Oystein
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2009
- Messages
- 18,948
Oh, and one other thing: As has been repeatedly stated by numerous posters here on many occasions, and answering what I have no doubt is your unstated agenda here, Tony, there is a crucial difference between finding faults with the NIST model - which is intended to determine the most probable collapse sequence with a view to proposing modifications to building codes that will alleviate the damage in future occurrences - and establishing any doubt that the collapse was due entirely to the damage sustained by the building due to debris impact from other collapses and fires within the building. The latter would require either that any possible debris and fire related collapse sequence, rather than the specific sequence outlined by NIST, be shown to be at the very least highly implausible, or that specific and credible evidence be produced of some other cause of collapse; this does not include quote mining, vague, ambiguous or unverified eyewitness accounts, or speculation. In short, even if someone were foolish enough to take up this challenge and fail at it, it would not produce the result you want it to.
Dave
I declare Dave Rogers the WINNER of this thread, for he was the first to point out one of the many reasons why Tony's OP is a false start as a debate proposal.
In essence, Tony's hopelessly impossible debate proposal seems designed to fish for the stupidest person on ISF so Tony can score a browny point against the fool who'd take him up on the nonsense.
