does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

You can download and save the PDF files. That is what I would have sent by e-mail.

The PDF files are no more your FEA than the NIST reports are their FEA data.
The PDF files are a representation of a part of the data that you deem noteworthy, just as the NIST reports contain representations of those bits of FEA data that NIST deemed relevant.
 
I don't think Tony has answered this yet:

There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!
 
What duration for peak gas temperature do you think it should be?

You actually gave a link for a different paper by Dr. Korol. The right link is http://www.challengejournal.com/index.php/cjsmec/article/view/36

I gave the link to the right Korol paper on WTC 7 earlier in a post to Oystein on this thread. Did you miss that?

I note with a sly smile the section "REFBACKS" for this *cough* scientific paper:

  • investmentwatchblog.com
  • the911forum.freeforums.org
  • ae911truth.org
  • reddit.com (ii)
  • reddit.com (i)
  • reddit.com (iv)
:D
 
I would have to say your training within physics courses is probably not as rigorous as full courses on specific topics like those given in a mechanical engineering curriculum.

It isn't a hard thing to see that the extreme steel temperature claims in the WAI report are not possible. You can see that would also be the conclusion from the discussion in the paper by Dr. Korol et al....

Dr. Korol, with Paul Heerema and Ken Sivakumaran, has another paper in that Journal, from 2016:
http://www.challengejournal.com/index.php/cjsmec/article/view/50/41
It applies the Bazant crush-down-crush-up model to WTC7.

Why haven't you told him that it is nonsense to apply that model to the real-world collapses?

That paper also hinges on their guesstimate for concrete particle size distribution, which ought to be an output, not an input, of the model, absent any rigorously obtained observations from the site.

I think he is playing fast and loose with his assumptions and models.
 
My point is that you all accept that without precise gov documentation with timestamped listing of cut beams, and further that you assume that ALL the cut beams found must have been cut during the clean up and that no beam could have been cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to building collapse.

Wait....
What?

Please explain how that's possible. Be as specific as possible, keeping in mind the *********** fire.
 
So, you are at a complete loss as to what concept Mick was demonstrating? Here's a hint though,,,, it has absolutely nothing at all to do with the post of Crazy Chainsaw's that you quoted.

Perhaps you should take it up with him at Metabunk.org rather than discussing it here then.

I think Micah's point flew past you.
I think it's something about just-so experiments being taken too far to argue stuff about WTC7.

While I like Mick's soda-can-crush experiment as a demonstration of the obvious principle that loss of bracing dramatically reduces capacity once the vertical support actually bows - something that happened 100% at all WTC towers - CC's experiments speculate about conditions that are nowhere nearly as certain to have played a significant role in those collapses.
 
... I can only assume you do understand how utterly incorrect Korol's approach is but you are incapable of having a reasoned discussion about it. But go ahead and post something that actially supports Korol's 25 min-only heating times and prove me wrong. Your analysis here is ludicrous ...
In Tony's world, fires magically teleport from place to place at a "maximum" temperature (100 C lower than their experimentally observed maximum temperature) for no more than 25 min at a time. Obviously these magical teleporting fires could not destroy wtc 7, so we need a new investigation!

Am I a spoil-sport if I remind Tony that Abboud makes an explicit reference to Beyler's "pre-heating" claim - that by the time there is a fire directly underneath the steel in question, it is no longer at room temperature (as Korol et al assume) but already a couple of hundred K or so hotter, due to hot gases spreading throughout the large floor area. Apparently, the hot gases stay longer inside and thus pass more of their heat into building structure.


I think the Korol paper fails the moment they assume that a simple analysis beats the more complex analysis that NIST favoured. I assume (and yes, that is faith on my part now) that NIST consulted more eminent forensic fire specialists than Korol has ever heard about before deciding that simple analysis is NOT the right way to go.
 
I think Micah's point flew past you.
I think it's something about just-so experiments being taken too far to argue stuff about WTC7.

While I like Mick's soda-can-crush experiment as a demonstration of the obvious principle that loss of bracing dramatically reduces capacity once the vertical support actually bows - something that happened 100% at all WTC towers - CC's experiments speculate about conditions that are nowhere nearly as certain to have played a significant role in those collapses.

Oh really that's not what the forensic engineering shows, stack effects burning carbon have been known to damage structures before, and they are according to RJ. Lee the sourse of many of the Microspheres he examined.
 
My point is that you all accept that without precise gov documentation with timestamped listing of cut beams, and further that you assume that ALL the cut beams found must have been cut during the clean up and that no beam could have been cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to building collapse.

Had anyone thought of checking for it, it would have taken expert inspections to distinguish between beams cut via thermite cutters and lances. Had FEMA and NIST followed the NFPA921, the first responder testimonies of melted metal and explosions would have automatically set in motion a forensic investigation which would have looked for forensic evidence for explosives and "exotic accelerants" including thermitic materials.

No truck driver transporting the beams or any inspector at the storage areas had any reason to raise a red flag due to angle cut beams with melted metal sputter since the clean up crews left these sorts of marks on the beams. Beams cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to collapse could have been hidden in plain sight, right out in the open.

The direct evidence for thermite cut beams is there, but since the gov investigations did not go into forensic studies, this evidence is inconclusive on its own. There is however plenty of other supporting evidence for thermitic materials, including forensic evidence via WTC dust full of the signature iron spheres that these materials leave behind once ignited, the red-gray chips, the reports of melted steel etc. There is OTOH absolutely no evidence of any kind behind the official fire based explanations.

BWT. Richard Gage does mention this famous angle cut beam photo in his lectures but he also talks about its controversy.

No Columns show cutting under load, the residues can not be distingished from thermal lances with Aluminum, or a thermite cutter utilizing oxygen.
 
I don't think Tony has answered this yet:

There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!

My "Santa's Custard Hypothesis" is still better reasoned than Tony's CD claims.
 
Dr. Korol, with Paul Heerema and Ken Sivakumaran, has another paper in that Journal, from 2016:
http://www.challengejournal.com/index.php/cjsmec/article/view/50/41
It applies the Bazant crush-down-crush-up model to WTC7.

Why haven't you told him that it is nonsense to apply that model to the real-world collapses?.

Them's fighting words Oystein. You seem to get away with it.

Every time I make that should be bleedingly obvious comment there are several debunkers who line up to abuse me.

The B & V cd/cu model has the foundations of a workable generic analysis tool in it. And one ruddy great big issue. It doesn't apply to WTC Twin Towers 9/11 collapses. And we seem to be moving backwards on understanding the issue.

It must be 4-5 years since I had anyone consider what was needed to improve cd/cu to make it valid across a range of grid columns v open space designs.

And the irony I was anticipating for the tfk v T Sz "debate" was that tfk has it wrong and AFAIK T Sz has it right.
It would have been fun watching those two arguing from the opposite sides to where their allegiances normally lie. esp T Sz becoming a high level debunker...
...if only on one issue. ;)
 
Last edited:
No Columns show cutting under load, the residues can not be distingished from thermal lances with Aluminum, or a thermite cutter utilizing oxygen.
Plus the most obvious problem with Ziggi's hasty shift of goalposts.

Freshly made cuts at ground level had bugger all effect on starting a collapse about 1000 feet higher up the building.
 
Plus the most obvious problem with Ziggi's hasty shift of goalposts.

Freshly made cuts at ground level had bugger all effect on starting a collapse about 1000 feet higher up the building.

Also cutting the columns would have resulted in a noticible Jolt, Ziggi need to talk to Tony about that.

Oh and Ozzie, do you need to test any bolts I have a D9D hydrolic Cylinder set up with a force magnifier, that can apply 250,000 PSI to bolts and steel connections.

Tony must think no one here knows how to test bolts.
 
My point is that you all accept that without precise gov documentation with timestamped listing of cut beams, and further that you assume that ALL the cut beams found must have been cut during the clean up and that no beam could have been cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to building collapse.

Had anyone thought of checking for it, it would have taken expert inspections to distinguish between beams cut via thermite cutters and lances. Had FEMA and NIST followed the NFPA921, the first responder testimonies of melted metal and explosions would have automatically set in motion a forensic investigation which would have looked for forensic evidence for explosives and "exotic accelerants" including thermitic materials.

No truck driver transporting the beams or any inspector at the storage areas had any reason to raise a red flag due to angle cut beams with melted metal sputter since the clean up crews left these sorts of marks on the beams. Beams cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to collapse could have been hidden in plain sight, right out in the open.

The direct evidence for thermite cut beams is there, but since the gov investigations did not go into forensic studies, this evidence is inconclusive on its own. There is however plenty of other supporting evidence for thermitic materials, including forensic evidence via WTC dust full of the signature iron spheres that these materials leave behind once ignited, the red-gray chips, the reports of melted steel etc. There is OTOH absolutely no evidence of any kind behind the official fire based explanations.

BWT. Richard Gage does mention this famous angle cut beam photo in his lectures but he also talks about its controversy.

You are 15 years behind. Gage is a liar, a fraud. He is your source of woo.

Now you want to back in cuts made after 9/11 for proof of the CD fantasy. The WTC collapsed from the top down, thus the cuts at ground level (as already mentioned) make up your new gish gallop of woo.

Iron spheres are formed in fire. Keep repeating it is the signature of thermite is failure. There is no iron found from your tons of thermite in your fantasy. Why, because thermite is a fantasy. Where are the piles of thermite?

You will be upset when you finally see 9/11 truth is woo - please come back and tell us how much you are upset when reality sets in.

UBL did 9/11 with a trick - the USA treats hijackers in a way which gave the 19 idiots enough time to fail after Flight 93 figured out it was no a Hijacking, it was murder... 9/11 truth can't figure out 9/11 after 15 years; that is all that needs to be said. 9/11 truth and you offer no evidence, no proof, no rational story.

There was no melted steel. 9/11 was a crime, not an accident. Does 9/11 truth understand crime? 19 terrorists did it, not the fantasy thermite, or cutter charges which are silent... silent? lol

Thermite leaves behind iron... it was not found. How upset with 9/11 truth nuts will you be when you join reality? The Jones/Harrit paper is nonsense, get help with a science teacher, or any rational layperson with good reading comprehension skills.

Why gish gallop old failed claims?

What about the debate? Why does anyone need to debate NIST, it is published, go ahead, debunk NIST; you and Tony can't do more than make up nonsense about it.
 
Last edited:
The direct evidence for thermite cut beams is there, but since the gov investigations did not go into forensic studies, this evidence is inconclusive on its own. There is however plenty of other supporting evidence for thermitic materials, including forensic evidence via WTC dust full of the signature iron spheres that these materials leave behind once ignited, the red-gray chips, the reports of melted steel etc. There is OTOH absolutely no evidence of any kind behind the official fire based explanations.

You refer to the R.J. Lee report, but the problem is that nobody except 9-11 CTers make a thermite connection. Experts recognize the iron spheres are part of the fire and collapse signature - not thermite, and the reports of melted steel are just rumor that have never been substantiated.

The problem with egg-heads is that they're great at drawing up stuff on the chalkboard, but fall apart when they hand it to someone who has to make it work in the real world.

Nobody would sign off on the WTC7 job as A&ETruth has drawn it up - not one single black-ops professional. Bringing down #7 eight hours after the Twin Towers fell had zero dramatic effect - the whole point of terror - and killed nobody - the secondary point of terror, and as A&ETruth loves to point out in their brochures: most people don't know a third building collapsed on 9-11...

...Because nobody cares.

So why risk discovery to wire a third building only to bring it down sans occupants, hours after the fact?

Why risk using thermite, which nobody with a background in CD, or explosives would ever use willingly, when - if the whole point is to fake a terrorist attack - explosives would induce the desired panic?

Normal people would be freaked out by terrorists who could secretly wire an entire building with explosives and bring it down...you wouldn't even need to hijack passenger jets. No warning - just BOOM.

The black ops guys who actually pulled off 9-11 (KSM, UBL, Mohamed Atta, and Ramsey Yousef) actually did their homework on the WTC - TWICE - and figured out the best way to destroy their target.

And yes, Al Qaeda and all terrorist groups are by definition black ops.
 
You refer to the R.J. Lee report, but the problem is that nobody except 9-11 CTers make a thermite connection. Experts recognize the iron spheres are part of the fire and collapse signature - not thermite, and the reports of melted steel are just rumor that have never been substantiated.

The problem with egg-heads is that they're great at drawing up stuff on the chalkboard, but fall apart when they hand it to someone who has to make it work in the real world.

Nobody would sign off on the WTC7 job as A&ETruth has drawn it up - not one single black-ops professional. Bringing down #7 eight hours after the Twin Towers fell had zero dramatic effect - the whole point of terror - and killed nobody - the secondary point of terror, and as A&ETruth loves to point out in their brochures: most people don't know a third building collapsed on 9-11...

...Because nobody cares.

So why risk discovery to wire a third building only to bring it down sans occupants, hours after the fact?

Why risk using thermite, which nobody with a background in CD, or explosives would ever use willingly, when - if the whole point is to fake a terrorist attack - explosives would induce the desired panic?

Normal people would be freaked out by terrorists who could secretly wire an entire building with explosives and bring it down...you wouldn't even need to hijack passenger jets. No warning - just BOOM.

The black ops guys who actually pulled off 9-11 (KSM, UBL, Mohamed Atta, and Ramsey Yousef) actually did their homework on the WTC - TWICE - and figured out the best way to destroy their target.

And yes, Al Qaeda and all terrorist groups are by definition black ops.

Agreed, I can't comprehend how anyone could not see the absurdity of the whole CD scenario. It is logistically and technically impossible given the total lack of hard evidence, and so complex as to have no chance of being successfully carried out. It takes extreme blinders and deep denial to carry the belief. Debating anything not addressing the improbability of the operation is a waste of time.
 
@ozeco41 - Did you miss Tony Szamboti's request for clarification regarding a possible debate?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11637813&postcount=463

:o :o Ooops... Yes - I've not been giving much attention to this thread for reasons of my established posting SOPs.

Don't miss the significance of my comment:
...It wont happen - Tony is well aware that I have his measure and won't fall for his SOP debating tricks.

My goal in participating in forums is different to Tony's (and most others. ;))

I'm not into unarmed combat leading to "winners" and "losers". I would prefer a process of honest collaborative discussion to reach agreement on some aspect of WTC collapse understanding. I'm not in favour of "combative debate" where the objective is to prove the opponent wrong and honesty is subordinated to "win at any cost".

That said my criteria would include that the process must adhere to the relevant protocols of the scientific method. SPECIFICALLY a defined and agreed topic based on an affirmative claim put up by one party. Which the other party can oppose by legitimate process.

Since Tony does not abide by those criteria we would need to define some of the process parameters. AKA "rules"

THEN "What Topic?" For me to be interested it would have to be a significant issue of direct relevance to EITHER:
(a) advancing professional understanding of the WTC 9/11 collapses; OR
(b) a debatable topic of public policy impact and in the technical arena of WTC related collapses.

As I said I would not be falling for Tony Trickery - especially his SOP trick of "pre-emption".

AND that IMO severely limits the field to three topic areas:
The first two from Tony - his overriding explicitly stated claims which are:
(c) That there was CD involved in the WTC collapses; OR
(d) That "further investigation" is warranted.

And recall that those are Tony's claims. His burden of proof. If he wants to pursue either or both he needs to post his hypothesis as step one. ;)

The third sector of possible topics - where I could make the affirmative claim or hypothesis - go to the understanding of the Twin Towers collapses. "Initiation" stage; "progression" stage OR "limits of Bazant" are possibilities. I would go for the jugular and nominate "initiation stage" because that is the foundation of most of Tony's false technical claims THEREFORE:
(e) (Ideally) - explain the Twin Towers" "initiation stage in sufficient depth as needed to pull the rug out of most of Tony's Twin Towers claims; OR
(f) (More pragmatically.) I assert that Missing Jolt is wrong and once again show how and why. Since MJ is one specific issue which is falsely based on Tony's lack of understanding of "initiation" rebutting it again pulls the key card from under Tony's house of cards claims around Twin Towers initiation.

You should be able to see why I doubt that Tony would engage in either discussion or debate. :rolleyes:

And I would NOT be prepared to discuss WTC7 for reasons I have published many times. I am not interested in playing on ground defined by truthers which gives them facility to engage in trickery.
 
Last edited:
Agreed, I can't comprehend how anyone could not see the absurdity of the whole CD scenario. It is logistically and technically impossible given the total lack of hard evidence, and so complex as to have no chance of being successfully carried out. It takes extreme blinders and deep denial to carry the belief. Debating anything not addressing the improbability of the operation is a waste of time.

That's why I'm hammering Tony on the basics.

It all leads to proof that CD as the killer of WTC 1,2 AND 7 is impossible.

He knows it, they all do. They don't give a **** about NIST. They care about being right. It's absurd.
 
I think Micah's point flew past you.
I think it's something about just-so experiments being taken too far to argue stuff about WTC7.

While I like Mick's soda-can-crush experiment as a demonstration of the obvious principle that loss of bracing dramatically reduces capacity once the vertical support actually bows - something that happened 100% at all WTC towers - CC's experiments speculate about conditions that are nowhere nearly as certain to have played a significant role in those collapses.

No, I understood that he was referring various models. He did not strike me as refering to Mick's being more applicable than CC's. In fact he did seem at a loss as to it's relevance to the collapse mechanisms.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom