does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

I'm not saying the towers were a bubble party. The foam method is just one of the only examples I could find on video. Countless patents, military manuals discussing methods as simple as sand, mud, clay, water being used to cover up explosives, etc. just makes me think it's a matter more ambiguous than the posters here like to say.

After all, nobody here can give an exact decibel/distance measurement (or an estimation) for how loud the WTC collapses were. We have videos like these which show that the collapse was very loud from quite some distance (more than some other videos show, I guess it depends on the microphone). We have witnesses like this guy, who was four miles away at the News Corp building, who described the collapses as loud and used the word "explosion".

Why go far away? This one is quite close. The only thing I can hear in the video - and apparently that the firefighters can hear is the individual floors giving way as the collapse progresses.

Note the building is already moving before they react - meaning the noise followed the movement. In a CD doesn't the BOOM come first?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2-9TD3oQq3g

Here's my fav video of the North Tower collapse, taken from not all that far away where the sounds of sirens and people screaming is far louder than the sound the building makes as it collapses. And once again, building moves first, then comes sound. The exact opposite of any CD video I have ever seen.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xGAofwkAOlo&t=39s

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eem7d58gjno

Your desperation is showing. Stop clinging to mighta bins and start dealing with known facts.
 
I'm not saying the towers were a bubble party. The foam method is just one of the only examples I could find on video. Countless patents, military manuals discussing methods as simple as sand, mud, clay, water being used to cover up explosives, etc. just makes me think it's a matter more ambiguous than the posters here like to say.

After all, nobody here can give an exact decibel/distance measurement (or an estimation) for how loud the WTC collapses were. We have videos like these which show that the collapse was very loud from quite some distance (more than some other videos show, I guess it depends on the microphone). We have witnesses like this guy, who was four miles away at the News Corp building, who described the collapses as loud and used the word "explosion".
Your technical point is correct MicahJava BUT not relevant to WTC 9/11 collapses. Or rather you have not shown it to be relevant and I suggest that "tagging along" on a T Szamboti derailed thread of "tit-for-tat" mole whackery is not going to help your cause.

So why post in this thread unless your goal is to support T Szamboti's Tag Team Trolling?

AFAICS this is the status of the relevant key facts:
1) WTC Buildings collapsed on 9/11 following a combination of impact and fire damages;
2) The prima facie cause of each collapse was self evident on the day;
3) All three towers collapsed by mechanisms that have been explained with rigour of scientific method without any need for explosive or other malicious additional intervention;
4) There have been numerous claims for MHI or CD using explosive and/or incendiary cutting;
5 ) There has NEVER been a viable hypothesis to support CD or other MHI;
6) In forum discussions of the WTC1 and WTC2 collapses - whilst operating within the logical limits of "cannot prove a negative" - strong argument has been made that there was "no need for CD" and the stronger of those arguments by me and others have NEVER been rebutted;
7) Discussions about the Twin Towers saw those we now call "debunkers" accepting the "reversed burden of DISproof" - simply because no truther was able to present a pro CD argument worthy of serious discussion;
8) Following the delayed release of the NIST Report into WTC7 truthers switched attention to WTC7 for a reason which is obvious whether it is recognised or left implicit;
9) Truthers had lost the battle for CD at the WTC "Twins" and WTC7 gave ground for extending pointless claims because with the evidence hidden internally at WTC7 it was grades harder for debunkers to disprove CD;
10) The burden of proof still rests with those claiming CD. They show no indication of even getting close to proving CD;
11) So the current objective of T Szamboti et al continues to be "....bog down the discussion, not to make progress toward a solution" (Jay Windley referenced in DGM's "Sig")

The T Szamboti tactics of "going round in circles" has not varied for many years. He appears episodically with a new issue for obfuscated circling - and uses a different "Tag Team Troll" on each occasion. Recall C7 then Gerrycan and others - on this occasion a two person Tag Team of Criteria and Ziggi.

Different "assistants" - same game. And they are not posting for serious discussion here.

And you risk becoming the third member of the current tag Team.

Many members will continue to enjoy "whacking" each "mole" as Tony et al restore them for a brief return to centre stage.

Whatever legitimate point you may wish to make will get smothered in the cross fire and dead moles.

Meanwhile the issue of "One on One Debate" seems to be drifting between suggestions for a legitmate "debate" or remaining with Tony's game playing style.
 
I'm not saying the towers were a bubble party. The foam method is just one of the only examples I could find on video. Countless patents, military manuals discussing methods as simple as sand, mud, clay, water being used to cover up explosives, etc. just makes me think it's a matter more ambiguous than the posters here like to say.

After all, nobody here can give an exact decibel/distance measurement (or an estimation) for how loud the WTC collapses were. We have videos like these which show that the collapse was very loud from quite some distance (more than some other videos show, I guess it depends on the microphone). We have witnesses like this guy, who was four miles away at the News Corp building, who described the collapses as loud and used the word "explosion".

- Are you familiar with the concept that witness statements should be backed up with other evidence?
- People tend to explain things in words they know.

- I did wildfire accident investigations. I lost count the numbers of times firefighters described the uptake in fire behavior as "the fire exploded". During burn over entrapments firefighters have described the sound of the burn over as a "runaway freight train, a jet crash, etc).
No explosives, no train, no jet.

Got to ask. How would you described the noise WTC1,2, 7 made as it collapsed?
 
Last edited:
Your technical point is correct MicahJava BUT not relevant to WTC 9/11 collapses. Or rather you have not shown it to be relevant and I suggest that "tagging along" on a T Szamboti derailed thread of "tit-for-tat" mole whackery is not going to help your cause.

So why post in this thread unless your goal is to support T Szamboti's Tag Team Trolling?

AFAICS this is the status of the relevant key facts:
1) WTC Buildings collapsed on 9/11 following a combination of impact and fire damages;
2) The prima facie cause of each collapse was self evident on the day;
3) All three towers collapsed by mechanisms that have been explained with rigour of scientific method without any need for explosive or other malicious additional intervention;
4) There have been numerous claims for MHI or CD using explosive and/or incendiary cutting;
5 ) There has NEVER been a viable hypothesis to support CD or other MHI;
6) In forum discussions of the WTC1 and WTC2 collapses - whilst operating within the logical limits of "cannot prove a negative" - strong argument has been made that there was "no need for CD" and the stronger of those arguments by me and others have NEVER been rebutted;
7) Discussions about the Twin Towers saw those we now call "debunkers" accepting the "reversed burden of DISproof" - simply because no truther was able to present a pro CD argument worthy of serious discussion;
8) Following the delayed release of the NIST Report into WTC7 truthers switched attention to WTC7 for a reason which is obvious whether it is recognised or left implicit;
9) Truthers had lost the battle for CD at the WTC "Twins" and WTC7 gave ground for extending pointless claims because with the evidence hidden internally at WTC7 it was grades harder for debunkers to disprove CD;
10) The burden of proof still rests with those claiming CD. They show no indication of even getting close to proving CD;
11) So the current objective of T Szamboti et al continues to be "....bog down the discussion, not to make progress toward a solution" (Jay Windley referenced in DGM's "Sig")

The T Szamboti tactics of "going round in circles" has not varied for many years. He appears episodically with a new issue for obfuscated circling - and uses a different "Tag Team Troll" on each occasion. Recall C7 then Gerrycan and others - on this occasion a two person Tag Team of Criteria and Ziggi.

Different "assistants" - same game. And they are not posting for serious discussion here.

And you risk becoming the third member of the current tag Team.

Many members will continue to enjoy "whacking" each "mole" as Tony et al restore them for a brief return to centre stage.

Whatever legitimate point you may wish to make will get smothered in the cross fire and dead moles.

Meanwhile the issue of "One on One Debate" seems to be drifting between suggestions for a legitmate "debate" or remaining with Tony's game playing style.

:thumbsup:
 
I'm not saying the towers were a bubble party. The foam method is just one of the only examples I could find on video. Countless patents, military manuals discussing methods as simple as sand, mud, clay, water being used to cover up explosives, etc. just makes me think it's a matter more ambiguous than the posters here like to say.

When you have an iota of evidence to back your fantasy of sound abatement techniques being employed anywhere in the WTC complex on 9/11 be sure to come back and tell us about it.

You "could'a been" simply doesnt cut it anymore than magical space-a-beams.
 
Eight hundred cubic feet of foam to deaden the sound of one kicker charge worth of demolition explosives. That's a cube 20 feet on a side.

I'm sorry to correct you, but a cube with a 20 ft side length has a volume of 8,000 cubic feet.
 
Eight hundred cubic feet of foam to deaden the sound of one kicker charge worth of demolition explosives. That's a cube 20 feet on a side. How far apart were the columns in the twin towers? How much space between floors?

Oops.
800 cu.ft. is a cube 9.28 feet in height, width, and length.
Still pretty difficult to hide
ETA: added to Africanus post
 
Last edited:
A CONFESSION

As many members are aware over my internet posting career (~~40k posts) I have made two errors which I didn't spot in time and which came back to bite. (Don't ask how many more have not been noticed...:o )

Plus one where I went close - just beat the edit window - (jaydeehess MAY remember that one. I was playing smartarse with him in tag team over free body physics and over-G.) (And I got the "end for end rotating falling beam" example wrong - it is not as obvious as it looks. And I nearly ballsed it up. :mad: )

The ancient one was calculating the trajectory of a body projected horizontally >> therefore distance reached before hitting ground. An early discussion of the beams impaled in WFC alongside the Wintergarden and before I saw Major_Tom's neat bit of visual research into HTFCPNST << Hardly a catchy acronym which was not released into debate.

I calculated 912 and the opponent still calls me econ912 as a gentle reminder.

Remember the playing field is tilted. Truthers are allowed to be wrong all the time and occasionally getting something right is a call for rejoicing.

Debunkers who make a single error can expect to see it recycled....

That is part of the reason my running score against T Szamboti is Me 99.5 Tony 0.5 - I slipped up on half an answer - once...:o
I made
 
Last edited:
I'm not saying the towers were a bubble party. The foam method is just one of the only examples I could find on video. Countless patents, military manuals discussing methods as simple as sand, mud, clay, water being used to cover up explosives, etc. just makes me think it's a matter more ambiguous than the posters here like to say.

After all, nobody here can give an exact decibel/distance measurement (or an estimation) for how loud the WTC collapses were. We have videos like these which show that the collapse was very loud from quite some distance (more than some other videos show, I guess it depends on the microphone). We have witnesses like this guy, who was four miles away at the News Corp building, who described the collapses as loud and used the word "explosion".

Massive dodge noted. Try answering the questions for once.

When you have an iota of evidence to back your fantasy of sound abatement techniques being employed anywhere in the WTC complex on 9/11 be sure to come back and tell us about it.

You "could'a been" simply doesnt cut it anymore than magical space-a-beams.

I wouldn't hold my breath waiting, everyone except Micah it seems knows there is no evidence:

foam, bubbles, plastic tents or Sponge Bob were present during or after the collapses that day.
 
Well, I used to be scornful of conspiracy theories, but the suspension of Tony S has changed my mind.
How can this dastardly act be anything other than an attempt by the Illuminati shills that infest this site to shut down a hero of truth?
I truly sympathise with Tony. This cruel act means that:
  • He cannot post the evidence of CD he surely must have. Ever.
  • He cannot contact AE911Truth to enilst their considerable expertise and financial resources to produce a report on the problems with NIST etc., to be submitted for peer review. Ever.
  • There is now no chance at all of a new investigation. Ever.
  • Tony will not be able to reply to all the unanswered questions levelled at him by members of this forum. Ever.
You've got to feel for the little guy, bravely standing up against this kind of oppression.

There may have been a small element of sarcasm in this post. In case no-one noticed.
 
I'm sorry to correct you, but a cube with a 20 ft side length has a volume of 8,000 cubic feet.


Quite right, and thanks! No reason to be sorry to correct me when I need correcting.

A cube a little over 9 feet on a side, then, instead. Or a sphere over 11 feet in diameter.

Still would have caused considerable problems with the elevator shafts!
 
Quite right, and thanks! No reason to be sorry to correct me when I need correcting.

A cube a little over 9 feet on a side, then, instead. Or a sphere over 11 feet in diameter.

Still would have caused considerable problems with the elevator shafts!

Easy peasy, just put the elevators out of service ,,,,,,, for several weeks/months

,,,, move along, nothing suspicious to see here.,,,,
 
Quite right, and thanks! No reason to be sorry to correct me when I need correcting.

A cube a little over 9 feet on a side, then, instead. Or a sphere over 11 feet in diameter.

Still would have caused considerable problems with the elevator shafts!

Well, we don't know what they have.
Probably a sooper seekrit nano-boom-a-husher
 
Well, we don't know what they have.
Probably a sooper seekrit nano-boom-a-husher


Nah, it could have been ordinary mud, clay, or water. Only a thin layer would be needed because heavy incompressible materials are sure to be way more effective than light compressible foam for dampening shock waves, right?
 
Nah, it could have been ordinary mud, clay, or water. Only a thin layer would be needed because heavy incompressible materials are sure to be way more effective than light compressible foam for dampening shock waves, right?

I had one truther claim they used super secret energetic sonic disruption to cancel out the explosives detonation waves.

Essentially very big and powerful speakers.:jaw-dropp
 
Nah, it could have been ordinary mud, clay, or water. Only a thin layer would be needed because heavy incompressible materials are sure to be way more effective than light compressible foam for dampening shock waves, right?

sooper seekrit nano mud, clay, or water boom-a-hushercp
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom