does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Oh, and one other thing: As has been repeatedly stated by numerous posters here on many occasions, and answering what I have no doubt is your unstated agenda here, Tony, there is a crucial difference between finding faults with the NIST model - which is intended to determine the most probable collapse sequence with a view to proposing modifications to building codes that will alleviate the damage in future occurrences - and establishing any doubt that the collapse was due entirely to the damage sustained by the building due to debris impact from other collapses and fires within the building. The latter would require either that any possible debris and fire related collapse sequence, rather than the specific sequence outlined by NIST, be shown to be at the very least highly implausible, or that specific and credible evidence be produced of some other cause of collapse; this does not include quote mining, vague, ambiguous or unverified eyewitness accounts, or speculation. In short, even if someone were foolish enough to take up this challenge and fail at it, it would not produce the result you want it to.

Dave


I declare Dave Rogers the WINNER of this thread, for he was the first to point out one of the many reasons why Tony's OP is a false start as a debate proposal.


In essence, Tony's hopelessly impossible debate proposal seems designed to fish for the stupidest person on ISF so Tony can score a browny point against the fool who'd take him up on the nonsense.
 
In other words you lack the courage to discuss 9/11 as a whole.

Before any more useless debates can happen, you have to be prepared to tie all four plane crashes together in a manner that better explains them than reality.

Absent that, your pathetic little movement is just a joke.

HONORARY MENTION goes to Noah Fence for taking Tony's hopelessly wide debate topic to its logical end, which alone actually deserves being addressed and debated - and which never ever is by any 9/11 Truther at all (except for the totally nutty, which Tony, to his credit, isn't).
 


​


I would have no difficulty accepting what you and skyeagle409 are promoting about WTC 5 if the evidence was not so contradictory.

The 10 story WTC 5 was so impacted by large crushing structural steel debris from the 110 story WTC 1 which loomed over it, that major internal damage obviously had to occur. A finding of localized collapses would not be at all surprising.

Photos reveal this damage in excellent detail.

Considering it also suffered from long lasting major fires, the fact that the 10 story WTC 5 dramatically resisted global collapse is absolutely amazing, especially considering your ready acceptance of the total high speed global collapse of the more distant, far less damaged 47 story WTC 7.

I have already responded to this earlier. Why did you ignore it?

It's not just a matter of saying "hey, this building was also very much damaged so your theory doesn't work!" Each building must be looked at individually, and some may survive worse damage because of how they're built, or because they are smaller and sturdier, or because the damage was different, etc. You're over-simplifying things and this is the source of the perceived "contradiction".

And even IF there was an oddity with WTC 5, the conclusion isn't automatically that WTC 7 was an inside job! That's a complete non-sequitur.
 
... the fact that the 10 story WTC 5 dramatically resisted global collapse is absolutely amazing, especially considering your ready acceptance of the total high speed global collapse of the more distant, far less damaged 47 story WTC 7.
High speed? Over 16 seconds to collapse, which started inside WTC 7. High speed, is that suppose to make the fantasy of CD real?

What rate to objects on earth fall at? There was nothing high speed about WTC 7. Why make up BS to support a fantasy which is based on nothing. CD is a fantasy claim with no facts. Ignore the failure of steel in WTC 5, it is what 9/11 truth does, ignore evidence, and make up lies.

Did they fight WTC 5 and 6 fires?
NYFDWTCfire.jpg

Wow, when you fight fires may prevent global collapse, a know fire science thing, ignored by the cult of 9/11 truth.

15 years, and the fantasy of CD remains evidence free forever, and ever, amen. Case closed - 9/11 truth followers have no evidence, never will.
 
...
If you don't like the ground rules tfk and I used ...

It has been pointed out to you numerous times that the the ground rules tfk and you used were what doomed that debate from the start.

Perhaps this information - that we here at ISF (the more organized thinkers anyway) already rejected your previous debate as being "set up to fail" - prompted you to repeat the proposal, and thus set someone here up to fail, or if you can't find anyone stupid enough to take your bait, set your debate proposal up to fail - and then blame the failure on us?
Let's see:

It looks like there are no takers and tfk seems destined to be the one and only JREF'er to ever have the nerve to leave the nest here and debate in a one-on-one situation.

Not really surprising that none of you are confident enough to venture outside of the moral support of the gang after seeing what happened to him. He was a star here.

By golly! That was the plan!

Tony, how dishonest of you - once again. ;)



ETA: Mark F caught this dishonest scheming before I did:
This of course was likely the intention all along - Tony posts a dubious challenge he knew no one would be interested in, then proudly thumps his chest and declares yet another hollow and meaningless victory when nobody wants to play his little game.

And 9/11 Truth is now how much closer to busting the whole thing wide open?

Is this a narcissistic thing or what's the deal?
This earns Mark F another HONORARY MENTION.
 
Last edited:
Creation scientists tend to win the creation vs. evolution debates and many have been held since the 1970s particularly in the United States. Given the lack of evidence for the evolutionary paradigm and the abundant evidence for biblical creation, this is not surprising.
​
http://www.conservapedia.com/Creation_scientists_tend_to_win_debates_with_evolutionists

Congratulations for your win. You're now on par with creationists.

Tee hee :D

Let me search that old box over there for a BRONZE MEDAL... :thumbsup:
 
A point generally ignored by truthers of all stripes.
AE911T, and in point of fact one poster recently just above, are fond of saying "WTC7 is the smoking gun", yet have no scenario that is coherently inclusive of all the events of 9/11/01. ...

This could be a topic for another deba... urrr *glancing at myriad* argument: Arguably, AE911T has emerged as the strongest 9/11 Truth group precisely because Gage is so staunchly committed to ignoring almost everything important that happened on 9/11 (except for the twin tower collapses) and focus on something very unimportant - the totally expected WTC7 collapse.
Remember the one time when he decided to support "plane at Pentagon" proposal, how he got flak from the "Pentagon no-planers" and paddled back?
 
Setting up the T&Cs in such a way is no different than any religion. Load the dice before the game is played. Then set a venue which is sympathetic to ones cause.

Spanish Inquisition did the very same thing.
 
...
You could also spend your free time grabbing a coffee with Dr. Abboud of Thornton Tomasetti. He lives and works in NYC just like you but, unlike you, he has completed an award winning independent study of the WTC 7 collapse for Weidlinger Associates in connection with the Aegis Insurance litigation. ...

I am looking at that report for the first time just now - thanks!

Tony is gonna looove it: Abboud proves Nordenson and Bailey wrong. Oh, and he surely proves NIST wrong, too, for he has a different collapse initiation scenario (beams zip off the girder between c80 and c81 on floor 9).
Look at this refutation of Nordenson's floor-impact calculation - Tony convinced me and ozeco of it earlier this year, six years after Abboud found it in 2010:
NN Abboud said:
There is practically no allowance for the significant deformations (especially considering the degradation and deformations due to heating) of the upper floor that would occur upon impact. They have effectively treated the upper floor as a rigid impactor; this is erroneous, and contrary to reality, because it assumes that the floor cannot deform in any way upon impact and absorbs no energy.
...
These assumptions demonstrate that Mr. Nordenson’s assessment of the energy of the collapsing floor can be considered neither accurate nor “conservative” [Nordenson, 2010a, Appendix B, p. B2] and his conclusion, that collapse propagates when a single fire-damaged floor impacts an undamaged lower floor, is demonstrably false.

Now I make a bold claim:

Abboud's theory is wrong, too!​

Wow.
Well, something about his scenario is wrong - I am totally convinced of this.

NIST wrong
ARUP wrong
Weidlinger Ass. wrong

But the wrongest of all: AE911Truth and their darling TSz.

Why?
NIST, ARUP and WAI all show that fires of the sorts that raged through WTC7 on 9/11/2001 are well enough to bring that building down.
There were multiple structural failures in the fire-affected floors! Many many structural failures! This could not be any different, for those were the largest office building fires in the history of the world!
Some structural failure in addition to the many many that already had accumulated broke the camel's neck.

All studies agree that once the floor system in the east part of the building rushes down, total collapse as seen (more or less) will occur.


No criticism of any detail of any simulation can nullify these results.
 
I re-downloaded the NIST WTC 7 report, and like all mystery novels I skip to the end to see who dunnit.

Their recommendations spell it out:

- More robust connections and framing systems to better resist the effects of thermal expansion on the structural system.

- Structural systems expressly designed to prevent progressive collapse.

- Better thermal insulation (i.e. reduced conductivity and/or increased thickness) to limit heating of structural steel strength, and minimize both thermal expansion, and heating effect.

- Automatic fire sprinkler systems with independent and reliable sources for the primary and secondary water supply.

- New building be designed to ensure structural performance under maximum credible design fires where the active fire suppression has failed.

- Connection designs (especially shear connections) that cannot accommodate thermal effects.

Then they come right out and say that the "... effects of restraint of free thermal expansion of the steel on the framing systems, especially for the long spans on the east side of WTC7, were not considered in the structural design, and lead to the initiation of the building collapse".

They also come out and say that fire-codes for insulation need to be rethought as they were clearly inadequate to prevent the weakening of the steel at lower temperatures.

I'm not an engineer, what am I missing here?

I'm seeing a fire ignited across multiple floors, caused by a spectacular on-time event, where the fires were not engaged by fire fighters, and left to burn for 8 hours. I'm seeing a building designed to meet the minimum safety standards, in a building complex where city building codes were altered to allow constructing - thus pushing back those minimums to the barest forms.

I'm also seeing a building which took (after its 8- hour burn) 20 minutes to collapse, not 11 seconds (or whatever).

The last thing I am not seeing here is Controlled Demolition in any form whatsoever.

So what did I miss?:thumbsup:
 
I have some time right now and am wondering if anyone here who supports the conclusions of the NIST reports, for the three high-rise collapses in NYC on Sept. 11, 2001, would want to debate me one-on-one as I contend that these NIST reports have been shown to be non-explanatory and incorrect.

The debate would take place on the 911 free forum, like the one I did with tfk, and the rules would be the same as those for that debate shown below.

It's been 15 years now. There is no more debate. 9/11 was not an "inside job". That's just the way it is.

I know it sucks that so much time and effort was wasted, but seriously, it's time to move on.

You know, there are a myriad of real world problems and issues happening right now that could benefit from the dedication and expertise of a person such as yourself.

Perhaps you should consider changing your cause, and your focus. Why not end your day by actually helping someone, rather than concluding it with yet another hopeless circular argument within a dead cause that means nothing now, and will continue to mean absolutely nothing come tomorrow, and the next day, and the next?
 
Last edited:
The topic "In or on its footprint for the three towers -wtc1 wtc2 wtc7-" was illuminated in threads five and a half years ago.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7378798#post7378798
NIST FAQ
Q. Was the WTC debris tested for traces of explosive residues ?
A. No

Fonebone < Now you know

Aha! Fonebone, have a look at this.
The dust was tested for thermite: none was found.
http://911research.wtc7.net/essays/..._WTCDustSignatureCompositionAndMorphology.pdf

The nature of the collapses, and the debris itself, were examined for evidence of controlled demolition: none was found.
http://www.implosionworld.com/Article-WTC STUDY 8-06 w clarif as of 9-8-06 .pdf

Now, about that positive evidence you have....Any luck finding it yet?
 
Tony, you're not interested in finding the 'truth', or furthering anyones understanding of events that day; you're not even really bothered about bringing anyone to 'justice'; you're only interested in a restricted debate where you can claim some sort of 'victory' over 'JREFers', in front of the one or two deluded fools who support you that would actually be interested in watching.

This is about your ego, not truth or science.

ANY debate you engaged in with ANYONE wouldn't change one single thing about the facts of that day, it's just digital hot air on the internet. The 'Truth Movement' - even at its height - amounted to nothing but a group of people united in being completely wrong, and now it's a tiny group of people still determined to be just as wrong. You're basically reduced to trolling (what used to be) JREF, shouting "Come and have a go if you think you're hard enough", when it's not US you need to convince, but you're obsessed with claiming ANY kind of victory over 'us'.

Let me put it in terms you will understand; It's over - you lost and the facts won. Nobody even cares what you think anymore. It's OVER. Sorry Buddy - time to get a new hobby.
 
It occurs to me that any debate with Tony - no matter how broadly or narrowly Tony or anyone else wishes define the terms and conditions - is doomed to failure and not just for the usual reasons described above.

Tony's entire case against NIST has always been premised on the logical fallacy that if NIST was wrong about a detail, their overarching conclusion of fire-induced collapse must also be wrong(plus something, something, something) means it was CD.

But if that logic works for NIST - one detail wrong all wrong - then the same logic can be applied to Tony and his claims: One detail wrong means no CD = something, something, something,... must have been fire-induced collapse.

And since I think every one of us can point to at least one detail Tony has got wrong,...

:boxedin:
 
It occurs to me that any debate with Tony - no matter how broadly or narrowly Tony or anyone else wishes define the terms and conditions - is doomed to failure and not just for the usual reasons described above.

Tony's entire case against NIST has always been premised on the logical fallacy that if NIST was wrong about a detail, their overarching conclusion of fire-induced collapse must also be wrong(plus something, something, something) means it was CD.

But if that logic works for NIST - one detail wrong all wrong - then the same logic can be applied to Tony and his claims: One detail wrong means no CD = something, something, something,... must have been fire-induced collapse.

And since I think every one of us can point to at least one detail Tony has got wrong,...

:boxedin:
While true, do you really think TS will remotely have anything to do with it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom