does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

It is clear that no individual here, who supports the present official story for how the three high-rises in NYC collapsed on Sept. 11, 2001, is willing to leave the security of this group and defend what they claim to believe in a one-on-one situation.

That basically says that those of you who fit the above description have no faith in what you are actually saying and know it will not hold up to the heavy scrutiny which can and will be applied in a one-on-one situation where there is sufficient time for thoughtful responses.

I think one can guarantee that none here who fit the above description will venture out on their own after seeing what happened to the first to do so (tfk), who was a star and leader here. That is probably viewed as a gamble that didn't work out and won't be tried again.

The NIST has been contacted relative to the serious problems with the reports on the WTC they published. They will not engage in an honest discussion and simply say they stand behind their work while being protected politically and not forced to address the issues.

It would seem the function of the activity here is to maintain the charade that there is still support for the NIST explanation in the population and to denigrate those who have raised the serious problems with it.

Well, now that you have that sorted out, what's next? Any other areas of interest you intend to pursue?

I'd hate to see a good mind with a penchant for investigative inquiry go to waste.
 
Flapdoodle ! You got a minute ?

exhibit A
http://themindrenewed.com/in-the-media/713-news156
documented accounts of explosions

exhibit B
An ABC television reporter N.J. Burkett was standing on west street
broadcasting LIVE with the two WTC twin towers in the background.
Suddenly he screamed into the camera--
--HUGE EXPLOSION !!! ...raining debris down on all of us --
as the WTC2 tower began to collapse.
https://vidsn.com/v/liveleak-9-11-footage-a-reporter-doing-his-job+k0Tf5Q4Gc60.html
at 03:40

exhibit C
Firemen report explosions
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IO1ps1mzU8o

No one heard explosions from explosives. Firefighters later attributed the sounds they heard to things that had nothing to do with explosives. During an NBC news interview, some of the explosions they heard were attributed to exploding gas lines, and I am very sure that burning vehicles in the area still had fuel in their gas tanks as they burned. Molten aluminum from the aircraft coming in contact with water is a very explosive mixture and there was lots of water in those buildings.

Falling bodies were reported as sounding like explosions and even falling elevators were reported as sounding like explosions. In fact, the sound of explosions was still being reported long after the WTC buildings collapsed. As far as the reporter reporting the sound of an explosion, the sound he heard was the breakup of the WTC Tower, not from explosives. An explosion would have have been evident to me since I have been in war zones to know what real explosions sound like and I neither saw nor heard anything the could have been attributed to explosives as the WTC buildings collapsed.
 
It is clear that no individual here, who supports the present official story for how the three high-rises in NYC collapsed on Sept. 11, 2001, is willing to leave the security of this group and defend what they claim to believe in a one-on-one situation.


Are you willing to prove your case by addressing my list? If not, you have no case for a debate and its that simple. You have to show me the money before I buy your product, otherwise, it is just a waste of time because I expect some real change back as I don't accept play money. It is like this, I don't give the opposition wiggle room to interpret facts and evidence as he sees fit. I have presented undeniable facts and evidence, so let's see your undeniable evidence that CD explosives were used and do so in the absence of visual, audio, seismic, and hardware evidence and then explain why demolition experts and the majority of structural experts do not support your case after 15 years.
 
Last edited:
Beyond "It looks like CD", "mumble, mumble freefall mumble" and "ITS OWN FOOTPRINT!!!!!", has this ever actually been done?
After 15 years, AFAIK, we have
  • No trace of explosives in the debris.
  • No sound of explosives.
  • No witnesses who saw the buildings being prepped for demolition.
  • No whistleblowers who were involved, and who have now come forward.
  • No coherent explanation of how both thermite and explosives were used.
  • No explanation of how the thermite, explosives and all the associated fuses etc. survived 7 hours of being in an uncontrolled fire.
Tony, did I miss something? What evidence do you have for CD? I'm serious: I'd really like to know.

I would also like Tony to provide evidence on type of explosives used, how explosives were placed in secret in crowded, occupied buildings, how structural pre-weakening was performed in secret before explosives were placed in those crowded, occupied buildings, and for what reason the U.S. government would have for the destruction of the WTC buildings and four airliners and do so in light of the fact that countries around the world had warned the United States beforehand, including warnings issued by Afghanistan and Russia, that OBL and al-Qaeda would be responsible for their attack on the United States. Next, Tony would have to explain OBL's admission for the 9/11 attack and explain al-Qaeda's martyr videos of the 9/11 hijackers after the attack.

It is 15 years and counting and yet, there is not one single piece of evidence that explosives and/or thermite and nano-thermite was used to demolish the WTC buildings.

Short of adequately addressing the facts above and my list that I have provided, Tony has absolutely no case for a debate with anyone. I want clear-cut details from Tony, not speculation nor misinterpretation of facts and evidence currently revealed. If explosives were used to take down the WTC buildings, I would have seen and heard the evidence on video, which I did not.
 
Last edited:
WTC 5 & 6 stood between WTC 7 and the Twin Towers.

Though suffering far more impact damage than WTC7, as well as suffering from long lasting major fires, WTC 5 & 6 did not collapse.

Investigators were amazed that WTC 5 had suffered an internal collapse due solely to fire. In fact, I've posted photos of the internal collapse of WTC 5 from time to time.

Fire and impact damage did to WTC 1, WTC 2, WTC 5 and WTC 7 what a vehicle bomb explosion failed to do to WTC 1 in 1993.
 
It is clear that no individual here, who supports the present official story for how the three high-rises in NYC collapsed on Sept. 11, 2001, is willing to leave the security of this group and defend what they claim to believe in a one-on-one situation.

That basically says that those of you who fit the above description have no faith in what you are actually saying and know it will not hold up to the heavy scrutiny which can and will be applied in a one-on-one situation where there is sufficient time for thoughtful responses.

I think one can guarantee that none here who fit the above description will venture out on their own after seeing what happened to the first to do so (tfk), who was a star and leader here. That is probably viewed as a gamble that didn't work out and won't be tried again.

The NIST has been contacted relative to the serious problems with the reports on the WTC they published. They will not engage in an honest discussion and simply say they stand behind their work while being protected politically and not forced to address the issues.

It would seem the function of the activity here is to maintain the charade that there is still support for the NIST explanations in the population and to denigrate those who have raised the serious problems with them and shown they are non-explanatory.

If you can't debate the event in its entire scientific context, then there is nothing to debate.
One might as well debate Santa with a Four year old, as debate you.
 
Tony, all I can suggest is that you contact the proper authorities and say, "Nobody on the International Skeptics' Forum is prepared to debate whether the building collapses on 9/11 were caused by explosives, therefore it has been proven beyond reasonable doubt that they were, in accordance with the scientific method as understood by universal consensus. Please therefore carry out an investigation immediately that will identify and punish the people responsible." I don't see how they could possibly refuse to act on a request like that.

Dave
 
Tony, all I can suggest is that you contact the proper authorities and say, "Nobody on the International Skeptics' Forum is prepared to debate whether the building collapses on 9/11 were caused by explosives, therefore it has been proven beyond reasonable doubt that they were, in accordance with the scientific method as understood by universal consensus. Please therefore carry out an investigation immediately that will identify and punish the people responsible." I don't see how they could possibly refuse to act on a request like that.

Dave

The difference is Dave between wanting an intellectually stimulating debate, and an intellectually Boring debate of nonsense, and Fraud.
Regardless of whether NIST is right, Tony is absolutely wrong.
 
Oh, I am certainly interested in showing that those who rabidly defend a fraudulent story are full of s..t.

Feel free to do so right *********** here.

All you need to do is start at the beginning. An overview of the entire day's events and how they unfolded that will be able to convince just one person that what the rest of us call "reality" is wrong.

19 Hijackers, 4 planes. 3 Sites.

You need to include that in your opening statement and I'm a go.

How about it?
 
A debate won't work in your case because you have failed to produce a single shred of evidence that CD explosives were used to demolish WTC 7. You have to address the following facts before any debate is forthcoming.

For an example, you have:

1. Failed to produced video evidence that CD explosives were used

2. Failed to produced seismic evidence that explosives were used

3. Failed to produce audio evidence that explosives were used

4. Failed to produce CD explosive hardware evidence

5. Failed to produce direct physical evidence on steel structures that CD explosives were used

6. Failed to understand that demolition experts and cleanup crews found no evidence that CD explosives were used

7. Failed to account for the audible structural stress loads as stated by firefighters on the scene

8. Failed to account for structural load redistribution after the south facade of WTC 7 was gutted by debris from WTC 1 (no secondary explosions from explosives observed during that event)
WTC 7 did not fully collapse are free fall speed and the fact that WTC 7 tilted toward the south in the final seconds of its collapse was an indication that the structural integrity of WTC 7 was seriously compromised

9. Failed to account for additional structural load redistribution as uncontrolled fires continued to rage for hours within WTC 7 (no secondary explosions from explosives observed at any time as fires raged for hours)
10. Failed to address structural buckling of WTC 7 prior to its collapse, which should have told you that WTC 7 was in danger of collapse due to structural overload, which was clearly audible to firefighters on scene
11. Failed to produce visual evidence of explosive residue on structural steel

12. Failed to address how explosives could have been placed inside WTC 7 under strict secrecy
13. Failed to address how structural pre-weakening, which is required before explosives are attached to steel beams, could have been achieved in strict secrecy
14. Failed to understand why WTC 1 remained standing despite the detonation of a vehicle bomb beneath the building in 1993, which provides an indication just how ridicules the 9/11 CD theory is.

I may add to the list, but I think that you now have your hands full for the moment.

To sum it up, and as you can clearly see, you have no wiggle room to interpret or misinterpret documented facts and evidence as you see fit. The ball is now in your court to provide undeniable evidence that explosives or thermite, were used to demolish WTC 7. Anything short of that, you have no debate.

Basically Tony's a massive failure.
 
It is clear that no individual here, who supports the present official story for how the three high-rises in NYC collapsed on Sept. 11, 2001, is willing to leave the security of this group and defend what they claim to believe in a one-on-one situation.

That basically says that those of you who fit the above description have no faith in what you are actually saying and know it will not hold up to the heavy scrutiny which can and will be applied in a one-on-one situation where there is sufficient time for thoughtful responses.

I think one can guarantee that none here who fit the above description will venture out on their own after seeing what happened to the first to do so (tfk), who was a star and leader here. That is probably viewed as a gamble that didn't work out and won't be tried again.

The NIST has been contacted relative to the serious problems with the reports on the WTC they published. They will not engage in an honest discussion and simply say they stand behind their work while being protected politically and not forced to address the issues.

It would seem the function of the activity here is to maintain the charade that there is still support for the NIST explanations in the population and to denigrate those who have raised the serious problems with them and shown they are non-explanatory.

Coward.
 
It is clear that no individual here, who supports the present official story for how the three high-rises in NYC collapsed on Sept. 11, 2001, is willing to leave the security of this group and defend what they claim to believe in a one-on-one situation.

That basically says that those of you who fit the above description have no faith in what you are actually saying and know it will not hold up to the heavy scrutiny which can and will be applied in a one-on-one situation where there is sufficient time for thoughtful responses.

I think one can guarantee that none here who fit the above description will venture out on their own after seeing what happened to the first to do so (tfk), who was a star and leader here. That is probably viewed as a gamble that didn't work out and won't be tried again.

The NIST has been contacted relative to the serious problems with the reports on the WTC they published. They will not engage in an honest discussion and simply say they stand behind their work while being protected politically and not forced to address the issues.

It would seem the function of the activity here is to maintain the charade that there is still support for the NIST explanations in the population and to denigrate those who have raised the serious problems with them and shown they are non-explanatory.

This of course was likely the intention all along - Tony posts a dubious challenge he knew no one would be interested in, then proudly thumps his chest and declares yet another hollow and meaningless victory when nobody wants to play his little game.

And 9/11 Truth is now how much closer to busting the whole thing wide open?

Is this a narcissistic thing or what's the deal?
 
This of course was likely the intention all along - Tony posts a dubious challenge he knew no one would be interested in, then proudly thumps his chest and declares yet another hollow and meaningless victory when nobody wants to play his little game.

And 9/11 Truth is now how much closer to busting the whole thing wide open?

Is this a narcissistic thing or what's the deal?

A great moment in Hucksterous history for Tony.
 
This of course was likely the intention all along - Tony posts a dubious challenge he knew no one would be interested in, then proudly thumps his chest and declares yet another hollow and meaningless victory when nobody wants to play his little game.

And 9/11 Truth is now how much closer to busting the whole thing wide open?

Is this a narcissistic thing or what's the deal?

It appears so.
1) Knows little or nothing
2) Confident that he knows everything
3) Confident nobody else can challenge him.
 
I have some time right now and am wondering if anyone here who supports the conclusions of the NIST reports, for the three high-rise collapses in NYC on Sept. 11, 2001, would want to debate me one-on-one as I contend that these NIST reports have been shown to be non-explanatory and incorrect.

The debate would take place on the 911 free forum, like the one I did with tfk, and the rules would be the same as those for that debate shown below.

1. September 11, 2001, events, and any additional objectively verifiable information and analyses in the public domain about them as well as apropreately done experimental evidence.

2. Each person shall make an opening statement (of no more than 500 words) explaining what they believe caused the collapse of WTC 7 and briefly stating what they believe are the (approximately) 3 strongest pieces of verifiable evidence for/against Controlled Demolition, as "Controlled Demolition vs. No Controlled Demolition" is the heart of the debate.

3. Tony will go first after both participants make an opening statement.

4. Each person shall make no more than one post per day and cannot make another until it is responded to.

5. If a post is not responded to within a week the person not responding is considered to have forfeited his turn & the other person will proceed with his next statement.

6. Individual posts are limited to 1,000 words. If it is deemed necessary to exceed that limit, justification shall be provided by the person wanting to exceed it and agreement to by the other participant received prior to doing so. This should be done by private messaging, so as not to interrupt the flow of the debate, and should be the exception rather than the rule.

7. Each post will discuss one principle topic. Each topic consists of 4 posts. Person A will state a topic post, Person B replies, Person A counters, then Person B counters, and that topic is closed. Person B then leads off the next sequence.

8. Every point that either person brings up must be addressed in some manner by the other. Both parties will do their best to stay focused on the original topic point.

9. There shall be no name calling, denigration, or defamatory language used. Each person shall bring only technical arguments to the debate. If any derogatory comments are used they shall be addressed to arguments only, not to individuals.

10. The debate will end after a maximum of 50 total posts, or earlier if the participants mutually agree to an earlier termination, or whenever either participant decides to stop responding.

Fixed the debate post for you Tony, if you check I have never been a NIST defender!

Science Not NIST, wouldn't expect you to understand that.
 
This of course was likely the intention all along - Tony posts a dubious challenge he knew no one would be interested in, then proudly thumps his chest and declares yet another hollow and meaningless victory when nobody wants to play his little game.

And 9/11 Truth is now how much closer to busting the whole thing wide open?

Is this a narcissistic thing or what's the deal?

IMHO, it is AE911T in a nutshell.
Rather than DO engineering, they DO talk, talk, talk.
Gage wanders the world talking. Tony wants to talk, he wants to confront others with an opposing view, in talk. He goes as far as to claim that this is how science works!:eek: It's as if Einstein didn't write his theories out FIRST, then defend it. Tony would have Einstein having thought about G.R. then gone on a speaking tour, received a large backing and then wrote out his theory.

AE911T loudly touts its cadre of 2000+ engineers and architects. That is a good pool of expertise to draw on, even if you only take into account the structural or otherwise relevantly educated in that group. So what do they DO with that apparent expertise?
Talk! mostly.
Look at their 'papers'. Any detailed engineering reports there? Nope. Certainly nothing on the scale or detail of any of the NIST reports, or the Purdue U. aircraft impact study, or Nordenson Associates reports.
Why not?
Because AE911T and Tony Szamboti among them, don't want that. They prefer to stand aside from the engineering and snipe away.
AE911T and Tony, are all about discussing what they believe didn't happen, then proudly proclaiming, with nothing to back it up other than supposition, their own pet claims.

While NIST and Nordenson have studied the collapse of WTC7 and detailed a 'most probable' initiating event and progression to global collapse, those who push a controlled demolition have yet to detail what type of explosive, where these explosives were placed, how they were placed without detection, how they could be set off in sequence, or for that matter ANY detail at all.

It goes back and forth between thermite used to sever columns, to thermite as fuse for conventional explosives, through massive number of severed columns to only a few key columns being taken out. Just think about how many times thermite has changed over the years(thermite, nano-thermite, explosive thermite).

Why does AE911T concentrate on WTC7? Because there is no patently obvious initiating cause of collapse. The towers and the Pentagon had big freakin aircraft fly into them. Arguing that explosives and/or thermite were used there requires that one minimize the effect of ramming a 500 MPH, 300K pound aircraft with 10K gallons of fuel, into the buildings. That is inconvenient and sounds silly on the face of it to most people. How do they minimize this? By claiming the fires were jet fuel fires that could not burn for an hour, by claiming that the towers were supposedly said to be brought down solely by fire effects, and some, by actually backing the ridiculous Pilots for 911 truth contention that Flight 175 was a 'modified' aircraft.:rolleyes::eek::rolleyes:

Does anyone really wish to debate such lunacy?
 
Last edited:
IMHO, it is AE911T in a nutshell.
Rather than DO engineering, they DO talk, talk, talk.
Gage wanders the world talking. Tony wants to talk, he wants to confront others with an opposing view, in talk. He goes as far as to claim that this is how science works!:eek: It's as if Einstein didn't write his theories out FIRST, then defend it. Tony would have Einstein having thought about G.R. then gone on a speaking tour, received a large backing and then wrote out his theory.

AE911T loudly touts its cadre of 2000+ engineers and architects. That is a good pool of expertise to draw on, even if you only take into account the structural or otherwise relevantly educated in that group. So what do they DO with that apparent expertise?
Talk! mostly.
Look at their 'papers'. Any detailed engineering reports there? Nope. Certainly nothing on the scale or detail of any of the NIST reports, or the Purdue U. aircraft impact study, or Nordenson Associates reports.
Why not?
Because AE911T and Tony Szamboti among them, don't want that. They prefer to stand aside from the engineering and snipe away.
AE911T and Tony, are all about discussing what they believe didn't happen, then proudly proclaiming, with nothing to back it up other than supposition, their own pet claims.

While NIST and Nordenson have studied the collapse of WTC7 and detailed a 'most probable' initiating event and progression to global collapse, those who push a controlled demolition have yet to detail what type of explosive, where these explosives were placed, how they were placed without detection, how they could be set off in sequence, or for that matter ANY detail at all.

It goes back and forth between thermite used to sever columns, to thermite as fuse for conventional explosives, through massive number of severed columns to only a few key columns being taken out.

Why does AE911T concentrate on WTC7? Because there is no patently obvious initiating cause of collapse. The towers and the Pentagon had big freakin aircraft fly into them. Arguing that explosives and/or thermite were used there requires that one minimize the effect of ramming a 500 MPH, 300K pound aircraft with 10K gallons of fuel, into the buildings. That is inconvenient and sounds silly on the face of it to most people. How do they minimize this? By claiming the fires were jet fuel fires that could not burn for an hour, by claiming that the towers were supposedly said to be brought down solely by fire effects, and some, by actually backing the ridiculous Pilots for 911 truth contention that Flight 175 was a 'modified' aircraft.:rolleyes::eek::rolleyes:

Does anyone really wish to debate such lunacy?

So nothing has Changed since Loosed Change, Twoofers, are continuing to be nothing more than hit and run stupid.:D
 
This of course was likely the intention all along - Tony posts a dubious challenge he knew no one would be interested in, then proudly thumps his chest and declares yet another hollow and meaningless victory when nobody wants to play his little game.

And 9/11 Truth is now how much closer to busting the whole thing wide open?

Is this a narcissistic thing or what's the deal?

Conspiracy theories aren't about busting anything open. The chest-thumping is the goal.
 
You have made it clear that you aren't genuinely interested.


I have indeed made it clear, year after year, that I'm not interested in a pointless "debate" over matters that are much better addressed by a detailed and mathematically rigorous technical analysis. Such as, by a group of engineers interested in supporting their stated position on the matter. (Perhaps someone should start such an organization, and see what it can accomplish.)

What I'm interested in, and what I (as a citizen in good standing of a township, county, commonwealth, and republic) am qualified to debate about, is what can or should be done. I assume that the reason you want to argue about NIST is that ultimately you want some sort of action to be taken by someone. (If that assumption is wrong there's no opportunity lost, because in that case there's no point to the exercise at all.) I'm saying, cut to the chase: propose the action you want taken, and we can debate about that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom