does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

I love that he posted two papers that show him to be totally incompetent in engineering, priceless.
Any fool knows fire suppression is sprinklers, Fire retardants, heat sinks, and structural insulation!
Tony is so priceless I think he is going to kill me, my back is hurting where I hit stumps my side where I fell, on the excavator track hurts,
Now Tony has me laughing so hard I think I am going to Die.

And... you know, those firefighter guys.

Too bad they were busy either being buried by 2 110 story buildings, or busy trying to find the ones buried under 2 110 story buildings.
 
Tony--when are you going to stop making stuff up and just acknowledge that you and the Korol paper made a fundamental error? You keep claiming, without any evidence, that the pre-heating phase in a traveling fire would be insignificant. You claim it over, and over, and over. But you never provide any evidence. In fact, as I have demonstrated repeatedly to you, NIST actually ran a fulsome simulation that included the convection heating period you claim was so insignificant that it could just be ignored. As you well know, NIST's simulation shows the heating during that period--which, for example, on floor 12 included over 2 hours of exposure to temperatures between 200 C and 800 C, lead to the pre-heating of a beam to around 400 C before the peak fire reached that beam. And that's just one beam on one floor. There were other floors where NIST believed the fire conditions were far worse.

You are seriously stuck on stupid in trying to baldly assert your way out of this error.

Here are the facts:

You claimed that both the Cardington studies and the NIST WTC 7 report supported Robert Korol's use of a 25-30 min heating time frame, which time frame you cited as your basis for opposing WAI's temperature model. You even baldly lied and claimed that Korol was correct because about 99% of heat transfer in a fire occurs in 25-30 min, a statistic you blatantly fabricated out of nothing to try to win an argument (which you later try to hand wave away by saying such a statistic was a "figure of speech"). The very quote you cited in the NIST report, however, referenced figure 9-9 thereof (you can find that chart here for reference), which clearly shows areas were heated for hours (see, e.g., the middle portion of the northern side of the building). Further, the deeper you dive into the NIST report, the more apparent your error becomes. NIST included as figure 10-1 to its WTC 7 report a very helpful graph of gas temperatures in a single location on floor 12 (see here for the plain chart), which was not even where they thought the worst fires were. To illustrate how obviously incorrect you are, I've marked up the figure 10-1 chart to overlay your ridiculous assumptions (mark-up also attached for reference).

The 25-30 min heating theory you espouse based on the NIST report is proven wrong based on that same report. It's right there in 10-1, staring you in the face. You and Korol assume that there is no heating of the beam during the first 4.5 hours of the simulation. Actually, you already did admit that assumption was at least partially wrong, but, as with your other statements, even that admission was lacking. You pulled 200 C out of thin air without any evidence or even a rudimentary back-of-the envelope calculation to back it up. Meanwhile, in reality, we know that NIST--which is your source on temperatures--did do an exacting calculation of how much beam pre-heating would occur based on the figure 10-1. They show, on page 452 of their report that, at 4:30, there was almost 400 C of pre-heating on that beam. Attached for reference is a copy of that page. All you have to the contrary are bald assertions about how that's contrary to your understanding of convection heating, with no math or other experimental source to back you up.

Moreover, you were wrong about the Cardington studies supporting the 25-30 min heating time. As I pointed out to you repeatedly, even in the Cardington studies' limited compartmental fire tests (which do not simulate the pre-heating that would be experienced in a traveling fire scenario, let alone a traveling fire scenario on the scale of the fires observed in WTC 7), there is no 25-30 min period when 99% of the heat transfer occurred. The Cardington study you cited to specifically (direct link to the report here) shows heating for over 50 minutes, and the Cardington temperature data is all public and so, if there were a 25-30 min period where 99% of the heat transfer occurred (the beam heating graphs from that study are on page 41 for reference), you could simply pop that data into excel and tell me exactly when such period begins and ends. But you can't. Further, you continue to ignore that another Cardington study has shown that, even without the pre-heating of a large traveling fire, a protected beam subjected to a compartmental fire could reach 700 C (See pg F47 of that Cardington study here). You continue to ignore this experimental finding because it alone shows how utterly incorrect and un-tethered to reality Korol's theoretical findings are.

In sum, you've proven you either have no idea what you are talking about when it comes to fire science or else you are just willing to blatantly lie and make things up. Korol's 25-30 min heat transfer model is indefensible and, in your ill-fated attempt to defend it, you have thrown away the small amount of credibility you had left. You cannot pretend to be interested in the truth if you are so willing to ignore reality--including the reality of the very sources you cited.

Hey benthamitemetric, a study you might want.

9-205.pdf
Experimental and Numerical Investigations of Heat Impact and
Flame Heights from Fires in SBI Tests
JIANPING ZHANG, MICHAEL DELICHATSIOS, MATTHIEU COLOBERT, JOHAN HEREID,
MARTIN HAGEN and DIMITRIOS BAKIRTZIS
FireSERT, Research Institute of Built Environment
University of Ulster
FireSERT, University of Ulster at Jordanstown, Newtownabbey, BT37 0QB, Northern Ireland



FDS predicts reasonably the flame heights (see Table 2) but underpredicts significantly the surface
heat flux (see Fig. 9). Sensitivity studies showed that: 1) use of the radiative fraction in FDS is
essential for predictions in which the grid size is in the order of centimeter because the radiation model
can not solve accurately the radiation equation due to the fourth power dependence of radiation on
temperature, and 2) use of a constant soot yield to represent the soot production in FDS is inaccurate
even though the effect of soot on radiation is attenuated by use of the radiative fraction, and more
accurate soot models are required for predictions of soot production in applications where soot and
radiation interaction is important.

But then I would know anything about fire science Tony says so, so it must be true.
 
We are talking about heat transfer mechanisms without reference to sprinklers.


Speaking of sprinklers, Fire Chief Daniel Nigro, had said that there were numerous fires on many floors of WTC 7 burned without sufficient water supply to attack them, and he went on to say that "certain high-rise structures subjected to damage from impact and from fire will collapse."Another confirmation from a firefighting expert who was there that there were numerous fires burning on many floors of WTC 7 for hours, and yet, not one single secondary explosion from an explosive.

The fact the WTC 7 fires burned as long as they did is further evidence that no explosives were placed and set for detonation within WTC 7. It would have taken many months to prepare WTC 7 for demolition and remember, we are talking about a steel-framed building, not some wooden shack in someone's backyard. Furthermore, you cannot detonate explosives in one part of a steel-framed building and expect that building to collapse because the steel structure will redistribute structural loads around the damaged area and remain standing, which was the case as B-767's struck WTC 1 and WTC 2.

It is clear to me that you do not understand what it takes to demolish a steel-framed building with explosives, otherwise, you would have understood how ridicules your attempt to paint the destruction of WTC 7 as a controlled demolition operation really is, especially in light of the fact there is no CD evidence to support such an absurd claim.

I've posted videos to show what happens when buildings are not properly pre-weakened and in one case, a building was seen rolling on its side.

article-1203676-05EBE313000005DC-552_634x362.jpg


article-1203676-05EB76EA000005DC-299_634x363.jpg


article-1203676-05EB771D000005DC-571_634x410.jpg



I have also posted details regarding the accidental bombing of the Chinese embassy where that building absorbed multiple bomb strikes and yet, the building remained standing. I've posted a photo of WTC 1 after the detonation of a huge bomb beneath that building and yet, WTC 1 remained standing despite the huge explosion. You seem to think that explosives were responsible for the collapse of WTC 7, explosives that somehow withstood major impact damage and the damaging effects of fires that raged out of control for hours. Did you really think a demolition expert would have waited for hours as his explosives were exposed to such damaging effects before pushing the demolition button? I think not!

You have failed to provide details how WTC 7 could have been properly prepared for CD in secret. You have also failed to provide an explanation in regard to the lack of CD hardware evidence within the rubble of WTC 7.

The use of explosives would have left behind CD evidence, CD evidence for which no such evidence was ever found at ground zero and yet, you wish us to believe that the collapse of WTC 7 was the result of CD.

I have posted references regarding the internal collapse of WTC 5, which can be applied in reference to the collapse of WTC 7, but you've failed to get the hint, which brings into question, why do you want a debate when you do not understand the specifics of what controlled demolition is all about?

We have undeniable evidence of uncontrolled fires raging within WTC 7 and major impact damage on the south wall of WTC 7, but no CD evidence.

.
 
Last edited:
All three reports have invalid assumptions and calculations and do not explain the observed behavior of the collapse of WTC 7.

I am not rejecting because I just want to. Nobody should accept invalid work as an explanation.

Then you need to write all your objections to each report, in great detail, backed by calculations, and submit it for review by ASCE or similar professional org, or professional journal. Why are you utterly wasting your time cajoling anonymous internet users to debate you?

Do you suppose that even thoroughly beating each and every memer here in a one on one debate would garner you support from the organizations that matter, that the desire for a new investigation would be garnered by doing this?

You have been asked this question probably a dozen times, in different wording, by several posters but continue to slough it off.
 
Last edited:
Furthermore, you cannot detonate explosives in one part of a steel-framed building and expect that building to collapse because the steel structure will redistribute structural loads around the damaged area and remain standing, which was the case as B-767's struck WTC 1 and WTC 2.


as well as, say, the Oklahoma City bombing

ct-oklahoma-city-bomb-terrorism-mcveigh-fbi-okbomb-edit-0419-bd-20150417
 
Then you need to write all your objections to each report, in great detail, backed by calculations, and submit it for review by ASCE or similar professional org, or professional journal. Why are you utterly wasting your time cajoling anonymous internet users to debate you?

Do you suppose that even thoroughly beating each and every memer here in a one on one debate would garner you support from the organizations that matter, that the desire for a new investigation would be garnered by doing this?

You have been asked this question probably a dozen times, in different wording, by several posters but continue to slough it off.

Why Tony has went all way back to 2002, to make his point, the study I posted was 2008 and says Tony is basicly nuts for making that old achient false claim.

Tony's Claim from the 2002 website,

Radiation is the transfer of
heat energy by electromagnetic waves, which depends on
the gas temperature raised to the fourth power.)
For protected structural steel, the temperature increase
due to fire results primarily from (radiation to the fire pro-
tection material and conduction through the protection),

Actually peer reviewed experimental findings 2008,

") use of the radiative fraction in FDS is
essential for predictions in which the grid size is in the order of centimeter because the radiation model
can not solve accurately the radiation equation due to the fourth power dependence of radiation on
temperature, and 2) use of a constant soot yield to represent the soot production in FDS is inaccurate
even though the effect of soot on radiation is attenuated by use of the radiative fraction, and more
accurate soot models are required for predictions of soot production in applications where soot and
radiation interaction is important. "
 
Last edited:
Crazy Chainsaw, I have a question. Since you seem to burn stuff on a regular basis, how often does the fire do something unexpected?


I've read the NIST WTC7 report and it seems to boil down to a lack of remote fire suppression, and a building design that was not up to the events of the day.

Out here in California we just came off one of our worst wildfire years in our history, and talking with the Cal Fire crews over lunch one day they all agreed that entire chapters of fire fighting manuals would have to be rewritten.

As far as #7 goes, I think a good question to ask is had there been no fire, could the building be repaired, or would it have been demoed and rebuilt?
 
Why Tony has went all way back to 2002, to make his point, the study I posted was 2008 and says Tony is basicly nuts for making that old achient false claim.

Tony's Claim from the 2002 website,

Radiation is the transfer of
heat energy by electromagnetic waves, which depends on
the gas temperature raised to the fourth power.)
For protected structural steel, the temperature increase
due to fire results primarily from (radiation to the fire pro-
tection material and conduction through the protection),

Actually peer reviewed experimental findings 2008,

") use of the radiative fraction in FDS is
essential for predictions in which the grid size is in the order of centimeter because the radiation model
can not solve accurately the radiation equation due to the fourth power dependence of radiation on
temperature, and 2) use of a constant soot yield to represent the soot production in FDS is inaccurate
even though the effect of soot on radiation is attenuated by use of the radiative fraction, and more
accurate soot models are required for predictions of soot production in applications where soot and
radiation interaction is important. "

Could you point me to the post numbers where you and Tony link to these studies?

I admit that I thought radiative coupling between floor fire and upper steel would be disrupted by soot in the intervening atmosphere.
I also thought that hot upper gases would be emitting IR too, even as the fire aproached the area directly below the steel of concern.
 
Last edited:
...As far as #7 goes, I think a good question to ask is had there been no fire, could the building be repaired, or would it have been demoed and rebuilt?
I don't think there is any doubt for WTC7 - if there had been no fire the damage was minor and recoverable.

The case for the Twins is different. But the "no fire" scenario was not possible.

However if it had been no fire I'll go out on a limb and say repair would be challenging BUT possible. It would present similar challenges to demolition starting with that impact damage in place. So why pull it down rather than fix it? Which would become a marketing/customer acceptance decision - not technical.

The more challenging engineering recovery scenario would have arisen if the collapses had halted and NOT progressed to global collapse.
 
I don't think there is any doubt for WTC7 - if there had been no fire the damage was minor and recoverable.

The case for the Twins is different. But the "no fire" scenario was not possible.

However if it had been no fire I'll go out on a limb and say repair would be challenging BUT possible. It would present similar challenges to demolition starting with that impact damage in place. So why pull it down rather than fix it? Which would become a marketing/customer acceptance decision - not technical.

The more challenging engineering recovery scenario would have arisen if the collapses had halted and NOT progressed to global collapse.

Or worse, if the CD had partially failed leaving the tower(s) only partially destroyed with live explosives in the wrecked building(s).:jaw-dropp:cool::rolleyes:
 
Hey benthamitemetric, a study you might want.

9-205.pdf
Experimental and Numerical Investigations of Heat Impact and
Flame Heights from Fires in SBI Tests
JIANPING ZHANG, MICHAEL DELICHATSIOS, MATTHIEU COLOBERT, JOHAN HEREID,
MARTIN HAGEN and DIMITRIOS BAKIRTZIS
FireSERT, Research Institute of Built Environment
University of Ulster
FireSERT, University of Ulster at Jordanstown, Newtownabbey, BT37 0QB, Northern Ireland

FDS predicts reasonably the flame heights (see Table 2) but underpredicts significantly the surface
heat flux (see Fig. 9). Sensitivity studies showed that: 1) use of the radiative fraction in FDS is
essential for predictions in which the grid size is in the order of centimeter because the radiation model
can not solve accurately the radiation equation due to the fourth power dependence of radiation on
temperature, and 2) use of a constant soot yield to represent the soot production in FDS is inaccurate
even though the effect of soot on radiation is attenuated by use of the radiative fraction, and more
accurate soot models are required for predictions of soot production in applications where soot and
radiation interaction is important.

But then I would know anything about fire science Tony says so, so it must be true.

Interesting paper, for sure. I think, however, that we can't even get into talking with granularity about the limitations FDS or NIST's assumptions because we can't even get Tony to acknowledge the generally accepted principles of fire science and the outcomes of previous, base-level studies. I thought Tony would actually want to have a detailed, adult conversation about these things because he is smart enough and he certainly claims to be interested in them. But his bias is so strong that he cannot even bring himself to acknowledge the shortcomings of an approach so glaringly incorrect as Korol's. How can you meaningful discuss these issues with someone who believes analyses has to start from an assumption of magical teleporting fires that last no longer than 25-30 min in a single spot?

I really hope his fellow travelers have been paying attention to how obviously flawed his and Korol's approach to temperatures has been.
 
Crazy Chainsaw, I have a question. Since you seem to burn stuff on a regular basis, how often does the fire do something unexpected?


I've read the NIST WTC7 report and it seems to boil down to a lack of remote fire suppression, and a building design that was not up to the events of the day.

Out here in California we just came off one of our worst wildfire years in our history, and talking with the Cal Fire crews over lunch one day they all agreed that entire chapters of fire fighting manuals would have to be rewritten.

As far as #7 goes, I think a good question to ask is had there been no fire, could the building be repaired, or would it have been demoed and rebuilt?

The more complex the fire the more unexpected events occur.

Fire is a complicated set of chemical reactions.

World Trade 7 was doomed from the start even if it had not collapsed the damage to the structure would have been too much to repair.

If you can control the temperature, or the oxidation of the fire you can control the fire.

We just got a new tempest PVV Fan for burning green stumps, with out a fan to super heat them they will not burn. They have to remain hot enough so they don't act as heat sinks and cool themse!ves below 600C.
 
Could you point me to the post numbers where you and Tony link to these studies?

I admit that I thought radiative coupling between floor fire and upper steel would be disrupted by soot in the intervening atmosphere.
I also thought that hot upper gases would be emitting IR too, even as the fire aproached the area directly below the steel of concern.

I can't link PDFs, so I gave the author and information, I have only 223 more studies in my library of published peer reviewed studies from around the world that say basicly the same thing.
It is a world wide conspiracy.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11652156#post11652156
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11652011#post11652011
 
Interesting paper, for sure. I think, however, that we can't even get into talking with granularity about the limitations FDS or NIST's assumptions because we can't even get Tony to acknowledge the generally accepted principles of fire science and the outcomes of previous, base-level studies. I thought Tony would actually want to have a detailed, adult conversation about these things because he is smart enough and he certainly claims to be interested in them. But his bias is so strong that he cannot even bring himself to acknowledge the shortcomings of an approach so glaringly incorrect as Korol's. How can you meaningful discuss these issues with someone who believes analyses has to start from an assumption of magical teleporting fires that last no longer than 25-30 min in a single spot?

I really hope his fellow travelers have been paying attention to how obviously flawed his and Korol's approach to temperatures has been.

It isn't his biases, he makes that clear, Gage wouldn't like it if his pet engineer, actually showed some intellectual honesty, he might stop paying him for mowing his lawn.
I can't even comprehend or imagine him doing any ligitamate engineering.
 
World Trade 7 was doomed from the start even if it had not collapsed the damage to the structure would have been too much to repair.

I disagree. The question was if there was no fire would the building have survived?

I see no evidence that the building was damaged badly enough structurally that it could not have been repaired. There were reports that it was "leaning" but, I've seen no real evidence to point to this being actually true.

WTC7's fate was sealed by the (prudent) decision of the FDNY to concentrate it's resources on rescue and recovery.

WTC7 would not have been destroyed by "normal office fires", it was destroyed because of the total combination of the events of the day.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom