does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Concise and direct to the point as ever Noah.


I don't mind exploring the genuine and true minutiae
BUT so many persist in chasing Tony's evasive and dishonest derails.

Tony has always been one long derail of logical thought, I never expect that to change Ozzie.
 
Have to Agree.

Do you think Tony would lend me his Time machine to go back to 1992, to an art show in June to tell my stupid young self, to say yes to the plain Jane, who asks me if I come with the art work?

Her dad was a multi billionaire and I said no I couldn't leave until the show was over.

I was very stupid back then, I let diamonds Rubbies and gold shiny bobbles blind me, and my buddy didn't tell me until after I opened my mouth.

How I would love to go back in time, and correct that mistake.:D

:crazy:
 
One thing we can say for Tony - he is consistent.

Nearly every reasoned post he responds to he proves the point he is trying to disagree.

The issue Tony was YOUR persistent Reversal of Burden of Proof.

;)

He's also been consistent in responding to direct technical questions regarding fire simulation and heat transfer, with wordy assertions totally lacking any technical content whatsoever.
 
He's also been consistent in responding to direct technical questions regarding fire simulation and heat transfer, with wordy assertions totally lacking any technical content whatsoever.
Many of my historic interactions with him have been where I have identified the false starting assumption of his claim - even tho his maths built on the false foundation MAY have been correct the argument is falsified (or not made out) because of the false premises.

So my critique was a valid comment on his false logic. And time and again he would ask me for my maths or FEA.

As if either could correct logic. But he appears to have little concept of reasoned argument outside the limited domain of maths. (Or FEA which is only a fancy tool for making maths easy or practical.)

Now at risk of once again getting off-side with my professional engineering colleagues - the problem of "trees in wrong forest" is endemic with engineers (and accountants - left brainers) They bog down in detail and lose the plot so often, AKA "alligators and swamp draining" to use another metaphor - which is another thing that many cannot process....:o
 
The NIST WTC 7 report has been discredited and we need a new one that is honest.


I find the NIST report much more credible than the CD @WTC claim because we have fire, buckling and impact damage evidence, but no CD evidence. In addition, we have evidence the fires raging within WTC 7 was more than adequate in order to collapse that building.
 
It has been said before, but the central point of this thread is somewhat revealing of the way some people think.

The very idea that a 'debate' between two anonymous forum users would somehow force an institute like NIST to redo its work (or failing that another institute/orgenisation to redo it) is simply....... special. That's the word.
 
It has been said before, but the central point of this thread is somewhat revealing of the way some people think.

The very idea that a 'debate' between two anonymous forum users would somehow force an institute like NIST to redo its work (or failing that another institute/orgenisation to redo it) is simply....... special. That's the word.

The point of this thread is to show Tony fighting the evil ISFers and gain more donations for
AE/911truth.
 
The point of this thread is to show Tony fighting the evil ISFers and gain more donations for
AE/911truth.

Yes. More than most likely.

But that is not the statement of the OP.
I was taking that one at face value for my comment. :)
 
Yes. More than most likely.

But that is not the statement of the OP.
I was taking that one at face value for my comment. :)

To be able to take truthers now at face value, you have to put your brain in a microwave and hit defrost turkey 20/pounds.
 
I will accept it as error. Either way the report has been discredited and a new analysis and report needs to be performed and issued.

Well when are you starting on the first experiments nessisary to verify your claims to be a forensic engineer?

Anyone can launch a private investigation into anything, I suggest as a member of AE/911Truth you issue a call to use 90% of it's funding on an independent science based investigation, starting with experiments by a neutral Non Biased Lab, to back up your Forensic assessment.
Please have such peer reviewed and published in an engineering journal.
 
I will accept it as error. Either way the report has been discredited and a new analysis and report needs to be performed and issued.

Two other reports on WTC7 were done , you reject them all.
Imho, you will reject every report that doesn't either conclude that impact and fire could not cause collapse, or that only explosives could do so.
IOW you have a conclusion in search of a report.
 
Last edited:
I will accept it as error. Either way the report has been discredited and a new analysis and report needs to be performed and issued.

To achieve what?

I asked this before and you (predictably) ignored it. Is there something wrong with the fire safety recommendations at the end of the NIST report that justifies a do-over?
 
Two other reports on WTC7 were done , you reject them all.
Imho, you will reject every report that doesn't either conclude that impact and fire could not cause collapse, or that only explosives could do so.
IOW you have a conclusion in search of a report.

All three reports have invalid assumptions and calculations and do not explain the observed behavior of the collapse of WTC 7.

I am not rejecting because I just want to. Nobody should accept invalid work as an explanation.
 
To achieve what?

I asked this before and you (predictably) ignored it. Is there something wrong with the fire safety recommendations at the end of the NIST report that justifies a do-over?

The NIST WTC 7 report has been shown to be invalid and non-explanatory. It is not proper to accept recommendations that are based on an invalid and non-explanatory analysis.
 
Last edited:
The NIST WTC 7 report has been shown to be invalid and non-explanatory. It is not proper to accept recommendations that are based on an invalid and non-explanatory analysis.


So when is AE911 starting their own? You would think with their roster, they would have the talent required. You would also think with Gage's fundraising efforts over the years, they would have the budget.
 
The NIST WTC 7 report has been shown to be invalid and non-explanatory. It is not proper to accept recommendations that are based on an invalid and non-explanatory analysis.

Thanks Tony.

That's why I object to your forensics Analysis it has no experimental support.

Please start working on that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom