does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Are you saying I haven't done that?

But I didn't. I clearly stated some of the essential ground rules for a debate. I made no pre-emptive accusations. Pre-emption is one of Tony's tricks. I don't use it.

Yet Tony cannot even read a clear statement without EITHER failing in reading comprehension OR misrepresenting.
Trying to change the process of debate even BEFORE we have opened negotiations as to IF we have such a debate.
 
Are you saying I haven't done that?

You didn't claim to have just by noting the title of this thread.
Instead you are asking others to defend what would be a very narrow affirmative claim, the NIST report, if NIST had claimed the entire scenario put forth in their report was the definitive description of what really happened.

1) There exists in the above , no affirmative claim by you.
2) NIST repeatedly refers to their scenario as "probable". This is most applicable to their initiating failure event, yet that is the very point you have concentrated your dispute with NIST on.
 
You didn't claim to have just by noting the title of this thread.
Instead you are asking others to defend what would be a very narrow affirmative claim, the NIST report, if NIST had claimed the entire scenario put forth in their report was the definitive description of what really happened.

1) There exists in the above , no affirmative claim by you.
2) NIST repeatedly refers to their scenario as "probable". This is most applicable to their initiating failure event, yet that is the very point you have concentrated your dispute with NIST on.

What the NIST, ARUP, and Weidlinger reports on WTC 7 actually show are "impossible collapse sequences".

If the first domino never falls the rest won't either. Many here seem to have trouble understanding that. The most likely reason for this is that, if someone's livelihood depends on not understanding a reality, many are too weak to do the right thing and will try hard not to.

The public has had false reports about how the NYC building collapses occurred foisted on it and a large segment of the population now knows that. The only people who believe them now, or pretend to believe them now, are those who have not looked into it or those whose livelihoods depend on the public believing them.

The above mentioned reports fall apart under serious scrutiny and that is why tfk could not possibly win in the one-on-one debate he had with me and why no others here are willing to try to defend these reports in an honest debate.
 
Last edited:
What the NIST, ARUP, and Weidlinger reports on WTC 7 actually show are "impossible collapse sequences".

If the first domino never falls the rest won't either. Many here seem to have trouble understanding that. The most likely reason for this is that, if someone's livelihood depends on not understanding a reality, many are too weak to do the right thing and will try hard not to.

The public has had false reports about how the NYC building collapses occurred foisted on it and a large segment of the population now knows that. The only people who believe them now, or pretend to believe them now, are those who have not looked into it or those whose livelihoods depend on the public believing them.

The above mentioned reports fall apart under serious scrutiny and that is why tfk could not possibly win in the one-on-one debate he had with me and why no others here are willing to try to defend these reports in an honest debate.

I understand what you are saying Tony I also understand you don't have the forensic engineering skill to make that Claim. The burden of proof is on he who makes said claim.
You have to prove 100% your claim, because you are trying to prove a negative not design a bicycle.
Most forensics engineering studies have experimental evidence that they cite in reference to the claim to lend support to said claim.
Your studies have none, and it appears your data is using minimum tollerances, not average failure strengths, arrived at by experimental investigation under actual conditions.

I fail to see how such highly flawed analysis can be said to prove anything impossible,
You may call me what ever you wish, you may say about me whatever tickles your fancy.
However I must reject your work based on the fact it is as it now stand unsupported by Science and irrelevant to scientific understanding, on what did or did not cause the collapses
on 9/11/2001.
 
What the NIST, ARUP, and Weidlinger reports on WTC 7 actually show are "impossible collapse sequences".

If the first domino never falls the rest won't either. Many here seem to have trouble understanding that. The most likely reason for this is that, if someone's livelihood depends on not understanding a reality, many are too weak to do the right thing and will try hard not to.

The public has had false reports about how the NYC building collapses occurred foisted on it and a large segment of the population now knows that. The only people who believe them now, or pretend to believe them now, are those who have not looked into it or those whose livelihoods depend on the public believing them.

The above mentioned reports fall apart under serious scrutiny and that is why tfk could not possibly win in the one-on-one debate he had with me and why no others here are willing to try to defend these reports in an honest debate.
For $500 Alex, I'll choose, "What was the question Tony asked?".

Answer is of course that in response to Ozeco wanting Tony to put forth an affirmative ( thats the key word here) claim, he (Tony) asked if he hadn't. I pointed out that in the OP that indeed he hadn't. Tony now quotes me then goes about again making no affirmative claim. Either because can't, or because he fears doing so.
 
Last edited:
What the NIST, ARUP, and Weidlinger reports on WTC 7 actually show are "impossible collapse sequences".
If you believe this then your next step is to produce a coherent and detailed engineering rebuttal and submit it to a proper engineering journal.
If the first domino never falls the rest won't either. Many here seem to have trouble understanding that. The most likely reason for this is that, if someone's livelihood depends on not understanding a reality, many are too weak to do the right thing and will try hard not to.
Yes, or no; it is fully possible to determine the exact initial component and mechanism of failure of that component, in WTC7?

The public has had false reports about how the NYC building collapses occurred foisted on it and a large segment of the population now knows that. The only people who believe them now, or pretend to believe them now, are those who have not looked into it or those whose livelihoods depend on the public believing them.
If you believe this then your next step is to produce a coherent and detailed engineering rebuttal and submit it to a proper engineering journal.

The above mentioned reports fall apart under serious scrutiny and that is why tfk could not possibly win in the one-on-one debate he had with me and why no others here are willing to try to defend these reports in an honest debate.
Post 19
Originally Posted by jaydeehess
So, Tony, as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?
 
For $500 Alex, I'll choose, "What was the question Tony asked?".

Answer is of course that in response to Ozeco wanting Tony to put forth an affirmative ( thats the key word here) claim, he (Tony) asked if he hadn't. I pointed out that in tge OP that indeed he hadn't. Tony now quotes me yhen goes about again making no affirmative claim. Either because can't, or because he fears doing so.

I'm not entirely sure he knows what it means.
 
Oh, and concerning the Cardington tests, where again can we see that 25 minute heating phase illustrated?

I believe you had it as an 850C gas temp, 25 minute fire, heating a steel component that begins at 20C .
Something like that?
 
Oh, and concerning the Cardington tests, where again can we see that 25 minute heating phase illustrated?

I believe you had it as an 850C gas temp, 25 minute fire, heating a steel component that begins at 20C .
Something like that?

Take a look at this Jay,

"Soot. - National Institute of Standards and Technology
fire.nist.gov › bfrlpubs › fire93 › PDF
At flame temperatures, soot behaves not unlike a black body. emitting visible and infrared radiation following Planck's Law. A large portion (@5090 of the carbon atoms present in a hydrocarbon fire exist in the form of ..."


Look at page/25
 
Take a look at this Jay,

"Soot. - National Institute of Standards and Technology
fire.nist.gov › bfrlpubs › fire93 › PDF
At flame temperatures, soot behaves not unlike a black body. emitting visible and infrared radiation following Planck's Law. A large portion (@5090 of the carbon atoms present in a hydrocarbon fire exist in the form of ..."


Look at page/25

I'm having a hard time navigating to the fire93 pdf. I get to the search page at bfrlpubs but then need an author, title or keyword. Do you have the paper title or author name?
 
I'm having a hard time navigating to the fire93 pdf. I get to the search page at bfrlpubs but then need an author, title or keyword. Do you have the paper title or author name?
F93056.PDF,
Anthony Hamins
NIST,
Gaithersburg

It is so easy for me to find experimental research that supports my claims, why is it so hard for the Great TonyS.
Super Engineer?
 
Last edited:
F93056.PDF,
Anthony Hamins
NIST,
Gaithersburg

It is so easy for me to find experimental research that supports my claims, why is it so hard for the Great TonyS.
Super Engineer?

Wow, there is a ton of great research in that archive all freely accessible. An unbelievable amount, actually. Thanks for the tip.

Tony is still staring at the attached figure 10-1 from NIST's WTC 7 report and claiming it supports a 25-30 min heat transfer time for a given beam in WTC 7 under the observed fire conditions. He is so far gone he is literal incapable of simply stating what is obvious to everyone else: Korol's use of only a 25-30 min heating time is clearly erroneous. I don't think he's going to be diving into even more detailed fire science research any time soon. In all likelihood, he'll hide from ISF for a few weeks and hope that we forget his inability to be even remotely intellectually honest about the actual extant research.
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1.jpg
    16.1 KB · Views: 4
Last edited:
I have some time right now and am wondering if anyone here who supports the conclusions of the NIST reports, for the three high-rise collapses in NYC on Sept. 11, 2001, would want to debate me one-on-one as I contend that these NIST reports have been shown to be non-explanatory and incorrect.

The debate would take place on the 911 free forum, like the one I did with tfk, and the rules would be the same as those for that debate shown below.

1. The debate is restricted to the collapses of WTC 1, 2 & 7 in NYC on September 11, 2001, the NIST reports on these events, and any additional objectively verifiable information and analyses in the public domain about them.

2. Each person shall make an opening statement (of no more than 500 words) explaining what they believe caused the collapse of WTC 7 and briefly stating what they believe are the (approximately) 3 strongest pieces of verifiable evidence for/against Controlled Demolition, as "Controlled Demolition vs. No Controlled Demolition" is the heart of the debate.

3. tfk will go first after both participants make an opening statement on June 21, 2016.

4. Each person shall make no more than one post per day and cannot make another until it is responded to.

5. If a post is not responded to within a week the person not responding is considered to have forfeited his turn & the other person will proceed with his next statement.

6. Individual posts are limited to 1,000 words. If it is deemed necessary to exceed that limit, justification shall be provided by the person wanting to exceed it and agreement to by the other participant received prior to doing so. This should be done by private messaging, so as not to interrupt the flow of the debate, and should be the exception rather than the rule.

7. Each post will discuss one principle topic. Each topic consists of 4 posts. Person A will state a topic post, Person B replies, Person A counters, then Person B counters, and that topic is closed. Person B then leads off the next sequence.

8. Every point that either person brings up must be addressed in some manner by the other. Both parties will do their best to stay focused on the original topic point.

9. There shall be no name calling, denigration, or defamatory language used. Each person shall bring only technical arguments to the debate. If any derogatory comments are used they shall be addressed to arguments only, not to individuals.

10. The debate will end after a maximum of 50 total posts, or earlier if the participants mutually agree to an earlier termination, or whenever either participant decides to stop responding.

At the risk of taking this discussion dangerously back on topic,...

I am wondering what the point of all of this is.

1. A debate between two unknowns on an obscure internet forum read by scores of people, about just a single report (just one of several that exist on the topic) isn't going to change anything.

2. What needs to be changed? What is your objective Tony? Are there fire safety recommendations in the NIST report that you take issue with? If so, what are they and how does a debate on an obscure interweb forum read by scores of people change that?
 
At the risk of taking this discussion dangerously back on topic,...

I am wondering what the point of all of this is.

1. A debate between two unknowns on an obscure internet forum read by scores of people, about just a single report (just one of several that exist on the topic) isn't going to change anything.

2. What needs to be changed? What is your objective Tony? Are there fire safety recommendations in the NIST report that you take issue with? If so, what are they and how does a debate on an obscure interweb forum read by scores of people change that?
Tony's entire basis for life lately seems to be, using an analogy:
A missile hits a 747, and the airplane crashes into a neighborhood, killing everybody aboard, a lot of people on the ground, and burning down a neighborhood.
The investigation states that a missile into the airplane caused loss of structural integrity and control due to its severing the spar box and setting off the fuel.
Tony contends that the missile actually went through the wing box forward of the spar, killing the pilots, and that the spar severing and subsequent fire were due to a bomb in the baggage compartment.
 
Wow, there is a ton of great research in that archive all freely accessible. An unbelievable amount, actually. Thanks for the tip.

Tony is still staring at the attached figure 10-1 from NIST's WTC 7 report and claiming it supports a 25-30 min heat transfer time for a given beam in WTC 7 under the observed fire conditions. He is so far gone he is literal incapable of simply stating what is obvious to everyone else: Korol's use of only a 25-30 min heating time is clearly erroneous. I don't think he's going to be diving into even more detailed fire science research any time soon. In all likelihood, he'll hide from ISF for a few weeks and hope that we forget his inability to be even remotely intellectually honest about the actual extant research.

I based many of my own experiments off of similar articles, and untold hours of research,
Most people think I was just having fun trying to blow myself up, what they never saw was the
Thousands of actual research papers I read in order to properly design the experiments to have fun blowing myself up.

That's why Tony and Cole fail, no actual research, just fraudulent nonsensical claims.
 
Tony's entire basis for life lately seems to be, using an analogy:
A missile hits a 747, and the airplane crashes into a neighborhood, killing everybody aboard, a lot of people on the ground, and burning down a neighborhood.
The investigation states that a missile into the airplane caused loss of structural integrity and control due to its severing the spar box and setting off the fuel.
Tony contends that the missile actually went through the wing box forward of the spar, killing the pilots, and that the spar severing and subsequent fire were due to a bomb in the baggage compartment.

He wants people to think he is Doing Forensic engineering, but he doesn't know the first thing about doing forensic engineering, is research, and accurate experimentation to determine actual failure rates based on averages. Not minimal aspects of strength.
He can't differentiate forensic engineering from design engineering.
There was a good article I had, in a popular science mag once, but I lost it when my old computer crashed.
Basicly forensic engineering uses experiments, and the data from those experiments to determine where design engineers specifications didn't work and why.
The case of the Lockheed Electra, that kept crashing is a good analogy for the difference in the two methodologies.
However explaining this to Tony is like explaining Quantum mechanics to a stone.
 
What the NIST, ARUP, and Weidlinger reports on WTC 7 actually show are "impossible collapse sequences".


1. How long did fires rage out of control within WTC 7 before the building collapsed?

2. Did fighters report creaking noises from within WTC 7 as those fires raged out of control? Yes or no.

3. From a structural standpoint, what did those sounds indicate?

4. There were reports that WTC 7 was buckling. What does structural buckling indicate as fires continued to rage out of control?

5. Why was a decision made to create a collapse zone around WTC 7?

6. As WTC 7 collapsed, was the sound of explosives heard in the range of 130-140 decibels? Yes or no.


If not, then you might as well shelve any idea that WTC 7 was demolished by CD explosives.
 
Last edited:
For $500 Alex, I'll choose, "What was the question Tony asked?".

Answer is of course that in response to Ozeco wanting Tony to put forth an affirmative ( thats the key word here) claim, he (Tony) asked if he hadn't. I pointed out that in the OP that indeed he hadn't. Tony now quotes me then goes about again making no affirmative claim. Either because can't, or because he fears doing so.

I'm not entirely sure he knows what it means.
I'm near certain that he doesn't. And I'm sure that a lot of other members don't see the issue either.

And I'll illustrate using a metaphor from DGM's "sig" - which will further confuse those who don't process metaphors or similar devices :) :
DGM's Sig said:
"How many leaves on the seventh branch of the fourth tree?" is meaningless when you are in the wrong forest: ozeco41
..and the circular back reference to me as authority will add further "amusement"... ;)

Put simply the ongoing problem with Tony's claims and discussion with Tony is that ALL of his claims are rely on argument of details which are based on false foundations.

Two separate levels:
Top Level - The claim overall starts from false premises AKA false foundations;
Detail level - argument of details which are irrelevant because the foundation is wrong.

I identified the issue in my first internet post - Nov 2007 - long before I knew or met Tony - when I said this:
The paper referenced as Engineering Reality by Tony Szamboti is typical of many which look impressive in detail to the non-engineer. The complex calculations may even be correct but the base premises are faulty and the resulting conclusions can readily be demonstrated to be totally wrong.
"Missing Jolt" is the most recognised of Tony's claims to infamy and it suffers from the same fatal error of wrong starting assumptions. Two of them actually - but I'll resist the temptation to derail. :o

Now Tony has not changed his SOP of arguing "in the wrong forest" AKA false starting point assumptions. He has changed the type of false foundation in the last couple of years. Rather than a false technical foundation as per "Missing Jolt" he now relies on a false procedural foundation - wrong logic base for his "argument". All his recent claims based on implied false dichotomy. I'll separate the two bits "false dichotomy" and "implied".

The cuirrent example:
What the NIST, ARUP, and Weidlinger reports on WTC 7 actually show are "impossible collapse sequences".

OK - begging the question of whether Tony is right or not. No matter how many reports from whatever experts disagree on the causes of WTC7 collapse they do NOT prove either of Tony's claims - either "It was CD" OR "Further investigation is necessary".

That is where the "implication" comes in - because Tony can play games with denying.

There is an arena for all these ongoing technical discussions including whether or not Nordenson et all were right or wrong. BUT it has zero persuasive power on Tony's two claims "It was CD" therefore "Further investigation is warranted".

Which is why I was explicit in my approach to the challenge for debate.

I MAY be interested in a debate with Tony. But ONLY of a legitimate topic and following legitimate process.

I don't see Tony agreeing to either - it would break his 9 year consistent game plan.

I'm not sure that he even understands either of those two issues. So - like you Mark -
...I'm not entirely sure he knows what it means.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom