does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Agreed, I can't comprehend how anyone could not see the absurdity of the whole CD scenario. It is logistically and technically impossible given the total lack of hard evidence, and so complex as to have no chance of being successfully carried out. It takes extreme blinders and deep denial to carry the belief. Debating anything not addressing the improbability of the operation is a waste of time.
Agreed. And AE911 et al hanging on to CD as the foundation of a strategy to get more investigation is a sure fire loser...

...unless the goal is to raise someone's salary and pay for his ego tripping.


Meanwhile Tony's Tactics don't change - episodic visits to various forums peddling details which keep discussion going round in circles.

The only variable being who signs up as Tag Team Troll - he seems to get new TTT(s) each time he bursts back on the scene.
 
FTFY. There was no significant amount of aluminium oxide in the residue, compared to iron.




Ditto.

You are referring to the residue of the red gray chips, I am referring to the residue of the oxygen thermal lances with Aluminum and steel rods inside.
Those were donated by the company that makes them.
 
The direct evidence for thermite cut beams is there, but since the gov investigations did not go into forensic studies, this evidence is inconclusive on its own. There is however plenty of other supporting evidence for thermitic materials, including forensic evidence via WTC dust full of the signature iron spheres that these materials leave behind once ignited, the red-gray chips, the reports of melted steel etc. There is OTOH absolutely no evidence of any kind behind the official fire based explanations.

The dirrect evidence is the event that RJ. Lee refers too, included the use of thermal lances with aluminum wire cores to cut Columns those leave the same residues as thermite, thermate.

You see Ziggi since you have to have someone to hang, I will admit guilt, I met Bush in owensboro My, in 2000, at million air, hanger in Owensboro Ky. we planed the hole thing.
Unfortunately for you my plan is fool proof you can't find proof of my guilt, because
Thermitic lances with Aluminum wires inside, leave the exact same residues dust as the thermite oxygen cutters and nano thermite we used.
We planned it so well that no one will ever find any true evidence to convict us, even AE/911 Truths best and brightest Tony S. Can't prove his theories because we did such a good job hiding everything.
Xerography also leaves tons of Identical fly ash derived Microspheres, as does a stack effect like the ones we planned and induced in the cores of the buildings.
We knew from experiments that we could do it, simply and easily, we built robots drones, to install the thermite cutters, at night when no one would notice.
Actually the thermite cutters were suicidal drones they were not designed to survive.
They were made from Aluminum so they would melt in the fires destroying the evidence.
Are plan is fool proof even you and Tony and the other super intelligent Truthers like Chandler will never find any evidence to Convict us.
You will go down in history, as Looney Tooney Cters, while our true plan to conquer the world, and establish the new world order will be unstoppable.

Our ultimate goal is to conquer the world especially the Middle East, take all the oil, kill all the Camels, because no animal spits on me, and doesn't go exstint, then the Alien Invasion can begin.

What did you actually think I was human doing chainsaw tricks and blowing myself up in insane experiments?

If I were Human Ziggi I would be dead, unfortunately for your species though there just never was any hope for you, the majority of your species is not capable as you are Ziggi of being a super intelligent Truther.

We counted on people Like Beachnut, Like Oystein. Like Ozzie, Like Jay, and DGM,
we used them to further our plan and hide the evidence behind Science, Logic, and Reason.

We now Conquer all we are the Invasion from planet X.:rolleyes:
 
You are referring to the residue of the red gray chips, I am referring to the residue of the oxygen thermal lances with Aluminum and steel rods inside.
Those were donated by the company that makes them.
Since no aluminium oxide was found in the residue in a remotely comparable quantity to that of iron, the iron microspheres don't come from thermal lances with aluminium.

Either they weren't the aluminium type, or the origin of the microspheres is not these lances.
 
Since no aluminium oxide was found in the residue in a remotely comparable quantity to that of iron, the iron microspheres don't come from thermal lances with aluminium.

Either they weren't the aluminium type, or the origin of the microspheres is not these lances.

Actually Aluminum Iron Microspheres were found by Jones as well as Aluminum Microspheres, and microspheres containing Al203.

Such low temp Microspheres though are common, from machine wear, and other sources such as arching switches and wires, so Jones did not think the relevant.

Other researchers also found them, but as I said aluminum they are common, as is Aluminum oxide, and Carbonized Aluminum.
Only hard to form compounds like Aluminum Nitride, would be unusual and point to possible incite into certain chemical events in the fires.
But finding Aluminum nitrite in the dust would be almost impossible.

PS I never said all the Microspheres came from thermitic lances I was referring to cut residue and the Microspheres that did come from the lances given off as sparks during cutting.
 
The direct evidence for thermite cut beams is there, ............. plenty of other supporting evidence for thermitic materials, including forensic evidence via WTC dust full of the signature iron spheres that these materials leave behind once ignited, the red-gray chips, the reports of melted steel etc. There is OTOH absolutely no evidence of any kind behind the official fire based explanations.

I have asked this question many times and do not recall getting an answer:

IF the iron spheres and red gray chips are thermite byproduct and unreacted thermite respectively, then I would expect a next relatively easy step would be to estimate the amount of thermite originally loaded into the WTC structures.
Thus the question is: Has Harrit et al calculated an estimate(or lower limit and upper limit) of the quantity of thermite they contend was used?


The contention of thermite use has changed greatly over the years. Originally the contention was that explosives blew the towers to smithereens (yes that exact term was used by at least one truther). The idea being that each level's columns were severed as the collapse progressed.

With debunkers pointing out that this would have been a lot louder than any audio evidence has recorded the meme of thermite demolition was born.

Debunkers then pointed out that thermite cutting of vertical columns is problematic in the first place, and more importantly very slow. It would not be possible to sever heavy columns in a very fast, timed sequence.

Thus was born the nano-thermite meme, a faster reacting and thus faster heat release thermite.

Debunkers point out it is still too slow for a fast closely timed sequence.

Thus it morphed into explosive thermite, a supposedly quiet high explosive.

Nope debunkers point out, millisecond severance of heavy columns still requires a supersonic pressure wave ie.:LOUD.

Then we came full circle and it was put forth that thermite was only used as the fuse for conventional high explosive.

Debunkers shake their collective heads and fear for the future of the human race.

Point is: there is no and never has been a coherent description of exactly how thermite was supposedly used
BUT
with truthers believing they have evidence of thermite being present in a known concentration in the dust, they have the opportunity to calculate an estimate of how much was there prior to first aircraft impact. THAT would go a long way to help in beginning to put together a coherent scenario of it's supposed use in the destruction of the towers. That is something that should have been done ten years ago or at least when the red gray chip paper was completed but hell, better late than never.


Mind you, it still would have to conform with other truther memes such as pools of molten steel in the rubble and long term hot zones caused by thermite.
 
Last edited:
PS I never said all the Microspheres came from thermitic lances I was referring to cut residue and the Microspheres that did come from the lances given off as sparks during cutting.

Hmmm, 15 to 20 second high speed "rock crusher" grinding hundreds of thousands of kilos of steel and concrete together.................... now where oh where would iron microspheres get generated in such an event????????

http://previews.123rf.com/images/vladj55/vladj551111/vladj55111101973/11339389-Rusty-old-bench-vise-and-a-hammer-with-sparks-from-a-blow-on-a-black-background-Stock-Photo.jpg
 
Hmmm, 15 to 20 second high speed "rock crusher" grinding hundreds of thousands of kilos of steel and concrete together.................... now where oh where would iron microspheres get generated in such an event????????

http://previews.123rf.com/images/vladj55/vladj551111/vladj55111101973/11339389-Rusty-old-bench-vise-and-a-hammer-with-sparks-from-a-blow-on-a-black-background-Stock-Photo.jpg

The event in the RJ. Lee report is not the collapse of the towers, but the Damage to 130 west Liberty Street.
 
The event in the RJ. Lee report is not the collapse of the towers, but the Damage to 130 west Liberty Street.
Not sure what the difference is wrt iron mircospheres.

You would agree though that the dust at 130 West Liberty Street was essentially the same dust deposited over a large part of Manhattan and thus anything found in that dust was from the grinding, crushing and general smacking together of the structural components of two 110 storeys office buildings?

Yes, of course thermitic lances will produce them as well and one would expect that a higher concentration of iron microspheres would be found downwind of any location where lances were used (or cutting wheels ). However to my knowledge no one did a comprehensive grid collection of dust samples over the area, for the very good reason that there was no good reason to do so.
 
Not sure what the difference is wrt iron mircospheres.

You would agree though that the dust at 130 West Liberty Street was essentially the same dust deposited over a large part of Manhattan and thus anything found in that dust was from the grinding, crushing and general smacking together of the structural components of two 110 storeys office buildings?

Yes, of course thermitic lances will produce them as well and one would expect that a higher concentration of iron microspheres would be found downwind of any location where lances were used (or cutting wheels ). However to my knowledge no one did a comprehensive grid collection of dust samples over the area, for the very good reason that there was no good reason to do so.

Exactly so Jones & Harrit, Tony and Ziggi using the RJ Lee report as an average concentration of Microspheres is a fraudulent Claim especially since it was a bank hit by a bank, and Microspheres are likely to have higher concentration in banks do to use of magnetic toner and Microspheres in printing checks and magnetic strips on credit cards.
Remember RJ. Lee was preparing a report for an insurance claim.
The report must be viewed as such.
 
Not sure what the difference is wrt iron mircospheres.

You would agree though that the dust at 130 West Liberty Street was essentially the same dust deposited over a large part of Manhattan and thus anything found in that dust was from the grinding, crushing and general smacking together of the structural components of two 110 storeys office buildings?

Yes, of course thermitic lances will produce them as well and one would expect that a higher concentration of iron microspheres would be found downwind of any location where lances were used (or cutting wheels ). However to my knowledge no one did a comprehensive grid collection of dust samples over the area, for the very good reason that there was no good reason to do so.

The EPA actually did extensive dust testing and likely does have systemic data sets as to dust composition by sample region. The master report containing an overview of the contents of the dust collected is here: https://archive.epa.gov/wtc/web/pdf/contaminants_of_concern_benchmark_study.pdf. If 9-11 truthers wanted, they could surely get all of this data from the EPA and put together a very nuanced assessment of the dust. They don't do so, however, because they are not actually interested in trying to understand it; they seek confirmation of their theories, not understanding.

As with other aspects of 9-11, the dust and the ailments that came from it have also been subject to serious and repeated litigation. The dust has also been the subject of multiple independent medical studies. Truthers ignore both.

The people in the 9-11 Truth movement who are smart and educated enough to know how to research a topic properly have no interest in actually doing so as they are relishing making money off of, or even just getting attention and meaning to their life from, the completely ignorant folks. It's why 9-11 Truth can have a panel discussions about "the truth" of the collapses of the towers and not invite any of the dozens of highly regarded professionals who have actually conducted true forensic investigations of the collapses. They don't want to know the truth; they want to keep the fantasy alive. It's why I, and not AE911Truth, was the one to actually obtain copies of the Aegis Insurance litigation expert reports and reach out to people like Dr. Beyler, and why, to this day, AE911Truth does not provide to its members access to, or discuss, the Aegis Insurance litigation expert reports.

It's also why you have someone like Tony posting nonsensical theories of magical teleporting fires on this site. Did Tony, in all his years of practice as a engineer, actually learn a theory to support the analysis of steel temperatures under the condition of subjection to magical teleporting fires? No, of course not. But, given the choice between acknowledging that fires could have caused the collapse of the building and supporting a theory based on magical teleporting fires being the best representation of the true fire conditions on that day, he chooses magical teleporting fires.
 
Last edited:
The EPA actually did extensive dust testing and likely does have systemic data sets as to dust composition by sample region. The master report containing an overview of the contents of the dust collected is here: https://archive.epa.gov/wtc/web/pdf/contaminants_of_concern_benchmark_study.pdf. If 9-11 truthers wanted, they could surely get all of this data from the EPA and put together a very nuanced assessment of the dust.

I did not know that, thanks.

@Ziggi, @Tony Szamboti did you guys know about this?

You may well have an opportunity to refine your thermite theory here. You may be able to determine a map of the varying concentration of iron mircospheres in the area. By extension then you could potentially again refine your estimate of the supposed quantity of thermite used in the thermite demolition theory, both in total amount and quantity in each of the three buildings.

Exciting isn't it?
 
The EPA actually did extensive dust testing and likely does have systemic data sets as to dust composition by sample region. ... If 9-11 truthers wanted, they could surely get all of this data from the EPA and put together a very nuanced assessment of the dust. They don't do so, however, because they are not actually interested in trying to understand it; they seek confirmation of their theories, not understanding.
...

As a matter of fact, even some of the dust that the EPA collected may still be stored in sealed containers under controlled conditions, and may be available for further lab testing.

And this has, in fact, been done: A group of people interested in 9/11 CTs got together, collected money, and had a lab retrieve dust samples previously used for the EPA study, and have them analysed specifically for the presence of thermite in curious red-gray chips.
That group of people was us - Chris Mohr and JREF posters.
The lab was James Millette's MVA in Conyers, Georgia.
The result was: Sorry, no thermite. Looks like paint, actually.

AE911Truth, in a Newsletter (March or April 2012) announced a rebuttal in their next newsletter - but none ever came forward.
AE911Truth no longer uses the allegation that thermite was found by Harrit et al as an argument e.g. for their AIA resolution.
Mark Basile, after years, has been unable to reproduce the results.

Tony and Ziggi may soon be the last persons on earth still hanging their hats on the hoax.
 
The people in the 9-11 Truth movement who are smart and educated enough to know how to research a topic properly have no interest in actually doing so as they are relishing making money off of, or even just getting attention and meaning to their life from, the completely ignorant folks. It's why 9-11 Truth can have a panel discussions about "the truth" of the collapses of the towers and not invite any of the dozens of highly regarded professionals who have actually conducted true forensic investigations of the collapses. They don't want to know the truth; they want to keep the fantasy alive. It's why I, and not AE911Truth, was the one to actually obtain copies of the Aegis Insurance litigation expert reports and reach out to people like Dr. Beyler, and why, to this day, AE911Truth does not provide to its members access to, or discuss, the Aegis Insurance litigation expert reports.

Yes, I found it quite instructive to learn that contrary to AE911T contentions, there apparently was no need to have all of NIST's FEA data inputs in order to carry out a new investigation of the collapse of WTC7.
Before learning of the reports filed in the court case I had argued that as far as I could see, there was enough information in the public realm to do so, but who was I to say for sure. I am not an engineer, just a mere electronic technician.
Then along came the reports (you posted, I believe) on Metabunk, and lo and behold there were in fact other engineering studies of this collapse of similar depth as the NIST report!
In reading it I saw that again it was determined that fire caused the initiating failure, and that again, a finite element analysis of the structure's response to multiple floor failures demonstrated a progression to global collapse.

I rather doubt that anyone visiting the AE911T website would learn that there are now several engineering studies of the collapse of WTC 7 that all conclude that fire damage led to multiple floor failures, and most importantly , that the structural response to these floor failures was a progression to global collapse.

We now have a mechanical engineer and a civil engineer claiming that fire sciences experts in three studies are all wrong. We have these two engineers claiming that all the failure analyses done in these studies are wrong as well. But what do they claim is wrong? That multiple floor failures would lead to global collapse? After all the supposed smoking gun is that fact that this building fully collapsed. They contend it could not do so without explosive demolitions!
However, they concentrate not on progression to global collapse. Instead they kvetch about the least significant, least determinable aspect, the initial structural failure.

Astounding!
 
Yes, I found it quite instructive to learn that contrary to AE911T contentions, there apparently was no need to have all of NIST's FEA data inputs in order to carry out a new investigation of the collapse of WTC7.
Before learning of the reports filed in the court case I had argued that as far as I could see, there was enough information in the public realm to do so, but who was I to say for sure. I am not an engineer, just a mere electronic technician.
Then along came the reports (you posted, I believe) on Metabunk, and lo and behold there were in fact other engineering studies of this collapse of similar depth as the NIST report!
In reading it I saw that again it was determined that fire caused the initiating failure, and that again, a finite element analysis of the structure's response to multiple floor failures demonstrated a progression to global collapse.

I rather doubt that anyone visiting the AE911T website would learn that there are now several engineering studies of the collapse of WTC 7 that all conclude that fire damage led to multiple floor failures, and most importantly , that the structural response to these floor failures was a progression to global collapse.

We now have a mechanical engineer and a civil engineer claiming that fire sciences experts in three studies are all wrong. We have these two engineers claiming that all the failure analyses done in these studies are wrong as well. But what do they claim is wrong? That multiple floor failures would lead to global collapse? After all the supposed smoking gun is that fact that this building fully collapsed. They contend it could not do so without explosive demolitions!
However, they concentrate not on progression to global collapse. Instead they kvetch about the least significant, least determinable aspect, the initial structural failure.

Astounding!
To make it worse, they concentrate on that one as if it existed in isolation--as if no collapse was possible without that single triggering failure at that particular time
 
To make it worse, they concentrate on that one as if it existed in isolation--as if no collapse was possible without that single triggering failure at that particular time

yes!

All studies of the floor system's response necessarily include a lot of unknowns.
It is possible to conduct a forensic estimate of the effects of fire on structural components in the areas involved. This is also done in isolation of course, and assumes the local structures in that area are under original loads and stresses when the fire starts attacking them.
We already know that at least one such study also concluded that column 79 had been pushed by expansion of a girder to one side (west IIRC) of it. Obviously that not only reduces the distance required for pushing 79-44 girder off it's seat, it also stresses the connections to col 79 a floor above and below, even if only slightly.
I am but a mere electronic technician but I also note that if this column was pushed then it also shortened the distance between floor and ceiling on that level in the area of col 79, and that this has, at that early stage already reduced the load carrying ability of col 79.
I also note that several lower levels length of the SW corner column of WTC 7 are gone and there is also other damage to south side columns.
Because it is nigh on impossible to determine what stresses the south side damage would put on the NE corner structures, this is not taken into account.
There were fires on higher floors as well. One could conduct the same study of those levels and determine if there was an effect on columns there, but again, very difficult to determine the stresses that damage might transmit to the lower NE corner, so again it is not taken into account.

All of the above would be relatively insignificant compared to the effects of the fires actually in the NE section of WTC 7, and insignificant in their individual contribution to the initial floor failures, AND very difficult if not impossible to calculate within an acceptable margin of error, BUT, IMHO, indicate that any study of an initial failure simply needs to get it close.


On the more macro scale of things though, we know for certain that:
-THERE IS NO other proximate cause of structural failure, that is visible and as obvious as the fires in WTC 7!
-THE FIRST outwardly visible indication of collapse is the infalling of the EPH, indicating a loss of support from col 79.

Of the fires in WTC 7, there were those proximate to col 79.

So how difficult is it to put two and two together and assume that the fires (the only known and patently obvious mechanism of structural damage) in the vicinity of col 79 (the known and patently obvious first visible sign of structural failure) led to that failure of col 79?

You don't need to be a rocket surgeon to see that!

But AE911T would retort simply that "that's what they want you to think....".
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom