does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me


What controversy here it is being cut.
diagonalcut-112_zpsdnvca0tm.jpg


He can be seen cutting the exact column at 45 degrees!
 
Last edited:


Demolition experts would have known better than to use thermite rather than RDX because thermite would not have been effective against the WTC buildings.

We can also take a look here.



It took 1500 pounds of thermite just to burn through two steel legs of a tower and took two attempts to drop a steel-framed dome that was already in danger of collapsing due to repeated bombings in World War II. In addition, 1/2 tons of thermite was unable to cut a vehicle in two pieces and 175 pounds of thermite was unable to damage a vertical steel beam despite the fact that thermite was packed around that steel beam.
 
Last edited:
Demolition experts would have known better than to use thermite rather than RDX because thermite would not have been effective against the WTC buildings.

We can also take a look here.

Ziggi and Tony need to stop embarrassing Truthers so much though no actual truther still exists.
 
My point is that you all accept that without precise gov documentation with timestamped listing of cut beams, and further that you assume that ALL the cut beams found must have been cut during the clean up and that no beam could have been cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to building collapse.
The argument from ignorance fallacy.
 
Ziggi and Tony need to stop embarrassing Truthers so much though no actual truther still exists.


I was surprised as they continued to ignore that, for which any school-aged child would have known, and that is, explosions have a way of making their presence known, but I should have known the jig was up when I saw Tony's name up in lights with Steven Jones and AE911Truth.


The Sound of Explosions

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rInxeNBXS3o

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rfmNErY0FIU
 
I was surprised as they continued to ignore that, for which any school-aged child would have known, and that is, explosions have a way of making their presence known, but I should have known the jig was up when I saw Tony's name up in lights with Steven Jones and AE911Truth.


The Sound of Explosions

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rInxeNBXS3o

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rfmNErY0FIU

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11652797&postcount=1540
 

You brought up this nonsense before and had zero evidence to back it up.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=310297&highlight=foam&page=29

Are you prepared to do better this time?

How much foam was used? How many explosives?

How come none of this foam was found? Did it magically disappear?

Who installed the charges and foam? A massive amount of foam and explosives would've been required to pull this off, how was that done undetected?

Have you read the reports from the link you provided? They explain that the foam needed a vessel to contain it. There would've been hundreds of these at minimum. Again who installed them and how did they go unnoticed?

Why were none of them ever found?
 
Last edited:


It is clearly apparent that you are unaware that blankets are normally placed around demolition explosives before detonation. It is a normal part of the preparation process.

building-implosion-20.jpg



And yet, the blankets do not muffle the sound of demolition explosions in the 130-140 decibel range as evident in the number of demolition videos that I've posted from time to time. Show us photos of the foam you thought could have been used. Such huge amounts of foam would have been spread all over ground zero. Notice the detonation wires and understand no such wires were found at ground zero nor were such wires evident inside WTC 7 during normal working hours in the moments before the 9/11 attack began.
 
Last edited:
You brought up this nonsense before and had zero evidence to back it up.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=310297&highlight=foam&page=29

Are you prepared to do better this time?

How much foam was used? How many explosives?

How come none of this foam was found? Did it magically disappear?

Who installed the charges and foam? A massive amount of foam and explosives would've been required to pull this off, how was that done undetected?

Have you read the reports from the link you provided? They explain that the foam needed a vessel to contain it. There would've been hundreds of these at minimum. Again who installed them and how did they go unnoticed?

Why were none of them ever found?

It wouldn't work on demolition charges because sound is transmitted though steel at 5900 meters per second, anyway it is not used to dampen sound, but to reduce shrapnel.
 
I suggest we have no further debates with Tony, it is far to embarrassing too the truth movement,
They might leave and never talk to us again, then what would we do for comic entertainment?
 
You brought up this nonsense before and had zero evidence to back it up.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=310297&highlight=foam&page=29

Are you prepared to do better this time?

How much foam was used? How many explosives?

How come none of this foam was found? Did it magically disappear?

Who installed the charges and foam? A massive amount of foam and explosives would've been required to pull this off, how was that done undetected?

Have you read the reports from the link you provided? They explain that the foam needed a vessel to contain it. There would've been hundreds of these at minimum. Again who installed them and how did they go unnoticed?

Why were none of them ever found?

I'm just saying, how could anybody here say in confidence that good sized demolition charges can't have their noise dampened when BUBBLES do exactly that if you use a lot? You all understand that but play dumb to ignore a valid point.
 
Last edited:
I'm just saying, how could anybody here say in confidence that good sized demolition charges can't have their noise dampened when BUBBLES do exactly that if you use a lot? You all understand that but play dumb to ignore a valid point.


What you say doesn't make any sense at all. Did you really think that plotters would have encased WTC 7 in foam as a means to cover-up a sinister CD plot without anyone noticing such foam planted on every floor level or spread out over a wide area in the rubble?

Pre-weakening the steel structure would have attracted a lot of attention and placing explosives afterward would have attracted a lot of attention as well and no doubt that placing such foam in a busy building would have raised eyebrows above the hairline.
 
I'm just saying, how could anybody here say in confidence that good sized demolition charges can't have their noise dampened when BUBBLES do exactly that if you use a lot? You all understand that but play dumb to ignore a valid point.

So you are saying that 3 buildings on 9/11 were rigged with giant bubble machines :confused:

How about you stop resorting to the ridiculous, trying to rationalize the outcome you want and start dealing only with known facts? That could be fun.
 
I'm just saying, how could anybody here say in confidence that good sized demolition charges can't have their noise dampened when BUBBLES do exactly that if you use a lot? You all understand that but play dumb to ignore a valid point.

No, we are pointing out that your proposal is dumb.
It requires a large bit of real estate in the structures be taken over to accomodate this foam dampening without being discovered,
AND
there is no evidence in the rubble, or dust, of this foam.

You are stabbing wildly at that windmill but its still a windmill, not a dragon.
 
I'm just saying, how could anybody here say in confidence that good sized demolition charges can't have their noise dampened when BUBBLES do exactly that if you use a lot? You all understand that but play dumb to ignore a valid point.

That isn't a valid point, it's idiotic. Now are you going to answer the questions or run away like last time?
 
Tony--when are you going to stop making stuff up and just acknowledge that you and the Korol paper made a fundamental error? You keep claiming, without any evidence, that the pre-heating phase in a traveling fire would be insignificant. You claim it over, and over, and over. But you never provide any evidence. In fact, as I have demonstrated repeatedly to you, NIST actually ran a fulsome simulation that included the convection heating period you claim was so insignificant that it could just be ignored. As you well know, NIST's simulation shows the heating during that period--which, for example, on floor 12 included over 2 hours of exposure to temperatures between 200 C and 800 C, lead to the pre-heating of a beam to around 400 C before the peak fire reached that beam. And that's just one beam on one floor. There were other floors where NIST believed the fire conditions were far worse.

You are seriously stuck on stupid in trying to baldly assert your way out of this error.

Here are the facts:

[SNIPPED AWESOME DOCUMENTATION OF FACTS FOR BREVITY; Oy]

In sum, you've proven you either have no idea what you are talking about when it comes to fire science or else you are just willing to blatantly lie and make things up. Korol's 25-30 min heat transfer model is indefensible and, in your ill-fated attempt to defend it, you have thrown away the small amount of credibility you had left. You cannot pretend to be interested in the truth if you are so willing to ignore reality--including the reality of the very sources you cited.

Quoted and #oysteinbookmark for utter awesomeness - quoted post contains a detailed and lethal breakdown of many pages of conversation between Tony Szamboti (engineer) and benthamitemetric (lawyer, afaik) on engineering reports and fatcs, in which the engineer is proven to make up stuff to defend stuff that's thoroughly false. The occasion is a paper by Korol, Greening and ... someone else on maximum steel temperatures in the WTC7 fires.
 
I'm just saying, how could anybody here say in confidence that good sized demolition charges can't have their noise dampened when BUBBLES do exactly that if you use a lot? You all understand that but play dumb to ignore a valid point.

Because:

1. C-4 was not the explosive one would use. Cutting charges are more powerful - hence LOUDER.

2. Under Tony's scenario, the demo team had to get all of that stuff into WTC7 AFTER WTC1 fell, then get it wired, then get out without dying in the fire or being seen by any of the hundreds of fire and police surrounding the building.

3. For people sort of living in the real world, the wiring of those explosives would have taken weeks, and the World Trade Center complex was routinely swept for explosives after the 1993 attack.

For your claim to be a valid point it would have to be realistic, and it would have to be provable. For example - THEY WOULD HAVE FOUND ALL OF THAT STUFF IN THE WRECKAGE.

This is the key - had explosives been used there would have been evidence of their use. The NYPD Bomb Squad was in the shadow of WTC7 when it came down...the one group of EXPERTS who would have recognized explosives detonating were right there. Tony suggests that they and the FDNY were all in on the conspiracy (because he's never wrong, and neither organization believes in CD on 9-11).
 
That isn't a valid point, it's idiotic. Now are you going to answer the questions or run away like last time?

I'm not saying the towers were a bubble party. The foam method is just one of the only examples I could find on video. Countless patents, military manuals discussing methods as simple as sand, mud, clay, water being used to cover up explosives, etc. just makes me think it's a matter more ambiguous than the posters here like to say.

After all, nobody here can give an exact decibel/distance measurement (or an estimation) for how loud the WTC collapses were. We have videos like these which show that the collapse was very loud from quite some distance (more than some other videos show, I guess it depends on the microphone). We have witnesses like this guy, who was four miles away at the News Corp building, who described the collapses as loud and used the word "explosion".
 
Eight hundred cubic feet of foam to deaden the sound of one kicker charge worth of demolition explosives. That's a cube 20 feet on a side. How far apart were the columns in the twin towers? How much space between floors?

How did the elevators work with their shafts stuffed entirely full of sound-dampening foam? (If it was clay or sand or water or mud instead, the problem gets worse.) How did people get on and off the elevators with the lobby sides of the elevator shafts also stuffed entirely full of sound-dampening foam? How did people in the offices get their work done with their cubicles and meeting rooms and archives ALSO stuffed entirely full of sound-dampening foam? If the exterior columns were involved, why didn't anyone notice that the windows were completely blocked off from both sides by at least ten feet of sound-dampening foam?

Why didn't the airplane crashes produce a huge spray of foam (or sand, water, clay, mud, …) instead of a big fuel-air explosion?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom