The word "necessary" in most cases, and I am sure in the current context, pertains to subjective judgement (an exception would be if there existed a defined legal requirement), and hence to an opinion.
Could be from a devils advocate point of view . My purpose was to identify the objective - not to comprehensively define it. Maybe "justified" would have been a better choice of words.
Tony has two identifiable "output" objectives - in taxonomic "means end" - or rather "End <> Means" order they are:
Achieve the END goal of a "New Investigation"
by the MEANS of claiming to have proved CD.
He states those in many ways including denying them in some of his interactions.
I have several times suggested that his current and dominant "objective" is to keep debate going round in circles...but put that one aside for now.
The end of "New Investigation" cannot be achieved in the current context of internet processes whether "discussion" or "debate". It is a disagreement with US Governance and statute empowered due process. The provisions of due process have so far not given Tony et al the New Investigation and - simply put - further progress to that end will need a critical mass of political support.
You comments as to subjectivity could be appropriate in the setting of a proposed debate. My objective for recent posts has been to suggest a legitimate process and some topics that I could support as a basis for debate.
Since Tony true to his SOP has ignored what I have said .....whether or not you can find fault with one of the words I used is moot.
You can't "prove" that a "further investigation is necessary", nor can you "prove" none is "necessary".
I don't have to. For Tony et al to achieve a New Investigation they will have to justify it - whether or not my use of "necessary" was devils advocate "nit pickable" in an internet forum discussion. And he or they will need a critical mass of political support - I doubt that my use of an inappropriate word in forum discussion would be a factor.
For the record I agree with you further comments:
If a debate were to be held on the question "Is a new investigation necessary, given that those we have may be mistaken on details[*]?"
I think we are all already at least vaguely mutually aware of why Tony thinks one is necessary, and why many of us think none is necessary (and why some are probably indifferent). A discussion would merely serve to enumerate the respective reasons for the opposing opinions. Tony needs no opponent however to enumerate his reasons, and he could ask any of us to enumerate theirs. No point in discussing them, really.
[*] I'd predict that Tony would want the word "details" qualified with an adjective like "important" - but that doesn't change what I am saying one bit, as this distinction is the same as the distinction under discussion, "necessary" or "not necessary".
...I've simple been suggesting a way forward.