does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Crazy Chainsaw, I have a question. Since you seem to burn stuff on a regular basis, how often does the fire do something unexpected?


I've read the NIST WTC7 report and it seems to boil down to a lack of remote fire suppression, and a building design that was not up to the events of the day.

Out here in California we just came off one of our worst wildfire years in our history, and talking with the Cal Fire crews over lunch one day they all agreed that entire chapters of fire fighting manuals would have to be rewritten.

As far as #7 goes, I think a good question to ask is had there been no fire, could the building be repaired, or would it have been demoed and rebuilt?

Sorry I misunderstood your question barely here today, world trade center 7 would have survived without the fires, but the fires were a result of the collapses of the towers and a reverse stack effect in the collapses.
That superheated carbon soot similar to an elevator car falling in the shaft, in the NIST
Stack effect paper Tony mentioned.
So the towers collapsing actually most likely doomed 7 from the first seconds of collapse.

Ps. I am only half here today pain medication and muscle relaxers have my head spinning, not to mention the pain induced by all the laughter today.
 
I disagree. The question was if there was no fire would the building have survived?

I see no evidence that the building was damaged badly enough structurally that it could not have been repaired. There were reports that it was "leaning" but, I've seen no real evidence to point to this being actually true.

WTC7's fate was sealed by the (prudent) decision of the FDNY to concentrate it's resources on rescue and recovery.

WTC7 would not have been destroyed by "normal office fires", it was destroyed because of the total combination of the events of the day.

I misunderstood the question DGM muscle relaxers and pain pills.
That and I think I am dying of laughter.
 
First, it was convection that I said was minimal in the case of fire protected structural steel, which that in WTC 7 was.

Second, conduction only comes into play after radiation has heated the insulation and takes it through the fire insulation into the steel. The fire insulation has low thermal conductivity and the conduction is thus slow and the insulation prevents the radiation from heating the steel directly.

Radiant heating is the predominant heat transfer mechanism to fire protected structural steel in a building fire. See what the AISC says about it on page 5 paragraph 1.13 here https://www.aisc.org/globalassets/aisc/publications/facts-for-steel-buildings-1-fire-facts.pdf

I have no desire to be rough with you, but you do seem to shoot from the hip and you should stop it, because you are incorrect on this issue. The NIST, ARUP, and Weidlinger Associates reports on WTC 7 are not valid explanations for the collapse. There is no legitimate analysis that shows WTC 7 came down due to fire.
Well then you really need to point out the gross error you picked up on in Beyler's analysis.
Perhaps contact Nestor R. Iwankiw
Hughes Associates, Inc.
and
Farid Alfawakhiri
AISC, Inc.

Jensen Hughes would truly need to know about this in order to safeguard their reputation.
Beyler needs to be hauled up on the carpet to explain his massive faux pas.

Let us know when you've done this.
 
WTC7 would not have been destroyed by "normal office fires", it was destroyed because of the total combination of the events of the day.

That's certainly the decision the trial and appellate courts came to in the Aegis Insurance litigation. Everyone interested in this subject should read through at least the appellate decision, which can be found freely here. I think that's likely correct, but it is essentially impossible to prove for sure. One judge did dissent saying he wanted to hear more about the defendant's technical responses to Aegis's allegations re improperly insulated flutes and other alleged issues with the building design/construction, but I think the court was driven by a general public policy against looking to assign blame beyond the proximate cause of the terrorist attacks. Given the uncertainty, that was probably the right call, but it does leave open whether WTC 7 could have survived the fires were they fought. There is a non-trivial argument that it would have still collapsed (which argument is set forth in the Aegis Ins. expert reports).
 
Crazy Chainsaw, I have a question. Since you seem to burn stuff on a regular basis, how often does the fire do something unexpected?


I've read the NIST WTC7 report and it seems to boil down to a lack of remote fire suppression, and a building design that was not up to the events of the day.

Out here in California we just came off one of our worst wildfire years in our history, and talking with the Cal Fire crews over lunch one day they all agreed that entire chapters of fire fighting manuals would have to be rewritten.

As far as #7 goes, I think a good question to ask is had there been no fire, could the building be repaired, or would it have been demoed and rebuilt?

1. Wildfires are not like building fires.
2. Cal Fire crews were most likely discussing wildfire suppression methods.
The effects of long term draught, beetle kill, and invasive species has changed the wildland fire environment. Fires today seem to have more erratic behavior.
3. Wildfire suppression methods mainly work around the principle of robbing the fire of its fuels. Not so much for structure suppression.

As far as wildfires doing something unexpected. Depends on the size and intensity of the fire, the fuels its burning in and what it can burn into, the weather and if it stays the same or not.
 
Ultimately, it is not just the room fire temperature that con-
trols structural response, but the heat input and correspon-
ding temperature rise that occurs in the structural material.
In general, heat transfer can occur in 3 ways: conduction,
convection, and radiation.
Conduction is heat transfer through solid materials, and
involves the material properties of density, specific heat,
and thermal conductivity. Convection is heat transfer
through fluids, either gases or liquids, which is a linear
function of the gas temperatures. Radiation is the transfer of
heat energy by electromagnetic waves, which depends on
the gas temperature raised to the fourth power.
For protected structural steel, the temperature increase due to fire results primarily from radiation to the fire pro- tection material and conduction through the protection, with
inclusion of the appropriate insulating properties and thick-
ness of the material. Therefore, the temperatures in pro-
tected steel will be continually less than those of the fire
during the heating phase. How much less depends on the
thickness and nature of the insulating material, as well as
the size and weight of the steel member itself. Of equal
importance are the thermo-physical properties of the steel
fire protection material, such as cohesion and adhesion dur-
ing the fire event.
Tony assumes that gas temps in the 400C range do not heat the thermal protection and thus no conduction through it to the steel.
Tony also assumes that fire directly heating nearby structural steel does not see conduction to connected steel.
Tony also changed "primarily" to "predominantly ".

This general paper is from the same company that produced the Beyler report.
 
That's certainly the decision the trial and appellate courts came to in the Aegis Insurance litigation. Everyone interested in this subject should read through at least the appellate decision, which can be found freely here. I think that's likely correct, but it is essentially impossible to prove for sure. One judge did dissent saying he wanted to hear more about the defendant's technical responses to Aegis's allegations re improperly insulated flutes and other alleged issues with the building design/construction, but I think the court was driven by a general public policy against looking to assign blame beyond the proximate cause of the terrorist attacks. Given the uncertainty, that was probably the right call, but it does leave open whether WTC 7 could have survived the fires were they fought. There is a non-trivial argument that it would have still collapsed (which argument is set forth in the Aegis Ins. expert reports).
You are correct. This also pushes the argument as to at what point should a design be "indestructible". ;)
 
You've got to stop blowing yourself up!!!!!.

Take care my friend.. :)

Actually I am beginning to think that blowing myself up might be better than working in slippery sloppy mud.

Muddy boot on muddy excavator track, old burnt stump hidden under deep sloppy mud back into with the dozer so hard the seat latch on the new dozer seat broke. Cheap piece of plastic. The seat was made in China, I can't use Chinese or Japanese equipment, unless they have air ride seats, the suspensions aren't strong enough to hold me.
They kill my back when I hit something they just are not designed for someone near 7 foot tall.
 
A bomb that was truly massive and blew the windows out of pretty much everything within blocks.

Nope...9 story reinforced concrete frame with shear walls. Design in accordance with the ACI 318-71 building code.

Conspiracy theorists still dispute the NIST case study. Claim it was an inside job, and the explosives were planted inside the Murrah building.

While I tend to accept that the truck bomb could have done all of the damage to the Murrah building, I think there are still some problems which have not been resolved.

I made a wikia on the subject of the bombing, and made a (currently incomplete) article about Reports and witnesses of bombs found at Murrah Building site.

Many of you know that there were a few bomb scares at the Murrah building during the rescue and recovery operation. There are media reports and official records that reported as a fact that explosive devices were recovered from the scene. The official explanations on these have come out as: 1. A "suspicious suitcase", which turned out to be insignificant or non-existent, 2. a "suspicious crate", much of the same, 3. inert devices designed as training tools for the ATF and bomb-sniffing dogs, 4. dummy objects used as explanative props in court cases, 5. a novelty alarm clock that looked like a bundle of dynamite, and finally, 5. an inert TOW missile used as a prop in sting operations.

The TOW missile story seemed to stick. There are a couple of witnesses who carried a TOW missile and perhaps mistakenly believed it was real, so it could definitely be true.

But like I said, I think there are still some problems. I'll list the ones I can think of now.

1. Toni Garrett, a nurse who tagged bodies recovered from the wreckage, said that she was told of a timing device on one of the apparent bombs set to go off ten minutes after the first one. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KrQtjCPV-oU&t=6m20s

2. There is quite a bit of information on the ATF illegally storing firearms, ammunition, blasting caps, and even crates marked "Explosives" in the Murrah building. One interesting account is from state park ranger Randall A. Yount, who claimed (in an affidavit) to help carry several crates marked "U.S. Army" and "Explosives", viewed a vault room which had apparently been blown out from a secondary explosion, and overhear an ATF agent say “Yeah, my last inventory was 1200 pounds of C-4. That’s what went up. The C-4 went off and detonated.”

3. Phillip O'Halloran, editor of an untidy conspiracy-oriented right wing magazine called Relevance, wrote that OKPD Public Information Officer Bill Martin said that containers of fulminated mercury were discovered (quoted in this book, page 346). Apparently, Bill Martin later denied this, so perhaps this could be written off as a bit of nonsense. However, something more credible came forward. William Jasper of The New American published a story about a retired CIA operative named Joe Harp, who went to the Murrah building shortly after the bombing. He said that he witnessed containers marked as fulminated mercury being carried out of the building, and that he gave a sample of wreckage to a laboratory which showed traces of fulminated mercury.

Joe Harp made a sworn affidavit of this: http://www.whatreallyhappened.com/RANCHO/POLITICS/OK/bombs/harp.jpg

A follow-up story in The New American said that Harp claimed that shortly after the first interview, authorities came to his house and seized the lab report. He says another copy of the lab report was owned by a friend named Woody Lemons, who died in a private plane crash before he could show the lab report to anyone. http://www.thenewamerican.com/usnews/crime/item/16440-proof-of-bombs-and-coverup

There are indeed newspaper reports of a man named Woody Lemons and his family who died in a private plane crash. http://amarillo.com/stories/051798/new_LD0872.001.shtml http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1998-05-17/news/9805170400_1_plane-plunges-vernon-savings-plane-had-engine-trouble http://www.apnewsarchive.com/1998/3-Die-in-Texas-Plane-Crash/id-62853d0518fb0293ad101bb7b8f5ce6f

4. There may be seismic evidence of smaller explosions occurring before the truck bomb explosion, which would fit with a few witness accounts.

This was explained by seismologist Dr. Raymond Brown here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EXQ2Ze7hfgI&t=7m21s

And later explained in a report written by Robert D. Vernon, a chemist with "over thirty - five years of experience in failure analysis, engineering, and troubleshooting in microelectronics and process control industries."

That can be found in this book: https://www.dropbox.com/s/71yrgir4zyub06h/The%20Final%20Report%20on%20the%20Bombing%20of%20the%20Alfred%20P.%20Murrah%20Building.pdf?dl=0 starting at page 207 of the pdf, the part about the seismic evidence is at page 238 of the pdf.

Here is a simplified view of the seismograph of April 19th compared to the seismograph of when the remains of the Murrah building were demolished with explosives:

https://i.imgur.com/R8kKMgt.jpg

Basically, if the area marked in blue is the truck explosion, and the area marked in green is the aftershocks of that explosion, then what are the smaller signals marked in red which lasted for 4 seconds?

I don't want a new sub-thread for this, or a debate, because frankly I don't know what to make of it. I'm just pointing some of this out.
 
Last edited:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...1#post11652011
Tony assumes that gas temps in the 400C range do not heat the thermal protection and thus no conduction through it to the steel.
Tony also assumes that fire directly heating nearby structural steel does not see conduction to connected steel.
Tony also changed "primarily" to "predominantly ".

This general paper is from the same company that produced the Beyler report.

Oh dear, Tony doesnt want to say anything about section 7 of that paper because oddly enough, even though it extensively comments on the WTC structure failures, the authors seem to completely accept that they succumbed to fire.
 
The Murrah building was steel rebar-reinforced concrete.


Apparently, that wasn't the case regarding WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7.

* WTC 1 did not collapse despite major damage suffered from the 1993 bombing and did not immediately collapse from the high-speed impact of American 11.

* WTC 2 withstood the high-speed impact of United 175 and as a result suffered major impact damage but WTC 2 did not immediately collapse despite the high-speed impact.

* WTC 7 suffered major impact damage on its south wall and to its southwest corner but WTC 7 did not immediately collapse despite suffering major impact damage.

Other WTC buildings in the vicinity withstood major impact damage and remained standing. WTC 5 had suffered major impact damage but WTC 5 remain standing. However, WTC 5 eventually suffered major internal collapse due to fire only.

Let's do a recap:

WTC 1, WTC 2, WTC 5, and WTC 7 withstood major impact damage. However, the resulting fires would eventually weaken their steel structures which would trigger major collapse events within those buildings. Had those fires been fought and extinguished in enough time, those buildings would have remain standing. Had explosives and thermite/nano-thermite been planted in those buildings, they would have been rendered ineffective due to the impacts and from the fires, yet, there were no secondary explosions or audible sounds of explosions on video that would have indicated that explosives were planted in those buildings.

To sum it up, the major collapse events involving those buildings had nothing to do with CD @ WTC.

.
 
Last edited:
I will not be drawn into a complete derail from WTC/Sept11,2001

I don't think it matters much the Radiant heating comment may have made this thread s little to hot for Tony to handle doubt he will want much debate seeing how exposed his Ideas are here.
 
Thanks for the replies.

For me the debate about #7, and even the Twin Towers should evolve into better remote, automatic fire suppression which can supplement, or be introduced without the need for water. From what I've read I think this debate has already happened.

The focus of NIST's work was about SAFETY based on the events of 9-11. They weren't trying to solve a crime.
 
Thanks for the replies.

For me the debate about #7, and even the Twin Towers should evolve into better remote, automatic fire suppression which can supplement, or be introduced without the need for water. From what I've read I think this debate has already happened.

The focus of NIST's work was about SAFETY based on the events of 9-11. They weren't trying to solve a crime.

I thought about devising a device that could be used via drone, and a nano wire to secure a micro cable to the buildings and send up a glider like device that inflates via air as it falls to make jumping from similar fires easily survivable.
But there is little interest in funding such devices.
 
The focus of NIST's work was about SAFETY based on the events of 9-11. They weren't trying to solve a crime.

Indeed. Hence my question to Tony earlier today about what fire safety recommendations from the NIST report will be improved by demonstrating it was beam X instead of girder Y that failed first.

In the case of 7 WTC there is no crime to solve. This was a building that was not subject to terrorist attack nor should it have been. Unlike the other 9/11 targets 7 WTC was not a world famous symbol of American economic, military or political power. If one did not work there or live in the immediate neighborhood chances are they never heard of it before 9/11 and there was nothing of great importance about the building or anything going on inside of it.

7 WTC was collateral damage, an unintended victim and nothing more. It only became the centerpiece of CT mythology and folklore after fanciful and clearly specious tales of bombs in the Twin Towers, missiles at the Pentagon and shoot-downs over Shanksville failed utterly to capture the public's interest. For a conspiracy theorist 7 WTC's anonymity and unimportance were ideal. It meant the building and its fate got little attention, allowing CT's to fill the void with their own narrative and to create something out of nothing.

So far its working great! :o
 
Last edited:
Or worse, if the CD had partially failed leaving the tower(s) only partially destroyed with live explosives in the wrecked building(s).:jaw-dropp:cool::rolleyes:
....err........Yes!


Rather - on second - more serious thoughts - Nah - despite the implied ridicule of truther nonsense - clearing the remaining failed explosives would be a routine sapper assignment. Similar to clearing booby traps and unexploded ordnance.

Recovery of the building still the bigger problem.

The two overlap because the first stage of either operation would be establishing safe means of access to the site. And structural instability involves higher risks than UEO.

EC
RAE(Ret)


(Pls excuse my reversion to seriousness whilst responding to a fun post.... :o )
 
Seeing as skyeagle409 provided clear and dramatic photo and video evidence to support that claim, yes.

You missed the part where he also provided evidence that Ae911Truth was trying to pass these types of cuts off as "thermite."

Does anyone here believe that thermite was used to cut columns during execution of an unspecified "controlled demolition" for which no evidence exists?

Reply: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11648171&postcount=1012
My point is that you all accept that without precise gov documentation with timestamped listing of cut beams, and further that you assume that ALL the cut beams found must have been cut during the clean up and that no beam could have been cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to building collapse.

Had anyone thought of checking for it, it would have taken expert inspections to distinguish between beams cut via thermite cutters and lances. Had FEMA and NIST followed the NFPA921, the first responder testimonies of melted metal and explosions would have automatically set in motion a forensic investigation which would have looked for forensic evidence for explosives and "exotic accelerants" including thermitic materials.

No truck driver transporting the beams or any inspector at the storage areas had any reason to raise a red flag due to angle cut beams with melted metal sputter since the clean up crews left these sorts of marks on the beams. Beams cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to collapse could have been hidden in plain sight, right out in the open.

The direct evidence for thermite cut beams is there, but since the gov investigations did not go into forensic studies, this evidence is inconclusive on its own. There is however plenty of other supporting evidence for thermitic materials, including forensic evidence via WTC dust full of the signature iron spheres that these materials leave behind once ignited, the red-gray chips, the reports of melted steel etc. There is OTOH absolutely no evidence of any kind behind the official fire based explanations.

BWT. Richard Gage does mention this famous angle cut beam photo in his lectures but he also talks about its controversy.

Do you have anything to say?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom