an airliner of the types used on 9/11, wire them for remote piloting (or hire ex-Mossad pilots that can steer the plane towards the Tower then exit through the wheel wells) and show the world that plane crashes and their resultant fires cannot bring down a skyscraper. Hell, they could even rig the building with CD explosives, thermite, mininukes, and fire a DEW after the crashes.

That would show 'em!
 
That much should have been obvious from the outset Tony. Your narrow limitation of the target group to join you in "debate" clearly prevents me and any others of like mind offering to join in discussion. I stopped relying on the "official story" back in 2007. I will support NIST on the things they got right. I will disagree on the bits they got wrong. I will continue to disagree with you whenever you assert that NIST is globally wrong AND you refuse to identify which bits you are claiming are wrong.

Of course - actually it is a truism. Your definition excluding those like me who may otherwise have been prepared to joint in the "interaction". (Note I am avoiding playing the evasive trick of refining "debate" to suit my preferred limits on topic OR process. I understand and agree with your intended process of "interaction" via forum posts. I will NOT resort to evasive tricks either by re-defining words OR suggesting another medium. I see no problem with your preference for "discussion" on "internet forum" as a process.)

More or less agreed. I would say "tfk who saw himself as a star and leader..." - others may have agreed - I didn't for reasons that should be obvious. He appeared to be making a play for the crown left unclaimed since Ryan Mackey departed.
Certainly not within the limitations of the rules that BOTH you and tfk drafted. I would insist on the relevant principles of "scientific method" and the related discussion protocols before I would engage. And there will always be the issue of "who is the judge" when it is a discussion process on forums.
A lot of presumptions in that set of assertions Tony. If I was to engage with you you would need to cease relying on lies by partial truth or innuendo. And that would be a big step for you or any of the prominent currently active "truthers".

You really do need to stop relying on denigration of your opponents when you should be publishing counter arguments.

Whether or not they also play "dirty and dishonest" is not the issue. On the school buses I drive - retirement hobby job - about once every week or three I wil get grade/primary school kids fighting. They don't realise that "He hit me first" is a confession NOT a defence. "He does it also" is NOT a tactic of adult reasoned rational discourse.

Ozeco41, Tony already had a debate sort of on the 9/11 forum in which he lost, he admitted that debris raining down inside building 7 could have caused the facade failure, as observed.
Then have covered his tracks with an excuse, the columns could not have stood long enough to allow the observed collapse, do to earths spin.
I would think the spire standing taller than building 7 after the towers collapsed, would prove Tony's statement of earths rotation preventing the columns from standing totally false.
But what do I know, I am not an Engineer, how could I possibly win an Argument against the Great Tony S.:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Yep, exactly. The argument that Tony would like to use is that it must have been a CD because it couldn't have been anything else, but then all we really get is "NIST is wrong about this and left out that" ad nauseam. But even winning those points doesn't work; "anything else" is a very long list, and you'll never get very far into it. Clearly, Tony doesn't understand why that argument will never work, so there's no point in doing laps around the barn about it.
Tony has been playing that false dichotomy for the past year or so. "I have proved XYZ's explanation is wrong THEREFORE mine is right."

Begging the question of whether he has or has not "proved XYZ wrong" - no matter how many wrong uns he finds it will NEVER prove him right. Proof that he is right requires affirmative proof.

(And of course - also begging the question that "proof" is the wrong word.....but it is easier than using the proper scientific method terminology about "hypotheses" and "falsification". ;) )

Also the false structure of logic has been with us a long time.... the standard "truther claim for CD" goes like this:
"I don't understand the collapse physics THEREFORE it was CD..." -- and adding the mandatory reversed burden of proof -- "...you prove me wrong!"
 
Last edited:
The NIST has been contacted relative to the serious problems with the reports on the WTC they published. They will not engage in an honest discussion and simply say they stand behind their work while being protected politically and not forced to address the issues.
You mean they care not to enter into discussion with people who have repeatedly called them liars and frauds, and part of a vast conspiracy and cover up? I am shocked!
:rolleyes:
 
It is clear that no individual here, who supports the present official story for how the three high-rises in NYC collapsed on Sept. 11, 2001, is willing to leave the security of this group and defend what they claim to believe in a one-on-one situation.

That basically says that those of you who fit the above description have no faith in what you are actually saying and know it will not hold up to the heavy scrutiny which can and will be applied in a one-on-one situation where there is sufficient time for thoughtful responses.

I think one can guarantee that none here who fit the above description will venture out on their own after seeing what happened to the first to do so (tfk), who was a star and leader here. That is probably viewed as a gamble that didn't work out and won't be tried again.

The NIST has been contacted relative to the serious problems with the reports on the WTC they published. They will not engage in an honest discussion and simply say they stand behind their work while being protected politically and not forced to address the issues.

It would seem the function of the activity here is to maintain the charade that there is still support for the NIST explanations in the population and to denigrate those who have raised the serious problems with them and shown they are non-explanatory.
Why do you make up nonsense?

... (2007)
You have lost the argument as to whether or not the collapse of WTC 7 was a controlled demolition. The evidence proves it most certainly was and now you are ridiculously trying to redefine well used and long accepted terms, instead of being a man and just admitting you were wrong. I have to say you look pretty bad stooping to this inane level and I feel sorry for you.
You failed to produce evidence for this lie, and it has been years. Unable to face the fact you are evidence free for years, and never will have the evidence for the lie of CD.

Two lies. A lie of CD. A lie there is evidence for CD.

A debate method of saying there is evidence...
...

I have provided plenty of evidence to show those buildings came down via controlled demolition. The reason you simply deny it is because it goes against your obvious agenda to cover up that fact.
But plenty of evidence is never presented. Then the old people who know it was CD, are in some cover up. 19 terrorists did 9/11, they did not plant silent explosives, or product free thermite; Tony, they used planes and started the biggest office fires in history, using jet fuel. Kind of ends the debate... Video evidence proves it was planes, evidence proves it was 10,000 gallons of jet fuel, twice. Evidence proves no explosives, video evidence. The CD claim remains a fantasy, picking NIST as a scapegoat is not engineering, it is BS. Where is the "plenty evidence"?
 
Last edited:
<<sigh>>
While there is the concept of symmetry in Geometric Dimensioning and Tolerance, it has nothing to do with the events of 9/11.
Referring to the collapse of WTC7 as "symmetric" would require an extremely lax tolerance for the concept to apply.
The eastern mechanical penthouse (it's called "eastern" because it is not in the center) falls in first then the rooftop caving progresses westward, the north face appears to fail before the south face, the split in the north face occurs at ~1/3 the distance between east face and the west face, the eastern section leans in to the initial facade failure line (kink), the western section(twice the size of the eastern section) does as well, the facades then fail and the entire structure then falls, the eastern section twists and falls to the NE while the western 2/3rds falls to the south.

In all of this the only "symmetry" that could be applied is the part I have in red above.

This reminds me of the truther woo that WTC7 collapsed in 6 seconds. No, it collapsed in 16-20 seconds, but truthers do not care to think too much about anything other than the final 25-30% of that sequence.

Blinders much?
 
WTC 5 & 6 stood between WTC 7 and the Twin Towers.

Though suffering far more impact damage than WTC7, as well as suffering from long lasting major fires, WTC 5 & 6 did not collapse.
”Unlike the 47-story WTC 7, the shorter 10-story WTC 5 sustained major rooftop penetration due to its closer proximity to WTC1 and WTC2 and the resulting greater velocity of the impacting debris.

It also suffered from long lasting major fire activity.

It did not collapse and was later 'pulled down' with cables.
”Investigators were amazed that WTC 5 had suffered an internal collapse due solely to fire.

In fact, I've posted photos of the internal collapse of WTC 5 from time to time.”
As skyeagle409 has confirmed, a significant part of the internal structure of WTC 5 did, in fact, collapse.

This was a collapse of a steel framed structure, and just like the other three steel framed structure collapses that took place on that day, the consensus of sane and competent engineers is that it was caused by fire damage, aided to a greater or lesser degree by impact damage.

Your disinclination to accept this does not make it untrue.

Dave

I would have no difficulty accepting what you and skyeagle409 are promoting about WTC 5 if the evidence was not so contradictory.

The 10 story WTC 5 was so impacted by large crushing structural steel debris from the 110 story WTC 1 which loomed over it, that major internal damage obviously had to occur. A finding of localized collapses would not be at all surprising.

Photos reveal this damage in excellent detail.

Considering it also suffered from long lasting major fires, the fact that the 10 story WTC 5 dramatically resisted global collapse is absolutely amazing, especially considering your ready acceptance of the total high speed global collapse of the more distant, far less damaged 47 story WTC 7.
 
does anyone here want to support the NIST reports commonly accepted engineering opinion that a combination of factors, impacts, fire and design, caused three of the structures destroyed in Manhattan on 9/11/01 to suffer global collapse, in a one-on-one debate with me

Fixed that for the thread
 
Considering it also suffered from long lasting major fires, the fact that the 10 story WTC 5 dramatically resisted global collapse is absolutely amazing, especially considering your ready acceptance of the total high speed global collapse of the more distant, far less damaged 47 story WTC 7.

Again, what structural design differences between WTC 5 and WTC7 just might have played a role in the difference in how they reacted to the damage each received?
 
Tony--why don't you invest your free time into studying fire science so you can understand the answer to the question you posed re fire simulations here? It looks like you ran away from that thread when you started to realize the answer, but now's as good a time as any to buckle down and learn something.

You could also spend your free time grabbing a coffee with Dr. Abboud of Thornton Tomasetti. He lives and works in NYC just like you but, unlike you, he has completed an award winning independent study of the WTC 7 collapse for Weidlinger Associates in connection with the Aegis Insurance litigation. Have you ever reached out to him--engineer to engineer--to ask about your issues with his fire simulations or anything other aspect of his collapse model? It seems you've already missed a great opportunity to invite him to the AE911Truth forum you had in NYC this fall. Why is that?

REKT.

Hey Tony, is this what the "truth movement" has been reduced to? Trolling forums and trying to pick fights with anonymous posters in some desperate attempt to validate your existence?

Is this how little relevance your movement has?
 
Ozeco41, Tony already had a debate sort of on the 9/11 forum in which he lost,....
Sure - but you are "preaching to the choir" telling me that. The purpose of my post was NOT to categorise Tony's faults. I've confronted him many times of his foundation errors. So I was distancing myself from some of the false arguments made AGAINST Tony whilst picking his main debating tricks and outlining grounds for a discussion should he want to "debate" with me. He won't because he will not enter legitimate discussion even if I stick rigorously with appropriate protocols for the medium -- I've never seen him post legitimate argument.

But what do I know, I am not an Engineer, how could I possibly win an Argument against the Great Tony S.:rolleyes:
I am an engineer and can out argue Tony in the engineering as he knows all too well. BUT the engineering is not the barrier - he simply will not engage in reasoned argument. So if he does on this occasion it will be a "first" and a massive shift for Tony.


If he intends to change his errant ways and join reasoned argument I could be interested. But as I have already said the procedural conditions include relevant aspects of "scientific method". And - since his claims overall comprise a few "house of cards" bits of logic - I would start with the base cards of his nonsense so (a) his "Missing Jolt" claim and (b) his reliance on "false generalisation" in his claims of error by NIST.

Dispose of those two "base level cards" and his full suite of Twin Towers claims is falsified. THEN think about WTC7.....maybe.
 


​


I would have no difficulty accepting what you and skyeagle409 are promoting about WTC 5 if the evidence was not so contradictory.

The 10 story WTC 5 was so impacted by large crushing structural steel debris from the 110 story WTC 1 which loomed over it, that major internal damage obviously had to occur. A finding of localized collapses would not be at all surprising.

Photos reveal this damage in excellent detail.

Considering it also suffered from long lasting major fires, the fact that the 10 story WTC 5 dramatically resisted global collapse is absolutely amazing, especially considering your ready acceptance of the total high speed global collapse of the more distant, far less damaged 47 story WTC 7.

Hahahahahahahaha "dramatically resisted".

Keep on framing, buddy, keep on framing.

I hear Trump might need a new spokesman. Look into it, you could meet the President of Goldman Sachs, maybe trade some 'spiracy stories.
 
Hey Tony, is this what the "truth movement" has been reduced to? Trolling forums and trying to pick fights with anonymous posters in some desperate attempt to validate your existence?

Is this how little relevance your movement has?

IE: Post 19
So, Tony, as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?

Tony could debate each and every one of us on this forum, and it would do exactly what, to the veracity of the claims that AE911T makes? Note that for this question it matters not a whit what the outcome of said series of debates would be. Whether Tony came out on top of every single poster here, or was completely shot down by every poster here, or if it resulted in a tie, makes absolutely no difference to the furthering of the cause. Does anyone think that, for instance, the CTBUH, or the ASCE, or the AIA would be swayed to look more favourably on the claims of AE911T if Tony could say that he had debated, and won, each and every single ISF poster?
 
Last edited:


​


I would have no difficulty accepting what you and skyeagle409 are promoting about WTC 5 if the evidence was not so contradictory.

The 10 story WTC 5 was so impacted by large crushing structural steel debris from the 110 story WTC 1 which loomed over it, that major internal damage obviously had to occur. A finding of localized collapses would not be at all surprising.

Photos reveal this damage in excellent detail.

Considering it also suffered from long lasting major fires, the fact that the 10 story WTC 5 dramatically resisted global collapse is absolutely amazing, especially considering your ready acceptance of the total high speed global collapse of the more distant, far less damaged 47 story WTC 7.

Oh. We have a new unit of measure.

How many dramatics equal a hysteric?

What fraction of a dramatic is an indifferent?
 
...
1. The debate is restricted to the collapses of WTC 1, 2 & 7 in NYC on September 11, 2001, the NIST reports on these events, and any additional objectively verifiable information and analyses in the public domain about them.
...


Hahahahahahahahahahaha :D:D:D






FAIL ;)
(What you describe there is not a restriction to a debate - it is an invitation to wander endlessly in an effort not to come to a conclusion)




I declare Tony Szamboti the LOSER of this thread - reason: false start.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom