does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Tony's FEA has a fatal flaw it relies on bolt shear without tearing of the Seat or girder,
Tony has in fact contradicted earlier statements he made to present an FEA that shows his incompetence!

Here is my discussion with Crazy Chainsaw on the 911 free forum. He wants to comment in both places, so he is wrong in both and that needs to be shown.
Edited by Agatha: 
Removed breach of rule 12


Crazy Chainsaw: This is an evidence based forum Tony, what you have given is Opinion.

Edited by Agatha: 
Trimmed for rule 4. Please do not post large amounts of material available elsewhere. You may post a short extract and a link.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Here is my discussion with Crazy Chainsaw on the 911 free forum. He wants to comment in both places, so he is wrong in both and that needs to be shown.

Edited by Agatha: 
Removed previously moderated content

My reply, still waiting on the experimental evidence I asked for.

Why is it so hard to find a paper on an actual experiment that supports your Opinion?


Re: Trapping of girder A2001 behind column 79 side plate
Thu Dec 29, 2016 1:31 pm
https://www.fastenal.com/en/79/structural-bolts

That's minimal tensile strength Tony, I have directly tested A325 bolts that did not yield until 178.65 psi.

Shear is time Dependant.

Oh and yes I understand strain hardening, which can induce sheer depending on how the strain is applied, and the amount of (Time)
Involved.

https://www.nde-ed.org/EducationResourc ... hening.htm

You make yourself look silly Tony again I ask the reasonable question you present an experiment backing up your claims!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Will all participants please endeavour to be civil and polite, and to address the arguments made rather than attacking the arguer. This includes name-calling.

Further, telling someone that they are either on your ignore list or will be added to it is neither civil nor polite, and it is also a breach of rule 11.

I am sure that you all can raise the civility level of this debate, so please do so before more mod attention is necessary. If things do not improve, the thread may have to be put on moderated status until the rule-breaches stop.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Agatha
 
Why is it appropriate to model fires as if they only appear magically at maximum intensity for 25 min and then suddenly disappear? Can you cite a single other serious engineer who has used that approach except for Korol? Korol himself does not cite anyone who does. None of the NIST authors used that approach, nor did ARUP, nor did Bailey, nor did Mohwer, nor did Beyler. The Cardington study that you cited as an authority does not at all support that approach, and nor do the actual model fire studies of wtc 1 & 2 floors and cubicles.

So why are you citing it as if it even deserves consideration? Whether or not Beyler's approach is the best one, the alternative you are suggesting is garbage.

Remember heat transfers from hot to cold, so the only time that should be considered is when the object transferring the heat to another object is actually hotter than it.

How many minutes are the Cardington gas temperatures above the temperature that the WAI report claims the steel on floors 9 and 10 got to?

Why is it that you so very often will not answer questions asked of you? Even when you quote back the question posed, such as above, you do this.

Six fire science specialist studies cited, and you were asked why you and Korol, both non-specialists in this area, insist that it be done differently.

You have set yourself and Korol up as experts, yet those with demonstrably greater credentials perform the same task quite differently and with vastly different results.
An appeal to authority is a fallacy if it can be demonstrated that the authority is lacking. Abboud and Beyler certainly speak with demonstrably greater authority than either you or Korol.
 
,,,,,, and then there are the points most pertinent to this thread, and which have been thoroughly ignored by Tony, and Ziggi ,and Criteria.
Write a scholarly paper on your central thesis, get it successfully peer-reviewed by structural and forensic engineers, then get it published in one of the premier journals of structural and/or forensic engineering. That use of your free time should get you started on your goal of setting the record straight far more effectively than challenging anonymous laymen to debates in a backwater internet forum.

So, Tony, as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?
 
I don't think I have ever seen anyone come up with as many tortured explanations as you seem capable of. Of course, the probability of their actual occurrence is near zero, but that doesn't seem to matter to you. You just keep pumping out different scenarios as though repeating an actual probable situation is what you want to stay away from.

At least they come up with explanations, unlike some other folks who choose to ignore the blatantly obvious.
 
At least they come up with explanations, unlike some other folks who choose to ignore the blatantly obvious.

He doesn't realize you need to use actual sheer dynamics from actual experiments in
A forensic FEA, you can do that by torquing the volts until they break, pulling on them until they break, or by impact sheer. You don't do a forensic FEA using the minimum sheer strength of the bolt manufacturer!
 
He doesn't realize you need to use actual sheer dynamics from actual experiments in
A forensic FEA, you can do that by torquing the volts until they break, pulling on them until they break, or by impact sheer. You don't do a forensic FEA using the minimum sheer strength of the bolt manufacturer!

As you know, I go a little less technical than that.

He (and all these truthers) needs to provide a complete alternative scenario that explains the entire day's events.

Otherwise, what he's saying is that there were 4 hijacked aircraft, and 4 crash locations.

IN ADDITION

Someone decided to rig WTC 7 for demolition. Totally separate event.

There aren't enough :crazy: icons to draw that conclusion.

Ergo - it's all related.
 
My reply, still waiting on the experimental evidence I asked for.

Why is it so hard to find a paper on an actual experiment that supports your Opinion?


Re: Trapping of girder A2001 behind column 79 side plate
Thu Dec 29, 2016 1:31 pm
https://www.fastenal.com/en/79/structural-bolts

That's minimal tensile strength Tony, I have directly tested A325 bolts that did not yield until 178.65 psi.
Generally, we try really hard not to use fasteners in tension
Shear is time Dependant.
What? No.
Oh and yes I understand strain hardening, which can induce sheer depending on how the strain is applied, and the amount of (Time)
Involved.

https://www.nde-ed.org/EducationResourc ... hening.htm

You make yourself look silly Tony again I ask the reasonable question you present an experiment backing up your claims!
 
As you know, I go a little less technical than that.

He (and all these truthers) needs to provide a complete alternative scenario that explains the entire day's events.

Otherwise, what he's saying is that there were 4 hijacked aircraft, and 4 crash locations.

IN ADDITION

Someone decided to rig WTC 7 for demolition. Totally separate event.

There aren't enough :crazy: icons to draw that conclusion.

Ergo - it's all related.

Tony can't even explain his own FEA, even though it contradicts his statements on the building seven Thread here about bolt and weld failure.
I have 385 peer reviewed papers detailing experiments on shear, vs ductile failure, not one
Of them backs up Tony's conclusion not a single one.
Is it too much to ask that he provide support to his theory?
 
As you know, I go a little less technical than that.

He (and all these truthers) needs to provide a complete alternative scenario that explains the entire day's events.

Otherwise, what he's saying is that there were 4 hijacked aircraft, and 4 crash locations.

IN ADDITION

Someone decided to rig WTC 7 for demolition. Totally separate event.

There aren't enough :crazy: icons to draw that conclusion.

Ergo - it's all related.
It's a very strange notion, that some miscreants rigged building 7 to burn and collapse but then had their plans almost ruined by some terrorists flying planes into the buildings next door. But that version raises the question of what was the point of destroying building 7 on its own, and what was their plan if the fire department had managed to quell the fires and discovered the building was rigged?

Alternatively the events were linked: somebody pre-rigged 7 to burn and collapse, having carefully calculated that flying planes into 1 and 2 would definitely cause them to collapse and their debris would cause sufficient damage to 7 (not too little, not too much) so the arson would look natural, the fires could not be tackled and the collapse would seem explicable. Except of course how could they be sure that 1 and 2 would collapse yet 7 would not? And more fundamentally, what did it matter which buildings collapsed and which did not? What was gained from the collapse of 7 (a building most of the world never heard of) which was not achieved by crashing two airliners into the world's largest and most iconic office buildings?

It's ludicrous.
 
Generally, we try really hard not to use fasteners in tensionWhat? No.

I understand that.

Are we taking ductile shear or lag shear?

Shear lag is time Dependant, fast while ductile shear requires stretching of the material.

Brittle shear is not lag, shear or ductile shear isn't that Right?
 
Last edited:
Otherwise, what he's saying is that there were 4 hijacked aircraft, and 4 crash locations.

IN ADDITION

Someone decided to rig WTC 7 for demolition. Totally separate event.
Yes, there are the questions begged wrt any and all conspiracy theories.
Who rigged the towers & #7, and the Pentagon?
Why were these buildings rigged for demolition? (shock and awe simply doesn't cut it as an excuse. Hijacking 4 American aircraft and suicide ramming them is quite enough S & A to garner any war)
When were these buildings rigged with explosives?
What were they rigged with? (this has morphed in conspiracy circles, even AE911T has changed it several times)

Where were the charges installed/how was this done that precluded discovery of them?

AE911T says they want a new investigation but their real agenda is to have their pet allegation brought forth. A point curiously missing from some AE911T bumph. However there is only slightly more evidence for it as there is for extraterrestrial alien involvement.(and that is being generous)

Let's look at this dispassionately: there were 4 hijacked aircraft, all of which were deliberately crashed. If we narrow this down to the Pentagon and the towers the null hypothesis must be that the destruction wrought is a direct or indirect consequence of these extremely violent events. Next is the further destruction of the rest of the WTC complex of buildings and several others proximate to them. There were two of the tallest office buildings in the world that collapsed, and the null hypothesis must be that the debris fall from these two towers is the direct or indirect cause of that destruction. Certainly even AE911T has no dispute that WTC 3,4,5 & 6 were all destroyed by the tower's debris.
Similar argument for the Pentagon, and the crash site in Pennsylvania.

There exists no compelling argument for any other direct/indirect cause of all of this destruction, and to overcome a null hypothesis based on such very obvious events as aircraft ramming requires an extraordinary amount of evidence.
 
Last edited:
None of the fire science engineers who have signed AE911Truth's petition agree with the NIST fire simulation and heat transfer analysis and the steel there doesn't get nearly as hot as that claimed by the WAI report.

Why isn't Scott Grainger the AE911T lead on the refutation of Abboud and Beyler?

I read his resume and it would appear he has much greater authority by which to request the Abboud/Beyler study than either you or Korol.

Can you point to ANYTHING he has said publicly about this (Abboud and Beyler)?

How about Edward Munyak? Could he and Grainger together request the study?
 
Last edited:
I understand that.

Are we taking ductile shear or lag shear?

Shear lag is time Dependant, fast while ductile shear requires stretching of the material.

Brittle shear is not lag, shear or ductile shear isn't that write?
We may be talking past each other here, CC
In design, we work really hard to not be so close to the edge, as it were, that we have to worry about ductile vs brittle (static vs impact) loading on fasteners. This is especially true in commercial use, where a number of factors are beyond our control, such as maintenance and field repair, not to mention field assembly.
Using threaded fasteners, we generally design so that the holes are tightly toleranced and then torque to a pretty high preload (typically 75-90% of yield, with the upper end being "Do not reuse this fastener" if you ever take it apart), to avoid slop and impact loading. We also design for Bearing Failure (the parent material around the hole yields) which tends to equalize the loads on fasteners in a pattern. That way we can go to zero margin at ultimate load.
If a joint is shear critical (Shear margin< Bearing Margin), we always allow a 15% margin (Margin is (allowable/actual)-Safety Factor) and we use the Minimum Allowable spec for that fastener
 
It can be experimentally proven Tony, if you or any of the others At AE/911 Truth could actually do a credible experiment that was not designed to fail.
I can heat a piece of steel to 600C with a torch and directly oxidize carbon black on it's surface!
The governing facter is Oxidation!
Your Ideas like many truther Ideas are way to oversimplified!

Just a few days ago, Mick West posted a video of him crushing a soda can and claiming it has something to do with WTC 7! :D

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jjoHaXrm_u4
 
Just a few days ago, Mick West posted a video of him crushing a soda can and claiming it has something to do with WTC 7! :D

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jjoHaXrm_u4

So, you are at a complete loss as to what concept Mick was demonstrating? Here's a hint though,,,, it has absolutely nothing at all to do with the post of Crazy Chainsaw's that you quoted.

Perhaps you should take it up with him at Metabunk.org rather than discussing it here then.
 
Last edited:
It's a very strange notion, that some miscreants rigged building 7 to burn and collapse but then had their plans almost ruined by some terrorists flying planes into the buildings next door. But that version raises the question of what was the point of destroying building 7 on its own, and what was their plan if the fire department had managed to quell the fires and discovered the building was rigged?

Alternatively the events were linked: somebody pre-rigged 7 to burn and collapse, having carefully calculated that flying planes into 1 and 2 would definitely cause them to collapse and their debris would cause sufficient damage to 7 (not too little, not too much) so the arson would look natural, the fires could not be tackled and the collapse would seem explicable. Except of course how could they be sure that 1 and 2 would collapse yet 7 would not? And more fundamentally, what did it matter which buildings collapsed and which did not? What was gained from the collapse of 7 (a building most of the world never heard of) which was not achieved by crashing two airliners into the world's largest and most iconic office buildings?

It's ludicrous.

CD at WTC 7 is quite literally the most insane, fact free notion that humans have ever come up with.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom