does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

And since I think every one of us can point to at least one detail Tony has got wrong,...

I certainly did, but that's years ago. The debate has moved on since then.

But I have to agree with you. The question that's important to me is what happened on 9/11. I don't think any one study is universally comprehensive and accurate, but I think there's enough in aggregation to build up a general picture that confirms the conventional narrative as the most plausible explanation. That said, I think the mark of a rational person is being open to hearing alternative theories. In other words, the general goal of open-mindedness is met by not dismissing claims on their face but rather by hearing them waiting to judge them on their merits. We've done that for Tony, and have ample reasons to reject his claim on the merits.

But what we get from Tony et al. is not so much an alternative theory for the events of 9/11 as it is a fairly narrowly-tailored "NIST is bad" theory. This is similar to the most common practice among JFK conspiracy theorists: it's a "Warren Commission was wrong" theory, not so much a "who killed Kennedy?" theory. And here as there, the conspiracy theorist always wants the debate to look like someone stepping up to be the proxy for his designated enemy. And more importantly, he wants the proxy to have the burden of proof to defend the designee. (I believe this is usually because the designated enemy generally won't give conspiracy theorists the time of day.)

So it becomes a quest for personal validation, which most of us seem unwilling to satisfy. That manifests itself in the paradoxical approach of expressing disdain for critics for their unwillingness to debate, insinuating it's because they know they'll lose as opposed to their having seen through the ploy. The other side of the paradox is the implied value of such a debate as the sine qua non of the issue. The claimant needs to believe his interlocutor is a credible proxy. But he also needs to believe we're a bunch of irrelevant low-lifes for not wanting to engage on his terms.
 
While true, do you really think TS will remotely have anything to do with it?

But now I'm almost tempted to say the magic words 'sure, why not', just to get the opportunity to tell Tony; "since you are wrong about this detail you are globally wrong about CD, therefore it must have been fire-induced collapse. Prove me wrong."
 
Tony you always want to discuss the NIST report. When are you going to publish your CD explanation? It would be interesting to read to see how you came to the conclusion on
Who did the CD, Why they did it, What was used, ho they implemented the CD, and how "they" avoided having the planes disrupt the CD.

Of course we would like to see evidence and explanation on why the other CD explanations are wrong. For example, Prager's mini neutron bomb explanation.

Your theory of CD should stand on its own merits. You shouldn't need NIST explanation.
 
I am looking at that report for the first time just now - thanks!

Tony is gonna looove it: Abboud proves Nordenson and Bailey wrong. Oh, and he surely proves NIST wrong, too, for he has a different collapse initiation scenario (beams zip off the girder between c80 and c81 on floor 9).
Look at this refutation of Nordenson's floor-impact calculation - Tony convinced me and ozeco of it earlier this year, six years after Abboud found it in 2010:


Now I make a bold claim:

Abboud's theory is wrong, too!​

Wow.
Well, something about his scenario is wrong - I am totally convinced of this.

NIST wrong
ARUP wrong
Weidlinger Ass. wrong

But the wrongest of all: AE911Truth and their darling TSz.

Why?
NIST, ARUP and WAI all show that fires of the sorts that raged through WTC7 on 9/11/2001 are well enough to bring that building down.
There were multiple structural failures in the fire-affected floors! Many many structural failures! This could not be any different, for those were the largest office building fires in the history of the world!
Some structural failure in addition to the many many that already had accumulated broke the camel's neck.

All studies agree that once the floor system in the east part of the building rushes down, total collapse as seen (more or less) will occur.


No criticism of any detail of any simulation can nullify these results.

Exactly what many here have said in the past. While NIST and others may have gotten the initiating event details wrong, each and every study done so far concludes that fire damage led to a cascade of floor failures and that this then led to column instability resulting in further progressive failure and global involvement in the collapse.

I find it almost epiphany to see Abboud note that in common office fire situations the lower floor burns for a time and then the next upper floor, while in the case of WTC7 both 8th and 9th floors were involved with the lower lagging (rather than leading) the upper.
It is not too unlije the situation in the towers where an extreme amount of liquid acellerant was spread over several contiguous floors igniting simultaneous wide area fires on those floors.
Both were situations that were not, and only in hindsight could be, considered.

While NIST, Nordenson, ARUP, WAI all performed extensive study and computational analyses, AE911T has done........ nitpicking of those initiating event details, very little study, and minor computational analyses. Of course when I refer to AE911T, I am referring to a single individual from the supposed expertise pool of 2000+ engineers.


But Tony wants to debate the NIST report. Tony wants to continue the nitpick about initiating event. He has gone so far as to claim fires could not have started in WTC7 as a result of debris from WTC1. ( The initial, initial event.....)
 
Tony you always want to discuss the NIST report. When are you going to publish your CD explanation? It would be interesting to read to see how you came to the conclusion on
Who did the CD, Why they did it, What was used, ho they implemented the CD, and how "they" avoided having the planes disrupt the CD.

Of course we would like to see evidence and explanation on why the other CD explanations are wrong. For example, Prager's mini neutron bomb explanation.

Your theory of CD should stand on its own merits. You shouldn't need NIST explanation.

Noooooooo, AE911T will never do that.
Let us pretend they have. They would have a most probable location for thermite and/or high explosives. That would simply and loudly, beg the questions about when, who and how these were installed and how they were kept from being discovered, not to mention that biggee question of why?

If, if, if,,, this was a inside job, false flag, whatever label you wish to call this supposed operation, it would necessarily be the single most despicable act of treason and mass murder in the history of the USA. That would require the greatest of caution wrt discovery, and yet here we supposedly have these traitors blithely planting explosives in not one, not two, but three structures in Manhattan (one of which lacks the cover of being a result of direct aircraft impact), more at the Pentagon ( nightmarish scenario for discovery there aside one would deduce), and, we are told, patsy hijackers/remote controlled aircraft/surreptiously swapped aircraft/aircraft modified to be able to extraordinarily exceed design speeds.


Oooh that last one really would bring a belly laugh if it were the plot in a bad action movie. Here we have a building laden with explosive charges designed to cause a global collapse under the guise of being the result of aircraft impact. But despite the extreme requirement for non-discovery, the perps , for some ridiculous reason, arrange for an aircraft that has to fly faster that it should be able to..........:boggled::eek::boggled:

Sure that later is a PFT fever dream, the explosives at the Pentagon the lunatic ravings of the CIT, but they share an underlying complete lack of a cohesive scenario.
 
Last edited:
But now I'm almost tempted to say the magic words 'sure, why not', just to get the opportunity to tell Tony; "since you are wrong about this detail you are globally wrong about CD, therefore it must have been fire-induced collapse. Prove me wrong."

No, do not get sucked into that BS. I would rather cut off my own leg.
 
Tony you always want to discuss the NIST report. When are you going to publish your CD explanation? It would be interesting to read to see how you came to the conclusion on
Who did the CD, Why they did it, What was used, ho they implemented the CD, and how "they" avoided having the planes disrupt the CD.

Of course we would like to see evidence and explanation on why the other CD explanations are wrong. For example, Prager's mini neutron bomb explanation.

Your theory of CD should stand on its own merits. You shouldn't need NIST explanation.

Welcome. Good luck with that. Tony is not interested.
 
Welcome. Good luck with that. Tony is not interested.

I know that. In another forum Tony ignored questions, or answered with insults. Tony does not accept that any explanation should stand on its own merits. It is good enough to have the opinion it was not fire induced. The only conclusion then for Tony is it was CD.
 
Last edited:
I know that. In another forum Tony ignored questions, or answered with insults. Tony does not accept that any explanation should stand on its own merits. It is good enough to have the opinion it was not fire induced. The only conclusion then for Tony is it was CD.
I really could not say why TS resorts to outright abuse at the drop of a hat. Probably I could but that would break the board rules.

Far more interesting is that he is not even conscious of it. He is happy to castigate anyone except himself.

911 is a dead duck. Mostly, I took a watching brief, rarely posting. The volume of TS vitriol is stunning.

That said, we do talk about all manner of things hereabouts in a civilised manner. Here is my opinion, there is your opinion, what does the evidence show? and so forth. Minds may be changed. Mine has. And I have learned things in my time here. Maybe you can too. I hope so.
 
...And since I think every one of us can point to at least one detail Tony has got wrong,...

:boxedin:
Yes. I can point to detail errors also...

BUT...

as you know Mark I prefer to focus on false premises and false foundation arguments. Because if the premises, assumptions and main foundations of his argument are wrong ALL the detail stuff is moot. And chasing details is a waste of effort.

Remember "Missing Jolt" - Tony's foundation premise was wrong. There never could be such a jolt - missing or not - because the scenario at the foundation of his "argument" NEVER existed. Yet we saw all sorts of measurements looking for different scaled jolts. Utter nonsense - the foundation premise was wrong.

And reliance on false premises was Tony's main SOP trick from 2007 thru last year 2015 when he switched to his current favourite tactic - false dilemma's. "Since I have proved Nordenson wrong - I AM RIGHT" -- and the same folk fall for the trap - discussing whether or not Nordenson was right. When it is irrelevant. (Add the list of "experts who Tony claims to have proved wrong" - I'm only using Nordenson as an example.)
 
It is incredible to see some of the silly comments here when the reality is that we do not have an official analysis which even remotely explains the collapse of WTC 7.

The NIST WTC 7 report and Nordenson's report, for the Con Edison vs. WTC 7 Properties court case, have provable fatal errors and assumptions.

The Weidlinger Associates report has a provably unsupportable and ridiculous assumption of two floors being heated to 850 degrees C simultaneously through 4 hour long preheating.

A new investigation which explains the observations is needed period. Those who would deny a new investigation have either not looked into the matter sufficiently or are part of a deliberate attempt to obfuscate the issue and obstruct it.
 
Last edited:
It is incredible to see some of the silly comments here when the reality is that we do not have an official analysis which even remotely explains the collapse of WTC 7.

The NIST WTC 7 report and Nordenson's report, for the Con Edison vs. WTC 7 Properties court case, have provable fatal errors and assumptions.

The Weidlinger Associates report has a provably unsupportable and ridiculous assumption of two floors being heated to 850 degrees C simultaneously through 4 hour long preheating.

A new investigation which explains the observations is needed period. Those who would deny a new investigation have either not looked into the matter sufficiently or are part of a deliberate attempt to obfuscate the issue and obstruct it.

No investigation into phantom explosives needs to be conducted Tony no CD, evidence was ever found. Fire driven collapse is the only scientificly valid theory, the rubble falls and kicks out the columns as it spreads.
We have nothing from you that is indicative of anything worthy of a scientific inquiry when do you propose a testable CD theory?
Regardless of whether NIST is wrong or Right the fire induced collapse theory is the only proposed theory of merit.
Why should anyone pay attention to the open Huckstering of AE/911 truth?
 
It is incredible to see some of the silly comments here when the reality is that we do not have an official analysis which even remotely explains the collapse of WTC 7.

The NIST WTC 7 report and Nordenson's report, for the Con Edison vs. WTC 7 Properties court case, have provable fatal errors and assumptions.

The Weidlinger Associates report has a provably unsupportable and ridiculous assumption of two floors being heated to 850 degrees C simultaneously through 4 hour long preheating.

A new investigation which explains the observations is needed period. Those who would deny a new investigation have either not looked into the matter sufficiently or are part of a deliberate attempt to obfuscate the issue and obstruct it.

That's lovely, Tony.
Now, do you have any evidence for CD? That might just be the thing you need to get a new investigation off the groud.
 
It is incredible to see some of the silly comments here when the reality is that we do not have an official analysis which even remotely explains the collapse of WTC 7.
Yes they all agree, global collapse after floor failures.
Btw, do YOU have an analysis of the detail of any of tge ones discussed here, that does explain collapse? I only recall the breeze of your handwaving.

Everyone else is wrong, Tony is right.
 
That's lovely, Tony.
Now, do you have any evidence for CD? That might just be the thing you need to get a new investigation off the groud.

I would like first to see actual evidence he is a working engineering professional, because based on his pattern of nonsense I significantly doubt he could design a latrine for Kangaroos.
He only tries to prove others wrong, never doing original work, he would start such a project,
By attempting to prove Kangaroos don't excrete.
Thus he saves time and money making the project unnecessary, but watch where you step.

Tony is it to much to ask, for an original thought that doesn't involve nitpicking someone else's work?
 
Last edited:
I would like first to see actual evidence he is a working engineering professional, because based on his pattern of nonsense I significantly doubt he could design a latrine for Kangaroos.
He only tries to prove others wrong, never doing original work, he would start such a project,
By attempting to prove Kangaroos don't excrete.
Thus he saves time and money making the project unnecessary, but watch where you step.

Tony is it to much to ask, for an original thought that doesn't involve nitpicking someone else's work?

Yep!
On the off chance that a professional engineering group managed to produce a report that Tony could not find fault in, he would simply fall back on his claim that fires could not have been started in WTC7 by the debris + impact of WTC1. Prove beyond a doubt that they could, he will fall back on tower CD, and on and on.

pick away at the most difficult part of collapse sequence to pin down, and ignore that every single study produced has multiple floor collapses progressing to global collapse.

Tony would be better off simply claiming [truther mode on] that the floor collapses were brought about by placing a few pounds of thermite on girder connections on two floors just above the ones actually on fire. They would be above the heated levels and thus protected. The fires would have been started by the perps. These floors would then collapse onto the fire weakened floors. In such a scenario WTC now has 3-4 levels of unbraced columns and 3-4 levels worth of debris moving down towards the core bracing. Progression then advances as per NIST, Nordenson, WAI.[/truther mode off]

No big booms required, no progression study required, no ridiculous claim that FF=CD, etc.
BUT, of course no true Scotsman truther can ever allow that any part of any 'official story' could be true, beyond the date of the event.

(thus also the 'modified' aircraft, swapped aircraft, patsy hijackers, space-a-beam weapons, mini-nukes, unseen flyover, swapped aircraft, thermite/nano-thermite/explosive-super-duper-nano-thermite, pods, vicsims, empty towers, concrete tower cores, etc, etc., etc. post 166)
 
Last edited:
It is incredible to see some of the silly comments here when the reality is that we do not have an official analysis which even remotely explains the collapse of WTC 7.

The NIST WTC 7 report and Nordenson's report, for the Con Edison vs. WTC 7 Properties court case, have provable fatal errors and assumptions.

The Weidlinger Associates report has a provably unsupportable and ridiculous assumption of two floors being heated to 850 degrees C simultaneously through 4 hour long preheating.

A new investigation which explains the observations is needed period. Those who would deny a new investigation have either not looked into the matter sufficiently or are part of a deliberate attempt to obfuscate the issue and obstruct it.

Remind me again where the bolded was proven, Tony? Last time you brought it up, you could not articulate any basis for the timeline being incorrect. It is also consistent with the fire model timeline used by ARUP, NIST, and Bailey. As far as I can tell, even Hulsey is using a similar timeline for his temperature model. Yet we are to believe it is wrong because Tony says so? And why does Tony say so? As far as I can tell, it's because Tony needs an excuse to dismiss the work of people who have studied the collapse far more seriously than Tony.

You ever reach out to Dr. Abboud to talk to him about it, Tony? How does it feel to get recognition from the dozens of non-engineers who fervently want to believe what you peddle, all while knowing there are true professionals out there who have done work that dismantles your castle of BS? Building the walls higher won't stop everyone outside the castle from seeing the BS--quite the opposite.
 
Last edited:
A new investigation which explains the observations is needed period. Those who would deny a new investigation have either not looked into the matter sufficiently or are part of a deliberate attempt to obfuscate the issue and obstruct it.

Or are properly trained and qualified and see through this rubbish for what it is. Your inability to garner even a modicum of interest and support among the relevant professional community is quite telling, and bears on the real reason you lurk in backwater web forums and berate people you seem to despise.

I was serious earlier. You say you have some free time on your hands. Great, write up a scholarly paper expounding your theory, have it peer-reviewed (not friend-reviewed) at get it published in one of the flagship journals on structural engineering, forensic engineering, fire-protection engineering, or the like. That will put your theory to a proper test among the relevant professionals in a forum they would find hard to ignore. It will also promote the discussion to the attention of people who can make a new investigation happen, if you manage to convince them. I simply fail to see how it's so helpful to your stated cause for the people here whom you write off as losers to engage with you here and now, on your foisted terms. Even if you were to win the debate here hands down, how would beating a bunch of obscure anonymous laymen in a rigged game lay groundwork for a new investigation?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom