Tony--when are you going to stop making stuff up and just acknowledge that you and the Korol paper made a fundamental error? You keep claiming, without any evidence, that the pre-heating phase in a traveling fire would be insignificant. You claim it over, and over, and over. But you never provide any evidence. In fact, as I have demonstrated repeatedly to you, NIST actually ran a fulsome simulation that included the convection heating period you claim was so insignificant that it could just be ignored. As you well know, NIST's simulation shows the heating during that period--which, for example, on floor 12 included over 2 hours of exposure to temperatures between 200 C and 800 C, lead to the pre-heating of a beam to around 400 C before the peak fire reached that beam. And that's just one beam on one floor. There were other floors where NIST believed the fire conditions were far worse.
You are seriously stuck on stupid in trying to baldly assert your way out of this error.
Here are the facts:
You claimed that both
the Cardington studies and the
NIST WTC 7 report supported Robert Korol's use of a 25-30 min heating time frame, which time frame
you cited as your basis for opposing WAI's temperature model. You even baldly lied and claimed that Korol was correct because about
99% of heat transfer in a fire occurs in 25-30 min, a statistic you blatantly fabricated out of nothing to try to win an argument (which you later try to hand wave away by saying such a statistic
was a "figure of speech"). The very
quote you cited in the NIST report, however, referenced figure 9-9 thereof (you can find that chart
here for reference), which clearly shows areas were heated for hours (see, e.g., the middle portion of the northern side of the building). Further, the deeper you dive into the NIST report, the more apparent your error becomes. NIST included as figure 10-1 to its WTC 7 report a very helpful graph of gas temperatures in a single location on floor 12 (see
here for the plain chart), which was not even where they thought the worst fires were. To illustrate how obviously incorrect you are, I've marked up the figure 10-1 chart to overlay your ridiculous assumptions (mark-up also attached for reference).
The 25-30 min heating theory you espouse based on the NIST report is proven wrong based on that same report. It's right there in 10-1, staring you in the face. You and Korol assume that there is no heating of the beam during the first 4.5 hours of the simulation. Actually, you already did admit that assumption was
at least partially wrong, but, as with your other statements, even that admission was lacking. You pulled 200 C out of thin air without any evidence or even a rudimentary back-of-the envelope calculation to back it up. Meanwhile, in reality, we know that NIST--which is your source on temperatures--did do an exacting calculation of how much beam pre-heating would occur based on the figure 10-1. They show, on page 452 of their report that, at 4:30, there was almost 400 C of pre-heating on that beam. Attached for reference is a copy of that page. All you have to the contrary are bald assertions about how that's contrary to your understanding of convection heating, with no math or other experimental source to back you up.
Moreover, you were wrong about the Cardington studies supporting the 25-30 min heating time. As I pointed out to you repeatedly, even in the Cardington studies' limited compartmental fire tests (which do not simulate the pre-heating that would be experienced in a traveling fire scenario, let alone a traveling fire scenario on the scale of the fires observed in WTC 7), there is no 25-30 min period when 99% of the heat transfer occurred. The Cardington study you cited to specifically (direct link to the report
here) shows heating for over 50 minutes, and the Cardington temperature data is all public and so, if there were a 25-30 min period where 99% of the heat transfer occurred (the beam heating graphs from that study are on page 41 for reference), you could simply pop that data into excel and tell me exactly when such period begins and ends. But you can't. Further, you continue to ignore that another Cardington study has shown that, even without the pre-heating of a large traveling fire, a protected beam subjected to a compartmental fire could reach 700 C (See pg F47 of that Cardington study
here). You continue to ignore this experimental finding because it alone shows how utterly incorrect and un-tethered to reality Korol's theoretical findings are.
In sum, you've proven you either have no idea what you are talking about when it comes to fire science or else you are just willing to blatantly lie and make things up. Korol's 25-30 min heat transfer model is indefensible and, in your ill-fated attempt to defend it, you have thrown away the small amount of credibility you had left. You cannot pretend to be interested in the truth if you are so willing to ignore reality--including the reality of the very sources
you cited.