does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

NIST Supporters Are Blowing Smoke

”Why are the fires in these other structures [~WTC 5 & 6] not supposedly suspicious?”
WTC 5 & 6 stood between WTC 7 and the Twin Towers.

Though suffering far more impact damage than WTC7, as well as suffering from long lasting major fires, WTC 5 & 6 did not collapse.
As I recall, WTC5 suffered a major internal collapse; due to its construction, the roof remained standing, so it wasn't obvious enough for anyone to pretend it was suspicious.

Dave

Unlike the 47-story WTC 7, the shorter 10-story WTC 5 sustained major rooftop penetration due to its closer proximity to WTC1 and WTC2 and the resulting greater velocity of the impacting debris.

It also suffered from long lasting major fire activity.

It did not collapse and was later 'pulled down' with cables.

Other than allowing opposing members to create a debating quagmire, for what reason does the debate have to start by swallowing the whole topic of the WTC on 9/11?

WTC 7 is the 'smoking gun'.

Until NIST supporters can credibly defend the legitimacy of the NIST's conclusions about why WTC 7 collapsed, it would seem totally unnecessary to broaden the debate.

A pre-planned controlled demolition of WTC 7 means that there had to be perpetrators 'on the ground' prior to 9/11.
 
Unlike the 47-story WTC 7, the shorter 10-story WTC 5 sustained major rooftop penetration due to its closer proximity to WTC1 and WTC2 and the resulting greater velocity of the impacting debris.

It also suffered from long lasting major fire activity.

It did not collapse and was later 'pulled down' with cables.

And?

Are you of the opinion that every damaged building that has a fire in it must collapse for the WTC7 collapse to be believable?
 
But *shrug* my take on this is that even if 911 wasn't an 'inside job', it may as well have been for all the BS which is going on in relation to protecting investing in and supporting of systems of disparity...


I don't think your message of "It doesn't matter what the actual truth is; we should just promote the narrative that supports our ideological agenda" will resonate with 9/11 conspiracy theorists. That's a bit too truthful for truthers to admit to.
 
Unlike the 47-story WTC 7, the shorter 10-story WTC 5 sustained major rooftop penetration due to its closer proximity to WTC1 and WTC2 and the resulting greater velocity of the impacting debris.

It also suffered from long lasting major fire activity.

It did not collapse and was later 'pulled down' with cables.

As skyeagle409 has confirmed, a significant part of the internal structure of WTC5 did, in fact, collapse. This was a collapse of a steel framed structure, and just like the other three steel framed structure collapses that took place on that day, the consensus of sane and competent engineers is that it was caused by fire damage, aided to a greater or lesser degree by impact damage. Your disinclination to accept this does not make it untrue.

Dave
 

​


Unlike the 47-story WTC 7, the shorter 10-story WTC 5 sustained major rooftop penetration due to its closer proximity to WTC1 and WTC2 and the resulting greater velocity of the impacting debris.

It also suffered from long lasting major fire activity.

It did not collapse and was later 'pulled down' with cables.

Other than allowing opposing members to create a debating quagmire, for what reason does the debate have to start by swallowing the whole topic of the WTC on 9/11?

WTC 7 is the 'smoking gun'.

Until NIST supporters can credibly defend the legitimacy of the NIST's conclusions about why WTC 7 collapsed, it would seem totally unnecessary to broaden the debate.

A pre-planned controlled demolition of WTC 7 means that there had to be perpetrators 'on the ground' prior to 9/11.

LOL
 

​


Unlike the 47-story WTC 7, the shorter 10-story WTC 5 sustained major rooftop penetration due to its closer proximity to WTC1 and WTC2 and the resulting greater velocity of the impacting debris.

It also suffered from long lasting major fire activity.

It did not collapse and was later 'pulled down' with cables.
You were also asked whether or not the way it was constructed versus the way WTC7 was constructed might have played a part in this. You skipped merrily past that.

Other than allowing opposing members to create a debating quagmire, for what reason does the debate have to start by swallowing the whole topic of the WTC on 9/11?
Care to expand that thought so that it makes some sense.


WTC 7 is the 'smoking gun'.
Yeah, we have been hearing that quip from truthers for a decade now. How odd that no professional organization at all sees it the way you do.


Until NIST supporters can credibly defend the legitimacy of the NIST's conclusions about why WTC 7 collapsed, it would seem totally unnecessary to broaden the debate.
Why? What do you have to offer in the way of an engineering report of the scope and detail equivalent to NIST's, that you use to counter it?


A pre-planned controlled demolition of WTC 7 means that there had to be perpetrators 'on the ground' prior to 9/11.
,, and yet pre-planned controlled demolition remains a bald claim with no more veracity than any work of fiction.
 

​


Unlike the 47-story WTC 7, the shorter 10-story WTC 5 sustained major rooftop penetration due to its closer proximity to WTC1 and WTC2 and the resulting greater velocity of the impacting debris.

It also suffered from long lasting major fire activity.

It did not collapse and was later 'pulled down' with cables.

Other than allowing opposing members to create a debating quagmire, for what reason does the debate have to start by swallowing the whole topic of the WTC on 9/11?

WTC 7 is the 'smoking gun'.

Until NIST supporters can credibly defend the legitimacy of the NIST's conclusions about why WTC 7 collapsed, it would seem totally unnecessary to broaden the debate.

A pre-planned controlled demolition of WTC 7 means that there had to be perpetrators 'on the ground' prior to 9/11.

Ten story structure are not as gravitationally loaded as 47 story, or 110 story structures so floor failure induced collapses are not as prone to Collapse the Facades DA.:D

Simply not enough energy stored in the structures height.
 
... (those involving WTC 1, 2, and 7) and what the public domain evidence points to as the reason for the collapses of these buildings. ...
Public domain evidence points to fire, and gravity. Debate is over. Next.


Unless you intend on bringing in fake evidence, fantasy evidence, and nonsense, the debate ended on 9/11 as to evidence pointing to the gravity collapse of buildings on fire. Learn what simile is, and look up probable, it might help you understand NIST, and the fake evidence based on simile.
 
It looks like there are no takers and tfk seems destined to be the one and only JREF'er to ever have the nerve to leave the nest here and debate in a one-on-one situation.

Not really surprising that none of you are confident enough to venture outside of the moral support of the gang after seeing what happened to him. He was a star here.
Creation scientists tend to win the creation vs. evolution debates and many have been held since the 1970s particularly in the United States. Given the lack of evidence for the evolutionary paradigm and the abundant evidence for biblical creation, this is not surprising.
​
http://www.conservapedia.com/Creation_scientists_tend_to_win_debates_with_evolutionists

Congratulations for your win. You're now on par with creationists.
 
It is clear that no individual here, who supports the present official story for how the three high-rises in NYC collapsed on Sept. 11, 2001, is willing to leave the security of this group and defend what they claim to believe in a one-on-one situation.

That basically says that those of you who fit the above description have no faith in what you are actually saying and know it will not hold up to the heavy scrutiny which can and will be applied in a one-on-one situation where there is sufficient time for thoughtful responses.

I think one can guarantee that none here who fit the above description will venture out on their own after seeing what happened to the first to do so (tfk), who was a star and leader here. That is probably viewed as a gamble that didn't work out and won't be tried again.

The NIST has been contacted relative to the serious problems with the reports on the WTC they published. They will not engage in an honest discussion and simply say they stand behind their work while being protected politically and not forced to address the issues.

It would seem the function of the activity here is to maintain the charade that there is still support for the NIST explanations in the population and to denigrate those who have raised the serious problems with them and shown they are non-explanatory.

It's clear you have nothing but 15 years of pathetic failure.

Let me know when you you're ready to put on those big boy pants and we can get started.

Shanksville- you go first...
 
Shanksville- you go first...

A point generally ignored by truthers of all stripes.
AE911T, and in point of fact one poster recently just above, are fond of saying "WTC7 is the smoking gun", yet have no scenario that is coherently inclusive of all the events of 9/11/01.
If WTC7 is the smoking gun, what scenario does it point to? Was Shankesville crash also faked, the Pentgon? If so then it begs the questions on how. If WTC7 is the smoking gun then explain coherently, how the towers, and the aircraft that hit them fit into this scenario. If not then why fake the Manhattan events?

I asked above why the fires in #3 ,4,5,&6 that rendered these structures complete write offs, which would have utterly destroyed the contents of them, are not suspicious. The answer,,, "just 'cuz" .

No truther wants to tie this altogether because the supposition and odd twists of logic just pile up and add up to sounding like lunacy.
You end up with remote controlled aircraft, a covered up shoot down, modified aircraft. As with explosives in #1,2&7 those also are absolute fiction with absolutely no evidence to support them.

What does the commonly accepted history of events have to tie this all together?
A history of both suicide attacks and aircraft hijackings. In the 1960s one such hijacking involved simultaneous take overs of several aircraft, but truthers would tell us that 9/11 was a first.
History has OBL publicly declaring war on the USA & the west in general.
We have OBL publically declaring 9/11 an AlQada operation.
We have the African embassy suicide bombings and the USS Cole suicide bombing.
We have photos of the 9/11 hijackers at airports on that day. We have cockpit audio, we have a couple of DFDRs.
So, motive, opportunity and means and confession, not to mention a pile of forensic evidence.

It all makes this commonly accepted history the null hypothesis. It would take extraordinary evidence to overturn the null but what is put up against it is truly weak.
 
Last edited:

​


WTC 7 is the 'smoking gun'.

The available evidence proves beyond a shadow of a doubt, that fire, in conjunction with impact damage, was responsible for the collapse of WTC 7.

A pre-planned controlled demolition of WTC 7 means that there had to be perpetrators 'on the ground' prior to 9/11.

The use of explosives to bring down the WTC buildings is not supported by the overwhelming visual, audio and seismic evidence, which is underlined by the lack of physical and hardware evidence.
 
Last edited:
It is clear that no individual here, who supports the present official story for how the three high-rises in NYC collapsed on Sept. 11, 2001, is willing to leave the security of this group and defend what they claim to believe in a one-on-one situation.

That basically says that those of you who fit the above description have no faith in what you are actually saying and know it will not hold up to the heavy scrutiny which can and will be applied in a one-on-one situation where there is sufficient time for thoughtful responses.

I think one can guarantee that none here who fit the above description will venture out on their own after seeing what happened to the first to do so (tfk), who was a star and leader here. That is probably viewed as a gamble that didn't work out and won't be tried again.

The NIST has been contacted relative to the serious problems with the reports on the WTC they published. They will not engage in an honest discussion and simply say they stand behind their work while being protected politically and not forced to address the issues.

It would seem the function of the activity here is to maintain the charade that there is still support for the NIST explanations in the population and to denigrate those who have raised the serious problems with them and shown they are non-explanatory.
You had two offers both of which you reject out of hand for some reasons.

We all know what those reasons are. You want to artificially restrict and bias the entire argument, pure and simple.

When that is your starting point, why would anyone have any interest in a debate with a dishonest opponent? We already know from your posts here that your are entirely willing to fling bovine fecal matter and insults around. Who want's that? Why should anyone on any side put up with such nonsense?

Oh, I am certainly interested in showing that those who rabidly defend a fraudulent story are full of s..t.
Straight out violation of the MA you signed up to. Doesn't bother you apparently, so why should we expect any other dishonesty would?

I could report it and have it consigned to AAH, but I won't. I prefer to leave it so that people can see whence your baseless opinions come.

You might argue, sure. But nobody can help how you self present. How you self present is up to you, not me, not anyone. It is entirely up to you.
 
Yup, total fraud. No better way to describe it. The fact that their website still promotes it as factual and complete proves that they are hucksters. Also recall how they took out the shear studs after Shayam Sunder said "We're having trouble getting a handle on Building 7".

Another claim of fraud based on a fantasy of CD. 9/11 truth has failed to come up with proof of fraud. Thus another post filled with lies, and nonsense.

Another post exposes zero knowledge of engineering, and no clue why.

NIST report is done, where is 9/11 truth proof of fraud, proof of CD, proof of anything? There is no evidence for 9/11 truth claims, and CD remains forever a fantasy which fools a few gullible believers, followers.

No evidence for fraud, no substance for 15 years.
 
Tony--why don't you invest your free time into studying fire science so you can understand the answer to the question you posed re fire simulations here? It looks like you ran away from that thread when you started to realize the answer, but now's as good a time as any to buckle down and learn something.

You could also spend your free time grabbing a coffee with Dr. Abboud of Thornton Tomasetti. He lives and works in NYC just like you but, unlike you, he has completed an award winning independent study of the WTC 7 collapse for Weidlinger Associates in connection with the Aegis Insurance litigation. Have you ever reached out to him--engineer to engineer--to ask about your issues with his fire simulations or anything other aspect of his collapse model? It seems you've already missed a great opportunity to invite him to the AE911Truth forum you had in NYC this fall. Why is that?
 
Last edited:
Tony--why don't you invest your free time into studying fire science so you can understand the answer to the question you posed re fire simulations here? It looks like you ran away from that thread when you started to realize the answer, but now's as good a time as any to buckle down and learn something.

You could also spend your free time grabbing a coffee with Dr. Abboud of Thornton Tomasetti. He lives and works in NYC just like you but, unlike you, he has completed an award winning independent study of the WTC 7 collapse for Weidlinger Associates in connection with the Aegis Insurance litigation. Have you ever reached out to him--engineer to engineer--to ask about your issues with his fire simulations or anything other aspect of his collapse model? It seems you've already missed a great opportunity to invite him to the AE911Truth forum you had in NYC this fall. Why is that?

hell the airlines had at least 1.2 billion reasons to show that it was an inside jobby job. Curious that they did not ask Tony to "debate" this with the plaintiffs' experts that they settled with.
 
Tony--why don't you invest your free time into studying fire science so you can understand the answer to the question you posed re fire simulations here? It looks like you ran away from that thread when you started to realize the answer, but now's as good a time as any to buckle down and learn something.

You could also spend your free time grabbing a coffee with Dr. Abboud of Thornton Tomasetti. He lives and works in NYC just like you but, unlike you, he has completed an award winning independent study of the WTC 7 collapse for Weidlinger Associates in connection with the Aegis Insurance litigation. Have you ever reached out to him--engineer to engineer--to ask about your issues with his fire simulations or anything other aspect of his collapse model? It seems you've already missed a great opportunity to invite him to the AE911Truth forum you had in NYC this fall. Why is that?
It's funny how the AE911 Truthers keep trying to narrow things down to a battle they think they can drag out, NIST and WTC 1/2/7, and purposefully ignore anything else. They even use slurs like "NIST defenders", which fools no one here and thus must only be employed to rally their own troops.
 
hell the airlines had at least 1.2 billion reasons to show that it was an inside jobby job. Curious that they did not ask Tony to "debate" this with the plaintiffs' experts that they settled with.

Airlines!!! How about the insurance Companies? You would have thought they would contest claims,,,,,, oh wait,,,, yeah,,,,,
 
Last edited:
The topic "In or on its footprint for the three towers -wtc1 wtc2 wtc7-" was illuminated in threads five and a half years ago.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7378798#post7378798

I had a quick look back at that thread. Beyond the semantic bickering about the difference between 'onto' and 'into', is there any actual evidence that this shows CD? Photos and videos clearly show that debris fell some distance from the towers. How does this support the idea of demolition?
NIST FAQ
Q. Was the WTC debris tested for traces of explosive residues ?
A. No

Skyeagle409 has repeatedly linked to all the other agencies which did test the debris for explosive residue, and found nothing. I'll try to find the links when I get a bit more time. However, I'm surprised you missed this.
Fonebone < Now you know
No, I don't think so. I asked if I'd missed the evidence for explosives and thermite, or the installation of such. Your post contains no evidence of this.
Do you have any? Tony seems to be ignoring me.
 
[
WTC 7 is the 'smoking gun'.



A pre-planned controlled demolition of WTC 7 means that there had to be perpetrators 'on the ground' prior to 9/11.

Excellent. This means you must have evidence for this. Do please show me this "smoking gun". You are convinced it was CD, so can you show me what convinced you? tfk is not my leader, and I have no connection or affiliation with NIST. I am open to persuasion.
Show me the perps on the ground, show me the explosives, and I'll be convinced like you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom