A different analogy for what Tony is trying to do is to (correctly) state that a map isn't the same as the real terrain, just as a model isn't necessarily reality. Where he goes wrong is insisting that any detail in the map that doesn't correlate with the actual terrain is reason to completely discard the map and substitute one's own reality. ...
An analogy in a different area of private study that currently fascinates me no end (and is the main reason I am often online at very sinful hours of the night):
I have inherited from my father a big box with copies and notes from genealogical documents for our family that a cousin of his had assembled in the 1980s. Her results go back to the 1500s, but unfortunately my father didn't copy or cite any sources for that oldest family history. That was a time before inheritable family names were in use in our neck of the world. That came sometime during the 1600s.
A couple of months ago, I googled my family name + "family tree", and found a very massive family tree, very nicely done by a guy married to woman with whom, it turned out, I share grand-grand-grand-grand-grand-parents
Both researchers traced my family name back to the given (Christian) name of a widow in the early 1600s.
However!!! Between that widow and our common ancestor, they have a different lineage! Whily "my" family tree has a "Joseph" as grand
6-father, "hers" has a "Leonard" - grand
6-mothers have same last name, but different first names, too. grand
7-parents are different, but eventually, they both branch back to said widow.
And anyway, the other researcher's data records - at least half of them are "wrong" - or at least differ from mine: Different spellings, birth places, death years, numbers of children, etc.
And even original documents are sometimed wrong! My great-grandmother's official church obituary (that's a little printed card handed out to those who attend the funeral service) has her birth year wrong by three years, and the birth day by one day; onle the month is correct.
Now we are three researchers - the guy with the massive online tree, my father's cousin, and I. The former two have used previous work by at least three further researchers.
Now I can guarantee you:
All six of us produce incorrect family trees!
Does this mean we are not relatives? Does this mean our family name is not derived from a widow's first name in the early 1600s? Is it more likely that we don't actually have any ancestors on planet earth before the year 1750?
Of course not.
All it means is that data before ca. 1800 is scarce, often ambiguous, and it is therefore nigh impossible to be certain of the genealogy.
None of this is reason to consider special creation or immigration from another galaxy.