does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Tony's entire basis for life lately seems to be, using an analogy:
A missile hits a 747, and the airplane crashes into a neighborhood, killing everybody aboard, a lot of people on the ground, and burning down a neighborhood.
The investigation states that a missile into the airplane caused loss of structural integrity and control due to its severing the spar box and setting off the fuel.
Tony contends that the missile actually went through the wing box forward of the spar, killing the pilots, and that the spar severing and subsequent fire were due to a bomb in the baggage compartment.
clap.gif
clap.gif
 
[qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg] [qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg]

What this shows me is that Tony is still stuck in 2008, and doesn't want to leave that time.
Same old Tony, he never will change.
 
Tony's entire basis for life lately seems to be, using an analogy:
A missile hits a 747, and the airplane crashes into a neighborhood, killing everybody aboard, a lot of people on the ground, and burning down a neighborhood.
The investigation states that a missile into the airplane caused loss of structural integrity and control due to its severing the spar box and setting off the fuel.
Tony contends that the missile actually went through the wing box forward of the spar, killing the pilots, and that the spar severing and subsequent fire were due to a bomb in the baggage compartment.


No, no, no. Tony is all about getting a new investigation. Everything he says and does is laser-focused on that all-important goal.

That's why I expect any moment now he'll take me up on my offer to debate him one-on-one about a new investigation. He wants to debate, he wants a new investigation, so of course he won't miss this chance.
 
No, no, no. Tony is all about getting a new investigation. Everything he says and does is laser-focused on that all-important goal.

That's why I expect any moment now he'll take me up on my offer to debate him one-on-one about a new investigation. He wants to debate, he wants a new investigation, so of course he won't miss this chance.

clap.gif
clap.gif

I like BUT disagree the hilited point.

IF he was laser focussed he wouldn't be in the no-where to go situation he is in.

Maybe "is focussed like moonlight reflected off ..." ;)



Alternatively references to black cat - coal mine -- total eclipse -- of moon... I'll leave it for others to do the neat word play stuff. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
You've made it clear you have no interest in debating the events of 9/11.

Let me know when you want to debate the entirety of that day, we'll start with Shanksville and do it on this forum. Let me know when you're ready , I have lots of time.

15 years of utter failure and counting...

So when do we start Tony????
 
I disagree...

...it is no later than 2007.

:runaway
Have to Agree.

Do you think Tony would lend me his Time machine to go back to 1992, to an art show in June to tell my stupid young self, to say yes to the plain Jane, who asks me if I come with the art work?

Her dad was a multi billionaire and I said no I couldn't leave until the show was over.

I was very stupid back then, I let diamonds Rubbies and gold shiny bobbles blind me, and my buddy didn't tell me until after I opened my mouth.

How I would love to go back in time, and correct that mistake.:D
 
...they do NOT prove ... "Further investigation is necessary".
The word "necessary" in most cases, and I am sure in the current context, pertains to subjective judgement (an exception would be if there existed a defined legal requirement), and hence to an opinion.

You can't "prove" that a "further investigation is necessary", nor can you "prove" none is "necessary".

If a debate were to be held on the question "Is a new investigation necessary, given that those we have may be mistaken on details[*]?"
I think we are all already at least vaguely mutually aware of why Tony thinks one is necessary, and why many of us think none is necessary (and why some are probably indifferent). A discussion would merely serve to enumerate the respective reasons for the opposing opinions. Tony needs no opponent however to enumerate his reasons, and he could ask any of us to enumerate theirs. No point in discussing them, really.





[*] I'd predict that Tony would want the word "details" qualified with an adjective like "important" - but that doesn't change what I am saying one bit, as this distinction is the same as the distinction under discussion, "necessary" or "not necessary".
 
Tony's entire basis for life lately seems to be, using an analogy:
A missile hits a 747, and the airplane crashes into a neighborhood, killing everybody aboard, a lot of people on the ground, and burning down a neighborhood.
The investigation states that a missile into the airplane caused loss of structural integrity and control due to its severing the spar box and setting off the fuel.
Tony contends that the missile actually went through the wing box forward of the spar, killing the pilots, and that the spar severing and subsequent fire were due to a bomb in the baggage compartment.

The analogy doesn't hit the nail on the head.
Tony does not agree with what (missile) brought the plane down.


My version:
Following a bird hit, a 747 crashes into a neighborhood, killing everybody aboard, a lot of people on the ground, and burning down a neighborhood.

One dead man on the ground had apparently sustained heavy impact injuries and widespread burns. The physician signing the death notice suspected the man had died from a concussion on the head. An autopsy was done on the dead man's remains. It found that he was hit by a control surface in the abdomen and he probably died within 5 minutes from a ruptured liver. A civil litigation later ensued when his insurance wouldn't pay: There was a clause that death by fire was not covered, and their own expert claimed that skin burns from fires, causing a lethal shock were the likely cause of death, while it was unlikely that this control surface could have hit the man in the abdomen. An expert retained by the widow's counsel showed that fire as such was an unlikely cause of death and rather hypothesises that he had inhaled the hot exhaust of burning jet fuel spray and died from the resulting loss of lung function.

Tony takes issue with all these expert reports and insinuates that the man was't killed by the plane crash at all, but by evil agents of the government who set arson to his house and then beat him up with ice blocks that don't melt in fire. The issue of a plane crashing into the house is diligently ignored or construed as a cover for the murder. The bird that hit the plane was a patsy of the secret service.
 
Last edited:
The word "necessary" in most cases, and I am sure in the current context, pertains to subjective judgement (an exception would be if there existed a defined legal requirement), and hence to an opinion.
Could be from a devils advocate point of view . My purpose was to identify the objective - not to comprehensively define it. Maybe "justified" would have been a better choice of words.

Tony has two identifiable "output" objectives - in taxonomic "means end" - or rather "End <> Means" order they are:
Achieve the END goal of a "New Investigation"
by the MEANS of claiming to have proved CD.
He states those in many ways including denying them in some of his interactions.

I have several times suggested that his current and dominant "objective" is to keep debate going round in circles...but put that one aside for now.

The end of "New Investigation" cannot be achieved in the current context of internet processes whether "discussion" or "debate". It is a disagreement with US Governance and statute empowered due process. The provisions of due process have so far not given Tony et al the New Investigation and - simply put - further progress to that end will need a critical mass of political support.

You comments as to subjectivity could be appropriate in the setting of a proposed debate. My objective for recent posts has been to suggest a legitimate process and some topics that I could support as a basis for debate.

Since Tony true to his SOP has ignored what I have said .....whether or not you can find fault with one of the words I used is moot. ;)

You can't "prove" that a "further investigation is necessary", nor can you "prove" none is "necessary".
I don't have to. For Tony et al to achieve a New Investigation they will have to justify it - whether or not my use of "necessary" was devils advocate "nit pickable" in an internet forum discussion. And he or they will need a critical mass of political support - I doubt that my use of an inappropriate word in forum discussion would be a factor. :rolleyes:

For the record I agree with you further comments:
If a debate were to be held on the question "Is a new investigation necessary, given that those we have may be mistaken on details[*]?"
I think we are all already at least vaguely mutually aware of why Tony thinks one is necessary, and why many of us think none is necessary (and why some are probably indifferent). A discussion would merely serve to enumerate the respective reasons for the opposing opinions. Tony needs no opponent however to enumerate his reasons, and he could ask any of us to enumerate theirs. No point in discussing them, really.

[*] I'd predict that Tony would want the word "details" qualified with an adjective like "important" - but that doesn't change what I am saying one bit, as this distinction is the same as the distinction under discussion, "necessary" or "not necessary".
...I've simple been suggesting a way forward.
 
...Tony takes issue with all these expert reports and insinuates that the man was't killed by the plane crash at all, but by evil agents of the government who set arson to his house and then beat him up with ice blocks that don't melt in fire. The issue of a plane crashing into the house is diligently ignored or construed as a cover for the murder. The bird that hit the plane was a patsy of the secret service.
Well said. I liked rwguinn's version and gave some though to a more accurate analogy but....had no brilliant idea so let the opportunity go....:o

The core issue is the change of strategy that Tony has been following for the past year or more. From 2007 through to recently the tactics of his claims was "Make false starting assumptions - build house of cards on false foundation". With Missing Jolt the most obvious example. But from a year or so back his strategy has changed to:

"High Level False Dichotomy"
"If I can prove an expert wrong I can (IMPLY) that I am right." AND
"The more experts I can prove wrong - the more right it makes me."

And my loose terminology because I don't think informed internet forum posting members are Tony's target. IMO he is playing the game mostly for his sycophant supporters. To them whether his logic is correct or not is irrelevant - they will accept whatever spin Tony puts to them.
 
But from a year or so back his strategy has changed to:

"High Level False Dichotomy"
"If I can prove an expert wrong I can (IMPLY) that I am right." AND
"The more experts I can prove wrong - the more right it makes me."

There's also a reversal of the burden of proof involved. We know that WTC7 was on fire and that fire can cause collapse of steel framed structures, yet Tony is insisting that the burden of proof is against the conclusion that the fire caused the collapse, and that if this cannot be proven beyond an unattainable level of certainty then we must conclude that the collapse was caused by some other means of which there is no evidence whatsoever.

Dave
 
There's also a reversal of the burden of proof involved. We know that WTC7 was on fire and that fire can cause collapse of steel framed structures, yet Tony is insisting that the burden of proof is against the conclusion that the fire caused the collapse, and that if this cannot be proven beyond an unattainable level of certainty then we must conclude that the collapse was caused by some other means of which there is no evidence whatsoever.

Dave
Fully agreed Dave. I tend to take it for granted that truther claims involve "Reversed Burden of DISproof" - so I often don't mention it explicitly.

I have gone even further and suggested that without RBoP there would be very little internet forum discussion of 9/11 CT.

I suspect "ALL" but I'll say MOST truther claims involve RBoP.

The structure of a typical truther claim being:
1) I don't understand (some single or limited anomaly);
2) Therefore I claim CD;
3) You prove me wrong.

sure they foggy it up and add more details but that is the foundation structure of the arguments.
 
There's also a reversal of the burden of proof involved. We know that WTC7 was on fire and that fire can cause collapse of steel framed structures, yet Tony is insisting that the burden of proof is against the conclusion that the fire caused the collapse, and that if this cannot be proven beyond an unattainable level of certainty then we must conclude that the collapse was caused by some other means of which there is no evidence whatsoever.

Dave

Spot on.
 
There's also a reversal of the burden of proof involved. We know that WTC7 was on fire and that fire can cause collapse of steel framed structures, yet Tony is insisting that the burden of proof is against the conclusion that the fire caused the collapse, and that if this cannot be proven beyond an unattainable level of certainty then we must conclude that the collapse was caused by some other means of which there is no evidence whatsoever.

Dave

Sorry Dave but I am not buying a report that omits stiffeners from a girder that would have prevented the girder's flange from folding up if it was pushed past its seat. Or one that could only show 5.5 inches of beam expansion and claimed the girder seat was 11 inches when the drawings showed 12 inches. Or one that says there were no shear studs on the girder that would have prevented the girder from being pushed at all when there was information saying it had 30 shear studs. Or one that ignores the fact that the heated girder would have been trapped behind the column 79 side plate after just 3 inches of westward travel. Or one that can't even generate the impact load to break through the next floor down that is simply asserted as a start of a cascade.

The NIST WTC 7 report has been discredited and we need a new one that is honest.
 
Last edited:
Oh but you accept a report that ignores preheating and convection heating because........ you just wanna.
And you will of course be encouraging Korol, or maybe a couple of AE911T fire sciences engineers, to submit a fire intensity/spread report to, for instance, The Journal of Fire Sciences.
 
There's also a reversal of the burden of proof involved. [EDIT: Followed by Reasoned argument ]
Dave
Sorry Dave but I am not buying a report ...[EDIT: Followed by lots of irrelevant unproven assertions ALL subject to Burden of Proof]...The NIST WTC 7 report has been discredited and we need a new one that is honest.
One thing we can say for Tony - he is consistent.

Nearly every reasoned post he responds to he proves the point he is trying to disagree.

The issue Tony was YOUR persistent Reversal of Burden of Proof.

;)
 
Oh but you accept a report that ignores preheating and convection heating because........ you just wanna.
And you will of course be encouraging Korol, or maybe a couple of AE911T fire sciences engineers, to submit a fire intensity/spread report to, for instance, The Journal of Fire Sciences.

Or maybe Tony could find an experiment that proves, the girder edge, and seat,
Would not suffer ductile tear out.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom