does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

In an attempt to get this back to "does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate":

IE: Post 19
So, Tony, as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?

Tony could debate each and every one of us on this forum, and it would do exactly what, to the veracity of the claims that AE911T makes? Note that for this question it matters not a whit what the outcome of said series of debates would be. Whether Tony came out on top of every single poster here, or was completely shot down by every poster here, or if it resulted in a tie, makes absolutely no difference to the furthering of the cause. Does anyone think that, for instance, the CTBUH, or the ASCE, or the AIA would be swayed to look more favourably on the claims of AE911T if Tony could say that he had debated, and won, each and every single ISF poster?
 
Last edited:
To make it worse, they concentrate on that one as if it existed in isolation--as if no collapse was possible without that single triggering failure at that particular time

That was the whole underlying absurdity of the missing inch, and the girder expansion under heat. They always take the column as built positions as sacrosanct or as where they need them to be. It's as if there could not be another inch provided somewhere else. It's perfection or CD in their minds, and they always run away from addressing that fact, because then they have to give up their dream of Cheney in the hot seat.
 
That was the whole underlying absurdity of the missing inch, and the girder expansion under heat. They always take the column as built positions as sacrosanct or as where they need them to be. It's as if there could not be another inch provided somewhere else. It's perfection or CD in their minds, and they always run away from addressing that fact, because then they have to give up their dream of Cheney in the hot seat.

You are talking trash here and omitting the stiffeners, just like NIST.

The difference between whether the girder falls or not is much more than an inch with the stiffeners NIST omitted from the girder.

You have to know that and if you didn't, you do now. I put the FEA on this on the 911 free forum here http://the911forum.freeforums.org/s...807.html?sid=3d4fd36b132fd3f2a96c49ee068b200d

It never ceases to amaze me how loose some of you get with the facts.

You should also see that the girder would actually get trapped behind the column side plate in the NIST scenario. A fact NIST ignored. See http://the911forum.freeforums.org/t...808.html?sid=3d4fd36b132fd3f2a96c49ee068b200d
 
Last edited:
That was the whole underlying absurdity of the missing inch, and the girder expansion under heat. They always take the column as built positions as sacrosanct or as where they need them to be. It's as if there could not be another inch provided somewhere else. ...

Ironically, Leroy Hulsey picks up that point in his recent talks on the "WTC Evaluation" project:
He claims that, according to the NIST model[*], the WTC7 perimeter and the west core (up to the 73-74-75 column line, iirc) are modeled as infinitely strong (or stiff?), while only the east core inside the perimeter is free to move as heat-induced forces arise. He implies that this assumption/engineering judgement is invalid.
Those truthers who treat column 79 as absolutely immovable ought to take it up with Hulsey.
But one hyena doesn't bite another, right?



[*] The perceptive people here will ask: "'The'? Which 'the'? There are several different models in the NIST report". Right, but Hulsey himself seems blissfully unaware that the ANSYS and the LS-DYNA models are different and have different boundary conditions. At some later point, he attributes the assymmetry of the dynamic LS-DYNA collapse model - east core failing first in great chaos, all the rest going down nice and straight - to features of the static ANSYS model. Moron.
Anyway, Hulsey, in what I talk about here, refers to the 16-story ANSYS model.
 
Last edited:
You are talking trash here and omitting the stiffeners, just like NIST.

The difference between whether the girder falls or not is much more than an inch with the stiffeners NIST omitted from the girder.

You have to know that and if you didn't, you do now. I put the FEA on this on the 911 free forum here http://the911forum.freeforums.org/s...807.html?sid=3d4fd36b132fd3f2a96c49ee068b200d

It never ceases to amaze me how loose some of you get with the facts.

You should also see that the girder would actually get trapped behind the column side plate in the NIST scenario. A fact NIST ignored. See http://the911forum.freeforums.org/t...808.html?sid=3d4fd36b132fd3f2a96c49ee068b200d

Thanks for bringing up how Truthers misrepresent solution convergence reasons to omit stiffeners as malfeasance, in order to grandstand, in addition to selectively setting structural member positions in order to grandstand.
 
You are talking trash here and omitting the stiffeners, just like NIST.

The difference between whether the girder falls or not is much more than an inch with the stiffeners NIST omitted from the girder.

You have to know that and if you didn't, you do now. I put the FEA on this on the 911 free forum here http://the911forum.freeforums.org/s...807.html?sid=3d4fd36b132fd3f2a96c49ee068b200d

It never ceases to amaze me how loose some of you get with the facts.

You should also see that the girder would actually get trapped behind the column side plate in the NIST scenario. A fact NIST ignored. See http://the911forum.freeforums.org/t...808.html?sid=3d4fd36b132fd3f2a96c49ee068b200d

Did you figure out why Korol's approach is erroneous yet or do you still believe magical teleporting fires are a reasonable approximation of actual fire conditions? If the latter, can you cite any actual serious professional fire science expert who uses that approach?
 
Ironically, Leroy Hulsey picks up that point in his recent talks on the* "WTC Evaluation" project:
He claims that, according to the NIST model*, the WTC7 perimeter and the west core (up to the 73-74-75 column line, iirc) are modeled as infinitely strong (or stiff?), while only the east core inside the perimeter is free to move as heat-induced forces arise. He implies that this assumption/engineering judgement is invalid.

[*] The perceptive people here will ask: "'The'? Which 'the'? There are several different models in the NIST report". Right, but Hulsey himself seems blissfully unaware that the ANSYS and the LS-DYNA models are different and have different boundary conditions. At some later point, he attributes the assymmetry of the dynamic LS-DYNA collapse model - east core failing first in great chaos, all the rest going down nice and straight - to features of the static ANSYS model. Moron.
Anyway, Hulsey, in what I talk about here, refers to the 16-story ANSYS model.

Fits in with my point above. How could the west perimeter be infinitely stiff in reality? It was missing the SW corner and had been measured as "bulging".
From NIST:
wtc7diagramforfaqs_1.gif


That is column 15 that is no longer carrying any gravity load, it is missing. There is also damage to a few other south perimeter columns between col 15 and 21 in the diagram.


and now a ramble:
The "kink" appeared on the north side at about column 44 or 45. That is unsurprising in any scenario that has the girder from col 79 top col 44 having been the initial failure. In fact it is evidence that such a scenario is correct.

Now envision the building at this time.
It has effectively been divided in two, a smaller east section(east of col 44) and a larger western section. The east section perimeter is intact on north, east and south sides.
The western section is intact west of the kink on the north and through most of the west side but is missing the SW corner and has damage to parts of the south side.

AE911T makes much of 'all four corners descending at the same time'. A bit specious to include the SW corner in that since it effectively no longer existed wrt holding the structure up.

The WAI structural heating diagrams show that many areas of the floor were heated prior to collapse. It is therefore not set in stone that with the impact damage on the south west side, and the fire damage across the much of the floor structure, that col 79 was straight, or that the core at that level was stiff and immovable.

JayUtah pointed out in the past that an FEA necessarily must make simplifying assumptions in order to stay within the constraints of computing power and how long you are willing to wait for the program to run. Perhaps that would be why the ANSYS model stiffens part of the core.

So, fires around col 79, col 79 loss implied by EPH infalling, loss of support to col 44 low in the building implied by formation of the kink. This narrows the area within which the initial failure can be heavily assumed to have taken place. The impact damage to the south side, especially that lower down, plus the effect of the fires across a large portion of the 7th, to 13th floors would most likely be stressing connections even at col 79 before initial floor failures occur.
 
Last edited:
A 767, right over his head.
clap.gif
clap.gif

Exactly - and instant next post feedback from Tony confirming that it has gone right over his head - or that he is pretending that it has.

You are talking trash here and omitting the stiffeners, just like NIST....
And that "single issue ignoring context" debating trick has been SOP for Tony since 2007 in my experience. My first internet post:
Me - elsewhere-Nov2007 said:
The paper referenced as Engineering Reality by Tony Szamboti is typical of many which look impressive in detail to the non-engineer. The complex calculations may even be correct but the base premises are faulty and the resulting conclusions can readily be demonstrated to be totally wrong.
So that set the pattern - false scenario and/or false assumptions.

The same error of argument with "Missing Jolt" when he took Bazant's "limit case abstract model" and applied it to the real event.

And he continues to make the same errors - which can no longer be seen as "mistakes". The problem has been identified and explained to him many times.

He clearly wants discussion going round in circles.

As DGM's "sig" reminds us:
"Remember that the goal of conspiracy rhetoric is to bog down the discussion, not to make progress toward a solution" Jay Windley
 
Last edited:
[qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg] [qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg]
Exactly - and instant next post feedback from Tony confirming that it has gone right over his head - or that he is pretending that it has.


And that "single issue ignoring context" debating trick has been SOP for Tony since 2007 in my experience. My first internet post:

So that set the pattern - false scenario and/or false assumptions.

The same error of argument with "Missing Jolt" when he took Bazant's "limit case abstract model" and applied it to the real event.

And he continues to make the same errors - which can no longer be seen as "mistakes". The problem has been identified and explained to him many times.

He clearly wants discussion going round in circles.

As DGM's "sig" reminds us:
"Remember that the goal of conspiracy rhetoric is to bog down the discussion, not to make progress toward a solution" Jay Windley
And he could be absolutely correct about that particular joint, although we'll never know, because we have no way of knowing. His assumptions are also based on guesswork about the conditions, despite his unwillingness to admit it.
Regardless, somewhere in close proximity to that joint, something or somethings hit ultimate and beyond. We know that for a fact, because the building came down
 
And he could be absolutely correct about that particular joint, although we'll never know, because we have no way of knowing. His assumptions are also based on guesswork about the conditions, despite his unwillingness to admit it.
Yes - and whether he is right or wrong matters not because he is missing the remainder - most of - the "argument".

Regardless, somewhere in close proximity to that joint, something or somethings hit ultimate and beyond. We know that for a fact, because the building came down
Truther #2 error - Starting from the predetermined end rather than from a known true foundation.
A) We know that the building fell down;
THEREFORE we know there was a cause.

B) We know that the EPH dropped into the building shell;
THEREFORE Col 79 and associated bits of structure had failed.

C) What failed Col 79?
(a) Added gross overload - no.
(b) Explosive CD - no valid hypothesis;
(c) Column buckling under original loads
THEREFORE what caused change of critical length?

Forlorn hope - getting truthers to take the reasoning the right way round. :rolleyes: :boggled:


(Truther Error #1 IMO is "Reversed Burden of DISproof")

-
 
Yes - and whether he is right or wrong matters not because he is missing the remainder - most of - the "argument".

Truther #2 error - Starting from the predetermined end rather than from a known true foundation.
A) We know that the building fell down;
THEREFORE we know there was a cause.

B) We know that the EPH dropped into the building shell;
THEREFORE Col 79 and associated bits of structure had failed.

C) What failed Col 79?
(a) Added gross overload - no.
(b) Explosive CD - no valid hypothesis;
(c) Column buckling under original loads
THEREFORE what caused change of critical length?

Forlorn hope - getting truthers to take the reasoning the right way round. :rolleyes: :boggled:


(Truther Error #1 IMO is "Reversed Burden of DISproof")

-

Good synopsis, Oz, I would just clarify that Col. 79 itself may not be the initiating cause, just something in that vicinity.
 
Good synopsis, Oz, I would just clarify that Col. 79 itself may not be the initiating cause, just something in that vicinity.
Thank you.

You probably can recall that I have consistently disagreed with NIST over Col79 "initiating" for a couple of reasons.

The first being my preference for pedantic word usage. Col 79 failed because something caused it to fail. Something near certainly loss of horizontal bracing. If there are three steps in a sequence I don't see how the third step could be described as "initiating" - which in my AU English means "starting".

So whatever cause loss of horizontal bracing was the initiating factor - Col 79 was only a big bit of steel that came further down the sequence. I've also been very forgiving of NIST on the basis that "everyone should understand what you are intending to mean"...

...but T Szamboti is part of the set "everyone' - he doesn't see it. So I lose the global claim - false generalisation of "everybody"

At my age I should know better. :o

I agree that Col 79 and the associated bits of structure under EPH failed. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
In an attempt to get this back to "does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate":
I've several times indicated my willingness to discuss - maybe even "debate" BUT in accordance with the proper protocols.

So someone makes an affirmative claim hypothesis.

A relevant one for NIST in a setting with T Sz is "I affirm that there are errors in NIST reports which are of sufficient significance and public policy interest to warrant further investigation".

Fine tune the words BUT that is T Szamboti's position. THEREFORE he puts forward the hypothesis - the affirmative claim - and me or some other of us opposes.

It cannot be the other way around - with me or "us" claiming that "...there is insufficient...whatever" CANNOT prove a negative.

And it would be "one giant leap for mankind"# if Tony did put forward a coherent hypothesis worthy of discussion.






# Apologies to Armstrong, N

 
So someone makes an affirmative claim hypothesis.

A relevant one for NIST in a setting with T Sz is "I affirm that there are errors in NIST reports which are of sufficient significance and public policy interest to warrant further investigation".

Fine tune the words BUT that is T Szamboti's position. THEREFORE he puts forward the hypothesis - the affirmative claim - and me or some other of us opposes.

Are you saying I haven't done that?
 
I would just clarify that Col. 79 itself may not be the initiating cause, just something in that vicinity.

I would say Column 79 couldn't be the initiating cause. Something else had to give first for Col. 79 to go. There are no doubt several plausible culprits (none go by the initials C and D).

Toss them in a hat and pick one.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom